News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by dalemhurley on Friday July 11, 2025 @06:24PM (#44537376)
Cursor (and Garry Tan’s X post) has shown us that the VC money is propping up these companies astounding growth, the only way for them to become profitable is to increase the cost per a request, which means they need to innovate like crazy.

The moat is paper thin.

GitHub has open sourced copilot.

The open source community is working hard on their own projects.

No doubt Cursor is moving fast to create amazing innovations, but if the competition only focuses on thin wrappers they are not worth the billion dollar valuations.

I love watching this space as it is moving extremely fast.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by woeirua on Friday July 11, 2025 @07:37PM (#44537910)
There is no moat. If you’re a true believer that strong agents are around the corner, then all of these add on companies will be obsolete in a few years. The first company to strong agents can trivially rebuild Cursor or Windsurf.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Friday July 11, 2025 @09:07PM (#44538414)
If you believe AGI is around the corner, doesn’t it mean it’ll replace ALL products?
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by yieldcrv on Friday July 11, 2025 @09:27PM (#44538510)
So grifting for investor cash and revenue right now is the obvious play either way
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by kevindamm on Saturday July 12, 2025 @01:06AM (#44539451)
That would be true if the product was the goal. In my experience,

  marketing > market > product
Even with AGI in hand, there will still be competition between offerings based on externalities, inertia, or battle-testedness, or authority. Maybe super-intelligence would change the calculus of that, but you'd still probably find opportunities beyond just letting your pool of agents vibe code it.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Saturday July 12, 2025 @01:43AM (#44539615)
Sounds like the kind of thing Windsurf & Cursor had as their most valuable asset - mindshare and authority?
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by pjc50 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @02:52AM (#44539920)
If you believe AGI is round the corner (I don't), then you face the dilemma of investing in a company that will be the one profitable survivor in a disintegrating world.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by charcircuit on Saturday July 12, 2025 @03:36AM (#44540096)
This would only be true if it was cheap to run and would return results quickly. If AGI only has compute to serve 1 customer per hour then their is an upper bound of market share it can take from other products.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by TrackerFF on Saturday July 12, 2025 @08:24AM (#44541572)
If AGI is around the corner, I don't believe one single company will "own" that tech. It will be like it is today, where you have multiple models competing.

And after that, AGI will be open source.

In the end, ownership of data and compute will be the things that define the victors.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aziaziazi on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:15PM (#44545230)
We don’t eat intelligence: bikes, bottles, food, energy… have room for improvement but I hardly see how AGI would replace them.

Same for physical services like labors, miners and cooks, even taxi/bus drivers for +99% of the world. Automation immensely improve their efficiency and the Modern Times is the past for half of the globe, but AGI isn’t the main facilitator.

Replace all (most*) Silicon Valley -and cousins- similar "products" and services, perhaps yes !

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:18PM (#44546057)
You don’t see how robots would replace all these roles? I take it you never seen a Waymo or read about how agriculture needs a tiny fraction of humans in the US vs a couple of decades ago? And those aren’t even “AGI-level” solutions…
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aziaziazi on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:43AM (#44548637)
Waymo aren’t build, maintained and disposed by robots only. Even if they were we’ve still to see how that can be deployed (and make sense economically) to more than a couple percentiles of the richest people in the top cities. That has nothing in common with "replacing the humans".

Agriculture efficiency mainly comes from last century fertilizer. The modern robot trucks are also limited to some richest countries and farmers and have nothing to do with AGI.

Your vague dream of AGI solutionism missed the barriers to technologie deployment: raw ressources availability, politics, demography, energy… IA can have a small impact there but it certainly won’t replace ALL products. How would a computer replace a mining truck or a reactor turbine?

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Sunday July 13, 2025 @10:29AM (#44550699)
You’re missing the point so completely, I don’t see why I should keep engaging.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aziaziazi on Sunday July 13, 2025 @01:33PM (#44551999)
If I missed your point you’d be wonderful to clarify it, perhaps by detailing the first post "replacing all products":

- what do you consider a product?

- ALL as in Everything (obviously not I guess)?

Regarding "don’t you see how robots…" I clearly see the theory but also can’t see how it would happen in reality for the reasons I mentions in my precedent post: mainly access to ressources/energy to build/maintain those robots for a signifiant time scale and socio-politico barriers.

I’d be glad you reconsider explaining your point because I only see vague allusions, but if you want to stop the conversation here that’s all up to you.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by seunosewa on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:38PM (#44545409)
Google spent 2.4 billion dollars
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by dalemhurley on Sunday July 13, 2025 @06:13AM (#44549071)
I am saying the subsidies tokens are the paper thin moat.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by TechDebtDevin on Friday July 11, 2025 @07:51PM (#44537998)
Cursor just committed mass consumer fraud at worst, and at best pissed off all their best customers. I feel really sorry for those who invested at a 9bb valuation.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aeve890 on Friday July 11, 2025 @08:16PM (#44538127)
>Cursor just committed mass consumer fraud at worst, and at best pissed off all their best customers.

What happened?

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by wadefletch on Friday July 11, 2025 @08:36PM (#44538243)
flip-flopping on pricing has led users to feel nickel-and-dimed

i like cursor fine, but check out the forum/subreddit to see people talking like addicts, pissed their fix is getting more expensive

i think this aggressive reaction is more pronounced for non-programmers who are making things for the first time. they tasted a new power and they don't want it taken away.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by TechDebtDevin on Friday July 11, 2025 @10:45PM (#44538874)
I agree with your take, but I still don't excuse anti consumer practices like that. It annoys me because this is a repeat problem in this space, where these companies don't take into account the market dynamics, or costs of their service. From the start I've been looking at these $20.00 subscriptions, and then my own personal api per token costs and been wondering how they aren't all bankrupt.

Look no further than founders in the sports betting space, like the fanduel founders. Borrow a bunch of money at huge valuations because of hype and ignore the fact, that despite it being exciting and popular, the margins are like <5%. Fanduel founders sold for 400 something million, walked away with nothing. Its now a multibillion dollar company when the new owners realized the product was marketing, not the vig. These AI companies are shifting towards their "marketing" eras.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by sbarre on Saturday July 12, 2025 @09:09AM (#44541822)
I think any "value add" business that has a primary product built on top of another larger business' non-commodity service(s) runs the risk of having to re-do their pricing in ways that are outside their control.

This is nothing new. I'm not sure if it's "anti-consumer" as much as it's just a risky play from a brand and customer happiness viewpoint. Because your prices can be forced up by your supplier, and your customers will be mad at you, not at your supplier.

I do also think it is on consumers - in some part - to go into it with eyes open and do their research.

Thankfully a product like Cursor is a monthly sub and not a big up-front investment so if you don't like - or can't afford - the new pricing, you can just stop paying.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by TechDebtDevin on Saturday July 12, 2025 @10:24PM (#44546976)
I think my primary concern are the customers who paid $220 for a yearly subscription, only for it to get nerfed and asked to pay $200.00 a month to get similar output.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by bn-l on Friday July 11, 2025 @10:19PM (#44538759)
No I’m a programmer and I’m better about the rug pull also.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by hobofan on Saturday July 12, 2025 @02:34AM (#44539842)
What surprises me is just how much they've missed the mark.

I'm not an extreme user of Cursor. It has become an essential part of my workflow, but I also probably on the lower/medium section of users. I know that a lot of my friends were spending $XXX amounts/month on extra usage with them, while I've never gone beyond 50% included premium credits usage.

After their changes I'm getting hit with throttling multiple times a day, which likely means that the same thing happens to almost every Cursor user. So that means one or more of:

- They are jacking up the prices, to squeeze out more profit, so it looks good in the VC game

- They had to jack up the prices, so that they aren't running at a loss anymore (that would be a bad indicator regarding profitability for the whole field)

- They are really incompetent about simulating/estimating the impact of their pricing decisions, which also isn't a good future indicator for their customers

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by raesene9 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @02:45AM (#44539893)
My guess is that it's your second scenario there (avoid running at a loss). In the start-up game scale/growth is the most important thing and profits really aren't that important. you want to show to later stage VCs that your idea has traction and there's a large addressable market.

Whilst profits aren't important you also can't burn all your current capital, so if the burn rate gets too high you have to put up prices, which seems likely to be what Cursor is doing.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by LunaSea on Saturday July 12, 2025 @04:48AM (#44540420)
That's where the real test lies for Cursor and programming LLMs.

Will users feel that a $200 subscription is worth it or not?

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by lelanthran on Saturday July 12, 2025 @10:05AM (#44542154)
I think what everyone, including those programmers advocating coding agents, are forgetting is that if you can have a full time programmer for $200/m, then that becomes the new value of programming labour in the open market.

IOW, the market will slowly but surely drive the labour rate for programming down to the cost of the cheapest coding agent.

So, sure, boasting about a 10x speedo on boilerplate has good metrics, but let's not delude ourselves that programmers are going to be paid enough to afford the $200/m coding agent in the future.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by bluefirebrand on Saturday July 12, 2025 @08:44PM (#44546500)
Hooray!

So how do I fight this as a programmer?

Because I have no interest in devaluing my skills with this crap, but unfortunately many others are all in!

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by lelanthran on Sunday July 13, 2025 @03:28AM (#44548250)
> So how do I fight this as a programmer?

I wish I knew. I get a lot of joy out of programming and almost none from copy/pasting.

> Because I have no interest in devaluing my skills with this crap, but unfortunately many others are all in!

We are certainly living in Interesting Times.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by BeFlatXIII on Saturday July 12, 2025 @10:42AM (#44542410)
I want that entitled attitude to spread. Destroy profitability.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by immibis on Saturday July 12, 2025 @03:07PM (#44544273)
If the people are still paying the increased prices, it's a success. Rugpulling literal addicts is a great business model. Remember that business profits are primary, not consumer opinion.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by jen729w on Friday July 11, 2025 @08:05PM (#44538067)
> I feel really sorry for those who invested at a 9bb valuation.

Because they didn't do their jobs properly?

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by bmau5 on Friday July 11, 2025 @07:05PM (#44537693)
What was Garry's post?
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by forrestthewoods on Friday July 11, 2025 @09:51PM (#44538632)
I have same question
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by ec109685 on Friday July 11, 2025 @10:13PM (#44538734)
https://x.com/garrytan/status/1941553682736439307

The thesis is that once you’re paying $200 a month, you’re beholden and won’t pay and compare it with anything else.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by romanovcode on Saturday July 12, 2025 @02:29AM (#44539821)
Until something else comes around for similar price and is much better.

Good thing for consumers who use AI coding tools is that there is no lock-in like in Photoshop or similar software where you hone your skills for years to use particular tool. Switching from Cursor to any other platform would literally take 10 minutes.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by tootie on Friday July 11, 2025 @07:03PM (#44537680)
I think the recent Grok release and considering xAI was relatively late to the game shows that the only moat to training giant models is how many GPUs you can buy. ChatGPT was earth-shattering and it took less than two years for multiple credible competitors to match or exceed them. Making these models profitable is proving extremely difficult in the face of so much competition and such unsustainable expectations being set. Google seems to be most likely to sustain themselves through this melee. Them and the Chinese companies.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by parthdesai on Friday July 11, 2025 @08:53PM (#44538331)
Gary gives off a grifter vibe to me. Such a shame seeing how YC has fallen
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by sebmellen on Friday July 11, 2025 @10:41PM (#44538852)
He blocked me (a relative nobody) on X for remarking on the number of people I know who’ve made it to YC on completely fraudulent credentials.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by atakan_gurkan on Saturday July 12, 2025 @03:29AM (#44540055)
His reaction seems entirely appropriate. He could ignore you, but then you might keep replying to his posts and potentially spread incorrect but damaging information. He is losing close to zero by blocking you, but preventing a potential big loss. Why did you make that remark, if not to damage YC's reputation? This does not seem like the correct approach, if you wanted to improve their selection process.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by samrus on Saturday July 12, 2025 @03:48AM (#44540152)
> Why did you make that remark, if not to damage YC's reputation?

Seems harsh and cultish to assume malice. He didnt say you parents have false credentials

I would say calling out people and institutions like that is important so as to keep them honest, and if they arent honest and are trying to grift/defraud people then they deserve the reputation loss

> He is losing close to zero by blocking you, but preventing a potential big loss.

Thats great for gary, but the rest of the world isnt there waiting to be optimized for his benefit. If people trust YC to incubate good talent, but feel its becoming a hub for grifters, then some accountability is in order. Institutions are beholden to their public stakeholders, even private institutions, because they still have people who are using and supporting them

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by raincole on Saturday July 12, 2025 @06:59AM (#44541095)
Well, incorrect or not, now that person has a very strong motivation to talk bad about YC. Smart "reaction."
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by sebmellen on Saturday July 12, 2025 @12:15PM (#44543048)
The hilarious part is that I never interacted with him directly at all. I was just commenting something to a mutual on X, the thread blew up, he snooped it, and went on a blocking spree. It may have been different if I were directly accosting him in replies to his posts.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by BrtByte on Saturday July 12, 2025 @06:15AM (#44540883)
It feels like we're watching a hype cycle in real time
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by anton-c on Saturday July 12, 2025 @10:57AM (#44542513)
I seriously cannot keep up. I fell a bit behind and now I feel I need a primer to know who owns/acquired/developed all these additional things surrounding the ai space
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by theyinwhy on Saturday July 12, 2025 @02:29PM (#44543975)
That information is as important as knowing about soap opera characters.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by Andrex on Saturday July 12, 2025 @03:13PM (#44544317)
I really hope Sonny doesn't go through with killing Marco!
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by devnullbrain on Sunday July 13, 2025 @08:54AM (#44550097)
Not so, you need to know how long you have until they shut it down.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by anton-c on Sunday July 13, 2025 @09:27AM (#44550313)
That is refreshing to hear and a great perspective shift for me, haha