News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by woeirua on Friday July 11, 2025 @07:37PM (#44537910)
There is no moat. If you’re a true believer that strong agents are around the corner, then all of these add on companies will be obsolete in a few years. The first company to strong agents can trivially rebuild Cursor or Windsurf.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Friday July 11, 2025 @09:07PM (#44538414)
If you believe AGI is around the corner, doesn’t it mean it’ll replace ALL products?
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by yieldcrv on Friday July 11, 2025 @09:27PM (#44538510)
So grifting for investor cash and revenue right now is the obvious play either way
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by kevindamm on Saturday July 12, 2025 @01:06AM (#44539451)
That would be true if the product was the goal. In my experience,

  marketing > market > product
Even with AGI in hand, there will still be competition between offerings based on externalities, inertia, or battle-testedness, or authority. Maybe super-intelligence would change the calculus of that, but you'd still probably find opportunities beyond just letting your pool of agents vibe code it.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Saturday July 12, 2025 @01:43AM (#44539615)
Sounds like the kind of thing Windsurf & Cursor had as their most valuable asset - mindshare and authority?
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by pjc50 on Saturday July 12, 2025 @02:52AM (#44539920)
If you believe AGI is round the corner (I don't), then you face the dilemma of investing in a company that will be the one profitable survivor in a disintegrating world.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by charcircuit on Saturday July 12, 2025 @03:36AM (#44540096)
This would only be true if it was cheap to run and would return results quickly. If AGI only has compute to serve 1 customer per hour then their is an upper bound of market share it can take from other products.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by TrackerFF on Saturday July 12, 2025 @08:24AM (#44541572)
If AGI is around the corner, I don't believe one single company will "own" that tech. It will be like it is today, where you have multiple models competing.

And after that, AGI will be open source.

In the end, ownership of data and compute will be the things that define the victors.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aziaziazi on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:15PM (#44545230)
We don’t eat intelligence: bikes, bottles, food, energy… have room for improvement but I hardly see how AGI would replace them.

Same for physical services like labors, miners and cooks, even taxi/bus drivers for +99% of the world. Automation immensely improve their efficiency and the Modern Times is the past for half of the globe, but AGI isn’t the main facilitator.

Replace all (most*) Silicon Valley -and cousins- similar "products" and services, perhaps yes !

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Saturday July 12, 2025 @07:18PM (#44546057)
You don’t see how robots would replace all these roles? I take it you never seen a Waymo or read about how agriculture needs a tiny fraction of humans in the US vs a couple of decades ago? And those aren’t even “AGI-level” solutions…
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aziaziazi on Sunday July 13, 2025 @04:43AM (#44548637)
Waymo aren’t build, maintained and disposed by robots only. Even if they were we’ve still to see how that can be deployed (and make sense economically) to more than a couple percentiles of the richest people in the top cities. That has nothing in common with "replacing the humans".

Agriculture efficiency mainly comes from last century fertilizer. The modern robot trucks are also limited to some richest countries and farmers and have nothing to do with AGI.

Your vague dream of AGI solutionism missed the barriers to technologie deployment: raw ressources availability, politics, demography, energy… IA can have a small impact there but it certainly won’t replace ALL products. How would a computer replace a mining truck or a reactor turbine?

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by herval on Sunday July 13, 2025 @10:29AM (#44550699)
You’re missing the point so completely, I don’t see why I should keep engaging.
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by aziaziazi on Sunday July 13, 2025 @01:33PM (#44551999)
If I missed your point you’d be wonderful to clarify it, perhaps by detailing the first post "replacing all products":

- what do you consider a product?

- ALL as in Everything (obviously not I guess)?

Regarding "don’t you see how robots…" I clearly see the theory but also can’t see how it would happen in reality for the reasons I mentions in my precedent post: mainly access to ressources/energy to build/maintain those robots for a signifiant time scale and socio-politico barriers.

I’d be glad you reconsider explaining your point because I only see vague allusions, but if you want to stop the conversation here that’s all up to you.

Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by seunosewa on Saturday July 12, 2025 @05:38PM (#44545409)
Google spent 2.4 billion dollars
Re:OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is goin... by dalemhurley on Sunday July 13, 2025 @06:13AM (#44549071)
I am saying the subsidies tokens are the paper thin moat.