News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by standardUser on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:27AM (#43853991)
If you're going to put a guy in charge who is completely unqualified and has a history of alcohol abuse you should at least make sure he's competent. It's actually very grating to see someone operating at this highest level of authority and treating it like its beneath them. It feels like we're watching history get written by the most entitled and inept among us.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by sillyfluke on Thursday May 01, 2025 @02:21AM (#43854258)
What kind of tickles me is that any new poltical thriller tv series or movie that posits that matters of state in the US are conducted by serious and knowledgable people is now virtually unwatchable for me. It's virtually impossible to suspend the disbelief required to enjoy something that is so far removed from the reality of today's politicians.

(The recent cringe inducing Deniro series comes to mind)

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mycatisblack on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:09AM (#43855262)
You should watch Civil War (2024) some time. The disbelief is shrinking on that one.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by sillyfluke on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:42AM (#43856381)
As I recall the battle lines were a bit awkwardly drawn for that one. The realism would increase if Cali and Texas were governed by the same party for some time in real life (as I recall they were allies in that movie).

I would like to see someone take up the idea of Canamerimex Union in a movie for kicks -- that is, the idea of Canada, California and Mexico forming a union on the west coast (and maybe continuing down the east coast, with Canada bridging both coasts)

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by nozzlegear on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:51AM (#43857659)
> As I recall the battle lines were a bit awkwardly drawn for that one. The realism would increase if Cali and Texas were governed by the same party for some time in real life (as I recall they were allies in that movie).

I actually liked that little detail and don't think it's too farfetched. In real life those two states are currently on opposite sides of the political spectrum, but (iirc) we don't actually know why the civil war started in the movie and it seemed careful to avoid any kind of left vs right ideology. California and Texas both have a rich history of calls for secession from the union, and both have heavyweight economies that could allow them to stand as their own countries. I think if a civil war did break out where both states disagreed with the Federal government, they'd be more likely than you think to form an alliance.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by righthand on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:19AM (#43858033)
The war in the movie starts because authoritarian elected Potus Nick Offerman creates an economic division between the states which causes the states to group up geographically and ally on their divisions. California and Texas today wouldn’t pair but given enough pressure they might to ensure they remain an economic power house.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by nerdponx on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:45AM (#43858365)
I could imagine them seceding independently, but allying once seceded, especially if the CA secession government shifts more conservative.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by fireflash38 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:01PM (#43862681)
All it would take is one major disaster hitting the two most populated areas in CA to turn the state red.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by nozzlegear on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:28PM (#43863560)
We're getting deep into the hypotheticals now, but that disaster would probably also wipe out what makes California such a formidable economic powerhouse -- maybe that would be one reason California would want to ally with Texas. The disaster might also kneecap the state's ability to field an effective military via the National Guard.

But like I said, what was interesting to me about the movie was the fact that the two states were allies against the Federal government, without any mention of the modern day left vs right culture war. It's interesting to think about how such an alliance could come to be when we remove the things we suppose might spark a civil war today.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by sillyfluke on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:43PM (#43863700)
If they had developed that whole backstory of an alliance (how loose is it, how close or apart are they politically despite the military alliance etc) it would have been a different, and in my opinion, much more interesting movie. It just felt it was leaning too much on the visceral war aspect of it, and that didn't contain enough originality to carry my interest frankly. Others have mentioned the style, I just found the style uninspired "Vietnam War nostalgia" including aping the glorification of photojournalists and the overemphasis on non-social media "respectable journalism" from older reputable Vietnam movies.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mapt on Thursday May 01, 2025 @11:40AM (#43859199)
They currently vote different, but there are a few things they have in common.

They're both ridiculously disenfranchised in the Senate.

They've both got significant antivax elements.

They've both got a very large Hispanic population and a portion of the Mexico border.

They're both large states with large economies and large governments; Whereas the Connecticut governor leading the Connecticut national guard is numerically incompetent at protesting the actions of the federal government, or has to overcome a bunch of coordination problems with other governors, they aren't and don't. Whereas Trump was free to seize the COVID pandemic supplies that Maryland bought and paid for, and redistribute them as political favors to red states, it would have been more difficult to do to a state with six times the population and a power center far from Washington. Any effort to oppressively regulate interstate trade is diminished somewhere you're dealing with large amounts of intrastate trade; Conversely, any impediments on trade with and travel to Mexico are going to be substantial issues in both Texas and California.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mnky9800n on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:59AM (#43855634)
I found that movie to be disgusting as it takes real footage of war horrors such as 20 days in Mariupol, suicide bombers, etc. and sanitizes that for American audiences. Using this visual style of movies like 20 days in Mariupol indicates the filmmakers watched those movies and thought that could make them buck. Then it gives you some bullshit feel good call of duty action at the end to go kill the president which is tonally different both in visual style and in the context of the narrative. And it replaces the horrors of war such as bombing maternity hospitals and watching pregnant women be dragged from the wreckage with stereotypical racist Americans. And it justifies all this because it tells the tale of some war time reporters and asks the question what if they are just adrenaline junkies which is why they do their jobs? Thereby undercutting the real value and heroism of those who report on these conflicts who are captured, tortured, and murdered (e.g., Viktoriia Roshchyna). It does nothing to connect the audience with anything that is actually happening in the world and even serves to insulate Americans from the horrors of Ukraine and elsewhere while attacking journalists. I thought that movie was disgusting.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by nathan82 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:45AM (#43856409)
Do you have a different example other than 20 Days in Mariupol? Because the filmmakers definitely didn't watch that and think it could "make them buck". Principal photography for Civil War took place the year before 20 Days in Mariupol premiered.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by decimalenough on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:09AM (#43856157)
...huh? Civil War is about a group of reporters in the final days of a future civil war in America where a rather Trumpian president is about to be overthrown by rebels. It's not "replacing" anything in Ukraine because it's an entirely different story than Ukraine.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mnky9800n on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:22AM (#43856224)
I am talking about the visual language of the movie and how it takes the style of documentary films like 20 days in Mariupol (a movie about the beginning of the war in Ukraine). not the narrative.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by A4ET8a8uTh0_v2 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @08:10AM (#43856617)
I am confused. What is your complaint here? That US author's stole the visual approach?
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mnky9800n on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:28AM (#43858156)
I don't think the approach was stolen. It is fine for artists to take styles and ideas from other works and put them in their own. My point is that I found the film to be generally an affront to the suffering of people in actual, ongoing wars. It trivialized those experiences using them as a costume so american audiences could giggle in delight at the cinema without having to worry about the trappings of an actual war. And it did so all to tell a narrative that was somewhat against war-time journalism, painting their efforts as self absorbed and self serving. Like look at the way they film the death of the Kirsten Dunst, in this hero pose with camera in hand searching for the perfect picture. Contrast that to the actual life and death of someone like Viktoriia Rushchyna who was tortured and had organs removed or Shireen Abu Akleh who was allegedly shot in the head by a sniper while wearing a press vest. I simply found the film disgusting and if people disagree with me that is fine.

Of course any film about war (or perhaps any topic) could be controversial to someone. The WW2 epics starring John Wayne or Sergei Eisenstein's Alexandr Nevsky are both examples where the directors twisted every detail and used every opportunity to present a political message that the viewer may or may not agree with. My view on this is that the director of Civil War, Alex Garland, makes statements with the film that I disagree with. He seems to not see the humanity in people, at least, in my opinion. The movie never doubles down on anything, there is no deeper examination of the characters in the film, they just are until they aren't anymore. This is similar to his 2018 film Annihilation, which is essentially a retelling of J.G. Ballard's The Crystal World, and all of those characters in some way lack a humanity (although I think this works much better in this film as you discover that each character goes into the zone to find something about themselves that is missing and what defines them as human to themselves). And similar to The Beach, the novel he wrote that was turned into the movie The Beach, starring Leonardo Dicaprio about vapid westerners partying in thailand, or 28 days later, the zombie movie he wrote directed by Danny Boyle. Garland seems to see life as cheap and meaningless across the books and movies he has created. He cares more about the visual trappings of the setting he creates than the humans who live there. In the case of Civil War, I find it offensive as it uses the visual style of documentary films about ongoing wars as a costume and set dressing for his movie. And this movie comes from a culture (American) that started a war in Iraq and has done basically no introspection as to how those decisions completely changed their society into what it is today. This also influences the Civil War film. The president is blamed exclusively for all bad things across america. The entire movie is about how everything is the president's fault but lets interview him to see why.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by A4ET8a8uTh0_v2 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:12PM (#43862814)
<< My point is that I found the film to be generally an affront to the suffering of people in actual, ongoing wars.

In a sense, you do have a point. I do happen to agree that it is rather hard to match the sheer.. what is a good word here.. brute reality of war. It is genuinely hard to do even with the best efforts, because, and this is kinda the point that I am slowly leading towards: that the reality has to meet the expectations of the audience.

And this is where I think you seem to fail at something you chastise the director/producer/maker(whole crew?), who made that movie. You seem to think that all wars all the same at all times; that the esperanto of violence would immediately cause a rather quick, normative default 'war' state that anyone could recognize. But you would be wrong... I don't want to bore you with the details, but just to give an idea consider the thought that it was not that long ago that soldiers wore rather colorful uniforms ( for a reason ) and it is only more recent wars that made them try to blend into environment. And this is but one, small, but visible difference, which will define how a war "looks" like.

<< It trivialized those experiences using them as a costume so american audiences could giggle in delight at the cinema without having to worry about the trappings of an actual war

Does it? I watched the movie, because I heard so many differing opinions that it got me curious. I try to abstain from most movies lately. Frankly, were it not for my wife, we wouldn't stream, but it is what it is.

But more to the point, which scene seemed trivial to you? Maybe my experience is different, because I watched it home?

On the other hand, I think, again, you misunderstand something. Just by default, most of us do make odd sounds, when were are nervous or uncomfortable ( yes, even laugh ). I do not want to assume too much, but I think even if you saw someone laugh, you might be misinterpreting something. My point is that, even if what you observed ( assuming it was observed ) is true, it is.. not the movie's fault. People's come in all shapes and sizes. I know I laughed hard that one time I thought I was close to dying.

<< And it did so all to tell a narrative that was somewhat against war-time journalism, painting their efforts as self absorbed and self serving.

I mean.. I did not get that impression, but I think that one could be safely left to interpretation.

<< I simply found the film disgusting and if people disagree with me that is fine.

I am not sure what to disagree with. That war is bad? That the movie does not capture its true horrors? That people suffer? You might be losing your point a little.

<< Of course any film about war (or perhaps any topic) could be controversial to someone.

I didn't see it as controversial. It was mildly interesting, but that was it. I personally think too many read too much into it, while Bill Hicks probably would have called it for what it is.

<< The WW2 epics starring John Wayne or Sergei Eisenstein's Alexandr Nevsky are both examples where the directors twisted every detail and used every opportunity to present a political message that the viewer may or may not agree with.

Ok. Now I know you are older than me. And to that I can only say: welcome to the cinema. It is not just WW2 movies. Everything now has a message. Sometimes, it is ridiculously overt, sometimes not.

<< My view on this is that the director of Civil War, Alex Garland, makes statements with the film that I disagree with.

Hwell, you probably should not have watched the movie or listened to him or both.

<< The movie never doubles down on anything, there is no deeper examination of the characters in the film, they just are until they aren't anymore.

Well that.. is an interesting criticism. I was going to respond reflexively, but I am going to ask you a real question that ties back to your original complaint how movies don't show the true horrors of war.

Would you agree, especially based on the lack of deeper examination phrase you used, that, the fact that all those deaths don't matter is in a sense a lot more terrifying than whatever deeper meaning you would want to add to those deaths. Meaningful death could mean immortality, but just not being there anymore is just that..

<< The president is blamed exclusively for all bad things across america. The entire movie is about how everything is the president's fault but lets interview him to see why.

Again, I think you misunderstand the audience of that movie, because that part is a very clear reflection of the real life in US.

I was going to continue, but I think it is clear that we disagree to a fair degree. Please let me know what you think. It may end up being an interesting conversation.

For the record, I was fortunate enough to not have experienced actual war, but some of family members did so I got to hear some of the stories. I am not even talking about a trained soldier doing a tour in a foreign land ( though that experience clearly gives you a close insight into what is happening in that time ). I am talking about the civilians just trying to survive.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by wickedsight on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:30AM (#43855409)
I'm currently watching 24 again and it now feels even more like fiction than it ever did.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mnky9800n on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:00AM (#43855646)
24 was a wonderful piece of American propaganda whose only goal was to make it seem like torture was okay.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by acdha on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:13AM (#43857252)
Yes, it was sickening to watch a lot of people - even self-proclaimed libertarians – flip on torture during that period. There was a stark reversal from the 90s where the War Crimes Act was unanimously passed because back then anti-torture laws were thought of as affecting enemies like the Viet Cong, which lasted less than a decade.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Crimes_Act_of_1996

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by Der_Einzige on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:39AM (#43857523)
The jack bauer power hour is a strong memory of my childhood.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mrguyorama on Thursday May 01, 2025 @02:39PM (#43861706)
People who talked about how 24 and Jack Bauer showed that torture was good actually included a goddamned supreme court justice and I think the SecDef? The Bush Jr admin was openly fans of the show.

Oh, and the cast were invited to have a panel at a conference for the fucking Heritage Foundation!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_P52G4Kyq5M A look at the 24 world and it's insane violence by Jon Bois

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mnky9800n on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:59PM (#43862658)
There should be a whole PhD dissertation in how 24 took over American culture and was used to justify heinous acts with some trite “the ends justify the means” hero porn on prime time.

Edit: and don’t forget this show was on fox.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by layer8 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:42PM (#43862441)
Yeah, the “justified torture” is when I had to stop watching.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by pjc50 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:50AM (#43855562)
On the other hand, the UK Spitting Image puppet series of sketches The President's Brain is Missing holds up remarkably well, due to being about Reagan.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by ryukoposting on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:35AM (#43855894)
In that case, you may enjoy Veep.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by sillyfluke on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:33AM (#43856308)
Yes, I am familiar. When the dust has settled, it should probably go down as one of the best written shows this side of the century.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by trhway on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:52AM (#43856021)
Total endorsement for Veep!

There is a significant difference though which even Veep didn't predict - the people in Veep were still riding in the well-oiled deep-state car, while those clowns today is actively destroying that car.

Wrt. clowns - note that the most important Hegseth's staffer is his wife who was his producer back at Fox and basically does the same for him at the Pentagon.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by jay_kyburz on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:17AM (#43857297)
And "Don't look Up!"
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mrbombastic on Thursday May 01, 2025 @08:34AM (#43856863)
Yeah it has ruined the old zombie movies where the government ends up the bad guy but a competent bad guy that makes unilateral decisions like quarantining a city or bombing a civilian center to contain infection. I am pretty sure they are gonna all be either 1) running around panicking with the rest of us 2) infighting and useless 3) denying the truth before their eyes if such a catastrophic crisis ever were to happen.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by ModernMech on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:56AM (#43857731)
True, anything that doesn't approximate Idiocracy is now not realistic enough.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by pjc50 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:33AM (#43854016)
The entire administration is selected for loyalty. In this environment competence is a threat.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by SequoiaHope on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:32AM (#43854682)
> It feels like we're watching history get written by the most entitled and inept among us.

I suspect this is somewhat common in history (this is not meant to excuse it), but we can’t tell because those people still wrote the narrative.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by twixfel on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:24AM (#43855358)
So Trump will be looked back on as a good president? Highly unlikely, I'd say. Trump is quite uniquely awful in the history of the US.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by VierScar on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:13AM (#43855740)
Japan's WWII history is uniquely bad but they don't learn about it.

Can threaten authors with treason for negative books like he did in an EO recently. Change school curriculums. Then Maga can start revising history..

Was the 2025 recession from tarrifs? Nah it was Biden's inflation, or Ukraine aid. Actually.. didn't China impose tarrifs on US and US just reciprocated?

The reality will be altered and murky

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by yobi0h on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:22AM (#43856226)
> Japan's WWII history is uniquely bad but they don't learn about it.

I see this claim form time to time, but the unsavory side of WW2 is thought in classes, although not without controversy [1]:

Despite the efforts of the nationalist textbook reformers, by the late 1990s the most common Japanese schoolbooks contained references to, for instance, the Nanjing Massacre, Unit 731, and the comfort women of World War II, all historical issues which have faced challenges from ultranationalists in the past. The most recent of the controversial textbooks, the New History Textbook, published in 2000, which significantly downplays Japanese aggression, was shunned by nearly all of Japan's school districts.

On the other hand, after the occupation, GHQ had imposed a press code [2], i.e. censorship of mass media, that undoubtedly had an impact on postwar Japan, so you could say that the point still stands.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_history_textbook_cont...

[2] https://www.hiroshimapeacemedia.jp/?p=139387

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by MostlyBad on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:43AM (#43858329)
Having lived in Japan for 2 year and working in what one would hope being a very educated environment (Todai and Rikadai PhD candidates), I can personally account that the number of Japanese who actually know about that bit of their history is few. Culturally, they don't speak about this topic - and there if something is not spoken about then it does not exist. I would not be surprised if some teachers could simply not cover that bit of the programme without any consequences; Japan is specifically good at not following its own laws, when such laws have been written mostly to appease international observers - same with women equality and discrimination of minorities laws.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by twixfel on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:05AM (#43856126)
The problem is that everyone knows tariffs don’t work. History will not be kind to trump nor his supporters.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:21AM (#43857334)
> The reality will be altered and murky

The reality is already altered and murky. There has been a full-blown total information war over reality for several years now.

But Trump and MAGA, even if they win, won't win forever. There will someday be an end to this particular attempt to impose unreality. Then history (or at least the history of this) can be told honestly. (Or at least without MAGA spin. It may have a new spin, but it will at least be a different one.)

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by SequoiaHope on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:24PM (#43860662)
Trump is awful and so was G.W. Bush and Reagan and Nixon and Andrew Jackson and even George Washington[1].

We don’t learn much in school about George Washington burning down Iroquois villages because we focus on other things. It’s entirely possible that Trump becomes so bad that the people who remember his misdeeds get erased like so many Iroquois or Vietnamese people or gays with HIV under these other presidents.

Here’s a clip [2] of Noam Chomsky describing the war crimes of every post WW2 president. Many people still regard those people as good presidents because they ignore their misdeeds.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Town_Destroyer

[2] https://youtu.be/5BXtgq0Nhsc

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by djaychela on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:53AM (#43858456)
I think your suspicions are wrong. Yes, there are plenty of less competent people in history, but not to this level. Trump is an imbecile who just happens to be good in one direction (bullying and manipulation). Put him in an escape room on his own and he'd die in there. While I can think that many previous UK leaders have not been genius-level, I can't think of one who was anywhere near as stupid and beligerent as Trump. Other than maybe Liz Truss, who is thick as two short planks, but fortunately was ousted quickly. That won't be happening with Trump, and the US (and the larger world) will pay for these pocket-lining morons' mistakes.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by SequoiaHope on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:27PM (#43860698)
George HW Bush, Reagan, Nixon, Andrew Jackson, George Washington. They all did horrible things and their incompetence or evil led to widespread suffering of people most of us have forgotten.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43860662

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by int_19h on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:39PM (#43862397)
None of the people you've listed approach the level of incompetence of Trump and his administration.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by djaychela on Friday May 02, 2025 @05:08AM (#43867650)
Ditto the other response here. Trump is orders of magnitude worse. No other US leader in living memory has had such a negative effect overseas, and everyone I know in business in the UK is looking to move away from dealing with the US as quickly as possible given the unpredictable and capricious nature of the administration.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by eviks on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:42AM (#43854069)
Competence is part of qualification, so what you're asking for is not possible even in theory
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by verisimi on Thursday May 01, 2025 @02:44AM (#43854402)
True. But what did you think was happening before, with previous governments?
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by michaelt on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:23AM (#43854640)
https://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/23/us/politics/23berry.html

For a High-Tech President, a Hard-Fought E-Victory

For more than two months, Mr. Obama has been waging a vigorous battle with his handlers to keep his BlackBerry, which like millions of other Americans he has relied upon for years to stay connected with friends and advisers. (And, of course, to get Chicago White Sox scores.)

He won the fight, aides disclosed Thursday, but the privilege of becoming the nation’s first e-mailing president comes with a specific set of rules.

“The president has a BlackBerry through a compromise that allows him to stay in touch with senior staff and a small group of personal friends,” said Robert Gibbs, his spokesman, “in a way that use will be limited and that the security is enhanced to ensure his ability to communicate.”

[...]

The presidency, for all the power afforded by the office, has been deprived of the tools of modern communication. George W. Bush famously sent a farewell e-mail address to his friends when he took office eight years ago.

While lawyers and the Secret Service balked at Mr. Obama’s initial requests to allow him to keep his BlackBerry, they acquiesced as long as the president - and those corresponding with him - agreed to strict rules. And he had to agree to use a specially made device, which must be approved by national security officials.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by philipallstar on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:36AM (#43855464)
It's fascinating to see the difference in coverage.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:38AM (#43855479)
> the difference in coverage

Because there was a difference in conduct. Obama consulted "lawyers and the Secret Service," "agreed to strict rules" and "use[d] a specially made device...approved by national security officials." Hegseth yelled YOLO before effectively tweeting target co-ordinates for our warbirds.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by darkerside on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:07AM (#43855691)
It's fascinating to see the victim mentality on behalf of those who really don't need it
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by yubblegum on Thursday May 01, 2025 @08:35AM (#43856882)
> "lawyers and the Secret Service,"

Yeah, but that bit about "handlers" of the President of the United States could also be a data point here. That term is usually used in conjunction with 'asset'.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by PaulDavisThe1st on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:44PM (#43860956)
That term is widely used in multiple contexts.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by mrguyorama on Thursday May 01, 2025 @02:59PM (#43861933)
The President is supposed to be "an asset". An asset of the USA. They are subservient to an institution, despite being granted certain powers and authority.

Nixon once said "If the President does it, it's not illegal", despite that being just nowhere to be found in the Constitution in any form, yet that statement caused a bunch of right wing think tanks and policy institutions and voters to agree so wholeheartedly that they spent 70 years ensuring it would become reality.

Significant portions of the Republican party have been trying to make the US a monarchy again for decades.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by verisimi on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:21AM (#43855801)
There was also all that nonsense about Hillary's laptop and emails.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/sep/02/hillary-clin...

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by whydid on Thursday May 01, 2025 @02:48AM (#43854426)
This is an example of the False Equivalency logical fallacy.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by kubb on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:07AM (#43854530)
When you feel real love for your favorite celebrity convict, whose incompetence is beyond denying, you'll put your mind to work to search for any device that will enable you to excuse anything he does and who he nominates.

People will talk about "politicians being incompetent", or act like actually anyone who has ever been in the office was like this. It's a pretty close and comforting way to deal with the reality of supporting a fraud without having to admit that you were duped.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by verisimi on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:51AM (#43854779)
I don't think so. The original post is based in 'false equivalency'.

My position - for many years - is that government is immoral, and the people who serve in it are the worst; I don't have a preference between blue or red.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by yummypaint on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:38AM (#43855063)
What a coincidence that the Kremlin has been pushing that exact line of propaganda to western audiences through mouthpieces like Hegseth for years
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:43AM (#43855512)
"Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email [email protected] and we'll look at the data."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by DonHopkins on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:58AM (#43855180)
>I don't have a preference between blue or red.

In other words, you prefer red, but prefer not to admit it.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:40AM (#43855498)
> In other words, you prefer red, but prefer not to admit it

Lazy nihilism doesn't belong exclusively to one party.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by darkerside on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:09AM (#43855709)
No, but in this context, it's hard to disagree with the comment
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by verisimi on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:28AM (#43855839)
> In other words, you prefer red, but prefer not to admit it.

No.

I invite you to look into my historical comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=verisimi

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by pjc50 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:57AM (#43855619)
> government is immoral

Maybe you're going to find out how much more immoral warlordism is. "Not having a government at all" is a weird fantasy of teenagers.

(the really odd combo is people who hold both the "government is immoral, especially the US federal government" and the "the US federal government should go to war with China" combo, which a few moments thought will show the contradiction)

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by verisimi on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:26AM (#43855826)
Let's imagine we do go to warlordism and I do get to see how immoral it is.

At least I won't have to pretend that the coercion and theft is actually moral and good, right? At least I won't have to doublethink myself, turn myself inside out to justify the unjustifiable.

Ackonwledging the problem (immoral government) is just the first, esxential step towards making an actual difference. Why continue to pour in more effort to support an already failed system?

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by HWR_14 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:10AM (#43856162)
> I won't have to pretend that the coercion and theft is actually moral and good, right?

Of course you will. Not praising the warlord as moral and good will result in real physical consequences for disloyalty, maybe even summary death. As opposed to saying the same thing on HN when just your position is attacked.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by gadders on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:09AM (#43855712)
"A false equivalence or false equivalency is an informal fallacy in which an equivalence is drawn between two subjects based on flawed, faulty, or false reasoning"

What is the faulty reasoning here? Apart from "My side good, your side bad."

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 01, 2025 @09:34AM (#43857465)
You can find incompetence in previous cabinet officials. This batch of cabinet officials has far more people who are far more incompetent and unqualified than any previous cabinet.

The faulty reasoning is saying that "this is just like previous administrations". It's not.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by gadders on Thursday May 01, 2025 @10:53AM (#43858465)
But the previous president was in the advanced stages of alzheimers and struggled to form coherent sentences. I think he alone beats anyone in the current organisation.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by jmye on Thursday May 01, 2025 @08:33PM (#43864942)
> and struggled to form coherent sentences

As opposed to the current guy, who hasn’t completed a sentence or a thought in twenty years and regularly goes off on tangents about black people eating pets. Great take. Love when you folks make it clear you’re just here to shitpost dishonestly.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by lesuorac on Friday May 02, 2025 @09:35AM (#43869562)
Nor can the current guy remember things for more than the day and the then he admitted it live on tv after taking a dementia test!

Perhaps one of the more depressingly funny thing to learn is that in the first Trump term people would just steal papers and etc from Trump because by the end of the day he'd forget about something if there wasn't a sheet in front of him. And this would keep him from doing something crazy.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by lesuorac on Thursday May 01, 2025 @11:03AM (#43858604)
The faulty reasoning is the conduct is different.

Obama's and Hillary's blackberries were government procured devices altered by the NSA for security purposes.

The current US defense secretary isn't doing that.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by gadders on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:33PM (#43860787)
What about Hillary's personal email server?
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by int_19h on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:42PM (#43862430)
It was pretty bad, and there should have been more serious consequences for sure.

Did they discuss details of upcoming military operations on it, though? Because that's a whole other level of wilful negligence.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by Sabinus on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:48PM (#43864662)
Hilary answered questions for 11 hours in front of a partisan House committee regarding her email server.

Trump's admin won't get a fraction of that scrutiny.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by vkou on Thursday May 01, 2025 @04:55AM (#43855165)
Generally there would be a few garbage appointments, not an avalanche, and more important people have been shitcanned for lesser scandals.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by 1oooqooq on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:26AM (#43855374)
they at least had to pretend. and to pretend they had to let competent staffers do the work so they could take credit.

even bush fooled everyone he was literate (save from the two times he held books upsidedown) while in office.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by gadders on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:08AM (#43855699)
Stuff like this I would imagine: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/jan/20/hillary-clin...

"Some of the classified emails found on former secretary of state Hillary Clinton’s home server were even more sensitive than top secret, according to an inspector general for the intelligence community."

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by enaaem on Thursday May 01, 2025 @02:59AM (#43854488)
Imagine Hegseth was a black woman…
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by xanderlewis on Thursday May 01, 2025 @05:14AM (#43855289)
(It’s easy if you try…)
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by pjc50 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @06:02AM (#43855658)
UK comparison: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-47996907 ; black woman MP has a train can, everyone treats it as a massive scandal. I think someone had a survey once where they found that one third of all hate mail and death threats directed at UK MPs was aimed at her.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by prawn on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:22AM (#43856229)
For anyone else confused by the phrasing:

"Shadow Home Secretary Diane Abbott has apologised after a photo emerged of her sipping a can of M&S mojito on a London Overground train."

Meanwhile in Australia, the opposition leader visited a pub during his campaign and the crowd yelled at him to drink a beer out of his shoe.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by ben_w on Friday May 02, 2025 @05:51AM (#43867873)
*In theory* the problem wasn't the drink, but that it was on the train. Even in the UK, Farage is famous for drink-related photo-ops.

I'm emphasising "in theory" because it took a lot of concerted pressure for Johnson to leave after actual pictures of him celebrating with alcohol during the pandemic, so of course it was more an excuse than an actual cause of the vitriol against Diane Abbott: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partygate

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by gadders on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:14AM (#43856180)
There are no excuse for death threats but she is widely acknowledged as borderline competent at best.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by thrance on Thursday May 01, 2025 @07:16AM (#43856191)
And this is coming from the supposedly "anti-DEI" administration. What a fucking joke.
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by imglorp on Thursday May 01, 2025 @01:52PM (#43861059)
This is highly competent.

One skirts the official tools like this to prevent accountability from a written record. Completely sensible if you're planning to be judged for your actions.

Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by layer8 on Thursday May 01, 2025 @03:46PM (#43862498)
There was a related HN submission yesterday that didn’t get traction: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43846682
Re:US defense secretary circumvents the official communicati... by ncr100 on Friday May 02, 2025 @11:13AM (#43870898)
> history of alcohol abuse

Should be a disqualifier for US security clearance.

Is easily manipulable - either give them booze to pry secrets or encourage "booze mind" in 1-1 conversations to pry secrets. Plus the huge slip-up of using Signal #signalgate.