News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by sebtron on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:11AM (#43413051)
> Avanti West Coast offers customers:

> 15 minutes — 25% off

> 30 minutes — 50% off

> 1 hour + — 100% off

To me they look like very generous refund policies. I checked Italy's Trenitalia and what they offer is[1]:

> 30-119 minutes: 25%

> 120+ minutes: 50%

I suppose anything below 30 minutes is consideres "on time".

[1] https://www.trenitalia.com/it/informazioni/indennizzo_per_ri...

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by sensen on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:24AM (#43413264)
I commuted via train for years when I lived in Chicago and a refund policy like Italy's definitely would've been amazing. Perhaps the trains would be more reliable with refunds, all we received was a late slip when the train was delayed by 2 hours..
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by BeeOnRope on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:47PM (#43418480)
What is a late slip?
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by nobody9999 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:34PM (#43418773)
>What is a late slip?

I imagine (I don't live in the Chicagoland area, so guessing here, perhaps someone from the 'burbs there can chime in) it's a note from the CTA saying the train was delayed so you can limit your negative exposure when you boss wants to know why you're two hours late.

Which is actually much more than NYC does. Although that has its advantages as well. The linked fortune[0] (actually an excerpt from a NYT 'Metropolitan Diary'[1] piece ca. 1980) details this:

   I for one cannot protest the recent M.T.A. fare hike and the accompanying
   promises that this would in no way improve service.  For the transit system,
   as it now operates, has hidden advantages that can't be measured in monetary 
   terms.

   Personally, I feel that it is well worth 75 cents or even $1 to have that 
   unimpeachable excuse whenever I am late to anything: "I came by subway."
   Those four words have such magic in them that if Godot should someday show up    
   and mumble them, any audience would instantly understand his long delay.

[0] https://motd.ambians.com/quotes.php/name/freebsd_fortunes/to...

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/column/metropolitan-diary

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Kon-Peki on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:48PM (#43419499)
CTA never did that; I don’t think they could if the wanted to.

Metra did it, I’m 99.9% sure they stopped years ago. But yeah, there would be a person at the platform when the train arrived downtown with a piece of paper saying that the train was delayed. A late slip.

Nowadays, you have real-time location tracking of the train. If it’s late, you can tell your employer what train you’re on and they could verify it. At least to a better degree than with the late slips. Still not perfect. But if you’ve got an employer that would want to verify such things, you’ve got worse problems.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by nobody9999 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:06PM (#43419574)
>CTA never did that; I don’t think they could if the wanted to.

>Metra did it, I’m 99.9% sure they stopped years ago. But yeah, there would be a person at the platform when the train arrived downtown with a piece of paper saying that the train was delayed. A late slip.

Thanks for the clarification. I wasn't 100% sure about who the relevant agency was (as I mentioned, I don't live there -- although I do have family that does).

>Nowadays, you have real-time location tracking of the train. If it’s late, you can tell your employer what train you’re on and they could verify it. At least to a better degree than with the late slips. Still not perfect. But if you’ve got an employer that would want to verify such things, you’ve got worse problems.

A fair point, but there are some circumstances where both employee and employer may need to justify/document such circumstances -- but on the whole, you're spot on.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Ray20 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:54AM (#43421288)
>A fair point, but there are some circumstances where both employee and employer may need to justify/document such circumstances -- but on the whole, you're spot on.

I think we should also make it common practice to share grocery lists with your employer, as well as the date and time of sexual acts. This is even more justifiable than the status of the train that takes you to work.

I mean, trains are late not often enough to make any significant difference. Whereas unhealthy diet, or say, sleepless nights of lovemaking, can dramatically affect a worker's productivity almost permanently.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by nobody9999 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:05PM (#43428970)
>I think we should also make it common practice to share grocery lists with your employer, as well as the date and time of sexual acts. This is even more justifiable than the status of the train that takes you to work.

>I mean, trains are late not often enough to make any significant difference. Whereas unhealthy diet, or say, sleepless nights of lovemaking, can dramatically affect a worker's productivity almost permanently.

You misunderstand me completely -- is that on purpose, are you only focused on your situation and assume no other situation could possible exist?

Or are you just dumb?

Contracts that an organization may have with their customers may require that personnel be onsite at particular times, with the caveat that penalties in the contract may be lessened or eliminated if the lapse was an event outside the contractor's control.

In such situations, it can be important (assuming you want to get paid) to be able to document such events.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by seabass-labrax on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:49PM (#43429960)
Parent's comment was the sarcastic observation that if employers ought to be able to verify workers' commutes, they could justifiably also want to monitor other aspects of workers' lives outside of work that have a significant impact on productivity.

The argument is valid whilst being entirely dystopian. There is a level of trust, or at least tolerance, between employer and employee that must be accommodated in society; otherwise there is no choice but brutally invasive surveillance of all workers.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by nobody9999 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @07:03PM (#43430067)
>Parent's comment was the sarcastic observation that if employers ought to be able to verify workers' commutes, they could justifiably also want to monitor other aspects of workers' lives outside of work that have a significant impact on productivity.

Was it? Where did you get that idea?

Based on their posting history (and I did check before replying just to make sure I wasn't misunderstanding), that they were absolutely serious is most likely.

>The argument is valid whilst being entirely dystopian. There is a level of trust, or at least tolerance, between employer and employee that must be accommodated in society; otherwise there is no choice but brutally invasive surveillance of all workers.

Absolutely, and I never said anything different. In fact, the bit GP quoted and replied to was:

   >A fair point, but there are some circumstances where both employee and 
   employer may need to justify/document such circumstances -- but on the whole, 
   you're spot on.
Their response was orthogonal to my point. Which made me wonder why. And so I asked.

Keep an eye on my userid. If you don't like what I have to say, I strongly suggest you don't read my comments.

Have a great day!

Edit: Removed poorly supported assertions.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by seabass-labrax on Thursday March 20, 2025 @07:36PM (#43430279)
> Based on their posting history (and I did check before replying just to make sure I wasn't misunderstanding), that they were absolutely serious is most likely.

I, on the other hand, didn't check their posting history, and it looks like you might be right... Poe's Law strikes in reverse, perhaps!

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Spare_account on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:21AM (#43421129)
Somewhere else in the thread, it was suggested that these 'late slips' might be useful for proving to one's employer why they were late to work.

Is this the only use for them?

I am reminded, once again, how lucky I am to have been employed by people who trust me.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by tmtvl on Thursday March 20, 2025 @09:44AM (#43423290)
The only use for a late slip is to prove to someone (doesn't necessarily have to be an employer) that you were late due to no fault of your own.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by alwa on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:42PM (#43419465)
To be fair, NYC’s MTA writes tardy slips too: https://delayverification.mta.info/

I shudder to imagine the working relationship where that’s relevant.

But I very much appreciate the advantages you point out. I felt a little sense of loss when, on work in that city, I noticed that some degree of cellular service had reached the stations…

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by nobody9999 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:10PM (#43419592)
>To be fair, NYC’s MTA writes tardy slips too: https://delayverification.mta.info/

Wow. TIL. I'm a life-long NYer and never knew that.

Thanks!

>But I very much appreciate the advantages you point out. I felt a little sense of loss when, on work in that city, I noticed that some degree of cellular service had reached the stations…

If it makes you feel any better, such signal isn't very common, although the MTA is looking to change that[0]

[0] https://www.mta.info/press-release/mta-announces-5g-wireless...

Edit: Added quote that I replied to.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Larrikin on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:28AM (#43419904)
An absolute requirement in Japan if you are more than a few minutes late in Japan. A thirty minute delay during morning rush hour used to have train staff with a stack of papers handing them out to everyone going out of the gate kiosk. I used to get them after any delay at all on my commute.

I assume now annoying bosses can check online, but it's Japan so an old person in charge might ask for the paper slip as well just in case you overslept when you were in a nearby business hotel after a rather awful stint of over time the night before.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by dylan604 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:22AM (#43413225)
> I suppose anything below 30 minutes is consideres "on time".

sounds about right for the stereotype. it's the 'murikans that are the ones so uptight about time

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by ikawe on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:34AM (#43413396)
I think by and large this doesn’t play out with trains. American trains tend to be much less frequent, slower, and less comfortable than most European trains.

I road a swiss train a couple years ago that was something like 5 minutes late. To me (American) it was “on time” but the conductor came on the PA and apologized. He did make a point to clarify the delay was because they’d been stuck behind an off schedule German train.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by worldsayshi on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:57AM (#43413694)
It would be so great if the rest of the world could take inspiration from Switzerland and Japan regarding train management.

Also perhaps Ukraine. I heard they had stepped up during war time to the point of being more punctual than many other European countries.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by dan-robertson on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:20PM (#43414048)
Swiss trains are often on time because they are deliberately slow, and so they can speed up a bit if things are delayed. They are sometimes deliberately slow because the Swiss system is designed to have trains arrive and leave interchange stations at the same time to make changing trains easier. Some are also slow because they take routes that wind along mountainsides which are scenic but not particularly direct.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by worldsayshi on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @06:06PM (#43417777)
Interesting. I wonder if this goes further than just allowing trains to catch up. Like, does going slower lower the chances of failures and failure cascades in the first place?

Maybe trains in many/most systems are running faster than they should for optimal performance?

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by dkga on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:45PM (#43418834)
Well, that and their amazing logistics. Their annual time table is even connected to the local public transport in major and medium-sized cities.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by ruszki on Thursday March 20, 2025 @04:11AM (#43420740)
I travel between Vienna and Budapest quite frequently, and ÖBB (Austrian railway) does also this deliberately on Austrian side towards Vienna. Trains can arrive about 15-20 minutes early in Vienna if they go full speed in Austria, and they arrive in time to the Hungarian border. This rarely happens, and in that case, they go slower.

Also, there is almost always delay between Budapest and a smaller Hungarian city. ÖBB changed schedule for their own trains quite quickly reflecting that. MÁV (Hungarian railway) still hasn’t done that for almost two years now on the same line. They still basically lie about it.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by cyberax on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:53PM (#43417694)
Ukraine and most of the xUSSR countries have always had timely service. Trains are usually on time, although they are not always very fast.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Ray20 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:21AM (#43421429)
>It would be so great if the rest of the world could take inspiration from Switzerland and Japan regarding train management.

I would be glad to hear more about their success in the train management. Probably starting with one of the most important parameters - the cost of travel per kilometer per passenger (taking into account all subsidies, infrastructure and operating costs, and everything else)

>Also perhaps Ukraine. I heard they had stepped up during war time to the point of being more punctual than many other European countries.

Probably they have simply returned to the good old Soviet tradition of compiling beautiful statistics. Brought back bad statistics? Perhaps you and your male relatives will be more useful in the trenches. Complaining about train delays instead of productive work? Such active people and their male relatives are exactly what are needed to storm Russian fortifications! And voila - the statistics went through the roof.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:16PM (#43417406)
> American trains tend to be much less frequent, slower, and less comfortable than most European trains.

Exception: the New York regional rail system. Its on-time stats are comparable to Switzerland.

We love to talk about subways and intercity high-speed rail. But in America, it doesn't make sense in most cases without subsidies. Drive-on / drive-off regional rail, on the other hand, trades pursim for pragmatism and could really work in our car-dependent metros.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by jeroenhd on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:13PM (#43419313)
> But in America, it doesn't make sense in most cases without subsidies

That's the point of public transit, and that's the case everywhere. Also that of roads; roads wouldn't exist without government subsidies because nobody wants to pay toll to exit their driveways.

Of course you'd need to reduce car dependency for any public transit system to make sense, and I don't think Americans care for that. For some reason, "15 minute towns" were turned into some kind of boogeymen to scare conservatives for a while during the last election cycle, which says a lot about the American approach to infrastructure design.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 20, 2025 @02:05AM (#43420226)
> you'd need to reduce car dependency for any public transit system to make sense, and I don't think Americans care for that

This is what I mean. To reduce car dependence given America's built infrastructure, demographics and geographic spread, you'd have to build such a massive amount of public transportation that I think--outside major metropolitan areas--it would be cheaper to stick to cars.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by lmm on Thursday March 20, 2025 @03:45AM (#43420612)
Most major American cities have terrible traffic and air quality problems already, which are only getting worse as cars get bigger and heavier (and electric cars can be worse). America might need thirty years of densification before some of the high speed rail boosters' ideas make sense, but congestion charging, better zoning rules, and gradual elimination of street parking coupled with improving bus and rail infrastructure made sense thirty years ago and made more sense today. Amsterdam didn't get to be a nice place to live through natural luck or some magic non-Americanness, it took fifty years of gradual improvements and rebuilding, and the fights about it in the '70s were just as bitter as the fights about transport in the US today.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Lanolderen on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:12AM (#43421088)
Just quickly gonna shill that carsharing and motorcycles/scooters are a pretty good option as is home office/decentralized offices for many current commuters.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by lmm on Friday March 21, 2025 @10:30AM (#43436153)
Carsharing doesn't really help with peak time traffic which is the biggest issue. Motorcycles/scooters/e-bikes can work if you can figure out the right incentives to get people to use them. If you can get employers to support working from home that would help hugely, but that's a big if.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by throwaway2037 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @04:32AM (#43420869)

    > But in America, it doesn't make sense in most cases without subsidies.
Do you think any of those magical NYC metro area trains run without govt subsidies?
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Suppafly on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:40PM (#43417608)
>He did make a point to clarify the delay was because they’d been stuck behind an off schedule German train.

That's hilarious.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:22PM (#43418279)
> less comfortable than most European trains.

For long haul journeys, not really true. The reclining seats on most Amtrak rolling stock are amazing compared to most European seating (bigger, softer and they genuinely recline). The sleeping cars on Amtrak are at least if not more comfortable than the equivalent in Europe until very recently (and that exception only applies to specific night train routes so far).

It is true that if you're just hopping on a train to move around within a metro area, or to take a short journey within a corridor, US trains are not particularly comfortable, and their European equivalents are probably more so.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by kevinventullo on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:47AM (#43413558)
Japan would like to have a word.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by dylan604 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:32PM (#43414205)
I think there's a difference from being uptight about time and obsessively punctual
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by criddell on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:06PM (#43417342)
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by 1024core on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:52PM (#43417681)
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Aeolun on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:44PM (#43418460)
To be fair, it’s hard to see why a properly planned train journey would have any delays at all.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by labster on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:55PM (#43419226)
Maybe a huge snowstorm happens blocking the train overnight, then someone is murdered on board, and a detective has to figure out who the perpetrator is before the next station?
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by nobody9999 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:18PM (#43419628)
>Maybe a huge snowstorm happens blocking the train overnight, then someone is murdered on board, and a detective has to figure out who the perpetrator is before the next station?

That sounds like a great idea for a mystery novel. Perhaps one that includes the world's greatest detective. It might even get adapted several times for movies, both on the big screen and made for TV.

I'm going to write it all down and make a mint!

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by labster on Thursday March 20, 2025 @02:14AM (#43420251)
Now that’s using your little gray cells!
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by devnullbrain on Thursday March 20, 2025 @04:47AM (#43420954)
The optimal amount of train delay is non-zero. You need high redundancy to avoid many causes - and their knock on effects - and redundancy is antithetical to efficiency.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Aeolun on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:40AM (#43421227)
That’s only true if your goal is to optimize for profit instead of passenger satisfaction.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by devnullbrain on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:18AM (#43421410)
Passengers have to pay.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by RandomBacon on Thursday March 20, 2025 @08:01AM (#43421981)
have to or choose to?
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by devnullbrain on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:04AM (#43423650)
Yes, you're not a legitimate passenger if you haven't paid the fare.

It's immaterial though. They could instead face increased cost in taxes, decreased investment elsewhere, or good-old eminent domain for infrastructure expansion. The downstream effects of an infinite number of backup lines to guarantee service following an infinite number of track trespassers are not good for passenger satisfaction.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by RandomBacon on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:38AM (#43424770)
Sorry, I misunderstood something earlier.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Aeolun on Thursday March 20, 2025 @07:06PM (#43430086)
And trains have to reliably get people to their destination on time.

Regardless, my point is that the optimal amount of delay for profit and passenger satisfaction is not the same.

Ever since I’ve seen Japan’s trains drive perfectly as long as it’s not raining, on segments as short as 2 minutes apart, its become abundantly clear to me that delay is not an inherent property of any rail system.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by seabass-labrax on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:56PM (#43430012)
You're missing an axiom there - that efficiency is a superior goal to punctuality, or to something else entirely. Considering the amount of rolling stock just sitting around unused in sidings at depots, one can presume that many railway operators don't rank efficient allocation of resources quite as highly as you do!
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by toephu2 on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:51PM (#43418871)
China would like to have a word.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by B1FF_PSUVM on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @10:31PM (#43419397)
They are not prepared to have that conversation yet - still slumbering in 1972.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by charlieyu1 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @08:24AM (#43422159)
When I was taking a train in Japan I heard an announcement apologising for severe delays. It was less than 5 minutes.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by tdeck on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @12:55PM (#43414461)
FWIW Amtrak's policy is 15 minutes, but they're not known for being on time:

https://www.amtrak.com/on-time-performance

It's interesting how much effort here is dedicated to explaining that it's the freight rail companies' fault.

Re:I got 100% off my train travel by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @07:23PM (#43418289)
Because it is ... though Amtrak trains do sometimes break down, the vast majority of delays on long-haul Amtrak routes is caused by decisions made by the freight rail companies who own the lines.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by Tomte on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @11:38AM (#43413452)
Deutsche Bahn: 1hr+ --> 25%, 2hr+ --> 50%
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by eCa on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:56PM (#43417244)
I believe that’s the level EU requires for long distance trains.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by chgs on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:50PM (#43417671)
So 80% of journeys have a 50% refund?
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by usr1106 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @01:22AM (#43420084)
First of all while punctuality is not good, the majority of delays is at most 60 minutes. On many lines there is a train every hour, more in denser areas. So for the majority of the delays, zero refund. And then even if entitled for a refund many passengers never apply for it. Not sure whether there are any reliable calculations available, my feeling is a significant part. While annoyed when it happens many are not excited by the paperwork (or type and clickwork) later. And if you do your paperwork sloppily the refund will be refused. Also correct but complicated cases will often be refused in the first round, so you have go through a 2nd or even 3rd round of detailing your connection and ticket.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by chgs on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @04:53PM (#43417218)
This is standard U.K. policy
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by tecleandor on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @05:11PM (#43417364)
When high speed trains started operating on Spain in 1992 (AVE [0]) they offered 100% refund in any delay higher than 5 minutes (here a TV ad with very happy passengers because the train is arriving six minutes late [1])

But nowadays and after some mismanagement and also private operators coming to share lines it's:

For all high speed and other long distance trains: 60min delay, 50% refund. 90min delay, 100% refund.

This and other policies [2]

--

  0: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVE
  1: https://youtu.be/Djv91oHkj4k
  2: https://www.renfe.com/es/es/ayuda/compromiso-puntualidad
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by brnt on Thursday March 20, 2025 @04:10AM (#43420731)
I was once over 90 minutes late on a TGV. Naturally, SNCF reported a delay of 59 minutes when calculating my rebate...
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by dataengineer56 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:10AM (#43421075)
This is UK law(?) or standard across all rail networks. It's automated too, you don't have to fill in a form. Immediately after arriving at your destination you get an email telling you that your train was delayed by enough to give you compensation, click a link and the money is in your bank account in a couple of days.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by lozenge on Thursday March 20, 2025 @05:29AM (#43421171)
Automatic Delay Repay depends on your train company and which company you used to buy the ticket.
Re:I got 100% off my train travel by ivanjermakov on Thursday March 20, 2025 @12:28PM (#43425384)
Trenitalia would be out of business with higher refunds haha. I had horrible experience with rail transit in Italy.