News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by onepremise on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:47PM (#43272138)
Given that the Trump administration aligns itself with Russia and North Korea, the EU will need it. The US convinced Ukraine to scrap their nukes as they promised they would come to Ukraine's aid if needed. Trump is basically exploiting the situation to gain access to their natural resources. He's also telling them to let Russia keep the territory they stole when they Invaded Ukraine. Yes imagine that, Russia starting a war. Our country is so gaslit, our own citizens don't know right from wrong; fact from fiction. Protect your networks ppl. It's only going to get worse.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:58PM (#43272302)
> The US convinced Ukraine to scrap their nukes as they promised they would come to Ukraine's aid if needed.

Glad this video of Rubio making an impassioned speech about how "the credibility of America is on the line" when it comes to defending Ukraine has resurfaced: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

The complete collapse of the Republican party into one man's personality cult, any scintilla of principle be damned, is definitely not something I wouldn't have predicted 25 years ago.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by robwwilliams on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:58PM (#43272297)
Not just a large fraction of US citizens, but essential all Republican “leaders”.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by deactivatedexp on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:01PM (#43272346)
hmm what does game theory say about the situation?

right from wrong is not applicable to this situation not even one bit

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:55PM (#43272264)
The war has been going on for three years with no end in sight. What's the next move? What are your ideas to defeat Russia and take back the areas they've gained since 2014?
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by picafrost on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:09PM (#43272448)
The US funded wars in Afghanistan and Iraq for 20 years with no idea what the next move was, no tangible end in sight, and stakes far lower. The so-called threat of weapons of mass destruction was enough to swiftly defeat Iraq's army, topple its government, and start an unprecedented manhunt for its leader.

Russia has invaded a neighboring country twice and spent the first two years of the war they started threatening nuclear weapons. They disregard all negotiated agreements and treaties, poison dissidents in countries the US is allied with, with impunity, engage in asymmetric warfare against Europe and the US, meddle in elections. The Russian government has nothing but contempt for a rules based world order.

Why, suddenly, is the US cowering back when the stakes are much higher and its direct involvement much lower?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:26PM (#43272710)
I don't need a lecture on Russia's character. What I was curious to learn from you, or anyone, what could be done differently to defeat them? How would Russia respond if we send more advanced weaponry? Does Ukraine have the men to fight?

I'm getting downvoted but honestly looking for answers.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by picafrost on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:49PM (#43273048)
It’s a war of attrition now, which is a war of will and logistics. Can anything be done differently? I don’t know, but I don’t think so. Isn’t victory under these circumstances making the war so costly that your opponent must find a way out?

The US was doing that. Russia’s will has won out over the US’s, that is a defeat, and we can only hope next time it isn’t the same.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:59PM (#43273211)
War of attrition. I thought we'd be further along after three years of sanctions and weapons but I wonder if Ukraine has the manpower to keep it up. From what I understand, Ukraine is drafting men ages 25-60 which may signal they need boots on the ground soon.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by picafrost on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:18PM (#43273462)
Ukraine probably does not. Is Russia willing to risk the possibility of US/EU troops ending up on the other side of the trenches? Probably we’ll never know now, and maybe that’s better. But is it better that Russia knows maybe three years and the US might call it quits?

My country, Norway, shares a border with Russia. We have 5.5 million people. Would the US abandon us because we’re running out of troops? That’s the question we’re asking ourselves.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:54PM (#43273897)
You can’t fully defeat a nuclear power. You can, at best, drive it back — if you’re willing to pay the price.

And that price means Europe will have to absorb a dramatic, sustained drop in quality of life — plus forced mobilisation.

Even the Poles - the most serious player in Europe right now — only have about 200,000 troops.

The British and French combined have maybe 40,000 soldiers actually capable of high-intensity combat. That’s enough for, what - four weeks of real war?

After that, there will be no volunteers. That means a draft.

So the real question is: Are you ready to be drafted to “defeat Russia”?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by yks on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:53PM (#43273126)
The realistic answer is to say that Ukraine is going to be supplied with weapons for as long as needed, case closed. The whole Russian strategy after the initial blitz failure was to wait for Trump to get into power, who telegraphed to anyone with the brain, that he doesn't care about Ukraine and loves Putin very much. Russia can't do it forever, but it focused on appearing "strong" until the elections, the bet that paid off for them. Now imagine they were facing a prospect of non-friendly US administrations for decades, they would've already stopped.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:04PM (#43274912)
Realistically, does Ukraine have the manpower to sustain this tempo for years? If not, what countries should put boots on the ground?
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by yks on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:25PM (#43275119)
Ukraine needs to sustain significantly lower tempo than Russia and there are other options than boots on the ground. Simply flying in and shooting down slow-flying drones inside the Ukrainian airspace would probably give Ukrainian economy years of "runway". And any breathing room in the economy translates into more available manpower in the military and Ukraine still has millions available.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:08PM (#43274041)
Except Putin doesn’t need to outrun America — he just needs to outrun Ukraine.

There’s a finite number of Ukrainians, and an even smaller number of Ukrainian men actually willing — or physically able — to fight.

20% of the population already left, and around 1.5 million of them went to Russia. Another 15% are stuck under occupation.

Ukraine’s demographics were already a disaster after the WW2 wipe-out, the Soviet collapse, and 30 years of economic decline and emigration. Now they’re drafting 18 to 60-year-olds just to keep units filled - at 40%.

So what happens in a year or two, when there’s no one left to draft?

The Poles aren’t volunteering to die en masse, and they’re the only EU country with anything resembling a real army — and even that is one-fifth the size of Russia’s.

So who’s holding the line then?

The US Army? The Marine Corps?

Is anyone actually ready to send Americans to die in the Donbas?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by yks on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:09PM (#43274525)
Russian economy doesn't have enough juice to "outrun Ukraine" under the sanctions regime and the war intensity they maintain to impress the Westerners. It's not a "year or two", it's a decade at least.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:38PM (#43274711)
So what’s the plan here, exactly?

Keep Ukraine on life support for a decade, hoping Russia collapses under sanctions?

Cuba’s still standing after 60 years. Iran after 40. The USSR took decades to fall — and none of them had China bankrolling their survival.

Russia’s economy bleeds, but it’s not cut off. China sends tech and machines, India buys the oil, and Europe keeps quietly paying top dollar for gas through backdoors.

Meanwhile, Ukraine’s population shrinks, its economy is wrecked, and its army can’t fight without Western money, Western weapons — and soon, Western bodies.

Because if you actually want to push Russia back — not even collapse it, just push it back — that means European and American troops on the front line. Conscription, mobilized economies, the whole package.

Without a sustained meat grinder to chew up Russian forces, Russia just consolidates and digs in — with China keeping the whole thing afloat.

And if the West isn’t ready for that, who exactly do you think will still be standing in 10 years?

The only guaranteed winner? China — with Russia as a client state, Europe as a deindustrialized theme park, and America too exhausted to stop them.

If this is a game of who bleeds out last, Ukraine’s already done, Europe bleeds out first, Russia bleeds to its usual stupid level — and China walks away without a scratch.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by yks on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:10PM (#43274968)
The Westerners have been tirelessly making excuses about how it's impossible to defeat Russia for a while now, so forgive me for not being impressed, but the proposition is quite simple really — if you don't want to support Ukrainians fighting for themselves against Russia today, Ukrainians will be sent to fight poles and others for Russia tomorrow. Of course as it's clear now, the US wouldn't defend Poland either, fighting Canada is the new geopolitical priority, so there's that.

Agree that China is a winner of it all simply by virtue of not being mad, but as they like to say in Russia — it's not the evening yet.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:40PM (#43275257)
Funnily enough, this is exactly Putin’s own logic — just flipped.

“We had to support those rebel Ukrainian states so Ukrainians fight them, not us.” “We had to preemptively disarm Ukraine, or we’d be fighting Ukrainians inside Russia within five years.”

As for China — surely they’d be nervous if Taiwan was one-third of their population and shared a land border.

Ukraine isn’t just a border state, it’s alt-Russia, as Taiwan is alt-China (and so was Hong-Kong). A competing civilizational project trying to jump off the imperial train and build a Polish-style normal nation-state — and that makes it an existential threat. Not because Ukraine is strong, but because it offers Russians a dangerous glimpse of an alternative path — a Russian identity without the empire.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by yks on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @09:38PM (#43275756)
> Funnily enough, this is exactly Putin’s own logic — just flipped

Except Ukrainians ask the West for support to fight for themselves, so the West is given a rarest opportunity to do a morally right thing while furthering its own interests.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by GeoAtreides on Thursday March 06, 2025 @02:42AM (#43277516)
> they’re the only EU country with anything resembling a real army

??????

guess France is out of EU or... ?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Thursday March 06, 2025 @08:49AM (#43280145)
French land army is 77k total, with maybe 30k actually combat-capable — the rest are admin, logistics, and training. Add 9k Foreign Legion, but only a fraction of that is high-intensity capable.

With rotations, France can probably field about 15k troops on an actual frontline — and after that, it’s draft time.

For comparison:

* Russian armed forces: 1.1 million. * 500k deployed in Ukraine. * ~300k on the active frontline right now.

In terms of real land warfare capacity, France is in the same weight class as Belarus or Romania — and about 20 times behind Russia.

Even if you argue technical edge (better equipment per soldier), France has zero industrial mobilization capacity and no modern large-scale combat experience.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by cloverich on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:55PM (#43273153)
> I was curious to learn from you, or anyone, what could be done differently to defeat them

Russia doesn't have infinite capacity, their primary strategy was to take as much as possible at all costs as fast as possible, while waging info campaigns against the far right, in the hopes that Trump would come to power and cement a deal with them. If that option goes away, it strictly reduces Russias exit strategies. They can't escalate, because the west has more leverage and more options, it would be zero sum at _best_ for Russia. The West would likely hand them Crimea for peace, but giving them all of Donbas is too large a victory for Russia. The post WW2 orders foundational principle is that appeasement of land grabs leads to stronger positions for the grabber - see Hitler's numerous escalations before his full on attack as an example. Ideally you don't wait until the attacker is on your door step before fighting back, that's what this whole debacle is about.

Some of the options could have been:

    - Continue on, but with aligned support from the left and right (read: Russian psyops campaign vs the US right failed). Probably enough on its own.
    - Pressure China (tariffs) to pressure Russia
    - Pressure Europe to increase commitments
    - Offer Russia Crimea (already done ages ago, when their position was stronger)
    - Setup an increasing schedule of more advanced weaponry

> How would Russia respond if we send more advanced weaponry?

AFAIK they haven't responded to the last several increases; what would they respond with? The Nuke is their last card, and in addition to pulling in more Western support would alienate the other players (India, China) who have their own leverage on Russia. IDK overall it seems like the only major limitation here was the psychology of Trump's party.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:39PM (#43273733)
And what exactly is "The West" these days? A glorified open-air Continental museum, a failed British Empire with an army the size of Belarus, and a bickering hegemon half-convinced it should retreat to regional power status, house divided and all.

Europeans are still high on their own supply, fantasizing they’re global players, when in reality they’ve got no money, no energy, no industry, no credible army, no unity, and no diplomatic weight — not even within their own borders.

Europe spent decades as an American piggy bank and a strategic liability. Now the bill’s come due — and Uncle Vlad is doing Uncle Donald a favor, playing the bogeyman just well enough to scare Europe’s capital and industry back into the safe harbor of the New World.

And if Russian pressure helps deliver "MAGA in four years" by triggering capital flight from Europe to the US — is Ukraine really too steep a price for such a valuable service?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by yks on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:11PM (#43273370)
> the only major limitation here was the psychology of Trump's party.

The party that has 50/50 chance of winning the elections has been communicating to Putin all this entire time that they will hand him Ukraine when they win. Now they conclude that this strategy didn't help Ukraine and therefore it's time to hand Ukraine to Putin. Brilliant strategy, I wish them to enjoy their Russian friends who will definitely not screw them over very soon.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by aerostable_slug on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:28PM (#43272730)
Because this President campaigned on ending the long wars, which he opposed. I'm not sure where the confusion lies because Trump has been very clear about getting the US out of what he views as foreign entanglements.

I'm not passing judgement on it, just noting that what we're seeing is consistent with his campaign messaging.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:32PM (#43272802)
> getting the US out of what he views as foreign entanglements

The point is our alliances are also foreign entanglements. These idiots didn’t think through that withdrawing from those means fewer weapons (and other) orders from America, more nukes pointed at America and less strategic depth between our adversaries and our shores.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:50PM (#43273065)
The US hasn't withdrawn from any of its military alliances, and thus far has expressed no plans to do so.

I feel like this is where a lot of NATO commentary gets bogged down. There's a large group of people, conventionally referred to in US media as "the blob" (https://www.vox.com/22153765/joe-biden-foreign-policy-team-r...), who believe that the United States has an affirmative duty to engage in lots of global military interventions above and beyond the actual commitments it's made. I don't think they're lying - people seem to genuinely believe, for example, that the US is betraying NATO by cutting off support for Ukraine when most NATO members would prefer to expand support. But the North Atlantic Treaty simply does not contain a promise to align foreign policy in this way.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by chronid on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:22PM (#43273509)
The NATO treaty doesn't imply in his wording any obligation for a military reaction to an invasion of a member of NATO. There's no penalty to just respond with a strongly worded letter, but there's an expectation an ally will react militarly.

Will your allies trust you any longer if you just follow the letter of the treaty? I don't think they will. More critically, nor will anyone else.

The US have historically positioned themselves as "defenders of democracy" and have multiple times used that positioning actively. It's inevitable for an expectation to be there for them to do just that. The US is free to violate expectations and just follow the letter of the treaties it has, it is a sovereign nation after all, but the surprised and frankly childish "we have no obligation!" reaction to the blowback is more unreasonable than the expectations for its support of Ukraine, particularly in how it has been handled politically.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:21PM (#43274167)
One of the US's most recent foreign deployments is the Iraq War, which was based on a lie and extraordinarily unpopular among NATO members. I think abandoning Ukraine is very bad, and I agree it's unreasonable to expect Europe to be OK with it, but the US's current position in NATO was never based on a foundation of good behavior or uniform foreign policy alignment.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by chronid on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:55PM (#43275369)
There was effectively uniform foreign policy between the US and its allies for the last thirty years, even under the first Trump presidency, and this included at least a certain degree of interventionism (first Iraq war, Yugoslavia...) which solidified international institutions (differently from the second Iraq war and Afghanistan, which weakened them).

Even if they didn't agree, EU nations and Canada at least sent their soldiers to die in Iraq and Afghanistan anyway.

Why are you surprised people expect such policy alignment after thirty years of it?

Why are you surprised people consider this a betrayal of what NATO stood for in the past, as a proxy of the democracies of the west? Just because there is no violation of the letter of the treaty?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @09:46PM (#43275821)
I'm not sure why you keep saying "surprised". I'm not surprised. But it's not the case that EU nations and Canada sent their soldiers to die in Iraq; France in particular sided with Russia to block the Security Council from authorizing military action, leading to substantial tensions with the US and widespread disapproval from the public on both sides. European demonstrations against the war remain one of the largest mass movements in history.

I don't think it was surprising that the Iraq War led to anti-American sentiment, I don't think it's surprising that the current about-face on Ukraine is leading to anti-American sentiment, and I won't be surprised when it happens again in the 2040s.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by chronid on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @10:28PM (#43276092)
> But it's not the case that EU nations and Canada sent their soldiers to die in Iraq

They did, not all of them but many did. On Canada I may be wrong, sure. I believe even Ukraine has KIAs in Iraq.

> France in particular sided with Russia to block the Security Council from authorizing military action, leading to substantial tensions with the US and widespread disapproval from the public on both sides. European demonstrations against the war remain one of the largest mass movements in history.

The Iraq and Afghanistan wars broke the model the US and EU had been trying to push until that moment, alienating the south of the world from it and providing certain countries with a justification for their future actions. France had the right of it in the UN assembly.

People were angry back then for similar reasons they're angry and shocked now, and once again it has to do with expectations.

I also don't believe the Iraq war alone is not really enough to deny the alignment between EU and US foreign policy in the last 30 years or so anyway. You won't have complete agreement with 30 nations involved ever.

> But the North Atlantic Treaty simply does not contain a promise to align foreign policy in this way.

I think this in your original comment highlights your surprise at what those people believe, or at least your not understanding it?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:53PM (#43273122)
> people seem to genuinely believe, for example, that the US is betraying NATO by not supporting Ukraine

You’re correct in this being incorrect.

The informed concern is in Trump and Musk’s coziness towards Putin. That brings up questions around what, if anything, Trump would do if Putin annexed Latvia.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:09PM (#43273344)
It does, and it would be wise for the US to take steps to defuse those questions. This is why US troops often (and have continued in the new administration) engage in various celebrations and joint drills with NATO allies; there was a detachment of US troops in an Estonian Independence Day parade late last month, which I'm quite confident will not be happening for Russia Day in June no matter how much US-Russia relations warm.

But reasonable questions about the strength of an alliance aren't the same at all as withdrawal from or betrayal of the alliance.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:34PM (#43272828)
Yeah, agree that's what is happening. My original question wasn't rhetorical in nature. I would really like to know what would secure victory without escalating it to involve American troops on the ground and/or potentially a nuclear exchange.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by aerostable_slug on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:55PM (#43273146)
I would as well. It's unclear to me what would change the picture there. Do they just need more of the same (155mm artillery shells, drones, tanks, etc.) or are there qualitative things that need to change?

This speaks to the fact that I haven't seen any clear "this is how we win it" proposals. I could understand why the details would be classified, but I've not seen broad strokes, either. Has anyone else?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by robwwilliams on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:00PM (#43272326)
Help them win it. Like we did in two world wars in the 20th century. Here in the 21st century we get off easy and just provide material support, and intelligence; not blood. Hell of a deal to defend democracy.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by deactivatedexp on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:02PM (#43272362)
why not lead the way and go join the fight? you never know you might inspire people to join voluntarily
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by FranzFerdiNaN on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:09PM (#43272446)
Ah the we should improve society somewhat meme in the flesh.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:22PM (#43272631)
US helped Russia win in the second world war. You want them to do that again?
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:22PM (#43272646)
We've been doing that. What more do you suggest we do?
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by azan_ on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:04PM (#43272396)
Letting Russia keep the territories they control now is a great way to ensure that in few years when they rebuild their military potential they will attack again.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:16PM (#43272551)
It also signals wars of conquest are back. That’s a message that will also be heard by revanchists in Beijing and New Delhi and expansionists in Tel Aviv, Riyadh and D.C.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:58PM (#43272291)
> What's the next move?

Let the Ukrainians decide. The war could have been over if Biden and Musk hadn’t meddled in Kyiv’s strategy.

There is no peace with a Moscow that believes it can gain resources and mollify its population with wars of expansion. Pausing in Ukraine just allows for build-up for another wave. Maybe in Ukraine. Maybe elsewhere.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by rafaelmn on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:12PM (#43272481)
> Let the Ukrainians decide.

With money and military/economic tensions for EU and US ? EU might have some interest in stabilizing the border and preventing future threats, but US literally has no interest there. And the only EU member that possibly had to worry about Russia is Finland, but they are in NATO now.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by jajko on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:23PM (#43272663)
What motivation? russia is US sworn enemy, always was and always will be. Only fools don't take chance to make your enemy weaker, especially when its causing it to itself by their own stupidity and greed. US waged wars for less, far less.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by rafaelmn on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:30AM (#43277064)
I think from Trumps POV Russia is not that relevant and China is the rival. US has spats with Russia when they play globalist games, but Trump does not seem to be that interested in playing and Chinese are way stronger than Russia recently since they are growing their presence in Africa and SA.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by m4rtink on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:41PM (#43272948)
Good thing US integritiy has no value anymore and US word is apparently worthless nowadays - otherwise I guess honoring the Budapest memorandum would make sense:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum

You know, that one thing that certainly prevented a lot of nuclear proliferation so far.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by Aloisius on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:25PM (#43275120)
What part of that has the US not honored?

Did we (1) fail to respect their borders? (2) Threaten to use force, invade them or use those nukes against them? (3) Wage an economic war against them? (4) Fail to seek UN Security Council action in response to Ukraine being nuked? (5) Nuke them? (6) Refuse to talk to them about the agreement?

Because that's basically the entire agreement.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by jimbob45 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:09PM (#43272445)
The war could have been over if Biden and Musk hadn’t meddled in Kyiv’s strategy.

This is the exact line of thinking that Hitler used to justify WW2. Surely we can all see this logic for the farce that it is. Ukraine never had a shot at winning this war and it’s only with massive international support that they’re able to maintain the fragile stalemate they now find themselves in.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:12PM (#43272486)
> is the exact line of thinking that Hitler used to justify WW2

Hitler argued that he lost WWII because external powers were limiting the Nazis through diplomatic channels?!

> Ukraine never had a shot at winning this war

A significant amount of Russia’s naval and air assets were vulnerable to Ukrainian drone and missile fire in ‘22.

> it’s only with massive international support

You mean like the American Revolution, WWI for the Allies, WWII for the Allies and the Cold War for Europe?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by watwut on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:18PM (#43272583)
> This is the exact line of thinking that Hitler used to justify WW2.

Hitlers literal claim was that Germany needs a living space, that Germans do not fit into German. Plus he claimed that the world is a war of races. Like, these were his literal justications.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by Tainnor on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:27PM (#43273571)
Well yes. But he also claimed that Poland had attacked first.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by watwut on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:36PM (#43273692)
The equivalent there would be Russian claims about Ukraine attacking them right before invasion. As of now, the Russian invasion itself is provably existing.

It is about zero paralel with "The war could have been over if Biden and Musk hadn’t meddled in Kyiv’s strategy."

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by Tainnor on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:03PM (#43273974)
Oh for sure, I agree, OP's take was nonsensical.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by Vilian on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:25AM (#43277026)
They never had a shot so they used black magic to drive russia out of Kyiv in the first days of the wars?
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by erentz on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:00PM (#43272321)
Surrendering is not known to be a good negotiating position.

They were building into a good position with russia very depleted and economically on the ropes. Despite hold ups in US aid over the Biden admin. Pressing more aid and strengthening their position would be better for negotiating a peace. But quite simply Trump/Vance/Musk don’t want that.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by deactivatedexp on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:03PM (#43272375)
what do they get by supporting russia? would love some data
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by kdmtctl on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:33PM (#43273650)
If I remember correctly Trump promised to stop the war in 24 hours. The only way to do negotiate this fast is to totally diminish one side's position. When there no discussion, there is nothing to negotiate. The goal is not long standing peace, it is a plain populism and potential "peacemaker" title, and likely even a Nobel prize, if this wasn't derailed by Zelensky who refuses take words as a guarantee.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by CamperBob2 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:58PM (#43272301)
Give them the tools they need to finish the job.

This whole thing started when they willingly disarmed in return for security assurances that didn't turn out to be worth the paper they were written on. It progressed when Obama failed to help them stop Putin in 2014, and now it's metastasized due to Biden's half-assed support and Trump's active antipathy.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:29PM (#43272759)
That's exactly what I'm asking: what tools? The only thing I see is endless supply of money and ammo which means attrition. Russia will win in manpower but maybe not economically. I'm kindly asking to be educated with more than talking points we've all heard from politicians.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by m4rtink on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:45PM (#43272991)
Not arbitrarily stopping intel sharing and - reportedly - remotely disabling supplied wepons (!!) would be a good first step.

Like if you ever want anyone to give you a single dolar for your weapons in the future.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by mopsi on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:17PM (#43274122)
The most critical need is air defense: anti-air missiles and cannons capable of shooting down Russian missiles and drones. Long-range missiles are important too, because it is better to shoot the archer than to try take down every arrow. Long-range missiles can blow up the bombers that launch cruise missiles against Ukraine. This protects Ukrainian cities, factories, and military sites from further destruction.

Next, they need artillery to halt the slow advance of Russian ground forces. With the new unjammable wire-guided drones that were introduced early this year, Ukrainians have already successfully halted Russian advances in most sectors, but ample artillery support is even more effective. They need lots of artillery to blow up with a big bang everything that the Russians throw at them.

Finally, Ukraine must be equipped for counteroffensives. They need a large supply of planes, tanks, IFVs, and other vehicles to go from defense to attack and liberate occupied territories. Once Ukraine has the means to counterattack, it is up to them to decide how far they want to go before sitting down with the Russians to negotiate peace. Strong enough pushes by Ukraine may force the Russians to concede some areas without a fight, just as they previously withdrew from Kyiv, Kharkiv, Kherson, and Sumy.

The current approach has been a slow trickle of aid in a naive hope that Putin might back down. That strategy has clearly failed. Ukraine needs full support, everything we can provide. This is both the moral choice, and the cheapest option in terms of money and lives.

It is really important to stress that Ukrainians do not expect others to fight for them. They are only asking for material support: weapons, ammo, vehicles. The rest they can handle on their own.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by watwut on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @03:57PM (#43272285)
The thoughts are to NOT allow them to have time to rearm, get ready for another invasion, get another territory. And then again and again. That is all the peace right now would be - strategic pause so that Russia can get stronger for the next attack.

Also, Trump is supporting Russia while attacking Europe, Canada, Mexico, Greenland ... . Trump talks about annexing parts of Europe (Greenland) and annexing Canada.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by robwwilliams on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:02PM (#43272372)
More than a maniac.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by clivestaples on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:31PM (#43272786)
So by continuing to send more cash and weapons, it will eventually force Russia to retreat? I'm trying to understand what would secure victory.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by watwut on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @10:27PM (#43276091)
Prevent further expansion and besides, yes, they are attritioning. Or were before they found new supporter and ally in the form of America.

Like common, Trump is not just stoping to send arms. He is doing everything he can to weaken west and empowers Russia.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:22PM (#43272652)
> The US convinced Ukraine to scrap their nukes as they promised they would come to Ukraine's aid if needed

No they didn't. There was never any promise like that.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:35PM (#43272840)
> There was never any promise like that

There wasn’t a treaty obligation. But there was a promise.

Similarly, there is no treaty obligation for America to respond to Russia nuking Paris with even harsh words. Just promises around the treaty obligation to take “such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force” [1].

Let there be no doubt: the United States is defaulting on its promises in Ukraine.

[1] https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/official_texts_17120.htm

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:46PM (#43273812)
The Budapest Memorandum did not promise any defense.

> Seek immediate Security Council action to provide assistance to the signatory if they "should become a victim of an act of aggression or an object of a threat of aggression in which nuclear weapons are used".

Which they did.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:12PM (#43274072)
§ 4 only applies "if Ukraine should become a victim of an act of aggression or an object of a threat of aggression in which nuclear weapons are used" [1].

Russia is violating § 2. But Trump, Musk and Vance, by directly negotiating with Putin in respect of Ukraine's borders, are failing "to respect the Independence and Sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine" (§ 1).

[1] https://policymemos.hks.harvard.edu/files/policymemos/files/...

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by absolutelastone on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:29PM (#43274243)
This seems like a sideways trade and in the same spirit. Military defense guarantees, not on the table according to 4 presidents now, could become a possibility for that subset of land which does not require entry into a currently ongoing war. The prior tactic (mere 100's of billions of aid, plus some sanctions) has resulted in the same outcome via a stalemate anyway.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:10PM (#43274971)
> Military defense guarantees, not on the table according to 4 presidents now, could become a possibility

If someone trades territory for a U.S. security guarantee--absent a U.S. base that would have to be bombed by anyone trying to take more of the country--they're an idiot.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:23PM (#43274188)
4 is a bit ambigious if the nuclear part applies to the threat or to both.

Russia violates 2, but not US. Negotiating with Putin does not violate "to respect the Independence and Sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine" because it's not enforced. Ultimately it is up to Ukraine if they want to accept the deal negotiated by Trump

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @06:36PM (#43274292)
> Negotiating with Putin does not violate "to respect the Independence and Sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine" because it's not enforced

America negotiating with Putin on the future borders of Ukraine absolutely disrespects its sovereignty (by not including them) and borders. The proper role, if we wanted to directly mediate, would have been making it clear to Kyiv that the resource roll was done while informing Russia that if they come to the negotiating table then sanctions relief will be on the table. Then step back.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @07:55PM (#43274835)
Again, it doesn't because America is not deciding for Ukraine. America negotiates a deal with Russia, then sends the deal to Ukraine and it's up to them to take it or leave it. Just because you don't like how the negotiating is done does not mean that US is disrespecting Ukraine's sovereignty.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:10PM (#43274959)
> America negotiates a deal with Russia, then sends the deal to Ukraine and it's up to them to take it or leave it

Come on.

> because you don't like how the negotiating is done does not mean that US is disrespecting Ukraine's sovereignty

We're treating their borders as violable in the negotations. That violates the deal. The fact that many Americans have jumped the shark when it comes to honest dealing sort of underwrites why we're no longer a reliable partner--we don't even know when we're lying.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @09:05PM (#43275477)
US does not force any of the deal onto Ukraine, thus not violating the deal. US has negotiated a deal and offered it to Ukraine, who, in their full right, have not signed on.

US is still a reliable partner - which is why many countries continue to be in partnership with it. Fact is, US had made no promise to protect Ukraine.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:49AM (#43277194)
> US has negotiated a deal

That challenges its borders! If I agree not to steal your stuff and you find me hiring someone to steal your stuff, and I start arguing around the technicalities of our agreement, I’m a dishonourable liar!

> US is still a reliable partner

Are you watching the markets? Are you seeing the trade barriers go up? Our export companies are crashing. Our allies are writing separate security agreements, agreements that not only duplicate our own but balance American power.

I swear to god modern America is half made up of Calvin Coolidges. I’m not quite with Thiel on revisiting universal suffrage. But obviously the law of large numbers isn’t working when so correlated by social media.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @11:21PM (#43276396)
https://bsky.app/profile/igorsushko.bsky.social/post/3ljnqjm...

'to refrain from economic coercion designed to subordinate to their own interest the exercise by Ukraine of the rights inherent in its sovereignty and thus to secure advantages of any kind;'

The US is making any support contingent on a peace agreement that Ukraine doesn't want because it doesn't want to give up it's land.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by pqtyw on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:47PM (#43273026)
Technically the Budapest Memorandum was a "political agreement" between the governments of US/UK/Russia at the time. It wasn't an actual treaty like NATO that was ratified by congress. Of course you do have a point about the "such action as it deems necessary" part.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by WinstonSmith84 on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:30PM (#43272766)
Yes they did (with Russia)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine_and_weapons_of_mass_de...

> ... In 1994, Ukraine agreed to transfer these weapons to Russia ... in exchange for economic compensation and assurances from Russia, the United States and United Kingdom to respect the Ukrainian independence and sovereignty in the existing borders....

And yes there is this point but this is irrelevant. Ukraine played by the rules and got played. Nobody would have invaded Ukraine in 1994 if they had refused, especially given the state of the Russian army at this time

> While all these weapons were located on Ukrainian territory, they were not under Ukraine's control.[4]

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:45PM (#43273794)
> Seek immediate Security Council action to provide assistance to the signatory if they "should become a victim of an act of aggression or an object of a threat of aggression in which nuclear weapons are used".

Which they did. Please tell me which exact aspect of the Budapest Memorandum did US not follow through?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by kdavis on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:31PM (#43272785)
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by arandomusername on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:45PM (#43273795)
> Seek immediate Security Council action to provide assistance to the signatory if they "should become a victim of an act of aggression or an object of a threat of aggression in which nuclear weapons are used".

Which they did. Please tell me which exact aspect of the Budapest Memorandum did US not follow through?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @11:19PM (#43276381)
The current United States Secretary of State disagrees with you:

https://bsky.app/profile/dittie.bsky.social/post/3lji5yzf5ns...

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by mlinhares on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:32PM (#43272806)
> Protect your networks ppl. It's only going to get worse.

Most important piece here, don't despair, protect your people, build mutual aid communities with your neighbors and friends, there is no one coming to save us but ourselves.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:35PM (#43272844)
Ukrainian nukes were about as Ukrainian as Texas-based US nukes are Texan — they were Soviet weapons targeting US cities, with launch authority and maintenance cycles controlled from Moscow.

After independence, Ukraine had physical possession of a huge nuclear arsenal but lacked the codes and infrastructure to operate or maintain it long-term. The only practical options were to dismantle them, bargain them away, or possibly sell off some nuclear material or technology to third parties — though they ultimately chose to denuclearize under the Budapest Memorandum in exchange for security assurances.

What could have truly deterred Russia was Ukraine’s enormous conventional military inherited from the USSR (actually, the size of Russia's), but it was steadily gutted over the decades through underfunding, corruption, and arms sales.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by palata on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:04PM (#43273283)
> though they ultimately chose to denuclearize under the Budapest Memorandum in exchange for security assurances.

That the US and the UK (and obviously Russia) did not honour, did they?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by Aloisius on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @08:17PM (#43275031)
It has been honored by the US and UK.

The only obligations it imposes, besides not attacking Ukraine, is to seek UN Security Council action should Ukraine be nuked. I don't know why people keep trotting it out like it's a comprehensive defense pact.

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @11:17PM (#43276370)
That isn't the American Secretary of States opinion:

https://bsky.app/profile/dittie.bsky.social/post/3lji5yzf5ns...

Nor is the US currently 'honoring it' clear from a direct reading of the langauge:

https://bsky.app/profile/igorsushko.bsky.social/post/3ljnqjm...

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by ssssvd on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:24PM (#43273540)
It had been honoured — or at least not directly violated — for 20 years. And in international affairs, 20 years is "forever."

Between 1918 and 1938, how many treaties were signed, broken, rewritten, and ignored by how many powers?

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by palata on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:29PM (#43273594)
I'll keep that in mind next time I sign a contract: "I commit to honouring it until I don't".
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @11:18PM (#43276376)
Man so many American's about to be relieved they can stop honoring their 30 year mortgagee.
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by pqtyw on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @04:40PM (#43272920)
> The US convinced Ukraine to scrap their nukes

To be fair Ukraine didn't really have nukes. I mean they technically had nukes in their territory and maybe could have kept them if they really wanted to but it's a bit like e.g. Scotland trying to keep British nukes after declaring independence. Wouldn't make a lot sense.

Economically Ukraine was in a horrible state. Nuclear weapons have extremely high cost and I'm not sure if they even had any delivery vehicles? Also the the political repercussions, trade relations with Russia were very important etc.

Last but not least Russia and Ukraine were certainly not adversaries back in those days. After all Ukraine was on Russia's side when they attacked Moldova to establish Tranistria. Them going to war back in the 90s would have been almost as absurd as US invading Canada...

Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by Vilian on Thursday March 06, 2025 @01:17AM (#43276974)
You forget that development and nuclear power knowledge comes from Ukraine, so they had nukes and were direct involved on it's creation if wasn't created by them
Re:Macron to open debate on extending French nuclear protect... by pqtyw on Thursday March 06, 2025 @04:44AM (#43278244)
You forget that Britain and Canada also directly participated in the Manhattan project. Then they were locked out by Truman in 1945 and it took them another 7 years to develop their own nukes. It's just not that simple or straightforward.

Ukraine might have been in much better spot in some ways (they actually had functioning nukes) but in other ways it was simply infeasible politically (Russia was closer to being an "ally" than and adversary back in those days) and obviously economically unjustifiable.