News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by plantain on Saturday February 22, 2025 @03:20AM (#43137215)
How on earth is it possible they can cover a 1.5B loss? Are they really sitting on that much profit, or is the goal to ponzi it out from here, MtGox style?
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by reisse on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:06AM (#43137423)
Bybit trading volume is in tens billions of dollars daily. Their comission rate for the retail traders is up to 10bp (0.1%). Even considering a huge part of that volume is coming from institutional players who enjoy significantly reduced commission rates, I think they're surely making few million dollars daily on comissions alone, maybe tens of millions in a good day. And besides comissions, they also have other sources of profit, like staking, crediting customers, and forced liquidations.

Being a crypto exchange in current market is very profitable. If the crypto itself does not collapse, I think it's totally possible for them to repay that sum in a year or less.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by plantain on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:50AM (#43137605)
Most of the trading is not done by retail traders but at much lower fees than that, if not being paid (market makers). I just can't make it add up.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by reisse on Saturday February 22, 2025 @05:26AM (#43137783)
I know! As I stated,

> Even considering a huge part of that volume is coming from institutional players who enjoy significantly reduced commission rates...

But the volume is huge. Even if we take the best publicly shared MM rates from Bybit (which is 1.5bp taker commission, 0.5bp maker rebate), and assume the whole volume is traded with these rates, it is still 1bp from 40B dollars, which is 4M dollars daily.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by skeeter2020 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:10AM (#43139064)
even if this is true, they'll use their entire cashflow for more than a year to cover a single loss? That's not how business works...
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by TimJRobinson on Sunday February 23, 2025 @02:14PM (#43152170)
It's not like they have a choice. If they don't they have to declare bankruptcy because they can't honor customer withdrawals.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by spaceman_2020 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @05:02AM (#43137650)
Hyperliquid, a decentralized perp exchange, is a good proxy for ByBit’s revenues. On an average, Hyperliquid does between 800k-1M in revenue per day. ByBit is substantially bigger and easily does 50-100M in monthly revenue
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by xnickb on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:50AM (#43138562)
I'm nowhere near expert on any of the things below, but: My gut tells me if an exchange makes as much money as you suggest, people involved in that exchange are making even more profit from the said exchange, otherwise they wouldn't engage. The whole thing being literally money out of thin air, it feels like a huge bubble that should inevitably burst bringing down _ a lot _ of collaterals with it.

</speculation>

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by alberth on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:26AM (#43138797)
Coinbase charges 100bps (1%) between trader & maker fee.

Just last quarter, Coinbase had:

  Revenue:    $2.2B
  Net Income: $1.3B
https://help.coinbase.com/en/exchange/trading-and-funding/ex...

https://s27.q4cdn.com/397450999/files/doc_financials/2024/q4...

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by FabHK on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:55AM (#43139418)
Note that Coinbase (like most exchanges) charges retail clients outrageously high fees (orders of magnitude more than you would pay at a competitive FX or equity broker), but institutional and whales that trade a lot very small fees.

Yet another way crypto moves money from poor suckers to insiders.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by alberth on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:12AM (#43139638)
You just described volume-based discounts.

What’s so wrong with that?

It’s the same reason why buying a single soda at a convenience store cost more (per unit) than buying a large pack at Costco.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by _factor on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:35AM (#43140457)
Try to become an insider at one of these exchanges even with a couple million dollars. See how it goes.

This is like Coke ONLY giving discounts to Costco instead of anywhere else so that Costco can reap the rewards. Walmart, Target, they can all pay full price.

The convenience store spends more money to package individual items. A crypto transaction is the difference of a keystroke. They are not comparable on many fronts.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by alberth on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:43PM (#43141756)
Just curious, do you have concerns/issues with progressive discounts?

  Tier        Taker Fee   Maker Fee
  ----------  ---------   ---------
  $0K-$10K    60bps       40bps
  $10K-$50K   40bps       25bps
  $50K-$100K  25bps       15bps
Everyone is still paying the same full price (for the volume tier they are in).

Only those transactions at the higher volume tier get the higher discount (and everyone is eligible for that same discount).

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by _factor on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:59PM (#43145987)
From a capitalist economic perspective, it makes logical sense to maximize your profits and entice wealthier customers with quantity discounts.

From a societal impact perspective, it adds transactions that may not have happened otherwise, but these are mostly isolated effects from what I can tell. This can spur the economy with spending, and be more efficient. Ultimately however, it ensures that those with more money and the ability to buy in bulk lose less money than the tired masses. This should lead to wealth inequality over time.

Without knowing what impact each of these individual variables has in isolation, it’s difficult to define metrics for “net benefit” to society with any real certainty, let alone begin to measure them.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by FabHK on Sunday February 23, 2025 @03:08AM (#43147623)
They charged consumers on average 155 bp (!), and institutional 4 bp.

So consumers are charged 40x. Nice business. TradFi has wet dreams of margins like that for simple exchange business.

Source: Their 2024 10K, pages 92 and 94, and my calculation.

For 2024, in $bn:

  Transaction   Volume   Revenue   Cut
  Consumer        221      3.43   1.55%
  Institutional   941      0.345  0.04%
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by themgt on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:35AM (#43138849)
Yeah, as a layman this MSTR explainer was an "aha" moment for me:

No, what is likely happening with all the convertible bond issues is that MicroStrategy prices the bonds in a manner to attract market neutral hedge fonds, meaning arbitrageurs. Saylor has briefly mentioned these firms, as opposed to firms seeking actual Bitcoin exposure. For issue after issue, they can be spotted as the largest bond holders by anyone with a Bloomberg terminal. By buying the bonds, even when conversion price is at a large premium, and by simultaneously shorting the shares, these arbitrage funds can lock in close to risk-free profits. Due to the convex nature of the value of the convertible bonds, the hedge funds attempt to profit no matter whether MicroStrategy shares rise or decline

Like, a broker profiting off PFOF in the stock market makes sense because there's an underlying asset generating real cashflow that people are buying into. But where is the money in crypto actually coming from? You have to pay miners, brokers, rugpulls/thefts/etc and there's barely any cashflow from the underlying assets (dApps?). But if it really is ~just a casino, with retail gamblers as the only real source of cash, it can still be profitable for smart money to pour billions in and use their PhDs to trade the vol. It goes up, it goes down, overall retail is bleeding huge amounts of cash on a sort of 5 dimensional pyramid scheme but enough gamblers go viral winning the slots/blackjack that the casino doesn't run out of customers.

Can this continue indefinitely? Maybe / probably? Seems similar to sports betting, Polymarket, retail now ~70% of options trading. The west and especially America becoming a gambling culture. The "bubble" may burst and reinflate over and over.

https://medium.com/@bdratings/all-your-models-are-destroyed-...

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by treyd on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:35AM (#43139889)
> Due to the convex nature of the value of the convertible bonds, the hedge funds attempt to profit no matter whether MicroStrategy shares rise or decline.

This sounds exactly like the rationale for the box spreads incident on WSB a couple years ago.

"literally cannot go tits up!"

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by nullc on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:58AM (#43140668)
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by fc417fc802 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:19PM (#43143354)
> But where is the money in crypto actually coming from?

Where does the valuation of a payment processor come from?

Or is the objection that no one is actually using them to process payments, only to gamble? If so I'd ask for citations regarding the exact market breakdown.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by malfist on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:49AM (#43139370)
You might be interested in reading Warren Buffett's reasoning for not investing in crypto. Basically he says crypto produces no goods, products or services, and it's only value comes from finding a "bigger fool" to pay a higher price than you did for it.

It's value is from speculation assuming future speculation will assume more future speculation

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by desumeku on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:05AM (#43140153)
It's easy to agree with this position if you deliberately ignore that the "service" crypto provides is a decentralized, censorship-resistent, self-contained, global system of finance that is designed specifically for the modern internet age and which does not need to be under the control of any particular nation-state or company in order to function.

Otherwise, it is clear where the value comes from.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:56AM (#43140654)
Do you think Buffett isn't aware of these things?
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by desumeku on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:18PM (#43140887)
Probably. That guy is really old.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by sambapa on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:27PM (#43141007)
Yeah yeah yeah, then why everyone is losing their shit when the amount of worthless, centralized dollars they can buy per one Bitcoin decreases? Hmmm...
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by DrillShopper on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:29AM (#43140390)
Dunning–Krugerrands
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by evdubs on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:24PM (#43142200)
ByBit's trading volume is almost certainly largely wash trading. Most unregulated crypto exchanges are rife with wash trading.

https://www.nber.org/papers/w30783

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by earnesti on Saturday February 22, 2025 @04:12AM (#43137452)
Fractional reserve helps.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by ghhrjfkt4k on Saturday February 22, 2025 @05:47AM (#43137876)
FXCM forex trading broker covered a similar sized loss of client money (not hack) when EUR/CHF was unpegged in 2015.

Since it was a profitable broker business, another bigger broker gave them the money to plug the loss in exchange for taking over the business.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by cmcaleer on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:19AM (#43138035)
These exchanges make an absurd amount of money. That amount of money is basically a decent quarter for Coinbase in fee revenue, and Bybit is smaller but it isn't that much smaller.

It sucks if you're Bybit, but they're going to have plenty of lenders happy to provide them liquidity while they make it all back.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by scrlk on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:33AM (#43138436)
I can understand why some FTX creditors are pissed that the exchange didn't start back up under new management. They would have actually been made whole, unlike the current situation where they're getting "repaid" but pegged to November 2022 valuations (i.e. the absolute bottom of the crypto bear market).
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by qqqult on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:27AM (#43138078)
bybit makes $100 million a month and has substantial excess reserves
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by rvz on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:47AM (#43138151)
A lot more money than the majority of AI startups and it is creating jobs rather than purposefully destroying them.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by laughingcurve on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:04AM (#43139022)
I respect everyone's coping mechanisms, including yours.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by dang on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:16PM (#43142128)
Please don't cross into personal attack.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by skeeter2020 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:12AM (#43139079)
yes, great jobs: "I used to have to GO to the casino to play slots, and even without the one arm bandits, had to physically push the button. Now I work from anywhere!"
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:14AM (#43138723)
How on earth is it possible they can cover a 1.5B loss?

Easy! They give Binance an IOU in exchange for 1.5 billion BUSD which is just "minted" out of fresh new electrons. Everyone can then carry on as if it never happened.

In the bizarro world of crypto, this is business as usual.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by killerstorm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:35AM (#43138848)
How it it different from what banks do? (Except for a central regulator.)
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:53AM (#43138948)
How it it different from what banks do? (Except for a central regulator.)

Your exception is the answer.

Only the central regulator can "mint" money and doing so has real world consequences. The central regulator has financial incentives to limit this sort of activity.

The bizarro world of crypto has no such regulation and as a result, it is inherently unstable.

The proof of this is right in front of you --- it is the fact that "stable coins" exist. The only way to bring stability to the bizarro world of crypto is by tying it to "fiat" --- which is the very thing crypto is supposedly working to eliminate.

Contradict and hypocrite much?

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by owlninja on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:27AM (#43139192)
I saw a quote somewhere:

>Crypto is speedrunning the entire evolution of finance to end up at the same place

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:47AM (#43139349)
I saw a quote somewhere:

    Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it.
The only thing new about crypto is paper has been replaced by electrons.

Individuals/banks minting their own money has been tried before. It didn't go well.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by philipov on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:22AM (#43139756)
However, this quote is usually intended to be a warning, not an opportunity to run all the old scams again.

These people hear it and think "You mean we get to repeat history?!"

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by mikeyouse on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:52AM (#43140611)
It’s not an uncommon joke about how easy it would be to be a serial killer or bank robber in “the olden days” - just need to move 1 town over and you can do it all again which has a strong similarity to being able to commit crypto crimes with hardly a consequence by virtue of doing it across jurisdictions..
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by desumeku on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:56AM (#43140072)
I sure hope we don't end up in the same place where the monetary system is only being held up by the fact that there is more debt than money creating an endless competition for the limited quantity of money that exists in order to pay off ever-increasing debts and expenses with a currency that is continually debased throughout the process.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by pclmulqdq on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:12PM (#43140828)
We crossed that point years ago. It's the stablecoins that hold all the debt and use it to back their "dollars."
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by DrillShopper on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:22AM (#43140329)
We're already there. That's called "going to the moon". That's the end state. Get in, ride the rise, and then sell out and tell others to "buy the dip".
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by desumeku on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:01AM (#43140114)
They are being loaned ETH to cover withdrawals and prevent what would amount to a bank run, not stablecoins. This entire comment chain is stupid and pointless.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by killerstorm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:03AM (#43139526)
False. Money on your bank account is backed by bank's assets, not by the central regulator. Recommended reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking , M1 money supply, etc.

> The only way to bring stability to the bizarro world of crypto is by tying it to "fiat"

False. It's possible to make stable-coins using just price oracle and collateral. "Fiat" is not necessary. E.g. https://www.liquity.org/bold

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by bryant on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:07AM (#43139593)
> False. Money on your bank account is backed by bank's assets, not by the central regulator. Recommended reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking , M1 money supply, etc.

You didn't even finish reading the first paragraph.

> Bank reserves are held as cash in the bank or as balances in the bank's account at the central bank

The collapse of svb shows how much the central regulator cares about making sure the entire banking system doesn't fall apart, too.

With the way you remarked "false" at the OP, though, I don't expect you're here for an engaging and educational discussion, so I'll leave it here. lol

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:15AM (#43139681)
It's possible to make stable-coins using just price oracle and collateral.

Most attempts at "algorithmic" stable coins have failed. See TerraDollar, Luna and Titan.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by killerstorm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:29AM (#43139820)
Over-collateralized stables are different from "algorithmic": the algorithmic ones are not fully backed by reserves.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by rafale on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:43AM (#43139960)
They are very capital inefficient and still can fail during black swan events.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:49PM (#43141269)
the algorithmic ones are not fully backed by reserves.

And you just know that the "collaterized" ones are? In most cases, their books aren't open. And they wouldn't lie about this would they?

In some strange way, the crypto brain has been programmed to ignore the obvious with a hand wave and just accept all the chicanery that is crypto.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by killerstorm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:32PM (#43141663)
I gave you Liquity as an example. They don't have "books", it's a smart contract which takes ETH as a collateral and lets ppl to borrow LUSD against it.

Maker initially worked same way, but eventually they started accepting off-chain collateral.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by PhilipRoman on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:39PM (#43141725)
Regarding fractional reserves...

https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/mone...

>the Board has reduced reserve requirement ratios to zero percent effective on March 26, the beginning of the next reserve maintenance period. This action eliminates reserve requirements for thousands of depository institutions and will help to support lending to households and businesses.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Fade_Dance on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:00AM (#43138994)
Because while banks hold duration, the net value of their current assets, future asset streams, and equity is above zero. Indeed the core focus of the business and regulatory side is ensuring this is so.

The central regulator caveat is also a huge caveat to brush aside. During the last round of systemic stress, the banking system essentially got a guarantee that all uninsured deposits would be protected, and banks were allowed to post their collateral for liquidity at terms that no other business has access to.

What OP is referencing is the oft-seen practice in the crypto space where failed entities fill an asset hole with propped up tokens, essentially transforming their paper loss on the balance sheet into liquidity risk that doesn't show as readily.

The important point here is that in the latter case, the entity may be fully insolvent, even after accounting for future cashflows on loans. When it comes to banks, even the left tail cases like SVB, their "problem assets" are things like long term treasuries, which are way down the risk curve when compared to the ponzi-tokenonics style "stablecoins" that we've seen unwind over the past few years.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by skeeter2020 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:02AM (#43139007)
Banks don't print money for each other, and if they get money for free it's backstopped by the government and hence all of us. Crypto wants this single aspect but none of the central regulation.

Both systems stink for those at the end of the chain, i.e. us; you can decide which one is worse.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by killerstorm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:16AM (#43139688)
Banks borrow from each other all the time. What do you think "overnight loans" is for? And when banks gives a loan that creates money
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by phony-account on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:52AM (#43138941)
> How it it different from what banks do?

I often read this sort of comment from crypto-defenders, but is it what banks do?

I’m relatively naive about these things, but my impression is that a bank losing this proportion of their assets can’t just ‘pretend’ they have the money, or create ‘new’ money.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by malfist on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:45AM (#43139332)
That's because they're mistaken. In traditional banking only the central authority can print money, not the individual banks.

If someone stole a trillion dollars from JP Morgan, JP Morgan can't make themselves whole by creating a new trillion dollars.

The central authority might guarantee the customers of JP Morgan that their money is protected, but they won't print money to make the bank whole.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by lxgr on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:20AM (#43139733)
That's one model/theory for how modern money creation works.

Another is modern monetary theory (MMT), and in that, commercial banks are indeed the primary creators of money, with the central bank playing a technically more passive role.

Still, in either model of money creation (i.e. classical "money multiplier" and MMT), governmental regulators (which can be the central bank or others) do ultimately control the rate of money creation via various mechanisms.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by killerstorm on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:18AM (#43139727)
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by JW_00000 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:38AM (#43139915)
Banks create money by issuing loans; but they can't create money out of thin air if $1.5B was stolen from them.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by malfist on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:27PM (#43141613)
Banks create credit within the confines of law. That isn't creating money. Only the central bank can do that
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by tonyhart7 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @08:37AM (#43138863)
FEDS can print money while Binance does not
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by skeeter2020 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:08AM (#43139050)
not exactly true - Binance is indeed "printing money", just with no centralized regulation. When the Feds do it the expectation is that they are aware of the long-term impacts of doing so, and include in their calculation. For crypto it's the opposite: do it before you erode trust & goodwill to the point where it's no longer valuable. I see it more like it is very different than printing money in a economy that's perceived as stable and quite similar to printing money in one where the people have no faith in the value of sovereign currency. So the crypo-promoters are right about the use-case in certain jurisdictions, but the problem is that's not where the wealth is, so they target rich economies that tend to have stable government currencies & established banking, and do not need crypto for legitimate tasks.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by tonyhart7 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:41AM (#43139301)
I doubt they can because they peg it to USD, do you think they can pay aws bill with busd??? maybe you can but people with busd would convert it to usd at some point
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:37AM (#43139267)
Binance doesn't mint BUSD, BUSD is emitted by Paxos, which is an american licensed company.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:03AM (#43139523)
I have a license to drive a car. Having it doesn't limit my ability to mint crypto.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:12AM (#43139632)
https://www.dfs.ny.gov/consumers/alerts/Paxos_and_Binance

It was approved by the New York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS).

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jqpabc123 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:21AM (#43139745)
From your reference:

      The Department has not authorized Binance-Peg BUSD on any blockchain, and Binance-Peg BUSD is not issued by Paxos. 
If you insist, feel free to replace BUSD with an unregulated "stable coin" of your choice. How about FDUSD?
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:34AM (#43139879)
The sentence right before says "It is important to note that the Department authorized Paxos to issue BUSD on the Ethereum blockchain."

As far as I know Binance ended the Binance-pegged BUSD (the BNB chain version bridged from ethereum) without any problem or holder loss?

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by m00dy on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:05AM (#43139554)
Gary Gensler called BUSD a security and banned it years go. What a guy!
[dead]
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jvanderbot on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:17AM (#43139712)
Yes we definitely should have left all the sector unregulated or else how would we make a profit?
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by desumeku on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:53AM (#43140040)
They didn't regulate the crypto industry. They told everyone to stop and then refused to provide regulations or guidance on acceptable behavior despite continual begging by coinbase et. al. to be allowed to cooperate.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:24AM (#43139779)
I never said that it should be unregulated, just that the sanction applied to BUSD had a political motive. Of course stablecoins are not securities, just like a 20$ note isn't a security.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by jvanderbot on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:48PM (#43141259)
The analogy to cash feels a bit strained. There's a difference in backing, don't you think?
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:58PM (#43141359)
I was referring to the Howey test, that is used to determine if an asset is a security: https://www.findlaw.com/consumer/securities-law/what-is-the-...
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Gorkys on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:11AM (#43139075)
In crypto, there is the concept of the "fictional reserve" which can be used in situations such as this.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by DrillShopper on Saturday February 22, 2025 @11:33AM (#43140438)
If it's big enough you can even get the devs to fork the blockchain to reset things (see The DAO)

It's not that crypto folks don't want some protection from hacks or fraud - the just think it should only be for the rich.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:36AM (#43139260)
Bybit is one of the most used crypto exchanges and does >100M$ of revenue per month, growing fast.

If this isn't enough, I'm sure that every crypto VC would line up to buy a single digit % of their equity to cover up the hole. Crypto hosts the most profitable businesses in the world.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by FabHK on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:52AM (#43139392)
> Crypto hosts the most profitable businesses in the world.

Well, because the retail clients expect to get rich and don't mind paying 1% or so fees per exchange.

Similarly, the BTC future basis (the difference between the spot price and future price) on many exchanges around 10 to 5 years ago was easily 80% p.a. which you could realize by buying Bitcoin and selling the future. What happened there is that people going long Bitcoin with leverage essentially borrowed the money giving them that leverage at usurious rates (this implied rate is not usually displayed and thus invisible to your average retail client, but definitely very visible to the finance professionals moonlighting in crypto (such as Jane Street, Jump trading, and many others)).

Crypto use case: ripping off retail.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:06AM (#43139575)
You pay 1% on Coinbase because they are a quasi monopoly due to regulation. Offshore exchanges take less than 0.1% usually.

The neutral rate for perps is 10%, which is lower than the credit card borrowing rate in the USA. And nothing prevents retail investors to earn it by shorting while holding spot.

Last, Tether is crypto's most profitable business, and likely the world's most profitable if you account on $ of profit per employee, and is not an exchange.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by FabHK on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:11AM (#43139628)
Tether is an absolutely remarkable business, indeed. Basically an unregulated bank that pays no interest and follows no KYC/AML/ABC/CTF rules (because they just deal with wholesale, and then the Tethers are transacted on some permissionless "who, me?" blockchain).

Remarkable dereliction of responsibility. I don't understand why we let them get away with it.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by Saline9515 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:29AM (#43139830)
Yes, that's the concept of crypto. Uncensorable transactions. USDT is used in many countries that have capital controls, shoddy banks, or simply no proper payment infrastructure. Stablecoins work on week ends and are settled instantly. It's a superior form of money compared to what your average bank proposes.

And of course that stablecoin providers conduct AML and KYC when you redeem/mint them. It's like complaining that the gold foundries don't control the secondary market for ingots and gold coins.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by lxgr on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:28PM (#43141018)
Selectively censorable. Tether has the ability to freeze any address, and has been making use of it for quite a while now.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by lxgr on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:37AM (#43139908)
Presumably for the same reason the US let offshore banks get away with creating Eurodollars in the past: It's useful to maintain the status of the US dollar as the currency of global trade.

This utility has always been at odds with the (relatively recent in comparison to Eurodollars, as far as I understand) desire to and ability of the US government to use USD financial rails as a political tool via sanctions.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:48AM (#43139355)
Yes, the profits are insane in that business. Binance was raided for a similar amount, and paid it out easily. Mtgox was raided for ₿650k ($60B in today's money), and plans to return ₿140k to traders. However, I believe most Mtgox investors are better off this way because they were forced to hold onto their investments; otherwise, they would have sold at around $1,000 or so.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by snailmailstare on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:01AM (#43139487)
This loss is more than 5% of their holdings.. To me that implies the supposed benefit of crypto is nonexistent. If an institution is making so much money off your crypto assets that they can return 5% of them, they are a bank doing whatever it was that was so evil.
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:41PM (#43141171)
Institution is making money from trading fees which are not too high percentage wise. But the trading activity is very high, for many reasons. A lot more people can participate, from all over the world. Some use it to circumvent sanctions. Some enjoy day trading (no need to deposit $25000, as with US stocks). There are literally millions of instruments to trade. Some like to write algorithms, arbitrage, market making etc. Some dream of 1000x returns (and few do get them).
Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by misja111 on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:53PM (#43141317)
We don't know if they can cover it. All we know is a statement from their CEO.

Can we trust that? Suppose that ByBit couldn't cover the loss, and the CEO would honestly inform the world about it. What would happen? The crypto-equivalent of a bank run. So he would never say that.

Re:Bybit CEO Confirms Exchange Was Hacked for $1.46B by hnburnsy on Saturday February 22, 2025 @02:55PM (#43142540)
I had read they got loans and antcipate paying them back qith recovered proceeds. Interest they could cover with on going operations.