News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by coldpie on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:00AM (#42780825)
You're correct, but this is quite a boring response. If no one tried to make the world a better place, the world would never get better. It is an uphill battle, but I wish the OP luck all the same.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jklinger410 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:22AM (#42781877)
> If no one tried to make the world a better place, the world would never get better.

This is kind of a cost-benefit issue though. The benefits of having a local community outweigh the negatives of the platform having its own issues.

If your issues on the platform cause you to ditch it, which ruins your community, than what have you actually done?

I believe when it comes to anything that is not-for-profit, that the path of least resistance the only path. Therefore moving off of Facebook is simply not a consideration.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by cyanydeez on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:54AM (#42782326)
you're arguing local, short term benefits with global long term damage.

Very near sighted, but an actual problem government, good governance, has struggled with absolutely. Part of the techno fascism is emerging because people are entirely easily manipulated with todays egg prices and not tomorrows suffering of human rights.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#42783462)
> techno fascism

I keep hearing this. What does this mean?

My guess would be "a system in which big technology firms can effectively censor speech with coordination from the state". But I think those that use it mean something else.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jfactorial on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:12PM (#42784679)
I think "techno fascism" is a term people are using to describe tech company CEOs operating as unelected oligarchs embedded within the new US government.

If you're looking for a better term, we could call it "technocratic anti-liberalism" to perhaps cover all the bases. People are attempting to describe the current situation in which the wealthiest humans in all of history are supporting an anti-liberal executive by making financial donations to anti-liberal leadership and making changes to their products to further the messages thereof, e.g. broadcasting Nazi ideology and making Nazi salutes.

"Wealthy" as in "holding more personal wealth than the bottom half of the US population"; "anti-liberal" as in "espousing and acting in opposition to classical liberal values of consent of the governed and equality under law by denying the validity of elections, attempting to overthrow the US liberal democratic government with force, pardoning foot soldiers found guilty of such an attack, utilizing king-like executive direction to undermine the highest law of the land, avoiding all punishment for his own guilt, and so forth.

That's how I interpret the term.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:51PM (#42785045)
I'd say categorically that fascism is not a helpful term to define movements outside the 1900-1945 period in Europe. (e.g. Japan's movement was anti-colonial if anything, Tokugawa Japan would have been happy to be left alone to gaze its navel, if that wasn't possible it wanted the asia-pacific region as a buffer zone)

Today it is "Keir Starmer is a fascist" (Sci-fi writer Charlie Stross), "the local people department is fascist" (BLM supporters), I half expect to hear "Jesus was a fascist" although certainly that accusation is leveled at his followers.

There's something seductive about the imagery in Pink Floyd's The Wall and V is for Vendetta that is evocative of the period. Perhaps today's political systems are on the brink of failure due to inaction the way that the remnants of European aristocracy were. But we're not going to face what we're up against using "thought stopping" terms.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by spencerflem on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @04:23PM (#42785352)
Elon Musk did a Nazi salute, live on stage, twice
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @07:04PM (#42786903)
They told General McArthur when he was getting a tickertape parade to never hold his hand higher than heart level otherwise people would accuse him of making a Nazi salute.

As for Musk, I think he's mentally ill, I think he may have what I've got.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by spencerflem on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @07:52PM (#42787295)
If that's austism, I know several severely austistic people and am diagnosed autistic myself and absolutely none of us have done what can only possibly be described as a Seig Heil. I refuse to believe it was accident.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by PaulHoule on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @08:55PM (#42787868)
Autism isn't a mental illness, it's also a fad like gluten intolerance if you are self-diagnosed.

That said, I've seen autists take a spaz and go off on an anti-semitic rant that they didn't really mean.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jfactorial on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @05:42PM (#42786041)
I agree with you about trying to avoid thought stopping terms, and the desire for more specific language in important topics. It's tempting to think that history repeats itself, but it doesn't. It really doesn't. Historians will find ways of comparing and contrasting one moment with another, but whatever is happening right now is not determined by any historical law playing out.

Our language is bending as it ever does to help people explain these political shifts—often people who see what's happening but don't have much education on the matters of history, political science, philosophy. Bear in mind that 21% of US adults are illiterate, and far fewer are even equipped to read, say, Thomas Paine.

We need ways of talking about the values that are winning (nationalist theocratic autocracy) and the ones that are not (the open society, secular liberal democracy), and the word "liberalism" in the US has beenn so tarnished, so I think "fascism" today has come to mean "anti-liberal." I'll take what I can get.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by computerthings on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:23AM (#42791564)
To me the more defeatist part here was the claim that OP shouldn't even try moving off Facebook, than using "techno fascism" as a shorthand for the situation we're all familiar with in a reply arguing going the path of least resistance (going along) is destructive in the long run.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @06:12PM (#42786399)
Just leaving this there:

> Over 90% of political donations from employees at major tech companies like Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, and Google have gone to Democrats since 2004.

> In 2020, 90% of contributions from the internet industry went to Democrats, while only 9% went to Republicans.

> However, there are signs of a slight shift in recent years:

> In 2024, 15% of donations from employees at major tech companies like Google, Apple, Amazon, and Meta went to Republican causes, up from 5% in 2020 and 8% in 2018.

It sounds like your definition is "a few visible billionaires donated to someone I don't like"

> broadcasting Nazi ideology and making Nazi salutes.

Look, I get it. You have your politics and that's fine. But if you want to win hearts and minds, try another strategy. It's all just so exhausting and people check out.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jfactorial on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:44PM (#42788735)
Elon Musk is actively supporting AfD, the current far-right nationalist German party whose members have been caught sharing Nazi memes on Facebook with one another and, well, just read about them. He interviewed their leader on X in which the two of them agreed to rewrite history by saying Hitler wasn't far-right and was a communist. He wrote an op-ed in support of them. He stood behind a podium with the Seal of the President of the United States on it and did a Nazi salute two times in a row.

> broadcasting Nazi ideology and making Nazi salutes

This is a fact, not a rhetorical device.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_for_Germany

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by archagon on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:42PM (#42784965)
Big tech leadership cheerily cozying up to an authoritarian president, felon, and rapist who started an insurrection and literally tried to overthrow the last election by begging politicians to find him votes.

Musk — one of the most powerful people in Washington — doing things like throwing a sieg heil salute, supporting the AfD, claiming that "Hitler was a communist,"[1] and calling for the execution of a government witness[2].

Thiel proclaiming to "no longer believe that freedom and democracy are compatible," and then half of Silicon Valley showing up to party with him[3].

Techno fascism is what it says on the tin: technologists who are very happy with fascism for the sake of money and power. (Just don't call them fascists, they hate that.)

[1]: https://www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-far-right-german-leade...

[2]: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

[3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42773678

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by throwway120385 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @07:39PM (#42787213)
A lot of really smart people in the 1930's were also really into eugenics and forced sterilization and so on. Hitler had a lot of support, even in the US, for what he was doing openly. Being smart doesn't prevent you from being an asshole. Only being empathetic does, and you don't have to be smart to be empathetic.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pixl97 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:39PM (#42783707)
>you're arguing local, short term benefits

Whelp, we know which one is going to win then. An economic benefit now wins the vast majority of the time.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by cyanydeez on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:42PM (#42784967)
Yes, local maximums are deceptive and should be pointed at as often as possible
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by computerthings on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @06:07AM (#42791466)
Well, they asked about ways to do something, not whether to do it.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by underdeserver on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:08AM (#42781696)
Facebook is where his community is, and it's good enough for them. Why would anyone move? What possible hope does he have of overcoming the network effect and convincing people to move to something they don't know? (And is most likely - for their use case - a worse experience)
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by coldpie on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:17AM (#42781806)
Everyone agrees this is an uphill battle. What I'm saying is that's a boring reason not to do something you believe in.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:31AM (#42782001)
> Everyone agrees this is an uphill battle

No, most people don't care about having this battle - that's the point. If there's no demonstrable reason to leave (e.g. "former president got banned from major platform, so go to new platform") then the - valid, if personally boring to you - point is: how will you persuade people to leave it?

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by coldpie on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:57AM (#42782370)
Good question, let's try to answer it. Suppose OP believes they have a serviceable replacement in place. What arguments could they use to convince their communities to switch to it? Here's some ideas:

- No ads.

- Free, even for business-use.

- No algorithm interfering with visibility.

- It's usable by community members who do not have a Facebook account, for whatever reason.

- Allows for more free-form content.

- More choices for content delivery format & notifications (say, email, text message, newsletter links).

Maybe you can come up with some. What would you find to be a convincing argument to switch to a community-owned organization platform instead of Facebook?

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by briandear on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#42783465)
Who pays for it?
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by lowercased on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:20PM (#42784173)
I'd suspect the 'free' and 'no ads' would be somewhat mutually exclusive. Perhaps a particular group organizer pays a modest amount - $19/year(?) - to manage/moderate groups up to X000 members.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pc86 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:11PM (#42784672)
Which means it isn't free, it's a charity project paid for by the group organizer(s). That's probably fine in the short term, maybe even longer, but eventually the organizer(s) will move out of the area, or get tired of managing the group, or die, or whatever, and someone will need to manage it.

Honestly if it really would just need to cover the price of the cheapest hosting you can find and the domain registration a single small-to-medium Adsense ad in the sidebar might generate enough to cover it. I don't know how many impressions/pageviews it takes to generate $20 but it can't be that many.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by lowercased on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @01:37PM (#42796041)
I didn't say it would have to be free.

I run some meetup groups, and still pay for it for now, but the price hikes and other charges they're adding are onerous. I know many groups who have shutdown, and I know of some other players wanting to get in to this space to take over from meetup.com. $10/month to run a smallish group is affordable for a lot of folks. $50/month is not. $300/year is just not worth it to many folks, but... $99/year would be. Meetup seems to be moving in to some weird 'hyper optimize for short term revenue' move, which makes me think they'll be gone or acquired/dismantled in the next 5 years.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pixl97 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:44PM (#42783753)
Hello, it appears you've never even ran the most basic internet platform before in your life.

Simply put you have to ask the most important questions first, then build an app backwards from that

1) How will it be paid for

2) How will it be moderated.

So, you've already failed number one. You have no means to pay for it.

Then you failed number two. If it gains even a modicum of popularity it will be completely and totally over ran with spam.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by coldpie on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:12PM (#42784094)
I agree it's unlikely to succeed, but I find thinking about our problems and trying to fix them much more admirable & interesting than just rolling over and accepting things as they are. You can't improve things if you never even try.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pixl97 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:47PM (#42785014)
The important issue in thinking about problems is understanding all the interconnected problems.

The internet is a horrifically hostile place. If you design a product without that in mind you're creating a danger for yourself and for your users. Slap a community site up without thinking about COPPA or GDPR or whatever Californian law and suddenly you'll have problems. Slap a site up without heavy moderation and it will be filled with the most awful porn you can imagine.

It's not about just accepting the way things the way the are, it's avoiding becoming a casualty of the way things are.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:35PM (#42784323)
These aphorisms also don't improve things. There are actual barriers to trying something; if your suggestion doesn't clear them then yes, it's no point trying that suggestion.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bdangubic on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:42PM (#42784972)
You can't improve things if you never even try.

There are things you should not try as you can easily deduce that they are not rooted in any reality, e.g. "free" and "no-ads"

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by sam_uk on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @06:04PM (#42786319)
Signal not existing at all proves your point i guess.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by mmooss on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:39PM (#42784944)
> most people don't care about having this battle

That is also true of every advance society makes: Most people are happy the way they are. It's an obstacle every innovator and leader faces. Yet somehow, we make changes and advances.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by redserk on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @04:51PM (#42785566)
Most people don't care about the platform that's used if there's enough buy-in.

I was part of something similar a few years ago at a local makerspace. We were using Meetup.com for a while then someone relatively new suggested we try using Discord instead. There wasn't much of a convincing reason besides "let's try it", so a bit over half of the active people gave it a shot, and everyone else followed since that's where the activity was.

While a few people were initially grumbly over making a new account, there aren't many complaints now that we have bots to help with calendars and a bot to help us monitor equipment.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by talldayo on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:24AM (#42781900)
There are a lot of justified, boring reasons to not do something. I despise Facebook, but I'm also not going to waste my time trying to convince my cohorts to use a self-hosted federated alternative. You have to be blindly foolish to even hold out the slightest hope that these people will use an alternative, and I say that as a Mastodon user/apologist.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by coldpie on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:26AM (#42781936)
Okay.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by horacemorace on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:35PM (#42784901)
Many of us are insane in this way. Deride us as blind and foolish.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by briandear on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:18PM (#42783451)
It’s a Quixotic quest. Moving an online community off Facebook isn’t changing the world for the better or worse. It’s inconsequential unless you build an objectively better community. Just switching from Coke to Pepsi isn’t a wasted effort. Focus on zero to one, not zero to another version of zero.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by mmooss on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:40PM (#42784956)
It increases privacy (depending on the new platform), and reduces exposure to whatever toxic stuff is on FB.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:20PM (#42783493)
Doing something personally is fine. But trying to convince an entire community to ditch something that works and is likely incredibly valuable to them to stick it to some billionaire you don't like is just wrong.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by Zolomon on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:24PM (#42783546)
We all helped our families and loved ones to ditch MSN for Google Talk for Skype for WhatsApp for Discord etc.

It might happen again. :)

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by darthrupert on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:26PM (#42784227)
You're being sarcastic when you're implying that any of those switches were worth it, right?
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by spencerflem on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @04:26PM (#42785382)
its not wrong - we should all ditch facebook

it does seem unlikely to work though, for the reasons you mentioned

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:39PM (#42783697)
It doesn’t matter what the poster believes. He is doing something for the benefit of a community that doesn’t care about whatever ideological battle he is trying to fight and inconveniencing them in the process
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by archagon on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:52PM (#42785055)
Fine, let’s nobody do anything and convince nobody of nothing. Sit on couch, watch telly, mind own business. Great life!
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by righthand on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @02:07AM (#42789936)
If this is how you feel, you must feel inconvenienced that HN isn't a Facebook Group.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:01AM (#42780842)
If you can't communicate with anyone you can't make the world a better place.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bee_rider on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:45AM (#42781365)
We could communicate more effectively 20 or so years ago. Communication technology had already matured, but we didn’t have these engagement-driven social media platforms. The goal of these platforms isn’t to communicate, it is to sell ads and pick engaging posts to re-broadcast.

What gets people engaged is stupid anger. Even stuff I agree with on some fundamental political level, the social media version is just stressed out, to the point of being ineffective and often wrong in detail.

Centralized as driven social media can’t go out of business fast enough.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:31AM (#42782011)
Sure, but if nobody is on the platform or other end of the line, who cares?
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by briandear on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#42783509)
Communication was more effective 20 years ago? I remember using a Skypager when I was a Reuters journalist. I also remember processing film in bathrooms at news events then having to scan negatives using a suitcase-sized scanner and computer and it being 30-60 minutes to get photos onto the wire. Now it’s instant.

Saying communications were more effective 20 years ago is highly debatable and certainly an argument tinged with nostalgia.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pixl97 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:51PM (#42783830)
>Saying communications were more effective 20 years ago

Of course it's debatable because reality can be measured in multiple dimensions.

Is it faster, yes. Is filtering out the massive amounts of bullshit communications easier? Not really, especially with content aware spambots than can be ran by the millions. It's easy to get crushed by bullshit asymmetry. For me this makes most communications less effective because I have to spend even more time figuring out the actual poster and their motivations.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:25PM (#42783564)
I think you're mixing a few things here. There's social media (TikTok, Instagram, X, viral crap) and then there's social media (organize parties, facebook marketplace, Whatsapp, etc).

They may share a technology platform, but they are not the same.

If you have children you'll see social media (#2) is incredibly useful and facilitates greatly in communication. We're much more connected than our parents were thanks to these apps.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by BlarfMcFlarf on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:59PM (#42784544)
Facebook is rapidly moving away from effective communication. AI slop, AI posters, and algorithmic preferences for decisiveness over local community with engagement farming algorithms. If the communication medium you use is turning toxic, it’s imperative to find alternatives before communication breaks down and a switch becomes impossible.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @06:05PM (#42786329)
Do you use it for #2?

I use it for parent stuff and parties. It just does what it supposed to. See pictures of kids (private group). Get birthday invites. Just go to the group. No algorithm or engagement farming. It just works.

And marketplace has been a game changer.

What's better? Simpler to setup and maintain for local businesses or daycares. One daycare used a different app and it was awful. Janky, weird, missing features and the teachers complain about it.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:41AM (#42781307)
Tell that to Jadav Payeng, who planted a forest by himself. He accomplished, on his own, more for the good of the world than most communities on Facebook ever will.

https://interestingengineering.com/science/jadav-payeng-the-...

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by zdragnar on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:28AM (#42781967)
Rural Facebook communities aren't trying to change the world. They're there for light conversation, gossip and organizing get-togethers.

It's important to note that Jadav didn't get other people to change and join his crusade before it happened. He merely went out and did what he wanted. People were inspired by seeing it happen.

People aren't going to be inspired by yet another social network touting federation and other technical mumbo-jumbo, because it doesn't help them do anything they weren't already doing on Facebook.

This whole conversation is very strange to me indeed.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:04PM (#42782504)
> This whole conversation is very strange to me indeed.

Because you’re not engaging with the point?

For starters, the original claim was to “make the world a better place”, not “change” it. Beyond that, the point of my reply was to show that it is indeed possible to make the world better without communicating with anyone else (contrary to the original claim).

Anything else is your own addition.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:32AM (#42782021)
Eh, that's improvement, but the world didn't change because of a small forest.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:56AM (#42782353)
You (and your parent comment) said “make the world a better place”, not “change” it. Very few things change the world meaningfully.

And the point stands: what he did was more relevant than most (if not all) Facebook communities will ever accomplish.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:01PM (#42782449)
Splitting hairs.

If you use a platform nobody uses to try and change the world you won't change it just like if you tried to plant trees without using seeds.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:07PM (#42782545)
The point is precisely that you don’t need a platform to do something meaningful.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:37PM (#42782928)
I don't think the author was talking about isolated change like planting some seeds.

Real change requires humans to collaborate and work together.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:46PM (#42783054)
> isolated

The whole thread is about limited and well-defined communities, not the world. What the OP wants is specifically “isolated”.

> like planting some seeds

Spending thirty years planting a 550 hectare forest and restoring wildlife to it is not “planting some seeds”. Please don’t be reductive.

> Real change

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman

Change is change. You don’t get to define someone’s life work, which was more meaningful and impactful than most of us will ever achieve, not “real” to fit your narrow definition.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:41PM (#42783719)
50K people is a limited community to move to another platform???
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:55PM (#42783893)
Yes, yes it is. By definition. “Limited” means “restricted in size”, not “an arbitrary number a random person thinks is small”. From the moment OP defined “this is for this specific community of this size”, it is limited. It will be abundantly clear when they have moved no one, or every one, or a critical mass, or not enough. Because it’s limited, bounded, constrained.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:02PM (#42783977)
Well in that case so is the total population of earth.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:01PM (#42784560)
We’re not discussing the total population of the Earth. The thing about words is that their meaning may depend on context.

If we were discussing everyone who has lived and will ever live, the current population of the world would be a limited snapshot. Same if we were discussing every planet and civilisation in the fictional world of Start Trek.

But we’re not discussing that. Making up something we’re not talking about to attack what we are is called a straw man argument.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:05PM (#42784606)
And for the purposes of the stated goal, for one person or even a company to get 50K people to switch from Facebook or to use another platform especially when all someone else has to do is start a group on Facebook, might as well be “the number of people on earth” difficult.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:14PM (#42784694)
Yes, I agree, I’ve said that several hours ago.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42781581

What you’re arguing against is not the point I was making. My point in this thread is way up there: it replies to someone saying you cannot make the world better without communicating with other humans, by presenting someone who on their own improved the world more than most (if not all) Facebook groups ever will.

When I used the word “limited”, it was clearly in reference to it being an “isolated” specific community and not everyone.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:19PM (#42784157)
Mincing words and splitting hairs again.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:53PM (#42784500)
Words have meanings. Communication between humans, which you’re keenly defending, depends on a shared understanding of them. I haven’t commented on it until now, but in my view you’re splitting hairs by repeatedly creating your own definitions (e.g. defining what is “real” change or not; changing the definition of words you said; saying “improvement” is not “change”; misunderstanding “limited”). So your repeated accusations don’t really land.

I don’t think it’s worth either of our times to continue, though. We’ve strayed too much from the original point.

A good evening (or your equivalent time of day) to you.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @04:30PM (#42785411)
Yeah, and mincing words to make a silly argument valid isn't communication, it's arguing for arguments sake.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by gabruoy on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:35PM (#42784318)
He very literally did change the world. There wasn’t a forest there and now there is. In fact the conception of “the world” as an abstract global concept is much less impactful than what people see outside their window and in their city/community.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by diggan on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:36AM (#42781243)
Maybe that's why OP is looking for an alternative to use for communication and organization?
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by ecshafer on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:10AM (#42780933)
Do you think its a better place, or do the users think its a better place? Take political partisanship out of it. So its about a 30/30/40 breakdown between Trump/Harris/None. So 70% of people either Support or Don't care that much about Trump, and that's assuming that every single democratic voter is angry enough to quit Facebook over this, this is probably not true. You are looking at probably >85% of people that don't think that getting rid of Facebook would make things better.

A better world is subjective.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by vladms on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:52AM (#42781459)
Is Facebook though the perfect community tool? Using centralized systems has advantages (simple/easy/available/cheap) but also disadvantages (less customization/less control/more expensive). When Facebook appeared maybe the alternatives were not there due to technical complexity is this still the case nowadays?...
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by robertlagrant on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:32AM (#42782025)
There were alternatives, but the network effect is real. Facebook wants people to stay on their platform, sure, but people also like staying in one app if they can. They know how to use it, and it's not yet another app.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by coldpie on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:21AM (#42781074)
> A better world is subjective.

Yeah, obviously. So part of the OP's task will be selling their communities on why switching away from Facebook is a good thing. Given everything that's going on, now is a good opportunity to do that. But before they can do that, they need to know what to switch to, which is the topic of this thread.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pimlottc on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:35PM (#42783658)
I wish them luck too! But you have to be realistic and understand your users. Their value are not necessarily your values. A new services must be clearly better for them to switch; just being "not Facebook" is not that compelling to the average person.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by tobyjsullivan on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:44PM (#42783756)

   The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists
   in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on 
   the unreasonable man.
- George Bernard Shaw, Man and Superman (1903)
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by randcraw on Wednesday January 22, 2025 @09:46AM (#42793360)
More precisely, that unreasonable man must add sufficient extraordinary value to his product to convert complacent users into willing defectors.

Thus you must convince users that 1) FB is clearly inferior to your product (e.g. many important hidden demerits) or 2) your product adds something essential that's absent in FB. Otherwise, why switch?

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pc86 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:05PM (#42784613)
Nobody is talking about "making the world a better place," we're talking about a few Facebook groups using a different app instead (and approximately 100% of those people will still be on Facebook doing other things).
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by danparsonson on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @06:41PM (#42786673)
Incremental change is also a thing