News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:01AM (#42780842)
If you can't communicate with anyone you can't make the world a better place.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bee_rider on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:45AM (#42781365)
We could communicate more effectively 20 or so years ago. Communication technology had already matured, but we didn’t have these engagement-driven social media platforms. The goal of these platforms isn’t to communicate, it is to sell ads and pick engaging posts to re-broadcast.

What gets people engaged is stupid anger. Even stuff I agree with on some fundamental political level, the social media version is just stressed out, to the point of being ineffective and often wrong in detail.

Centralized as driven social media can’t go out of business fast enough.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:31AM (#42782011)
Sure, but if nobody is on the platform or other end of the line, who cares?
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by briandear on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:22PM (#42783509)
Communication was more effective 20 years ago? I remember using a Skypager when I was a Reuters journalist. I also remember processing film in bathrooms at news events then having to scan negatives using a suitcase-sized scanner and computer and it being 30-60 minutes to get photos onto the wire. Now it’s instant.

Saying communications were more effective 20 years ago is highly debatable and certainly an argument tinged with nostalgia.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by pixl97 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:51PM (#42783830)
>Saying communications were more effective 20 years ago

Of course it's debatable because reality can be measured in multiple dimensions.

Is it faster, yes. Is filtering out the massive amounts of bullshit communications easier? Not really, especially with content aware spambots than can be ran by the millions. It's easy to get crushed by bullshit asymmetry. For me this makes most communications less effective because I have to spend even more time figuring out the actual poster and their motivations.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:25PM (#42783564)
I think you're mixing a few things here. There's social media (TikTok, Instagram, X, viral crap) and then there's social media (organize parties, facebook marketplace, Whatsapp, etc).

They may share a technology platform, but they are not the same.

If you have children you'll see social media (#2) is incredibly useful and facilitates greatly in communication. We're much more connected than our parents were thanks to these apps.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by BlarfMcFlarf on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:59PM (#42784544)
Facebook is rapidly moving away from effective communication. AI slop, AI posters, and algorithmic preferences for decisiveness over local community with engagement farming algorithms. If the communication medium you use is turning toxic, it’s imperative to find alternatives before communication breaks down and a switch becomes impossible.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by bko on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @06:05PM (#42786329)
Do you use it for #2?

I use it for parent stuff and parties. It just does what it supposed to. See pictures of kids (private group). Get birthday invites. Just go to the group. No algorithm or engagement farming. It just works.

And marketplace has been a game changer.

What's better? Simpler to setup and maintain for local businesses or daycares. One daycare used a different app and it was awful. Janky, weird, missing features and the teachers complain about it.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:41AM (#42781307)
Tell that to Jadav Payeng, who planted a forest by himself. He accomplished, on his own, more for the good of the world than most communities on Facebook ever will.

https://interestingengineering.com/science/jadav-payeng-the-...

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by zdragnar on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:28AM (#42781967)
Rural Facebook communities aren't trying to change the world. They're there for light conversation, gossip and organizing get-togethers.

It's important to note that Jadav didn't get other people to change and join his crusade before it happened. He merely went out and did what he wanted. People were inspired by seeing it happen.

People aren't going to be inspired by yet another social network touting federation and other technical mumbo-jumbo, because it doesn't help them do anything they weren't already doing on Facebook.

This whole conversation is very strange to me indeed.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:04PM (#42782504)
> This whole conversation is very strange to me indeed.

Because you’re not engaging with the point?

For starters, the original claim was to “make the world a better place”, not “change” it. Beyond that, the point of my reply was to show that it is indeed possible to make the world better without communicating with anyone else (contrary to the original claim).

Anything else is your own addition.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:32AM (#42782021)
Eh, that's improvement, but the world didn't change because of a small forest.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @11:56AM (#42782353)
You (and your parent comment) said “make the world a better place”, not “change” it. Very few things change the world meaningfully.

And the point stands: what he did was more relevant than most (if not all) Facebook communities will ever accomplish.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:01PM (#42782449)
Splitting hairs.

If you use a platform nobody uses to try and change the world you won't change it just like if you tried to plant trees without using seeds.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:07PM (#42782545)
The point is precisely that you don’t need a platform to do something meaningful.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:37PM (#42782928)
I don't think the author was talking about isolated change like planting some seeds.

Real change requires humans to collaborate and work together.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:46PM (#42783054)
> isolated

The whole thread is about limited and well-defined communities, not the world. What the OP wants is specifically “isolated”.

> like planting some seeds

Spending thirty years planting a 550 hectare forest and restoring wildlife to it is not “planting some seeds”. Please don’t be reductive.

> Real change

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_true_Scotsman

Change is change. You don’t get to define someone’s life work, which was more meaningful and impactful than most of us will ever achieve, not “real” to fit your narrow definition.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:41PM (#42783719)
50K people is a limited community to move to another platform???
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:55PM (#42783893)
Yes, yes it is. By definition. “Limited” means “restricted in size”, not “an arbitrary number a random person thinks is small”. From the moment OP defined “this is for this specific community of this size”, it is limited. It will be abundantly clear when they have moved no one, or every one, or a critical mass, or not enough. Because it’s limited, bounded, constrained.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:02PM (#42783977)
Well in that case so is the total population of earth.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:01PM (#42784560)
We’re not discussing the total population of the Earth. The thing about words is that their meaning may depend on context.

If we were discussing everyone who has lived and will ever live, the current population of the world would be a limited snapshot. Same if we were discussing every planet and civilisation in the fictional world of Start Trek.

But we’re not discussing that. Making up something we’re not talking about to attack what we are is called a straw man argument.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by scarface_74 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:05PM (#42784606)
And for the purposes of the stated goal, for one person or even a company to get 50K people to switch from Facebook or to use another platform especially when all someone else has to do is start a group on Facebook, might as well be “the number of people on earth” difficult.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:14PM (#42784694)
Yes, I agree, I’ve said that several hours ago.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42781581

What you’re arguing against is not the point I was making. My point in this thread is way up there: it replies to someone saying you cannot make the world better without communicating with other humans, by presenting someone who on their own improved the world more than most (if not all) Facebook groups ever will.

When I used the word “limited”, it was clearly in reference to it being an “isolated” specific community and not everyone.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:19PM (#42784157)
Mincing words and splitting hairs again.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by latexr on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:53PM (#42784500)
Words have meanings. Communication between humans, which you’re keenly defending, depends on a shared understanding of them. I haven’t commented on it until now, but in my view you’re splitting hairs by repeatedly creating your own definitions (e.g. defining what is “real” change or not; changing the definition of words you said; saying “improvement” is not “change”; misunderstanding “limited”). So your repeated accusations don’t really land.

I don’t think it’s worth either of our times to continue, though. We’ve strayed too much from the original point.

A good evening (or your equivalent time of day) to you.

Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by jf22 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @04:30PM (#42785411)
Yeah, and mincing words to make a silly argument valid isn't communication, it's arguing for arguments sake.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by gabruoy on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:35PM (#42784318)
He very literally did change the world. There wasn’t a forest there and now there is. In fact the conception of “the world” as an abstract global concept is much less impactful than what people see outside their window and in their city/community.
Re:Ask HN: Organize local communities without Facebook? by diggan on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @10:36AM (#42781243)
Maybe that's why OP is looking for an alternative to use for communication and organization?