News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by gorkish on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:10PM (#41771605)
This is great; for your next trick, can you please figure out how to install MacOS on an iPad so that we can all finally get the dang computer we want Apple to build?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by makeitdouble on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:15PM (#41771652)
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:26PM (#41771760)
> It took two and a half hours for my iPad to crawl through installation.

Jailbroken Apple M1 iPads with iOS16 can use the iOS hypervisor to run VMs without overheating their devices or waiting hours to boot.

Still, we can thank Apple for small mercies like UTM, ashell and iSH.

As a science experiment, Apple could silently launch a "VM store" with $100 VMs, accessible only via hidden URL. How badly do Apple customers want to use the iPad hardware they already purchased? Could Apple customers be extorted into paying for VMs? Will anyone ever ship a competitive tablet running Linux?

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by acchow on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:59PM (#41772420)
Apple definitely does not want bad reviews on their iPads because the VMs they are selling are crashing more often than their other offerings. Any product Apple sells for actual $ would have meet Apple’s standards of support and customer service, or they would be deteriorating their Goodwill.

Except their charging cables. Apple actively trades goodwill for those margins.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by saagarjha on Monday October 07, 2024 @10:08PM (#41773160)
You do realize that Apple sells Macs, right?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by lostlogin on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:48PM (#41779918)
While accurate, this misses the point. The chip is very similar to that in the Mac and it’s frustrating to have Apple prevent it being used more fully.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by saagarjha on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @11:46PM (#41784328)
I agree. But this has nothing to do with Macs crashing more often.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Monday October 07, 2024 @11:58PM (#41773691)
> the VMs they are selling are crashing

VMs would be a subset of existing iOS/macOS. VMs are more uniform targets than bare-metal, less likely to crash.

Think Microsoft CAL (client access license) paper entitlements.

Or papal certificates of indulgence, https://theconversation.com/the-catholic-view-on-indulgences...

Software margins with iPad-as-dongle, investors would be pleased! Broadcom and Qualcomm would be envious.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by tambourine_man on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:27PM (#41771769)
Without JIT, it’s more a prof-of-concept than a useful tool, IMO.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by makeitdouble on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:40AM (#41773892)
With the current iPad limitations, however slow it gets, running any arbitrary code locally can be a big deal.

If you wanted to debug and print out your original papercraft without remoting into another machine, that will probably be good enough.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:15AM (#41774900)
> running any arbitrary code locally can be a big deal

yt-dlp on iPad via iSH is surprising useful.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by eru on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:08AM (#41774851)
> [...], running any arbitrary code locally can be a big deal.

Well, unless you are using JavaScript?

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by striking on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:02PM (#41772040)
Prior research section reads:

> [Zhuowei Zhang] concluded that (GUI) macOS applications cannot run on iOS—but (graphical) iOS apps can run on macOS. Mac Catalyst seems to work, expectedly, only one way.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by worstspotgain on Monday October 07, 2024 @06:46PM (#41771919)
If they called it a Macbook Air with an upside-down bulge and a detachable keyboard, would that be just as well?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:44PM (#41772317)
With touch screen, iOS and macOS?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by SheinhardtWigCo on Monday October 07, 2024 @08:08PM (#41772486)
macOS when the keyboard is attached, and iOS when it is not, with instantaneous switching.

One can dream… but really, this is not all that far-fetched

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:36AM (#41773880)
What would happen to the macOS applications when switching to iOS? iOS applications would be fine in macOS-mode (Mac Catalyst already exists). But, there isn't a good way to make macOS applications usable in iOS-mode.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:48AM (#41773938)
Start with macOS CLI VM. Give it a couple of years and see how customers use it.

Or allow Linux/FreeBSD VMs.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by diffeomorphism on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:20AM (#41774299)
We cureently have that on pixel devices, where you can just run windows if you want

https://www.cnx-software.com/2022/02/14/android-13-virtualiz...

We had that with linuxonDex or maruos or motorola or..

People say they want that, but when they actually do, it completely flops.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:32AM (#41774635)
> People say they want that, but when they actually do, it completely flops.

That feature isn't yet exposed to end-users, although the plumbing is in place. So far only on Pixel devices.

There's potential for phones docking to desktops via USB-c, running both Android and Linux/ChromeOS VMs.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:17AM (#41774914)
Except no one except a few geeks ever cared about Samsung DEX, or Windows Phone/Table continuum.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by sznio on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:04AM (#41775529)
Well, it couldn't run any real programs. ARM caught up now.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:07AM (#41775553)
I thought that was what FOSS was all about having all those people in their Internet coffee shops using Termux under DEX to compile their real programs.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:41PM (#41783346)
Google Android (Linux) App Store 2023 revenue was over 45 billion dollars.

Google is a major contributor to Linux in support of Android and Chromebooks.

Some non-zero portion of those value flows would benefit from mobile intermittent-desktop UX.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:16AM (#41786216)
And that is related to people not buying DEX, because?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by guax on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:55AM (#41784915)
Near native speeds. VMS. Android desktop mode. Etc. it's never a keyboard less computer. It's always a bodge on top of Android. Of course it flops.

I don't think the real thing would be good enough. The compromises can only be worse.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by worstspotgain on Monday October 07, 2024 @07:55PM (#41772391)
Touch screen but no iOS.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by azinman2 on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:13AM (#41773761)
What is it about the iPad you want with macOS? It has one port (which is largely used for power), no built in keyboard, an incompatible input device (touch) by default, and often smaller screens. What’s the appeal?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:22AM (#41773801)
This question has been endlessly asked and answered, https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/22/22396449/apple-ipad-pro-m...

The answer is obvious to Apple iPad Pro + Magic Keyboard customers:

   MOBILE MICROTASKING
No, dear Apple, it will not compete with your precious Macbook revenue, because an iPad is not a laptop. Your customers who are pleading for un-crippled iPads will keep buying desktops and laptops. But it will be life-changing for on-demand portable anytime anywhere access to OSS code and professional apps, for last-minute edits, quick checks during video calls, testing-while-learning and countless other scenarios. iPad enables flexible computing, i.e. unlimited use cases -- and revenue! Still the only mobile device with 4:3 HiDPI screen.

Apple continues to pour billions into science experiments like Vision Pro (iPad-on-Skull) and anemic cloud services, while refusing to improve the workflows of millions of customers who are willing to pay for repackaging of existing technology already sold by Apple. Fortunately, the industry has not been standing still while Apple squandered a decade of feature-frozen tablet supremacy. Google is now shipping VMs on both phones and tablets.

> At a privately held event, Google recently demonstrated a special build of Chromium OS — code-named “ferrochrome” — running in a virtual machine on a Pixel 8. However, Chromium OS wasn’t shown running on the phone’s screen itself. Rather, it was projected to an external display, which is possible because Google recently enabled display output on its Pixel 8 series... Hopefully, Google will offer the ability to run Chrome OS alongside Android in a future device

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:14AM (#41774889)
Ferrochrome was canceled.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:50PM (#41782600)
Could an equivalent demo be constructed using open-source components, e.g. via GrapheneOS?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @06:17AM (#41786219)
I guess if enough people care, then again, what is the business case?

Being a cool technology demo will end the same way.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Friday October 11, 2024 @01:24AM (#41806442)
The same business case for headset displays powered by phones.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:07AM (#41774019)
As much as I would like macOS on iPads, running macOS applications on an iPad without the Magic Keyboard would suck. Windows can do it though, so it's not really an excuse.

But, in Microsoft's case, it's sort of different. They had Windows 10 Mobile for tablets which is the closest thing to iPadOS, I suppose. Windows 10 Mobile couldn't run Win32 applications, similar to how iPadOS can't run macOS applications. Microsoft killed Windows 10 Mobile...

Implementation-wise though, it's a big effort for Apple. They can't just make macOS applications runnable on iOS. Something like reverse Mac Catalyst for iPadOS wouldn't work due to how complicated and different macOS is compared to iPadOS. It would probably have to be a full on emulation of macOS on iPadOS for applications to run.

So, it would seem like starting with macOS then implementing iPadOS on-top would be better than starting with iPadOS and implementing macOS, which is literally what Mac Catalyst is. So now, Apple has to make sure that all iPadOS APIs work with Mac Catalyst (they don't yet) and they have to do something to make the UX work better when switching between touch and M&K.

Bringing it back to Microsoft and Windows now. It's quite similar actually. Think of Windows 10 Mobile = iPadOS, UWP = iPadOS apps, Win32 = macOS apps. Microsoft killed Windows 10 Mobile and replaced it with full-on Windows 10. Windows 10 can run UWP apps.

Similarly, Apple will likely have to kill iPadOS and fully implement compatibility with iPad apps on Mac for macOS to ever be on iPads.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:49AM (#41774166)
> starting with macOS then implementing iPadOS on-top

This would lose the security properties of iOS, which is a big part of the value proposition for iPhones and iPads.

> They can't just make macOS applications runnable on iOS.

Other operating systems can run in _parallel_ with iOS. Hardware support for nested virtualization has shipped on Apple Silicon since M2. Google implemented Android Virtualization Framework. There's no shortage of candidate VM operating systems. Microsoft implemented WSL (Windows Subsystem for Linux) VM. Apple could ship ASF (Apple Subsystem for FreeBSD) VMs.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:13AM (#41774275)
> This would lose the security properties of iOS, which is a big part of the value proposition for iPhones and iPads.

Right. Apple is adding more and more security features from iOS into macOS. But, people are going to complain about that too.

> Other operating systems can run in _parallel_ with iOS

Absolutely, but there is a performance hit and memory management becomes an issue. You still need a host OS as well to unify the UX. Also, there needs to be some way for IPC between the applications of different OSes.

> Microsoft implemented WSL

WSL has networking and memory management issues. WSLg sort of works. Its architecture is wild [1]. Display scaling is terrible though. IPC between Windows and WSL guests is limited.

WSL 2 was released in 2020 and it still has issues. It's not a simple problem to solve.

Microsoft has also gone from WinRT, UWP, WinUI, MAUI, and now WinUI 3 trying to unify application development [2]. Again, it's not a simple problem to solve.

I think the only OS that has actually unified application development across all form factors is Android/Chrome OS. But, people complain about how limited Chrome OS is.

[1] https://github.com/microsoft/wslg?tab=readme-ov-file#wslg-ar...

[2] https://www.irrlicht3d.org/index.php?t=1626

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:16AM (#41774904)
The problem with WinRT, UWP, WinUI, MAUI, and now WinUI 3 is the usual Microsoft mess.

As anyone can imagine by that list, every new acronym requires a rewrite, and most folks that aren't on Microsoft pay list no longer care.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:16AM (#41775282)
Well, with Android/Chrome OS they just recently released Jetpack Compose Material 3 Adaptive which is further iteration by Google to try to unify UI development between form factors [1]. And there's the breaking changes with every major version of Android [2]. Then there are the incompatibilities for Android apps for Chrome OS [3].

You can shit on Microsoft all you want, but those listed APIs still work. People expect Microsoft APIs to exist essentially forever, so every breaking change pretty much has to be a new API.

Having a single simple API for developing across different devices and inputs that automatically provides great UX across the board just isn't possible. It's going to be complex and it's on the developer to cater to each device. An API to cater to everything is literally web APIs.

[1] https://chromeos.dev/en/posts/io-2024#android-on-chromeos

[2] https://developer.android.com/about/versions/13/behavior-cha...

[3] https://developer.android.com/topic/arc/manifest

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:00AM (#41775506)
Tell me you never used those APIs, without telling me.

No they don't work, that is why each iteraction requires a rewrite.

WinRT for Windows 10, isn't the same as WinRT for Windows 8.1, isn't the same as WinRT for Windows 8.

WinUI 3.0 has features that are Windows 11 only, although Project Reunion promised compatibility across Windows 10 and 11, it is still quite far from Win 2.0 in features and tooling, years away in fact.

Likewise the WinRT used by WinUI 3.0 in Win32 mode, isn't the same as WinRT used by WinUI 2.0 in UWP mode. Meaning the set of underlying COM plumbing differs in behaviour and exposed set of interfaces.

And I will leave it here, as Github issues and discussions already have plenty of rant material on the matter from the Windows developer community.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:32AM (#41775773)
I'm not saying that the newer APIs are backwards compatible with the older ones. I'm saying that they're not which is why they are different APIs. WinRT is a bit different since you target a Windows SDK. But, likewise newer SDKs have APIs that are not backwards compatible.

What I am saying is that the older APIs are forwards compatible with newer versions of Windows. On Windows 11, you can still run applications using those old APIs.

On Android and iOS, your old app may break when running on a newer OS version.

Microsoft doesn't have the luxury of changing the behavior of older APIs on newer versions of Windows, so they end up having to make completely new ones.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by pjmlp on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:15AM (#41776064)
Try to run a Windows 8.0 WinRT application on Windows 11 to see how forward compatible it is.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by nolist_policy on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:59AM (#41774465)
ChromeOS solves the memory management very well.

Depending on how you use it, you have up to 3 VMs running in the background with Wayland passtrough: ARCVM (Android), Crostini (Linux dev environment) and Borealis (SteamOS).

All these VMs run Linux and Google uses MGLRU in cooperation with Chromes tab discarder to balance memory.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:16AM (#41774556)
Wow. Never knew about the move to ARCVM. Though the first thing that comes up when I search it is memory and CPU usage issues though :/

Google et al. has put a lot of effort into improving Linux's virtualization capabilities. Goes with being the OS of choice for pretty much all servers I suppose.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by makeitdouble on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @07:17AM (#41776074)
> But, in Microsoft's case, it's sort of different.

Microsoft has a long history of trying to make both work, but I think the reality of it is actually not that far away:

Windows 10/11 is a very poor tablet OS, a ton of stuff will be clunky with touch as it's currently just a very thin layer of adjustments on top of the OS, and expecting to get access to all the potential of the machine without a keyboard and trackpad will be a recipe for disappointment.

So, if the iPad had to rival the Surface Pro, it could probably do it tomorrow by just sticking macos on it with the accessibility options (virtual keyboard, mouse etc) and call it a day.

Where Microsoft is truely different is that they still shipped the Surface Pro and let users deal with it. The UI in tablet mode is almost the same, with just the taskbar a bit bigger. Sometimes you'll absolutely need a mouse, so if you don't have one you pull the virtual mouse, solve your situation and go back to what you were doing. Sometimes the entry field is from an obscure API and doesn't pop the keyboard, so you pop it manually and deal with it. Or you absolutely need a shortcut, so again you pop the keyboard in the middle of nowhere, hit the shortcut, and make the keyboard go away.

This is the clunkiness Microsoft has fully embraced, and it makes their tablets actually "just work" as you're given all the tools to straightly do what you want to do. That's where Apple is backing out, and chose to build a DisneyLand OS instead of a gritty, dirty and clunky, but fully functional city like environment.

I get why people want a more polished and elegant experience, but if the goal is to get things done, it's probably the most realistic way forward.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by walterbell on Thursday October 10, 2024 @12:55AM (#41795645)
Apple could provide an opt-in, obscure Accessibility mode for clunky-functional.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by nicoburns on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @08:15AM (#41776479)
> As much as I would like macOS on iPads, running macOS applications on an iPad without the Magic Keyboard would suck.

The ability to run macOS on an iPad with a keyboard and mouse (and perhaps even a second screen), and run ipad OS when you're away from those things would be pretty great.

The hardware is already capable of this.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kuhsaft on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:06PM (#41779453)
I wish they would at least allow VMs on iPadOS. With the release of macOS 15, you can now use iCloud in the guest macOS VM [1].

[1] https://developer.apple.com/documentation/virtualization/usi...

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by gorkish on Thursday October 10, 2024 @09:33PM (#41805275)
Bingo bango. In truth they just need to allow actual apps to use the virtualization that’s already in the goddamn things. It’s maddening.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kmeisthax on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:54AM (#41773962)
Apple doesn't sell a MacBook with a cellular modem, drawing stylus, or 4:3 screen. Also, iPads sometimes get the newest chips first (e.g. M4)

To be clear, as an iPad Pro owner, I don't think "just put macOS on iPad" is the answer to the iPad's problems, either. But I can appreciate why people complain about it. Apple sold them "a computer", they want "a computer". With full iPad ports of Mac apps, a filesystem that isn't entirely built around share sheets and hope, project exports that don't demand you keep the app foregrounded because Apple can't be arsed to add a "Eat The Whole Battery" multitasking mode, multiple user profiles, third-party developer tools, third-party app distribution, and generally, the ability to innovate on the platform without Apple's prior written consent[0].

The iPad was originally announced as Apple's answer to the netbook: a cheap(ish) touch computer for casual computing tasks and games. In that narrow lane, it succeeded. But in 2015 with the introduction of the iPad Pro, Apple decided that the iPad was going to replace the Macintosh. The Mac was there to be to the iPad what the Apple Lisa was to early Macs: an annoying technical relic to bootstrap software onto the newer, superior platform. Except Apple didn't have the courage to pull the trigger on several features necessary for creative and development workflows on iPadOS until it was too late. e.g. The reason why iPadOS is built so heavily around share sheets is because, for the first six years of the iPad's life, that was the only way to share data between apps[1]. So there's a lot of old apps that do things the annoying way, a lot of roadblocks that get put up arbitrarily, and so on.

[0] More broadly, the creative economy needs to stop talking about consent. Consent is for sex, not creativity.

[1] iOS 9 (?) added support for shared containers, but AFAIK each app that wants to use the container has to opt into it; and all apps have to be published by the same corporate entity or otherwise consent to data sharing in this way. There was no way to just have files owned by the user and nonconsensually modified by other apps.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by prxtl on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @04:52AM (#41775148)
> But in 2015 with the introduction of the iPad Pro, Apple decided that the iPad was going to replace the Macintosh.

Although that is an intriguing (and controversial) possibility, Apple has never explicitly stated that. What they have done, is continued to heavily invest in the Mac lineup. IMO the ‘Pro’ in iPad Pro is meant to target creative professionals, not all the types of professionals (for e.g. programmers).

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by kmeisthax on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @03:33PM (#41780948)
The Mac lineup from 2015 thru 2019 was one of the least compelling set of computers to buy. Fragile keyboards that broke in a year of normal use, high-end laptops with i9s that overheated immediately under any level of use, an annoying and gimmicky touchbar, and so on. If I wanted to absolutely murder a platform, I'd just do what Apple was doing to the Mac in this era, forever.

The iPad division was advertising their product with taglines like "what's a computer" and phrases like "desktop-class" that indicated Apple - or at least, the iPad division at Apple - considered the iPad to be a MacBook replacement, not just a companion. And they still do this, even now when the Mac team is actually putting out good hardware again (ironically, by putting iPad chips in them).

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by memsom on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @07:54AM (#41786883)
Well... the way the Mac lineup was broken in the date range you have given was less to do with wanting to kill the line, more to do with poor management of the designs being used. It was a very egotistical "we can make a better keyboard", "you want a fance second screen", "we decided for you you don't need ports", "our design is style over substance" type of deal. Whether that was Ive or not, after he left it seems like it all got redone.

You second paragraph - you need to understand the audience. For most average people, they don't need a Mac. They need a web browser, a banking app and a few other sundry apps for casual tasks. For the pro artist, they want a canvas. The iPad fits that fine. With a keyboard it is a very capable computer, with a pen it is a very capable canvas. Even for professional workers, the iPad can be enough if all they are doing is creating documents[1]

The MacBook Pro/Air is for anyone who - want to code in general and/or wants to create apps for iOS and macOS, wants to use addition hardware that requires extra power to be used (music production interfaces for example, or other types of compute module), needs to multitask, needs to consume files from different sources (local, usb, network etc)... etc. So, professional people, or "power users". This includes those that simply prefer a traditional computer. This is a fuzzy cross over. It is not precise.

The M series chips are not "ipad" chips. They are just chips. They happen to be used in multiple places, but this is no different to using an Intel chip in a tablet (which for sure happened. I owned a Windows 8 tablet that had the form factor of a Nexus 7 tablet.)

[1] Anecdote - a guy came to my house last week to do a survey for some heating system changes, and all he had was 2 ipads, a printer and his regular tools. All the documentation and quotes he printed on-site, they all came from the iPad Pro he had with a keyboard. The other one was most used to survey, he had a thermal camera to look for where out underfloor heating was laid as we don;t have the original owners installation documents.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by Uehreka on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:06AM (#41774014)
I have an M4 iPad Pro, it beats my M1 Max MacBook Pro on a lot of benchmarks, yet I cannot use it for programming, 3D modeling or VFX. Yes, I know that apps “technically” exist to do those things. No, those apps are not professional grade. I want VS Code, a Terminal, Blender and Adobe After Effects.

Seemingly the only thing stopping those apps from running on the iPad unmodified is the operating system. I want the operating system that runs on the other Mx devices to run on my iPad Pro. I have wanted this for years. I have never been even close to alone in wanting this.

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by miramba on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @01:07AM (#41774022)
Oh, 1000 times this! Literally my research subject in the last weeks, a tablet with a dev OS. Sizewise I love the iPad Mini, but iPadOS is useless. Looking now at a Surface Go: slightly too large. If anyone has another suggestion for a small tablet with Win11 (I know there is none with MacOS), please post it here. Will order from China if needed.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by Joeri on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @02:21AM (#41774303)
What about the GPD Pocket?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by ankurdhama on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:48AM (#41775436)
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by sgerenser on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:14AM (#41775622)
Small tablet? It has a 14” screen.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by creole_wither on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @12:38PM (#41779189)
GPD Pocket 3. It has an 8" screen. It is laptop form factor but the screen can be folded 180 and flat over the keyboard for use as a tablet. Spec page says it can run Windows 11 but comes with Windows 10.

https://gpd.hk/gpdpocket3

Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by miramba on Monday October 14, 2024 @04:17AM (#41835383)
Thank you and Joeri - this is indeed the closest to what I am looking for.
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by jbverschoor on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @05:15AM (#41775273)
The iPad Pro is the fastest machine out there (M4)
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by amelius on Tuesday October 08, 2024 @06:25AM (#41775725)
Can we please get iOS on Linux so we don't have to buy the phone to develop for it?
Re:Virtualizing iOS on Apple Silicon by guax on Wednesday October 09, 2024 @01:58AM (#41784933)
Or add 4g to the MacBook air and 80% of people will stop asking for MacOS iPads.