We had 2 developers, a PM, 20-30 content writers and $5B ARR. Websites were strictly for marketing/leadgen. Even when we switched to building a static site, we still had our content editors write markdown in WordPress because it was easier to do that and pull all of the content from the database on deploy than train them.
The absolute worst part of being a WP Engine customer was being on Linode and the yearly Christmas Eve DDOS.
So they weren't web sites but spam.
What I'm curious about though is if your former workplace still exists or is now AI generating the spam...
Oh wait. You used "corporate sites and portofolios". The OP used the generic "content" though. There's a difference.
Think top 10 keywords space and spanning about 4-5 of them.
It's the largest business in its space and a major national advertiser both digitally and traditionally. You have seen their ads on the street, on TV, on websites and on Youtube.
Even internationally, you have seen their ads on TV. Big hint.
When you're using terms like marketing, leads and content writers, it sounds like a content mill with zero substance. Even if it's "top 10 keywords".
No that’s on the various design agencies that sell “custom websites” and instead they just slap together a 59$ theme and a dozen plug-ins. Most customers don’t know shit about the web and they just trust the agency to do a professional job. And in my 10+ years of experience as a freelancer I’ve seen plenty of agencies taking advantage of clients.
Wordpress used as a CMS where you build everything from scratch using built in functions and the absolute minumum number of plugins (in my experience it was exactly 1, ACF) can generate sites that are solid.
I have projects I built a decade ago that are still online, are still running and haven't been hacked.
The problem is that the overwhelming majority of WP sites aren't built like that. Because "there's a plugin for that". And you end up with these monster sites with dozen of plugins, each importing their own scripts and styles, all injecting their own crap, all bringing in their own issues. And you use those on kitchen-sink style themes that are designed to do everything and end up doing nothing well.
But that's the inevitable result when you lower the barrier to the point where one can just click buttons and install whatever.
These businesses exist and operate the way they do because of customer desires. The customers could hire better agencies but for a number of reasons don't.
Please tell me that these 30 people weren't the full company generating $5B in annually recurring revenue?
Basically, no our marketing team didn't turn the coal into diamonds, but obtaining the coal was our team's primary function and 100% our output. We spent several hundred million annually on advertising (roughly the GDP of Tonga!).
me neither but it pays; when we get called, bad things already happened, so it's always an emergency which means we can ask for 400-500$/hr to fix it. And there are so many bad wp sites that we can retire on that alone. But let me tell you about OpenCart, Drupal, etc which also are all lovely targets and more niche so higher hourlies!
As someone with a formal verification and static typing background, it is the most terrible crap there is, but it is very good business.
May I ask how you find this kind of work? The kinds of orgs with hacked/broken/incompetently-run WP installs don’t tend to be the type of orgs you’d find via professional networking, but by going through the dregs of Craigslist’s gigs pages, no?
For example, I notice that most of the automated "attacks" on my server are WordPress related. Is its defect rate significantly higher than other systems', or is it just that if you're going fishing you should bait for the most common fish? PHP and Apache come up a lot too.
“WordPress takes care of 80-90% of the mechanics of Search Engine Optimization (SEO)”
Agencies really latched onto that!
SEO was the new hotness.
An industry was then built around WordPress.
Clients would hear that it was the best at SEO, and they wanted a CMS they could update themselves.
Agencies could churn out variations of the same WordPress site and plugin stack, and then charge clients for ongoing hosting and maintenance fees to keep it updated.
Then there are all the plugins that get added depending on the whims of the 'developer' at the time.
The WordPress website then languishes when the agency or dev vanishes, WordPress gets hacked, and the client gets charged again.
The WP GUI builder plugins are a whole separate hellscape all to themselves!
So because the majority of users are not savvy, it's become a cesspool. Then you read about it on a tech forum like HN and it is derided as an inferior product rather than allowing improper use by the user/operator.
It's not only the non-tech-savvy, even CS guys become trash when they go too close to WP
Its quality is astonishingly bad. It was clearly developed by someone who didn't even have a basic understanding of relational databases. Unless something has changed, plugins and themes can run arbitrary PHP on the server.
Anything ubiquitous is going to be hated. I agree. But WordPress is bad from a fundamentals perspective.
But I've been writing web software for 30 years and WordPress is among the worst mainstream applications. It's worse than its PHP competitors at the time, and it's worse than Ghost and many of the competitors that came after it.
You can't just dismiss all criticism of the past because it was the past. Some people wrote worse software than others in the past, just as they do today.
And as worse is better predicted, all new ones went insecure, with less features, but nicer looking themes.
I don't particularly love PHP, but you don't need to touch it if you don't try to write any plugins. Yes, some of its practices are pretty wacky, like every plugin has full access to the filesystem and database to do basically anything, and the system expects to be able to update code files in place from web requests, but meh, just give it it's own $5 server and let it do its thing, and definitely be very careful which plugins you use and how you get them.
What you get in return for this is a perfectly fine CMS that anyone with basic computer skills can run. Yeah, static site generators are cool and all that from a tech expert's perspective, but nobody who isn't a tech expert can actually do anything with them, and oh, by the way, the ability to make any changes at all typically involves at the very least SSH access to the host server with full write permissions.
A PHP version is vulnerable. If you upgrade it, some plugin breaks. If you manually upgrade the offending plugin, the pesky developer now wants a subscription. Just a nono. I build on Hugo.
“I need to add and edit multistep forms that send an email to me”
“I need to change one of our social media links”
That can be mostly or entirely self-serve for marketing folks on Wordpress, with all the work happening in their browser. Plus tons of other stuff.
Once we installed a few security plugins, it worked out just fine!
Which means, if we want to kill WordPress, we need to offer a better solution. Not just for WordPress, but a coherent system that also reimplements the top hundred or so plugins.
If anyone wants to join me rewriting it in Laravel so we could add a WSL-like layer for WordPress cancer plugins… I don’t know. I wish someone would have the conversation. I don’t even care whether it’s Rust.
And a solution for which a typical non-tech business can ask around their family/friends/employees and find someone who's experienced enough to come in for a few hours out a few hours a week to to typical CMS admin/editorial stuff. And for which there are heaps of easy to find tutorials and youtube videos which can get someone up to speed enough to keep their own site running, while still spending 95+% of their time making widgets or selling trinkets or whatever their actual business is.
I'm not _that_ much of a fan of WordPress, but WordPress on WPEngine is 100% my initial recommendation for anyone asking about how to run their business website.
(I'd be curious to see a Rust backend API replacement for the WP + top 100 plugins that uses the standard html/frontend, to have the type safety and security Rust is famed for, while being identical in use to WordPress so all the people currently admin-ing WP site wouldn't have to even know it's different. But not curious enough to expend any effort to make it. )
I wrote a WYSIWYG CMS for Laravel called Prodigy that I really enjoy but it hasn’t gotten much market pick up.
There’s definitely some thinking in this area on how to move WP users toward Laravel.
However, Statamic is not a WordPress replacement. We need a system that can be installed, with hundreds of themes and plugins available, without touching code. An open-source Squarespace, basically.
Statamic has a role, but not as a WordPress replacement for most people unfortunately…
Except they don't. A static website would work for 99.9% of all businesses and could be hosted on a potato.
The problem is that marketing wants a website that "Doesn't look embarassing and has 5 nines uptime."
Translation: "Marketing wants a website that looks completely like our competitors(because reasons)! But make it completely different (because reasons)! And make sure it's on AWS (because reasons)!"
Response from IT: "Our website results in zero revenue to the company and is a gigantic security problem and spam magnet. And because marketing is involved it's also a headache of a political football. Here's the WP Engine credentials. Now fuck off."
... they can publish and update content without having to get IT involved - just like they did at their last job where the website was WordPress.
Oh, and IT who thinks their company has a marketing department that adds zero revenue to the bottom line needs to go back to they mom's basement or academia. That's just not how the world works.
For anywhere small enough to not have an IT department, or so large and where the IT department has effectively become obstructionist to other department's jobs, just buy marketing their own WPEngine subscription and let them do their thing.
I think people who work in an "IT Department" sometimes have a too narrow view of the rest of the world. Both ignoring that almost all small and most medium sized businesses do not have an IT department, and also that there are people and departments in their own organisations who's IT needs are real but are not considered a priority by the IT Department.
(Often understandably not the IT departments priority, the people in a bank IT department who're securing financial systems from continuous attacks almost certainly don't consider the HR departments need to set up a quick website for the company bbq or RUOK day to be a prioroty. But someone in HR is getting _super_ frustrated at not being able to do the "simple things" they know they could do if IT didn't keep pushing back.)
The main problem, security aside, is when shit goes south (and it will at some point), IT will be asked to handle something they didn't set up, don't know anything about, and will be looked down upon when they can't get it working quickly.
As long as there is ownership of any problems by whomever set it up, yeah, go nuts, but experience also tells me that's never how it works.
Please reread. I said the website brought zero revenue.
The website for our company never broke 5 digits in total views. I could almost precisely correlate who was looking at our website with who marketing was currently talking to. Scaling was useless. Dynamism was useless. etc.
All resource spent on the website was worse than useless as it took marketing away from doing anything else which would could result in revenue.
A lot of businesses are in the same boat where the website brings in zero revenue. A static website would be more than good enough but somebody in mangement chain has a "Must Keep Up With The Joneses" streak. And then you wind up on WordPress.
This is where the mistake was made. Tens, possibly hundreds, of thousands of small businesses do not have an IT department.
Even the business I work in - almost a dozen employees before a single IT guy.
WordPress and Squarespace, and software like them, are the off-the-shelf solutions for them. You sign up for GoDaddy or another shared hosting provider, what do you get? Right now though, Squarespace is eating WordPress’ lunch, and (if you don’t need plugins) is objectively superior in many ways.
We need a modern replacement for WordPress to fulfill that role which won’t make programmers swear, or let closed-source solutions shut out the open ones.
I'm in a monthly directors meeting of all depts and marketing unveils their wonderful website to much applause and oohs and ahhs. They then say, looking at me, "Yes we should be ready to launch in a couple weeks after IT sets up authentication and integrates it with our CRM and mail blast system."
I was so lost for words I just kind of nodded my head, wide-eyed.
The way they had it set up did not allow us to use the same SSO/auth we used for everything else. So users would need a separate account. Their auth system didn't support any kind of MFA. Their plugins were not compatible with our CRM. External accounts would need to be set up manually. They used a different domain thinking they could just change it later but it got so baked into everything that changing it everywhere would be extremely difficult. Their hosting solution was going to cost us a shit ton of money because none of the graphics were optimized for web. Every image was like a 50MB PNG. It did look nice, but nothing was set up in a way that made it compatible with anything we already had in place.
I told marketing there was no way I could make this work and they'd wasted a year's worth of effort by not pulling me in from the get go to at least help them find some sane compatible solutions. "Well, if we can't use SSO, couldn't we just build a spreadsheet with everyone's logins so you could plug that in?" Jfc no.
The CEO/owner sends me a meeting invite and asks me why I'm refusing to work with marketing on their website. I explain that they had decided not mention any of this to me from the get go and explained the reasons why I couldn't make it work.
I said, "well, technically we could make anything work, but you're going to have to hire a small dev team to integrate this with our CRM. We're going to have to pay a lot more monthly for our CRM because now we need API access (we'd need that either way even if the plugins were compatible) and if you want a team to write some custom integrations for this, you'll need some kind of retainer to make sure they can support it when the plugins change and break everything in unpredictable intervals or the plugins are no longer maintained."
He refused to believe me and basically said "Well I'm not sure why I'm paying you if you can't even get a website to work."
I quiet quit and resigned about a month later. You can imagine the other kind of shenanigans that went on if that was considered acceptable.
* their CRM plugins did not support Salesforce
* even if it did, they didn't realize that was like an extra $1500/month for API connection (something like that), which was also balked at, but just a plain fact
* they already built everything out and changing plugins was not an option
* I have almost no experience with WordPress and 0 time to figure it out alongside the myriad of other projects on my plate
* 0 thought went into authentication and that was also something I couldn't change
* this was not built by a team with WordPress experience, or any technical experience
They said "it's set up like this, make it work". I couldn't, not without dropping everything and hiring someone to do it, and managing a contractor(s) which was also not an option.
I would quit the moment I was spoken to in that way, if not sooner.
It's a new stack, but it's pretty revolutionary foundation, and as we get some good templates and imrpove the UX, I think it should bring a lot of joy to people who currently suffer with wordpress. It's all open source/public domain. Having started my programming career in Wordpress ~17 years ago, I have been able to take my favorite parts from it and get rid of all the annoying parts (like requiring a database, php/javascript hybrid, etc).
Instead of WordPress, what solutions do you use?
Wix, Squarespace, Webflow, Webnode and other wysiwyg ones are even worse imho.
Are there any non-Nodejs or non-React open source CMS that don’t vendor lock you?
Because I feel that WP somehow sucks in details and maintenance, but I can’t find anything comparable without being sucked into development hell. :)
Thanks for suggestions.
The only issue is to have more themes available, at getkirby-themes_com there are 22 only.
More themes that you can choose from -> more Kirby users -> stability -> more users coming from other solutions etc…
So Kirby is really nice to run.
And I understand your point.
What "broken and malware ridden WordPress site" typically means is "customer installed a bunch of random plugins from random sites written by teenagers or bozos who don't know what they're doing". And yes, that can screw things up, but that's not really WordPress's fault IMHO.
Maybe it can do more to protect users from this; I don't know. But obviously the plugin ecosystem is a hugely important part of the WordPress platform and you can't just lock that down technically. Just make sure you only install plugins from authors who aren't teenagers or bozos.
I'll add that personally I don't especially like WordPress for various reasons. But at the same time I don't think this is really a fair criticism.
In my experience, WordPress itself could be called a Cancer to the Web.
The amount of new clients I've picked up who needed help rescuing broken and malware ridden WordPress sites is... well, it's more than I'd like as I really do not enjoy WordPress LOL