News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by hexage1814 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:25PM (#41275633)
Brazil is essentially living under a judicial dictatorship for the last 5 years or so. The media and press have been looking the other way (as well as actively helping in the persecution) because they didn't like the people being persecuted, so they were fine with the whole thing.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by silvestreh on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:51PM (#41275844)
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship. This also applies to Bolsonaro’s government as well. Just because you don’t agree with the ruling party doesn’t make it a dictatorship.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by woooooo on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:56PM (#41275891)
It's true, judges in Brazil are like gods.

I worked for a (large, powerful) company where our Brazilian compliance people were 100% outside of Brazil to reduce the risk of them being thrown in jail because a judge wasn't getting answers fast enough.

Not sure if those judges are elected but it doesn't really matter.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by rgbrenner on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:31PM (#41276223)
You should expand on that more if it's actually unreasonable.. because what you wrote sounds exactly the same as the US. The court can issue legal subpoenas, and if they aren't complied with by the deadline specified, the court has the right to enforce those orders, which can include jail time. That's an important tool for the rule of law and an independent judiciary.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by woooooo on Saturday August 17, 2024 @04:35PM (#41277751)
I'm not sure of the exact details but companies aren't afraid to have their paralegal live in the US.

As a matter of fact. I think it would be highly unusual for any corporate official, let alone a low-level case handler, to be at risk here.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by vouaobrasil on Saturday August 17, 2024 @07:37PM (#41278946)
The difference is that in Brazil, the judges very frequently do not act on good faith and are basically easy to buy.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by guax on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:09AM (#41281383)
You might have been told that but there is no way jail is the first thing a judge will issue. First comes an order, then fines, lots of them. A company will only get anyone arrested if they willingly ignore judicial decisions for a very long time. The only path I see for a company deciding to keep their "compliance" department away from the country would be if they're not planning on complying at all. Judges have a lot of power but they're still bound by process.

Brazil is a conservative leaning country with neoliberal aspirations that looks up to the US (florida specially) like the paradise on earth. Judges are friendly to business and it takes a lot to piss them off if you're part of the circle (rich). These examples from twitter are a niche where the company is caught between the politics of the supreme court and what it sees as threats (some times correctly, sometimes too much and dangerously overbearing).

Supreme court judges are not elected, they are appointed by the president. As a tradition during the years where the current party was in power before Bolsonaro the court itself made a list of candidates that they voted for and the president was asked to pick from the top three (as a request, not binding), Lula and Dilma always picked the top candidate to avoid any showing of interference. President Temer picked the second choice and Bolsonaro picked someone outside the list (twice) and that tradition will likely die down because of it, Lula already picked from outside the list too now.

Another fact people seem to ignore/disregard, the Brazilian STF cannot just issue orders without a request from the prosecution or lower courts. An example where Judges exert the god like power is on lower courts where the prosecution aligns politically with a judge and work together like they did on the Lula trial and ended up overthrown by the supreme court for it. If they do it for someone less popular, they get away with it.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by clarkmoody on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:56PM (#41275886)
> I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship.

Have you read any history?

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:07PM (#41275990)
I did. And rare were the autocrats government which came in power from a non-rigged, open election.

Two exemple which are frequently used as exemple are Italy and Germany in the 1930´s but neither Hitler nor Mussolini came in power through the election, but by strong arming the power in place, and after that (at least for Germany) use the excuse of rigged election to validate their power.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by peterfirefly on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:48PM (#41276383)
Hitler and Allende both gained power legitimately.

They both abused that power afterwards to become dictators.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:01PM (#41276521)
I think you mean legally. And yes, yes, Hitler came to power legally. Doesn’t mean it came to power through some elections, which was my point.

And calling Alende a dictator need some Shutzpah. On this point, I think we would have to stop at the « agree to disagree » level.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by ineedaj0b on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:13PM (#41276639)
Bukele is a large hole in your argument.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @06:13PM (#41278428)
First, I never said than a dictator never came to power through fair and healthy election. Just that it is rare, much rarer than a lot people think.

Second, I would say that the jury is still in debat for Bukele. Yes, it’s re-election is anti-constituai but he seems to still have the support of the population, as the election seemed to be fair and healthy.

But I agree that his legal shenningans to allow for his re-election don’t bode well for the future. Let’s wait and see.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by selimthegrim on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:41PM (#41276851)
*chutzpah
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @06:07PM (#41278389)
Thanks
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by yakireev on Saturday August 17, 2024 @05:29PM (#41278131)
In a typical retelling of Chilean 9/11 there indeed was a guy who abused his power to become a dictator, but that was not Allende.

It seems that the story you have is different from the one I have. Could you tell yours?

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by throwaway918299 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:53PM (#41275867)
You can vote your way into a dictatorship, but you cannot vote your way out.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by bwanab on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:59PM (#41275913)
True, but given the fact that Brazil has in recent years voted the left in, then the right, and now the left again it doesn't strike me that a dictatorship has been established.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by stale2002 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:05PM (#41275969)
Thats why the original poster said " judicial dictatorship" and not "Executive dictatorship".

The judicial branch, not the presidency, is the issue in brazil.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by tankenmate on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:49PM (#41276401)
Can you quote any analysis (even your own if it's peer reviewed) of how there is systemic illegal behaviour by the judicial branch in Brazil?
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by stale2002 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @07:16PM (#41286335)
> of how there is systemic illegal behaviour

I didn't say anything about illegality.

Dictatorships can be perfectly legal. Especially if a court says so.

And, given the fact that this is about the judicial branch taking dictatorial actions, almost by definition anything that they decide or choose to do would be legal (As the judicial branch is the one that decides in the first place if its legal or not!)

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by tankenmate on Thursday August 22, 2024 @04:44AM (#41318083)
But judges can only interpret the law (legally), they can't author the law. If they are taking dictatorial action that implies executive action, which is not within their remit in most countries (even including most non democracies). If a court issues an order it is up the the executive to enforce that order (for example an arrest warrant). So then to your argument, it would have to be more than the judicial branch in order to be dictatorial, it would also require at a minimum non opposition from the executive, or more likely cooperation.

And so, where is the evidence? Even 3 high impact examples would suffice as a starting point.

[EDIT]; typo fix

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by akira2501 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @07:17PM (#41278829)
Either the people are suddenly that fickle, or the results are being manipulated, and Hacker News of all places should understand the problem with modern electronic voting systems that require highly competent IT and MIS people to manage and secure. People who we know do not often work for the government.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by vouaobrasil on Saturday August 17, 2024 @07:38PM (#41278952)
Keep in mind that in practice in Brazil, the elected party does not have the same kind of control that the elected party has in Canada, U.S. or Australia.
[dead]
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by throwaway918299 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:38PM (#41276295)
Donald Trump was not a dictator...? He may have had policies you didn't like but that's a far cry from a dicator.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by yakireev on Saturday August 17, 2024 @05:31PM (#41278148)
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by cryptonector on Saturday August 17, 2024 @08:29PM (#41279189)
That's only because the then dictator didn't want to dictate anymore.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by seydor on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:53PM (#41275861)
> I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship

That's not how it works

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:00PM (#41275924)
for me that’s exactly how it’s work. For a government to be a dictatorship, you need a dictator. And one key element which define a person as a dictator is that his word is law, that’s in the name. doesn’t seem to be the case in Brazil right now. The second key element, which more implied in the modern definition of dictator, is that it stay in position of power against the will of the majority of it’s country inhabitants. Against, doesn’t seem to be the case in Brazil right now.

I would welcome any elements which would invalidate my (quite incomplete, I recon) perception of the situation.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by ToucanLoucan on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:09PM (#41276000)
> for me that’s exactly how it’s work.

For history it isn't. Read up on the fall of Wiemar Germany.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:53PM (#41276433)
I did. And Hitler was never elected in a position of power. He strong armed the weimar republic to be named in chancellor, and only after that he held some referendum to validate his decision.

Also, when he is named chancellor, it’s been a while since the democratic value of weimar were hurting. Paul Von Hindenburg started as soon as 1930 to govern through executive act, ignoring and/or strong arming the Reichstag. Not really what I would call a healthy democratic government.

Also, Hitler was named as chancellor through a plot of the current weimar government to avoid calling new elections, like the laws said they must.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by InTheArena on Saturday August 17, 2024 @08:38PM (#41279232)
The last point is incorrect - as you yourself note, Hinderburg had the power as symbolic head of state to declare who was to form a government. Therefore, although the Nazis won more votes than anyone else in 1932(the Nazis won 232 to the SDP's 133 seats), conservatives and the SPD blocked it.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by dankle on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:58PM (#41275911)
Thats exactly how it works. See russa, turkey, hungary now. Germany in 1930s.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by baq on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:04PM (#41275965)
> I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship.

You're a couple votes from becoming a dictatorship in any democracy, by definition: 1) amend constitution or equivalent to allow the vote, 2) vote in the dictator, 3) there is no step 3.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:21PM (#41276682)
You forgot all the votes you need to win to be able to cast your first vote. It’s not easy part, at least in a more-or-less healthy democracy.

In France, for exemple, you need first to have majority in both chambers (Senate and parliament) to validate the content of the modification. Then you need to have of 3/5 of parliament OR the majority in a referendum for apr roving the modification and putting it in the constitution.

And for almost every healthy constitutional democracy, it the same order of difficulty.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by squidbeak on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:17PM (#41276081)
You speak as if institutions didn't exist.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by marcosdumay on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:47PM (#41276368)
Institutions like the Supreme Court?
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by mensetmanusman on Saturday August 17, 2024 @11:45PM (#41279992)
Like states.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by dazilcher on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:05PM (#41276570)
Brazil's Supreme Court is not "a government elected by the people".
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:56PM (#41275889)
The Brazilian Supreme Court, like most judicial bodies, is not elected by the people.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:02PM (#41275949)
You know that the case for most occidental democracies which doesn’t follow the anglo-saxon model ?
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by skissane on Saturday August 17, 2024 @07:56PM (#41279039)
The "Anglo-Saxon model" does not involve an elected Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom is not directly elected. Nor is the Supreme Court of the United States. Nor the Supreme Court of Canada. Nor the High Court of Australia. Nor the Supreme Court of New Zealand.

The US is unusual in having an elected judiciary at the state and local levels (only in some states, however) – but not at the national/federal level. However, this is not the "Anglo-Saxon model" since none of the other major Anglosphere countries do that.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:14AM (#41281161)
Thanks for the clarification.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by immibis on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:14PM (#41276049)
> I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship.

The people elected Adolf Hitler, who promptly changed the law to prevent himself being unelected.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:22PM (#41276694)
No. That’s factually false.

Hitler was named chancellor of the weimar republic by the government. Not elected as such.

And it was part of a plot from the weimar government to be able to continue to work without casting new elections, as asked by the laws.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by cryptonector on Saturday August 17, 2024 @08:30PM (#41279196)
He was a member of their parliament.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:22AM (#41281195)
Didn’t find any source on that. He ran for presidential mandate in 1932 and lost against Hindeburg. But never won an election for the Reichstag.

But I agree that, if it he had run, he would have win, as the NSDAP was the leading party in Reichstag at the time.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by cryptonector on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:14PM (#41293824)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichstag_(Nazi_Germany)

says

> Finally, there were 855 deputies; Adolf Hitler was No. 433, elected to the Reichstag constituency 24 Upper Bavaria – Swabia.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by robswc on Saturday August 17, 2024 @05:50PM (#41278288)
>I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship

Seems dictators get voted into power more often than not...

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by vouaobrasil on Saturday August 17, 2024 @07:36PM (#41278943)
> Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. I don’t see how a government elected by the people can be considered a dictatorship.

Just to add my two cents, even though it's not a link to documents with proof, but Brazil is a tightly controlled country with very little that is democratic. Yeah there are elections but politics do NOT operate here the same way they do in North America. You've got a lot of corrupt government and even if you elect someone else, they can do very little to make it more democratic.

For the record, I'm Canadian, and I've been living in Brazil for almost two years. When you actually experience it, you feel you are under a system that acts a lot like a dictatorship...or at least something VERY far away from democracy.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by croes on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:42PM (#41275769)
That would mean it happened under Jair Bolsonaro
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by hexage1814 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:55PM (#41275875)
It did. Their excuse (both the court itself as well as the media trying to justify the court's actions) was/is something among the lines of "Oh, Bolsonaro would establish a dictatorship [an hypothetical that never happen, Bolsonaro unlike the Supreme Court, never crossed a red line], so we will instead establish our actual dictatorship to prevent his dictatorship".

And here we are in 2024, Bolsonaro is not president anymore, the elections (organized by people who pretty much opposed Bolsonaro btw...) are over, but the Supreme Court is still arresting people. They are still having trials were the court is the accuser, the "victim", and the judge – all in the same figure. They are still ordering profiles on social media to be blocked. They are still trying to arrest journalists abroad. They are still sentencing protesters, or at best rioters, to 17 years in prison because they broke some stuff – they accuse those random people without any real power, random common people, to have threaten the rule of law.

It's bad.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by thor-rodrigues on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:33PM (#41276238)
It sounds very misleading to frame those responsible for storming into the Congress on January 8th, while attempting to "stop the steal" that the elections supposedly were, as simply "at best rioters, to 17 years in prison because they broke some stuff".

This would only sense if you also believe the rioters of 6th of January that stormed the capital also "just" broke some stuff.

Otherwise, this argument is just not okay.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by marcosdumay on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:51PM (#41276420)
> Bolsonaro unlike the Supreme Court, never crossed a red line

Crossing the line and failing is not the same as "never crossing the line".

Anyway, Bolsonaro was quite supportive of that same structure. Because he wanted the money-flow that came with it (previously illegal flow, but since 2021, well, it's up to be seen). Just like Lula, and Dilma, and Temer...

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by tail_exchange on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:01PM (#41275933)
Not the full story. You are omitting the fact that Bolsonaro made several allegations of voter fraud on social media, and Brazil had their own version of January 6th after he lost (what you called "at best rioters"). These decisions are a response to those events, but your post paints him as a blameless victim.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by greiskul on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:16PM (#41276070)
Are we just going to ignore all the people that were camping in front of military barracks? The manifesto that was going around in the Army, in support of a coup to prevent Lula from taking power? How the US government, thanks to Biden, pressured generals in Brazil to uphold democracy (which means if Trump was president, there might have been a successful coup?).

We have the documents. We have the witnesses. Don't play disingenuous games and try to gaslight us that it is all in our heads. Alexandre de Moraes will go down in Brazilian history as a men who did everything to keep Brazil a democracy.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by matthewrobertso on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:34PM (#41276245)
Then why does Moraes need to censor people on Twitter? If the argument is ironclad, shouldn't it be able to defend itself from speech?
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by mamonster on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:01PM (#41276516)
One look at the photos of Bolsonaro eating the Florida KFC immediately after the elections would tell you immediately that he never had the "it" to be a dictator, especially one that would need to actually do the regime change(and not simply inherit like Maduro).
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by meiraleal on Sunday August 18, 2024 @08:09PM (#41286610)
> And here we are in 2024, Bolsonaro is not president anymore, the elections (organized by people who pretty much opposed Bolsonaro btw...) are over

Crimes committed 2 years ago don't prescribe this fast, Bolsonaro will probably go to jail yet.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by dalmo3 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:47PM (#41275812)
The President is part of the executive branch, not the judicial branch.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Teocali on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:55PM (#41275878)
Quick question : what’s a judicial dictatorship, for you ?
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by meiraleal on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:13PM (#41276032)
Criminals facing the judicial system (and others doing crazy things to avoid it) is what's being considered a judicial dictatorship in Brazil by some. Crazy times.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by taway2024081712 on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:01PM (#41275939)
The seemingly unlimited[1] power of the Judiciary is showing its ugly head in many countries: Brazil, the US, Israel and many others. We take it as God-given word, but it's worth remembering that the theory of the separation of the Judiciary from the other powers came from the head of a single man, and maybe he was mistaken. There's no reason for judicial review, despite the name, be in the hands of the Judiciary and not Congress or other elected body. If laws are unclear, let those with the power to change it to determine its meaning and improve the wording.

[1] Frankly, I believe this is Godel's loophole

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by marcosdumay on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:53PM (#41276438)
The Brazilian Constitution doesn't even assign to the Judiciary unlimited power. All of it is legally subjected to the Congress.

But it doesn't matter, the power is there anyway.

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by epups on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:59PM (#41275917)
This is what the far right in Brazil wants you to believe, but it's not true. It's especially not true in regards to X, as they have repeatedly ignored judicial decisions that are very similar to those by European courts (ie, remove illegal content).
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by vintermann on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:25PM (#41276155)
Well, one of the people calling out this insanity is Glenn Greenwald. How can he be "the far right in Brazil", when his reporting on Lava Jato is one of the main reasons Lula is not in jail any longer?
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Qem on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:56PM (#41276477)
I admire Glenn, he did a great job reporting on Snowden revelations and the Vaza-Jato scandal in Brazil. I believe his stand is principled, but he appears to have the shortcoming of often trying to apply concepts from the US legal and institutional framework to places where it simply doesn't apply, like trying to fit square pegs to round holes. This sent him into a wild goose chase in this case.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by epups on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:14PM (#41276649)
Greenwald is an odd one, I'll give you that. He seems to see this issue from a libertarian perspective. He would also say that Germany banning Nazi speech is censorship, for example. It's worth nothing that his last professional occupation was being a stooge in a far right show.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by ImJamal on Saturday August 17, 2024 @03:18PM (#41277159)
> He would also say that Germany banning Nazi speech is censorship, for example.

Are you suggesting it is not? If you don't think it is censorship then how do you define censorship?

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:32PM (#41276226)
How do you know that they’re similar? As the source article describes, the court has not published the orders they’re asking Twitter to enforce, and they don’t seem to be available at all to the public.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by epups on Saturday August 17, 2024 @02:11PM (#41276617)
A huge chunk of them were made public: https://apnews.com/article/brazil-twitter-elon-musk-x-censor...

To the people disagreeing with my parent statement, could you find one non far right affiliated legal scholar who would say those orders are illegal?

Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by ilikehurdles on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:18PM (#41276088)
What's illegal in Brazil isn't illegal elsewhere. Their requests would impact people far outside their own jurisdiction.
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's ... by Qwertious on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:36PM (#41276262)
...how is that different to EU court rulings? Take your comment, and swap out "Brazil" with the name of any other country, and absolutely nothing changes.