taway2024081712
taway2024081712 on Hacker News
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's content or...
on Saturday August 17, 2024 @01:01PM (#41275939)
The seemingly unlimited[1] power of the Judiciary is showing its ugly head in many countries: Brazil, the US, Israel and many others. We take it as God-given word, but it's worth remembering that the theory of the separation of the Judiciary from the other powers came from the head of a single man, and maybe he was mistaken. There's no reason for judicial review, despite the name, be in the hands of the Judiciary and not Congress or other elected body. If laws are unclear, let those with the power to change it to determine its meaning and improve the wording.
[1] Frankly, I believe this is Godel's loophole
Re:X says it is closing operations in Brazil due to judge's content or...
on Saturday August 17, 2024 @12:53PM (#41275857)
X was being fined for not taking down certain account linked with allegedly criminal (as in anti-democratic) content.
While seemingly noble, some of these accounts were from people not living in Brazil, and supposedly being read by people also not living there. So there's the question of if an American corporation should censor the (one-way?) communication between, say, two US residents at the request of a foreign government.
The court should have issued a more reasonable request of restricting those accounts to be reached by accounts based in Brazil, which should restrict the judge's decision to his jurisdiction.