In a complementary hypothetical scenario where you’re not being saved but rather harmed by an agency’s actions, with the matter being decided in the courts, you can now expect to have well established protections like due process and appeal.
Even the Supreme Court has trouble differentiating its party drugs from its pollutants, with a level of understanding equivalent to a street junkie. Judges have no business making regulatory decisions, they should be left up to actual experts.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2024/06/28/supreme...
Then why is congress be denied the same latitude (via agencies)?
> Then why is congress be denied the same latitude (via agencies)?
Come on, that's obviously false. Even in an alternative world where agency rule-making was totally abolished, and everything has to be enacted directly through legislation, Congress could still defer to experts to draft that legislation.
Also the courts themselves are supposed to be the experts at interpreting legislation. In our system of government, it's their job to have the final say about that.
Let me put it another way: do you think it would be a good idea for judges to be required to defer to prosecutors (also in the executive branch) on the interpretation of criminal law? (e.g. "Prosecutor: Your honor, the defendant is guilty because I say the law says he is. Judge: OK, your call. How long should we lock him up for?")
What are the odds that the experts a biased towards special interests? How many laws do you suppose congress can write in one session? How many laws will now need to be written to match the average number rules developed by all agencies per year over the past 40 years since Chevron? In practice, this will result in gigantic acts that members of congress can't read before voting, amd increase the likelihood of loopholes. Which is intentional, IMO.
Frankly, when the judges and politicians who believe there are too many rules/too much government and decry government dysfunction suggest the answer is more rules or better laws (completely disregarding self-professed dysfunction), I won't take their words at face value, the sudden confidence in government competence and efficiency is likely tactical in pursuit of "dismantling the administrative state" (an actual stated goal).
Did the word choice have any bearing on the ruling? No, it didn't?
So we are clutching at pearls.
Politically appointed bureaucrats typically have none of these skills, are always beholden to people in power, and often are given an agenda to peruse.
Congress outsourcing law making to bureaucrats is unconstitutional and SCOTUS made the right call legally. If it causes problems, Congress is empowered to fix it.
Very simple and very wrong.
Yes, partisan politicians appoint judges with legal principles that they favor but that doesn't make the judges themselves partisan.
Trump's SCOTUS appointees have all decided cases in ways that were distinctly not partisan, based on their legal principles and not any kind of party loyalty.
Partisan people (like yourself, presumably) don't even notice these decisions or try to downplay them. This is hyper partisanship itself and it's toxic to a democracy.
Because laws often have room for interpretation, conservative justices tend to decide cases in ways that the conservative Republican Party agrees with. And liberal justices tend to decide cases in ways that the liberal Democratic Party agrees with.
But both conservative and liberal justices very often decide cases in ways that go against their own personal views. The Supreme Court judges that Trump appointed have done this multiple times.
please spare us, as Clarence Thomas continues to accept tens of millions of dollars in gifts and free airfare from billionaires with business before the court, unabated
I don't get why that would be a "concern", that is their job. The job of the courts is to settle controversial decisions. They're one of 2 institutions we have in the anglosphere democracies that are competent to do that, the other being the parliaments.
There is a lot of good theory - and practice - that the executive branch should be limited by consensus. The overall results are much better for everyone.
> In terms of realpolitik though, Congress is so deadlocked that new proposed legislation is unlikely to ever come
Happy to report that is just pessimism - I'd expect a democracy to very quickly enact laws that everyone agrees with and then sit deadlocked forever on everything else. The situation we face in the world doesn't change very often - it is mostly repeats of things that we've seen in the past.
I'm not sure if this is satire or not. Absent election reform, that's certainly not what you're going to get in the US, in a world with an increasing pace of change.
[0] https://www.appropriations.senate.gov/news/majority/murray-r...
[1]https://www.mediamatters.org/immigration/myths-and-facts-sur...
[2]https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/senate-republicans-blo...
[3]https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/trump-bo...
"As Ukraine runs low on ammunition to fend off Putin’s brutal invasion, it is imperative we finally extend our support. We must also live up to our commitments to our allies around the globe and quickly get more aid to innocent civilians caught in conflict, including in Gaza, where the humanitarian crisis is especially dire. I never believed we should link policy demands to emergency aid for our allies, but Republicans insisted—so Democrats negotiated in good faith over many weeks and now there is a bipartisan deal on border policy legislation. Ukraine’s fate and so much more hangs in the balance—it’s time for Congress to act."
I don't trust that this can be represented as a border bill. The person introducing the bill seems to think it is a Ukraine (and Gaza) bill with compromises included. 80% of the money mentioned in the dot point list is going to non-border things. This tells us more about the Republican stance on foreign interventions than their feelings on borders.
Also, the effort being put into calling this a "bipartisan" bill (in everything I'm reading, it seems) is highly suspect. They can't call a bill bipartisan if one side is voting against it - it clearly isn't bipartisan.
I'm repeating myself here I suppose, but do you have any references for what the Republicans are saying in their own words? Because the links were doing line-out-of-context quotes and I don't have confidence those are representative.
I don't think there is strong evidence here that the Republicans were shooting things down border legislation to avoid giving Biden brownie points. The situation appears to be the the Democrats were trying to send ~$80 billion split among Ukraine/Israel/Taiwan and their negotiations to get that through Congress failed. In that process it doesn't look like the Dems were even trying to deal with the border except as a compromise.
Occam's razor suggests that the bill wasn't going to get the outcome on the ground that the Republicans wanted. Otherwise the story is they negotiated to add something unrelated in only to vote it away, which seems a bit counterproductive even as political theatre (ie, why? it only gives the Dems something to talk about). They don't gain anything by voting down something that they nominally wanted and asked to be included in a totally unrelated bill. If anything the process would suggest they were being disingenuous on being willing to fund Ukraine rather than anything border related.
> Otherwise the story is they negotiated to add something unrelated in only to vote it away, which seems a bit counterproductive even as political theatre (ie, why? it only gives the Dems something to talk about)
This is what happened though.
> This is what happened though.
For the sake of argument, ok. But that isn't consistent with the idea that they torpedoed a recent border bill because they didn't want to give Biden brownie points. The Democrats don't seem to think that this gives their team brownie points - they didn't even want it included in this amendment. The person introducing it literally says that!
So whatever the Republicans are doing it isn't trying to deny Biden brownie points, because that would rely on the Republicans offering brownie points to deny him - which makes no sense (outside wild incompetence, and even then that doesn't fit well with the theory they are doing this just to deny a good look - it fits with the idea they are incompetent and did something silly). It is much more likely that either the negotiations over the Ukraine spending were in good faith but failed (which happens all the time) or the Republicans were bluffing in negotiations and didn't think the border provisions would be included then had to vote the amendment down when their bluff was called (less common, but that would just suggest they value blocking Ukraine spending at a higher priority than the border provisions the Democrats offered). Neither of those explanations (both of which are routine politics) even involve the Dems wanting the border provisions or thinking they are strategically helpful. If either of those things were true they should have introduced an actual border bill in a non-appropriations setting.
[0] I suppose technically it is a pure border bill in the sense that we're talking about Ukraine's/Taiwan's/Israel's/the States' borders but I don't think you meant that.
This seems more like the Motte and Bailey disease in an election cycle. Both parties pass a bill that they both like 75% of, but then they need something to campaign on. So one party says "we're going to repeal the dastardly bill" and cites the parts of it they don't like. The other party says "they say they're going to repeal the vital bill, we have to stop them" and cites the parts of it that everybody likes. Then if the complaining party gets in they keep the parts everybody likes and maybe change some of the other parts.
Never confuse what politicians say they're going to do with what they're actually going to do.
They weakened it considerably, and also spent a lot of time and money that could have been spent on other problems trying to repeal it altogether.
>it seems unlikely that the bill that actually passed was an unmodified publication of the Heritage Foundation.
I feel like it would be rather trivial to determine if the initially-proposed ACA and the HF version were substantially different. You don't have to "seems unlikely" it; go and check.
So.. let's actually fix that rather than using an undemocratic "hack" to work around it. Otherwise anyone who wants to take advantage of this merely needs to use their influence to foster this deadlock, which is probably less expensive and more repudiable, so is much more likely to be the mode.
The question you really have to ask is why would judges be less deferential to businesses and large entities than congress? Aside from lacking the skill they have no power to investigate the issue, which congress does, and can only operate on the arguments put forth in front of them.
This is _explicitly_ a game which is won by money or size, and we seem to know this in any other sphere, but suddenly it's acceptable because occasionally the government _is_ the 800lb gorilla, and occasionally it _is_ incidentally doing what the people would want, when the entity it's challenging is significantly smaller than it. Otherwise the best it seems to be able to do is fine super large entities for an amount equal to less than a day of revenue or month of profits.
The capture is obviously not comprehensive, it's de jure, and fatalist attitudes like yours I suspect as being part of the problem here. It seems to me you're not actually interested in a solution, one which you could easily imagine for yourself just as I can, but you're interested in doing precisely what I worried about above.
There are people who apparently _prefer_ the gridlock instead of being involved with their own government on any level. It truly is amazing to me.
> Until one materializes that "hack" as you call it
Since you speak the language of the bully, then please explain to me the utterly exigent issues that will befall us if we fail to obey basic constitutional law?
> most effective method for government agencies to actually do their jobs.
Government agencies are not entitled to determine what their job is. That is the role of Congress. This is why the "Due Care" clause exists. This is a democracy not a state of administrative convenience.
Do you think that's how government works in the real world?
My professor wanted a new law passed to support entrepreneurship. He went to “DC Days” to meet his Senator. Senator said “bring me a proposal”.
Working with a local entrepreneurship org, he wrote up the law and the Senator brought it to the floor for a vote. It almost passed.
Politicians listen to organized voters, not Hacker News posts.
This is an actual joke.
Meanwhile, Flint's water crisis is past the 10-year mark and still not completely settled, despite massive, national pressure. Organizing isn't even effective at the state level, in many circumstances. The reason being that many of our institutions, and especially our courts, are nigh-hopelessly corrupt. No one went to jail for poisoning an entire city. And the entire thing would have been avoided if experts had had the leeway to tell miserly politicians and craven judges to f*ck off until they'd assessed the effects of the switch to Flint River water.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/10-years-flints-lead-wa...
The reason being that Flint's water crisis was caused by the government not adding corrosion inhibitors to the water when they switched to another water source, which stripped the lining from the lead pipes, causing them to permanently leach lead into the water. They basically ruined the city's entire water grid all at once and caused hundreds of millions in damage because all of the pipes had to be inspected and replaced. Which takes a long time to do.
More to the point, it was the executive branch that did this! You can hardly blame the courts for the actions of the Governor and his underlings.
Fixing these problems in a timely manner would require more fundamental changes to how they're handled, not simply better organization and awareness within the current paradigm.
No, it’s an actual example of a normal citizen getting a vote on the floor of a bill they wrote.
The Flint water crisis is a crisis in name only. Blood lead levels were lower during the crisis than years before it happened.
So color me shocked it’s not “fully resolved”.
“ The study, which appears in the Journal of Pediatrics, found a decrease in Flint childhood blood lead levels, from 2.33 micrograms per deciliter in 2006 to 1.15 micrograms per deciliter in 2016 — a historic low for the city.”
https://www.michiganmedicine.org/health-lab/study-examines-b...
Limited debate is NOT democracy A motion for cloture is NOT democracy An appointed judge deciding policy is NOT democracy
1. Individuals don't revive the regular process. OP offered their opinions and took the time to write them well enough for us to form some of our own. Democracy, in its ideal form, measures a society of perfectly informed minds, each drawing on their own experience. Ours might not live up to that ideal, but calmly describing pros/cons in current policy doesn't seem like a bad move. It's also not mutually exclusive with voting the "right" people in.
2. Appointed judges deciding policy can absolutely be democratic. If we're allowed to be one step removed with a representative democracy, why not 2? It's a nuanced problem, not an ALL-CAPS emergency.
2a. Particular judges seem to currently be behaving badly with little recourse. Maybe we should fix that. Maybe Chevron is a smokescreen enabling that problem. If that's what's happening, we should call a spade a spade. Maybe in that case it's worth fighting the new Chevron decision as a stop-gap measure, but that's very different from arguing that it's a bad decision a priori.
3. We'll see what abuse happens (abuse always happens; most major laws are worth a retrospective to see what the 2nd order effects actually were), but the decision was, at face value, absolutely not about judges deciding policy. It was saying that when ambiguity requiring judging exists, a judge should resolve that ambiguity. That's not a God-given nugget of ethics, but it is stronger than you seem to be giving it credit for.
4. Somewhat unrelated, suppose an ideal world exists where this particular decision is revoked (posit the existence; I'm not currently arguing for the decision one way or the other). If the policy makes our country better in the next 1, 5, or 10 years, is it worth being held back just because we can imagine a hypothetical world with a better congress?
One huge problem though, and one that you allude to, is that we've created a web of legal protections allowing corporations to get away with all kinds of stuff in tandem with the regulatory framework propped up by Chevron. The problem as I see it isn't that companies will get away with dumping toxic chemicals until Congress holds them responsible. The problem is that companies are allowed to grow so large and powerful that only an act of Congress can stop them.
That said, company size and influence has plenty to do with dumping chemicals. Most importantly, they are able to buy regulatory cover for said dumping of chemicals. Dupont pulled this off extremely well, lying about what they knew to be damaging impact on ground water while buying off regulators who effectively looked the other way.
It doesn't matter if dumping PFAS, in this case, is legal for me to do just like it is for a company or the Air Force. I am not engaging in activities that lead to a large amount of PFAS that I need to deal with.
Well obviously not, the Air Force is under the command of the elected head of the executive branch. All you would need is for the President to tell them to do otherwise.
Which kind of implies that the whole thing is a political act to make headlines before the election. Otherwise why is the Air Force challenging the interpretation of their own administration's EPA?
Then we need to deal with that.
Please think about it - if we try to subvert this system of checks and balances that we have, that subversion mechanism absolutely will be exploited by bad actors and/or the next party that gets into power. That's far worse than mere inaction while we try to straighten Congress out.
The only people who want you to subvert the checks and balances are those who have not thought through this for five seconds, and those who want to take advantage of the hole you open.
The coverage is not hyperbolic, it hits on real concerns that the courts will now be involved in every controversial decision. Previously, if your company was involved in something that would fall under the governance of a governmental agency, like dumping some new chemical into a body of water, the EPA could be brought in to make a ruling on the matter.
Now, that ruling might not be in the best interest of that company depending on the level of regulatory capture.
In our current world, that organization will now file a lawsuit to block the ruling of the govt organization and cite the removal of Chevron deference. Then a long, tedious process of court rulings might follow. With the ultimate ruling mentioning "the Clean Water Act does not mentioned chemical XYZ specifically by name". Resulting in the company continuing to release said chemical.
When a new toxic chemical enters the water supply near your home, I hope that your congressman responds promptly. In my experience, they have been quite slow moving on most of my concerns...