News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:32PM (#41195300)
The biggest problem I've seen with Intel is that they are "getting high on their own supply" and the whole tech press enables them with the sole exception of Charlie Demerjian.

They should pick a few random people out of the phone book and pay them handsomely for their advice, this way they might start to "see themselves as other see them". Most of all they need to recognize the phenomenon of "brand destruction" which has manifest in clueless campaigns such as "Ultrabooks", brands that should have been killed off years ago ("Celeron", sorry, low performance brands have a shelf life, there's a reason why Honda is still making the Civic but GM is not making the Chevette) and that they should write it in their bylaws that they are getting out of the GPU business permanently (they've made so many awful products it will take 15 years for people to get the idea that an Intel GPU adds value, instead it's this awful thing you have to turn off so that it won't screw up graphics in your web browser when you're using a Discrete GPU.) People might get their heads around the idea that an Intel CPU is a premium brand if it had a GPU chiplet from a reputable manufacturer like AMD or NVIDIA.

(Oddly when Intel has had a truly premium brand, as in SSDs, they've ignored it. Hardly anybody noticed the great 95% latency performance that of Intel SSDs because hardly anybody realizes that 95% latency is what you feel when your computer feels slow. Intel SSDs were one Intel product that I would seek out by name, at least until they sold their SSD division. Most people who've run a lot of Intel SSDs swear by them.)

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Miraste on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:56PM (#41195542)
A lot of these are symptoms of the root cause: a bad product. Ultrabooks aren't a terrible concept; they're the Wintel version of Macbook Airs. Making a non-Apple Apple device is a fine business strategy, and Samsung has made plenty of money off of it. The problem was that Intel chips continually crippled them, making them hot and slow with no battery life. People don't like Celerons and iGPUs because they all run at the speed of molasses.

Any of these branding decisions would have worked fine, if the products did. But no amount of marketing will fix bad engineering.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by soulbadguy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:13PM (#41195704)
bad product is a symptoms of a even deeper cause... Lack of competition. The decline of intel started long ago. The financial results here are just very very lagging indicator of that. The lack of competition combined with very agressive anti competitive practice allow them to survive on pretty bad product line. In a healthy market, competition would have force intel to improve well before the point we are now
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jakobson14 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:18AM (#41198969)
They are only moving because AMD is finally providing that competition, but it's not fair to say that "if only AMD had gotten their act together sooner, intel would be a better comapny."

Ultimately, intel chose to let intel rot while AMD was out of the picture. (ignoring that intel's backroom deals with Dell and co. are a big part of what pushed AMD out)

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:17AM (#41202074)
AMD and ARM-based solutions too. I can't picture wanting to run Windows on ARM for a few product generations but for server use I'd have no problem w/ Linux on ARM.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by adrian_b on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:00PM (#41196209)
While the Intel laptop CPUs may have been not good enough, that is not where Intel has lost money.

The current financial results have shown decent profits for the consumer CPUs, which could have been greater if Intel had succeeded to produce more Meteor Lake CPUs. Intel could not produce as many Meteor Lake CPUs as the demand because their new Intel 4 manufacturing process has low production yields.

While Intel lost money in their foundry, that was unavoidable due to the high expenses needed for catching up with TSMC.

Where Intel had great losses was in server CPUs. The reason for these losses must have been that Intel had to grant very large discounts to the big buyers of server CPUs, in order to convince them to not buy superior AMD server CPUs.

These losses in server CPUs were easily predictable, because even if Intel has succeeded to reach in time all the publicly announced milestones of their roadmap, their roadmap itself does not hope to reach parity with the AMD server CPUs before H2 2025 (and that assuming that AMD will not introduce Zen 6 during 2025, which would move the target).

It looks like Intel has made a PR mistake. Even if their public roadmap has shown all the time that they will continue to have big losses for at least one more year, that was obvious only for technical people, who could compare the future Intel products with the AMD products, because Intel has not said any word in their roadmap about what the competition will have at the same time. For non-technical people, the Intel press releases sounded more optimistic than they should have been, leading to disappointment caused by financial results that should not have been surprising.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Tuna-Fish on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:39PM (#41197139)
> The current financial results have shown decent profits for the consumer CPUs,

Only after serious financial alchemy. The client group has a decent op margin, but the foundry group has an absolutely terrible one, and the client group sells products that they buy (internally) from the foundry group at arbitrarily set prices. What would the client margins be if the internal price they pay for their products was set so that the foundry breaks even?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by walterbell on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:52AM (#41200034)
Are client margins different for Lunar Lake, where the compute/platform tiles are made by TSMC?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by formerly_proven on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:25AM (#41201146)
iirc the reason for that split in margins is precisely because Intel started pricing their foundry internally as-if they were external sales (i.e. made at competitive prices).
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by einpoklum on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:16PM (#41196388)
> Ultrabooks aren't a terrible concept; they're the Wintel version of Macbook Airs.

I'd say both are a terrible concept. I mean, it sells, but it's still terrible. A laptop being thin is not really such a virtue and people's life would be better with a decent-travel keyboard, better heat dissipation and more ports than with 5-10mm less laptop height.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by katbyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:48PM (#41197582)
I would have agreed with you a couple months ago, but picked up an air for travel so I could leave the 15” MBP at home and I’m really enjoying it and appreciating how thin and light it is. Wouldn’t want it for home or office use but for occasional on the go use? Perfect. And I imagine for many it would suite their needs pretty well
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by blackoil on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:46AM (#41198846)
Thin and Light are two independent variables, you can make a lightweight PC which still has good keyboard, thermals, repairable and ports by making it few mm thick. Its utility on the go comes primarily from weight and not thinness.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Dalewyn on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:12AM (#41199469)
I travel frequently. Thinness is absolutely a significant mobility factor.

I actually hate thinness for the sake of being thin, I want practical amounts of USB-A ports and a god damn headphone jack. But a thinner laptop is easier to stow in my luggage and handle in space-limited environments like a hotel room desk or a seat table in an airliner or lounge.

Likewise, I don't want a chungus portable phone from 1993, but I also want my smartphone to be thick enough to reasonably grasp and have a headphone jack.

This is also putting aside the fact that most people in general clearly prefer thinner and lighter computing over thicker and/or heavier.

There are times and places for a bigly desktop replacement tabletop heavy enough to crush your kneecaps and hot enough to burn your skin, but most people don't need that.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by katbyte on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:19AM (#41209709)
Sure but thin and compact are also good for travel as it can slide into bag pocket easy or even a large purse and not take up much room.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by sharpshadow on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:43AM (#41200896)
The new MacBook Air design is really fantastic.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by einpoklum on Monday August 12, 2024 @05:33AM (#41222707)
Sorry, but both of these are, IMHO, irrelevant. You can't connect them to (almost) anything, and they don't have a decent keyboard to type on. I might as well use an etch-a-sketch or something.

Speaking of being light, though - a Lenovo X220 is pretty light. With today's tech and the amount of money an AirBook goes for you could reduce the weight much further.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Almondsetat on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:27PM (#41196493)
Who are you to say what would make people's lives better?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:41PM (#41196612)
An actual computer user who's probably at least as qualified as whoever made these decisions at Intel.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Almondsetat on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:34PM (#41197093)
I'm an actual computer user and I disagree. Now what?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by fredoliveira on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:11AM (#41199791)
Now, hopefully, we all come to a simple realization: opinions vary.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by askafriend on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:26PM (#41197029)
That's wrong and the market has proven it. The M3 MacBook Air is the best computer for most people - period, not just best ultrabook or best laptop. There are almost no compromises for 99% of people's usage.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by soulbadguy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:46PM (#41197196)
> The M3 MacBook Air is the best computer for most people.

Maybe, that it doesnt imply that it's the best because it's an ultrabook, or that a non-ultrabook version of the macbook air (not the macbook pro...) wouldn't have been better.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wwtrv on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:22AM (#41199521)
To be fair from the perspective of most consumers what downsides does the Air have that are only there because it's an "ultrabook"?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Panzer04 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:43AM (#41199078)
Well, I mean, if you ignore the 8GB RAM base model.. and the pricetag at 2-3x a similarly-performing windows equivalent, and probably +50% on similar screen windows equivalent.

I can make a great computer that meets everyone's use cases for 2x the going price too :).

Unfortunately it is far too easy for a non-savvy person to walk into a store and buy a piece of shit windows laptop for the same price as a macbook, because they don't know what they want or need and the salesmen aren't that interested in making sure you get good value :'(

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wwtrv on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:20AM (#41199514)
> and the pricetag at 2-3x a similarly-performing windows equivalent, and probably +50% on similar screen windows equivalent.

Can you actually list any of these "equivalents"? I'm actually genuinely curious

Just to get this straight you're saying that you can get a Windows laptop that's just as fast, has comparable battery life and build quality as an M3 Air for $400-650 (i.e. 1/3 - 1/2 of the cheapest 16 GB Air)? Really?

> Unfortunately it is far too easy for a non-savvy person

So could you help those of use who are not that savvy by being more specific?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Rinzler89 on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:15AM (#41199820)
>Can you actually list any of these "equivalents"? I'm actually genuinely curious

I paid 780 Euros almost a year ago for a 14" Lenovo with an 8 core AMD Ryzen 7840HS, 32GB LPDDR5X and 1TB NVME, and 2560x1600 IPS display. I can't justify spending double the Euros for a Mac with less RAM and storage. I just can't.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Panzer04 on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:13AM (#41199805)
I don't think you could find a windows laptop with comparable build quality (or display quality, which I consider important if you intend to use a laptop for its intended purpose) for 1/2 the price of the air. I do think you could find a laptop in the same performance ballpark (ie. 75%+ of the single core speed, which seems to be where the newest gen Intel mobile chips sit in comparison). This is a bigger difference than I expected, admittedly, though the gap closes if you care about multicore performance numbers.

Here in AU, a 16GB air with 512GB SSD = 2400AUD. The base model (8/256)) = 1800 AUD.

I would consider an appropriate comparison model to the air to be something like this: https://www.harveynorman.com.au/acer-swift-go-evo-14-inch-co...

For 1/2 the price, you get a laptop with an OLED screen and one of the newest/fastest non-M3 processors you can buy. It also happened to be the cheapest laptop with a new Meteor lake processor I could find, though I'd have to imagine there are laptops with worse specifications in other areas for the cheaper.

You can obviously spend up from there to improve build quality, get more SSD space (probably by swapping out the stock NVMe drive), more RAM (if you're lucky maybe they have SODIMMs, though I'd guess most laptops, especially non-16", might have soldered memory).

In terms of non-savvy vs savvy, mostly it's that a non-savvy laptop buyer, generally speaking, doesn't understand:

- Screen quality/tech. Resolution, TN vs IPS vs OLED, matte vs gloss, maximum brightness

- How different processor generations compare. Especially walking into a store, it's common in my experience for laptops with 5500u (Zen 2 6 core) to be sitting next to a laptop with a new eg. 125H, both at similar prices. The newer processor is the pick (performance wise), but this is completely nonobvious. It's particularly bad at lower specs, where you can have an i3 N300 (8 e cores) next to perhaps a Ryzen 5700u or Intel 13600h...

In theory salespeople should lead them in the right direction, but likely as not they can spend twice as much on a fancy laptop that looks schmick (and probably is) when they could get 90% of the same experience with something like the Acer above. eg: https://www.harveynorman.com.au/hp-envy-x360-14-inch-ultra-7...

This is admittedly a 2in1, and it has a better processor, but it could well be worse in every other way.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by diffeomorphism on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:34AM (#41200240)
From my recent purchase decision:

14 macbook pro, 32gb of ram, 1tb of storage, 120Hz high res sceen: 2900€

HP Elitebook, same specs, same weight, etc.: 1200€

https://www.campuspoint.de/hp-elitebook-845-g11-sondermodell...

Surely, the macbook pro will be better in some ways but at that price difference "better" is just not good enough.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by lynguist on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:31AM (#41208344)
A Macbook Air M3 is significantly faster than this HP Elitebook in for example compilation tasks.

I don’t know about all of you but in my day to day work I compile code very often, and I used personally a work issued M2 Air and a work issued HP Elitebook Raptor Lake. The M2 Air was leaps faster, leaps.

Some older and more traditional colleague who had a Alder Lake workstation laptop was surprised how much faster the M2 was to his machine.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by diffeomorphism on Sunday August 11, 2024 @06:20AM (#41215186)
The M3? No, the opposite. It is pretty much a wash with the M3 Pro and for 3x the price this is not at all "significant".
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by eertami on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:17AM (#41199843)
The market? I don't know a single person personally or professionally with a MacBook Air. I haven't seen one in person in like 7 years.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by piva00 on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:44AM (#41200001)
Anecdotes don't really cut it though. I see MacBook Airs all the time, even had a MBA M1 that I handed down to my partner when I got a MBP M3, she uses it both personally and professionally. Two other friends have MBAs, a third just bought one yesterday.

At cafés in Stockholm I'd say 50% of the laptops I see people working with are a version of the MBA. At local universities it's an even higher percentage.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wtallis on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:53PM (#41196736)
Heat dissipation and lots of ports are why I have a desktop. I don't want that from my MacBook Air. A fan isn't necessary or desirable for a machine that is primarily used for web browsing, watching movies, and light gaming.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by saulpw on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:15PM (#41196933)
You know what I want for my desktop, is a battery, so my computer doesn't reboot when I lose power for 5 seconds. Yes I know about UPSes, but they're $100+ and unwieldy. I just need 30 seconds grace period to save my work!

This is the main reason why I probably won't get a desktop again.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by chmod775 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @09:43PM (#41198119)
Amortized cost of a desktop is like 1/3rd that of a laptop of comparable performance. You're willing to pay thousands more because you don't want to pay for an UPS? This doesn't check out.

The space argument makes more sense and from that I assume you're in a space constrained apartment.

At the end of day I'm more curious what causes those intermittent power outages. Are you regularly tripping breakers?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by saulpw on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:28AM (#41199008)
It happens twice a year, it goes out neighborhood-wide during a storm or an animal chewed through something.

Anyway I don't know where you get that "amortized cost" number. They seem a lot closer in price than that to me.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Panzer04 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:39AM (#41199063)
Depends on the class of performance you want. I think at the low end laptops are surprisingly cost-competitive with desktops, but if you want high-end laptops either don't exist or are hilariously expensive.

Also depends on the type of laptop. A desktop-replacement laptop with extremely basic frame and screen (ie. cheap and shit) can have excellent specs at a competitive price, whereas an XPS or mac with a great screen, aluminium frame etc will be very expensive relative to the specification.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by chmod775 on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:57AM (#41200058)
This. Additionally desktop parts last longer and can be upgraded individually. They also have good resale value, offsetting the cost of upgrades (especially true for GPUs).
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by skydhash on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:41AM (#41201277)
True even for the mini form factor (the 1L desktop that uses laptop component). As you do not have to stay close to it, you have a great experience out of the box. I could use a chromebook for what I still use the laptop for (browsing and ssh from the sofa)
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by immibis on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:23AM (#41201134)
Silly and dangerous idea: open up a power supply, study it thoroughly, then connect a 300 volt battery bank in parallel with the DC link capacitors.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by sdenton4 on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:12AM (#41201514)
The UPS is a battery...
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by the_af on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:28PM (#41197772)
For some of us, a laptop is essentially an easily movable desktop. It's not portable as in "I want to travel with it", it's portable as in "I can easily take it anywhere within my house/office".

Those kind of "movable desktops" benefit from performance, additional ports, etc, and instead have little use for thinness or less weight.

I simply cannot see myself ever owning a bulky, noisy desktop ever again.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wtallis on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:00PM (#41198200)
The desktop replacement segment of the laptop market exists, but does not undermine the validity of more portable machines or make a fanless laptop a terrible idea. The viability of desktop replacement notebooks as desktop replacements is in large part due to the efficiency gains driven by the demand for the other kind of laptop—the ones that are thin and light. A 5lb+ slab of a notebook is still a pretty constrained form factor compared to the thermals and acoustics of a mini tower desktop.

I can understand you characterizing desktops as bulky, but calling them noisy in comparison to desktop replacement laptops is ridiculously wrong. Small fans with restricted airflow are what makes computers noisy, and they're much easier to avoid with a desktop form factor. Your laptop cannot sustain desktop performance without getting loud, and if it doesn't get loud under sustained load it's because your laptop is choosing to instead get slow.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by skydhash on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:51AM (#41201351)
> it's portable as in "I can easily take it anywhere within my house/office"

As I grow older, that is becoming less and less true. Unless it’s for quick tasks, I prefer my office chair, my big monitor and my comfortable keyboard. Laptop are still great, for ad-hoc computing and traveling, and I’d prefer a less power-hungry device for these.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by einpoklum on Monday August 12, 2024 @05:28AM (#41222685)
My argument was actually focused on "I want to travel with it". But - I travel with it to places where I need to connect to to things: A monitor in a hotel room; a USB device of a friend or host; a physical network in an institution or company or a home I'm visiting. That's what the ports are for.

As for the keyboard - I absolutely need a decent keyboard to type, traveling or no.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Groxx on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:41AM (#41198822)
I've recently started using a fanless laptop as my primary day to day device, and 100% agreed I'm never going back.

I'll give up a LOT of performance for silent and long battery life, because I find waiting a second occasionally much less annoying than a fan blasting randomly, or my legs baking. SSDs have largely resolved the perceived UX latency issues that used to occur, CPUs and GPUs now are far more powerful than needed for everything but specialized stuff (compiling, encoding, stuff that intentionally maxes out the machine. Regular applications do not do this, on purpose, but they do regularly bog down on I/O).

Though the screen on this thing is awful.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by soulbadguy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:46PM (#41197200)
There is nothing wrong about the concept of ultrabook. Just terrible implementation.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by bee_rider on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:18AM (#41199499)
The implementation is left up to the OEMs but they seem to have done pretty well. Thin and lights are in a pretty good spot overall.

Have people forgotten how bad laptops were in like 2010? Great big chunks of plastic that somehow still feel cheap and weightless, keyboard flex, mushy keys. They were really quite bad.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by paganel on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:23PM (#41196467)
I don't really care that much about brands nor laptops for that matter, but my M1 Air is really, really nice given the money I've paid for it. Why should I burden myself with carrying a big laptop thing when I can instead carry a Macbook Air that is much lighter and which does very good job?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wwtrv on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:11AM (#41199462)
> people's life would be better with a decent-travel keyboard

Most people don't generally seem to agree with that, though (not explicitly, they just generally don't prioritize things like that)

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jakobson14 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:14AM (#41198957)
ultimately it was a focus on marketing that led them to kill engineering

(if itanium and the many failures and lucky breaks that led up to it hadn't already convinced you that intel might never have had good engineering)

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:16AM (#41202063)
Intel tried to get away from x86 over and over again with radically overengineered architectures that didn't work (as well as mainstream architectures) and failed:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_iAPX_432

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_i860

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Itanium

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Panzer04 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:36AM (#41199048)
I don't think I agree at all with your assertions about ultrabooks and blaming intel CPUs.

To be honest, all x86 processors are reasonably efficient if you pick the right power points to run them at. My experience with my laptops is that windows will arbitrarily use 2-3x idle power draw while on battery for no apparent reason. There is no reason for a CPU to be running higher than idle the vast majority of the time in a laptop, for tasks that you would be using a laptop for on battery.

I think most laptops are just poorly designed and Windows isn't reliable about using minimal power. MFGs make big laptops with 60whr batteries (instead of 100wh), they put bloatware on them that consume excess power at idle, MS Windows doesn't reliably ensure low power consumption on battery (seriously, I have to hibernate/shut down my laptop when I stop using it, otherwise it will consume its entire battery in 8hrs during sleep mode, somehow), and so on. Most problems with Windows laptops aren't Intel's fault, IMO.

I agree that Intel really should clarify, at least, the difference between their "Celeron" class (e-core only) and "Core" class processors (with P cores), since there's such a massive difference in performance capability between them.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by WalterBright on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:03AM (#41199160)
> There is no reason for a CPU to be running higher than idle the vast majority of the time in a laptop, for tasks that you would be using a laptop for on battery.

True. I once got suspicious and opened the process list window. I had installed a server so I could stream to my Roku device, and I wasn't streaming, yet the server was sucking up quite a bit of compute time, all the time.

I uninstalled it.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wwtrv on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:09AM (#41199453)
> will arbitrarily use 2-3x idle power draw while on battery for no apparent reason

You might be thinking about Linux? IIRC OS X wasn't particularly impressive about that back in the x86 days and high-end Macs had horrible battery life.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Panzer04 on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:22AM (#41199522)
No, this is Windows. It absolutely can use minimal power, but my experience closely monitoring my laptops consumption is it will regularly spike from 5-6w to 15-20w for extended periods, which obviously obliterates battery life. I've been unable to figure out why.

My particular specimen came with a 97wh battery (XPS), so it would be able to linger on for ~10+hrs if it could maintain its idle power consumption with brief spikes to do work, but in reality it's basically always less than that in my experience (and worse, its inconsistent as hell about it).

The other issue is sleep states, which as another commenter mentions leads to laptops using all of their battery in your backpack so it's dead by the time you actually try to use it :'(

It's made worse by comparison to modern phones, which deliver reliable, consistent power consumption throughout the day - so a laptop that regularly lasts a fraction of the time and doesn't know how to sleep just looks awful by comparison.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by kemotep on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:29AM (#41201181)
I don’t think I have ever had a Windows laptop last 10 hours without a consistent effort to keep it in low power modes, keeping screen brightness as low as I can, and actively keeping the number of running processes and background programs as low as I can.

Sure 10-15 years ago, we were lucky to get 3-4 hours of battery life so getting 8-9 is great but they advertise these things as having upwards of 20 hours.

Linux not coming close to that is “acceptable” because they aren’t advertising it constantly as the reason you need to buy the latest laptop or get onto Windows 11. Apple is more honest in this regard and it really is the vertical integration that allows them to control the entire system.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Dalewyn on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:00AM (#41199412)
>Most problems with Windows laptops aren't Intel's fault, IMO.

Intel works very thoroughly with Microsoft, and it is absolutely on Intel for bringing forth the most inexcusable failure mode: Laptops "sleeping" with the CPU still on and proceeding to cook themselves in your backpack because they thought they were still on mains power.

Why is this on Intel? Because they removed a C-state that actually slept properly in favor of a C-state that theoretically saved more power but in practice almost never works with how people actually use laptops.

AMD might also share the blame here. I don't know, because I don't care to know further with how stupid everything is.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Panzer04 on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:25AM (#41199538)
Agree on the sleep state stuff. idk who's fault it really is, but at least on the software front I mostly blame microsoft, because it's really their duty to deliver consistent, reliable power consumption on battery power.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Jochim on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:07AM (#41200100)
Everyone involved does a pretty poor job imo.

The processors/chipsets seem to do what they're they're supposed to. However, it's far too easy for other parties to create a scenario that prevents the system from reaching deeper c-states.

Motherboards manufacturers produce boards that can't go below C3, despite showing up to C10 in the bios. The actual level of support won't ever be mentioned.

PCI devices, e.g. wifi cards, can prevent the system from reaching deeper C states entirely.

Putting devices into a PCI slot connected to the CPU lanes rather than the PCH can also prevent the system reaching the desired states. The CPU slot will frequently be the only choice.

Operating system defaults often prevent the system from reaching deeper c-states. Linux has been worse for this than Microsoft in my experience.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by josephg on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:16AM (#41200713)
> My experience with my laptops is that windows will arbitrarily use 2-3x idle power draw while on battery for no apparent reason.

Preinstalled bloatware is a massive problem for the average consumer. My partner is constantly surprised how well windows runs on the computers we have in our house - she’s so used to windows computers running all sorts of crap all the time. Our media box is just bare windows, but with all the obnoxious stuff disabled. (Like start menu news items, game bar, telemetry and all that).

Most work computers running windows come with antivirus and rootkits like crowdstrike. And personal computers are usually even worse. I bought a brand new HP machine a few years ago which idled at about 15% cpu usage, even on battery. It got hot and ran itself flat in no time, just sitting there. Turns out it was running some bloatware hp audio noise cancellation plugin or something all the time, even when the microphone wasn’t in use.

Modern computers are crazy fast. But there’s not much power left over if you install clown car of crap on them.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by bayindirh on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:32AM (#41200824)
The day I lost all faith in Windows was the day when one of their top guys said that dual-core CPUs will be great because they will be able to offload antivirus software to a core while users use the remaining core for using their computers.

No words on increasing security and reducing the attack surface of Windows. Just tuck that antivirus there, keeping the status quo while ripping users of the benefits of increased processing power.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by 0xcafecafe on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:49AM (#41200930)
Anecdata here but I bought a thinkpad T14 in 2022. My colleague bought the same at the same time. We both have identical machines except for me opting for an intel processor and him picking an AMD. My laptop has heating issues and terrible battery life. His lasts an entire day and no heating issues. Forums research shows others in the same timeframe are facing the same issue as me so it is entirely Intel related.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by sapiogram on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:11PM (#41205011)
I'd still be more inclined to blame a software issue. Do you have the exact same software installed on both?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by 0xcafecafe on Monday August 12, 2024 @08:56AM (#41223877)
Yes. I have bare minimum s/w on the windows 11 that came with it.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by mmis1000 on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:24AM (#41201140)
> My experience with my laptops is that windows will arbitrarily use 2-3x idle power draw while on battery for no apparent reason

same with my experience. My computer have a hardware issue recently, so I am on steamdeck. When I am on windows, the whole system stays on 50%+ load even I only have browser and discord opened. Playing games on it is so laggy that can't even hit 50 fps stably. But the same setup somehow works completely 60fps stable on steamos even it is literally the same hardware.

Windows is really optimized so badly for low power hardwares.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by wwtrv on Friday August 09, 2024 @04:40PM (#41205241)
And battery life with most laptops (even the Framework) is pretty horrible on Linux compared to Windows without excessive tweaking (and even then).
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Friday August 09, 2024 @11:17AM (#41202692)
I've bought i7 machines whenever I bought a new machine with my own money (so have my employers) but I've had various i3 and i5 desktops come into my possession and always been disappointed by limitations baked in. For instance I was hoping to install Steam & Proton on an i3 machine for entry level gaming but found it wouldn't talk to a 1030 card I had laying around.

On paper it looks like Intel machines from 2010-2020 have sufficient I/O bandwidth but when you look at the artificial restrictions Intel puts on i3 and i5 machines (unless you get some special motherboard with PCIe switches) it's best to assume that you won't be able to "get there from here" and that many seemingly reasonable configurations of on-board peripherals and add-on peripherals "just won't work."

It reminds me of the hassle it was to get expansion cards to work in the day of the "PC compatibles" that used the ISA and other early busses: back then you had to mess with jumper cables and which card went in what slot to resolve IRQ conflicts. It was well documented, PC builders all knew it, and I was always able to get it to work.

In the PCIe age though I have often been running into undocumented or poorly documented limits, PC builders who are totally ignorant of this (they always buy i7 and/or high end motherboards I guess.), etc.

Related to that in my mind is the equally obscure situation with USB 3 which is the laptops I've had have all had undocumented limits on how many USB devices you can plug in. In the USB 1 era it was documented that you could plug in 127 devices into a USB tree, the USB 3 doc doesn't guarantee anything! You would think you could plug your laptop into one or two USB 3 hubs with a lot of ports but my experience is that I'd start having trouble when I had 4-5 devices plugged in, then I plug in a mouse and either the sound card or a mass storage device gets unmounted.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by paulmd on Saturday August 10, 2024 @12:19AM (#41207294)
> For instance I was hoping to install Steam & Proton on an i3 machine for entry level gaming but found it wouldn't talk to a 1030 card I had laying around.

this is absolutely a skill issue, there is no limitations about plugging anything into an i3 and in fact i3s are popular industrial processors and SOHO servers since they support ecc during the skylake era.

the rest of your comment all springs from the apparent issues you had installing a pcie card and doesn’t really say anything once that point is dismissed.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by albertopv on Saturday August 10, 2024 @01:53AM (#41207619)
Windows sleep mode is power hungry since the introduction of Modern Standby that allow for network connections even during sleep mode.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Sparkyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:12PM (#41195696)
Intel has always been an echo chamber of fiscal earnings and cutting corners to appease investors. For the longest time they stagnated on Mac hardware improvements because it would cost money, they would not have lost Mac as a business customer if they continued to innovate.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:23PM (#41195807)
Also they should have had a policy of "not one transistor for the national labs" and "not one transistor for hyperscalers", particularly because anything they do to appease hyperscalers just saves them money that they'll spend on their custom silicon transition.

There's something prestigious about HPC but the story of how commercial data processing went parallel in the oughts shows how out of touch the HPC community is.

In the meantime Intel has botched the deployment of SIMD, slowplaying to the point where maybe 7 or 8 years from now some mainstream software might support AVX512, maybe. Somebody should be tarred and feathered for introducing the idea that features should be fused off for all but the highest paying customers. If the customer is not paying for the fused off functionality, the shareholders are. It sounds really ruthless and avaricious and might impress some business analysts as a form of vice signalling but it's pure waste.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Sparkyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:40PM (#41195993)
Right it is wasteful. The reason some businesses are so successful is that they look at the common denominators rather than trying to perpetuate worth. Fewer variants and don't wall off features. AMD did this for the longest period getting back on it feet, but I am seeing a failure of them continuing down this path. They need to stop making variants and focus on 3 or 4 sets of consumer processors.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:55PM (#41196152)
Yep, “too many SKUs” killed off the consumer HDD a few years faster than it had to die. If these companies had focus groups that reached out to ordinary people they’d realize it sounds absolutely incredible to most people that you need one hard drive for a 3-5 bay NAS, another for a 6-9 bay NAS, another if you are recording from video cameras.

Even if there was a real benefit from optimizing firmware and saving a few cents with cheap washers for drives in a low vibration environment there is a much more certain cost in that you have to qualify the firmware, risk introducing errors, etc. I can imagine that Best Buy might have been able to stock one model of high capacity HDD but no way were they going to stock more colors of WD drive than there are on the rainbow flag. That lack of product sense locked manufacturers out of the retail market.

(Makes me think of the cringe monthly hard drive roundup in Anandtech where an enterprise drive produced in huge numbers in a single SKU would usually be $80-100 cheaper than prosumer drives that, according to the spec sheet, consumed about 0.5W less and were about 3db quieter… And I have plenty of those enterprise drives still spinning after all these years, the only time I think about the noise is when the machine boots and the drives emit a throaty chirp that makes me think of a Ferrari spooling up.)

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by mrandish on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:48PM (#41196684)
> " Somebody should be tarred and feathered for introducing the idea that features should be fused off for all but the highest paying customers. If the customer is not paying for the fused off functionality, the shareholders are."

This is very well put.

While I've always understood the economic motivation for margin optimization and the technical reality that CPU wafers aren't very granular, fundamentally, it's a long-term losing idea to intentionally fab gates that don't add end-user value. While it may work in the shorter-term, when it becomes the plan of record (as opposed to fixing a one-gen design or product mix error) it signals a shift to prioritizing value extraction over value creation.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Sparkyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:35PM (#41197515)
Current investor strategy is immediate gains no long term investment because that is deemed risky. Because they want to buy in and bail when they've doubled their investment.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by oivey on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:29PM (#41197047)
Even more simply, their goal stopped being making the best product at the best price. Features that were fused off could have made their products better for no extra manufacturing cost. Your business is broken when you view your products as being too featureful as a cost.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by paulmd on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:38PM (#41206726)
that’s silly. Everyone in this industry fuses off features, AMD included.

Ryzen Pro APUs have disabled ecc support for example. Consumer RX 7000 gpus have crippled DisplayPort feature support/bandwidth. Consumer Hawaii had gimped FP64 to segment the pro cards.

At a certain point these practices are just so broad and banal that it’s unremarkable.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by lynguist on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:41AM (#41208379)
Incidentally that is exactly the reason why ECC memory isn’t standard. Intel reserved it for only the highest paying customers.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jzb on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:38PM (#41195970)
"they would not have lost Mac as a business customer if they continued to innovate"

I'm not entirely sure this is true. I mean, I guess it depends on whether one expected Intel to be able to make not just a decent chip for PCs/laptops, but also one for phones & tablets. Once Apple started dabbling in its own chips for the iPhone and iPad, it seemed inevitable that they'd expand that to their macOS systems too. Apple has been a rough customer to please for chip designers/manufacturers, I'm not sure any company could've satisfied them with a general-purpose chip.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by hbn on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:22PM (#41196450)
If they played their cards right as the top dog ~20 years ago, they could have perhaps ended up with the relationship with Apple that TSMC does today.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by talldayo on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:29PM (#41196515)
1. Intel didn't have big fabs 20 years ago, so they didn't have anything to offer Apple that would resemble TSMC's partnership.

2. There's no money in designing licensed CPU cores as a middleman for a company that drives margins so low they're associated with suicide nets and forced labor.

3. If TSMC is lost due to Chinese aggression (which is a non-zero chance), Apple is left fabless and has to choose between importing Samsung silicon at-cost or partnering with Intel.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:43PM (#41196637)
Might take them a few years to update their software to run on the Samsung stack.

What are they going to do without all the auxiliary processors they build in?

Or do they have a team which has their software working on other people's silicon in case their supply chain get blown up?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by talldayo on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:32PM (#41197082)
Also, importantly, how hard will the US government be taxing imports and propping-up Intel? I think that an anti-Apple and pro-Apple administration would both want them to stop shipping jobs offshore. There's a tariff knob that can be adjusted until only Intel (or GlobalFoundries, lmao) are feasible choices, and if the US wants their Intel investment recouped then they may well push for that kind of deal.

Personally, I find the "samurai's honor" shit where one company avoids another to be childish and stupid. If you make Apple's board choose between ending their grudge-match or blowing up their margins, I don't think they'll care much either. Or maybe I'm wrong, and the 2027 iPhone is manufactured with 24nm wafers intended for the Toyota Prius.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by qwytw on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:35AM (#41199596)
> Intel didn't have big fabs 20 years ago,

They had leading edge ARM chips though. If Apple used XScale (i.e. the default choice had Intel not decided to get rid of it due to "reasons") for the iPhone that would have significantly reduced the likelihood of them developing competitive chips themselves.

Also 20 years? Samsung was still making Apple's chips back in 2014.

> 2. There's no money in designing licensed CPU cores as a middleman for a company that drives margins so low they're associated with suicide nets and forced labor.

Is Apple significantly or at all worse than their competitors in this regard? In any case only reason Apple is designing their own chips is because there weren't any decent options for their use cases available on the market (and Intel only has itself to blame for that...)

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by AtlasBarfed on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:43PM (#41196635)
Companies that are built on engineering eventually become subsumed by soul-sucking profit sucking bonus sucking middle management types that just plop themselves in their big huge hierarchy and destroy the company long-term with inertia and apathy.

See also. Boeing Medtronic GE AT&t

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by impossiblefork on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:56PM (#41195544)
But don't they need to get into the GPU business?

Surely GPUs or similarly very parallel machines for things like ML training are very needed and will remain very needed. Seeing as firms such as Groq have done fine, surely Intel can do something of that sort without much difficulty?

Since their GPU business has been unsuccessful perhaps they can go for whatever makes sense, as there's nothing of this sort that they can release that will compete with their own products.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by pradn on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:00PM (#41195591)
The AI boom is, in theory, a godsend for Intel and AMD. You can focus on creating good tensor computation hardware, without having to worry about getting gamers on board. No need for "Game ready drivers" or compatibility with complex legacy graphics APIs.

Of course, there's the elephant the room for general purpose tensor machines, which is CUDA - famously closely guarded Nvidia. But with the new wave of "above-CUDA" APIs like TensorFlow, PyTorch, and Keras, there's an opportunity to skip the CUDA layer altogether.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Sparkyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:17PM (#41195736)
AI doesn't exist with the right amount of collected data, we're going to hit a wall very soon where we just get bad AI data constantly because we are throwing data to the wall and hoping it sticks. Businesses should not be investing in AI right yet maybe 2-3 more years.

The businesses that should are the startups and businesses who are helping define the model, like ChatGPT and Microsoft, but the adoption is still too early. If I was McDonald's or Wendy's and I wanted to use AI to help promote sales to customers I would need to be able to grab demographic data which may not be appropriate PII data.

All of the lawsuits happening right now for data collected without permission of the data provider is going to all change the landscape.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by nullc on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:44PM (#41196052)
I think there is still a good business to be made taking the AI stuff we have right now and making it highly performant.

Stable diffusion models are awesome and super useful. I don't necessarily mean the simplistic text->image stuff (though it's clearly useful)-- but denoising, in painting, animation from stills, 3d from stills.... style changes, etc.

LLMs are at least somewhat useful.

We can radically improve image and video compression with performant enough AI.

Plenty of other applications of AI right now are already useful or would be useful if inference were made more efficient or more local (thus private). No more data needed.

You don't need some grand vision of an AI future to get a total addressable market for high performance AI that is in the same ballpark as high performance GPUs for non-AI usage.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Sparkyte on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:51PM (#41196109)
But for every business the chase seems to fail in finding worth. I can already tell you from where I am working we are struggling because eventually data is too old to be good or too incomplete. We need at least 3-4 years of collecting and storing the information to make full use of AI.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:18PM (#41195754)
In practice it's the other way around.

In practice AMD and Intel GPUs should be suitable for machine learning but the software story isn't good. I know I can buy a NVIDIA card and know it's a good investment because everything worth with CUDA and be training models in less than a day. If I went with some other brand I'd expect to put 6 man*months into figuring out the software story, and that's a lot more than the price difference in the cards.

I've been wondering about the soundness of Intel's software strategy in that OneAPI ("One" is a bad smell in marketing speak, the only premium product in my mind that has "One" in the name is "Purina ONE" pet food, the XBOX ONE is an astonishing own goal of a name because you'd never get your mom to understand that an XBOX ONE is better than an XBOX or XBOX 360) is based on OpenCL and the one thing I know about OpenCL is that I don't know anyone who likes coding for it. The idea that you could code for FPGA and GPU out of the same API also seems delusional because FPGA is (mostly) about latency and GPU is about throughput. That is, FPGA can do certain small operations insanely fast and avoid the overhead of 16-bit math when 13-bit math will do, GPU is all about doing large operations in bulk.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by bryanlarsen on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:39PM (#41195975)
> If I went with some other brand I'd expect to put 6 man*months into figuring out the software story, and that's a lot more than the price difference in the cards.

Several companies are spending >$10B annually on AI compute. There are a lot more than 6 man-months of savings in it for them...

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:59PM (#41196197)
One firm saving $2B saves $2B, open source software that opens up the market for everyone is priceless.

A company like OpenAI that is mostly concerned about pace might see going with the #2 GPU vendor is risky, even if it has the possibility to save money.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by ColonelPhantom on Friday August 09, 2024 @06:51AM (#41200584)
OneAPI is an implementation of SYCL. Apart from being standardized by Khronos, SYCL and OpenCL don't have that much in common, except that they are often interoperable due to many SYCL implementations running on top of OpenCL. Intel specifically has two backends, one for OpenCL and one for the lower-level Level Zero API.

Saying OneAPI/SYCL is bad "because OpenCL" is the same as saying OpenCL is good "because CUDA" (since the NVIDIA implementation of OpenCL is called CUDA and uses the larger CUDA stack).

As for the FPGA/GPU code sharing, iirc FPGA vendors including Altera/Intel and Xilinx/AMD support OpenCL as well. The idea doesn't sound that crazy to me: GPU code also often uses small data types (fp16, tf32, int4), and both work with data parallelism. GPUs operate in parallel with SIMD vectors, but a compute accelerator FPGA achieves a similar thing by essentially pipelining the program. Effective pipelining requires parallelism too, since a serial FPGA program only has one stage active, similar to how a serial GPU program only has one ALU per compute unit active. As such both are mostly suitable for massively parallel programs.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by BuyMyBitcoins on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:41PM (#41204308)
>"One" is a bad smell in marketing speak.

Thank goodness other people recognize this too. Whenever I see “One” in branding I sense a corporation bereft of creativity and afraid of risk. Alternatively, it might also indicate that were too many executives involved and no single person had the authority to make a decision, so they picked the most bland and uninspiring option they could all agree on.

It’s so lame and milquetoast. However, there is one exception I will make, the radio station 101.1 “The One”. Here it feels appropriate and even a little endearing.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by ein0p on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:42PM (#41196020)
The whole situation with Intel and AI is also baffling to me. They have an excellent product in this space - Gaudi2. Faster than A100 and very attractively priced. I’ve tried it, it works fine. Gaudi3 is also about to come out, and it’s twice as fast as Gaudi2. Yet nobody is buying. I get why you wouldn’t want this for training - it requires some minor code modifications and your Triton kernels are worthless. But for generative inference this is just what the doctor ordered.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by soulbadguy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:48PM (#41197211)
> generative inference this is just what the doctor ordered.

Naive question, wouldn't you need a descent tool chain for inference as well ?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by ein0p on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:09PM (#41197368)
Assuming you mean “decent” toolchain, it’s actually pretty decent. Could it use some polish? Yes. But any decent ML engineer would be able to get a high performance server (or a batch job) running in a relatively short time. Or in almost no time at all if using a lot of the FOSS models. You just basically create a model in PyTorch and then hand it over to Gaudi stuff which patches it with optimized, Gaudi specific ops and converts things into an inference graph.

“Closeness to CUDA” is less important for inference because all the experimentation is already done by then, and if need be you could just implement the model using Gaudi ops to begin with, in a span of a few days including tuning and debugging.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by alecco on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:02AM (#41201001)
Gaudi was made by an Israeli company Intel acquired in 2019 (not an internal project). Gaudi 3 has PCIe 4.0 (vs. H100 PCIe 5.0, so 2x the bandwidth). It's strange for Intel, of all vendors, to lag behind in PCIe. And Nvidia has SXM for larger models (5x bandwidth).

"N5, PCIe 4.0, and HBM2e. This chip was probably delayed two years." -wmf

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by ein0p on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:09PM (#41203152)
PCIe doesn't matter - these accelerators talk to one another, and Gaudi is outstanding in this regard. HBM2e also doesn't matter if you run decent sized batches (which you should, for throughput). In fact, HBM2e, being far less supply constrained, might even be an advantage.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by alecco on Sunday August 11, 2024 @09:31AM (#41216018)
Besides that it does matter (e.g. loading/saving LLMs), it speaks how Gaudi is not even using Intel's latest technology. They are clearly not in the main production pipeline. So Gaudi is not going to save Intel.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by ein0p on Sunday August 11, 2024 @02:23PM (#41218281)
But you don’t “load” models during inference. They are already on-device.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by mlsu on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:03PM (#41196233)
The AI boom that lead to Nvidia's market position is still, 3 years on, almost entirely speculative. The only products that are currently driving value (i.e., that are providing consumer surplus, for which businesses and individuals are actually opening their checkbooks for) are paid chat-bots.

Nvidia ate the whole pie because they were in the right place at the right time with shovels to sell. Getting into it now, in house, would be a huge bet that the pot of gold will be there when they get to the end of the rainbow -- and they have a long way to go.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Dalewyn on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:25PM (#41196474)
Intel actually has it even worse because they completely failed to bring ARC to market in time. The product came out (very) late, underdelivered, and permanently damaged the brand reputation. Yes, the drivers and thus the cards have gotten better, but who's talking about them now? Noone.

They say the opposite of love is indifference, and basically everything Intel has sold outside of CPUs and NICs have suffered market indifference. Actually, maybe even the NICs given everyone seems to prefer Realtek NICs over Intel NICs these days.

Nvidia and AMD have it way better because if the market doesn't love them, you bet the market will hate on them instead of be indifferent.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by speed_spread on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:14PM (#41206452)
Realtek WiFi NICs are dogshit. Intel AX210 shine where the others are slow and unreliable.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by dash2 on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:39AM (#41200262)
It's off topic, but congratulations on the triple mixed metaphor. Not sure whether you use the shovel to dig up the pot of gold to buy the pie, or sell the shovels to bash through the pie crust and get to the rainbow....
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jakobson14 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:22AM (#41198992)
No there isn't. Let's take pytorch as an example.

CUDA is an API. OpenCL is an API. Pytorch is not.

Pytorch is very firmly GLUED to CUDA. It will probably NEVER support anything else beyond token inference on mobile devices. The only reason Pytorch supports AMD at all is because of AMD's "I can't beleive it's not CUDA" HIP translation layer.

OpenCL is a real cross-platform API and with 3.0 it's finally "good" and coincidentally, intel is....half-heartedly interested in it, except they're shooting themselves in the foot by trying to also cover useless CPUs for inference/training and spreading themselves too thin (OneAPI). Because all intel can think about are CPUs. Everything must drive sales of CPUs.

At this rate just about the only think that might save us from CUDA is rusticl. If a real, full-fat, high-quality openCL 3.0 driver sudently popped into existence on every GPU platform under the sun, maybe pytorch et al could finally be convinced to give a shit about an API other than CUDA.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by bee_rider on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:36AM (#41199599)
Intel getting into the GPU business is good, for sure and I hope they don’t give up on it.

It is a tiny thing, but Intel really seems to charge a premium for PCIe lanes. Maybe if they sell a lot of dGPUs they’ll be less stingy with the sockets to plug them in to…

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by immibis on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:14PM (#41195707)
I have an Arc A770 and it seems to work fine so far... though I've only had it for a month. There are some tolerable teething problems: I can't set the fan curve from Linux so I had to duct tape some extra fans, and it's incompatible with BIOS boot (requires UEFI) which should be considered acceptable in 2024. For presumably the same reason, there's no graphics output in early Linux boot until the GPU driver is loaded.

The IGPU in my previous machine's i7-6700K (Skylake) was also just fine. Intel Graphics Media Accelerator, yeah that really sucked, but that was like 15 years ago?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Jochim on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:24AM (#41200189)
The main issue with ARC seems to be driver support in specific games, DX11 being particularly problematic.

Intel basically have to catch up on the ~10-20 years of kludges that AMD, Nvidia, and game devs had already implemented when the games were released.

They've been making strong improvements to their drivers though.

Their iGPU is great for home media servers. Low power draw, QuickSync can handle multiple 4k transcodes, and one less part to buy.

iGPUs still aren't a great choice for gaming on desktops, even the latest AMD APUs perform poorly in comparison to the cheaper dGPUs.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by immibis on Thursday August 15, 2024 @12:24PM (#41257754)
My Skylake iGPU ran everything on my PC just fine for me. That ranges from Minecraft to (apparently the most graphically intensive game I own) The Talos Principle. Sure, not always at the ultra high settings, but that's not something I care about.

Once I upgraded recently to a Threadripper I threw in an old GTX 760 because Threadrippers don't have iGPUs. The 760 also did fine. Now I finally have a bleeding-edge-ish Sparkle Arc A770, but that's only because I wanted to run a shader coding event and didn't want to force other people to care about the server having a behind-the-curve GPU.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by is_true on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:53PM (#41195508)
Does the new owner provides the same performance?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by christkv on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:53PM (#41195512)
The CEO had only been in charge since 2021 bringing an engineer back to the helm. How long does it take to bring a big ship like Intel around and undo decades of internal rot? It will be interesting to see who is let go in the coming months.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by code_biologist on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:16PM (#41195724)
Though prior to Gelsinger, Youtuber and chip leaker / rumor monger "Moore's Law is Dead" mentioned that Jim Keller's stint at Intel was so short (April 2018 - June 2020) because of internal cultural toxicity. In particular, things like leaders of major groups in Intel trying to get employees of other groups fired, so as to make their own relative progress look better. Take with a pound of salt of course, but MLiD's sources have been pretty decent.

You only resolve that kind of badness by firing a bunch of SVPs and VPs and Gelsinger hasn't done that, for many possible reasons.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jiggawatts on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:36PM (#41197516)
I knew Intel was a dying company when Jim Keller quit in disgust. The man is pure productivity, a relentless optimiser that just wants to build great things. Intel broke him and he ran away screaming.

PS: Microsoft demoting Jeffrey Snover (inventor of PowerShell) is in the same category of a business decaying from the top down. He quit too, and is now working for Google.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Rinzler89 on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:14AM (#41200132)
>Youtuber and chip leaker / rumor monger "Moore's Law is Dead"

He might be right but that youtuber has a poor track record. He's just constantly pushing out rumours for the sake of content farming. Some of the rumours are right, some are wrong as hell.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by akira2501 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:57PM (#41195553)
> How long does it take to bring a big ship like Intel around and undo decades of internal rot?

If it takes that long, then this is your actual problem, and not how many engineers are in the loop at the board level.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by soulbadguy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:15PM (#41195715)
>If it takes that long, then this is your actual problem

Most IC design life cycle are 5+ years. Expecting to turn over in less is part of the problem intel is having currently.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by macintux on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:16PM (#41195730)
I'm skeptical. Big company, design & manufacturing cycles on the order of years because chips are that sophisticated these days, I don't know what you'd expect to see within 3 years of a new CEO.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by barkingcat on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:42PM (#41196018)
to be honest, they should have done a layoff 3 years ago, as soon as Pat Gelsinger came onboard, and fired 2 entire layers of management.

No engineers or support people, but just pure middle managers - fire 2 or 3 layers. if they did that 3 years ago, they would be in a better position now.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:56PM (#41198648)
Gelsinger would be shooting blind and in order to cut enough to force compliance he would ultimately be sabotaged as the entire workforce unites against him unless he had the ability to bring in a few thousand loyal soldiers to manage every unit. He’s got the much harder job of ferreting out deep corruption and incompetence that perniciously hides in corners protected by knowing whose buried what bodies. Rough job that he cannot possibly accomplish. Instead he’s probably trying to root out these toxic messes and quarantine them in safe environments where they can be productive enough to realize ROI but disempowered and segregated while he works on fixing the broken systems and teams that got Intel to this point. Maybe this layoff was in his back pocket waiting for the right time to cut the shit loose with cover or maybe he failed to realize that should have been his first order of business and this was a desperate move to stop the hemorrhaging and Intels books are going to be even worse two years out when the consequences of firing qualified staff begins to manifest.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by samstave on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:59PM (#41196194)
Disclaimer: I used to work at Intel:

Specifically, I was the second person on the planet to game on a Celeron Proc. How? Me and my best friend ran the Intel Developer Relations Group Gaming Test Lab in the later half of the 90s.

Our job was to specifically test all PC games that were being developed against the Intel Celeron procs and the amd alts... with a focus on Subjective Gaming Performance of the Celeron as an "Optimized" feature leader whereby developers were given handsome marketing monies to optimize the games against latest SIMD instructions to allow for the games to be more performant on the Celeron.

THe goal: Show the world that a $1,000 fully capable gaming PC was possible, in their budget, and desirable.

---

The Issue at the time was the graphic bottlenecks -- all the pieces had yet to come to fore: AGP, Unreal, OpenGL, ~~NERDS~~ NURBS!, Games, Graphix Chips (VooDoo, 3DFX, blah blah)

Celeron should have died long ago - but certainly when the first, actual GPUs came along and did the heavy lifting.

I have a lot of thoughts about Intels mess (Transmetta really fucked Intel up in the way an abusive step-relative would) and caused them to lose focus...

Then, just the ridiculous amount of marketing over engineering....

(if anyone worked at intel in the DRG circles in SC5 - and has access to emails of that day - search my name and the thread I started asking why we cant just physically stack CPUs on top of eachother... (this was prior to the Voxel timeline) and was laughed at. it wasnt until several years after that I went on a hike with a labs head and found out about the 64-core text CPUs that were only coming out)

---

I was just having shower-thoughts about intels future as effectively computing grout -- a mechanism to get data from real-world INTO NVIDIA GPUs and then displayed again real-world. And thats it. Thats the only thing Intel may be doing in the future - is grout to display the data components solely computed, as NVIDIA CEO stated himself "All compute will be done on NVIDIA chips" -- delivery of the data through intel's grout (minimally) then again delivered to an NVIDIA desktop GPU...

Intel is like the maintenance staff of a home. NVIDIA is the architect, interior designer, party planner and end user.

(Intel was my first ever stock package: $70 with a $125 option price. 10K shares. I left before ever vesting... it was the late 90s and I had to chase the dream intc: https://i.imgur.com/U9PWURv.png )

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by gdiamos on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:02AM (#41198906)
Even then, why is Intel better grout than AMD today?
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by samstave on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:12AM (#41198946)
Good point to ask -- I meant any "CPU Only" technology company.

Personally what Intel should have shifted to was owning and building all the Fabs.

Sure they have them and are building them etc... but they missed the timing a bit.

I dont follow them close enough any longer - but they really should have gone all in on being the US TSMC... rather than the bit of catchup they are in...

They arent going anywhere (the birth of Intel from Fairchild was in Missle circuits - and the US War Leviathan will always have intel circuits in the big-ticket items. Forever.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by spookie on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:49PM (#41196699)
Having a third competitor in the GPU is great, for both Intel and the consumer. If one starts blaming newcomers for their shortcomings then we are failing to see the bigger picture.

When you talk about web browsers failing to display content because of the iGPUs I fail to even have heard of such a case. Maybe the performance is bad but that's it. Either way, that's more of a failure of the OS and not Intel. Windows is particularly biased to not use your dGPU on a laptop, but I blame the kernel for making badly calculated assumptions based on nothing but !={game, 3D modelling tool} then iGPU, and not the hardware.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by gorgoiler on Friday August 09, 2024 @12:30AM (#41198777)
Your second quote has always resonated very strongly with me, both as a concept and also from the original-ish verse:

  Oh would some power
    the gift He gives us
  To see ourselves
    as others see us
  It would from many
    a blunder free us
  And foolish notion
  What airs in dress
    and gait would leave us
  And even in CPU fabrication!
— adapted from “To a Louse”, R. Burns
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by larodi on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:26AM (#41199257)
from https://genius.com/Top-cat-a-friend-in-need-panik-and-m-rode...

""" A Friend In Need Is A Friend Indeed

But a friend with weed is better

So if you want to get high

Bring your own supply

Or we will know you as a joker smoker """

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by roydivision on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:22AM (#41200176)
Intel should never be directing its branding at the end user in the first place. Joe Public doesn't give a rats ass what is powering his device. Ask anyone off the street if they know who AMD are and what they produce. Concentrate on making good product and the device manufacturers will come to you.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Rinzler89 on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:37AM (#41200255)
>Ask anyone off the street if they know who AMD are and what they produce.

That's why Intel, AMD and Nvidia are super obnoxious with plastering laptop keyboards with their stickers. They want the consumers to know what's inside.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by greybox on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:40AM (#41200265)
I'm not so sure nobody cares. Because of the apple's M1-3 machines battery life, people already associate ARM chips with power efficiency.

People will always want their laptop/tablet/phone batteries to last longer, and if makers of those devices know that consumers associate ARM with power efficiency, they will want to take advantage of that.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by roydivision on Friday August 09, 2024 @06:08AM (#41200390)
They know that the latest Apple laptop is the fastest, but they don't know an ARM from a leg, and neither should they need to.
Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jakobson14 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @11:28PM (#41262897)
apple: "Out latest laptop has <magic maguffin>!"

consumer, at the store: "why doesn't this thing have <magic maguffin>!? bring me something that has <magic maguffin>!!!"

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by jakobson14 on Thursday August 15, 2024 @11:26PM (#41262884)
Intel has spent the last 25 years training consumers to look for the "intel inside" sticker. It's the only thing that's kept intel afloat while they butcher their engineering tallent.

People shouldn't care, but they do.

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by thaumasiotes on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:49AM (#41200302)
> instead it's this awful thing you have to turn off so that it won't screw up graphics in your web browser when you're using a Discrete GPU.

You can disable integrated graphics chips?

Re:Intel's Immiseration – The Chip Letter by Gettingolderev on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:29AM (#41200797)
They were leader for over 10-15 years. They wiped the floor with Nehalem left and right.

The tooling of intel is still better than AMD.

The celerons and other types of CPUs are in plenty of notebooks people have who buy laptops below 1k.

The SSD topic happened, and went away i guess it was a margen topic. Low margin, ultra mass product lots of other companies happily building them.

I think its critical for intel to have knowledge about GPUs for a stable longterm strategy. It was critical 10 years ago when they tried and failed hard with larrabee but they need to do that or buy AMD/Nvidia. With AI and modern workload you can't just have CPUs anymore and with CUDA and ML that was clear a long time ago.

The market itself is also totally bonkers. When AMD surpassed intel, intel still sold like cake and still does. The fab capacity in the world is limited. If you can't get an Nvidia GPU for 200-300 because they complelty ignore this price range, than you have only AMD and intel left.

Intel took the market of low end gpus already through their iGPUs.

Intel knows how to build GPUs and other things than CPUs. It would be a total waste for them to stop.

Intel should have bought nvidia or done something else but the Intel CEO is an idiot. He stated publicly that Nvidias position is just luck. That is such a weird idiotic take its bonkers that someone who would say something like this is the CEO of intel.

The amount of R&D Nvidia did and still does left and right is crazy. He totally ignores how much Nvidia was doing the right things at the right time.

Not sure were intel is heading but with their fab knowledge and capacity, their cashflow and core tech, they should be able to swing back. I was hoping that would happen already, unclear to me why they struggle so so hard