News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by scandox on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:42AM (#41189679)
It's clear from many of these discussions that there is an unbridgeable discursive gap between the "why on earth would you ever want to die" and the "life would become an intolerable nightmare" groups. Realistically if we do find ways to extend life then people will take advantage of them and all kinds of weird consequences will follow, and the two groups will argue about just how long life should be while trying not to die. Cosmically speaking all that will happen is that human development will slow down: after all if it requires a generation of human scientists to die so that new ideas can be accepted then [1]...

My personal preference is pro-death. I enjoy life but it's important to my enjoyment that there is a terminus. The fact that it's not under my control also makes me feel calmer - it's out of my hands.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_principle

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by dmm on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:28AM (#41190313)
> human development will slow down: after all if it requires a generation of human scientists to die so that new ideas can be accepted then

A worse problem is that whatever generation is in control when immortality is achieved will rule the world forever. Falling fertility makes this even more likely.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:22AM (#41191853)
> Falling fertility makes this even more likely.

Falling fertility makes us extinct very soon. The idea that the youngest generation, raised by many generations to be dismissive or even outright hostile to fertility will, by some miracle, be the ones who say "no, I will have 2.1 children" is silly. And because it's falling fertility and not just "stable but below replacement fertility", demographic collapse comes quickly. and extinction within 200 years.

If you're worried about immortality, then the good news is we don't even have enough time to figure it out.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by axus on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:58AM (#41192234)
The homo genus has survived huge variations over the last 200k years. The likely global warming scenarios are very bad but extinction would need a major screwup with AI and/or genetic engineering.

Evolutionary processes will prevent total extinction, even if "the next generation is raised" one way, new trends will emerge.

A population of few thousand is enough for humanity to come back. Even if population dropped 50% every 30 years, it's still 500 years to get down that low. And we haven't even started trending downward yet.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by zer0tonin on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:38AM (#41192016)
A century ago, Earth had 4 times less humans. We can handle quite a few decades of low fertility.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:44PM (#41194234)
China deliberately lowered its fertility to a below replacement level. A few decades later, they decided they wanted to raise it back up higher.

They couldn't. They're not exactly wishy-washy, they happen to be one of the most authoritarian regimes on this planet, even if they understand the benefits of a velvet glove. If they couldn't raise it, why would you think anyone else can?

And we're already at sub-replacement. The same people who make the next generation of people (as small as it is), are the ones who also raise that generation and instill their values in them. What does having one child teach that child about their parents' values? It teaches them that, at most, they should have just one. Or maybe even that they should have none at all. Not only is this a self-reinforcing problem, it accelerates. You don't have a few decades to solve this.

Nor will "evolution" fix it as the other guy said. While some still have large families, it's not just the parents' own values that are instilled, but that of our society collectively. The many who have few or no children have far greater influence on the children of those families, than those families have on everyone else.

Population is counter-intuitive, and none of you understand it.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by idiotsecant on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:35PM (#41194758)
You're making all these assumptions about how the population grows and shrinks on a tiny subset of human history. People are not going to disappear as a species from social trends like having fewer children. Society will change to accommodate the new status quo and reach an equilibrium, like it has for the entire history of the species. Whatever wipes out humanity, it won't be that.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by ab5tract on Saturday August 10, 2024 @06:49PM (#41212807)
It’s worth noting that the they only put population control measures in place because their prior policy of encouraging massive population growth backfired horribly due to the strain it wrought on society’s carrying capacity.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by pyuser583 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:49PM (#41198424)
The problem isn’t the absolute number of humans. The real issue is the dependency ratio.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by mensetmanusman on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:36AM (#41201691)
Dependency rationalizes itself with acceleration of death rates.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by pyuser583 on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:54PM (#41205669)
I don’t know what “rationalizes” means, but more deaths don’t necessarily lower the dependency ratio.

For example, a war would kill lots of young healthy soldiers, leaving even fewer people in to care for the old, young, and infirm.

I’m guessing Ukrainian and Russian dependency ratios are getting worse and worse.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by kiba on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:54AM (#41192194)
This is based on present trend and the current historical circumstance, not an inevitability of our development.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by whythre on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:49AM (#41192829)
The good news is those more likely to reproduce are automatically selected by evolution… since they are the only ones having children in any significant numbers.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by hooverd on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:29AM (#41191938)
You can blame older generations for sucking up all the housing and holding on until they die.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:33AM (#41191986)
I could blame them, but about 3 months ago I saw a headline here on Hacker News telling us that the government of Canada plans on having a population of 100 million within the next few decades (currently at 30ish million). The 70 million difference isn't old people. Quite clearly, looks like government policy.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by itishappy on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:07PM (#41204072)
The Century Initiative is not government policy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Century_Initiative

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by jimbokun on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:59PM (#41194986)
In the US can place much of the blame on local governments in progressive cities who refuse to allow more housing to be built.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by hooverd on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:06PM (#41195630)
Local governments who are voted in by civic minded home owners.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by rurp on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:02PM (#41196231)
Things don't happen in a vacuum and trying to extrapolate current trends 100+ years into the future is a fool's errand. A couple decades ago everyone was worried about the opposite problem. Neither of us has any idea what the new worry will be in a few more decades.

The earth currently has billions more people than are necessary to keep humanity going; there's plenty of slack in the current system. Yes societies will have to evolve if birthrates stay low for a while, but they always have to evolve and if populations ever did drop precipitously low people already know how to make more babies.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by ryandrake on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:56AM (#41192214)
Not only that, but the "cure for dying" will surely be priced such that only the already-wealthy elite of that generation will be able to afford it. It's not going to just be handed out to everyone.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by tavavex on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:26AM (#41192551)
Why not, actually? Why wouldn't it be at least somewhat related to the price of executing that life-prolonging procedure? The providers will surely want to sell it to the maximum number of customers in all countries.

Even if you argue that this would go against the interests of the highest class, what could they do? Technology is pretty unstoppable, and individual actors are usually pretty bad at conspiring together unless there's something in it for everyone involved. Not to mention that there's not even a way to define what specific dollar amount moves you from "wealthy commoner" to the "wealthy elite", especially if taking into account different countries.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by mlyle on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:06PM (#41197670)
> Why not, actually? Why wouldn't it be at least somewhat related to the price of executing that life-prolonging procedure?

Odds are we're talking about a suite of many procedures, some of which are intrinsically very expensive and that humanity doesn't have the resources to provide to everyone. But if it's really cheap...

> The providers will surely want to sell it to the maximum number of customers in all countries.

The maximum profit point isn't likely to be just above that really cheap price. People would be willing to give a significant fraction of their wealth for a magic bullet life extension, and most of the world's population has no wealth. Providers' ability to perform price discrimination isn't going to be perfect.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by saghm on Friday August 09, 2024 @11:35PM (#41207115)
> Why not, actually? Why wouldn't it be at least somewhat related to the price of executing that life-prolonging procedure?

If it's anything like medical procedures that exist today, it sounds like at least in the US it will be impossible to afford without insurance, and therefore employment. "You can live forever, as long as you work forever" is exactly the amount of depressing I'd expect from real life.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by nine_k on Thursday August 08, 2024 @12:55PM (#41193661)
Why, it just should be required regularly in order to not die. Like food.

Recurring revenue is best revenue. Customer's LTV would be only limited by astronomical circumstances like the Sun turning into a red giant.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:31PM (#41194111)
I just remembered this great sci-fi book which has a good take on these issues:

https://www.amazon.com/Buying-Time-Joe-Haldeman/dp/038070439...

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by pretzellogician on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:12PM (#41194547)
"Buying Time" is great! Enjoyable take on longevity through technology. I have multiple copies, at least one of which is signed by Haldeman.

There was a followup comic book series, which was decent.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by PaulHoule on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:16PM (#41194598)
There are so many great Haldeman books, particularly the ones where he sets out to kill a Heinlein book as did "The Forever War" (Starship Troopers) and "Worlds" (The Moon is a Harsh Mistress.)

That book popped into my mind; it took two tries to find it with Copilot and I was pleasantly reminded of who the author was.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by louky on Friday August 09, 2024 @06:48AM (#41200575)
Thanks for those book recommendations. I'm always interested in discussion or reactions to Heinlein.

>particularly the ones where he sets out to kill a Heinlein book

Interesting statement, I'm grabbing those books now.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by recursive on Thursday August 08, 2024 @01:59PM (#41194406)
"Altered Carbon" dealt with themes like that. I would imagine there are probably a bunch of other sci-fi works dealing with it. It's a cool idea.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by ElectroBuffoon on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:21PM (#41196431)
The elite will finally meet the long term consequences of their past and present decisions.

It will be an spectacle: the true test of how useful wealth is against the Universe, compared to other things like knowledge or wisdom.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by andsoitis on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:50AM (#41201835)
> The elite will finally meet the long term consequences of their past and present decisions. It will be a spectacle: the true test of how useful wealth is against the Universe, compared to other things like knowledge or wisdom.

This is casting categories of people in very rigid and binary terms. Wisdom and knowledge is not more prevalent amongst the non-elite is it? Isn’t it distributed more evenly?

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by ElectroBuffoon on Saturday August 10, 2024 @05:21AM (#41208311)
Thanks to their power, their decisions affect many. Those decisions are taken sometimes blindly, even if they could pay for good advice, sometimes knowing it's only for own benefit in short term at the expense of the rest. In the later case, they have knowledge, but decide to act anyway, as long term they will be dead. Any bad or good decision by a poor nobody will have a lot less impact.

Iain M. Banks probably said it best. "I mean, your society's broken, so who should we blame?"

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2013/jun/15/iain-banks-the...

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by markovs_gun on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:45AM (#41200284)
Yeah you think it's bad that the baby boomers can just run society seemingly forever? What happens if the worst boomers literally never die?
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by rurp on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:53PM (#41196128)
Yep and ossified control structures aren't exactly known for being flexible and well run in the long term. A permanent ruling class will almost certainly lead to a major collapse at some point, bringing down all of that fancy technology with it.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by RandomThoughts3 on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:17PM (#41203696)
> will rule the world forever

If by forever, you mean until they actually disappear from something they have failed to foresee or couldn’t avoid, then, yes maybe.

Nothing is forever. Prolongating human life would probably barely make a dent in the grand scheme of things.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by litenboll on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:50AM (#41189732)
What if reluctance to accept new ideas later in life stems from mortality in the first place?
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by scandox on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:56AM (#41189771)
Well who knows. My bet is on the very long-lived being fairly risk averse. And new ideas are risky.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by waterhouse on Thursday August 08, 2024 @07:25AM (#41190285)
If you're going to retire in N years, then that gives you an upper limit to how much you can benefit from learning (or even experimenting with) a new and potentially better approach, versus sticking with what currently works for you. As N gets smaller, the cost-benefit analysis increasingly favors the latter.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by ted_bunny on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:55AM (#41189763)
Enough people deny their mortality that I doubt this is the case.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by Filligree on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:17AM (#41189869)
People can deny their mortality all they like; they’re still mortal, and things like lower learning rates are likely to be genetic.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by FeepingCreature on Thursday August 08, 2024 @08:55AM (#41191008)
I like the concept that because we decline in liquid IQ as we age, so our static skill growth is always counterbalanced by our intellectual decline, we have never even seen a human being in the fullness of its power.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by kiba on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:55AM (#41192204)
That is silly. Some people are more adaptable than other and are able to change their mind through time.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by litenboll on Monday August 12, 2024 @09:32AM (#41224172)
What is silly? Your statement can be true at the same time... And just to be clear, I did not mean that it's the sole reason that people refute new ideas, I was just opening up the possibility that without mortality we might still have progress without relying on generation shifts.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by throw9474 on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:14PM (#41194574)
What if every time you accept new ideas, your old self dies a little bit?

Our five year old self is already dead.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by idiotsecant on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:41PM (#41194819)
I think neuroplasticity is well known to have a physical basis. We can probably extend the neuroplasticity of young adult and early middle age into longer and longer timespans, but all you have to do is watch a teenager or young adult for a few days to see that the extreme neuroplasticity of very young people definitely comes with some drawbacks.

I don't think I would want a future immortal billionaire with access to accumulated generations of power to enter a new adolescence with the brain reset that comes along with it.

We need young people to be stupid and brash and occasionally fearless and brilliant and unburdened by the lessons (or scars) of the past to keep society moving forward but those can't be the same people in charge of the world. There are roles for both.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by jimbokun on Thursday August 08, 2024 @02:59PM (#41195000)
In the US at least, young people are a lot more risk averse than previous generations.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by Nursie on Thursday August 08, 2024 @06:09AM (#41189830)
If flexibility and plasticity of thinking are age-related, couldn't prevention of ageing maintain that?

I think it's inevitable that such a change would cause big social upheavals. I find it highly ironic that those people who call this out as a negative often also call out how people living longer are change averse.

> I enjoy life but it's important to my enjoyment that there is a terminus.

Can I ask why, genuinely?

The fact that I will likely die sometime in the next 50 years doesn't make the evening out I have planned any better or worse. The band I'm going to see are getting older, but I'm going to see them because they're coming to my town and it'll be enjoyable. My eventual death has no bearing on it at all as far as I can tell.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by voiceblue on Thursday August 08, 2024 @10:23AM (#41191857)
On the one hand, we enjoy real flowering plants more than fake ones, and delight in anticipating their blossoming, though it is the fake plants that are ever blooming and ever lasting.

On the other hand, the only moment in which you have direct control and could actually affect is the current one.

When Pinocchio made his wish, was “agency” all he wanted, or was there something more?

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by Nursie on Thursday August 08, 2024 @11:01AM (#41192260)
> though it is the fake plants that are ever blooming and ever lasting.

I have recently been envious of a neighbours bushes - they flowered uninterrupted for many months, all spring, summer and autumn. Fantastic sprays of cream and crimson blooms. Both beautiful and long-lasting, I would love to plant those over more temporally limited ones that only flower for a few days per year.

It is not the permanence that is unappealing about fake blooms, nor the brevity that makes flowers beautiful. To me anyway. Silk wallpaper with floral prints that has survived for hundreds of years in old British castles and country homes is no less beautiful for its age.

I’m not sure I see the relevance of your other points. I guess we see things very differently.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by arisAlexis on Thursday August 08, 2024 @03:51PM (#41195487)
But you can always end it so why not give option? Options make for greatest value
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by neuralRiot on Thursday August 08, 2024 @04:32PM (#41195905)
I think that what most pro-immortality people forget is that forever is not just a very long time, our finite thinking does not allow us to understand something that never start or never ends and that death is life just as light is darkness and heat is cold one cannot exist without the other.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by goatlover on Thursday August 08, 2024 @05:02PM (#41196226)
Immortality isn't a thing, the heat death of the universe virtually guarantees that. But nobody seriously thinks they're going to live a Googleplex of years. They just don't want to be limited to a max 110 year lifespan, where there's a good chance you spend the last few years wasting away in some nursing home. Why not live a few centuries or even millenia until something inevitably kills you? There's way more to see and do than any one current lifespan.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by strogonoff on Friday August 09, 2024 @02:30AM (#41199271)
Effective immortality is very much a thing for everyone at present. Given immortality means living forever, if you cannot access experience before your life, and you cannot access experience after your life, then for all purposes your life is forever as far as your experience goes, and your experience is all there is for you.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by goatlover on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:44PM (#41205611)
Semantics doesn't change the equation. I'd rather live a few centuries than tell myself that.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by strogonoff on Saturday August 10, 2024 @03:14AM (#41207871)
> Semantics doesn't change the equation.

“Semantics” is simply “meaning”. If something has a different meaning, the equation no longer solves the same way.

If you feel defensive and want ways to put someone down, you can replace “semantics” with “sophism” or something like that.

> I'd rather live a few centuries than tell myself that.

But you can’t, can you? So might as well look into what life, death, and immortality might really be, beyond the naive and wrong intuitions we have picked up from fiction books about vampires.

Unless you believe in life after death (which I would not blame you for as many do, among scientists included), there is no span of time available to you in which you are not alive.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by neuralRiot on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:03PM (#41205391)
> There's way more to see and do than any one current lifespan.

Perhaps this a personal view but I had conversations with elder people and most will tell you the same, a very long life (even a healthy one) is quite boring and depressing, you start to see the same patterns again and again, everything and everyone you loved dissappear and the essence of humanity doesn’t change. Same play, different actors and costumes.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by goatlover on Friday August 09, 2024 @05:46PM (#41205625)
I'm sure some people feel that way, but I also know not everyone does. I have to wonder how much of that is a consequence of aging. Anyway, life extension can be a choice, once it's available.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by Viliam1234 on Saturday August 10, 2024 @12:09PM (#41210435)
Different people are different. For some people everything is so boooooooring already at high school. For other people, it's "vita brevis, ars longa".

> everything and everyone you loved disappear

Perhaps with immortality, there would be less of this?

Maybe I am just too young to understand the wisdom of the old people. I am almost 50, so in the optimistic case I might get the same amount of time again. That is definitely not enough to see all the things I want to see, try all the things I want to try, learn all the things I want to learn.

I imagine that when your health becomes shit, life sucks and you get tired of it. Good immortality should come with perfect (or at least average, from out current perspective) health. That includes mental health.

But if someone believes that he already understands everything and it's all just the same patterns over and over again... dude, where are all your Nobel prices? Maybe your life is boring because you don't try new things.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by neuralRiot on Monday August 12, 2024 @04:35PM (#41229022)
I’m in you age bracket and I wouldn’t say I find life “boring”, I find it recurrent, to me being able to communicate instantly from one end of the world to the other but being unable to understand our neighbor who thinks differently and losing the sense of “community” to become just individuals living closely in isolation to be able to travel in minutes what used to take months but at the expense of destroying our own environment and poisoning the future of our own descendants is no evolution. As Mahatma Gandhi said: “There’s more to life than increasing its speed”
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by snickerbockers on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:56AM (#41200969)
You seem to be under the impression that this is some sort of Faustian pact that prevents you from ever changing your mind at any point in the future.
Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by andsoitis on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:47AM (#41201808)
> all that will happen is that human development will slow down: after all if it requires a generation of human scientists to die so that new ideas can be accepted then

It isn’t obvious to me that that is given. An alternative would be that the breadth of parallel ideas would expand, more competition. There could then also be more depth because individuals behind groundbreaking ideas can build on their cognitive foundations for longer.

One major change, which it thibk would be a positive is that we will be directed to thibk more long term. With extreme life extension, the cosmos also becomes smaller because we could travel and explore space and time more extensively.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by DontchaKnowit on Friday August 09, 2024 @06:41PM (#41205965)
Just my 2 cents - "why on earth would you ever want to die"

Because its the end of any worry, doubt, suffering, fear, uncertainty. Because its over. And youll be dead, so you wont be able to feel what youre missing out on.

The finality of death is a beautiful and comforting eventuality in my opinion.

Re:A Nobel Prize winner's brilliant tirade against mortality by AuryGlenz on Saturday August 10, 2024 @12:15PM (#41210479)
I know a lot of people share similar sentiments but I doubt many feel that way when they’re on their deathbed.

Personally, I don’t want to die. There’s so much to do, see, and experience. One lifetime isn’t even close to enough, and that only got worse since I had children.