“Semantics” is simply “meaning”. If something has a different meaning, the equation no longer solves the same way.
If you feel defensive and want ways to put someone down, you can replace “semantics” with “sophism” or something like that.
> I'd rather live a few centuries than tell myself that.
But you can’t, can you? So might as well look into what life, death, and immortality might really be, beyond the naive and wrong intuitions we have picked up from fiction books about vampires.
Unless you believe in life after death (which I would not blame you for as many do, among scientists included), there is no span of time available to you in which you are not alive.
Perhaps this a personal view but I had conversations with elder people and most will tell you the same, a very long life (even a healthy one) is quite boring and depressing, you start to see the same patterns again and again, everything and everyone you loved dissappear and the essence of humanity doesn’t change. Same play, different actors and costumes.
> everything and everyone you loved disappear
Perhaps with immortality, there would be less of this?
Maybe I am just too young to understand the wisdom of the old people. I am almost 50, so in the optimistic case I might get the same amount of time again. That is definitely not enough to see all the things I want to see, try all the things I want to try, learn all the things I want to learn.
I imagine that when your health becomes shit, life sucks and you get tired of it. Good immortality should come with perfect (or at least average, from out current perspective) health. That includes mental health.
But if someone believes that he already understands everything and it's all just the same patterns over and over again... dude, where are all your Nobel prices? Maybe your life is boring because you don't try new things.