To make things worse, for 99% of people things might look normal but for 1% it may show a large skew. The net can have memorized this.
Obviously, this becomes an arms race. The usual strategy is to add random checks, friction to contribution and severe-enough punishments for offenders (lifetime RL bans, etc.)
Expert opinions welcome - I'm a tourist.
So they also have to give up all their user data?
Meaning if I record my own inputs, I should be able to recreate the suggestions I see using the published software. This doesn't mean the inputs of other users are exposed to me, but it does imply that "the algorithm" can only use data that is either publicly exposed or is my own inputs.
That seems pretty restricting given that even the most basic recommendation would try to cluster users based on interests and use that to recommend stuff (eg. Amazon's "customers who viewed this item also bought..." from decades ago).
That would be very hard/impossible to recreate in order to test the algorithm.
In whatever form it takes such that a regulator can scrutinise it. If that seems arduous or impacts the social media business model, too bad. Nothing of value will have been lost. I am not typically a person who favours over regulation, even my views on AI are likely too liberal for HN, but on the matter of social media impacting children, I'm all in for regulation.
If you publish your algorithm, you are giving interested parties the instruction manual on how to game it; spammers and propagandists can use that algorithm to make sure their content gets to the top.
Letting people see into it could make it easier for people to learn how to game the system but it could also make the system harder to game in the first place.
Enough researchers, at enough institutions with sufficiently diverse motives, that if multiple of them identify a problem and agree about it, Joe can make a reasonably confident assessment that there's probably something there.
They will make less ad money and engagement will go down because we won't be training children to become 5 second scrollers, but this doesn't seem like an issue to me.
How would new content discovery happen in your proposed world?
Content discovery was word of mouth or a separate page dedicated to popular stuff.
There is no sarcasm; does anyone genuinely only browse sites like hackernews by viewing the 'new' page? That is what the comment is advocating, that the only view should be the new page, with submissions listed by post date only.
If discovery is by a separate page dedicated to popular stuff, how is that any better? Whatever 'algorithm' is used to create that page would have the same problems that people are complaining about; why would putting it on a different page change anything? That is sort of how things are currently; you can view a feed by 'latest first' or by the 'algorithm'. You can choose either one, but most people prefer the algorithm version because it curates.
People WANT curation. You can argue with the particular type of curation, but I think the concept itself is pretty universally desired.
Look at Instagram, Twitter, or Facebook, I believe there is a desire for a less algorithmic approach on those sites, hence all the uproar about the algorithms and shadow banning. Reverse chronological ordering from people you follow was the standard before, and a feature before revenue mattered as much. You curated your own feed by following people, not by a black box
> Social media are interactive technologies that facilitate the creation, sharing and aggregation of content, ideas, interests, and other forms of expression through virtual communities and networks.
Hacknews is one virtual community. The whole point of visiting the site is to aggregate content and read and make comments about that content.
Reddit and slashdot are also both social media sites.
An ad hominem attack doesn't seem necessary to prove your point (speaking as someone who actually is old enough to remember).
There are definitely people in the tech field who have only (or mostly) experienced algorithmic based feeds.
If there's a need to provably ensure kids are not being influenced by algorithm, I think my solution works. Making social media less engaging for children is something I'm fine with. Adults can have whatever experience they want.
> How would new content discovery happen in your proposed world?
Seconding other posts—entirely fine, like it did before that kind of garbage.
Also a part of HN's "algorithm" is literally the mods manually adjusting things, and you can't publish that.
X/Twitter does now publish their algorithm, and it hasn't made it any less of a shithole.
The engagement ranking done to keep you hooked is probably not that interesting.
If that was the case, chinese state media ( where the chinese government actually has direct control over the content ) would be banned. But they are not banned.
Does it? And what does that even mean? Are there any other "content-neutral" and "fair" algorithms that you're aware of at other social media companies?
> we have no reason to believe it is unbiased.
Not only is that not how argument works, it's a bizarre bar that only tiktok has to leap to do business. We have every reason to believe that any and all commercial algorithms for selecting and prioritizing content to display to users are not "content-neutral," nor "fair" for every possible definition of fair.
Was this actually proven in specific incidents?
Is this the only media outlet this applies to?
No - and certainly not on any appreciable or meaningful scale.
The bill's proponents claim that intelligence agencies have found proof of this, and that the proof is classified and therefore cannot be shown to the public. (If you're over the age of 30, you're almost certainly getting early 2000s flashbacks reading that sentence).
> Is this the only media outlet this applies to?
No. The ban applies to TikTok, but as pointed above, not to Chinese (or Russian) state media, which do directly control the content shown to users.
(I'm sure it is; there have been plenty of people disappeared https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/nov/19/china-disappea... , but I'd just like to have a little evidence rather than do an Iraq war again)
In the US, the government has control over the content too, it just so happens that it mostly concerns itself with combatting certain moral vices (from prostitution to bootleg fireworks) - although to be fair, it also lightly pressured big tech into combatting political "misinformation".
In China, the same mechanisms exist, except the controls on speech are much tighter and the punishments more severe. Every other tech company operating there has a story of officials showing up with demands or threatening employees. I worked at two places where this happened. In addition, most businesses operate as formal or quasi-formal public-private partnership, where the CCP has officials within the corporate management structure. Again, ask anyone who tried to start a foreign-owned business in China.
You can make a reasonable argument that having an oppressive and geopolitically adversarial foreign government effectively in control of the most popular youth social media platform in the country is not great. Or you can make a reasonable free-trade argument. Free trade works only if all participants follow the rules; if Western social media can't operate on their market, they don't get to operate on ours.
There are things to dislike about the US government, but I really don't get the contrarian takes on TikTok. China is objectively worse and its government's legitimacy and lasting power is built in the bodies of tens of millions of victims. We're not getting along right now. This doesn't require cynicism to explain.
How is the Chinese government's control over TikTok content any more "direct" than the US government's control over Facebook content?
As for the US, we have documented evidence of US corporations cooperating with the US government for spying and propaganda efforts.
The US has 4x as many prisoners per capita than China, and Assange is still in captivity.
Let that sink in. (not in a musk way)
Last I checked, Elon Musk hadn't sent hundreds of Uighur women to rape camps to be "reeducated". He hasn't harvested organs from undesirables while they were still alive (for freshness) all that much either. I don't praise the United States government as saints and superheroes or anything like that, but to be unwilling to admit that there are still stark differences between the two countries probably means you wore a Che t-shirt in college and might even be wearing one now if your company permits casual dress.
I think that the parent point cedes this point, and argues that Musk's benefits, incentives, and morality are more favorable to that of the Chinese government.
An American civil war is high, if not at the top, of China's wish list. Yeah, they would feel the crunch, but would be able to cement unrivaled global power if the US unraveled.
So what? Why are Elon Musk and Sundar Piachi allowed direct control of what they show me but Shou Zi Chew isn’t? Is it due to governmental involvement? Imagine if the BBC broadcast direct to Americans!
Or are we, somehow, collectively, of the opinion China is an enemy of some variety? If so, what variety? And what weird peacetime rivalry are we having?
I don't think it's good that cabal of media and tech executives has so much concentrated control over public discourse. But there is a huge qualitative difference between them and a hostile foreign power.
[1] https://www.axios.com/local/salt-lake-city/2024/05/06/senato...
I think those are two sides of the same coin. If you read the whole quote in context[1], it seems equally likely that he was trying to imply that tiktok (the platform, not just the userbase) has a pro-palestinian bias, possibly due to the Chinese government. If it's the users who pro-palestinian, it would make little sense to ban the platform, because those users would still be pro-palestinian and migrate elsewhere. Reddit has a similar pro-palestinian bias, but it hasn't attracted similar scrutiny, presumably because no one suspects it of being controlled by the chinese government.
[1] https://www.state.gov/secretary-antony-j-blinken-at-mccain-i... (search for "SENATOR ROMNEY: A small parenthetical point, which is some wonder why")
Instagram apologises for adding ‘terrorist’ to some Palestinian users profiles bios [1]
Facebook violated rights of Palestinian users, report finds [2]
Activists: Google, Apple ‘Erasing Palestine’ from Geographic Apps [3]
[1] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/world/instagram-meta-palesti...
[2] https://apnews.com/article/technology-middle-east-israel-858...
[2] https://themedialine.org/by-region/activists-google-apple-er...
If TikTok can change public opinion then they must have speech right? How do they have speech without speaking? They have speech by filtering and weighing things a specific way. If you can speak without speaking then how does Section 230 come into play? If platforms can speak and have opinions and affect public opinion then whey do they get Section 230 protections? Should the algorithms be open sourced and transparent (or banned) since they have so much power?
It raises a lot of questions that we have put off answering. I think the (distant) relevance of Section 230 makes big tech scared to talk about it since that's their cash-cow.
Section 230 exists specifically to allow platforms to "have opinions and affect public opinion." Liability resides with the accounts making the content, not the platform. It would be impossible to have any degree of free expression on the internet if platforms were legally liable for everything posted there, or if they could be sued over every moderation decision they make.
>It raises a lot of questions that we have put off answering.
We haven't put off answering anything. We have the answers. Platforms are allowed to moderate content. They're allowed to filter and present content in whatever way they want. They're allowed to have a bias. There is no gray area here, no matter how badly people want there to be one.
I know people think that government regulating social media means some kind of laissez-faire free for all where all legal speech will be allowed without consequence (which would be even less moderation than you find on 4chan) but that is very much not how it would go.
Counterpoint: The law to ban tiktok was languishing after the US government got complete access to tiktok moderation, only still pushed by local anti-China grandstanders who ran on it when the government was busy extorting tiktok in order to get that access. The reason it passed now was to suppress the speech of Americans talking about the leveling of Gaza.
> All the talk about privacy and data collection were mostly to muddy the waters by bringing in all tech to the conversion, and divert attention from solely tiktok
Because an anti-tiktok law is a bill of attainder and completely unconstitutional (as I was once downvoted into oblivion for mentioning.) Generalizing the bill passes that constitutional hurdle, and if upheld allows the state to end-run around the 1st Amendment and ban speech at will. The bill would be useless if it didn't silence Americans, and all people will do after a tiktok ban is migrate to another speech platform. It's important to be able to silence speech everywhere.
> tiktok was banned primarily because of who controls the content delivered, not who is collecting the data.
The US doesn't care about tiktok, and has full access to ban whatever it likes. The US cares about silencing you.
Perhaps that's the real reason. But if so, why can't the US government just require Tiktok to push content that aligns with US interests? Say for every 3 videos a user watches, they are then required to watch a US army recruitment ad, or an VOA anti-China propaganda clip, or Uncle Sam telling them that there's a high chance they just watched foreign propaganda (think tobacco package warning messages). I'm pretty sure that Tiktok would find this acceptable as the cost of doing business, and that China wouldn't care — plenty of anti-China content already exists on Tiktok.
Of course I'm not seriously suggesting this. But I'm saying that if control over content is the real motivating concern, why wouldn't a solution like this be considered viable?
The suggestion doesn't restrict how much anti-US propaganda gets pushed.
I don't think TikTok or the US would find it acceptable. It is too heavy handed
It's less heavy handed than banning outright, though.
> The suggestion doesn't restrict how much anti-US propaganda gets pushed.
Good point. Let me refine my suggestion so as to require that TikTok prohibit all anti-US content: sophisticated AI algorithms would be put in place to ensure that content that doesn't align with US interests is not allowed. This will make the suggestion even more heavy-handed, but note that, once again, it's still less heavy-handed than banning outright.
Instead, it relies on US citizens embedded in US companies to push US ideals in social media. When it does presumably conduct social engineering attacks, it does it through bots and buying adds on platforms.
Last, I don't think the US government expecting to have to actually ban Tiktok. I think it is expecting to win, and get to have it's cake and eat it too. This would be the least heavy handed option.
All the talk about privacy and data collection were mostly to muddy the waters by bringing in all tech to the conversion, and divert attention from solely tiktok ("Everyone does it so why focus on tiktok?!"). It's still a threat, I'm not trying to minimize it, but tiktok was banned primarily because of who controls the content delivered, not who is collecting the data.