Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @02:55AM
(#39976790)
Spread LGBTQ hate, do not expect to participate in the wider open source community. Simple as. Codes of conduct effectively apply everywhere, because many CoC committees issue bans on the criterion of "likely to violate", not "did in fact violate".
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:02AM
(#39977118)
A moderator on Vaxry's discord changed a transgender person's pronouns from "they/them" to "who/cares". Vaxry did nothing about it, and even supported this change, stating that the person was making too big a deal about their pronouns:
It may therefore be concluded that Vaxry condones transphobia and transphobic behavior, and therefore he doesn't have a place on FDO or any mainstream open source project.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by PlutoIsAPlanet on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:07AM
(#39977146)
That's immature and unthoughtful behaviour, but I fail to see "hate" or continued spreading of "hate", why a Wayland compositor uses Discord as a community forum given Discord is the gutter when it comes to online converse , who knows.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @06:26AM
(#39977969)
Discord is much, much more convenient than the historic alternatives like IRC or email. If you want a project to grow you have to meet prospective developers where they are; and in the 2020s that's X (Twitter), Mastodon, and Discord. Discord communities can be moderated to be safe and friendly... but Vaxry couldn't be arsed to do so because he's "based".
As to whether Vaxry was "really" promulgating hate... Refusing to acknowledge and respect a person's gender identity is transphobic.
Condoning this behavior (and victim-blaming the person who called it out) is transphobic.
When trans people and trans allies have positions of authority in an open-source community, public transphobes will get issued preemptive bans for the health of the community and the project. It is altogether fitting and proper that this be done.
Oh, and the fact that Vaxry slagged off Lyude publicly in his blog for good-faith enforcement of the code of conduct (as she has the authority and duty to do) just means that FreeDesktop would ban him again harder if they could.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @08:08AM
(#39978554)
In case the cited example is not enough to count as "hate" for you (in which case, the code of conduct teams of major open source projects should take a good look at your behavior and determine whether to permit you to contribute to such projects), Lyude calls out a few specific instances in her opening email:
I'd like to take a moment to specifically point out some examples that were brought to our attention of this behavior:
* Hazing someone in your discord because they have pronouns in their bio
* Speaking pretty bluntly against queer people and minorities at large
- "at 15 he doesnt even know what he will be studying at uni and he already wanna go get AIDS?"
- "I think this server's motto should be 'love guns, hate damn minorities'"
But ultimately, I do not see your name on the FreeDesktop.org code of conduct committee... therefore, your opinion of what constitutes hate is completely irrelevant in this case. Code of Conduct committees are authorized to issue bans against anyone who, in their sole discretion, is an asshole specifically to avoid this kind of fruitless argument. The emphasis is on fostering a safe and welcoming community. Not in allowing freeze peach activists to sealion their way out of a ban.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by neonsunset on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @09:40AM
(#39979336)
This email is a very good demonstration on why you don't negotiate with terrorists or politburo representatives.
They have gotten where they are exactly because they enjoy abusing the power given to them. Pleading your case before them is to just give them amusement.
They will spit on the work you carefully worked on throughout the years and celebrate that.
Thus, you don't negotiate. Instead, you go to their higher-ups and highlight that the company's resources are being misappropriated for petty squabbles and personal tilting at windmills.
Though sadly nowadays it has gotten way more difficult, because a greater portion of bureaucratic, community and HR positions in the companies are captured, so when the damage is noticed, it may already be too late.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by throwaway_62022 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:21PM
(#39983804)
So, whatever is posted publicly on "polite" forums about what was going on Hyprland discord is tip of the iceberg. See for yourself - https://imgur.com/a/6Po3Paq
Hyprland discord appears to be a cesspool and one fermented by Vaxry himself, trans hate or otherwise. Now some people are saying - they have improved (and others are saying they have not). But reading his blog posts and seeing current status, I am not optimistic. I mean you can't make this stuff up. Why use a opensource discord community for sharing porn? (which likely have minors).
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by midnight2 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:25PM
(#39983854)
So? Is xe a discord moderator? Are you?
Stay out of other people's business. What they say and do in their discord server has nothing to do with code contributions an owner of the server makes.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @03:38PM
(#39983336)
No. We are at the level of holding people accountable for their BEHAVIOR. Something that historically hasn't been done, resulting in a chilling effect on contributions from decent people, especially those from marginalized groups. That's changing.
You can fulminate about trans people all you like in the quiet of your own home, but if you harass or intimidate them in a publicly viewable way, there will be consequences. And when a code of conduct board member for a project approaches you and tells you you need to do better, any response other than "Yes, sir/ma'am/other, I will do better" is grounds for questioning whether you should be permitted to contribute further to the project.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by midnight2 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @09:25PM
(#39986062)
Normal people aren't hall monitors and don't really care whether you're offended, just about avoiding your censorship boot. You'll find that out eventually.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by DarkByte8 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:31PM
(#39983922)
The more you talk the more people will avoid you and people like you. You are not holding people accountable you are having a power trip and enacting vengeance on perceived transgressions. He did not harass anyone and for past transgression he apologize but the CoC board member felt like he needed a power trip. People like you should be held far away from any position of power.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by DarkByte8 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @11:54AM
(#39980763)
> When trans people and trans allies have positions of authority in an open-source community, public transphobes will get issued preemptive bans for the health of the community and the project. It is altogether fitting and proper that this be done.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by zilti on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @07:13PM
(#39985322)
> Refusing to acknowledge and respect a person's gender identity is transphobic
He didn't do that though. He made fun of that person's obsession with pronouns. It is so simple, really - if you're a (trans/cis) woman, it's "she/her", if you're a (trans/cis) man, it's "he/him"; and if you think you need to shove your incredible uniqueness into everyone's conversation by coming up with something else, it's time to see a therapist for your narcissism.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @05:27PM
(#39984468)
When you make as many valuable contributions to the open source graphics stack as Lyude has, you might hold a position of significant authority within FDO or a similar project also.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by jacobgkau on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:35AM
(#39987979)
Unless Lyude decides you need to be banned for something that happened in a different place multiple years ago, in which case your valuable contributions mean nothing and you're no longer allowed to contribute.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @05:04AM
(#39988537)
If you wish to study physics at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and the dean finds out that you have a history of painting swastikas on buildings and decides to ban your ass from campus, it's not exactly an arbitrary or capricious decision.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by midnight2 on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @01:03PM
(#39993027)
Why would they ban a jew from jewish school?
Normal people don't think software projects should be like religious organizations or political clubs because making them such does nothing but harm the software.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by jacobgkau on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @06:55PM
(#39996543)
IMO, the rude and unprompted initial email was "inflammatory." It was responded to in kind, which the sender did not take well.
If you're that upset about someone publishing a supposedly formal email that you sent, perhaps you should consider why that is instead of just knee-jerk banning the person to protect yourself.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by midnight2 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:18PM
(#39983776)
It'll die before then, they're already putting him in a cage for not coddling people's feelings.
Already such flimsy material reasons to use or contribute to FOSS instead of using often better proprietary software. When you're endorsing the philosophy of reddit mod types by using FOSS and will get banned from contributing for being sane the negatives start to outweigh the positives
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by luyu_wu on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @12:37PM
(#39981189)
Vaxry has since responded to this and apologized numerous times.
As he states many times in his blogposts, he ais apologetic for this incident
I, like him, fail to see why this keeps on being brung up. The server and him have changed drastically, it's not very fair to judge a changed person on their past actions.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by drewdevault on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @01:53PM
(#39982125)
He has not made any meaningful apologies, and each example that might be construed as such is buried in qualifications and lengthy tirades about his persecution complex. Meanwhile, he continues to constantly post hateful tirades complaining about the fact that the free software community holds people accountable for their behavior. An apology without taking accountability for wrongdoing or fostering any meaningful change in behavior or attitude is worthless.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by zilti on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @07:07PM
(#39985288)
> stating that the person was making too big a deal about their pronouns
Some people turn their pronouns into their personality, and it's effing annoying. IMO it's perfectly fine to make fun of such people. Being trans doesn't protect them from being made fun of, nor does it make the person making the joke a transphobic.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by throwaway_62022 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:24PM
(#39983843)
So, whatever is posted publicly on "polite" forums about what was going on Hyprland discord is tip of the iceberg. See for yourself - https://imgur.com/a/6Po3Paq
Changing someone's pronouns without their permissions seems like least of their offenses.
Hyprland discord appears to be a cesspool and one fermented by Vaxry himself, trans hate or otherwise. Now some people are saying - they have improved (and others are saying they have not). But reading his blog posts and seeing current status, I am not optimistic. I mean you can't make this stuff up. Why use a opensource discord community for sharing porn? (which likely have minors).
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by midnight2 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @06:22PM
(#39984961)
Only as long as SJWs are in charge of successful open source projects. When those that shun chopped-off CoCs outperform those infected by the cancer you will have no ability to censor
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by jdiff on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @11:21PM
(#39986658)
There's more than enough competent people who aren't asocial edgelords. Most people are happy letting other people live their lives and will in fact shit on people who don't allow others to do the same.
That's not hall monitoring, that's what the both of us think we're doing. Difference is one of us is shitting on people who would exclude others based on their identity, and the other is shitting on people who would shit on people who would shit on people based on their identity. You're not against shitting on people, you just want to be allowed to shit on other people without consequence. That's not how the world works. Talk shit, you get shown the door.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by neonsunset on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @07:30AM
(#39989466)
The reference to asociality and anti-sociality is rather ironic in the context of abuse of power and specifically going out of one’s way, as a paid employee, to harm someone working on OSS projects full-time for free.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by jdiff on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @09:11AM
(#39990310)
Since stripping the nitpicky word out detracts from the comment a negligible amount, since always. It's obnoxious word and tone policing that doesn't say anything.
You're right that you're not a hall monitor though. You're worse, actually, because you are actually committing a good deal of the harassment of real people yourself. You have in these very comments. You're bullying people away and pretending that this is better than preventing someone from entering their own well-kept garden.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by midnight2 on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:17PM
(#39994674)
Yes, bullying people that want to censor others is good. As long as I'm not preventing them from contributing, there's nothing wrong with calling them and their views stupid. If they decide to contribute to a project I'm involved in they may, I do not care who they are. That's what's important
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by jdiff on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @03:27PM
(#39994793)
You (attempted to) tell a trans woman that they weren't a real woman. That's not anything to do with censorship or anything "noble," that's just transphobia and you're just a bully. Fuck off, dude.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by diidiidi on Thursday April 11, 2024 @02:58AM
(#39999131)
Me too. Or rather, I'm proudly in favour of supporting women and girls who need single-sex female-only spaces, proudly in objection to harmful "gender-affirming" cosmetic treatments for children, and stand proudly against the enforced and controlled speech that gender believers wish to impose upon all of society. If that makes me a "transphobe" then so be it.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by gandhi_lion on Thursday April 11, 2024 @03:31AM
(#39999324)
A 'trans woman' is a type of man though. All of them are male, by definition.
Only if you have nonsensical and sexist beliefs like 'a woman is anyone who says they are a woman' or 'a woman is anyone who performs femininity' or 'a woman is anyone feminine enough for me to be sexually attracted to them' would you think that these men are women.
The rest of us live in the real world where we understand women to be female and men to be male.
Wild accusations of transphobia are losing their impact, these days it means more to the accuser than the accused. It's like a Christian calling an atheist 'heretic'. No big deal really.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @11:37PM
(#39986706)
We don't have to tolerate assholes even if they're really, really good.
But uhhh... Lyude, Alyssa Rosenzweig, Xe Iaso, Gankra, Ariadne Conill, Sage Sharp... There are an absurd number of highly competent trans developers who have made profoundly significant contributions to the open source ecosystem and justly ascended to leadership positions because of it. Right-wing edgelords? Not so much. In fact without trans people you wouldn't have a computer to type your right-wing screeds on: Lynn Conway invented VLSI and Sophie Wilson co-developed the ARM architecture. So yes, ban the fascist edgelords. Nothing of value will be lost.
Hacker culture is queer, furry, neurodiverse. Deal with it.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by neonsunset on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @08:47AM
(#39978842)
Wow. This looks really bad and ideologically driven behavior from FDO member. As usual, the likely scenario is RedHat are unaware and the person who executed the ban is simply abusing their position of power.
This, unfortunately, is an extremely common occurrence throughout many dev communities today. Sadly, companies still have not learned the kind of damage it does to them and how inappropriate this kind of abuse is. Still someone should let RedHat representatives know that the account rights are being misused.
Perhaps creating a list is in order, so we know who to never give any rights to manage the community or participate across multiple projects?
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by neonsunset on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @09:58AM
(#39979504)
Have you read the email conversation in question? Surely it made you concerned at least a little in regards to the state of FDO and RedHat?
Thinly and not so thinly veiled threats to another person to police their own, not related to FDO in any way, shape or form, community because it does not adhere to your political ideology sounds like a severe abuse of power to me.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by robert_foss on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @10:17AM
(#39979690)
Yes, I read it.
No one is owed FDO membership.
FDO is a community, and having people be treated with respect is crucial for maintaining this community. Letting people with a history of not respecting others be a part of that community is a problem, even if that behavior was displayed elsewhere.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by neonsunset on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @10:25AM
(#39979768)
Surely you must be joking.
I don't remember since when "bowing down to threats" is adhering to CoC and "openly threatening someone over resolved conflicts under the suspicion of wrongthink" was "respectful behavior from community representatives".
Either way, it is always "we're just policing the bad people" until the bad person is you.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by srid on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @04:08PM
(#39983695)
I really find this comment fascinating.
It doesn't address the contents of this particular incident, rather it alludes to vague and nice-sounding moral principles thereby brushing off the whole specific issue. It is interesting, because by staying general the author gets to shrink from taking the responsibility of giving their actual opinion on the specific incident itself.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by immibis on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @07:01AM
(#39989304)
The specifics of this incident:
- Vaxry is obviously a transphobe
- Many good FOSS developers are trans
- Giving vaxry a space is likely to drive off many more good FOSS developers
- Therefore it's better for the project if we don't.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by bitwize on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @10:18AM
(#39979692)
> Have you read the email conversation in question? Surely it made you concerned at least a little in regards to the state of FDO and RedHat?
Have you? Because from my read, it was Vaxry and the people he condoned on the Hyprland Discord who exhibited the concerning behavior. Lyude was enforcing the code of conduct as written, as is her job to do as a code of conduct committee member.
And it wasn't just her. The entire committee agreed that Vaxry's behavior was problematic. If anything, Lyude was the committee member most likely to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Honestly, if you are "concerned in regards to the state of FDO and Red Hat" over a legitimate code of conduct enforcement measure against a person known to be toxic, I'd say that's right up there with blathering about "ethics in game journalism" as a proxy for being the sort of asshole who should be preemptively banned.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by doublepg23 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @11:38PM
(#39986712)
> And, to Vaxry – I know you’re reading this – there are going to continue to be consequences for your actions, but it’s still not too late to change. I know it’s humiliating to be called out like this, and I really would rather not have had to do so. FDO is probably not the last time you’re going to be banned if you don’t change course, and it would reflect better on you if you took it on the chin and didn’t post inflammatory rants on your blog – trust me, you don’t look like the good guy here. You are trapped in an echo chamber of hate, anger, and bigotry. I hope that you find a way out, and that someday you can build a community which is as great as your software is.
What the heck is this plea? It's like something a Mormon would say to their ex-Mormon "friend".
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by robert_foss on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @12:54PM
(#39981361)
Almost every FDO member is an employee of a corporation. Some are required to use their corporate email for upstream contributions. This is all very normal.
Re:RedHat employee bans Hyprland creator from fdo
by rtz121 on Tuesday April 09, 2024 @03:38PM
(#39983332)
It's both hilarious and sad to see a bunch of 30-40 year old open source devs with mentalities comparable to Reddit moderators collectively bullying a 20(?) year old slightly immature dude.
https://drewdevault.com/2023/09/17/Hyprland-toxicity.html
It may therefore be concluded that Vaxry condones transphobia and transphobic behavior, and therefore he doesn't have a place on FDO or any mainstream open source project.
Keyword in your message is "may".
As to whether Vaxry was "really" promulgating hate... Refusing to acknowledge and respect a person's gender identity is transphobic.
Condoning this behavior (and victim-blaming the person who called it out) is transphobic.
When trans people and trans allies have positions of authority in an open-source community, public transphobes will get issued preemptive bans for the health of the community and the project. It is altogether fitting and proper that this be done.
Oh, and the fact that Vaxry slagged off Lyude publicly in his blog for good-faith enforcement of the code of conduct (as she has the authority and duty to do) just means that FreeDesktop would ban him again harder if they could.
From what I see they both slagged each other.
Again though, I'm asking for where's the spreading of hate.
But ultimately, I do not see your name on the FreeDesktop.org code of conduct committee... therefore, your opinion of what constitutes hate is completely irrelevant in this case. Code of Conduct committees are authorized to issue bans against anyone who, in their sole discretion, is an asshole specifically to avoid this kind of fruitless argument. The emphasis is on fostering a safe and welcoming community. Not in allowing freeze peach activists to sealion their way out of a ban.
They will spit on the work you carefully worked on throughout the years and celebrate that.
Thus, you don't negotiate. Instead, you go to their higher-ups and highlight that the company's resources are being misappropriated for petty squabbles and personal tilting at windmills.
Though sadly nowadays it has gotten way more difficult, because a greater portion of bureaucratic, community and HR positions in the companies are captured, so when the damage is noticed, it may already be too late.
Hyprland discord appears to be a cesspool and one fermented by Vaxry himself, trans hate or otherwise. Now some people are saying - they have improved (and others are saying they have not). But reading his blog posts and seeing current status, I am not optimistic. I mean you can't make this stuff up. Why use a opensource discord community for sharing porn? (which likely have minors).
Stay out of other people's business. What they say and do in their discord server has nothing to do with code contributions an owner of the server makes.
You can fulminate about trans people all you like in the quiet of your own home, but if you harass or intimidate them in a publicly viewable way, there will be consequences. And when a code of conduct board member for a project approaches you and tells you you need to do better, any response other than "Yes, sir/ma'am/other, I will do better" is grounds for questioning whether you should be permitted to contribute further to the project.
Will the invasion of FOSS continue?
Never opposed by sane normal people?
Be ready for the masses to say "no" when you order them around.
A time when mentally ill men aren't given rule over all FOSS projects is coming.
Woman fights back!
Now read the first word of each line above :)
Someone has been held accountable for their behaviour and apologised, it doesn't mean they're forever in your debt and on a chain.
It sounds like abuse of power
He didn't do that though. He made fun of that person's obsession with pronouns. It is so simple, really - if you're a (trans/cis) woman, it's "she/her", if you're a (trans/cis) man, it's "he/him"; and if you think you need to shove your incredible uniqueness into everyone's conversation by coming up with something else, it's time to see a therapist for your narcissism.
No that’s simply acknowledging biological reality.
We don’t affirm schizophrenia or anorexia. Why would you affirm other mental disorders?
Just to be clear.
Normal people don't think software projects should be like religious organizations or political clubs because making them such does nothing but harm the software.
People keep trying to frame it like the ban was strictly for past actions from years ago, which I find disingenuous at worst and gullible at best.
If you're that upset about someone publishing a supposedly formal email that you sent, perhaps you should consider why that is instead of just knee-jerk banning the person to protect yourself.
The email said it wasn't up for discussion.
Have a nice day, neonsunset.
Already such flimsy material reasons to use or contribute to FOSS instead of using often better proprietary software. When you're endorsing the philosophy of reddit mod types by using FOSS and will get banned from contributing for being sane the negatives start to outweigh the positives
Some people turn their pronouns into their personality, and it's effing annoying. IMO it's perfectly fine to make fun of such people. Being trans doesn't protect them from being made fun of, nor does it make the person making the joke a transphobic.
It'll be wild to look back on all this when the spell finally breaks. Do you remember that one time people lost their shit over pronouns?
Changing someone's pronouns without their permissions seems like least of their offenses.
Hyprland discord appears to be a cesspool and one fermented by Vaxry himself, trans hate or otherwise. Now some people are saying - they have improved (and others are saying they have not). But reading his blog posts and seeing current status, I am not optimistic. I mean you can't make this stuff up. Why use a opensource discord community for sharing porn? (which likely have minors).
See: https://youtu.be/6i7a0cwyDDw
Remember to follow hyperlinks. They're there for a reason.
That's not hall monitoring, that's what the both of us think we're doing. Difference is one of us is shitting on people who would exclude others based on their identity, and the other is shitting on people who would shit on people who would shit on people based on their identity. You're not against shitting on people, you just want to be allowed to shit on other people without consequence. That's not how the world works. Talk shit, you get shown the door.
Want to reply to actual content or are you enjoying your nitpicking?
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/tscc3e5eujrsEeFN4/well-kept-...
You're right that you're not a hall monitor though. You're worse, actually, because you are actually committing a good deal of the harassment of real people yourself. You have in these very comments. You're bullying people away and pretending that this is better than preventing someone from entering their own well-kept garden.
They are still a transphobe though.
Only if you have nonsensical and sexist beliefs like 'a woman is anyone who says they are a woman' or 'a woman is anyone who performs femininity' or 'a woman is anyone feminine enough for me to be sexually attracted to them' would you think that these men are women.
The rest of us live in the real world where we understand women to be female and men to be male.
Wild accusations of transphobia are losing their impact, these days it means more to the accuser than the accused. It's like a Christian calling an atheist 'heretic'. No big deal really.
But uhhh... Lyude, Alyssa Rosenzweig, Xe Iaso, Gankra, Ariadne Conill, Sage Sharp... There are an absurd number of highly competent trans developers who have made profoundly significant contributions to the open source ecosystem and justly ascended to leadership positions because of it. Right-wing edgelords? Not so much. In fact without trans people you wouldn't have a computer to type your right-wing screeds on: Lynn Conway invented VLSI and Sophie Wilson co-developed the ARM architecture. So yes, ban the fascist edgelords. Nothing of value will be lost.
Hacker culture is queer, furry, neurodiverse. Deal with it.
This, unfortunately, is an extremely common occurrence throughout many dev communities today. Sadly, companies still have not learned the kind of damage it does to them and how inappropriate this kind of abuse is. Still someone should let RedHat representatives know that the account rights are being misused.
Perhaps creating a list is in order, so we know who to never give any rights to manage the community or participate across multiple projects?
Not agreeing with the CoC is one thing, but FDO is a community and it needs to be able to create a safe and inclusive space for its members.
I'm a FDO member and I see no problem here, the CoC existing and being upheld is a good thing.
Thinly and not so thinly veiled threats to another person to police their own, not related to FDO in any way, shape or form, community because it does not adhere to your political ideology sounds like a severe abuse of power to me.
No one is owed FDO membership.
FDO is a community, and having people be treated with respect is crucial for maintaining this community. Letting people with a history of not respecting others be a part of that community is a problem, even if that behavior was displayed elsewhere.
I don't remember since when "bowing down to threats" is adhering to CoC and "openly threatening someone over resolved conflicts under the suspicion of wrongthink" was "respectful behavior from community representatives".
Either way, it is always "we're just policing the bad people" until the bad person is you.
It doesn't address the contents of this particular incident, rather it alludes to vague and nice-sounding moral principles thereby brushing off the whole specific issue. It is interesting, because by staying general the author gets to shrink from taking the responsibility of giving their actual opinion on the specific incident itself.
- Vaxry is obviously a transphobe - Many good FOSS developers are trans - Giving vaxry a space is likely to drive off many more good FOSS developers - Therefore it's better for the project if we don't.
Have you? Because from my read, it was Vaxry and the people he condoned on the Hyprland Discord who exhibited the concerning behavior. Lyude was enforcing the code of conduct as written, as is her job to do as a code of conduct committee member.
And it wasn't just her. The entire committee agreed that Vaxry's behavior was problematic. If anything, Lyude was the committee member most likely to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Honestly, if you are "concerned in regards to the state of FDO and Red Hat" over a legitimate code of conduct enforcement measure against a person known to be toxic, I'd say that's right up there with blathering about "ethics in game journalism" as a proxy for being the sort of asshole who should be preemptively banned.
Drew's response at https://drewdevault.com/2024/04/09/2024-04-09-FDO-conduct-en... comes across as a more complete telling of the situation.
What the heck is this plea? It's like something a Mormon would say to their ex-Mormon "friend".
I understand person is a board member of conduct group for FDO. But using the redhat email is definitely a 1990s power move.
If RH or IBM have no association, then this is likely grounds for punishment or sudden dismissal. Even if the RH guy is “right”.
Whole situation smells to me.