Not agreeing with the CoC is one thing, but FDO is a community and it needs to be able to create a safe and inclusive space for its members.
I'm a FDO member and I see no problem here, the CoC existing and being upheld is a good thing.
Thinly and not so thinly veiled threats to another person to police their own, not related to FDO in any way, shape or form, community because it does not adhere to your political ideology sounds like a severe abuse of power to me.
No one is owed FDO membership.
FDO is a community, and having people be treated with respect is crucial for maintaining this community. Letting people with a history of not respecting others be a part of that community is a problem, even if that behavior was displayed elsewhere.
I don't remember since when "bowing down to threats" is adhering to CoC and "openly threatening someone over resolved conflicts under the suspicion of wrongthink" was "respectful behavior from community representatives".
Either way, it is always "we're just policing the bad people" until the bad person is you.
It doesn't address the contents of this particular incident, rather it alludes to vague and nice-sounding moral principles thereby brushing off the whole specific issue. It is interesting, because by staying general the author gets to shrink from taking the responsibility of giving their actual opinion on the specific incident itself.
- Vaxry is obviously a transphobe - Many good FOSS developers are trans - Giving vaxry a space is likely to drive off many more good FOSS developers - Therefore it's better for the project if we don't.
Have you? Because from my read, it was Vaxry and the people he condoned on the Hyprland Discord who exhibited the concerning behavior. Lyude was enforcing the code of conduct as written, as is her job to do as a code of conduct committee member.
And it wasn't just her. The entire committee agreed that Vaxry's behavior was problematic. If anything, Lyude was the committee member most likely to give him the benefit of the doubt.
Honestly, if you are "concerned in regards to the state of FDO and Red Hat" over a legitimate code of conduct enforcement measure against a person known to be toxic, I'd say that's right up there with blathering about "ethics in game journalism" as a proxy for being the sort of asshole who should be preemptively banned.
Drew's response at https://drewdevault.com/2024/04/09/2024-04-09-FDO-conduct-en... comes across as a more complete telling of the situation.
What the heck is this plea? It's like something a Mormon would say to their ex-Mormon "friend".
This, unfortunately, is an extremely common occurrence throughout many dev communities today. Sadly, companies still have not learned the kind of damage it does to them and how inappropriate this kind of abuse is. Still someone should let RedHat representatives know that the account rights are being misused.
Perhaps creating a list is in order, so we know who to never give any rights to manage the community or participate across multiple projects?