News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by smugma on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:40PM (#39911163)
Uniqlo (in Japan and at least in SF) has a cool checkout method.

You drop your clothes into a big bin (I’ve always done it one piece at a time, didn’t think to do all at once) and it adds up all your items. I’ve used this maybe 8 times, 100% accurate so far.

Not sure how it works but I guessed RFID and quick Google appears to confirm:

https://www.wsj.com/articles/uniqlos-parent-company-bets-big...

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by awelxtr on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:10PM (#39911397)
Self checkout systems based on RFID are very convenient, quick and quite accurate compared to self checkout on grocery stores'l. The main problem on groceries is that the tags are expensive compared to the product (tags prices are in the order of tens of cents depending on manufacturer and size)

Disclaimer: I work on a RFID reader manufacturing company

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by parhamn on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:36PM (#39911592)
Any ideas whats stopping it from becoming much cheaper? RFIDs on everything seem like a good move in the robotics age.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by kjkjadksj on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:56PM (#39911757)
Seems like a lot of ewaste to me for marginal convenience otoh
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by pcchristie on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @11:08PM (#39913237)
Agreed. It would be cool if you could recycle them then and there for re-use.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by teruakohatu on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:16AM (#39913551)
There has been at least one study on just this question

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/350413738_A_Model_o...

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by bbarnett on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:56PM (#39911758)
I don't want rfid tags in my apples, and putting them on the outside of each one seems costly.

And things like onions have a loose outer skin, which falls off. And grocery store clerks peel the outside (wilting) leaves off of things like local lettuce daily.

Seems like rfid on groceries would be hard for fresh produce, and we don't need everything wrapped in plastic.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by tempest_ on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @09:59PM (#39912865)
This is letting the perfect be the enemy of the good.

Sure an apple or a squash is hard to track, but a large (probably a majority) of a modern grocery stores selection is prepackaged goods.

It it is a lot easier to run a veggienet or whatever on a small subset of the goods purchased.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by ianstormtaylor on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:26AM (#39913592)
Some would argue that trying to eliminate self or manual checkouts from groceries stores is letting the perfect be the enemy of good.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by awelxtr on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:09AM (#39913796)
You won't have it anyway. An rfid tag tag placed on any conductor (apples are conductors because of their water content) 'detunes' the tag and makes it impossible to read
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by SkyPuncher on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @09:19PM (#39912652)
It’s not very expensive to being with, but it’s magnitudes more expensive than a print tag. Print is either free (a package being printed anyways) or extremely cheap (sticker).

Materials alone provide a huge challenge.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by awelxtr on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:12AM (#39913812)
I forgot to add that rfid tags placed on conductors are hard to read so food is a specially hard product to work with
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by mike_d on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:12AM (#39913810)
It is almost here. Computer vision combined with some secret sauce that is cheaper than RFID that Walmart is asking supplier to implement.

https://kioskindustry.org/walmart-self-checkout/

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by awelxtr on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:08AM (#39914145)
This doen't solve real time inventory. RFID does, also neither helps with EAS which RFID does'
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by mike_d on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @03:13AM (#39914465)
Some of my super smart colleagues solved real time inventory with big data within a small enough margin of error that Walmart scrapped the shelf scanning robots that were being deployed.

EAS is a purely psychological deterrent, for liability reasons stores can't really do much when it goes off. As more and more shrink is the result of ORC, RFID will have a place but money is better spent on alternative technologies like facial recognition and ALPR.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by chrisbolt on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:34AM (#39914277)
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by a_random_canuck on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:33PM (#39911560)
As far as I can tell, every Uniqlo has this. And you’re right, this is by far the best checkout experience. It’s what Amazon wishes they’d built.

I can’t imagine there’s that much untapped profit in the grocery business that Amazon could turn a profit with such an expensive and unreliable mess like Just Walk Out and I find it’s so typical Amazon to find out that the man behind the curtain is actually a bunch of offshore workers in India.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by rgmerk on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:03PM (#39911336)
It’s been discussed before on HN:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38715111

Unlikely to work for groceries given the costs of RFID tags, I imagine.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by colinng on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:14PM (#39911426)
If we had a better Blue Bin system it might work. Remove tags at home and place in compartment of Blue Bin, and at the recycling centre they get sorted out and sent back to the retailers.

But if we really could scale RFID tag production down to 1 cent each, then we’d likely just throw them out. Not that I’m a fan of throwing away silicon…

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by Iulioh on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:23PM (#39911492)
I mean, they cost 5-10c

Still more than printed paper but the cost is not astronomical. Some sellers on Alibaba even advertise 3c cad

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by madeofpalk on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:38PM (#39911601)
Orders of magnitude more than existing barcodes which are practically free due to being printed on the packaging. A 10c RFID tag would be 10% of the cost of many products, which im sure is unacceptable to grocery stores which I can't imagine have great margins.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by manquer on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @07:44PM (#39912057)
The wages of the scanning staff is a cost to be considered on the side .

At even 10c a tag , it is equivalent to one person scanning 200 items a hour (assuming $20/hour wages) .

Factoring in time to bag and do a cash/card/coupon transaction etc a retail employee is not doing more than 500 or maybe 1000 items a hour .

A cost of 2c is definitely close to economic feasibility if 10c is not

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by clintonb on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:30AM (#39913914)
Retail employees do more than checkout. You’ll still need them to stock, do customer support, clean, and more.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by manquer on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:11AM (#39914161)
I obviously didn’t mean all employees ,only the employees who are doing the check out .

I am not saying RFID will eliminate employees in retail , just that there is cost to not having RFID too, we should only see the diff as the cost of the tech not absolute numbers

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by clintonb on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:39AM (#39914300)
I understand, and what I am saying is that it is rare to have retail employees that _only_ do checkout. Nearly everyone performs multiple roles. Eliminating checkout will reduce the overall workload, but won't necessarily reduce headcount, or enough headcount to offset the cost of RFID tags.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @04:36AM (#39914889)
> it is rare to have retail employees that _only_ do checkout

Why is that relevant?

If 5 employees spend 20% of their combined time on checkout, and you get rid of checkout, you can go down to 4 employees, can't you? Why does the exact distribution matter? You'll still have a healthy variety of tasks to spread among those employees.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by filoleg on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @07:05PM (#39911809)
> A 10c RFID tag would be 10% of the cost of many products, which im sure is unacceptable to grocery stores which I can't imagine have great margins.

If the store decides to eat the cost of those? Sure, I can buy that logic.

However, I don't see stores being unable to just raise the price of items by 10c without much pushback, which would eliminate that issue with the profit margin entirely (since the cost of it is offloaded to the customer).

I, personally, would love to be able to pay just 10c extra per item, if it meant that I can have a checkout experience similar to that of Uniqlo.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by TheKidCoder on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:57PM (#39913177)
The tech in store is powered by RADAR (https://goradar.com) - next gen RFID sensor that can work with lower cost antennas. Still unlikely to ever get to unit economics that work for groceries, but really exciting what this team has created.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by gambiting on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:55PM (#39911282)
Decathlon in the UK has the same thing. You just drop everything in a bin near a till and it "magically" knows what you've put in.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by browningstreet on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:45PM (#39911197)
My local library does the same thing (books not clothes, glass surface not bin).
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by davidhunter on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @07:21PM (#39911930)
Did anyone else check each item manually one-by-one to ensure that the system was accurate?
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by dyim on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:48PM (#39911218)
The one by Barclays (in NYC) has the same thing! It's the best self-checkout experience I've had.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by pembrook on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:48PM (#39911217)
I'm pretty sure this is global, have experienced it at all their locations throughout Europe as well.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by dahdum on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:05PM (#39911360)
> Uniqlo (in Japan and at least in SF) has a cool checkout method.

Saw this in the Honolulu location and was similarly impressed. It's got to be pretty close to a theoretical minimum in check out speed, while requiring no labor and no accounts.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by none_to_remain on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @07:36PM (#39912019)
I have been able to dump about 7-8 items in there at once
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by kungito on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:50PM (#39911237)
Decathlon has the same
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by Iulioh on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @06:18PM (#39911462)
Decathlon does it but it's a little harder to implement in a grocery store.

You need to basically have custom packaging so the tags are not easily swappable and the RFID tag is not free too, it could really add up for small price items.

The maybe e-waste problem? I'm not really familiar with how much of a problem this really is but on a grocery store size it could add up

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by mathgeek on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @05:55PM (#39911281)
Uniqlo in Orlando also does this. Wonderful system.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by unscaled on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @08:43PM (#39912452)
Uniqlo checkout experience is really how self-checkout should be look like, but unfortunately relies on controlling the manufacturing of all products to implement efficiently.

The closest thing I've seen in a convenience store, was a fully automated 7-Eleven that I ran across in Taipei last year. It seems to rely on smart shelves[1], rather than just product video recognition. This could work for most types of groceries.

[1] https://www.retail-insight-network.com/news/7-eleven-itri-st...

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by rusticpenn on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @04:03AM (#39914727)
I have had the same experience at Zara which has cloths from different manufacturers.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by anshumankmr on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:11PM (#39912924)
Decathlon (a sports brand) has this thing too.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by getToTheChopin on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:11PM (#39912926)
Decathlon stores have the same self-checkout experience. Worked flawlessly the few times I've used it.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by prmoustache on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:29AM (#39915163)
I've had a few times when I bought lots of small items and it missed a few of them. Once, they were recognized when I moved stuff in the bin, another time I made sure I didn't move anything before paying and it worked in my favor.
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by hackernewds on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:19AM (#39913847)
This exists in most UNIQLOs it's the same mechanism through which the alarm goes off when someone attempts to steal things with the magnetic RFID attached.

It's borderline ancient tech. So why is it not applied everywhere? Because stores would rather have you line up and buy stuff from the "impulse aisle" and tip or donate at their PoS (higher rates with an employee glaring at your selection)

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by clintonb on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:28AM (#39913896)
> So why is it not applied everywhere?

RFID tags are expensive compared to printing barcodes. The volume of products moved in a grocery store is far larger than that of a clothing store like Uniqlo.

Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by dgellow on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:43AM (#39914329)
Decathlon in Europe does this too
Re:Amazon Ditches 'Just Walk Out' Checkouts at Its Grocery S... by tacocataco on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:39PM (#39919617)
Some thrift stores let you buy clothes by the pound here in the US. There are always the same people picking out stuff I swear. Probably picking stuff to resell.