News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by lisper on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:30AM (#39701587)
I think this is terrific. It's high time the indigenous people reclaimed their sovereignty. The idea that "When you’re building 30, 40-storey high rises out of concrete, there’s a big gap between that and an Indigenous way of building" is just ridiculous. Who the fuck are you, white man, to say what is and is not consistent with an "Indigenous way of building"? You aren't living the same lifestyle and building the same buildings that your ancestors were hundreds of years ago, why should they? I say: more power to the (Indigenous) people!

(P.S.: I'm a white guy.)

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by stavros on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:30AM (#39701874)
It was a woman, actually. Your point is valid, I just don't like how "white man" has become a slur.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by badcppdev on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:42AM (#39701920)
I think the quote is from a white man called Gordon Price.

Full quote to assist you.

"In 2022, Gordon Price, a prominent Vancouver urban planner and a former city councillor, told Gitxsan reporter Angela Sterritt, “When you’re building 30, 40-storey high rises out of concrete, there’s a big gap between that and an Indigenous way of building."

"White man" can be used in that form when the white man appears to be telling a different culture what they can or cannot do or be.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by chrisco255 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:01AM (#39702015)
Sure if you want to be racist. The shoe on the other foot, replace White man with Black man, Red man, etc and its clear that its racist.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ivan_gammel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:12AM (#39702080)
“White man” is not racist, it is a self-describing short term for Eurocentric supremacy and a quote from Kipling. As such it is not replaceable by Black/Red etc. Everyone can use it in such context as a metaphor, not as a racial reference.

Edit: previously my message included some poor choice of words, which I will keep here for history and an example of accidental bias: “White men are absolutely allowed to use it as a slur towards other white men.”

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by gambiting on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:41AM (#39702228)
>>White men are absolutely allowed to use it as a slur towards other white men.

What kind of nonsense is that, the mental gymnastics to not call it what it simply is - racism - is just unbelivable.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ivan_gammel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:52AM (#39702283)
Feel free to suggest another term for a person of European origin and Eurocentric education who is lecturing indigenous people on how to live. Modern discourse isn’t about physical characteristics at all, even it does have roots in old racial theory. It’s certain views, it’s identity and culture. If someone behaves like in Kipling’s poem, he is the white man, not because of his race, but because of his actions.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by gambiting on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:55AM (#39702301)
I'm not debating the original point - I'm commenting on the clearly quoted section which says what white men are allowed to call other white men.

Like, it really doesn't ring any bells of "something is not right here" when you read it?

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ivan_gammel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:00AM (#39702346)
Haha, now I got you and apologize for inaccurate choice of words. Those bells didn’t ring, as I’m not American and not native speaker. Of course, everyone can use it.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by williamcotton on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:44AM (#39703195)
Five year olds and internet commenters care about things being even-handed and fair.

The rest of the world either settles their matters or employs lawyers to do so for them. Most time settlement is a disappointing serving a crow, hence the glint of involving the courts. How much will that serving of crow cost?

Why do I bring this up? This “replace X with Y” is the ultimate form of an algebraic rhetoric that demands a fully balanced system of mathematical perfection as if this were a reasonable way to go about things.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by LunaSea on Saturday March 16, 2024 @05:22AM (#39724427)
Ironically, this is the most Twitter-logic garbage explanation I've seen in this thread.

Laws do impose parity so in fact it's not just some online rhetorical device.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:18AM (#39702111)
I disagree. It's an ad hominem point. Comments should focus on ideas. Race based commentary like this is a discredit to one's own argument and character.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by badcppdev on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:37AM (#39702202)
You could take the word fuck out of the original comment and it would still have the clear reasoning that Gordon Price as a white person should not be telling an indigenous group that what they want to do is not the "Indigenous way".

White person should not define "Indigenous way".

How else can we misinterpret this argument?

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by coldtea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:45AM (#39702248)
>White person should not define "Indigenous way"

Any person, white, black, asian, whatever, can however assess whether this development is in line with the indigenous tradition or something that might distort or endanger it.

Or do you think the same discussion doensn't happen within the indigenous community as well?

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by badcppdev on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:53AM (#39702290)
"indigenous tradition or something that might distort or endanger"

Are certain groups not allowed to change? Why use the word distort or endanger?

We aren't talking about the discussions inside the community. We are talking about people outside the community applying judgements to their decisions and actions.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by coldtea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:41AM (#39702594)
>Are certain groups not allowed to change?

Did I say that?

>Why use the word distort or endanger?

Because obviously some change can be distorting and/or endagering some things?

The fact that an individual or group is allowed to change doesn't mean each particular change is always for the better.

>We are talking about people outside the community applying judgements to their decisions and actions.

Yes, so? Do you think groups should only get judgements to their decisions and actions from within themselves?

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by itishappy on Thursday March 14, 2024 @12:26PM (#39705948)
Why is tradition relevant here? The indigenous community is a present day community, not a historical preservation society.

I disagree that we're all equal when it comes to defining what is and isn't "indigenous way."

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by BehindBlueEyes on Tuesday March 19, 2024 @11:13AM (#39756580)
Most outsiders lack the understanding of what indigenous way of life entails beyond stereotypes, and are therefor poor judges. Besides, indigenous culture has been distorted and endangered by oppresssion, the least we can do as outsiders is let them reclaim and rebuilt their traditions how they want it.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ethanbond on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:36AM (#39702198)
Race: Famously irrelevant to the whole tribal lands/indigenous rights topic
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by coldtea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:43AM (#39702240)
It's irrelevant to "does this follow indigenous tradition or violate it" point, which is the point discussed in the subthread - not tribal lands/indigenous rights.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by badcppdev on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:49AM (#39702270)
Why would Indigenous people have to follow tradition? I believe it is racist (or sexist) to say that a group of people cannot do something because that is not something they've done in the past.

For Mr Gordon Price to imply that a group should not do something because it has not been done before is him trying to deny their agency.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by coldtea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:42AM (#39702605)
>Why would Indigenous people have to follow tradition?

They don't "have to". But they can break with it in a nice way or in a bad way.

Same way a culture can change their tradition in a respectful way or to replace it with McDonalds and Starbucks for example.

This is not confined to "indigenous people". The same critique can and does apply to any group.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @05:14PM (#39720784)
No one said they do. The article provides no background or context from which one could conclude an implication that "a group should not do something because it has not been done before." He didn't say that. The article attempts very poorly to imply that meaning. You've created a dummy to punch and you're punching it. Unfortunately this is all too common. It's called a straw man fallacy.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by dudeinjapan on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:04AM (#39702366)
The correct slur to use here is Honky.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by skywhopper on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:11AM (#39702417)
I wouldn’t call it a slur. To the extent it’s an effective insult, it’s due to centuries of behavior by white men. If someone uses “white man” to call out certain behavior, it might be worth their target considering why they got called out. Maybe sometimes it’s unfair to the white man to be called out, but often it isn’t. For folks who find it troublesome or disturbing to not receive the benefit of the doubt about their intentions as a white man, consider how much benefit of the doubt is given in everyday contexts to pretty much any individual who is not a white man.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by stavros on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:16AM (#39702447)
Aren't you worried about the consequences of supporting generalizations over a group from the actions of their members? I learned at an early age that that's not OK, but it seems to be changing again, as long as the target is in a specific group.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by soupbowl on Thursday March 14, 2024 @01:20PM (#39706602)
I wouldn’t call it a slur. To the extent it’s an effective insult, it’s due to centuries of behavior by black men. If someone uses “black man” to call out certain behavior, it might be worth their target considering why they got called out. Maybe sometimes it’s unfair to the black man to be called out, but often it isn’t. For folks who find it troublesome or disturbing to not receive the benefit of the doubt about their intentions as a black man, consider how much benefit of the doubt is given in everyday contexts to pretty much any individual who is not a black man.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by EnigmaFlare on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:40AM (#39701913)
Find out what you're complaining about before getting race-baited into hating someone. The context of his statement might have made it perfectly reasonable. This article is obviously trying to paint everyone and their dog as a racist so don't trust it to be open about the context.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by badcppdev on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:45AM (#39701933)
I think you need to provide some links with context because the article makes a compelling case that people are trying to block an indigenous group from exercising their agency.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:06AM (#39702037)
Do we know that it's not a small few wealthy deal makers selling the land out from under people that wanted to preserve it? I'm not Canadian, so I have no clue. But that would be my immediate suspicion based on experience in real estate and movies I saw on TV.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by badcppdev on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:24AM (#39702146)
I agree that's absolutely a possibility. Also not a Canadian. But I will point out that superficially there doesn't seem to be opposition to development on the land. The opposition appears to be based on what is being built rather than where.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by kareemm on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:00AM (#39702732)
I am Canadian and lived a literal stones throw from the site in question for 4 years.

The real issue is that Vancouver is full of NIMBYs who want sightlines, low density, and “character” preserved. It’s basically encoded into the zoning laws for the municipality. Those groups will use whatever tactics at hand to prevent density at a scale they don’t approve of from being built.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by EnigmaFlare on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:17PM (#39709090)
I couldn't find the context so, given the tone of the article, I think it's a safe assumption that the author isn't being charitable and is trying to mislead.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by FredPret on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:06AM (#39702804)
You’re so virtuous
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by verticalscaler on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:32AM (#39702175)
> Who the fuck are you, white man, to say what is and is not consistent with an "Indigenous way of building"?

Who the fuck are you, white man, to say "It's high time the indigenous people reclaimed their sovereignty"? You're foisting your notions of sovereignty and time unto them, which is racist.

P.S.: I'm indigenous ;)

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by refurb on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:07AM (#39702808)
How is sovereignty and time in any way subjective?
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by verticalscaler on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:32AM (#39704527)
According to CNN being on time and indeed, daylights savings time, are forms of white supremacy. Although prior to being informed of this all I saw when glancing at my wrist was Mickey Mouse. Did not occur to me the rat bastard was out to get me.

I suppose whether I am being rescued by my white saviors espousing this new age philosophy or tormented and infantilized is a subjective matter.

It is important for us to remember not to judge a man until you've walked three full moons in his moccasins. ;)

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by zmgsabst on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:38AM (#39701905)
That’s people’s objection to “woke” views on ethnicity:

You’ve returned to the world of racial essentialism, the most debunked form of racism, where you argue nonsense about what kinds of buildings people should make based on their ancestry. No matter how you dress it up in the language of civil rights, the racialized views promoted by the institutional left (eg, academia, media, and government) are built upon that racism — which we see articulated in your quote.

But if you touch grass, you’d know people consistently build with the best technology available to them — and have throughout history.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by mschuster91 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:53AM (#39701974)
> You’ve returned to the world of racial essentialism, the most debunked form of racism, where you argue nonsense about what kinds of buildings people should make based on their ancestry. No matter how you dress it up in the language of civil rights, the racialized views promoted by the institutional left (eg, academia, media, and government) are built upon that racism — which we see articulated in your quote.

If anything, the person you're replying to rejected this kind of crap, they argue (like the article) that it should be the right of the Indigenous Nations to determine on their own what they want to build on their own land.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:58AM (#39702000)
I think I missed the meaning of the quote.

Skyscrapers are not an indigenous lifestyle. I suppose that's not okay to bring up in this context?

If someone put skyscrapers on the last Hawaiian island I'd be pretty upset about it. The entire population of the Earth should be. Can't we leave one thing undeveloped?

But okay, maybe there is plenty of land to go around in Canada that looks the same as this land, so I could see that...

How does any of that relate to indigenous people using granted land to build them?

Does Canada have some law about that?

I guess I don't see why this quote has any bearing for or against the development. It feels entirely out of place in the article. Just seems like an unrelated fact.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by timmytokyo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:05AM (#39702030)
In a city completely inundated with skyscrapers, it's odd -- and maybe a bit telling -- that some people become concerned for the first time in their lives only once an indigenous nation decides to build a skyscraper.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by kareemm on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:03AM (#39702766)
There’s been tons of opposition to building up in Vancouver, especially outside of downtown. Opposition isn’t unique to indigenous builders.

What is unique is that nimbys have a new arsenal of tactics to use as to why this isn’t a good idea eg “concrete skyscrapers aren’t the indigenous way so you shouldn’t build your project.”

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:24AM (#39702147)
I'm not sure you understand my question. I don't see from the quote that there is any concern. Where are you drawing that from?
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by comeonbro on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:23PM (#39708536)
In a thread full of people with weird preconceptions talking past each-other, this is the most perfectly wrong statement anyone has made.

The people you're talking about would strangle this entire country to death (and have) before allowing a single 3-story building to be built outside of the small areas that were already been zoned for it 80 years ago.

The Canadian Indigenous identity issues tied up in this project are the only force that have ever been powerful enough to bludgeon them into submission, just this one time.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by timmytokyo on Friday March 15, 2024 @01:52PM (#39718631)
You're making my point. I was responding to this comment:

>Skyscrapers are not an indigenous lifestyle. I suppose that's not okay to bring up in this context?

If people are going to oppose this project, don't do it on the basis of some vaguely bigoted notion that "these skyscrapers don't match the indigenous lifestyle". As if that's the reason the project's opponents are opposing it. It's clearly a smokescreen being deployed because they actually dislike the project for NIMBY reasons (e.g., "it'll block my view", "it'll reduce the value of my nearby properties").

(Whether the commenter I'm responding to actually believes this is immaterial. The article quoted a local government official who basically said the same thing.)

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:32PM (#39721780)
Skyscrapers not being indigenous has no bearing on whether they should be built or not.

I think we all agree on that. Here's what's really bothering me.

How did you arrive at the conclusion that the quote is implication of opposition to this development? Aside from the author of the article not so subtly injecting that implication, with no context, there's literally nothing to indicate that.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:44AM (#39713408)
I get concerned when anyone builds a skyscraper. It's typically purported to increase density and thereby create affordable housing. What actually happens is that I still can't afford anything in the skyscrapers, even in non major metros, and I'm in the top 1% of earners. I guess affordable only applies to the top half of a percent?

Destroying land to build them, I don't care who's land, is typically in opposition to environmental efforts. So before you say it's not my business, stop and consider that this is everyone's business. And using minorities as a scapegoat through what might be an underhanded deal might be pretty disgusting.

Since I don't know which it is, I'm asking.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:59PM (#39720655)
Notice that asking questions is downvoted. Horrifying. Must be someone very rich that wants another skyscraper apartment that the rest of us can't afford, no matter how many lives they ruin.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by nejkbnek on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:07AM (#39702400)
A modern "Indigenous lifestyle" means a lot of things. There's no contradiction in Indigenous people wanting to preserve their historical traditions, crafts and practices while also adapting to the current state of the world. Most Native people in Canada live in cities now and face issues of racism and generational trauma from colonial government practices like Residential Schools and the 60s Scoop which sought to cut their connections to their culture.

Developing land like this is a way for the tribe to generate revenue and take care of their members, but it's also a way for them to have meaningful input into the development process. They don't have some responsibility to leave the land as a pristine untouched wilderness, they can choose to develop it in a way that aligns with their values.

I visited a museum in the North once where they were talking about preserving the practice of carving giant canoes, to travel south and trade with Europeans. It struck me how this practice was historical and important culturally, but it also arose out of colonial interactions in the past 500 years. Both can be true.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:28AM (#39713311)
I'm wondering if you were talking to someone else but I can't figure out who.

My question was pretty simple.

How are you guys (commenters) drawing a connection between what the author quoted, and the assumption that the person being quoted opposes the building project?

What context are you using to correlate those?

Here's a logic diagram to help. Assume P1 is true, since that's what he's saying:

P1: indigenous lifestyle is not skyscrapers.

P2: skyscrapers can be built by indigenous people.

C: indigenous people can't build skyscrapers

The above is nonsensical. Your conclusion is in direct opposition to the premise.

Introducing this person's quote to the article was totally irrelevant unless you're aware of some context that is missing from the story.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ivan_gammel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:18AM (#39702108)
>Can't we leave one thing undeveloped?

Sure. Undevelop your own land and that will solve the problem.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:21AM (#39702128)
I don't own the last Hawaiian island, but I'm thankful someone who does hasn't developed it.

If they did and then "undeveloped" it, that wouldn't much help. Right? The last island will have been destroyed for future generations to study and enjoy.

Not being Canadian, I have no clue what the context is. This might be the last of a unique piece of nature, or it could be the first acre of an endless desert. That context changes the meaning quite a bit, doesn't it?

I'm not Italian, but I'd be upset if Italians bulldozed Pompeii.

It's a world heritage site! Some things belong to everyone and are worth preserving.

I'll gladly "undevelop" and take compensation to move if a temple was discovered under my house.

So your comment has no meaning. I sure will "undevelop" my land, and since the law would force me, we can see that society as a whole had voted that I should, in certain cases.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ivan_gammel on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:37AM (#39702207)
It is simply not your business to tell disadvantaged people how they should exercise their rights. They have agency and can decide for themselves. If this means, some of the nature has to be sacrificed, that’s their business, not yours to decide.

If you care so much, undevelop your own land and restore the nature and the balance. Plant forests over your parking lots and golf courses, erase suburbia and embrace minimalist living. That is so simple.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:57AM (#39713474)
My property value is dependent on what happens to the neighborhood around me. It's literally my business. That makes the rest of your comment just ridiculous.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by ivan_gammel on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:44AM (#39714089)
It is unfortunate that you did not account for possible development in the neighborhood when you got your property and it is your problem, but not your business. Also it is fun that your protection of nature in the end is just protection of privilege.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @07:51AM (#39714494)
I didn't say that. You did. Take responsibility for your own thoughts. Improve your reading comprehension. I'm not so smart as to be impossible to interpret. What does it say about you if you are gaining understanding that is missing from my comments? It says you're a zealot and a liar and more interested in conflict than understanding. Go back. Read again. Read with interest. Otherwise this conversation is truly not your business. Is it?
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by downut on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:35AM (#39702196)
If the island is privately owned then hard to see how "future generations" will be able to study and enjoy it. Maybe, but probably not, eh? That's the point of it being privately owned. Now if the State of Hawaii were to assert eminent domain, acquire it at fair market value, and then turn it into public park lands as designated wilderness, well that might work for your intent, I think.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @05:00AM (#39713500)
The island is owned by the natives. And it's still a tragedy to the entire world if they decide to put skyscrapers on it. It's the last bit of untouched wilderness in a unique ecosystem.

This story doesn't make a case for not telling people what to do. It makes a case for not trusting natives to protect the wilderness.

Or maybe not. I don't have context. I am asking a question.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by faeriechangling on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:13AM (#39705059)
Sure skyscrapers are an indigenous lifestyle. They build them, invest in them, live in them. Do you think indigenous people in 2024 are going to all go fish for salmon and live in teepee’s?

I remember on TV once this older indigenous guy promoting natural resource development he thought would create indigenous jobs going on about “Back in the old times, my people hunted the buffalo. Now my people hunt a new buffalo, called the loonie”

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @04:13AM (#39713231)
Obviously I don't think that. You didn't read my comment before replying.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by sgt on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:47AM (#39701948)
You're being downvoted because of statements like "Who the fuck are you, white man"

What if you said (in a different setting, where it would technically make sense): "Who the fuck are you, eskimo?"

I bet you wouldn't, because you've been programmed by woke media.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by coldtea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:41AM (#39702229)
>Who the fuck are you, white man, to say what is and is not consistent with an "Indigenous way of building"?

A person univolved with the colonization of Canada, not even from there or living there, that still believes that?

>You aren't living the same lifestyle and building the same buildings that your ancestors were hundreds of years ago

And that's bad in a lot of ways too. Not all modernization is for the better. It can turn a vibrant community into a gentrified Starbucks shitscape, for example.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by astrange on Friday March 15, 2024 @03:55PM (#39719985)
Gentrification has nothing to do with Starbucks. Gentrification is caused by blocking infill development.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by trallnag on Thursday March 14, 2024 @08:43AM (#39703185)
Unhinged
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by faeriechangling on Thursday March 14, 2024 @11:10AM (#39705026)
Hating/liking this project is going to fall on age lines more than racial ones, the age demo of hacker news is likely to almost universally LOVE this project.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by lisper on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:58PM (#39709975)
Not only am I a white guy, I'm an old white guy. (I'm 59.) Even worse, I'm rich too, so I am solidly in the demographic of the person I was quoting. But despite the fact that I am a rich old white guy, I don't consider rich old white guys to be my tribe. I look at the history of what rich old white guys have done (and in many cases are still doing) to racial minorities and it fills me with deep shame that I am one of them.

So I genuinely love seeing racial minorities stand up for themselves. I particularly admire what the Maoris have accomplished in New Zealand. And I especially love it when it ends up annoying the rich old white guys that the racial minority is starting to do the exact same thing that the rich old white guys have been doing for centuries. Seeing the irony and lack of self awareness lets me tell myself that no, I am not one them, despite the fact that I look like them.

BTW, the flip side of that is, "I am one of them despite the fact that I don't look like them." Which, it seems to me, is what we ought to be striving for.