What is unique is that nimbys have a new arsenal of tactics to use as to why this isn’t a good idea eg “concrete skyscrapers aren’t the indigenous way so you shouldn’t build your project.”
The people you're talking about would strangle this entire country to death (and have) before allowing a single 3-story building to be built outside of the small areas that were already been zoned for it 80 years ago.
The Canadian Indigenous identity issues tied up in this project are the only force that have ever been powerful enough to bludgeon them into submission, just this one time.
>Skyscrapers are not an indigenous lifestyle. I suppose that's not okay to bring up in this context?
If people are going to oppose this project, don't do it on the basis of some vaguely bigoted notion that "these skyscrapers don't match the indigenous lifestyle". As if that's the reason the project's opponents are opposing it. It's clearly a smokescreen being deployed because they actually dislike the project for NIMBY reasons (e.g., "it'll block my view", "it'll reduce the value of my nearby properties").
(Whether the commenter I'm responding to actually believes this is immaterial. The article quoted a local government official who basically said the same thing.)
I think we all agree on that. Here's what's really bothering me.
How did you arrive at the conclusion that the quote is implication of opposition to this development? Aside from the author of the article not so subtly injecting that implication, with no context, there's literally nothing to indicate that.
Destroying land to build them, I don't care who's land, is typically in opposition to environmental efforts. So before you say it's not my business, stop and consider that this is everyone's business. And using minorities as a scapegoat through what might be an underhanded deal might be pretty disgusting.
Since I don't know which it is, I'm asking.
Developing land like this is a way for the tribe to generate revenue and take care of their members, but it's also a way for them to have meaningful input into the development process. They don't have some responsibility to leave the land as a pristine untouched wilderness, they can choose to develop it in a way that aligns with their values.
I visited a museum in the North once where they were talking about preserving the practice of carving giant canoes, to travel south and trade with Europeans. It struck me how this practice was historical and important culturally, but it also arose out of colonial interactions in the past 500 years. Both can be true.
My question was pretty simple.
How are you guys (commenters) drawing a connection between what the author quoted, and the assumption that the person being quoted opposes the building project?
What context are you using to correlate those?
Here's a logic diagram to help. Assume P1 is true, since that's what he's saying:
P1: indigenous lifestyle is not skyscrapers.
P2: skyscrapers can be built by indigenous people.
C: indigenous people can't build skyscrapers
The above is nonsensical. Your conclusion is in direct opposition to the premise.
Introducing this person's quote to the article was totally irrelevant unless you're aware of some context that is missing from the story.
Sure. Undevelop your own land and that will solve the problem.
If they did and then "undeveloped" it, that wouldn't much help. Right? The last island will have been destroyed for future generations to study and enjoy.
Not being Canadian, I have no clue what the context is. This might be the last of a unique piece of nature, or it could be the first acre of an endless desert. That context changes the meaning quite a bit, doesn't it?
I'm not Italian, but I'd be upset if Italians bulldozed Pompeii.
It's a world heritage site! Some things belong to everyone and are worth preserving.
I'll gladly "undevelop" and take compensation to move if a temple was discovered under my house.
So your comment has no meaning. I sure will "undevelop" my land, and since the law would force me, we can see that society as a whole had voted that I should, in certain cases.
If you care so much, undevelop your own land and restore the nature and the balance. Plant forests over your parking lots and golf courses, erase suburbia and embrace minimalist living. That is so simple.
This story doesn't make a case for not telling people what to do. It makes a case for not trusting natives to protect the wilderness.
Or maybe not. I don't have context. I am asking a question.
I remember on TV once this older indigenous guy promoting natural resource development he thought would create indigenous jobs going on about “Back in the old times, my people hunted the buffalo. Now my people hunt a new buffalo, called the loonie”
Skyscrapers are not an indigenous lifestyle. I suppose that's not okay to bring up in this context?
If someone put skyscrapers on the last Hawaiian island I'd be pretty upset about it. The entire population of the Earth should be. Can't we leave one thing undeveloped?
But okay, maybe there is plenty of land to go around in Canada that looks the same as this land, so I could see that...
How does any of that relate to indigenous people using granted land to build them?
Does Canada have some law about that?
I guess I don't see why this quote has any bearing for or against the development. It feels entirely out of place in the article. Just seems like an unrelated fact.