Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development
by coldtea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:43AM
(#39702240)
It's irrelevant to "does this follow indigenous tradition or violate it" point, which is the point discussed in the subthread - not tribal lands/indigenous rights.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Why would Indigenous people have to follow tradition? I believe it is racist (or sexist) to say that a group of people cannot do something because that is not something they've done in the past.
For Mr Gordon Price to imply that a group should not do something because it has not been done before is him trying to deny their agency.
>Why would Indigenous people have to follow tradition?
They don't "have to". But they can break with it in a nice way or in a bad way.
Same way a culture can change their tradition in a respectful way or to replace it with McDonalds and Starbucks for example.
This is not confined to "indigenous people". The same critique can and does apply to any group.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development
by trimethylpurine on Friday March 15, 2024 @05:14PM
(#39720784)
No one said they do. The article provides no background or context from which one could conclude an implication that "a group should not do something because it has not been done before." He didn't say that. The article attempts very poorly to imply that meaning. You've created a dummy to punch and you're punching it. Unfortunately this is all too common. It's called a straw man fallacy.