"In the United States, it is widely accepted that economically disadvantaged and minority populations share a disproportionate burden of air pollution exposure and risk (26,27). A growing body of evidence demonstrates that minority populations and persons of lower socioeconomic status experience higher residential exposure to traffic and traffic-related air pollution than nonminorities and persons of higher socioeconomic status (5,28–31). Two recent studies have confirmed that these racial/ethnic and socioeconomic disparities also exist on a national scale (32,33)."
Setting aside race, to me it seems like "economically disadvantaged populations share a disproportionate burden of traffic-related air pollution exposure" makes this pretty clear. <shrug>
Even into the 1960s wealthy black people were prevented from buying and living in the 'good' parts of even northern US cities.
[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/apr/04/new-york-sou...
I suppose that there likely are small numbers of people living far outside of cities and away from traffic, like up in the mountains of Appalachia or living off the grid in tents or in communes deep in forests, who are poorer than people you'd typically find in urban areas, but it's still the poor in the US who are dealing with the worst of the harms traffic causes compared to the better off/wealthy. They're also the least able to mitigate those harms or deal with the fallout caused by them.
Density doesn't equal exposure.
If people really cared about this, they'd demand train-based public transport instead (no tires! fully electric! self-driving too!), or at very least limits on car weight regardless of the engine.
A mix of solutions will be needed to fix the variety of different and unique problems that exist.
Have you used bus systems in the US? Even in cities that have made a large investment in bus service, it can be a challenge.
An amazing claim.
My EV cost $13k and was fairly new at purchase.
This is especially a problem in enclosed spaces with limited ventilation: on parts of the London Underground, air pollution in the tunnels can be many times worse than on the streets above.
EVs aren’t going to be the savior of climate change. They do some things better than ICE cars, but do some things worse. Denying those worse things is just putting your fingers in your ears.
Having said this, if you can go 70k+ miles with the same brake pads, you could likely go much further than that if the car had regenerative braking.
Though to be fair, the tires on my previous ICE vehicle only lasted about 30,000 miles before they needed to be replaced, OEM car tires are often not long lasting. Brake fluid is due to be flushed next year, but not due to use of the brakes, just due to time.
https://www.fox5atlanta.com/news/atlanta-magnet-man-alex-ben...
That 20K set of tires had a slow leak from a nail that was patched incompletely. On the new set I had to replace two using the hazard insurance I purchased after three months and two thousand miles. I expect to use the insurance again.
I now have an EV with sport summer tires. They’re at 5K miles and have a screw embedded in one tire since about 400 miles. That tire was deemed to be safe and best left alone as it’s presumed to be running through a rubber block only. I’m just running it until it goes flat assuming it doesn’t manage to survive its whole expected life span.
Realistically I’ll end up running something else over this spring once construction gets into full swing.
Probably accurate if you exclude the brakes and ignore the fact that removing an ICE engine from consideration also removes nearly all the tricky bits that wear out on an ICE car.
What EV’s produce more of is tire particulates due to weight.
PS: And now the post says tires.
I thought the post had changed, but I wasn't 100%
Some people of course drive their EVs aggressively and wear out the tires faster. But that's true if you have a muscle car too. Doing donuts in the parking lot just wears out your tires. And if you are in Germany and like seeing how fast your car can go regularly that also wears out your tires. The driving style is a much bigger factor than the weight of the car.
But otherwise the numbers are about the same for ice cars and evs in terms of frequency of needing tire replacements. For most people the novelty of abusing their tires wears of quickly.
And because most EVs use regenerative braking, the main issue with the brakes in EVs is that they are used so infrequently that they need to be replaced because of corrosion issues. You actually need to use the brakes once in a while to keep them clean and functioning apparently.
In the case of brake dust specifically, presumably electric cars are worse because they're quite a bit heavier than ICE cars.
This counts even for hybrids though. A friend of mine had to replace his brakes after over 10 years and 180,000km on his Prius for the first time. Not because the brake pads were used up, but because the brake rotors started to rust too much from not being used.
Of course if you're one of those people that floor it and hard brake at every stop light, this doesn't work, but for most cars it works really well.
Electric car use regenerative braking. Yes they're heavier but their brakes barely get used...
They only get used at very low speed to bring the vehicle to a stop (low energy), or in case of emergency braking.
I might never replace the pads.
I tried it a few times, thought it was a gimmick and now I just use gas or brake.
I’d be careful with assuming that. A lot of consumables are imported directly from China, and the cost of car maintenance can be eye-watering, so it’s exactly the type of part I’d expect to be procured as cheaply as possible.
People care about the brand of tyres on their car, I don’t even know of any brake pad brands.
OTOH I don't think most people care about tires either.
On the other hand, EVs unfortunately pollute more with tire particles (thanks to both higher torque - especially from 0 - and higher average mass).
We have anecdotes of Tesla owners saying they go through tires more often. But I’ve also heard car fleet owners with both EVs and ICE saying they see no difference between them.
So I’m inclined to think this is entirely dependent on the specific EV. You can get an EV without significantly more weight than an equivalent ICE, and you can drive them in ECO mode where the torque curve is extremely gentle. I don’t see any reason why you’d have more tire particles in that scenario.
I think there are pathways to have less tire wear on EVs than with today’s ICE vehicles. Batteries with higher energy density would obviously help, but I think there are things you could do with the accurate control you have over the torque on the wheels, or making true all wheel drive with torque vectoring more common.
I wonder how much the higher torque of EVs is a real issue? Although they have the potential to do more aggressive acceleration and produce more tyre pollution, the Teslas I see leaving traffic stops seem to be accelerating the same as ICEs.
As the parent comment said - but I was questioning about whether increased torque has an actual impact on tyre wear.
(Certainly when I was young and dumb my clutch wore more when I went dashing about).
In Dubai prime real estate is along the major highway Sheik Zayed Road. It’s funny how these things can be cultural.
Some of the reason why poor areas in the US are around highways and busy streets have to do with the history of redlining (https://phys.org/news/2024-02-highways-historically-redlined...). Even today when a city wants to build a loud/smelly/polluting highway or a factory or a landfill or a sewer treatment plant it's the poorest areas that are the least able to fight back, and putting them in the areas where poor people are will mean the least amount of inconvenience for the wealthy who often live far away from those neighborhoods. After a source of pollution is in place, very few people want to move in right next to it, so any houses there tend to be inexpensive and may be the only housing poor people can afford which further concentrates them into those areas.
Driving up SZ road, all you see are tons of shitty retailers and car dealerships. Trust me, wealthy people especially are not living next to it.
It’s only Al Quoz that is car dealerships. But on both sides of Al Quoz you find high-end, high rise
Some of the most expensive houses in my neighbourhood are the closest to the highway. I just tried to check, but none of them are for sale right now. Traffic only decreases four hours at night but it never really stops. Only the noise is a big no-no.
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kontrollierte_Wohnrauml%C3%BCf...
A HEPA filter must remove at least 99.97% of aerosols 0.3μm in diameter. A filter which removed 99% and blows air 1% faster will remove just as much, or one which removes 50% and blows air twice as fast.
For recirculating air, all of those accomplish the same thing. Some of those have much higher noise, running costs, and general upkeep than others.
HEPA makes 100% sense for something where 100% of air passes through it. If you want an exhaust on a facility which handles biohazards, a vacuum cleaner kicking up dust, etc., sealed HEPA 100% is the way to go.
That's not what happens in a residential building, though. For that application, it's just bad engineering.
HEPA doesn't matter unless you have a sealed system. An open door or a cloth curtain means the 99.97% means nothing relative to 99%.
If you have two patients, they should both be isolated from each other. Which one gets the higher pressure, and which the lower?
The bottom line is that proximity to traffic is horrible for your health and your air quality. Electric cars can help with some of the problems but don't solve all of them. The people with the least amount of money end up having to move to apartments near highways and so they often suffer the worst impacts, but I've seen very nice and expensive apartments and houses very close to (or directly on) busy streets. Noise is usually the obvious and immediate consideration, and I doubt many people are aware of the risks they expose themselves and their families to just by opening a window in the summer.