News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by shp0ngle on Friday February 23, 2024 @03:48PM (#39485906)
I keep hearing about Scuttlebutt for a long time but haven't seen anyone actually using it? Why?

edit: hm, the recommended application on the website itself is ... from 2021, and the github of the app itself is archived now. And there is "bleeding edge" one ... from 2019.

OK I can see that there might be problems

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by evbogue on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:15PM (#39486196)
Oh Scuttlebot. Such a great idea, and for a time it actually worked. I haven't been actively developing with the codebase for years, but I believe the current status of the project is that there were too many code rewrites that simply broke things that previously worked at one point or another.

I tell people sometimes that I'd put together a team to do a retro Scuttlebot revival with a Patchwork-style app and of course git-ssb! If you're interested in this kind of project email or call me. Contacts are in my bio.

I'm mostly looking for devs who want to dive into an old Node.js codebase, who want to recapture the magic of the original protocol, and then upgrade all of the modules to modern standards. Maybe Deno or Bun even.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by black_puppydog on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:08AM (#39490479)
Not sure if you're aware of this but mycognocist has continued a rust implementation and it's really getting there in terms of "what one would need for a patchwork style application"

https://github.com/mycognosist/solar

I've also been toying with this, exactly for that kind of unapologetically desktop-only "classic" client. Suffice to say I'm also a bit butt(hehe)hurt about how the desktop client story worked out after manyverse decided dump the original protocol some years into the effort.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by earthwalker99 on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:11PM (#39486146)
>I keep hearing about Scuttlebutt for a long time but haven't seen anyone actually using it? Why?

It's called Scuttlebutt, meaning it can never be remotely popular enough to function as a worthwhile social network.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by todd3834 on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:27PM (#39486337)
I don’t think this should be downvoted. It’s a valid point and potential lesson for anyone thinking about reviving or doing something similar.

While this might not be the only issue I wouldn’t doubt that the name might prevent a larger audience.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by losvedir on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:34PM (#39486406)
Why? I think it's a fine name, better than most, because it's a normal English word that says exactly what it does / what it's for. You're not just saying that because the word happens to end in "butt" are you? Or am I missing something?
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by oli-g on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:10PM (#39487343)
> You're not just saying that because the word happens to end in "butt" are you?

They're saying precisely that and they're 100% right, and it seems you're missing a lot of things.

It's a social network. Its only value is in it having people using it and coming back.

Just try and imagine any person in your IRL circles (who's not on HN) actually using a social network with butt in its name. I seriously can't believe you see no issue there whatsoever. A teenager. A young artist. A YouTuber. "Follow me on TikTok, Instagram, Scuttlebutt and Poopypants". I dare you to find a creator willing to say these words.

Or if you just hang out with smart, like-minded tech-savvy middle-ages people who see past these things, then great, we have a new "social network" for smart, like-minded tech-savvy middle-aged people.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by jdougan on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:13PM (#39488194)
> we have a new "social network" for smart, like-minded tech-savvy middle-aged people.

Sounds great to me. The hard part is keeping the scammers away. If a ridiculous name can do that, I'm up for it.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by losvedir on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:31PM (#39488588)
I mean, I wouldn't expect problems if the thing were called "Buttercup" would you? Or what about "Button"? "Saturday" (which has "turd" in it)? Are there problems with a Harpoon ("poon") IPA?

Clearly the presence of a sequence of four silly letters isn't in and of itself disqualifying. Native speakers often won't even register the juvenile bit inside it.

My only surprise here is that "scuttlebutt" doesn't work that way for other native speakers. It must be just my dialect or circles then, because it's an ordinary word for me which subsumes the "butt" within it (like I'm certain "button" does for you). But I guess it's not universally like that and the word is odd or rare enough that it doesn't do the same for others.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by corobo on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:50PM (#39488693)
The butt is more noticeable because it's at the end of the word as a standalone syllable.

With your examples the butt sounds are mixed in so they don't stand out as much.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by tjpnz on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:13PM (#39489052)
"Follow me on Twitter to see my Wii reviews."

People will get used to it.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by filoleg on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:04PM (#39486705)
> I think it's a fine name, better than most, because it's a normal English word that says exactly what it does / what it's for

Just because the name says exactly what the product does and what it's for, that doesn't automatically mean it is good. In fact, imo it is bad in a lot of cases.

Do you think Instagram would have gotten as popular if it was named FlexGallery, or if Nextdoor was named SpreadRumorsActVaguelyRacistForum, or if Twitter/X was named PopularityContestShortMessagesAndBadNewsSourceSpaceWithSomePorn?

I personally would say "no" to all of those, and it isn't just because the names get unnecessarily long and ugly. McDonalds would never rename itself to Cheap Passable Fast Food Restaurant.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by simonw on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:00PM (#39487734)
Some things really can buck the trend - ChatGPT is a _terrible_ name but provided so much obvious utility that it managed to reach a large consumer market despite that.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by ziddoap on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:16PM (#39487833)
ChatGPT and Scuttlebutt are both bad names, sure, but in completely distinct ways.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rzzzt on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:53AM (#39490415)
FlexGallery could work... the rest are Java class names.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by filoleg on Sunday February 25, 2024 @01:18PM (#39503240)
Actually agreed about FlexGallery, now that I am thinking about it.

As for the rest, they just miss [...]Factory and [...]Controller prefixes, and then they truly would become typical Java classes.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by jrm4 on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:13PM (#39486831)
"Normal English Word" feels like a stretch. At least in the US, pretty obscure and kind of archaic sounding?
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by ziddoap on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:58PM (#39487230)
>it's a normal English word

I mean, it's an English word, for sure. I have never once in my many years heard someone actually say it seriously. Maybe a handful of times when someone was purposefully trying to be quirky.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by kstrauser on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:10PM (#39487797)
Weird. Maybe it's a regional thing. I've only heard it through the midwest and the west coast.

Also, all the freaking time when I was in the US Navy.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by samatman on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:35PM (#39487947)
The guy who started the project is a sailor, so that tracks.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by nine_k on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:07PM (#39486757)
A name that makes many of your friends smile ironically is not a name that would induce a network effect, except maybe in marginal communities ("bitards").

A name must not be even remotely silly, else it will be laughed out of the (already crowded) room.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by jrm4 on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:50PM (#39486561)
Upvoting because I'm also the guy who understands that, similarly, GIMP will never be big as it should be.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by RankingMember on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:17PM (#39487838)
Still waiting on non-destructive editing last I checked, which always seemed to be touted as "right around the corner" as much as a decade ago.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by oli-g on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:02PM (#39487264)
I wanted to hate on it, but I just downloaded the latest version and I see that after like 20 years, they finally realized that each tool window doesn't have to be a separate application.

Good for them, for once I might be able to try actually try it.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by BHSPitMonkey on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:12PM (#39488191)
I think single-window mode came as part of version 2.8, just shy of 12 years ago.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by smrq on Sunday February 25, 2024 @01:17PM (#39503232)
I guess the lesson here is that PR damage can be permanent.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by ziddoap on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:56PM (#39487212)
I have gotten some very strange looks from friends and coworkers when I have mentioned GIMP in passing.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by thatwasunusual on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:50PM (#39488059)
> GIMP will never be big as it should be.

But having something "photoshopped" is a bad thing. Interesting. :)

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:47PM (#39488392)
Yeah, the guy who renamed it to "Glimpse" is now worldwide famous for solving the only problem with the project. Designers are dropping Adobe Photoshop in droves and giving the project the complete recognition it rightfully deserved.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by foofie on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:42AM (#39490155)
Git is pretty popular,and github was bought for over 7 billion.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:18PM (#39486869)
Rumor has it, Microsoft balked away from a billion dollar acquisition of this source control and project management tool because they didn't want to be associated with a collaboration portal for gits.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by echelon on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:30PM (#39486976)
If you're good enough that your name doesn't hold you back, good for you.

As it stands, I turn my nose at stuff like Cockroach DB.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:52PM (#39487178)
I get not liking a name, but to pass judgement on the quality of a product/project based on its name alone seems like a complete midwit thing to do.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by oli-g on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:03PM (#39487281)
When it's a DB layer, sure.

When it's a social network?

"Hey guys, have you seen Dave's new post on Poopypants?"

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:59PM (#39487725)
Again, that's a total midwit dismissal.

Scuttlebutt has a context and a meaning behind it. People might hear it without knowing the context, think "that it's a weird name, why is it so?", and then judge whether they like it or not. But to just hear the name and claim that it is inappropriate/bad/not-to-be-used because it reminds you of something that has nothing to do with the original context is ridiculous.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by yownie on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:47PM (#39488038)
it's not ridiculous and countless FOSS projects will keep banging their head upon the wall forever till they actually learn it.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:37PM (#39488342)
Please name one FOSS project that has found its success after being renamed to something more "appropriate".
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by lukan on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:23AM (#39490059)
Codemonkey became codemirror. And it is now quite well established (in chrome dev tools for example).

But usually FOSS projects don't get renamed at all, or if they do the renaming causes so much drama that kills the project. So nothing changes, also not obscure design choices - and they remain niche.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:10AM (#39491234)
Was the name change motivated by general public rejection or branding issues?

Was it holding back mindshare growth?

Why greasemonkey" and "tampermonkey" didn't change their names?

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by lukan on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:04AM (#39491962)
You should probably ask the maintainer those questions. All I know he did made that decision at some point(before it took off) and he likely had a reason. Probably to be taken seriously, as he wants to live off his work. (I think he can)

And greasemonkey and tampermonkey are not really mainstream, nor do they make money as far as I know.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:30AM (#39492198)
I searched a bit to see if I could find myself the answer, and what I found instead is that there is another project called "code monkey", which seems to an educational tool to help people learn to code. That would explain the name change a lot better than "the author changed the name because he wanted to be taken seriously".

Besides, the original criticism of Scuttlebutt was "it will never catch on because it has a silly name", not "it will make money". By making it about "making money" you are moving the goalposts a bit, aren't you?

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by lukan on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:26AM (#39492753)
"Besides, the original criticism of Scuttlebutt was "it will never catch on because it has a silly name", not "it will make money". By making it about "making money" you are moving the goalposts a bit, aren't you? "

Operating a social global network, even decentralized, is not possible without money, if you are aiming to get mainstream adoption(which was the main question/goal here). But you are very welcome, to proof me wrong.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by RankingMember on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:44PM (#39488003)
No offense, but you're repeatedly using the term "midwit", which demonstrates that you have a higher-than-average tolerance/liking for non-layman vocabulary, and so might not be the best judge of what the average person is going to accept. Most people are not going to bother looking up the etymology of a word before dismissing a product named using it. Personally, I'm not a fan of the name because it's a word that, like "jitterbug", I associate with old people, because the only people I've known to use it in conversation are over 65.

Orgs spend millions on naming/branding because they know a name that doesn't hit right to the ear is going to be at a disadvantage. The vast majority of folks aren't going to bother giving your product a second thought if it doesn't appeal to them or has a negative connotation in their head right off the bat, regardless of the name's deeper relevance or origin.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:35PM (#39488328)
My point (in relation to the top the of the thread I responded to) is that there are other things beyond the name that are more important/relevant when evaluating why the product wasn't successful.

If Scuttlebutt had an amazing feature that had a viral component to attract people, was easy to use and had no roadblocks for distribution, it would likely succeed, regardless of the name (like github).

But it's not. Scuttlebutt is a complex system, requires users to understand concepts like public keys and distributed systems, content discovery literally involves chasing other people around the internet to spread the gossip to you, the client was primitive, the development team had a size of one, etc, etc, etc... Those factors are way more relevant to understand why it hasn't taken off. Even if Scuttlebutt had a perfectly "appropriate" name, it wouldn't matter.

To put it another way: "Glimpse" is a fork of GIMP, and the author forked only because of the name. How many people actually cared enough about it to switch? How many people left Photoshop and started using "Glimpse" because that was the tipping point? Or the inverse: look at the whole Twitter -> X "branding". How many people left Twitter because of the name change vs because of the other changes since Elon took over?

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rzzzt on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:48AM (#39490399)
How many people are calling the website X (and just X, no née-s and formerly known as-s)?
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rglullis on Saturday February 24, 2024 @05:18AM (#39490521)
That's a separate problem, but that also shows that names (good or bad) are not really a make-or-break attribute of a product.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by corobo on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:28PM (#39488578)
Aye, and most people who use social networks are midwits!

Butt in the name will absolutely make the project a joke and cause it to misfire. As a fellow midwit I only just heard of the project and dismissed it before I got to the technical pain in the arse you describe it being in other comments.

Butt, lmao. Now Mastodon has disowned the term they should start calling their messages toots.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by foofie on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:44AM (#39490161)
"Hey guys, have you seen Dave's new tweet?"
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by echelon on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:13PM (#39487810)
> I get not liking a name, but to pass judgement on the quality of a product/project based on its name alone seems like a complete midwit thing to do.

I get to make n-many "midwit" decisions in life and retain a certain success envelope / gradient. I'm happy for this to be one of them.

Just think about all of the everyday decisions being made just like this. People passing over your resume because they don't like your font, etc. This kind of petty little thing bears an absolutely astronomically impact on the deterministic evolution of the universe.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by serial_dev on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:25PM (#39487888)
2024 will be the year of Mastodong.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by Hamuko on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:29PM (#39486359)
Why? Well, for one thing, it's an append-only log, which I would argue is a terrible choice for a social network.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by r3trohack3r on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:25AM (#39489347)
Append-only logs are fine as long as they only contain pointers to content.

You can store 10k blocks in the size of a JPG image.

And, when trees grow large, with stale data that has been forgotten by the network, you can do garbage collection/compaction by shaking out the dead references and sharing a new tree.

Its just SSB never reached this point.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by woah on Friday February 23, 2024 @04:35PM (#39486424)
Social networks are strongly dependent on network effects. For a time SSB was actually used by some of my friends, but it required a desktop app, had a confusing onboarding process, IIRC had some rough edges around syncing content, and was just not smooth enough to compete against highly funded centralized companies in the cuthroat social networking space.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by nightpool on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:40PM (#39487070)
Scuttlebutt had the Bitcoin like problem of requiring everybody to have a local copy of the entire database, with a confusing / glitchy "syncing" process to download the latest posts. I tried to use it for a few days on my Android, but it never showed any new posts and the syncing process took like 30 seconds every time I opened the app.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday February 23, 2024 @11:47PM (#39489203)
A true Satoshi whitepaper Bitcoin would include everyone having a local copy of the database as well as peer-to-peer connections. No necessary middlemen. Is this correct.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by pooper on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:07AM (#39490244)
A Bitcoin of my dreams would have close to zero if not zero transactions cost with everyone on the network running at least full nodes fully synchronized with the main network. The fact that it costs money to send some Bitcoin from one wallet to another is sad.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:37PM (#39495350)
It requires a third party to send some Bitcoin from one wallet to another. Is this correct.

Was this contemplated by the Satoshi paper.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by r3trohack3r on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:23AM (#39489339)
This isn't entirely true.

Scuttelbutt had some design and scaling issues.

But there wasn't a global database. Each user gets their own blockchain.

Its a network of tiny blockchains where the consensus model was the signature from the private key and the chain of hashes.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by p4bl0 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:55AM (#39489949)
Not disagreeing with you, just nitpicking on the use of a word:

What you are describing is simply a signed Merkle tree, not a blockchain. You cannot really call an individual signing it's own ledger a consensus mechanism. Maybe "validity" or "authenticity" would be better terms here.

I know a lot of people make this mistake of labelling anything that has a Merkle-tree like structure a blockchain but it's impractical when you need to talk about the technology rigorously to have a word that meant something precise suddenly encompass so many things, including tools such as Git.

Coming back to Scuttlebutt, even the website of Manyverse, the mobile client, explicitly says "no blockchains", so it seems at least some of the people involved in Scuttlebutt development agree with this.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by jazzyjackson on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:10AM (#39490255)
right, blocks are specifically the result of a global consensus

if there's not a discrete unit of appended data that all peers agree has happened, there's not a block

"hashchain" maybe, but merkle tree is already plenty precise

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by hinkley on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:49PM (#39495039)
Many of these systems also don’t have a Merkle tree, they have a Merkle linked list. Which I think contributes a lot to the syncing problem. A skip list structure where each node has multiple hashes/identities would let you skip the last five years of edits and pull down only the individual edits for the last month.

The “Merkle tree” I worked on before this blockchain nonsense started was a Merkle DAG, representing a mostly linear state flow with some parallel elements.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by r3trohack3r on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:49PM (#39495417)
> A skip list structure where each node has multiple hashes/identities would let you skip the last five years of edits and pull down only the individual edits for the last month.

Do you have any references or reading material on this pattern? Would love to learn more.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by hinkley on Saturday February 24, 2024 @06:00PM (#39495925)
Not in crypto, but it’s a linked list structure with a logarithmic number of additional pointers that refer forward (or in the case of a diff algorithm, backward) into the list, to provide closer to log n lookup time.

I think they were invented by Bill Pugh, a professor who also had some noteworthiness in Java concurrency fifteen years ago, which is how I heard of them.

Wikipedia agrees (W Pugh for William)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skip_list

So the way I see it, you’d overlay the linear tree with one that refers to a single, recent hash, a much older hash (or another meta node of the same degree) and a roll up delta from that older hash, with a new hash that satisfies both. Then every time the number of records double, you add another layer over the previous one.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by r3trohack3r on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:13PM (#39495189)
I appreciate the nitpick! Words do matter.

I'll share my definition of these terms, for me they have very precise definitions:

A merkle tree is a specific data structure: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree

> In cryptography and computer science, a hash tree or Merkle tree is a tree in which every "leaf" (node) is labelled with the cryptographic hash of a data block, and every node that is not a leaf (called a branch, inner node, or inode) is labelled with the cryptographic hash of the labels of its child nodes. A hash tree allows efficient and secure verification of the contents of a large data structure. A hash tree is a generalization of a hash list and a hash chain.

If you have hashes co-located with data, and data spread throughout the chain, it is not a merkle tree.

A blockchain is a linear chain of hashes of the content in each block of the chain. In a blockchain, for any given block, there is only one valid next block.

When a blockchain is propagated over a network, there is a consensus algorithm used to agree on state of that chain. Bitcoin uses proof-of-work to agree on the next block. Anything that allows multiple nodes to reach consensus on the state of a blockchain is a consensus algorithm. SSB uses proof-of-signature, and the sequence number, as its consensus algorithm. The network reaches consensus on the state of any particular chain by validating the signatures and that the sequence numbers are in the correct order.

Colloquially, blockchains have been conflated with their consensus schemes. When people use the term blockchain conversationally, they generally mean a blockchain that propagates over a network using some sort of consensus algorithm. This conflation of consensus with blockchains has lead to many people in the p2p space rejecting the term blockchain to distance themselves from the crypto hype bubble, even though the data structure itself is quite useful.

Finally there is a Merkle-DAG, introduced by Juan Benet, that acts as a unifying data structure for both blockchains and merkle-trees. Merkle-DAGs can also express novel data structures that are neither a merkle-tree nor a blockchain.

tl;dr: a blockchain is not a merkle-tree, and a merkle-dag might be capable of representing a blockchain but they are separate concepts. A blockchain is independent of its consensus algorithm, although colloquially the two have been conflated.

P.S. Merkle-DAG might be capable of representing git, would be fun to give it a try sometime using something like IPLD.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by p4bl0 on Sunday February 25, 2024 @03:55AM (#39498960)
> The network reaches consensus on the state of any particular chain by validating the signatures

Ok I can see that. It's the distributed consensus problem in a centralized setting. It still feels strange to call that a blockchain but maybe it can be qualified like "centralized blockchain" (which questions the need for such a structure to begin with).

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by r3trohack3r on Sunday February 25, 2024 @04:56PM (#39505238)
> "centralized blockchain" (which questions the need for such a structure to begin with).

I’ve seen centralized blockchains used to great effect in ledger contexts where the chain is not synced, but references (hashes) of the chain are shared externally (I.e. transaction ids).

If an external auditor has a set of transaction ids that have been communicated externally, they can later audit the centralized chain and prove it has not been tampered with without having to have the full log of blocks.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by p4bl0 on Sunday February 25, 2024 @06:35AM (#39499973)
> If you have hashes co-located with data, and data spread throughout the chain, it is not a merkle tree.

Yes that's the theoretical structure but in practice its usage almost always implies data co-located with the intermediate hashes, if only because it's used to validate the integrity of a tree of files and directory and it's easier to manipulate a single structure with all the information. That's how it's done in Git internally, as well as in IPFS for example. I believe it's also how Merke-trees are used in some backup/synchronization tools.

> In a blockchain, for any given block, there is only one valid next block.

Yes, but that's just a particular kind of tree, where each node only has one child.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by r3trohack3r on Sunday February 25, 2024 @04:52PM (#39505196)
> Yes, but that's just a particular kind of tree, where each node only has one child.

Yes!

I’m personally building a SSB data structure that forks into a tree, forking to allow writes from each new writer, to allow multi-device writes! It is a multi-writer append database that behaves like a CRDT.

It’s a blocktree, not a blockchain. Which is also expressable as a merkledag.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by nightpool on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:15PM (#39493757)
Yeah, sorry, when I said "entire database" I was handwaving over "the entire database of posts relevant to them". The Merkle tree structure is the root of the scaling issues which is why I think it's fair to describe it as "bitcoin-like" and it serves as an intuition pump for people to understand why it was so difficult to use on mobile, regardless of whether it was actually quite as bad as Bitcoin or not.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by lurtbancaster on Saturday February 24, 2024 @06:14AM (#39490737)
Admittedly my only exposure to the Secure Scuttlebutt Protocol(SSB) is through manyver.se [1] - a FOSS private(optionally) social media app. And the syncing issue you mention has been one for me too. Sometimes it's even worse - it fails to sync entirely until another app restart. Maybe this is a manyverse issue, maybe a SSB issue. Either way, hitherto at least, it doesn't seem reliable.

If there are alternative ways to have an offline(over Wi-Fi/bluetooth, not internet) social media/messaging app, that works on both Android and ios, please do let me know.

Thanks.

[1] https://www.manyver.se/

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by evbogue on Sunday February 25, 2024 @09:19AM (#39501021)
At a certain point in the history of SSB the manlyverse team took over the maintenance of SSB and the apps locking until the end of a sync became the norm. Prior to this there were websocket-based web and Electron apps where you could at least see that progress was being made.

SSB always sank from the first post to the latest. IMO it's better to sync from the latest backwards.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by Solvency on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:43PM (#39487106)
Everyone here is focused on the tech and I'm here wondering how I'm supposed to convince my friends and family to join me on something called Scuttlebutt.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by kstrauser on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:08PM (#39487785)
The name was the part I liked best! "Scuttlebutt" is a naval term for a water keg, and it became slang for conversation around the watering hole. In other words, it was gossip around the water cooler from before we had water coolers.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by Solvency on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:20PM (#39487853)
...and this is why 99% of niche developer attempts don't flourish into the next big social network. Might as well call it "Codswallop", which is also a valid historical slang that is equally completely ridiculous for mass appeal.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by megous on Friday February 23, 2024 @08:19PM (#39488232)
Yeah, yahoo and google is very meaningful on the other hand.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by dewey on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:21PM (#39488544)
They are short, memorable and don’t have “butt” in the name.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by kstrauser on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:48PM (#39488686)
I currently have halibut baking in the oven with garlic butter, and butternut squash soup.

I love a good dumb butt joke, but not everything with the substring butt in it is automatically funny or reminiscent of butts.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by corobo on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:53PM (#39488718)
Correct, it has to be at the end to be funny.

Halibut is already a terrible name for a social network but if it wasn't it may indeed be a little bit bumular

(although in my accent at least you don't really end in a butt, it's more a "bit", maybe you could get away with it)

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by dewey on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:54PM (#39488722)
But you are also not trying to convince people to try yet another social media concept named “butternut”.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by ErikBjare on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:17AM (#39489793)
It was never meant to. It was founded by a guy who lived on his boat and wanted something for his friends. It became a hotbed for experimenting with P2P social networks, for a time.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by beAbU on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:20AM (#39492698)
You honestly saying you've never heard of the term scuttlebutt? Like "what's the latest gossip/scuttlebutt".

I've never associated this term with being nerdy or niche.

Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by rakoo on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:20PM (#39493245)
...and this is why 99% of developers will defend for-profit companies stealing data, enabling mass genocides and foregoing all privacy: because everything must become the next big XXX.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by ahazred8ta on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:17AM (#39489310)
Yes, an actual literal 'gossip protocol' named Scuttlebutt. Unpardonable. /s
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by oli-g on Friday February 23, 2024 @05:55PM (#39487205)
Someone at last, thank you!!
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by beAbU on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:18AM (#39492679)
Scuttlebutt is a brilliant name for a social network. It's right up there in the "why didn't I think of that" territory.
Re:Scuttlebutt social network: a decentralised platform by tazjin on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:02AM (#39489980)
It had a major technical flaw in that it depends on some weird, Javascript-only JSON-serialisation bugs (iirc), and these basically had to be reimplemented in other languages so nobody really ended up writing any other clients for it.