News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:53PM (#39318775)
> In February, I, along with real estate developer Bobby Fijan, went on the Bloomberg podcast Odd Lots to talk about why it’s so hard to find a family-sized apartment in the United States. I argued that North American zoning and building codes work together to drive up the size of multi-bedroom apartments in particular, putting them financially out of reach for many parents raising children. In other words, even if developers built more two-, three-, and four-bedroom apartments, you probably wouldn’t be able to afford one, because they would have to be so much larger than units with the same number of bedroom in Europe or Asia.

So, as an American living in Portugal, I'm not so sure the grass is greener.

It's true that our apartment would be illegal to build in the US. There's only one point of egress in a fire, and it's the stairway we share with our neighbors. That means there's no need to have a long hall like in America, but I'm not really sure the reason prices have ballooned in America is the extra few square feet spent on a little bit of stairway.

There are other ways European apartments are smaller, of course. Even our three bedroom apartment has no linen closet, no laundry room, no closets at all actually. The bedrooms have what I would call extra-large armoires. Again, our three bedroom place is very much built for a family, but the kitchen has a refrigerator smaller than the one my American best friend uses for beer. It's really RV-sized.

Just everything in Europe is tiny. T i n y. And frankly, it's not that much cheaper over here either.

Maybe the extra hall space you need to have two points of egress in a fire is part of it, but that ain't all of it.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by nottorp on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:04PM (#39318915)
> the kitchen has a refrigerator smaller than the one my American best friend uses for beer

It's possible that you can walk 5 min to get more beer while he has to drive 30 minutes?

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:24PM (#39319229)
Most people in America can drive for 5 minutes for more beer. If you can't legally drive because of how drunk you are, then most stores won't sell you more beer. People might drive 30 minutes for beer, but that is about either price or selection, not availability. Though many cities have weird laws so some places you can't get beer at all in town, and that would push you to the 30 minute drive. But where I live many people have a separate beer fridge despite being 5 minutes from a store where they can get more.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by malfist on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:41PM (#39320247)
Places will absolutely sell you more beer when you're over the legal driving limit.

Most regular drinkers function fairly normally around the legal limit, it is set really low.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by watwut on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:33PM (#39319375)
You cant legally drive when you had one small beer. You can legally buy beers or other alcohol when you already had one beer. If the store is not selling you alcohol due to intoxication, you should stop driving several drinks ago.

I can get good selection of beers or other alcohol at reasonable price in the regular store within 5-10 min of walk anywhere in the city assuming it is not middle of the night.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jessriedel on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:45PM (#39319560)
> You cant legally drive when you had one small beer

Not in the US. The legal limit in almost all states is 0.08.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by watwut on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @12:32PM (#39372565)
But they also sell alcohol to people who around that drunk.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by nottorp on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:48PM (#39319607)
Missing the point entirely, I see.

The point is the europe apartment doesn't need survivalist style storage because it's close to stores. I could have said Mars bars or steaks but the OP post was about a beer fridge so I went along with it.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:16PM (#39321155)
Once again, most in the US are only 5 minutes drive from a store. We still have that extra storage despite being that close.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by sillyfluke on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:19PM (#39321185)
I was quietly chuckling as I was reading the discussion veer off toward the finer implications the legal limit for driving in the USA has on beer acquistion -- the original frame of reference of the example being so foreign to the commenters as to cause them to miss the intent of the example that was probably immediately obvious to most european residents.

A while back someone here made a great point about why Americans love to take vacations to European cities. It triggers a nostalgic wave in them bringing up warm feelings they had the last and possibly only time they lived in a community that they could explore and enjoy simply by walking and biking around. You know, that wonderful time when they lived....on a college campus.

The reason why there is little room for storage in the those tiny european apartments is the same reason you didn't have a huge fridge in your dorm room in college.

And in many of those places you can walk around with a beer in your hand in public. Yes, that's right -- just like college.

Outside college, car culture in the US encourages stocking up habits which in turn encourages the search for more storage space.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by watwut on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @12:32PM (#39372562)
I just find the notion of "being too drunk to be able to buy another beer while not being too drunk to drive".
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by woleium on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:45PM (#39320898)
its not about driving for beer, its about not drinking warm beer
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:08PM (#39319881)
Kind of.

We live near a Lidl (similar to Aldi) and it's fine for a quick trip for the staples.

But if we're cooking something like what you'd find in the New York Times or Delish or whatever, we're driving to a big old supermarket just like in the States. We find ourselves still following the American model of driving to fill the car with groceries once a week because we like a lot of variety.

If you're content with the national cuisine of Portugal, you could totally always walk to buy groceries though. They're fond of fish and a specific kind of grilled chicken. And in fairness, their chicken is really quite good.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by throwway120385 on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:22PM (#39319212)
Nothing will drive this point home more than living on an island with a single ferry and no grocery store. You have to stock everything because everything you forget costs you $20 or $40 or more to go pick up.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by SllX on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:21PM (#39320013)
Depends on where you are in America because alcohol regulations can vary wildly and some States have dry counties and/or these things I like to call socialist liquor stores, but where I’m at I can get bourbon hand-delivered to me via DoorDash.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by PaulHoule on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:44PM (#39321405)
I grew up in NH where the state runs all the liquor stores despite the “live free or die” motto and the libertarian politics. I guess I know what it like to shop in a government store like they used to have in the Soviet Union. Neighboring states hate it because, in a normal state, the store makes a profit and the state taxes it but in NH the state just takes all the money and passes the savings on to the consumer.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by xboxnolifes on Friday February 09, 2024 @07:34PM (#39322240)
The idea that the average US city/suburb is a 30 minute drive from everything is a serious strawman built up (seemingly) by the collective internet. There are a lot of issues I personally have with car dependence and road infrastructure in the US, but the average/median drive is reasonable. Like, 5-15 minutes to get to most things.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by nottorp on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:28AM (#39324825)
Well, no one noticing the walk vs drive part only reinforces the strawman...
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by sspiff on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:14PM (#39319065)
>Just everything in Europe is tiny. T i n y. And frankly, it's not that much cheaper over here either.

I would argue the other way, as a European, I've been to multiple places Asia and the Middle East and everything is either the same size or smaller than in Europe.

I haven't been to Africa or the Americas, but I'd say from my perspective, that things in the US are just extra large.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by sandworm101 on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:30PM (#39319309)
There are many reasons behind this. It isn't just a fashion for bigger things. I chalk much of it up to differences in work culture. My European friends often talk about pickup up food on the way home from work, dropping in at a store to buy ingredients for dinner. I don't have time to shop like that. My food run is once a week. That means more food in a bigger fridge. They also go out to eat far more than we in North America. When work is busy I can easily go a month, sometimes months, without eating at sit-down restaurant. That is unheard of across much of Europe.

Last time I was in Europe at a friend's place they asked where I wanted to go for breakfast. Breakfast? I don't need to pay someone else to fry me an egg.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:36PM (#39319416)
> Breakfast? I don't need to pay someone else to fry me an egg.

Yet in the US there are a lot of restaurants open for breakfast. Some of them are not open any other part of the day.

In short what is your personal culture and what is really US vs Europe? I think you are correct the in Europe people shop more often, but I'm not sure we eat out that much differently as a whole - people who eat out eat out a lot, while people who don't don't.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by mancerayder on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:49PM (#39320349)
Where in "Europe" was this? Certainly not in France where a bistro scratches this itch. At any point in the morning or evening you can find some place to sit to serve you food or snacks/coffee/tea/beer. And pâtisseries are made for 'breakfast'.

Europe's a big place. The UK has strict open and closing times for restaurants (don't ask me what they are, only that 12 noon is 12 noon and I couldn't step inside at 11:55a for lunch). And the culture thinks beans and white toast are breakfast. But people definitely eat out for breakfast and even brunch.

But even those examples contradict your friend. I'll give you one generalizations to take home: Europeans like to mess with Americans.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by lxgr on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:37PM (#39319436)
> When work is busy I can easily go a month, sometimes months, without eating at sit-down restaurant. That is unheard of across much of Europe.

It's absolutely not. Doing one grocery run per week is entirely possible, and fresh food often doesn't last long beyond that anyway.

> Last time I was in Europe at a friend's place they asked where I wanted to go for breakfast. Breakfast? I don't need to pay someone else to fry me an egg.

You're generalizing from one experience in Europe to an entire continent. Going out for breakfast is very unusual in the places in Europe I've lived in. I don't doubt that it's common elsewhere, though. Personally, I've been to breakfast restaurants in the US much more often than in Europe.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by noduerme on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:44PM (#39319539)
The subtext of your post points more toward food culture than work culture. I've noticed most Americans eat to fuel themselves. Europeans eat to enjoy food and as a reason to spend time with other people. Often, going to dinner with people in America and they're all done eating in 5 minutes... I've barely taken a few bites. Friends call me a "slow eater". Whereas in other countries, dinner can last a couple hours. It's not just about your work schedule, but about how you regard your free time and what your relationship is with food.

I've had some people use having children as an excuse for why they eat so fast, but I've seen people in Europe or Latin America take their young children to dinner and those kids behave and sit at the table and listen. Such a thing is almost unbelievable to American parents.

I blame puritanism for the lack of interest in food, sure; but the emphasis on excusing it with the pressing need to work is funny because it's like a defense of joylesssness.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by idixbebr on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:05PM (#39319834)
plenty of people in america get take out, sounds like you’re just a workaholic
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:13PM (#39319927)
Take-out is so much cheaper in Europe than America. Not just Portugal, either. Take-out in Italy is dirty cheap and despite all of my hopes and dreams, I'll never cook something as good as what I can get for like 5 euros from a gas station in Italy.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by sspiff on Saturday February 10, 2024 @08:51AM (#39326115)
Once a week food runs are common in Europe as well, going out for breakfast is a fairly rare luxury.

The difference is maybe that often times you can supplement your weekly food run with small trips to the corner store during the week.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:11PM (#39319914)
> I haven't been to Africa or the Americas, but I'd say from my perspective, that things in the US are just extra large.

That's probably it.

I've also been to New Zealand, and everything was smaller there too. Though still not as small as stuff in Europe.

Cars are where it holds the most true. I told my American friend we're thinking of getting a Mazda CX-5. His reaction was, "why so small?"

I told my Portuguese tutor I was considering the same car. He asked why we needed something so large.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by Aurornis on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:19PM (#39319156)
> I would argue the other way, as a European, I've been to multiple places Asia and the Middle East and everything is either the same size or smaller than in Europe.

The parent commenter moved from America to Europe, so the size difference is obvious.

I agree that many parts of Asia have similar size standards.

Things in America are just very large.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jorvi on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:40PM (#39319480)
> Things in America are just very large.

Maybe harsh, but North Americans just love to consume consume consume planetary consequences be damned.

Per capita CO2 emissions (aka carbon footprint):

- 15.5 Canada (?!)

- 14.5 USA

- 8.5: China

- 3.3: Vietnam

- 15.5 Australia

- 3.7: Sweden

- 8.2: Germany

- 7.8: Netherlands

- 5.5: Italy

- 1.9: Morocco

- 6.8: South Africa

- 3.6: Mexico

- 2.2: Brazil

If you live at nearly x2 the CO2 footprint of West/Central Europeans, and above x4 for most of the planet, it gets a lot easier to live large.

Of course, North America having a lot of space geographically makes it easier to build big, and there is probably a ton of other factors as well. But it is an important thing to note.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by tmnvix on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:19PM (#39320672)
I assume these are tonnes per year. Worth noting that the average vehicle driven the average distance per year in the US accounts for around 4000kg of CO2. Quite the contribution.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by throwaway44023 on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:54PM (#39319680)
Canada is high probably because of the sparse northern population that uses fossil fuels year-round to get heat, transport and electricity.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:45PM (#39320291)
You missed Australia, at 15.25. Probably because they have all those coal reserves, and like houses as big as Americans.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jorvi on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:13PM (#39320625)
Edited in, thanks!
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by scythe on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:44PM (#39319535)
When I (American) had an apartment in Wuhan, the fridge was not particularly small and our 3-bedroom apartment didn't feel cramped. The beds were hard, but normal size. The bathroom was a little weird — no separation of the shower — but not particularly small. There was a laundry machine but no oven.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:49PM (#39320340)
Ya, same in Beijing. The bathroom was also wet room, which is probably just an economy. The laundry machine was in the bathroom, my wife had to buy an external oven because she liked baking.

But these were considered luxury by Chinese standards, older housing built before the 90s could get weird, like no hot water and instead you have a tank that needs to activated a half hour before your shower.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:04PM (#39321068)
The "wet room" thing is in Korea too.

I've been told it's for easy cleaning. You just pull the sprayer off the shower and splash the whole room like you're at a car wash.

Having said that, the person who told me that was not Korean.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by seanmcdirmid on Friday February 09, 2024 @08:12PM (#39322482)
It’s true, cleaning is easy, although I imagine they don’t last that long since I can’t see the grout keeping up without a lot of maintenance. At least it’s not a shower over a squat toilet, those are the worst.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:34PM (#39319384)
In the famous book "the Wealth of the Nations", it points out that when people get more money they typically spend it on larger/better places to live. Just looking at the historical economy of US and the rest of the world post WWII it shouldn't be a surprise that people live in larger apartments in the US in general. Larger fridges are another luxury that I'd expect in the US as well.

However this article is about people who live in apartments - in the US that means either those without a family or poor.

Those without a family may want 3 bedrooms - either for offices (his and hers) or a guest bedroom, but cannot really see need for more than that. They also want them to be large and so are happy with the current state of things.

You would expect the poor to want to compromise on smaller fridges, and bedrooms - but many would prefer to have 4 tiny bedrooms (with only beds in them), and 1 bathroom, all in the space of a current US 2 bedroom apartment. They still dream of the larger bedrooms, fridges and the like - but they well know they cannot afford it.

Like you said, fire needs to be considered. Current codes are harming the poor, but it may be less harm than from allowing fire to kill them.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jltsiren on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:58PM (#39319735)
> Like you said, fire needs to be considered. Current codes are harming the poor, but it may be less harm than from allowing fire to kill them.

The last time there was a discussion on fire codes on HN, I looked up some statistics and reports from Finland. It's a country with an unusually large number of fire deaths per capita for a developed country, because of attitudes and because saunas are common.

Almost all fire deaths happened in the unit where the fire started. Unusually deadly home fires almost always happened in single-family homes. I couldn't find any reports of fires where a second stairwell accessible from the same corridor would have prevented deaths. There were some fires where a second exit from the unit (to a different corridor) would have helped, because the fire started near the exit and people couldn't get out.

This only applies to mid-rise and low-rise buildings. There are very few residential high-rises in Finland.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by wolverine876 on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:25PM (#39320054)
> Almost all fire deaths happened in the unit where the fire started.

That could be because of effective fire codes.

> I couldn't find any reports of fires where a second stairwell accessible from the same corridor would have prevented deaths.

Meaning, you couldn't find anything either way, or in what you found, the second stairwell wouldn't have helped?

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jltsiren on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:52PM (#39320397)
Finland is small enough that all fire deaths (50-100 / year) make it into national news. There are very few deaths reported outside the unit where the fire started. When reading reports of those outlier cases, I couldn't find a situation where a second stairwell would have helped.

Fire codes are effective and fire fighters arrive quickly enough. If you can get out of your unit, you can get out of the building. Second stairwell requirements address a risk that doesn't really exist in Finland. The real challenge is detecting a fire in your unit quickly enough to get out.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by Aurornis on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:18PM (#39319135)
> Just everything in Europe is tiny. T i n y.

Having travelled through several parts of Europe and Asia, I think a more general takeaway would be that everything in America is very big.

Even if 4-bedroom apartments were plentiful, I suspect people would still be pushing to live in a house rather than an apartment. If the demand for large apartments isn't there, builders aren't very incentivized to build them.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:43PM (#39319513)
How much of that is developers can't build an option so people don't know what they want?

As I noted elsewhere, I think the demand for 4 bedroom apartments is mostly to the poor right now - they want 4 bedrooms in the same space of a current 2 bedrooms - make each bedroom smaller and only 1 bathroom to share (or may a half bathroom for the second bathroom not a full one). The layout of a US 4 bedroom by nature ends up with a lot of wasted space in expensive closets (unless you get a corner unit - there cannot be many of these in a two staircase building but they would look more like Europe)

Though I have often asked what it would take to attract an upper middle class family to an inner-city apartment. They want large apartment - but it needs to be affordable (not downtown rents). But there is a lot else about inner city that needs to be fixed first (crime tends to be bad)

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by epistasis on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:06PM (#39318936)
It's not just Bobby Fijan, there's also Michael Elias, an architect, who has been trying to build family suitable apartments in the US after experiencing them in Germany.

The problem really is the hallway cutting the building in half. It puts such restrictions on what can be built in sensible ways.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by wolverine876 on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:34PM (#39319385)
You might mean Michael Eliason, who is part of the OP's organization:

https://www.centerforbuilding.org/our-team

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by epistasis on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:41PM (#39319492)
Oops, two mistakes on my part here, the spelling, and somehow missing that he's in one of the early paragraphs of the linked article... I've been following Eliason's work for a long time so I can't believe his name didn't pop out to me in the article!
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by criddell on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:28PM (#39319292)
You could just put a staircase in the middle of the apartment and have two or three levels, no? That's how lots of homes are built, is there some reason reason why some apartments couldn't be like that as well.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by SoftTalker on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:38PM (#39319446)
Yeah I've lived in and visited friends in "townhouse" apartments that are two or three stories, the bedrooms are upstairs and the living space and kitchen downstairs.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by mperham on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:44PM (#39319531)
Those are called townhomes.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by criddell on Saturday February 10, 2024 @06:13AM (#39325297)
That’s not the kind of home Fijan or Elias are talking about. Those don’t generally have the problem of the hallway cutting the building in half.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bobthepanda on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:02PM (#39318888)
One thing to keep in mind is that in the US there are often things like setback restrictions and distance separation requirements such, so a small increase in square footage can be the difference between a building fitting on a lot, and not.

You can of course buy more lots to combine but that takes more money, and more time, because you have to wait for a bunch of adjacent lot owners to sell.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by foofie on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:29PM (#39319299)
> One thing to keep in mind is that in the US there are often things like setback restrictions and distance separation requirements such, so a small increase in square footage can be the difference between a building fitting on a lot, and not.

Any country with urban planning and building codes imposes this sort of restrictions.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:45PM (#39319556)
Some of those restrictions are worth having. Some are unreasonable. This is a debate worth having, but it cannot be done without going into details.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bobthepanda on Saturday February 10, 2024 @01:27AM (#39324090)
I didn’t really say that as in only the US does it, but more in case I got an HN “well ackshually” about some other place.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by varjag on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:18PM (#39319132)
Is this some old building? One egress on above ground floors is many decades since illegal to develop in EU harmonized bulding codes. The only exception I think if there are sprinkler points in the rooms.

And TBH you can't really extrapolate your residence in one place to conditions in all of Europe, it is quite different.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bogantech on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:00PM (#39320485)
> One egress on above ground floors is many decades since illegal to develop in EU harmonized bulding codes.

I was living in an Apartment in Sweden built in 2018 with only a central staircase and no sprinklers and never actually noticed anything else in the few years I lived there

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by diggan on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:22PM (#39319204)
> And TBH you can't really extrapolate your residence in one place to conditions in all of Europe, it is quite different.

I'm guessing parent also lives in Lisbon or Oporto, which doesn't exactly extrapolate cleanly to rest of Portugal even.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:16PM (#39319967)
> Is this some old building?

Not that old. 2010, maybe?

It's a building with 4 stories. We're on the second (Portuguese would call it the first floor; like hackers, they count the ground floor as zero).

If you walk out our door, you see an elevator and a stairwell with an insulated steel door to the stairs. That's it; that's the only point of egress.

Though in a pinch, I could jump from the balcony and probably just break an ankle or something.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by wolverine876 on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:37PM (#39319422)
> One egress on above ground floors is many decades since illegal to develop in EU harmonized bulding codes. The only exception I think if there are sprinkler points in the rooms.

I might be misunderstanding, but isn't the OP all about how Europe allows single-stairway and the US does not?

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by detourdog on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:38PM (#39319440)
What makes it even more complicated is that in Massachusetts and I assume other states in Union use the International Building Code to dictate building codes.

This means that new construction and significant renovation all fall under the international building codes.

I think that the USA doesn't have the existing family sized apartment stock that the market might current be demanding. The other countries by having larger existing stock means more housing available at lower safety standards.

The final type of zoning that could effect is the style and use type zoning. I personally think that the style and use type zoning has a small part in our housing availability.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by scythe on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:46PM (#39319571)
>International Building Code

As I've explained before, it's the World Series of building codes:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39050267

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by detourdog on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:28PM (#39320090)
I see what you are saying a number of "national" building codes exist. I imagine in one sense these codes open up one's products to national markets when demonstrated to be compliant.

On the other hand they can also be used as alignment tools to see measure compliance of various markets.

I have noticed a number of modular and manufactured builders will now build to any code standard.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by petschge on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:15PM (#39319077)
In Europe a closet is furniture, not a built in room.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by diggan on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:20PM (#39319176)
Not sure if that's wide-spread enough to claim "In Europe".

I currently live in a flat in Barcelona (the European one) and two out of three bedrooms has at least one built-in closet in them.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by FirmwareBurner on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:50PM (#39319629)
What other internationally famous Barcelonas are there? I'm sure there might be "a" Barcelona in every Spanish speaking nation, but only one is the Barcelona everyone is thinking about making confusion on international forums unlikely.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by oldtownroad on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:45PM (#39319558)
Either you’re misunderstanding closet to mean a built-in wardrobe or… I don’t know what other explanation there could be. American closets (i.e: a whole room of 100+ square feet, dedicated to storage of clothes) just don’t exist in “normal” European flats/apartments/homes. You’d be an outlier if you have an American-style closet in Europe. Regardless of how much you’re spending, they just don’t exist in >95% of properties.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by TheCleric on Friday February 09, 2024 @06:09PM (#39321635)
A 100+ square foot closet is a rarity in America. Most are between 5-15 in my experience.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by FpUser on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:26PM (#39319253)
I do not think stuffing everyone in ever smaller boxes is a good policy.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by 01HNNWZ0MV43FF on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:39PM (#39319457)
Forcing people to spend more money on a bigger box than they want isn't great, either
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by lxgr on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:32PM (#39319360)
> as an American living in Portugal [...] Just everything in Europe is tiny.

Sorry to invoke a cliche here but... Europe doesn't start and end in Portugal.

There are plenty of large-family apartments in some cities. Especially new developments usually have a mix of studios, one-bedrooms and beyond.

In terms of old buildings (i.e. older than ~100 years), many European cities have apartment buildings designed for wealthy families that would house their staff in the same building. The problem there is actually that these are too large to rent out to most families, not the opposite.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:18PM (#39319984)
I've lived/traveled outside of Portugal.

It really holds true across the continent. Stuff is just smaller.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by lxgr on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:26PM (#39320070)
With "stuff", are you comparing housing size in general? If so, I think that doesn't make sense given that single-family homes are just much more common in the US than they are in many European countries.

Comparing apartment sizes (i.e. excluding single-family homes) makes more sense in a conversation about family-sized apartments.

In my very limited experience, US apartments in expensive cities are often tiny as well, washer/drier in-unit is not a given (whereas any apartment without a washing machine would be considered archaic/unlivable in many places in Europe), and the most economical option to get more space is to move to a single-family house.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:07PM (#39320559)
Well yeah, that's a good example.

I haven't always had a laundry room in apartments I've rented in the US. When I haven't, there's been a shared machine room that all the tenants use with rows of machines. But most of the apartments I've rented in the US have had laundry rooms.

Laundry rooms are, as far as I can tell, something that simply doesn't exist this side of the Atlantic. They put clothes washers in the kitchen and even in humid Porto, vented tumble dryers are pretty uncommon.

Granted, New York, Boston, and San Francisco are different. But if you're in Denver, or Austin, or Dallas, etc, you can expect an apartment with far more storage than similarly sized European cities.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by lxgr on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:43PM (#39320878)
> vented tumble dryers are pretty uncommon

Yeah, they're considered crimes against both delicate fabric and the environment :) Drying racks have the added benefit of humidifying apartments in winter, when the air often gets quite dry from heating.

One peculiarity at least in Germany is that people move with their washing machines (as well as with their kitchens, very often). While I do miss my in-apartment washer a lot, I don't miss having to think about how on earth I'm going to get it to the other side of town without breaking either somebody's back or stairwell...

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bouncing on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:03PM (#39321050)
Yeah, I get the energy savings with air-drying. And I've always air-dried certain items, too, because like you said, it's hard on fabric.

But right now, the humidity in Porto is 91%. A pair of jeans would smell bad before they finish air drying. Also, my 3 year old loves soup but hasn't really figured out how to hold a spoon without spilling. We do laundry so much because of that kid...

Maybe someone can enlighten me about how to do air dry all of my family's clothes. Clearly I'm missing something because I don't get it. If you lay out your clothes to dry on a rack, you have room for maybe half a load, so is a family just doing laundry every day?

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by lxgr on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:16PM (#39321158)
People usually have multiple dryers (I used to use 1-2 for a single machine load by myself)! And use clothespins, they let you hang stuff more tightly spaced.

But yeah, hang-drying in high humidity is rough. It really works best in winter with heating on, or in summer with the AC running (which also removes humidity) if there is one. Ventilation is key, too (cross drafts are great; a room can get saturated very quickly).

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by ClumsyPilot on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:23PM (#39319225)
> Just everything in Europe is tiny. T i n y. And frankly, it's not that much cheaper over here either

The real kicker is that price of houses / assets is not attached to physical reality any more.

Financialization drives up the price of real estate. When the financial markets trade real estate, no-one gives a rat's ass if it's a mansion or a shed - the only thing that matters is that number goes up. As was demonstrated in 2008, no-one even knew anything about underlying value of the asset and nobody cared.

In every country in EU number of houses per person has been increasing, and at the same time, prices of houses have been increasing. You cannot build your way out of this.

Real solution to the housing crisis is to reign in financial markets, it's not anything to do with building.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by avidiax on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:46PM (#39319566)
30 year mortgages plus the 1/3rd of salary mortgage approval heuristic means that desirable real estate costs 10 years of salary.

If we had 10 year maximum mortgages, real estate would cost 1/3rd as much, roughly.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by antisthenes on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:27PM (#39320077)
> Real solution to the housing crisis is to reign in financial markets, it's not anything to do with building.

12 years of ZIRP certainly didn't help. It's a massive payout to the finance sector and to people who had assets to borrow against (or even just a bunch of cash to put in the stock market).

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by tmnvix on Friday February 09, 2024 @04:45PM (#39320897)
Absolutely. Nobody would be paying the current prices if they didn't expect the value to increase. Prices are a reflection of the financial value and not the utility.

This is the reason that interest rates are fundamental. If we really have turned the corner on the steady decline of interest rates that we've seen over the last 20-30 years then property markets are not going to 'plateau'. They will fall to a point where new buyers can afford to service the loans. Of course, as noted above (prices being as high as they are due to expected future increases), if prices are falling then not only do new buyers wait for prices fall to a point where they can service the loans again, but they will also focus more on utility value as public sentiment moves away from 'property prices always go up'. This will compound the falls.

That said, there will undoubtedly be a lot of policy engineering employed to avoid losses and kick the can further down the road. In the long run I don't think it will be successful. The only thing that will save the property market is a return to low rates.

Every time the issue of housing affordability comes up on this site, the debate quickly moves to zoning and nimbys and such. In my view this is important to an extent (more so in some areas than others), and building more homes is always helpful, but it is not as significant as interest rates and the 'artificial' demand that is induced by speculation.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by hooverd on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:56PM (#39318816)
Bobby Floorplans should know that the magic bullet is a land value tax, not single stair.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by epistasis on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:07PM (#39318951)
As a land value tax advocate, I also agree with Bobby Fijan here. There needs to be a way to build these safe, sensible floor plans in the US.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by hooverd on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:33PM (#39320135)
Agreed, it's definitely a "yes, and" scenario.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by aorloff on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:58PM (#39318829)
Land value taxes assume real estate values always increase, which they don’t
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by midasuni on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:12PM (#39319035)
If the rentable price was 6k one year and 5k the next then you’d simply pay less rent for the land.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by reaperman on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:07PM (#39318948)
How is this assumption required by the LVT system? My basic reading of LVT suggests that the assessed tax value of land could increase or decrease just as the current property tax system can increase or decrease.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by SoftTalker on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:40PM (#39319478)
When is the last time your property tax valuation decreased?

Where I am the rate increases are capped but if they want more money they just work around that by increasing the valuations.