News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by bluGill on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:34PM (#39319384)
In the famous book "the Wealth of the Nations", it points out that when people get more money they typically spend it on larger/better places to live. Just looking at the historical economy of US and the rest of the world post WWII it shouldn't be a surprise that people live in larger apartments in the US in general. Larger fridges are another luxury that I'd expect in the US as well.

However this article is about people who live in apartments - in the US that means either those without a family or poor.

Those without a family may want 3 bedrooms - either for offices (his and hers) or a guest bedroom, but cannot really see need for more than that. They also want them to be large and so are happy with the current state of things.

You would expect the poor to want to compromise on smaller fridges, and bedrooms - but many would prefer to have 4 tiny bedrooms (with only beds in them), and 1 bathroom, all in the space of a current US 2 bedroom apartment. They still dream of the larger bedrooms, fridges and the like - but they well know they cannot afford it.

Like you said, fire needs to be considered. Current codes are harming the poor, but it may be less harm than from allowing fire to kill them.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jltsiren on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:58PM (#39319735)
> Like you said, fire needs to be considered. Current codes are harming the poor, but it may be less harm than from allowing fire to kill them.

The last time there was a discussion on fire codes on HN, I looked up some statistics and reports from Finland. It's a country with an unusually large number of fire deaths per capita for a developed country, because of attitudes and because saunas are common.

Almost all fire deaths happened in the unit where the fire started. Unusually deadly home fires almost always happened in single-family homes. I couldn't find any reports of fires where a second stairwell accessible from the same corridor would have prevented deaths. There were some fires where a second exit from the unit (to a different corridor) would have helped, because the fire started near the exit and people couldn't get out.

This only applies to mid-rise and low-rise buildings. There are very few residential high-rises in Finland.

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by wolverine876 on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:25PM (#39320054)
> Almost all fire deaths happened in the unit where the fire started.

That could be because of effective fire codes.

> I couldn't find any reports of fires where a second stairwell accessible from the same corridor would have prevented deaths.

Meaning, you couldn't find anything either way, or in what you found, the second stairwell wouldn't have helped?

Re:Why we can’t build family-sized apartments in North America by jltsiren on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:52PM (#39320397)
Finland is small enough that all fire deaths (50-100 / year) make it into national news. There are very few deaths reported outside the unit where the fire started. When reading reports of those outlier cases, I couldn't find a situation where a second stairwell would have helped.

Fire codes are effective and fire fighters arrive quickly enough. If you can get out of your unit, you can get out of the building. Second stairwell requirements address a risk that doesn't really exist in Finland. The real challenge is detecting a fire in your unit quickly enough to get out.