- Y-axis is "drive"
- X-axis is "aptitude"
- low drive + low aptitude: never hire
- low drive + high aptitude: hire for targeted use cases where you need expertise
- high drive + low aptitude: hire, train, and foster aptitude growth
- high drive + high aptitude: hire on the spot
There's an indirect way of testing for this which is to test for curiosity and lack of ego. My experience has been that candidates with high curiosity tend to have low ego (they know what they don't know and are curious to learn). These candidates make great hires because you can teach them anything.
Wrote about this a little bit here (with a handy diagram): https://charliedigital.com/2020/01/15/effective-hiring-for-s...
Unethical is one thing, neuroticism should not be a disqualifier from decent employment.
I assume you’re young: there are many reasons people might be perfectly good at a job but not want to socialize with those people, or any other people.
This whole thread makes me sad as an unemployed autistic person. HN folks are horrible hiring managers!
Edit: and now downvoted for showing you losers that your personal model of the world and the people in it might be lacking; fuck vc tech bros.
Not wanting to get Friday beers with the team shouldn't really be a factor.
Not being able to communicate smoothly and effectively with them in a work context absolutely is.
I suspect the poster you are responding to is focusing on the latter, and you on the former.
This is why all the talk of valuing neurodiversity is BS. The leaders want an autistic savant without the autistic part. Playing one is exhausting and can never be done perfectly.
The problem as I see it is that people tend to see communication issues as a character flaw. They don't think it's a handicap like poor vision or a broken leg, but must stem from laziness or worse.
I sometimes long for a set of different drugs that people could take that would impair their brain/body for a short time in a similar way to how people experience the world as someone with autism or adhd or whatever else. I am sure that would be a somewhat "bad" idea, but I think it could also be a help in some cases. I'm autistic myself and it took me years of learning about autism and watching my autistic child before I really grokked how much of an impairment it has been for me in my life. That I am an old man with a relatively decent life and financial position for an American is a miracle, honestly, based on what I know now. I definitely had my Swiss cheese holes line up (in a good way this time) for me to be able to sail through the cheese of life this easily so far! I am not sure I can maintain that luck now, though.
Depending on the team and project , those challenges balanced against the pluses may mean that it’s worth doing anyway , or equally they may mean that it is not. It can be exhausting for the other people involved also.
I agree that anyone treating it as a character flaw is problematic and unlikely to result in effective mitigations. There also aren’t always effective mitigations , this stuff is all pretty context dependent .
i think you're not helping your case by this comment itself being antisocial.
my use of "asocial" was specifically the very common connotation attached to it of being hostile or inconsiderate which are the exact words used when you google its definition
In a startup, lots of mistakes will be made. A team with the right vibe knows and acknowledges this, but focuses on fixing the problems rather than finger pointing.
In that sense, "vibe" is not inherent to the individual, but I like to think of it as "we're on the same wavelength" when it comes to key things. So it really means "does this person fit with this team and this mission?" -- "vibes" sums that up for me.
https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2006/10/25/the-guerrilla-guid...
- low drive + low aptitude: never hire
Hammerstein thinks some use can be made of these folks
- low drive + high aptitude: hire for targeted use cases where you need expertise
Hammerstein has this group as high leadership positions
- high drive + low aptitude: hire, train, and foster aptitude growth
These are the ones who Hammerstein avoids
- high drive + high aptitude: hire on the spot
These go to the "General Staff"
My experience has been that aptitude can be developed. In the context of "low experience" (generally junior engineers), the ones that succeed are the ones that put the work in to learn and get better.
But I can appreciate Hammerstein's perspective, especially if there isn't an added nuance of Carol Dweck's "fixed" vs "growth" mindset. A high drive, low aptitude individual -- seen through a fixed mindset lens -- is indeed dangerous!
In a military context it's plausible "don't hire" isn't an option.
The stupid and lazy can be put to work and will probably get something harmless done, they just can’t be trusted with anything challenging.
The stupid and industrious are an active danger wherever you put them in the hierarchy.
But you probably shouldn't give them passwords to the production servers.
Someone I learned much from way back called this "wattage". As in: "he's too low wattage".
These two don't really match up, they are just driven for different things I suspect.
If you ask relevant but technically hard and esoteric questions _without the expectation of an answer_ you can sometimes see it in the manner of the response. Do they probe the question? Do they explore the idea, even if they don't know the answer? Do they readily admit that they don't know?? Or do they become defensive? Do they fake their way through it? If they make a mistake and you point it out, how do they respond?
uh? tell me more
This needs to be subdivided. There are plenty of people who've had a lot of opportunity for aptitude growth, but they didn't grow. And having high energy in those circumstances really messes up a lot of stuff (they're incompetent, but jump into and be involved in everything, and you have to politely tell them to get off your project).
Implication is that if you're high-slope, you'll eventually become high-intercept.
If you're a startup, you want to bias towards a mix of high slope, low intercept and positive slope, high intercept.
I think it's also worth pointing out that people can have negative slopes (due to social reasons, ego reasons), and that slope is not invariant over a person's career but often changes.
Ideally, you want to find people whose slope is positively-impacted by the environment of the company – a great hire is only a great hire if it's a great mutual-fit, in that way.
I think the industry really wants an objective, formulaic way of identifying these individuals, but the reality is that a lot of it does still come down to subjective factors since there's so much variability along so many different facets.
What I can say personally is that I've had pretty good success hiring, but I wouldn't claim that my "intuition" can be systematically applied by anyone to achieve the same success.
If it were necessary to rely on a shaft that had grown perfectly straight, within a hundred generations there would be no arrow. If it were necessary to rely on wood that had grown perfectly round, within a thousand generations there would be no cart wheel. If a naturally straight shaft or naturally round wood cannot be found within a hundred generations, how is it that in all generations carriages are used and birds shot? Because tools are used to straighten and bend. But even if one did not rely on tools and still got a naturally straight shaft or a piece of naturally round wood, a skillful craftsman would not value this. Why? Because it is not just one person that needs to ride and not just one arrow that needs to be shot.
If you only rely on natural talent, then your pool of candidates will always be very, very small and you'll be competing against Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Apple, and so on.Better that you can identify candidates with potential and have a system of knowledge transfer and training to make them productive.
[0] https://brians.wsu.edu/2016/11/14/han-fei-tzu-d-233-bce-lega...
You meet minimum requirements on both, and if you do your contribution better exceed your high maintainance demands.
But one way to try is to wholly hand off greenfield projects within your company. The whole idea of a "startup within a company" is fundamentally flawed, but you can attempt it anyway.
If you do choose to hire this person make sure to isolate them from other. I've seen a single low drive + high aptitude person single handly ruin teams. They are a cancer.
Some candidates can't make it through an interview without being condescending to someone, making snide remarks, being arrogant, trying to start arguments about trivial things, or other negative behaviors. If they're doing this during the interview, you're only seeing the tip of the iceberg. It's going to be 100X worse when you have to deal with that person 5 days a week.
Other candidates behave well during interviews but have a history of causing social problems at other companies. It takes some work to uncover these (and, importantly, validate their veracity). Some of the most toxic people I ever worked with were very charming in interviews. They swung from company to company, leaving a trail of unhappy coworkers behind them. They could only get hired into new companies where nobody knew any of their past coworkers, because a simple reference check would reveal how difficult they were to work with.
Filtering this behavior out before someone joins the team is very important. Hiring a single socially toxic or subversive person into a team is like dropping a bomb on a healthy team dynamic. You may lose multiple good employees before you figure out what's going on and put together a case for firing the bad apple.
Asshole means different things to different people but if someone is power flexing, condescending, aggressive, uses process as a weapon, bullying etc. this is what I mean rather than say straight shooting and direct talk.
In the US, if someone only reveals that they're a tremendous asshole to months into the role, you just fire them two months into the role.
this may well be a feature of (social) economics and hence a necessary evil
Would love to hear any strategies others have found successful.
You can’t single-handedly solve the systemic problem of unequal access to opportunity.
Of course a bit of a chicken and egg with hiring the diverse team.
Are they someone that's going to disrupt your team's focus on product and execution. No? Cool.
You're choosing companion for 8h a day. Nothing wrong with checking culture fit (because that's basically what it is).
Yeah, but that's the point. Those who come from wealth bring connections. Connections are what make or break a business. A mediocre worker with rich parents is far more beneficial to the business than a standout worker that came from the slums.
the vast majority of rich people are not well-connected enough to drive any business your way. if you have a tech startup do you really care that you hired the son or daughter of a car dealership magnate from the other side of the country?
in the USA it's possible and in fact more common to become a very wealthy without becoming hugely influential.
they may be well-connected in their particular geographic region or within a certain business sector, but this would be a specific advantage which usually wouldn't benefit your business.
this may be different in some other countries, where nearly everyone wealthy is part of the same national elite group.
but generally, in America, you'd be better off hiring the better employee.
Of course! That's an incredible resource. Even if they don't specifically drive business your way, having the person's ear is something that can be leveraged to great effect. You don't exactly become a car dealership magnate without knowing a thing or two about business and they can teach your startup a lot. A magnate is more likely to chum with investors who might be interested in helping your business. The list goes on and on. Unfortunately, at least statistically, the poor parents will never be able to offer the same.
American individualism may be the American identity, but individualism doesn't get you far in business. America is not unique like you are trying to suggest.
This is an enormous stretch. I highly doubt the son of the owner of Henrysburg Chevrolet in Henrysburg, Georgia is going to bring anything to the table that a startup in San Francisco needs, purely due to his dad. You have no idea if dad knows anything about business. And if he does, you have no idea if dad taught any of it to kid. And if he did, you have no idea if any of it is relevant to developing biotech software. Nobody in the company is going to care about dad's connections to the dude that runs Henrysburg Laundromat. But sure, go hire his kid because of some vague pedigree reason.
And what is it that you think this hypothetical startup actually needs? The most motivated janitor money can buy?
> You have no idea if dad knows anything about business.
A magnate that knows nothing about business? That doesn't make any sense. A magnate is literally characterized by their involvement in business. Perhaps you mean that mom could be the magnate instead of dad? There was nothing to suggest that she isn't the magnate. It was never specified.
> And if he does, you have no idea if dad taught any of it to kid.
And? You're not hiring the kid for his business acumen. You are hiring the kid for their mediocre capabilities in whatever work you need done and using them as a connection to get in touch with the magnate of the family.
A slightly better worker isn't significant like you make it out to be. In fact, even if you do find the 'magical rockstar', chances are they'll quickly move on to the next job anyway, and then you're back to dealing with mediocre. May as well design the company around mediocre from the start. Let's be real: Startups are generally not attractive places to work as compared to the alternatives the best of the best have in front of them. If the 'rockstar' really, truly, wants to live the startup life, they are going to start their own and eat your lunch in the process.
> And if he did, you have no idea if any of it is relevant to developing biotech software.
But the advice of a welfare parent is? There are no guarantees in life, but when playing the odds that is who you are choosing?
> Nobody in the company is going to care about dad's connections to the dude that runs Henrysburg Laundromat.
Except for the person who actually has to make the business a success, not just collect a paycheck and get a new job if the business fails. They don't get to sit around writing code all day. They have to actually get out there and meet people who will move things forward.
I get it, Field of Dreams is a fun concept... for a movie. But that's not how things work in the real world. Simply building it is not enough. Business is, at the end of the day, about people.
The tech world is filled with wealthy people not wanting to believe that their wealth was a determining factor in their success. Having the social and financial stability to found a company and get money to hire people is the kind of thing that takes a degree of wealth and tends to attract people with wealth and repel people without.
I don't think people consciously choose to hire the rich kid, but the pool of people to choose from will be filled with rich kids.
> if you have a tech startup do you really care that you hired the son or daughter of a car dealership magnate from the other side of the country
If their child was able to go to an expensive prestigious school across the country and then an expensive graduate school instead of needing to work, have a larger network of friends and colleagues from those experiences, and can pay for them to have better healthcare and a nicer apartment in San Francisco because you're not able to pay enough then yes. It's more likely you're going to pick them and they'll say yes to you.
It is a super cool story to hear in what jobs somebody already has worked in and a good indicator. I worked as a dancing instructor assistant and learned so much about people. This job does not correlate with my current job as a Java/Kotlin/Android dev but was taken quite well by everyone the interviewed me 10 years back.
You just have very little time during a job interview and mistakes are costly.
> Are they smart? > Are they cool? ... Are the right questions that need to be answered, but not asked directly. The article talks especially about what to ask to get meaningful answers.
People's intuitions around hiring are extremely Bayesian, which is why we have all sorts of laws and regulations and HR departments that try to counteract various prejudicial priors.
A prior would tell you how much each of those attributes would change your viewpoint.
Having very strong priors actually means your decision won’t change unless you have very strong evidence on the contrary.
- Are they smart? (understands quickly + communicates effectively)
- Are they cool? (won't put poison in the keurig + pleasant to be around)
- Are they high energy? (initiative + action bias)
- Do they have the experience needed to be successful in the role?
Those are pretty strong priors for success. If you find someone with all the above, you've got an ~80% chance of a hit. No need to over-complicate.
In my experience, adding more boxes tends to index towards box-checkers who grew up wealthy. That's how you miss the hyper-smart/diligent state school kids who happened to spend their summers working instead of doing model UN.