News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:02AM (#39290148)
I have a 4-quardrant way of thinking about this that's similar.

- Y-axis is "drive"

- X-axis is "aptitude"

- low drive + low aptitude: never hire

- low drive + high aptitude: hire for targeted use cases where you need expertise

- high drive + low aptitude: hire, train, and foster aptitude growth

- high drive + high aptitude: hire on the spot

There's an indirect way of testing for this which is to test for curiosity and lack of ego. My experience has been that candidates with high curiosity tend to have low ego (they know what they don't know and are curious to learn). These candidates make great hires because you can teach them anything.

Wrote about this a little bit here (with a handy diagram): https://charliedigital.com/2020/01/15/effective-hiring-for-s...

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by smeeth on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:10AM (#39290266)
I like this, but I do think it misses the social stuff. Just a few neurotic/unethical people can completely ruin a team and make all the best people quit. I find this to be extra true on diverse teams (all types of diversity).
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by jprete on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:11PM (#39291122)
As nineplay@ remarked elsewhere, "there's a nauseating bias here against people who've had horrific childhoods".

Unethical is one thing, neuroticism should not be a disqualifier from decent employment.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by 93po on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:37PM (#39291509)
neuroticism, no. asocial or antisocial behavior, yes.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ok_dad on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:32PM (#39292303)
Asocial? I guess autistic people are out!

I assume you’re young: there are many reasons people might be perfectly good at a job but not want to socialize with those people, or any other people.

This whole thread makes me sad as an unemployed autistic person. HN folks are horrible hiring managers!

Edit: and now downvoted for showing you losers that your personal model of the world and the people in it might be lacking; fuck vc tech bros.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ska on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:27PM (#39293039)
I suspect you may be interpreting this a bit too broadly, and it's obviously personal for you. Part of work is, nearly invariably, social.

Not wanting to get Friday beers with the team shouldn't really be a factor.

Not being able to communicate smoothly and effectively with them in a work context absolutely is.

I suspect the poster you are responding to is focusing on the latter, and you on the former.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ok_dad on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:04PM (#39296539)
That’s a good insight there, thanks
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by khzw8yyy on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:07PM (#39319863)
Then there are some of us for whom this smooth communication is a huge challenge. We spend a lot of time and energy masking, trying to fake the perfect vibe (and failing of course, because the result is predictably unnatural), but this is a necessary survival tactic.

This is why all the talk of valuing neurodiversity is BS. The leaders want an autistic savant without the autistic part. Playing one is exhausting and can never be done perfectly.

The problem as I see it is that people tend to see communication issues as a character flaw. They don't think it's a handicap like poor vision or a broken leg, but must stem from laziness or worse.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ok_dad on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:50PM (#39320369)
Thanks for writing it in a clearer way than I could write it.

I sometimes long for a set of different drugs that people could take that would impair their brain/body for a short time in a similar way to how people experience the world as someone with autism or adhd or whatever else. I am sure that would be a somewhat "bad" idea, but I think it could also be a help in some cases. I'm autistic myself and it took me years of learning about autism and watching my autistic child before I really grokked how much of an impairment it has been for me in my life. That I am an old man with a relatively decent life and financial position for an American is a miracle, honestly, based on what I know now. I definitely had my Swiss cheese holes line up (in a good way this time) for me to be able to sail through the cheese of life this easily so far! I am not sure I can maintain that luck now, though.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ska on Monday February 12, 2024 @04:47PM (#39350980)
I get that, really I do.

Depending on the team and project , those challenges balanced against the pluses may mean that it’s worth doing anyway , or equally they may mean that it is not. It can be exhausting for the other people involved also.

I agree that anyone treating it as a character flaw is problematic and unlikely to result in effective mitigations. There also aren’t always effective mitigations , this stuff is all pretty context dependent .

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by 93po on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:34AM (#39302349)
i'm mid-late 30s and neurodivergent myself.

i think you're not helping your case by this comment itself being antisocial.

my use of "asocial" was specifically the very common connotation attached to it of being hostile or inconsiderate which are the exact words used when you google its definition

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by dr_dshiv on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:07AM (#39298818)
It’s not about disqualification. We aren’t considering who we have to legally hire. We are thinking about what makes for great hires. Given the choice between neuroticism or no, why choose neuroticism?
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:32AM (#39290592)
Yes, I now call this "vibes".
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by babyshake on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:18AM (#39298876)
This is an interesting area because there's a lot of room for debate about what a good "vibe" is. Is being really positive all the time the right vibe? In many/most office environments, it is considered to be the right vibe. In a small startup where you're trying to validate PMF, it's not necessarily the best vibe IMO.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:16AM (#39302866)
"Vibe" isn't so easy defined as being positive; more like the way you interact feels "natural" and doesn't lead to negative emotions.

In a startup, lots of mistakes will be made. A team with the right vibe knows and acknowledges this, but focuses on fixing the problems rather than finger pointing.

In that sense, "vibe" is not inherent to the individual, but I like to think of it as "we're on the same wavelength" when it comes to key things. So it really means "does this person fit with this team and this mission?" -- "vibes" sums that up for me.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by brianmcc on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:52AM (#39290868)
High on both sounds like Spolsky's "Smart and Gets Things Done", and not surprisingly your conclusions rather agree :-)

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2006/10/25/the-guerrilla-guid...

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by walthamstow on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:32AM (#39290598)
Aren't these quadrants from about 100 years ago? Some Prussian General von Whatshisname?
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by Tangurena2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:26PM (#39291325)
They're simply 2-variable Karnaugh maps. Widely used in logic design in electrical engineering.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karnaugh_map

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by walthamstow on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:17PM (#39292081)
I mean the smart/dumb lazy/hardworking axes, not the underlying concept
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by conro1108 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:28PM (#39292249)
It's a similar shape but with quite different conclusions

- low drive + low aptitude: never hire

Hammerstein thinks some use can be made of these folks

- low drive + high aptitude: hire for targeted use cases where you need expertise

Hammerstein has this group as high leadership positions

- high drive + low aptitude: hire, train, and foster aptitude growth

These are the ones who Hammerstein avoids

- high drive + high aptitude: hire on the spot

These go to the "General Staff"

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:06PM (#39292786)
> These are the ones who Hammerstein avoids

My experience has been that aptitude can be developed. In the context of "low experience" (generally junior engineers), the ones that succeed are the ones that put the work in to learn and get better.

But I can appreciate Hammerstein's perspective, especially if there isn't an added nuance of Carol Dweck's "fixed" vs "growth" mindset. A high drive, low aptitude individual -- seen through a fixed mindset lens -- is indeed dangerous!

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by MichaelZuo on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:50PM (#39293359)
"A high drive, low aptitude individual", even if they have the best mindset in the world, shouldn't be placed in a sensitive position. As even a small chance of messing up with 'high drive' will really cause a lot of issues.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:07PM (#39294327)
These are generally junior-level engineers so it's a non-sequitur.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by MichaelZuo on Friday February 09, 2024 @08:37PM (#39322648)
Except when it’s not… when it becomes the most damaging, e.g. HP
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ska on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:29PM (#39293077)
> Hammerstein thinks some use can be made of these folks

In a military context it's plausible "don't hire" isn't an option.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by DoughnutHole on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:26PM (#39296697)
Well he seems to advocate getting rid of the stupid and industrious.

The stupid and lazy can be put to work and will probably get something harmless done, they just can’t be trusted with anything challenging.

The stupid and industrious are an active danger wherever you put them in the hierarchy.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by harperlee on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:49AM (#39300139)
At the risk of sounding like a LinkedIn post, it seems clear that the difference between General von Hammerstein and CharlieDigital is whether they have a fixed vs. growth mindset about their potential team.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by Viliam1234 on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:59AM (#39302660)
Another difference is that in a software company, "high drive + low aptitude" people usually don't cause anyone's death.

But you probably shouldn't give them passwords to the production servers.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by dboreham on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:36AM (#39290659)
> Y-axis is "drive"

Someone I learned much from way back called this "wattage". As in: "he's too low wattage".

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by agumonkey on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:25AM (#39290489)
out of curiosity, do you often run into low aptitude + low drive but highly politically skilled ? do they get caught early ?
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:42AM (#39290740)
It has happened. But generally, at least in tech, it is possible to filter this out with a good tech screen.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by ska on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:30PM (#39293090)
> low drive but highly politically skilled

These two don't really match up, they are just driven for different things I suspect.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by agumonkey on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:05PM (#39297957)
low drive toward efforts :)
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by powerset on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:06AM (#39290197)
How do you test for curiosity?
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:47AM (#39290805)
Curiosity and ego seem to be inversely correlated.

If you ask relevant but technically hard and esoteric questions _without the expectation of an answer_ you can sometimes see it in the manner of the response. Do they probe the question? Do they explore the idea, even if they don't know the answer? Do they readily admit that they don't know?? Or do they become defensive? Do they fake their way through it? If they make a mistake and you point it out, how do they respond?

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by PartiallyTyped on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:26AM (#39290510)
You take the person off the beaten path in the interview.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by pvaldes on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:44AM (#39304165)
> How do you test for curiosity?

uh? tell me more

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by BeetleB on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:44PM (#39292475)
> high drive + low aptitude: hire, train, and foster aptitude growth

This needs to be subdivided. There are plenty of people who've had a lot of opportunity for aptitude growth, but they didn't grow. And having high energy in those circumstances really messes up a lot of stuff (they're incompetent, but jump into and be involved in everything, and you have to politely tell them to get off your project).

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by gen220 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:06PM (#39293575)
This is The Way™! I've heard this alternatively described as "slope" (for drive, which incorporates the curiosity, lack of ego, excitability) and "intercept" for "aptitude".

Implication is that if you're high-slope, you'll eventually become high-intercept.

If you're a startup, you want to bias towards a mix of high slope, low intercept and positive slope, high intercept.

I think it's also worth pointing out that people can have negative slopes (due to social reasons, ego reasons), and that slope is not invariant over a person's career but often changes.

Ideally, you want to find people whose slope is positively-impacted by the environment of the company – a great hire is only a great hire if it's a great mutual-fit, in that way.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:10PM (#39294364)
Both can definitely change over time and that change can be influenced by a variety of factors including the types of projects, company culture, "vibes" with the rest of the team, and so on.

I think the industry really wants an objective, formulaic way of identifying these individuals, but the reality is that a lot of it does still come down to subjective factors since there's so much variability along so many different facets.

What I can say personally is that I've had pretty good success hiring, but I wouldn't claim that my "intuition" can be systematically applied by anyone to achieve the same success.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by nerdponx on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:17PM (#39293697)
But aptitude can be split into "experience" and "natural talent", which are different things and I think that's meant to be the whole point of the article.
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by CharlieDigital on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:22AM (#39302943)
In Chinese philosophy, there is a school of thought called "legalism" that was founded by Han Fei-tzu. There is a piece of writing in there that I'm quite fond of [0]:

   If it were necessary to rely on a shaft that had grown perfectly straight, within a hundred generations there would be no arrow. If it were necessary to rely on wood that had grown perfectly round, within a thousand generations there would be no cart wheel. If a naturally straight shaft or naturally round wood cannot be found within a hundred generations, how is it that in all generations carriages are used and birds shot? Because tools are used to straighten and bend. But even if one did not rely on tools and still got a naturally straight shaft or a piece of naturally round wood, a skillful craftsman would not value this. Why? Because it is not just one person that needs to ride and not just one arrow that needs to be shot.
If you only rely on natural talent, then your pool of candidates will always be very, very small and you'll be competing against Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Apple, and so on.

Better that you can identify candidates with potential and have a system of knowledge transfer and training to make them productive.

[0] https://brians.wsu.edu/2016/11/14/han-fei-tzu-d-233-bce-lega...

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by PeterStuer on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:46AM (#39300122)
I'd go with the crazy/hot axis myself.

You meet minimum requirements on both, and if you do your contribution better exceed your high maintainance demands.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by intelVISA on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:54PM (#39307557)
how do you keep 'high drive + high aptitude' from escaping to run their own venture?
Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by stanleydrew on Thursday February 08, 2024 @06:16PM (#39309132)
You don't. You just harness what they have and direct it while you can.

But one way to try is to wholly hand off greenfield projects within your company. The whole idea of a "startup within a company" is fundamentally flawed, but you can attempt it anyway.

Re:How to hire low experience, high potential people by astura on Sunday February 11, 2024 @10:01AM (#39335417)
>low drive + high aptitude: hire for targeted use cases where you need expertise

If you do choose to hire this person make sure to isolate them from other. I've seen a single low drive + high aptitude person single handly ruin teams. They are a cancer.