News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by AlexandrB on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:39AM (#39091527)
It's constantly frustrating to read about European users getting cool new features to help manage their digital life that the rest of the world doesn't get. The expected cost in lost ad revenue per user must be pretty significant to justify the complexity of keeping this stuff limited to Europe.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by miohtama on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:25PM (#39092260)
There are also downside for European regulations. There is no free lunch and some toll needs to be paid.

Some examples include

- Banning encrypted messaging (almost passed)

- Cookie pop ups

- Various regulations harming open source (discussed before on HN)

Also due to how Europe is wired up, the cost of doing startup business is higher, why there are fewer and fewer successful European software growth companies.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by ko27 on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:46PM (#39093540)
Your examples are terrible, which probably proves the point that EU users are getting more than they are losing. Btw Europe != EU.

> Banning encrypted messaging (almost passed)

It's a positive thing that it was brought up and struck down. EU is the actually the one you should be thanking because most European countries would ban it.

> Cookie pop ups

Malicious compliance by websites, but at least users have a choice of opting out of tracking. Again, a positive thing.

> Various regulations harming open source (discussed before on HN)

The most recent changes are so watered down that it basically only applies to commercial open source companies that are turning a profit. It's helping users more than it's harming the open source community.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by pronik on Monday January 22, 2024 @03:50PM (#39095251)
>> Banning encrypted messaging (almost passed)

> It's a positive thing that it was brought up and struck down.

You see, the thing about european legislation is that certain stuff, especially stuff people oppose, is proposed over and over again until it passes. It costs almost nothing to re-propose things like killing net neutrality or banning end-to-end encryption, but it's very costly to oppose them. Which the politicians and lobbyists know and use to their advantage.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by jonkoops on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:42PM (#39095886)
Well at least people's voices are being heard, not something I can say for every country, federation, or union.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Vinnl on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:35PM (#39096497)
That does not sound particularly specific to the EU to me?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by extraduder_ire on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:27AM (#39115748)
I don't think the EU has ever had net-neutrality as you'd call it in the US. The infrastructure and internet service are separated in most places which has similar outcomes. (and mobile data is wicked cheap for other reasons)

Most notably, this means a bunch of stuff gets "zero-rated" (e.g. free unlimited facebook/whatsapp with any phone plan, but other data is limited), which was explicitly called out as anti-competitive when the fight was going on about net neutrality in the states.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Vinnl on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:37PM (#39121691)
I believe zero-rating was contested in at least one EU country (the Netherlands) as well. I can find at least one source, which also references net neutrality legislation: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-deutsche-telekom-netherla...
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by whywhywhywhy on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:55PM (#39093670)
> Malicious compliance by websites

If the legislation had been written correctly then the current nightmare wouldn’t exist.

Should have been a browser level setting the sites are forced to comply with. The pop-up per site with free rein how obtuse it can work was always gonna suck. Pure incompetence from the politicians involved.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by imiric on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:06PM (#39093843)
This is always brought up when EU cookie regulations are discussed. If only the EU consulted HN readers...

It's true, though. The technical language could've been written in a way that makes it more difficult for websites to circumvent, and less annoying for users. Or the regulation could've been amended to clarify and improve the technical aspects.

That said, getting to a regulation at all was probably a bigger nightmare, with Big Tech lobbying against it every step of the way. So I'm glad that we even have the current GDPR, and that the EU is still leading the way in privacy regulations globally.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by varispeed on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:44PM (#39094357)
The cookie regulation was designed to train people to "Agree" without reading.

It was a prerequisite step for GDPR that was designed to legalise data collection and trading.

Before GDPR it was a gray area, now companies can easily get consent as users mindlessly click "Agree" to data processing and selling and they have a legal basis to do so.

These are corrupt laws, but most people blindly believe EU is good and totally not in bed with big corporations.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by imiric on Monday January 22, 2024 @03:07PM (#39094689)
> The cookie regulation was designed to train people to "Agree" without reading.

That's a cynical take. In reality, companies took advantage of the loose technical language to do the least possible work to comply with the law, while doing their best to implement dark patterns to confuse the user into clicking "Agree". This is something that can be improved with stricter regulation, but it will always be a cat and mouse game.

> It was a prerequisite step for GDPR that was designed to legalise data collection and trading.

Another cynical, and also false, take. The GDPR wasn't "designed" for that. In fact, it actively tries to prevent it. An EU citizen can contact any company in the EU and demand to access all their personal data, or for it to be deleted. This is an unequivocal win for people to regain control over their personal information.

Is this the best that governments can do? Certainly not. I'm still glad that at least something exists, and the tech industry is not entirely unregulated, as in most other parts of the world.

> These are corrupt laws

No. These laws are a step in the right direction. Unfortunately, the strong influence and rapid pace of development of the tech industry means that governments will always play catch up, even when they want to pass laws that protect their citizens.

> most people blindly believe EU is good and totally not in bed with big corporations.

Citation needed. Name me a government that is not in bed with Big <industry>. Big Tech in particular is in strong symbiosis with governments, as they both share some common goals. So, sure, there's that. And yet despite of it, the EU still passes laws that fight Big Tech's reach, and fines companies when they don't comply. Can it do better? Sure. But name me a government on Earth that does a better job at this than the EU.

We don't need to get political here. But it's foolish to spew cynical takes when some governments are at least trying to fight Big Tech, and even more foolish to imply that their attempts are making things worse for its citizens.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by akie on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:54AM (#39100658)
You have clearly not seen the amount of people who click "deny all" or "only statistics". Before the GDPR _everyone_ had to accept _everything_ a website sent their way and didn't have a say in it, after the GDPR only 33% of people click "accept all" on the cookie banner for the fairly large e-commerce site I work at.

If the goal of the GDPR was to train people to click "Agree" and to legalise data collection, then that law was an abject failure.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by varispeed on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:09AM (#39102341)
How do you know that only 33% click accept all if you are not meant to track those who deny?

That said 33% of consent, legal to be sold is better than 100% of gray area.

Before GDPR you didn't have explicit consent and you still could be on the hook for trading personal data.

The system is working as intended.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by sofixa on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:21AM (#39102959)
> How do you know that only 33% click accept all if you are not meant to track those who deny?

Without tracking it's easy to:

a) compare the total number of visitors vs those who accepted tracking

b) just increase a counter for each "No"

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by rakoo on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:04PM (#39096821)
> and less annoying for users.

You seem to be inverting cause and consequence: it's the websites who are annoying to the users, not the law. The banner is optional, it only exists because websites want to collect your private data, not even to make the thing work.

> Or the regulation could've been amended to clarify and improve the technical aspects.

The regulation has been clarified to mean something important: refusal must be as easy, visible and doable as acceptance, so people can click "refuse" everywhere. Lack of acceptance mean refusal, so people can close the banner.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by imiric on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:14PM (#39097500)
> You seem to be inverting cause and consequence: it's the websites who are annoying to the users, not the law.

No, I mean that the law could've been written in a way that makes giving consent less cumbersome for users. I agree with GP: if it had been a browser setting that websites _must_ comply with, like the abused and now dead DoNotTrack header, then we wouldn't have ended up with annoying consent forms to begin with. After all, it does make sense for this to be a global user preference, rather than something the user needs to consent to on each site. Even without getting into technical details, this should be evident to anyone.

I'm not aware of why this didn't happen, or why the DNT header was killed, but it wouldn't surprise me if the (ad)tech industry strongly lobbied against it, and won. The internet loves to criticize this oversight as incompetence from politicians, but politicians couldn't have elaborated the technical aspects of the law without IT consultants, and these surely understood what could be the implications. The fact they went with the consent form approach, and the fact this hasn't been rectified years later, is probably a sign that the tech industry still has considerable sway in regulatory matters.

But to blame this situation on the law itself, or the EU, is just delusional. I'm still happy it exists, warts and all.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by rakoo on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:11AM (#39101147)
But nothing prevents browsers from doing so ! In fact you can even configure your browser to never show those popups, and everything is fine. Everytime I switch people over to Firefox I install ublock origin and the list that blocks cookie popups: https://jasonmurray.org/posts/2020/cookies/ (there are even more settings to block even more popups today)

Actually Google is seeing the wind turn and is slowly moving away from cookies, so it did even better than what you wanted: it will effectively kill (unnecessary) cookies as a whole.

I have no issue believing lawmakers did in fact take advices from IT experts, seeing how they could make the difference between useful and unuseful cookies. But the law never goes into implementation details, that's another level of regulation, and the real effect is coming: the major browser will block third-party cookies. That will change everything.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by troupo on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:08PM (#39096191)
> If the legislation had been written correctly then the current nightmare wouldn’t exist.

It was written correctly. Because it's a General Data Protection Regulation. It applies in equal measure to websites, apps, paper records, SaaS, shops, government entities etc.

And it says: "do not get more data than is required for your business. If you want more data, the user must give consent, where opting out is the default, and must be as easy as opting in".

Now, what exactly is badly written in the law? You can start with quoting exactly where it requires existing cookie popups.

For example, GitHub found out they need exactly none: https://github.blog/2020-12-17-no-cookie-for-you/

> Should have been a browser level setting the sites are forced to comply with.

It's called the Do Not Track header, and at one point Safari removed it because the companies you think are blameless used it to track users

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by phatfish on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:07PM (#39096857)
It works fine now, many sites i visit have a "Deny All" button which was how it was supposed to work. Initially, (inevitably) private corporations found a way to subvert the spirit of the law to their benefit.

Getting the legalise of legislation right first time is almost impossible when there is an army of lawyers, paid by corporations, whose job it is to unpick it.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by klabb3 on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:57PM (#39097335)
> It works fine now […] many sites i visit have a "Deny All" button

That’s not fine. It’s anti-thetical to the very idea of the web. Accepting this shit as a compromise is exactly what we did with adblockers and that battle is still ongoing, and not solved. Whenever the greasy finger of corporations end up inside our browsers, whether it’s fingerprinting or meaningless consent screens, or tracking cookies/pixels/scripts, things are not dandy, imo. I don’t have a solution. Just saying.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by jocoda on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:22AM (#39100507)
> "... anti-thetical to to the very idea of the web"

I'm genuinely curious and not trying to pick a fight here. The core idea behind html when it was first conceived was that it allowed you as the viewer to present that info in any way that you chose. You can change the font, etc to suit your own preferences.

This idea got killed by content providers who mostly want to hardwire their content layout because they know better. So where is this "idea of the web" coming from. Surely there's no longer a central core idea, it's just what each of us make of it, and as a result we're often in conflict about how things go.

Did choice get formally taken away? Does the content provider get to choose how it's done now?

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by klabb3 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @09:45AM (#39103968)
> So where is this "idea of the web" coming from. Surely there's no longer a central core idea

Like with “democracy”, it is not possible to create a comprehensive formal definition that embodies the full spirit of the idea. Without getting too philosophical, the web is client-server based where the provider controls the server, and the user controls the client. There are fierce battles being fought on both fronts:

- Providers are being lured by ad tech giving you a free (as in beer) space in exchange for relinquishing any control of the server. An example would be YouTube where you get free hosting if you comply with opaque community guidelines and strike systems. Limiting linking to other “platforms” aka websites is another example. A more subtle example would be cloud infrastructure where switching provider is designed to be prohibitive.

- Users are under attack based on their IP geo, VPN usage, extensions (ad-blockers primarily), fingerprinting, UA sniffing, JS obfuscation, video DRM etc. The most egregious example is to force users to download an app (a client that the provider controls fully). Captchas is a more subtle example.

Note that there are real hard problems with a healthy web, notably DOS protection, which needs some level of client fingerprinting (like IP rate limiting).

However, large businesses – many of whose success is built entirely on top of the web – are actively eroding it for banal selfish reasons. Much like how democracy can be leveraged by those who don’t believe in it in order to gain traction, only to later be dismantled to maintain power and control.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by palata on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:04PM (#39097400)
> If the legislation had been written correctly then the current nightmare wouldn’t exist.

Legislation is not a technical spec. It's made purposely to be interpreted. And companies are made to optimize their profit given the constraints set by the law. Sometimes companies have to bet that if they do X, they won't get a fine, and decide if they want to take that risk.

Companies can even bet that the fine will be smaller than the profit, which is often the case. And that, IMHO, is the problem: we (I mean our governments) should be much, much more aggressive with the fines. BigTech can basically do anything they want because the fines are always ridiculous (because BigTech are too big, sure).

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by CaptainZapp on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:09AM (#39101139)
Well, if this scum, which is adware companies, would have respected the Do-Not-Track flag set in the browser this wouldn't have been necessary.

Now, would it?

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by varispeed on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:40PM (#39094317)
> It's a positive thing that it was brought up

No it's not. People should be fired for proposing such things as they breach human rights.

It's like being happy that someone proposed genocide of all men over 60 to save on pensions and that the idea didn't pass.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by aqfamnzc on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:28PM (#39095726)
Perhaps GP meant that the end result is a net good, since now it's in the books that it was positively, explicitly struck down? (Rather than being ambiguous or assumed, with no records etc.)

Anyway, reading sibling comments it seems like it's not that simple either way.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by sofixa on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:19PM (#39093121)
> Various regulations harming open source (discussed before on HN)

But coming from a good idea - make vendors responsible for the software they put out, to prevent tons of abusive practices like shutting of cloud services making paperweights, or never updating massively holed software harder. The ramifications for open source were then realised, and the legislation which is still under planning/review has been drastically updated to make it more applicable for open source software.

> Banning encrypted messaging (almost passed)

But didn't?

> Also due to how Europe is wired up, the cost of doing startup business is higher, why there are fewer and fewer successful European software growth companies.

Which has little to do with regulations, much more to do with the size and wealth of the potential markets.

> why there are fewer and fewer successful European software growth companies

Is that bad though? Are software "growth" companies a requirement for something? There are tons of successful software companies in various European countries, just not at the level of their American counterparts. Again, with quote obvious reasoning - there are 4x the people in the US compared to France (which is top 2 by population in the EU), and Americans both earn and spend more in USD not adjusted for anything.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by mderazon on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:45PM (#39095913)
Also lately, getting the newest LLMs features much later than the rest of the world, or not getting them at all
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by akie on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:23PM (#39093171)
> Also due to how Europe is wired up, the cost of doing startup business is higher, why there are fewer and fewer successful European software growth companies.

I really believe the primary reason is that Europe is not one culturally homogeneous area that speaks one language - like the US. Having that is such a huge benefit.

Doing marketing, promo, getting traction, legal documents, taxes, - anything - for your startup in your ONE country is already difficult. Now imagine doing it in 25 countries before you get to have scale benefits equal to the US or China.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by berkes on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:29PM (#39095735)
Exactly. We are building a platform that helps founders generate a sales strategy in the EU. We're half a year in and almost tackled "how to write good emails to Dutch prospects". Next up is Flemish, which has the same language, but a very different business culture. With luck, we have then captured a few percent of the EU tech market.

Germany is so different, that we'll need to hire several experts for the different regions in Germany. France too. Italy and Spain, unattainable (we are told) without at least a local branch and solid local staff. That's still only a portion of the EU.

"Cookie banners" are not the reason tech is hard in Europe. If you believe that, you really don't know anything about Europe or the EU.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by dataking on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:41PM (#39099722)
> I really believe the primary reason is that Europe is not one culturally homogeneous area that speaks one language

There are likely several reasons at play, culture being a big one. However, there are other reasons at play such as differences in law, financing, immigration, the job market. Bert Huber, an entrepreneur in the EU has given this some thought:

https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/is-europe-just-not-good-at...

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by airstrike on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:30PM (#39092344)
Cookie popups are a net positive because users are given a choice. Besides, in the US we often still get the popups but they're just useless, with the only option being "accept"
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by mderazon on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:50PM (#39095974)
I don't know. The web is pretty unbearable here in the EU due to the cookies consent.

Even more, many times I find myself wondering why a site is not responsive to my clicks just to find out there's some hidden cookie consent that didn't fire up properly and now I have to inspect the DOM to remove it manually.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by alwayslikethis on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:39PM (#39092516)
Unpopular opinion: the proper place to controll cookies is from the browser, not from the website. Browsers should show a prominent way to disable or otherwise restrict persistent storage to websites to inhibit tracking.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by ulucs on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:12PM (#39093031)
DNT exists, and the cookie banners did not need to be regulated into existence if the websites did not strategically ignore the DNT header.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by whatshisface on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:29PM (#39093283)
Why not regulate the DNT header into expressing the user's cookie banner preferences?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by shortsunblack on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:24PM (#39095667)
DNT specification does not allow for giving valid consent under GDPR because it is not granular and it is not informed. There's no browser dialogue that details the requested consent for which and what processing.

There are proposed browser signal specifications that would meet legal GDPR consent defintions. See https://www.dataprotectioncontrol.org/spec/

And as for why DNT did not took off, it's because MSFT sabotaged it by making DNT set by default in Internet Explorer. The social contract in that time between adtech, publishers and users was that the signal would strictly be opt-in. The adtech industry used IE making DNT the default as justification for not honoring any of the signals being sent by browsers. It doesn't take a lot of reasoning to realize MSFT did this on purpose, knowing it itself earns income from ads.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by progval on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:40PM (#39093446)
GDPR does not specify what technology to use to acquire consent [1], as long as the user consent. Trackers could honor the DNT header if they wanted to, and show the banner as a fallback for browsers not sending the header.

[1] You can read the text: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj there is a single instance of "cookie" (in the preamble) and no instance of "banner".

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Aloisius on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:39PM (#39094295)
> Consent should be given by a clear affirmative act establishing a freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject's agreement to the processing of personal data relating to him or her, such as by a written statement, including by electronic means, or an oral statement. This could include ticking a box when visiting an internet website, choosing technical settings for information society services or another statement or conduct which clearly indicates in this context the data subject's acceptance of the proposed processing of his or her personal data. Silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity should not therefore constitute consent.

While DNT could potentially be used for opt-out, it wouldn't comply for opt-in because it is not specific or informed as the user does not know what specific data processing activities will be done, can't opt-in or out of specific data processing activities, doesn't know the identity of those doing them or that they can withdraw consent at any time.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by progval on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:56PM (#39108854)
Indeed, that's a good point
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by petre on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:47PM (#39093560)
I've checked and sadly it's listed as deprecated on MDN. I don't know if there's anything to replace it.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by latexr on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:58PM (#39093728)
But it was deprecated precisely because websites either ignored it or used it as yet another signal to identify users (thus making it have the opposite effect to what was intended).
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by shortsunblack on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:20PM (#39095617)
Neither GDPR nor ePrivacy directive demands cookie walls. ePrivacy directive demands consent. That consent can be given programmatically by browser APIs. There's even acknowledgement of such possibillity in the legal text (see point 7 in the directive). GDPR itself does not demand cookie banners, either. It merely demands there to be a legal basis for processing of data that constitutes personal data. One of those bases is consent. It's not the only basis. Other notable basis includes contractual necessity (includes all the cookies that are necessary for user experience, i.e sth like PHP placed session cookie).

Browsers do not have automated means to give consent/not give consent under ePrivacy because the largest browser is ran by an ad company. Monetarily speaking, the ad company earns more if it coerces its users with dark patterns into giving consent under ePrivacy than it does offering pro-user choice technologies to give a blanket not consent.

And ePrivacy itself is not just about cookies. EDPB recently released binding recommendations that severely expanded the perceived scope of ePrivacy (the true scope was always as it is, the adtech industry just ignored it). ePrivacy includes JavaScript side tracking, fingerprinting with various APIs and so on. It's not just cookies.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by xigoi on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:08PM (#39092978)
The problem is that you can’t tell if the site actually needs the cookies to work properly. And it does not help against other kinds of tracking.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by tgv on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:33PM (#39093339)
Tell that to the Chrome team.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by summerlight on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:29PM (#39094174)
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/62052c52e90e0...

You probably want to tell that to CMA first.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by weberer on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:04PM (#39096143)
I use uMatrix for that. I have it set to block all cross-domain cookies by default.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by miohtama on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:46PM (#39096614)
Your opinion should be more popular. Seems like even a lot of technically savvy readers on HN miss this.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by EasyMark on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:28PM (#39097633)
I mean there are extensions like "consent-o-matic" that auto answer for you, but the law doesn't require any functions like that in a browser. I suppose it was a compromise between business interests and consumer advocates when they worked out the law for the EU?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Xelbair on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:42AM (#39101739)
It was done, and turns out that piece of info was just used as an additional data point for tracking.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by flohofwoe on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:28PM (#39092302)
The cookie banner isn't required if the web page isn't doing shady things with cookies though.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by poszlem on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:36PM (#39093402)
"shady things"
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by tester756 on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:02PM (#39095388)
>- Cookie pop ups

Websites do not have to show cookie pop ups if they are using only technical cookies like auth tokens.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by TheCoreh on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:34PM (#39094230)
What's frustrating is that we get the annoying things like the cookie popups everywhere but the beneficial stuff is somehow properly region locked to inside the EU?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by gherkinnn on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:48PM (#39092672)
Obtrusive cookie banners are somewhere between malicious compliance or a sign of shady business practices. Now that I see it spelt out like this, they are always a sign of scumbag companies.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by shp0ngle on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:07PM (#39092964)
They are present even literally on the pages of the EU organs that proposed them.

Go to European Commision page - bam, cookie banner.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by troupo on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:15PM (#39096272)
Compare a clear "allow cookies/allow only essential" to the industry standard wall of "we care about your privacy, so we sell your data to thousands of trackers that you have to opt out of manually"

Though yes, government services shouldn't use anything but essential cookies (for which you don't need a cookie popup)

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by shp0ngle on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:13PM (#39096907)
That's switching goalposts.

You said only scammy businesses have cookie banners... no, all websites have cookie banners now in EU, and it's majorly annoying, unless you use extensions that click it for you.

(The most popular one is owned by Avast. Which is a horrible company that sells users data. So... yay?)

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by troupo on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:32AM (#39100240)
> You said only scammy businesses have cookie banners

I didn't

> all websites have cookie banners now in EU

All the sites that collect more data than strictly necessary, yes.

Here's an example of a website that spent need a cookie banner: https://github.blog/2020-12-17-no-cookie-for-you/

> The most popular one is owned by Avast. Which is a horrible company that sells users data

Indeed. This should tell you all you need to know about these cookie popups and companies that use Avast's, or IAB's or Admiral's cookie popups.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by troupo on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:11PM (#39096225)
> fewer and fewer successful European software growth companies.

It's funny how you slipped in "growth companies" in there.

How about... profitable companies? In the past 10-15 years most "successful" US companies have been fueled by unlimited investor money with zero expectations of profits. I mean, look at YC's "top startups list". They lose billions of dollars every year. But sure, they grow. Like cancer

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by EasyMark on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:24PM (#39097600)
I've always been curious if you offer a service for profit, but don't want to adhere to EU laws (obviously just avoiding EU customers at all). Is it enough to block EU country IP addresses so that Interpol doesn't get the Feds to kick in your door and turn you over to them for prosecution or freeze all your bank accounts for not sticking to the many Internet laws that you might not be familiar with? Is anyone aware of how to deal with fire walling off countries where you don't want to deal with the legalese?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by camillomiller on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:36AM (#39100574)
Or, there are fewer overinflated unicorns that produce no societal value at all and exist solely as a marketing-fueled VC bet that will make a limited amount of people ultrarich relatively fast while the rest of us shoulders the social, economic, and financial burden of their efforts. Potato, potato.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by cnity on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:43AM (#39091589)
FWIW, we also get non-stop cookie permission banners and often just straight-up denied access to certain services that don't want to have to jump through the hoops.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by patrickmcnamara on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:50AM (#39091674)
The only things I've been denied as an EU citizen on the web so far have been US local news websites. And tbh I assume that is just one company that has a blanken policy of sorts. So I don't think "often" is accurate here.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by whatshisface on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:31PM (#39093305)
That's just the secret program to get Europeans to stop making fun of us.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by blackbeans on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:52AM (#39091704)
If you don't want to deal with cookie banners, there are browser extensions you can install to automatically accept them. However, although the cookie banners are sometimes a nuisance, it is still a good thing that people are informed and given the option to accept it or not.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by stavros on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:57AM (#39091803)
I agree in general, but when I see a dialog box titled "We respect your privacy" and a choice between "allow all" or "see more", I donate 0.10 € to NOYB.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by vdaea on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:00PM (#39091855)
If anything, every time I have to click through one of those banners I wish that activist organisations/politicians had to pay me for having to go through it.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Yujf on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:07PM (#39091967)
It is not the activists fault that the company wants to track you. They do not have to show you that stuff if they don't so unnecessary tracking
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by stavros on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:02PM (#39091893)
You can get an extension that will automatically click "allow all" and everything will be exactly as it was before this directive.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by vdaea on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:06PM (#39091953)
I wish that was true, but those extensions are far from flawless. Still, they are a massive improvement over having to click away all banners, especially for those of us who have our browsers set to clear cookies when quitting the browser.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Filligree on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:35PM (#39092444)
I want one that automatically rejects all.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by stavros on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:24PM (#39093193)
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by latexr on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:09PM (#39093882)
Emphasis mine:

> In most cases, the add-on just blocks or hides cookie related pop-ups. When it's needed for the website to work properly, it will automatically accept the cookie policy for you (sometimes it will accept all and sometimes only necessary cookie categories, depending on what's easier to do).

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by alwayslikethis on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:41PM (#39092541)
You can disable cookies in browsers so that cookies do not persist after session close. Firefox lets you add a whitelist of sites to allow cookies, too.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by probably_wrong on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:28PM (#39093258)
If I understand the law correctly, your suggestion is good on practice but could be harmful on the long run.

When I click "I agree" I am not agreeing to cookies but rather to tracking. If the website wants to track me with (say) browser fingerprinting, deleting the cookies will not stop them from tracking me across sessions. Even worse: since I agreed they no longer need to show me a warning, so I may not even notice that I may want to revoke that consent.

If I don't want to be tracked, saying "I do not consent" is the only legally-actionable way. Deleting cookies works now because cookies are still cost-effective, but this won't remain true forever.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by vdaea on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:00PM (#39092865)
Cookie banners will still appear.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by latexr on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:04PM (#39093801)
> when I see a dialog box titled "We respect your privacy" and a choice between "allow all" or "see more"

It’s usually “we value your privacy”, which always makes me think “you put a value on it, alright, can’t wait to take it away”.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by musasff on Thursday February 01, 2024 @12:54PM (#39218930)
You
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by switch007 on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:54AM (#39091752)
Those extensions are far from perfect in my experience (ditto the lists in uBlock Origin)

Often leave you wondering why you can’t click anything on the page

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by pgeorgi on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:11PM (#39093011)
https://consentomatic.au.dk/ also allows to reject them automatically.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by latexr on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:07PM (#39093856)
If anything, there should be extensions to automatically reject them. It’s a testament to how draconian the process to do it usually is that the extensions just surrender. Every time an extension or person accepts those, they’re reinforcing those companies’ choice to break the law¹ in the name or profit.

¹ The GDPR is clear that rejecting must be as simple as accepting.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by zht on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:49AM (#39091662)
that's propagated to the rest of the world lol
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by coldpie on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:10PM (#39092017)
We could have these regulations in the US, too, if we voted for them.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by BobaFloutist on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:29PM (#39092334)
Ok, how about this: "It's a bummer that the rest of the voting population doesn't agree with my priorities enough to enact similar privacy regulation to Europe."
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by JumpCrisscross on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:16PM (#39092113)
Or just called our electeds about it. I’ve worked on privacy issues. Past tense, because after a massive effort like two people call and the bill is dropped. (Except in Oregon. Oregonians apparently call and write about privacy.)
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Levitz on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:25PM (#39092264)
My experience is that stuff like this gets framed as "pro consumer" in Europe and "anti corporation" in the US. The difference runs deep.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by segasaturn on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:22PM (#39092212)
Both parties in the US are in the tank with big tech (see: NY Dems killing right to repair)
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by carlosjobim on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:36PM (#39092455)
European citizens didn't vote for those regulations.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by makeitdouble on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:53PM (#39094493)
To a larger point, european citizens are largely favorable to those regulations, which makes passing these rules possible, and not a political suicide.

HN might not be representative, but the number of comments we see defending companies's right to make as much money as they can and against regulation that would add costs to businesses is IMHO pretty high. If that's the general US sentiment, politicians the have little upside in putting burdens on tech companies in the first place.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by carlosjobim on Monday January 22, 2024 @03:25PM (#39094922)
European citizens are largely ignorant of EU regulations, EU politics and EU spending. Most European citizens do not know the name of the EU president. But Europeans will categorically support and agree with EU policy and laws.

As for cookie laws, can we honestly say that they have done anything to protect people from corporate spying and abuse of private information? Real regulation would be to outlaw that kind of spying, not putting up annoying banners so that some web developer can feel good about themselves.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by yau8edq12i on Monday January 22, 2024 @03:55PM (#39095310)
> European citizens are largely ignorant of EU regulations, EU politics and EU spending. Most European citizens do not know the name of the EU president.

Very bold claim. Do you have any sources to back it up? EU politics are in the news all the time here.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by carlosjobim on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:02PM (#39095391)
Go ask a European. Who are the three EU presidents? Who were the EU presidents before them? Then ask them who is the current US president? And which presidents were before him? Which are the two top candidates in the 2024 election?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by troupo on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:18PM (#39096298)
Because the person doesn't matter. Policies matter. And Europeans largely prefer privacy-protecting regulations
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by yau8edq12i on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:13AM (#39102890)
In case it wasn't clear from my comment: I'm European...
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by carlosjobim on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @09:15AM (#39103528)
That is my point: You can ask anybody on the streets.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Shacklz on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:28PM (#39097061)
> Most European citizens do not know the name of the EU president.

Probably a bit controversial but to some degree, that is a good thing. It prevents personality cult and allows to pursue agendas that think in longer terms.

In Switzerland, quite a big part of the population could probably not name the current seven members of the federal council - they can actually get work done, without having to appease the public at every corner.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by makeitdouble on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:58PM (#39098546)
> European citizens are largely ignorant of EU regulations, EU politics and EU spending.

On spendings, probably. On regulations, oh boy do people care.

Regulations have pretty direct impact on each countries' economy, and they get discussed nationally before being applied. That means meat prices rises when some practices get banned or a whole sector suddenly getting competitive when barriers to entry are lowered.

For better or worse, people care a lot, and the negative sentiments are enough to fuel may extreme side politics.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by drooopy on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:01PM (#39092871)
European Citizens voted for the people who voted for those regulations.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by tgv on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:39PM (#39093437)
And we have input via our governments, and the national parliaments have a say in the procedures: a group of 1/3 of all national parliaments can send proposals back.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by carlosjobim on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:41PM (#39093462)
Yes, and so do American citizens. Whether you agree or disagree with the regulations, they were never voted on by the people.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by int_19h on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:06PM (#39093850)
We don't vote for regulations, we vote for politicians. Who are a package deal, so in practice you're voting on several dozen different issues at once, and you inevitably have to prioritize. I don't think you'll find significant opposition to many of these laws in US, it's just that it's never going to be that one thing that drives people to vote for or against some candidate or party.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by greggsy on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:45PM (#39092611)
I wonder if I could just change my location in settings?
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by ProAm on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:52PM (#39097861)
Most apps like this us GPS to verify as well. A lot of gambling apps require that permission so you can't just VPN to legality.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by wizzwizz4 on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:41AM (#39091556)
It's just politics. Ask your legislators to give you the cool stuff as well.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by Hamuko on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:44AM (#39091591)
Eh, can't be that excited about anything involving the data hole that is Meta Platforms products, even if they make some EU concessions. Maybe when we get that EU-only iOS sideloading support I can finally be more smug about it.
Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by sofixa on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:13PM (#39093037)
Thanks to the Brussels effect[1] some of it can trickle down.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by makeitdouble on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:43PM (#39094348)
A part of this is the products being fitted to US market and only after they get traction do they hit the other countries. That means any of the wider digital management, privacy etc. are literally after thoughts, and the business model also doesn't properly fit.

With that approach I think we'll always get products that are optimized for free + ads first and foremost, as the US public reacts better to those, and once it's setup it's just so hard to pivot to paying models.

Re:Meta now lets EU users unlink their Facebook, Messenger a... by ProAm on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:50PM (#39097845)
If you are in the US write your local congressman. Its the only way things like this change with companies that are too big and powerful. Takes a long time to turn a big ship.