and to clarify: I chuckled with sympathy reading your response :-)
Far too often those introducing new words (or even worse redefining existing ones) are playing power games with their in groups best interests in mind, not the rest of us.
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/caretaker
hmmm is there some extended n-gram search these days where you can search for a specific word *with a specific meaning*?
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/recommend...
Only if you define man in a way such that any person can claim manhood.
On the other hand, if someone dresses and styles themselves in a typically feminine way but tells me they use masculine pronouns, I will of course by reasons of politeness call them by their preferred pronouns, but privately I would find it hard not to consider her a woman who prefers masculine pronouns.
And it's not purely about clothes. Even if you look at people adopting more clothing styles traditionally associated with their other gender, say Harry Styles at awards shows, they do not style themselves exactly as the other gender would. Ultimately gender is a social construct, and that involves some shared performance that we each choose to adopt when defining ourselves in relationship to everyone else.
Not to mention, women who got a histerectomy can't be pregnant either, does that make them men?
That's not catering to edge cases; it's just clear, easy to understand communication.
If there is a place I'd expect to "cater to edge cases" including those that only make up a fraction of a permille of the population, it'd be the CDC because they have to address hundreds of millions of people so even a one-in-a-million edge case still represents hundreds of people.
"No man goes into education to be called 'instructor', they're 'teachers'."
"No woman goes into CS to be called 'coder', they're 'developers'."
And since we’re being technically correct, raising a child is always optional (even for the parent).
I wouldn’t consider a parent who opts out of raising their child to be a child raiser.
It's interesting to me that anyone raising a child wouldn't want to be considered a parent. Is the use of this term by request of people actually in this position, or wasn't created by third parties in an assumption that we shouldn't call them parents?
Caretaker and legal guardian have different and more specific meaning than parent. Those terms are needed to more clearly describe a person's situation and involvement with someone else. Again its interesting to me that one would prefer not to be called a parent when they have taken on the responsibility and roles of being a parent to a child.
I.e. I could see your coworker correcting someone and saying they aren't the father or parent with little or no offense taken. Though I could see referring to someone with adopted children as "child-raiser" as being really offensive to the person, as though I effectively took away the term "parent" and everything that goes along with it.
As do I. Parents are the ones doing parenting. Whether or not they are the biological parents isn't relevant to that.
Is a grandparent who raises their grandchildren offended by the word parent? I doubt it.
What’s the point?
Because we are nazis and bigots if we do not.
Seriously. I work in accounting and also do scripting and IT support. For a group who has to be precise with numbers, they’re frustratingly vague with words. Some of us got it, and some of us don’t.
Is this a terrible dad joke?
> take offense (idiom) : to become angry or upset by something that another person has said or done : to be offended by something - Merriam-Webster
That's all it means. If you're upset because someone says something different to what you consider the natural default you're still offended.
People take offence to changes to and transgression against cultural norms all the time - offence at public gay affection, offence at interracial relationships, offence at not respecting christianity and religious norms, offence at use of swears, offence at the normalisation of talking about sex etc etc.
Taking offence to certain changes to language isn't necessarily wrong, but it's still taking offence. "Taking offence" is what happens to you when something transgresses against your belief system, it's not just what the bad people do.
You're incorrect. I didn't construct it to do that.
> "Taking offence" is what happens to you when something transgresses against your belief system, it's not just what the bad people do.
All the rest of your comment isn't really to do with what I was saying, although it does illustrate it. I was saying it's silly to change something and then call any pushback "offence", rather than a wide range of things it might be (unnecessary; harder to understand; unfamiliar; yet another change of a bazillion and it'll change again soon).
You mean, the "offended ones"?
I’m not a native speaker.
Nobody is offended. It’s just silly.
When that's the topic at hand we should keep those distinctions in mind.
They're parents, as simple as that.
I’d personally stick with the common “caretaker” or “guardians” though. “Child-raisers” really comes across as just wanting to say something different.
I have friends who are child raisers but not biological parents.
The main point is whether you are a primary carer for a child below school age.
Who's more of a parent, the guy who knocks up a woman and leaves forever, or the step-dad who actually raises the kid for 18+ years?
The idea was to specifically include caretakers/guardians who are not parents (e.g. older siblings, grandparents or uncles/aunts) but also exclude those who do not take an active role (or take a less active role) in the actual caretaking. If my spouse does the brunt of all the caretaking, I may still be a caretaker or guardian but I don't need daycare in order to be able to work (though daycare may enable my spouse to work).
My wife calls those people "sperm doners."
This term was not meant to be a commentary on the kind of language that comes out of HR departments, nor a statement on gender identity.
We detached this offtopic subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39054206.
Just say parents, what is the point in changing the verbiage here?