We saw a huge amount of user growth during the pandemic, we massively increased the number of users that could be in a single guild (server), we launched features that asked a lot more from our AV backend (stage channels, camera video in guild voice), had to deal with a massive increase in spam during the crypto boom, expanded voice calls to Xbox and PS5 and had to deal with an increasingly fraught regulatory environment.
We also shipped a lot of user-facing features during that timeframe. Some of those ultimately got removed because of poor results and depending on your use of the platform I imagine some of those that stayed may not be particularly visible, but we really did ship a lot of stuff and I'm not going to attempt to list it all here.
Obviously, in hindsight we should have had a tighter focus and probably hired a bit less, but this sentiment that we are/were hugely bloated feels pretty wild to me from where I'm sitting.
My sense is that Discord was exploring a lot of different ideas for monetization all at once, and that maybe the sprawl of new projects got unwieldy, esp. in 2022-23; how accurate would you say that is?
I'd expect more like a 50% cut to really speed up the significantly fewer projects by eliminating coordination overhead and giving PMs the ability to really slash projects.
ps -- I'm not claiming it was bloated, that's (implicitly, and I believe fairly?) the ceo's claim.
If you are part of that 200 original group, you probably have a paycheck for another 5 years just answering tech debt questions
I've been in tech for a long time, but this is the first time we've had a significant downturn where remote/videoconferencing options have been so good. In the past it felt like executive cries of "we'll just outsource everything!" always backfired because the communication and management overhead (not to mention varying quality levels) had been extreme. Now, though, with everyone used to remote work, why bother looking to save a few bucks hiring in Wichita when you can save more, and get just as good if not better quality, hiring from Cordoba Argentina?
The people in the "real low cost area" aren't the same employee - I'm not saying they are less capable, but most companies are afraid of the significant hidden costs when trying to go too cheap this way.
If the problem is "we hired every warm body in a 50 mile radius, turns out a lot of 'em aren't really qualified", I don't see how bringing in even garden variety decent people from elsewhere doesn't bring the average up.
Dear company, I did what you asked me to do. If my work doesn't have adequate impact, that is on you for planning poorly.
Leadership doesnt trust non-engineers to handhold engineers and spoon feed feature requests, all non-engineer types should be focused on selling/marketing product or customer support
But when you grow to the point of having a sizeable middle management layer that isolates engineers from one another, by enforcing strict area of interest for each team, you really shouldn't call yourself "engineering driven" anymore. And also, the more you scale, the more specialists you need. Specialists that aren't able, or just aren't willing to move from place to place rapidly
that's the collaboration part. But the final decision over prioritization of feature X over feature Y and planning is done by engineers, not salesmen
The part where managers who don't partake in these efforts refuse to believe engineering estimates, engineering challenges and unknown unknowns and yet feel empowered to blame engineers in performance reviews.
“Do you play any video games?”
“I’ve been playing a lot of KSP, but I’m not sold on KSP2 yet.”
“Yeah, I don’t play that game.” STRONG REJECT
Anonymous shill calls named lived experience a liar. What a time to be alive!
Today’s layoffs are a direct result of the irrational exuberance of that era.
Now the Federal spigot has dried up (well, is back to normal) and interest rates are higher.
Then it’s painful when more people slow things down because there wasn’t much process in place before the blitz hiring.
This isn’t a problem unique to engineering, you see it a lot with sales too. Leaders aren’t experienced or self reflected enough to work smarter.
Discord has added a bunch of new features over the past couple years. Unfortunately, they don't seem to be very useful features (at least not to me). I still just use it for voice chat during video games.
"Non-trivial" is a very low bar to clear. It's obvious that Discord simply does not need to be the scale it is. It doesn't need a billion dollars and it doesn't need a thousand employees. It's very clear that they only have the employees because the investors were stupid enough to give them that much money, and they need to find something to do with it.
Some products just do not need to be that big.
I don't know how eng grew over that time, but it doesn't strike me as bloated given their scale and user base.
I'm sure that last one in particular had quite a lot of headcount associated, and it seems obvious that after they totally shuttered the project, they just reallocated the employees to new stuff.
That still leaves them with more than 4x the employees they had in 2020 (when the product had already reached massive scale and, IMO, very high quality):
> “We grew quickly and expanded our workforce even faster, increasing by 5x since 2020,” Citron wrote. “As a result, we took on more projects and became less efficient in how we operated.”
I know someone always makes a comment about "wow, X company had Y000 employees? what do they even do all day?", and I don't wanna be glib, but it really does seem like they expanded beyond any kind of reasonable measure.
If I were at Discord, and I wasn't part of an extremely core team with a direct line to revenue generation, I would be sharpening up my resume.
---
Edit: Okay, I missed this:
> Discord has raised a total of about $1 billion in funding. It has more than $700 million in cash on its balance sheet and the goal to become profitable this year
That's actually a lot better than I expected. Clearly they are making non-trivial revenue, and still have quite a bit of cash; maybe keeping a still-pretty-high headcount to pursue new monetization projects is the right call.