News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by TheCycoONE on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:06PM (#38936011)
DKIM, SPF, and DMARC are old hat and implemented by anyone serious for years. What's buried in this article is the required https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc8058 support for one-click unsubscribe posts. I don't see many messages in my inbox yet with that.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:47AM (#38936684)
also it violates longstanding security measures against malicious prank unsubscribes; it means that if you forward an email list message to someone else, they can unsubscribe you without your consent as a prank
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by cameldrv on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:58AM (#38936739)
Requiring the user to login to unsubscribe also has the nice effect of requiring them to know the password, otherwise they have to go through the reset procedure. Of course you need to be really secure and do 2FA as well.

Hey, if this reduces the number of people who successfully unsubscribe, don't blame me, I'm just over here trying to make sure things are secure!

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kugelblitz on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:57AM (#38937086)
Yep.

Don't want these marketing emails? Unsubscribe here.

Oh, you need to login in order to do that.

No, that's the wrong password for your account. Forgot password?

Hm, we don't see your account existing. Probably a different email address?

... sigh... sent a couple of emails to the data protection contact listed, but after 5 years, I still get the emails and I occasionally try to login again.

So I just automatically mark it as spam every time.

But probably because they're a small provider and don't have the resources; this is the largest telecommunications provider in Germany.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by LinAGKar on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:32AM (#38937291)
Not only that, it also requires then to accept your EULA/Privacy Policy before you let them unsubscribe.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:29AM (#38949372)
requiring web access to subscribe or unsubscribe is unacceptable
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:18AM (#38937201)
the standard approach is that unsubscribing sends an unsubscribe confirmation mail to the subscribed email address, replying to which confirms the unsubscription. nothing about logins or passwords or the web. this has been standard practice for 25–30 years
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by murderfs on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:02AM (#38937948)
I have never seen anyone do that and I believe it has been literally illegal in the U.S. for the last 20 years. From https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act...:

"You can’t [...] make the recipient take any step other than sending a reply email or visiting a single page on an Internet website as a condition for honoring an opt-out request."

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:24AM (#38938118)
this is not 'taking any step other than sending a reply email' and it's the standard way mailing lists managed with mailman or majordomo or ezmlm have worked for quite a bit longer than 20 years

also, according to that page, the can-spam act only applies to 'any electronic mail message the primary purpose of which is the commercial advertisement or promotion of a commercial product or service', not to mailing lists

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by ghusbands on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:48AM (#38938321)
You keep talking about a particular style as though it is standard practice that's essential for security, even though it is both unusual and now illegal in many parts of the world.

I have not seen such an unsubscribe flow in more than a decade, at this point. I assume you're thinking of mailman or some other similar solution that was already dated two decades ago, let alone now.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:25AM (#38938583)
something can simultaneously be standard practice in one community, essential for security, unusual in another community, and illegal in many parts of the world, though nobody seems to have found any laws against the standard mailman unsubscription mechanism in this thread

it is understandable that people who are not familiar with a cultural practice might seek to marginalize it, but that does not make it right

i don't really care about making life easier for people who send email advertisements (a cultural practice i am sadly all too familiar with) but i think discussion email lists are important and valuable, even if you personally don't participate in them

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by QuadmasterXLII on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:59AM (#38939038)
That’s gonna catch a report spam from me dawg
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:16PM (#38944949)
hopefully people like you won't be able to figure out how to subscribe to the mailing list in the first place
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by bulbosaur123 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:21AM (#38938555)
There is a special place in hell for people who require login to unsubscribe
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by stubish on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:34AM (#38936976)
Forwarding an email should strip this header, probably along with most of the other irrelevant ones potentially containing sensitive information the user isn't aware of. Forwarding an email with GMail only keeps the From, To, Date and Subject headers.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:28AM (#38938147)
i feel like if we're talking about a header the user isn't aware of, most users probably won't be able to use it to unsubscribe either
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by calfuris on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:59PM (#38941236)
Users don't need to be aware of the header, they just need to use a client that knows what to do with it.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by stubish on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:04PM (#38944783)
End users won't use the header. Email clients will use the header when you hit the report spam or unsubscribe buttons they will display.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by SpaghettiCthulu on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:51AM (#38936703)
What real harm could come from such a prank? I hardly see the need for such "security" measures.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:17AM (#38937194)
- we're just about to discuss a contentious topic and vote on it. i bet bob and lauren will be opposed to our suggested solution. wouldn't it be nice if they accidentally happened to get unsubscribed for a few days without notice, so they can't rebut our arguments?

- adding a new member to the list requires a vote of approval of the existing members. bob apparently unsubscribed last week and now he wants to resubscribe. can we take a vote on whether to let him back in or not?

- when someone who isn't a member of the list attempts to post to it, we add their domain to the spam blacklist and report them to vipul's razor. hmm, weird that bob.example.com is on our spam blacklist, how could that happen?

- bob, i'm afraid i have to write you up for having violated the new company policy i posted to the policy-announce-important list last week. well, if you didn't read it, that's your problem

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by Thiez on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:37AM (#38937778)
So in other words, there is no plausible scenario.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:26AM (#38938135)
if you think these are unrealistic, i've got news for you; the world is a lot bigger than you think it is
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by gbalduzzi on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:25AM (#38940302)
What kind of newsletters are you subscribed to
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by aendruk on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:17PM (#38941456)
Mailing lists
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:17PM (#38944963)
newsletters are irrelevant to this thread
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by SpaghettiCthulu on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:59PM (#38996569)
In other words, you made these scenarios up and you know perfectly well that they're unrealistic, but now the onus is on everyone else to prove you wrong.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by falserum on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:37AM (#38936986)
Malicious compliance, to make unsubscription more annoying, so spam can continue to flow.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by RockRobotRock on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:35AM (#38936980)
It would be nice to have something you can put in the footer which email clients recognize and strip when you are forwarding an email
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by riffraff on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:28AM (#38936942)
I think unsubscription without requiring login should be already mandated by some regulations (CAN-SPAM law and maybe GDPR).
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:25AM (#38938130)
according to https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act... the can-spam act only applies to 'any electronic mail message the primary purpose of which is the commercial advertisement or promotion of a commercial product or service' so it's irrelevant to mailing list discussions
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by AlexandrB on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:44AM (#38940500)
As far as pranks go, this is one where I'll probably thank the prankster instead of being annoyed. Even stuff I'm subscribed to intentionally, I can live without if it went away.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by callalex on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:40PM (#38941700)
Is this a real problem in your life?
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by rstuart4133 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @07:26PM (#38945646)
> it means that if you forward an email list message to someone else, they can unsubscribe you without your consent as a prank

Surely that is a bug in the email client that forwarded the email. It should have replaced the headers, including List-Unsubscribe, with its own.

That looks to be what's happened in the emails I receive. The one exception would be if someone forwarded an email as an attachment, but in practice almost no one does that.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by kragen on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:30AM (#38949385)
what does your user interface for interacting with the list-unsubscribe header look like?
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by SpaghettiCthulu on Sunday January 14, 2024 @08:57PM (#38996560)
Ideally a big green "Unsubscribe" button. Make it promise cookies too for good measure.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by rstuart4133 on Monday January 15, 2024 @03:22PM (#39005589)
I haven't unsubscribed from a list in years, perhaps decades, despite being subscribed to a few. So I can only tell you from memory. In Thunderbird, I believe I've see a "List Unsubscribe" button in the list of actions available, alongside "Reply-All", "Edit as New" and so on.

In GMail I believe senders that have this implemented now have a big blue UNSUBSCRIBE button next to their email address at the top of the message.

Neither appear if the headers aren't there.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by jasonjayr on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:18PM (#38936086)
I understand that the request happens in the background by the MUA at the user's express consent, and the unsubscribe is not allowed to send back any ui/html/whatever to present to the user, but the RFC is missing any information about how a response ought to be handled, HTTP Status code wise? Retry if 400/500? Give user any affirmative or negative response that it succeeded or failed?
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by zie on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:09AM (#38940110)
You can't send back anything? oops. I better re-read the RFC's, that's not how I implemented it...
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by chuckadams on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:22PM (#38941505)
That's up to the MUA, but I imagine that they would at least show an error dialog. If the backend of that POST is broken, then the spam complaints are going to rack up, which will get the list blocked, List-Unsubscribe header or no (some of the most notorious spammers around were actually quite scrupulous about having said header, which they would actually obey ... temporarily)
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by Analemma_ on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:12PM (#38936049)
That's very odd to me. Where are you located? I'm in the United States and virtually all my newsletter/marketing emails have one-click unsubscribe these days. The only ones which don't are from foreign companies, e.g. I bought a day planner from Hobonichi and found they put their unsubscribe behind a login, to my irritation.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by OkGoDoIt on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:34PM (#38936212)
I’d say somewhere around half of the marking emails I receive in the USA have one-click unsubscribe. It’s still very common to have unsubscribe links that require you to enter your email address and then select that you actually want to unsubscribe from everything, etc. And some of them still require logins, although those are getting rarer. Not sure if it’s actually a loophole, but one of the dark patterns I’m seeing often is one-click unsubscribe generally only unsubscribes you from a very specific type of notification or topic of the mailing list, and you’ll still get other types of emails unless you fully log into your account and go in your email settings and unsubscribe from everything. Not sure exactly how Google and Yahoo treat those, but it feels kind of like marketers found a loophole that seems to work for them.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by petre on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:25AM (#38936559)
Github unsubscribe is behind a login. Very annoying. We have an account with a company e-mail that is an alias to admins and it was subscribed to a few issues. One morning I got so annoyed with Thunderbird's not working message filters that I took the time to look up the password, login, unsubscribe and disable all nuisance e-mail communication.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by dtech on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:40AM (#38937009)
That is not marketing email though
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by petre on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:38AM (#38938691)
Of course. But if I do my own service that notifies clients over e-mail, then it is "marketing e-mail".
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by thayne on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:18AM (#38937202)
I also get a fair number where there is am unsubscribe link, but it doesn't work. Or I unsubscribe and then a few months later am somehow resubscribed. It might be malicious. But I think in many cases the cause is just that the company doesn't really care that much, and don't prioritize fixing the unsubscribe flow if it breaks.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by MBCook on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:33PM (#38936205)
Same. Basically everything that comes from a legitimate mailing list/subscription has it. Even stuff I would personally consider spam like political mailing lists have it.

It’s only the worst spam stuff that doesn’t. The obvious scam stuff sent to any email address they can find, containing every language I don’t speak, with lots of bad obfuscation to stop keyword scanners from 2002.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by bediger4000 on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:41PM (#38936267)
> Basically everything that comes from a legitimate mailing

There's the fly in the ointment. "Legitimate" shades off very slowly into bottom feeding Sanford Wallace-ass spamming. The temptation to become worse and worse is real, economics favor spamming, as it externalizes advertising costs. Until the torches and pitchforks come out.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by TheCycoONE on Tuesday January 09, 2024 @11:37PM (#38936236)
I'm in Canada, but I don't think that's it.

- Docker Newsletter: `List-Unsubscribe: <mailto:[email protected]>` - but missing http post/one-click header

- Java Weekly: link in body but no header Expensify: compliant

- Gradle: compliant

- Confluence Digest: No unsubscribe header

- Apache Mailing Lists: mailto header, but missing required http post / one-click

I think the confusion is that it's not just having a link, it's a specific set of headers, dkim signed fields, and form response that allows a mail client to unsubscribe with no user interaction.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by pixelesque on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:48AM (#38936687)
A lot of the spam from the US I get (I'm in NZ), for things like US Political fundraisers for politicians, to car dealerships in the US in various states have links to click, but you often then seem to have to enter your email address when I do click them before submitting the form.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by swiftcoder on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:47AM (#38937407)
My favoutite thing is when the unsubscibe page itself blocks my country due to GDPR...
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by pests on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:09AM (#38937149)
I've seen a perverse dark pattern on one click unsubscribe. The page you land at has a button that lets you resubscribe! It looks non-obvious you've already unsubscribed and it looks like the regular two-click flow needing to enter your email address to confirm. Very sneaky.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by mullingitover on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:30AM (#38937276)
If unsubscribing requires even two clicks I always flag it as spam. The rule is one-click to unsubscribe and I ruthlessly enforce it. Make it their problem.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by pests on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:11AM (#38937571)
I tried that once with Nextdoor. They will group their mailings into different lists. The unsubscribe button only removes you from that list. To disable them all is 30+ clicks on the site once logged in. It's horrible.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by malka on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @04:13AM (#38938030)
For this kind, my 'unsubscribe' button is labelled 'report spam'
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by alright2565 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @08:11AM (#38939076)
I just went through this with Nextdoor in October. Well, I personally didn't do all 50 clicks, but I asked their customer service to do it and they confirmed I was unsubscribed.

Of course, I got a new message from them yesterday because they've added a dozen different lists since then and automatically opted everyone into them.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by xur17 on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:05AM (#38940064)
Is this technically permitted behavior under CANSPAM? Seems like a company could just create a new "newsletter / list" for every new marketing email they send.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by chuckadams on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:16PM (#38941437)
It'd be up to a judge and/or jury to decide. If one can establish that the intent was to ignore one's attempts to unsubscribe, it'd be a pretty clear-cut violation. Most reputable senders have an "opt out of all further communications" checkbox (with some fine print about legally required and transactional emails). Pretty much the only way to bring a private action under CAN-SPAM though is to be an ISP and show "actual damages".
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by croutonwagon on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:59AM (#38940651)
My rule is I unsubscribe once. Then I block the sender or in the case of places like nextdoor, the entire domain.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by jeromegv on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:25PM (#38940900)
Facebook too, unsubscribe is just a single of one of their hundred marketing emails.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by hospitalJail on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @01:26PM (#38941553)
Huh, I am an individual who is a scientist, not a web dev.

I paid some company to do my email.

I email 3 times per year and get 'spam' warnings from AWS every time despite everyone subscribing through a: "SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER"

No bait, just an email field and submit.

I wonder if its your type that makes it so I have to be Amazon for forgiveness. Or at least that is how it used to be, now I sell addicting clicking casino games. No emails needed. I make way more money than back when I was giving away free content via email.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by classified on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:17AM (#38937197)
It could have been that you clicked that tiny, greyed-out, hidden unsubscribe link by accident.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by dotancohen on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @03:35AM (#38937755)
Or forwarded the mail to 256 of your closest friends and one of them clicked the unsubscribe link.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by buttocks on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @08:13AM (#38939082)
Worse, the unsubscribe link is behind a tracker url so pi-hole blocks it. Drives me nuts.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by boplicity on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @12:33PM (#38940966)
> I've seen a perverse dark pattern on one click unsubscribe.

The new requirement specifically sidesteps this, by making it possible for the email client to send a POST request directly. No need to visit the website at all; just click a button in the email client. In Gmail, senders that have this implemented now have a big blue UNSUBSCRIBE button next to their email address at the top of the message.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by atesti on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @05:29AM (#38938617)
I have seen Outlook and other systems click on every link in our mailings. Using a sandboxed browser.

How can one click unsubscribe work here? Mail scanners, virus scanners and even Microsoft's own spam filters would probably click these links!

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by zie on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @11:08AM (#38940092)
The unsubscribe links are POST, not GET's. That's basically the entire safety net.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by atesti on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:44PM (#38942255)
Really? I have not seen a <form> html element in an email in decades! Do you mean a list-unsubscribe header? I mean the hyperlink at the end of an email with "unsubscribe". I think it would be good if that unsubscribe link opens a page where one would need to press one more button to prove that it is not automatically involved by url scanners. But this would not be "one click" unsubscribe anymore. So how can this be solved? Why is not everybody constantly auto-unsubscribed who uses office 365 or hotmail?
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by zie on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @02:47PM (#38942286)
I was talking about https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc8058. Where the URL is in the headers as List-Unsubscribe: <URL>

A 2 page overview is here: https://certified-senders.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/CSA...

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by gwbas1c on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @06:57AM (#38939022)
> required support for one-click unsubscribe posts

The article gets it wrong. They imply that emails have to have one-click unsubscribe links, which isn't true. Emails need to include headers (described in your link,) which the mail client can use.

Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by pbronez on Wednesday January 10, 2024 @09:13AM (#38939200)
Unsubscribe links make me nervous. Such an obvious attack vector.
Re:DMARC required by Gmail and Yahoo from Feb 2024 by illiac786 on Thursday January 11, 2024 @03:00AM (#38949160)
How does that interact with crawlers, like what Microsoft does? (They visit every link in every email it seems) does it automatically unsubscribes you by error then?