News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Simon_ORourke on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:04PM (#38572056)
There's absolutely no reason at all for anyone to possess more than a couple of million bucks. Anything over that should be taxed at 95%.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by shagymoe on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#38572223)
Given that 2 million is barely enough to retire on, does that mean you think everyone should work until they die?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Guvante on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:25PM (#38572355)
With a 4% burn rate 2 million is $80k a year plus social security.

I don't think that describes barely enough for the vast majority of people.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by shagymoe on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:09PM (#38573597)
When you’re always in danger of going broke from a medical condition or emergency, $80k isn’t enough to feel secure. The system is designed so it’s never enough but you can reduce risk with more.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by yowzadave on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:19PM (#38572267)
We should have a welfare state that provides for people who are retired (just like we should for other non-workers, like children, the disabled, students, etc.).
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by muglug on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:21PM (#38572290)
2 million is barely enough to retired on in a country without a social safety net. But one of the points of taxing people is to provide that safety net.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by rowanG077 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:23PM (#38572317)
In most countries with such taxes you can retire and have the state pay you.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by BlackjackCF on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:10PM (#38572126)
If you’re in the US, you’re basically just asking for the tax rate to return to what it was in the 1950s.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gruez on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#38572226)
>you’re basically just asking for the tax rate to return to what it was in the 1950s.

AFAIK the high tax rates of the 1950s were also coupled with high levels of deductions/tax loopholes (eg. company cars), so the effective tax rate didn't really change much.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Guvante on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:28PM (#38572394)
I feel like free company cars won't impact the super wealthy at all...
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gruez on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:18PM (#38572970)
"company cars" is just an example. If you want to look at the statistics, look at Federal government total receipts[1] divided by GDP. You'll see that it's mostly remained flat since the 1950s (since the data starts) despite large changes in headline tax rates.

https://files.catbox.moe/c1ltvd.png

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/W018RC1Q027SBEA

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Guvante on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:24PM (#38630687)
Effective tax rate is not the same as total receipts and talking about total receipts when discussing insufficient taxation of the wealthy is falling into the "all taxes are paid by the poor indirectly" trap.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by lainga on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:14PM (#38572180)
And many forget that the first cuts were proposed by Kennedy and passed by LBJ as part of the "Great Society" bills.

[] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenue_Act_of_1964

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by renegade-otter on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#38572225)
Funny how we have huge fans of the 50s but they don't want the tax rates or the unions. They just miss the racism and the casual misogyny.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by rowanG077 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:24PM (#38572337)
Do we have huge fans of the 50s? I have never met one I think.
[dead]
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by rowanG077 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:55PM (#38572746)
I'm not from the US. I don't know much about their politics. Still I would be very surprised for the republican party to want to go back 70 years in cultural terms.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by chrisco255 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:25PM (#38572349)
No incentive to take multi million dollar bets would mean most of the achievements of the last 200 years like railroads, airports and airliners, microchips, etc would have never gotten built.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by mrguyorama on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:11PM (#38572890)
>Railroads

You mean that thing that happened when we gifted huge tracts of lands to a few private businesses so they could pay for the railroads? American railroads were NOT a private investment, but a public one!

>airports and airliners

Once again, public money during the war, creating the giant B-29 was more expensive than the Manhattan Project! America absolutely pumped cash into any building that claimed they could put out a few screws a week to support the insane amount of war material building we did. The airliner industry was further supported by Cold War warplane development, with bigger planes and bigger jet engines.

>microchips

Bell telephone had a legal monopoly for several generations. Literal government handout for free extra profit. Further improvements in computing were once again funded by military desires, simulators for planes, early computers were designed nearly entirely for computing ballistic tables for artillery, and selling a little bit of spare time on the side.

Modern America exists because in 1940, America actually invested in itself. None of those investments were private.

More examples: IBM owes a lot of it's early success to mechanizing the US census, once again public money. They even took some money from the Nazis FFS. How much did Henry Ford make building Shermans and other war material, often for the british or soviets to use? Starlink's Dishy terminal wouldn't exist without shitloads of public funds put into new phase array solid state scanned radars that were built out for the aegis system.

Or how about basically the entire country's infrastructure exists because the feds spent billions on paying poor people to dig ditches so they wouldn't starve to death. I'm sure walmart and amazon would do great with our old state roads right?

But sure, let's keep pretending these were "bets" by "private" companies.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:57PM (#38575116)
> You mean that thing that happened when we gifted huge tracts of lands to a few private businesses so they could pay for the railroads

Do huge tracts of land magically become working railroads? The word "happened" is carrying a lot of weight here.

In general, your argument handwaves the difference between basic research (often paid for by public grants to universities) and a working implementation subject to market forces. The two have radically different incentive structures and require very different competencies.

Good things don't happen by a politician's fiat, no matter how many tax dollars you throw at the problem. Behind every story of "America actually investing in itself" is men and women toiling away, breaking backs and burning midnight oil, almost always out of a profit motive.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by mrguyorama on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:36PM (#38575598)
I will make clear that I'm talking about the transcontinental railroad.

The companies were gifted not just land for the railroads, but 100ft of land on both sides of the rail line, as well as bonus land grants for every mile of "grade" totaling about 6,400 acres (2,600 ha) for each mile of railroad built, because the desire was for the railroad companies to fund the construction by selling the land. We also gave them significant bonds at 6%, which were repaid in full and with interest. The money was free and didn't exactly have strings attached. Gifting land to private individuals or companies used to be America's favored way to set up the next generation of wealth. In total, the acts to build the transcontinental railroad gifted the private companies more land than the state of Texas covers.

The labor to build said railroads was then imported from Ireland and China. These same laborers were then treated as outsiders and "anti-american". The people who "burned the midnight oil" to build the cross country railroads were not americans working for a profit motive, but immigrants purposely encouraged to come to america with a false promise of "opportunity" so that they would be stuck here with limited opportunities outside of working for the railroad under shit conditions that often resulted in deaths, and underpaid with funds from the sale of land that was gifted to the companies by the federal government.

This was as clear cut a handout to build infrastructure as you can get, and then we let these same companies pretty much explicitly become robber barons. We paid for their capital costs and then let them eat the profits from said capital. The same acts giving railroads money also made provisions to build a cross country telegraph line, so there's some handout to future communications infrastructure.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @10:35PM (#38578290)
> but immigrants purposely encouraged to come to america with a false promise of "opportunity"

In other words, a profit motive on the part of those immigrants. They desired to make their lives better. That the opportunities were false doesn't mean they were not being sought out.

> This was as clear cut a handout to build infrastructure as you can get, and then we let these same companies pretty much explicitly become robber barons.

I agree the grants had inadequate oversight and because of that, it's fair to call it a handout. But again, just because land and money were handed out does not mean that you get a working railroad on the other side, or that public funding is the only way to get large infrastructure works done.

Were some of the risks subsidized by the public in the case of the transcontinental railroad? Sure. The same thing happened with Solyndra, and nothing of value was produced at the end of that. So clearly government handouts aren't the necessary and sufficient precursor to success; at least the transcontinental railroad was built.

And mind you, back in those days, US government spending as a percentage of GDP was in the single-digit percent, compared to the behemoth it is now at over 35%. If the redistribution of public money through taxation really generated wealth, we should all be living like kings given current levels of government spending.

> Gifting land to private individuals or companies used to be America's favored way to set up the next generation of wealth.

None of the descendants of the railroad tycoons are still so rich that they're worth being written about[0]. Cornelius Vanderbilt was estimated to have been worth 1/87th of the US GDP at the time of his death. His famous heir, Anderson Cooper, is estimated at the upper end to be worth $200M. In contrast, even the poorest state in the union, Mississippi, has had a billionaire from playing music, of all things[1].

[0]: https://www.forbes.com/sites/kerryadolan/2020/12/17/billion-...

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Buffett

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by hk__2 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:07PM (#38572086)
We’re talking about wealth, not money. If you buy a house $1M and a few years later it’s worth $1.4M, your wealth went up by $400k but it’s hardly taxeable unless you sell the house.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Reubachi on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:14PM (#38572179)
Ha. Maybe not a problem for rich people who have the ability to obfuscate local laws, mandatory appraisals, and inspections until they sell their property.

Me? A person who actually lives in the property and NEEDS to comply? MY home certainly is a tax burden on me when every single year it's taxable value is reassessed by the county for 20 percent more, requiring immediate and prompt payment before it's lien'd.

Such a joke.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Guvante on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:20PM (#38572274)
I feel like you are overselling a bit. Property tax needs to be very delinquent to trigger a foreclosure and a lien doesn't matter unless you sell the property.

Also in my experience there has been a relatively painless path to challenge the assessment. Although I have never seen an example where the $400 appraisal is worth paying to do so.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Reubachi on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:42PM (#38631066)
Neither of your statements make me feel better about the problem that greatly affects my life.

Sure, I need to be marked as a deliquent debtor (somehow) for my property to be taken away from me.

And sure, every year, I can pay the department of revenue an appraisal fee to undo the arbitrary decision to increase my tax responsibility.

How about though, we force municipalities and departments of revenues to actually examine the assessment, reassessments, and economic impact? The idea that my home, the land it sits on, an the unconscious value associated with it is worth 40 percent more to other homebuyers is absolutely laughable

Very shortly ,my town will have population 0 with the only commercial land being the giant paper factory owned by a chinese paper congolomerate with a stranglehold over shipping products.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by __loam on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:32PM (#38572443)
I think something like 45% of house sales in the US went to corporate investors last year. Land speculators are a plague.

They also cause problems like this because their goal is the appreciation of the assets, not necessarily to live in houses.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by undersuit on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#38572233)
Houses... like many assets can be leveraged. One of the ways to take advantage of your wealth increasing 43% is to take out a loan with your wealth as leverage and if your wealth increases another 43% in value next year you're happy that you only pay 1-7% interest on the loan and not 15-25% in capital gains taxation.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jzb on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:23PM (#38572321)
Fair enough - raise it to anything over $100M then. Absolutely nobody needs more than that, and it's a policy failure that people are able to amass that kind of money - especially when it's often then deployed to help shape public policy to funnel more wealth their way.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by cdiamand on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:41PM (#38572572)
Let's say an (extremely) successful businessman wants to create a new business that requires a 250m investment to launch. Wouldn't this prevent that individual from starting the business?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by neogodless on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:45PM (#38572628)
Guess he'll need some people to go in on this with him? He'll have to.. share the wealth?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by hk__2 on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:20PM (#38575407)
No, because he’re creating a company. The money goes into the company, not in the pocket of the people who help him create it.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jzb on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:44PM (#38572612)
If they can't secure loans for it, I suppose it would. Do I think the loss of the ability of extremely successful businessperson to independently launch a business that needs $250m up-front is a huge loss to society? No.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by cdiamand on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:00PM (#38572783)
So in this case we would be eliminating the power of the individual to undertake large, risky undertakings that would provide a net benefit to society.

Now you'd have to cobble together a group of investors, but if you can't find people who don't understand your vision, you're out of luck.

Or you could go to a bank, so now the banks have more power, but they probably won't invest in your risky idea anyway.

Okay so I guess, now it's up to the government to undertake this large risky project? Great.

I don't know, I like the fact that motivated individuals can take a large amount of their own capital and take on large projects.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by asadotzler on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:02PM (#38574341)
That one or two motivated billionaires start interesting businesses every once in a while is justification for an economic system hundreds of thousands die because of the resulting poverty?

2016 Study: A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) estimated that approximately 133,000 deaths in the US annually are attributable to poverty. 2019 Study: A report by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine suggested that around 300,000 deaths could be linked to social factors like poverty and lack of access to healthcare. 2020 Report: The Kaiser Family Foundation estimated that roughly 136,000 deaths in 2018 were associated with poverty-related factors like lack of access to healthcare and healthy food.

Your "please think of the rich guys" argument holds no sway with me.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by undersuit on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:46PM (#38577012)
Corporations aren't people?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by dangles on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:37PM (#38572513)
Income tax has no impact on already accumulated wealth. Increasing income tax to target wealth accumulation only makes it harder for high earners who aren't currently wealthy to become wealthy, it has little impact on the already wealthy. A person earning $1 million a year passively from accumulated wealth is much better off than a person earning $1 million a year in income, with no accumulated wealth. The former doesn't have to work at all and can continue earning that income indefinitely, while if the latter stops working there income drops back to zero. Breaking up dynastic wealth with an actual robust inheritance tax and taxing very high earnings derived from wealth (e.g. capital gains) will be much more effective than higher income tax.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by neogodless on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:43PM (#38572597)
Parent comment said "possess", not "earn."
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by slantaclaus on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:30PM (#38572405)
Round it up to 100, comrade
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jedberg on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:09PM (#38572117)
A noble idea, but the logistics of it are difficult. How would you actually do that tax?

For example, take Jeff Bezos. His income isn't all that much, so you'd probably want to tax his wealth. Luckily, most of his wealth is from a public company, so we can skip the difficulty of valuing it (something a lot of other billionaires would have to deal with).

But now how do you collect the tax? Do you make him sell 95% of his shares of Amazon? That would certainly tank the stock, and then you would owe him a big refund for overtaxing him.

Or does the government just take his Amazon shares? So now the government would be the biggest shareholder of Amazon. Is that good? What does the government do with that stock? Does it start giving shares to government workers instead of paychecks? Does it pay off its debts with Amazon stock? Would the government's vendors even take that as payment?

I agree that wealth inequality is a problem, and we need to do something about it. I'm not exactly sure what or how though.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:14PM (#38572182)
> I agree that wealth inequality is a problem, and we need to do something about it.

Why? Wealth isn't zero-sum. Most of the American super-wealthy got that way by providing value to others. I'd argue that the bigger problem to societal stability is jealousy and envy, and the idea that rich people got that way by taking from the poor.

The hugely inflated net worth numbers of the likes of Bezos and Musk are fake anyway, in the sense that their assets could not be converted to that amount of dollars; and the Fed should take a large share of the blame here, because ZIRP made it so that investors could only really put their money in growth tech companies.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jzb on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:35PM (#38572486)
"Most of the American super-wealthy got that way by providing value to others."

The super-wealthy don't get that way by providing value, they get that way by keeping as much profit from business for themselves and leveraging that money to amass more ways to make money, rinse and repeat. When you look at some of the super-wealthy what you'll find is a pattern of consolidation, wage suppression, bending public policy to benefit themselves, and consumption of public resources.

Consider Walmart. Walmart stores drove small businesses out of towns across the country. The wages paid by Walmart are typically lower than the small businesses they killed. Walmart seeks tax benefits for plopping a store in an area, so doesn't return the same kind of money to the public coffers that the collective small businesses did and the jobs offered are worse and they're harder on suppliers than the small business because of the predatory way Walmart works with suppliers.

Walmart workers are some of the largest consumers of Medicare and SNAP benefits -- because they don't pay enough for people to live on. So the public foots the bill for the difference.

What the American super-wealthy have provided, more often than not, is convenience and temporary lower prices -- not quite the same thing as value. It's easier to do all your shopping at Walmart. It's easier to shop with Amazon. They're cheaper until they've sufficiently snuffed out competition.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by henvic on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:27PM (#38572381)
Exactly. Thinking wealth is a zero-sum game is short sighted.

Yes, there are many rich people who are rich directly or indirectly thanks to wealth redistribution: the state is very powerful in taking wealth using force (violence) from the poor and giving it to some wealth people.

But the natural course of how people become wealth is by generating wealth in a way that is positive for everyone!

There's nothing wrong with being wealthy. Poverty is a real problem, and the states are partly responsible for driving people to misery through wars, and the evils of forcing their own fiat currency with inflation and taxation.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by mrguyorama on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:17PM (#38572955)
So when the potato chips at my local supermarket have gone from $2 to $6 in a couple years, they got 3X tastier/more good, right? The potatoes in the produce section are still the same price, and my friends up north who literally grow those potatoes aren't making a dime more, so the money is all going to the chip makers. Are lays potato chips suddenly curing cancer or something?

Or when netflix raises it's price, they definitely have way more content and more reliable distribution right?

Tell me again how a company making more profit while everyone else suffers is magically not zero sum

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by soulbadguy on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:27PM (#38572382)
> Wealth isn't zero-sum.

Source ? Wealth can and is in many case a zero sum game.

> Most of the American super-wealthy got that way by providing value to others.

Source ? Making money and providing value are not the same thing.

> I'd argue that the bigger problem to societal stability is jealousy and envy

Sure let's not address the problem but instead focusing on the emotion of the people affected. Jealousy and envy are human emotions. They are only a problem for society who fail to adequately provide for their citizen.

> the idea that rich people got that way by taking from the poor.

Every time a someone doesn't pay the adequate amount of taxe, or a company loobies for certain privilege. Where do you think that money come from ?

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by rockskon on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:29PM (#38572398)
What would you consider wealth that is inherited, then? The wealthy people who did not, in fact, get their wealth by providing value to others?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:38PM (#38572526)
The existence of lottery winners do not mean that all wealth in the world was generated via lottery, or some kind of heavenly manna that a select few were lucky enough to collect.

None of the top 10 richest Americans got to that place via inheritance. Of the next 10, there are heirs of the Walton, Koch, and Mars families, none of whose source of wealth goes back more than two generations. Contrast that to the egalitarian, redistributive European system which allowed the richest families in Florence 700 years ago to still remain the richest families today.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by notpachet on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:19PM (#38572270)
> Wealth isn't zero-sum.

Of course it is. We live on a planet with finite resources; everything here is zero-sum. I don't buy the myth that we can create value from nothing. Some people are just better at socializing their harmful byproducts.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Negitivefrags on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:28PM (#38572397)
So if I have some wood, and I create a chair out of it, would you would say that nothing of value was created?

Previously we had some lumber worth $10 and now we have a chair worth $250 dollars.

Where did the $240 dollars come from? Was it stolen from somebody else?

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by notpachet on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:35PM (#38573168)
Where did the wood come from? Where did the calories you used to make the chair come from? Where did your tools come from? Who trained you? Who owns the property where your workshop is located? How much marketing effort did you have to spend convincing another human that the chair is actually worth $250? What potentially carcinogenic chemicals did you treat the wood with, and how much grant money is your government giving to doctors to treat the consequences of those carcinogens in the larger population?

All of those factors have hidden externalities baked into them that erode the net value you're creating. My argument is that it's all just a shell game where we're passing costs down the line to future generations while telling ourselves we're creating something valuable from nothing because it's what we need to do to sleep at night. We just don't perceive the longer-term externalities in a lot of cases.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by Negitivefrags on Friday December 08, 2023 @03:09PM (#38573604)
I'm not going to claim that all externalities are priced. There is certainly a lot more that we could do. But many of them are. The cost of the calories, the tools, the training, the property, and the marketing are certainly all priced.

But let's just say that you priced all of the externalities perfectly. In this hypothetical example, can you really make an argument that all of that adds up to more than, say, 100 dollars?

And if you can't, then you still have a lot of "value" to account for.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by notpachet on Friday December 08, 2023 @07:13PM (#38576741)
If all the externalities are perfectly priced at $100, then that's the value of the chair. At that point the extra $150 you manage to get out of the buyer is just grift, not extra value produced from thin air.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by henvic on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:29PM (#38572403)
Value is subjective. It's not from nothing. It's from human action.

In an oversimplification, when Peter decides to do business with Paul and Paul is interested in taking his business it's because both believe they'll be better off after that.

Now you could [prematurely] argue that there might be externalities and so on, but you must recognize that that action of trading in itself can be seen as something that is going to increase the overall wealth of both as they'll be more satisfied after the fact (assuming everything goes well).

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:30PM (#38572412)
> We live on a planet with finite resources; everything here is zero-sum.

This isn't even true at a cosmic scale, let alone in human scales. Planet Earth receives exogenous energy from the sun.

You want an example of creating value from nothing? Say your choice this evening was to sit on the couch and do nothing versus charge your neighbor $20 to clean up his yard of fallen leaves. By choosing the latter, you have created $20 of value for your neighbor where none existed before.

> Some people are just better at socializing their harmful byproducts.

This is trivially true, but you make the great leap of equating all wealth creation to an arbitrage in externalities.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by notpachet on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:51PM (#38573346)
> you make the great leap of equating all wealth creation to an arbitrage in externalities.

I do indeed. I think on a long-enough timeframe, all human activity is just externality arbitrage.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:47PM (#38574955)
As Keynes said, in the long run, we are all dead.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by antifa on Saturday December 09, 2023 @11:13AM (#38583075)
> jealousy and envy

Pure Ad Hominem. What is the implication here? You think people are faking their (right or wrong) arguments to cover up jealousy? You think it's not possible to be wronged and envious at the same time? It's not an argument.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by yowzadave on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:24PM (#38572333)
> Do you make him sell 95% of his shares of Amazon? That would certainly tank the stock

Why would it tank the stock if the ownership of those shares was transferred from Bezos to a social wealth fund?

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jedberg on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:34PM (#38572469)
Because the market is irrational and fears change. The stock dropped when he got divorced and some of the shares transferred to his ex-wife, even though he still had a controlling share.

Stocks always drop when the biggest holder sells for any reason. People don’t understand the nuance they just see the headline.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by asadotzler on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:04PM (#38574365)
If this were a real example, he'd have been selling small amounts for a long time and your concern would never come to fruition.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by yowzadave on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:40PM (#38572551)
But in this hypothetical, Bezos was legally compelled to sell--there is no signal for the market that "maybe Bezos is losing confidence in the company."
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jedberg on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:44PM (#38572609)
Like I said, people don’t understand. When he got divorced he was legally compelled to transfer to her. Stock dropped anyway.

When the CEO of Netflix had to sell because his options expired, the stock still dropped because the headline said he sold.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by kwhitefoot on Saturday December 09, 2023 @08:56AM (#38581945)
Why would it matter if it did?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by ysofunny on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:13PM (#38572174)
I would start by leraning more about how public markets really work

that's were the solutions need to be implemented

but I find it impossible to have good conversations about this. the last time I was able to discuss this I ended up concluding that somehow euler's constant is basically the same as the gravitational constant but people tell me I'm misscalibrated, so my only retort is I'm mister calibrated....

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by FireBeyond on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:28PM (#38572395)
> But now how do you collect the tax? Do you make him sell 95% of his shares of Amazon? That would certainly tank the stock, and then you would owe him a big refund for overtaxing him.

Apropos of anything else, the IRS bases things on the calendar year, and then gives you to April to "settle up". It wouldn't owe him a refund in this situation, then, but his next year tax bill might be lower.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by jedberg on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:42PM (#38572586)
If the law didn’t have a way to get a refund for a loss in value when you sold to pay the tax then you could potentially owe more than you have.

I was assuming such a law would have to have a provision for that.

If you get assessed at 100 billion, start selling off the assets and when you get to 50 billion you have nothing left because of the loss of value, you’d still owe 45 billion? That wouldn’t be fair at all.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by dubcanada on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:17PM (#38572236)
The logistics are just more difficult because WE let it be more difficult. "Oh it's so difficult to tax a billionaire". No it isn't. If we wanted to do it, we could. We just do not care, and we let them get away with it.

Shares are not money, shares are a percentage you own of a company, that's it. It's when you sell said shares and turn it into money that it becomes taxable. It's not rocket science. If you hold the shares forever, that's fine. But as soon as your future son sells them, they get taxed.

I really don't know why everyone always says stuff like that, it's really not a difficult concept. Money is money, stuff that is not money is obviously not money. A house worth 1 million is not equal to 1 million until someone gives you 1 million for it. Before that it's just a pile of wood.

Now this would promote not selling shares, but maybe transferring them. Okay you can't transfer shares.

We just don't try, there is no attempt at anything. If we wanted too, we could.

I am not saying we'll get everything, but even 1% more of what we get right now is worth probably the same tax we collect from all of the poorer tax payers.

I personally don't think we should tax income, I am a proponent of a higher sales tax and zero income tax personally. I think that's easier. You want to buy a jet? Ya you're paying 40% tax, but you get to keep all of your millions.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by tengbretson on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:58PM (#38572767)
Making owner-operated farms functionally impossible might have unforseen consequences.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by narrator on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:16PM (#38572214)
That would mean that almost every public and private company would be owned and controlled by Blackrock and Vanguard or the government because that's who they'd have to sell the shares to. No private individual anywhere would have control of any large company. Basically that's where we're going with most assets in this country with Blackrock buying up millions of single family houses to rent using unlimited money from fed bailouts.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by golergka on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:32PM (#38572442)
There's absolutely no reason at all for anyone to be able to tell another person what property and how much he should be able to own.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by __loam on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:44PM (#38572607)
When that property is billions of dollars and they have so much of it that they start warping market economics and political organizations around them because of their own gravity, that becomes a public problem. If we want a functional democracy then we very much do need to think about the influence of billionaires. Accepting the notion that "it's just private property, who cares" is an ignorant view on the actual situation.

For example, I was listening to a discussion on how Bill Gate's philanthropic organization causes many problems. They've basically taken over the field of malaria research by virtue of spending a ridiculous amount of money, and Gate's personal influence has limited the directions of that research. There are people in Africa that are trying to tell the Gates foundation to leave because their solutions are poorly suited to the on the ground situation, but the neo-colonial nature of this organization means you have many "smart" people in Washington and Geneva dictating how the global poor should run things. The influence of the organization has on public education apparently been disastrous, with the charity reorganizing public schools in ways that are unproven and harmful to students. The foundation is a revolving door for corporate actors like pharmaceutical employees, and they take and use public tax dollars in ways that are unaccountable to the public. All of this is because one man has more money than god. It's anti-democratic and ineffective.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:03PM (#38575195)
The combined net worth of all billionaires in America come out to ~$4.5T. Even ignoring the fact that that number is fiction (because those assets cannot be converted to that amount of money in real life), it's not very much money in the grand scheme of things. It's not even one year of federal expenditure. It'll pay for maybe three years of Social Security.

If Bill Gates wasn't allowed to have so much money, I assume the government would have taken it at truly confiscatory tax rates. Then you have the same problem of meddlesome "aid" to Africa, except that the entity writing the check would be the US government, not Bill Gates.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by __loam on Friday December 08, 2023 @11:45PM (#38578680)
> Then you have the same problem of meddlesome "aid" to Africa, except that the entity writing the check would be the US government, not Bill Gates.

A democratically accountable entity is very much preferable.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:11PM (#38572141)
Who are you to decide this for someone else? If I make something valuable and sell it to others at a profit, what is the moral basis for your claim on the wealth that I accumulate? Shouldn't you simply be grateful for the value I've already added?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by adhesive_wombat on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:25PM (#38572354)
The general idea is that in a functional society, rich people's wealth is in some non-zero part enabled by that same well-functioning society. Roads, electricity, telecoms, educated workforces, rule of law, etc etc. Amazon doesn't work if there are no roads, the open internet was never invented, no one is educated enough to read a website or drive a truck, or write software to run on AWS, and every time a truck goes out it gets hijacked and the driver murdered and the datacentre has the copper wires ripped out by an armed gang. Thus the rich person doesn't get to claim all the proceeds as theirs alone, some of it gets paid back to the society that enabled it.

Now, exactly where you draw the line between "rich people earned every penny on their own" and "rich people did nothing and deserve nothing", well, that's politics, along with "who is rich and who is not" and "why do we trust these government chaps to use that money to improve society?".

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:38PM (#38572522)
Seems pretty simple: tax the users of the infrastructure (roads, electricity, etc.) to pay for it, tax the recipients of education (parents, students) to pay for that. Tax everyone to pay for the rule of law (courts, police) because as you say, we all benefit. This would leave the vast majority of the budget to give back to taxpayers. Mostly various mandatory insurance schemes - healthcare, unemployment, labour law, old age security - which are the ones I'm objecting to.

Before widespread public education, large companies would sponsor the education of the engineers they needed (think locomotives), with contractual obligations to work for the organization for a certain time or repay the cost of education. This is how military college works today, and seems pretty high-functioning.

> exactly where you draw the line

Pretty easy, once you've paid for all the stuff you directly use, the rest is yours free and clear.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by asadotzler on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:08PM (#38574423)
I am the government that put in place the conditions for you to make that wealth and that preserves those conditions today at great expense.

I take from you what ever I need to ensure those conditions persist.

You are nothing. You are a cog. I am the government, representative of the majority here, not the few lucky ones who won the lottery (that I created.)

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by megabless123 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:14PM (#38572184)
> Who are you to decide this for someone else?

a member of the same democratic society

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:16PM (#38572209)
So your argument is that anything willed by the (narrow) majority is morally justified? Seems pretty obviously flawed doesn't it?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by __loam on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:46PM (#38572641)
Would you prefer the situation where 200 billionaires get to will it instead?
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:15PM (#38574522)
I would prefer a government that maintained a liberal ecosystem - one where violence is delegitimized and disputes are resolved via due process. I would however prefer that the government then did not try to meddle in the outcomes that ecosystem produces.

I don't see a moral justification in the use of force to shackle the capable and the fortunate, forcing them to toil in maintenance of the incapable and the unfortunate. The ideal I'm describing was more or less the case in the US before United States v. Butler (1936), which changed the interpretation of the general welfare clause of the constitution.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by __loam on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:37PM (#38574826)
Man, I hate libertarians.

What you get with this kind of system is powerful people meddling with the government to reinforce their power using anti-democratic means. A plutocracy. You also have to contend with the toxic economics of monopoly.

I bet you want unregulated utilities too because you a) don't understand macroeconomics and b) subscribe to anti-social and psychopathic economic theories.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @04:53PM (#38575051)
We already have a mechanism to prevent such meddling - a constitution. The authority of the government should be confined to the small box required to maintain liberal order. Limiting power is the best way to minimize corruption. The power of the government being allowed to grow without limit is what led to that power becoming susceptible to capture.

This was successful for centuries, but the constitutional protections of this order eventually eroded. Were they stronger and more explicit (say there was no general welfare clause), we could well be living in such a liberal order today.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by __loam on Friday December 08, 2023 @08:02PM (#38577133)
I guess we're just ignoring the Robber Barons and the monumental effort to reign in their power through trust busting. It would be nice to live in your fantasy world but we don't. Plutocratic power must be checked by government. The alternative is monopoly and collapse. We have reams of evidence discrediting your view.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by gottorf on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:06PM (#38575230)
> powerful people meddling with the government to reinforce their power using anti-democratic means

As the other commenter alluded to, the solution to this is to limit the power of the government so that even if they meddle and gain influence, the harm they can do is limited because the government itself isn't allowed to do whatever it is the plutocrats want to do.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by achenet on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:35PM (#38572479)
In the case where "you" is the government, the moral basis for the claim on wealth created is that

1) government was instrumental in the creation of this wealth: you needed the legal system to enforce contracts, the common language taught in schools to communicate with employees, suppliers and consumers, regulators to make sure your suppliers were giving you legit stuff, roads for transport, postal service, etc

2) governement is instrumental in helping you keep this wealth: police forces, general property law enforcement.

edit: if you're very cynical, you can argue that high income tax + welfare is still cheaper than suppressing a violent revolution by poor people.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by wouldbecouldbe on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:23PM (#38572325)
The centralized digital world has created monopolies like never before.

Good for those who were smart & lucky enough to have taken advantage of this revolution.

But there was definitely some unhealthy excess & wealth gathering that's gotten very extreme & we can consider if we find this healthy and benificial for society as a whole.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by traverseda on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:22PM (#38572305)
There is a big difference between creating value, and capturing value. A business that operates on hair-thin margins arguably creates more value than one that operates at a profit, which is why we want competition to do things like lower prices.

Most of the companies at this size use a bunch of anti-competitive practices. See the wikipedia list of anti-competitive practices here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-competitive_practices

So something like microsoft trying to get people to use microsoft-teams and nagging people to set up onedrive for malware protection, is a clear example of market-distortion through anti-competitive practices.

Given that no one gets to be a company this size by playing "fair" then it seems perfectly "fair" to lay claim to that that excess wealth. We assume almost all profit was gathered anti-competitively since in a "fair" market competition forces you to lower your price to the bare minimum.

---

I mean that's mostly bullshit for a lot of reasons, but it seems to me like just as valid a take as the atlas-shrugged "it's my money, keep your government hands off".

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:46PM (#38572644)
Say you've invented a device that everyone wants, that vastly improves the quality and convenience of everyone's lives. People are willing to line up in the cold for the chance to buy one from you. Even if you capture the entire market for these types of devices, make billions, and ruthlessly squash any competition, you've already added tremendous value. People's lives have already been improved by your contribution to the world. They are better off than they were before.

Plenty of companies have accomplished the above while playing fair, simply because of the value their products add to their consumers. And once they have added this value, how much they nag you doesn't matter. If you didn't like it, you'd go back to DOS and IRC. The fact that you don't demonstrates my point.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by traverseda on Friday December 08, 2023 @02:15PM (#38572935)
I mean I do use linux and IRC, so that's probably not a great example. I'm more worried about my grandmother who is confused by microsoft telling her she's not secure unless she signs up for more microsoft products.

>you've already added tremendous value.

Or you've just filled a niche that already exists in the world, and that could have been filled by someone better, but you're more connected or more ruthless. See also "Multiple discovery" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery as compared to the "heroic theory" of invention and discovery.

You're not special, sure you might have invented whatever 20 years before someone else, but most great discoveries of big shifts would have been done by someone.

I guess my question is, what if the thing you invented was a better more addictive casino? Sure, you're preying on psychological weaknesses and misleading people, but you're still making money.

Most business lie somewhere in between "more addictive casino" and "genuinely add value to the world". I'd argue the difference between them is where almost all of the profit comes from for most companies.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:04PM (#38575208)
Well, your grandmother could go back to posting letters and going to the library if she wanted to. Her confusion is entirely her own, given she's an agent responsible for her decisions, just like you or me.

> but you're more connected or more ruthless

This stuff still counts though. Those are just as valid differentiators in a competitive ecosystem as any others. In fact I'd argue you can't separate them from "merit".

> You're not special, sure you might have invented whatever 20 years before someone else

This seems almost a contradiction in terms. The fact that you got somewhere 20 years before anyone else surely entitles you to the fruits of your success. Or rather, it entitles you more than any other person - what is the basis for your moral claim on the success of another?

> what if the thing you invented was a better more addictive casino?

That still counts. If you agree that we are fundamentally decision-making agents, then it doesn't matter what motivates our decisions. Who are you to decide that a better casino has less merit than a better space ship? What criteria do you use to differentiate "genuine value" from "value"? Why are you so sure these criteria are somehow universal?

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by traverseda on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:32PM (#38575551)
That's not an ethical system at all. Your logic allows for desperate people to sign themselves into slavery and have that be a net good for the world.

Ethics isn't a solved problem, but capitalism definitely isn't an ethics system.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:43PM (#38575672)
> That's not an ethical system at all

The whole point I'm making is that there is no such thing. People disagree axiomatically. There is no oracle. Ethics isn't just unsolved, it's unsolvable. The closest thing to a universalizable value we have is consent. You say that it's not an ethical system, but you don't say why exactly, and you don't point to an alternative "ethical" system.

> Your logic allows for desperate people to sign themselves into slavery

Not necessarily, it depends on the kinds of contracts that are legally enforceable. I favour monetary penalties only, protected by bankruptcy. The ethics are complicated, but it boils down to how much "present you" is entitled to impose on "future you". In either case, you've not elaborated why exactly that would be "wrong".

> capitalism definitely isn't an ethics system

I agree. Capitalism is a description of the emergent properties of a liberal order. It happens when free people are allowed to interact consensually and resolve disputes via due process. Winners win and losers lose. It's you who is asserting that these emergent properties, which are common to all ecosystems, and totally inescapable wherever living organisms interact, are somehow "wrong".

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by traverseda on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:17PM (#38576099)
> Not necessarily, it depends on the kinds of contracts that are legally enforceable.

Who are you to decide how capitalism works? Sure, people disagree axiomatically, but instead of basing everything off a best-effort preference-utilitarianism you've decided to base it off of consent, without accounting for how reality, and especially capitalism, are inherently coercive. Why does consent matter if you can coerse someone into giving it?

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by smokel on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:18PM (#38572251)
The moral basis would be that most extremely rich people are not rich by merit, but by having good connections, luck, narcissistic personality disorders, or a head start in life.

Consider a random thing that you are grateful for, trace down who actually made it possible for you to enjoy, and then consider whether those persons all get equal gratitude.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:30PM (#38572408)
> not rich by merit

There are lots of stats that disagree. The overwhelming majority of fortunes are made and squandered within three generations. Raising capable people in an environment of extreme wealth is very hard.

Most famous fortunes are self-made, in the sense that turning a few 100k into billions is something that clearly takes a lot of merit to accomplish. I would also argue that morally, your good fortune in domestic environment (which is the main predictor of economic outcomes) is entirely your own. I don't see a moral claim by a third party over my upbringing as any more valid than a claim over my organs.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by achenet on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:39PM (#38572546)
> The overwhelming majority of fortunes are made and squandered within three generations

people keep saying this but I can't find a rigrous source when I google it, it's always just LinkedIn puff pieces or Quora... would you have a link to the original by any chance?

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by smokel on Saturday December 09, 2023 @01:52PM (#38584574)
Note that I was implying that there is no merit to "making money" by itself.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by RobRivera on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:12PM (#38572158)
If I place a 5 million dollar bet on a roulette table, incure the 50.5% probability of losing it all, win, and now have 10 million dollars, why should your opinion removed my risk taking behavior and thus reward?

I think your perspective on capitalism is grossly unfair.

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by zeven7 on Friday December 08, 2023 @01:15PM (#38572187)
Your point may be valid, but your example is bad. Placing $5 million bets on roulette is hardly the kind of behavior we should want to encourage.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by RobRivera on Saturday December 09, 2023 @12:20PM (#38583660)
>should

And who is the arbiter?

The dictation of what should or shouldnt be is power.