Now, exactly where you draw the line between "rich people earned every penny on their own" and "rich people did nothing and deserve nothing", well, that's politics, along with "who is rich and who is not" and "why do we trust these government chaps to use that money to improve society?".
Before widespread public education, large companies would sponsor the education of the engineers they needed (think locomotives), with contractual obligations to work for the organization for a certain time or repay the cost of education. This is how military college works today, and seems pretty high-functioning.
> exactly where you draw the line
Pretty easy, once you've paid for all the stuff you directly use, the rest is yours free and clear.
I take from you what ever I need to ensure those conditions persist.
You are nothing. You are a cog. I am the government, representative of the majority here, not the few lucky ones who won the lottery (that I created.)
a member of the same democratic society
I don't see a moral justification in the use of force to shackle the capable and the fortunate, forcing them to toil in maintenance of the incapable and the unfortunate. The ideal I'm describing was more or less the case in the US before United States v. Butler (1936), which changed the interpretation of the general welfare clause of the constitution.
What you get with this kind of system is powerful people meddling with the government to reinforce their power using anti-democratic means. A plutocracy. You also have to contend with the toxic economics of monopoly.
I bet you want unregulated utilities too because you a) don't understand macroeconomics and b) subscribe to anti-social and psychopathic economic theories.
This was successful for centuries, but the constitutional protections of this order eventually eroded. Were they stronger and more explicit (say there was no general welfare clause), we could well be living in such a liberal order today.
As the other commenter alluded to, the solution to this is to limit the power of the government so that even if they meddle and gain influence, the harm they can do is limited because the government itself isn't allowed to do whatever it is the plutocrats want to do.
1) government was instrumental in the creation of this wealth: you needed the legal system to enforce contracts, the common language taught in schools to communicate with employees, suppliers and consumers, regulators to make sure your suppliers were giving you legit stuff, roads for transport, postal service, etc
2) governement is instrumental in helping you keep this wealth: police forces, general property law enforcement.
edit: if you're very cynical, you can argue that high income tax + welfare is still cheaper than suppressing a violent revolution by poor people.
Good for those who were smart & lucky enough to have taken advantage of this revolution.
But there was definitely some unhealthy excess & wealth gathering that's gotten very extreme & we can consider if we find this healthy and benificial for society as a whole.
Most of the companies at this size use a bunch of anti-competitive practices. See the wikipedia list of anti-competitive practices here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-competitive_practices
So something like microsoft trying to get people to use microsoft-teams and nagging people to set up onedrive for malware protection, is a clear example of market-distortion through anti-competitive practices.
Given that no one gets to be a company this size by playing "fair" then it seems perfectly "fair" to lay claim to that that excess wealth. We assume almost all profit was gathered anti-competitively since in a "fair" market competition forces you to lower your price to the bare minimum.
---
I mean that's mostly bullshit for a lot of reasons, but it seems to me like just as valid a take as the atlas-shrugged "it's my money, keep your government hands off".
Plenty of companies have accomplished the above while playing fair, simply because of the value their products add to their consumers. And once they have added this value, how much they nag you doesn't matter. If you didn't like it, you'd go back to DOS and IRC. The fact that you don't demonstrates my point.
>you've already added tremendous value.
Or you've just filled a niche that already exists in the world, and that could have been filled by someone better, but you're more connected or more ruthless. See also "Multiple discovery" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery as compared to the "heroic theory" of invention and discovery.
You're not special, sure you might have invented whatever 20 years before someone else, but most great discoveries of big shifts would have been done by someone.
I guess my question is, what if the thing you invented was a better more addictive casino? Sure, you're preying on psychological weaknesses and misleading people, but you're still making money.
Most business lie somewhere in between "more addictive casino" and "genuinely add value to the world". I'd argue the difference between them is where almost all of the profit comes from for most companies.
> but you're more connected or more ruthless
This stuff still counts though. Those are just as valid differentiators in a competitive ecosystem as any others. In fact I'd argue you can't separate them from "merit".
> You're not special, sure you might have invented whatever 20 years before someone else
This seems almost a contradiction in terms. The fact that you got somewhere 20 years before anyone else surely entitles you to the fruits of your success. Or rather, it entitles you more than any other person - what is the basis for your moral claim on the success of another?
> what if the thing you invented was a better more addictive casino?
That still counts. If you agree that we are fundamentally decision-making agents, then it doesn't matter what motivates our decisions. Who are you to decide that a better casino has less merit than a better space ship? What criteria do you use to differentiate "genuine value" from "value"? Why are you so sure these criteria are somehow universal?
Ethics isn't a solved problem, but capitalism definitely isn't an ethics system.
The whole point I'm making is that there is no such thing. People disagree axiomatically. There is no oracle. Ethics isn't just unsolved, it's unsolvable. The closest thing to a universalizable value we have is consent. You say that it's not an ethical system, but you don't say why exactly, and you don't point to an alternative "ethical" system.
> Your logic allows for desperate people to sign themselves into slavery
Not necessarily, it depends on the kinds of contracts that are legally enforceable. I favour monetary penalties only, protected by bankruptcy. The ethics are complicated, but it boils down to how much "present you" is entitled to impose on "future you". In either case, you've not elaborated why exactly that would be "wrong".
> capitalism definitely isn't an ethics system
I agree. Capitalism is a description of the emergent properties of a liberal order. It happens when free people are allowed to interact consensually and resolve disputes via due process. Winners win and losers lose. It's you who is asserting that these emergent properties, which are common to all ecosystems, and totally inescapable wherever living organisms interact, are somehow "wrong".
Who are you to decide how capitalism works? Sure, people disagree axiomatically, but instead of basing everything off a best-effort preference-utilitarianism you've decided to base it off of consent, without accounting for how reality, and especially capitalism, are inherently coercive. Why does consent matter if you can coerse someone into giving it?
Consider a random thing that you are grateful for, trace down who actually made it possible for you to enjoy, and then consider whether those persons all get equal gratitude.
There are lots of stats that disagree. The overwhelming majority of fortunes are made and squandered within three generations. Raising capable people in an environment of extreme wealth is very hard.
Most famous fortunes are self-made, in the sense that turning a few 100k into billions is something that clearly takes a lot of merit to accomplish. I would also argue that morally, your good fortune in domestic environment (which is the main predictor of economic outcomes) is entirely your own. I don't see a moral claim by a third party over my upbringing as any more valid than a claim over my organs.
people keep saying this but I can't find a rigrous source when I google it, it's always just LinkedIn puff pieces or Quora... would you have a link to the original by any chance?