News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by thegrimmest on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:43PM (#38575672)
> That's not an ethical system at all

The whole point I'm making is that there is no such thing. People disagree axiomatically. There is no oracle. Ethics isn't just unsolved, it's unsolvable. The closest thing to a universalizable value we have is consent. You say that it's not an ethical system, but you don't say why exactly, and you don't point to an alternative "ethical" system.

> Your logic allows for desperate people to sign themselves into slavery

Not necessarily, it depends on the kinds of contracts that are legally enforceable. I favour monetary penalties only, protected by bankruptcy. The ethics are complicated, but it boils down to how much "present you" is entitled to impose on "future you". In either case, you've not elaborated why exactly that would be "wrong".

> capitalism definitely isn't an ethics system

I agree. Capitalism is a description of the emergent properties of a liberal order. It happens when free people are allowed to interact consensually and resolve disputes via due process. Winners win and losers lose. It's you who is asserting that these emergent properties, which are common to all ecosystems, and totally inescapable wherever living organisms interact, are somehow "wrong".

Re:The wealth of the 25 richest families in the world soared... by traverseda on Friday December 08, 2023 @06:17PM (#38576099)
> Not necessarily, it depends on the kinds of contracts that are legally enforceable.

Who are you to decide how capitalism works? Sure, people disagree axiomatically, but instead of basing everything off a best-effort preference-utilitarianism you've decided to base it off of consent, without accounting for how reality, and especially capitalism, are inherently coercive. Why does consent matter if you can coerse someone into giving it?