News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by pwg on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:10PM (#38538227)
And these companies wonder why so many continue to pirate.

Pirated copies do not get erased due to the whims of the copyright owner.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by phone8675309 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:35PM (#38539463)
If purchase is not ownership then piracy is not stealing.

Simple as.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by omneity on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:06PM (#38539683)
Fascinating perspective. I wonder if such an argumentation could stand on legal grounds.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by autoexec on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:14PM (#38539751)
I doubt it. The laws are written by corporations to protect corporate interests and you may find industry sympathizers all over the place (see https://www.wired.com/2009/04/obama-taps-fift/ and https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/03/riaa-lobbyist-be...)
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by pdimitar on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:16PM (#38539762)
Your mistake is imagining that piracy gets legally persecuted for more than one in a million cases.

Sure, they make an example of some poor guy every now and then and they cross their fingers hoping that this scary PR turns people away from piracy, yeah. Which is wishful thinking and they know it.

99.9999% of everyone pirating though? They are never going to be persecuted.

Turns out, if you ask people to pay and can't even withhold a fair bargain from your side -- as in, don't delete stuff from people's libraries -- they stop caring about the legality of it all. Especially with the extra context that this legality is a table that's severely tilted in the favor of the vendors and is not consumer-friendly.

The truth that the copyright holders don't like is this: people, even very technically illiterate people, are not as stupid so as to pay ownership but get rented goods license in return. It ain't happening. They coasted on the public's indifference for a long time but it's visible that the public's perception is changing.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:54PM (#38552255)
>Your mistake is imagining that piracy gets legally persecuted for more than one in a million cases.

that 1 in a million tends to be the one person serving the million, though. That's why they don't waste time chasing the customers like the war on drugs. Go right after the dealer and throw the book at them.

>Turns out, if you ask people to pay and can't even withhold a fair bargain from your side -- as in, don't delete stuff from people's libraries -- they stop caring about the legality of it all.

Good thing most people still pay in that case. The other part of that metaphor is that 999,999 people may pirate, but 5m or so are still making that product profitable. anti-piracy isnt just about making pirates relent, but to shut down future pirates in later products.

>They coasted on the public's indifference for a long time but it's visible that the public's perception is changing.

could have fooled me. If we're being realistic, I doubt this will affect more than 10k people. How many people really used a play station store to buy a digital movie? And remember that PS shut down their movies side 2.5 years ago.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by pdimitar on Saturday December 09, 2023 @02:19AM (#38579480)
> could have fooled me. If we're being realistic, I doubt this will affect more than 10k people.

Could have fooled me x2 -- we both can pull numbers out of our bottoms. ;)

The part you seem to be downplaying is this: there are things that can't be directly measured. Public resentment is one of them. It's one of those variables that grows and grows until at one point an eruption happens. Include that in your analysis, history has proven that this factor does exist.

> Good thing most people still pay in that case. The other part of that metaphor is that 999,999 people may pirate, but 5m or so are still making that product profitable. anti-piracy isnt just about making pirates relent, but to shut down future pirates in later products.

Obviously, yes. It's a scaremongering tactic. I'll admit they are succeeding, one after another trackers fall down with a tempo that the pirate community does not seem to be able to sustain; they bring some other trackers back up and that seems to be enough for them for now, if I read TorrentFreak's articles well that is.

So back to the original topic: what stands in court is only a short-term factor. Again, looking at the pirate scene and the steadily declining revenue from streaming and the slow and steady grow of piracy (again), I'd say part of the people had enough. Start persecuting more aggressively and things might escalate in unpredictable ways.

How will this unfold? Beats me, and you, but I am interested in following the battle.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:02AM (#38540877)
The only legal grounds that really matter are that (in the US) an IP address cannot be used to identify an individual.

https://www.technologylawdispatch.com/2011/05/privacy-data-p...

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by r0ckarong on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @03:07AM (#38541535)
If there's no owner, there is no one to steal from.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by wilsonnb3 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:17PM (#38539330)
What percentage of people who pirate do you think do it for ideological reasons, rather than just liking free stuff?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by indymike on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:39PM (#38539488)
Almost everyone I know who pirates at this point does so for one of two reasons:

* Getting back content they've purchased that was removed by the vendor, or where their account with the vendor was closed without giving the customer a way to retrieve the things they've bought.

* content was not able to be purchased.

I haven't heard "beats paying" from anyone, almost everyone likes subscription music, Prime Video, Netflix and so on. Where the issues are is purchases, where people thought they bought something only to find out that they had a license that expires.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by speeder on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:12PM (#38539729)
Or stupid region restrictions.

Example: I signed up for crunchyroll after I learned a show I wanted to watch was there.

Then after I paid, found out that on my country, it is not available.

Or when I bought a ton of books in fictionwise, then Barnes e noble bought them and restricted downloads only to people from USA. Funnily I only bought from that site because was the only site that sold to my country.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by kyriakos on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:38PM (#38548474)
Or just no availability. I want to watch an HBO show. Not available in my country. Make it available and get my money.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by sameerds on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @11:51PM (#38540572)
This! A lot of young people pirate media to save money. But then when they grow up and start working, they /still/ keep pirating because now they are used to getting their hands on quality media that they like, rather than consuming whatever "curated content" the algorithm deems fit to make available. Usually these people are also subscribed to regular services, but still find it a far better experience to pirate stuff.

EDIT: Fixed typo "grow up".

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:52AM (#38540847)
I disagree with this. I pirated everything when I was a teenager/in college because I didn’t have money. Now the only thing I pirate is the occasional movie I want to watch that isn’t on Hulu, Netflix, Disney+, HBO Max or Amazon Prime Video. If it’s not on any of those FIVE subscription services, I’m pirating shamelessly and vindictively.

Pirating music isn’t worth my time with Spotify Premium.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by OrderlyTiamat on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:08AM (#38541199)
I'm just out of uni and still don't have a lot of money, so still pirating. However-

>the only thing I pirate is the occasional movie I want to watch that isn’t on Hulu, Netflix, Disney+, HBO Max or Amazon Prime Video.

You maintain 5 subscriptions and still have to pirate every now and again? I just watch whatever I want on plex+radarr/sonarr. That sounds exhausting.

I don't think I'll want to follow in your footsteps. Maybe I'll take out subscriptions for the things I really like, but I'm probably going to keep using pirated content for my actual consumption - its just a better experience at this point.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @10:57AM (#38545561)
There’s a balance I think many of us try to strike because we find pirating “everything” to be cumbersome, but at the same time we recognize that pirating is unavoidable as there are some TV shows and movies that aren’t on any subscription service it seems, nevermind the 4 or 5 we happen to have.

You can of course just “download everything” with sonarr and radarr, but then you’re maintaining a server at home with X hard drives to store all the content.

But yeah don’t pay for subscription services if you don’t want to.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by OrderlyTiamat on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:06PM (#38547428)
That's fair. My server setup is very small (pi with a harddrive) so I'm deleting stuff I don't watch anymore after it's seeded. And it is a hassle to set up. However I've also found now that it is setup, it takes basically no effort to maintain it, and I'd want the pi for other stuff anyway.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by bitcharmer on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:59AM (#38541497)
No. I started paying for movies and music the moment I could afford them which was relatively early into my adult, independent life. I still pirate content but it's because of regional restrictions, content being removed from my streaming service or otherwise unavailable in digital form.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by bbor on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:25PM (#38539819)
Wow you have a completely different experience from me. 100% of the pirates I know are pirating entertainment products that they usually wouldn’t otherwise buy. Not, like, getting back at some company who wronged them. Interesting lesson on different cultural groups I guess!
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:42PM (#38552183)
>I haven't heard "beats paying" from anyone,

Ive head

- beats paying, or too expensive - because I can lol - because fuck [insert company here] - because Plex is more convenient - because I want to apply an english subtitle/patch to it - because mods

none of my friends were banned from PSN/Netflix/Amazon/etc. It's just cheaper or more convinient for them.

granted, these were mostly for games, and there has yet to be a "Netflix for games" as of now.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by al_borland on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:26PM (#38539396)
People may start out doing it because it’s free, but likely keep doing it for ideological reasons after they’ve seen so many paying customers get screwed over.

I’ll pay for digital music on iTunes, which is DRM free, but won’t buy movies there, as the DRM means it’s only good as long as Apple decides to keep it going. As we move from people maintaining media libraries to streaming, it seems like it’s only a matter of time before those digital copies become worthless.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by JeremyNT on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:06PM (#38540072)
I can't speak for anybody else but this really resonates with me.

I think there's another component though. The megacorps that provide streaming video are so far removed from the actual creators, it almost feels like the right thing to do is to avoid lining their pockets with more profit. This is a stark contrast to music, where you have small groups of people you actively want to support.

Given the friction to paying for the music you want is so low and the relationship is more "personal" it just has a different feel.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Log_out_ on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @03:11PM (#38548858)
Would be interesting to compare a production patreon VS a distribution voluntarily payment.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:54AM (#38540857)
iTunes DRM used to be abysmal. There was a time when the music was not DRM-free. Not only that, you were limited to the number of copies of CDs you could burn your music to, and you were limited to 5 devices (computers running iTunes, iPods, et al).
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Fezzik on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:36PM (#38540223)
I don’t know what percentage it is, but people in my age range (40-50) that I know who pirate tend to do so for fear of losing the media they love. I don’t even have time to watch 1% of what I have downloaded on my storage drives, but when I want to watch Mrs. Doubtfire in 25 years I want to make damn sure I can watch the original. I have little faith that whatever conglomerate owns that IP in a quarter century is going to make it easy for me to do so. Or make it even possible.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by calamari4065 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:36PM (#38540226)
I will pirate things I pay for, since there's simply no other way to actually own a copy. One prime example is the latest Star Trek show. The ads on Paramount are absolutely intolerable, despite paying for the service. So we continue to pay and watch ad-free pirated copies.

The exception for me is old stuff. I have exactly zero qualms about not paying for a forty year old movie. Half the actors are dead anyway. The film studio doesn't need or deserve my money for something nobody alive had anything to do with.

I do blanket pirate music, though. There doesn't seem to be a way for me to buy music without 99.999% of the money going to a label or a studio. Apart from bandcamp and other indie stores, but those typically aren't my jam in the first place. If I could support artists directly, I would. But I can't, and I refuse to support predatory labels, so I don't. I do feel a little bad about it, but options are limited.

Oh, and I will gleefully pirate textbooks, of course. Also research papers and most nonfiction in general. Audiobooks and fiction are a hard no unless unavailable or older than I am. Everyone should pirate textbooks always, it's only just.

So yeah, mostly for ideological reasons and the incomparable convenience.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:57AM (#38540863)
Why do you pay for Paramount+ Essential (the one with ads) and then pirate stuff that’s available through it, rather than A) not pay for Paramount+ at all and just pirate or B) pay for the more expensive Paramount+ plan and not pirate?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by calamari4065 on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @05:58PM (#38550650)
Because even paying for the ad free service, you don't get a copy to play offline. Most of the time the performance I get from Paramount streaming is awful. Everything just works better when I stream from the server on my local network.

I also don't have to worry about my favorite shows disappearing from the service on a whim. The files on my server will always be available to me.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @06:32PM (#38550942)
So… why pay for Paramount+ at all?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Liskni_si on Thursday December 07, 2023 @02:33PM (#38560758)
> If I could support artists directly, I would. But I can't, and I refuse to support predatory labels, so I don't. I do feel a little bad about it, but options are limited.

I've had artists send me mp3 in the morning after I gave them cash at a concert the night before. :-)

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by autoexec on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:08PM (#38539708)
It's impossible to say, but studies have shown that the people who pirate the most also spend the most money on their preferred media, so an unwillingness to spend money doesn't seem to be the biggest reason.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by chalsprhebaodu on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:24PM (#38539386)
Is this a tangential question? The OP suggests that there’s a utility to piracy beyond ideological reasons and just getting stuff for free. In other words, the categories you posed are not mutually exclusive.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by kermatt on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:32PM (#38539438)
Deletion of previously licensed content will likely entice at least a few.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gymbeaux on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:49AM (#38540832)
The “theft” happens on both sides.

I stopped pirating music when Spotify came to the US. It’s proof that people will pay for things if A) the price is reasonable and B) consumption is convenient. Why? Pirating content is inconvenient. Popcorn Time was as close as it got to “convenient” but that was quickly shut down/abandoned.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:48PM (#38552220)
>I stopped pirating music when Spotify came to the US. It’s proof that people will pay for things if A) the price is reasonable and B) consumption is convenient.

yup, and the cost there is instead put on the artist. Who don't make any reasonable money but need to do it "for exposure".

I'm not surprised movies and games didn't follow. game devs and actors don't get paid tiny residuals, but instead are paid upfront.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by rowanG077 on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:38AM (#38541046)
I pirate because it has become impossible to purchase stuff. So in fact the only way to experience it on my terms is to pirate.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Gud on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:58AM (#38541487)
Personally I do it because I travel a lot. I also have Netflix, YouTube, Apple TV and Prime that I never bother looking at. Every new country I go to different movies and different shows are unavailable.

In one country show X is available on service Y - in another it’s available on service Z, in another it’s not available at all.

However, they are always available on Torrentleech and The Pirate Bay.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nwallin on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @03:59AM (#38541790)
What percentage globally? I have no idea. I'm not a pollster but I'd hate to try to design a poll that could figure that out. It seems like the sort of thing people will lie about.

When I was young, I pirated because I was broke.

When I got a job and grew older, I would continue to pirate, because it was annoying to shuffle through a DVD collection or for the game the disk to put into the drive bay for a game that was already installed on the computer's hard disk. I regularly downloaded no-cd cracks for games I had legally bought, and if I'm going to be fucking around with shady executables from disreputable corners of the internet anyway, I might as well save myself a car trip to the mall.

When Netflix streaming became ubiquitous and Steam became good, I stopped pirating, because it was more convenient to do media legally than it was to pirate them.

Now that Netflix has been Balkanized into a dozen competing services, all of which are shitty, I pirate TV/movies again, because it is more convenient to always know what site to go to to acquire media. I subscribe to Amazon prime for the free shipping, but even for media which is available on Amazon Prime, I still pirate it because -- wait for it -- the DRM doesn't work.

I still buy games on Steam because it's easy and convenient. If Ubisoft and EA get their way and cut into Steam's market share and make it so there are too few games available to play on Steam, or games that I've already paid for start becoming un-bought from my library, or Steam starts becoming unusable due to onerous DRM, I'll start pirating again.

Music is more complicated. In the '90s I ripped all my CDs into MP3s, and burned them onto data CDs which I put into a big ass CD changer in the trunk of my car. Later on, I could fit all of them on a DVD in the head unit. Later on, I could put them all on a USB thumb stick which I plugged into the console. As time went on, I realized I wasn't engaging with my music in any meaningful way. I'd turn it on and hit random and literally never think about what I was listening to. So I've picked up vinyl specifically because it's less convenient. I have to actually think about what music I want to listen to, and then actively make a decision.

So do I pirate movies and TV because I like free stuff? Not really. I probably spent in the ballpark of $50 on games a month, maybe $200 on music per month. I have the money to pay for video media. But the last thing I watched was the Legend of Vox Machina, which is produced by Amazon Studios specifically for Amazon Prime Video, which I already pay for, and I pirated it anyway because it's more convenient.

So do I pirate movies and TV for ideological reasons? Not really. I mean, don't get me wrong, Hollywood is kinda gross, but so is the video games industry and the music industry.

Sorry for rambling. I guess my point is that it's incorrect to set this up as a dichotomy between getting free shit and sticking it to the man. For me at least, it's neither of those things.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by BrandoElFollito on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @05:40AM (#38542307)
At 50 I pirate because of convenience. Before it was because I could not stand the ads, today it is because I will not go through hoops to get something in country X just because I am in France.

I have ample money and subscribe to netflix, amazon prime and something else I forgot (I hardly watch tv).

I never pirate music anymore - Spotify is perfect. I have a family subscription.

I subscribe to Youtube because I like the content free from ads.

Netflix is getting worse and worse so someday I will stop the subscription and get the content via BitTorrent

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by porridgeraisin on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:45PM (#38547141)
I subscribe to prime video and another streaming service, that basically cover all my streaming needs. However, sometimes their DRM means I cannot screen share on discord or parsec or whatever and watch with my friend. So, I pirate it.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by odiroot on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:12PM (#38547482)
Or just out of convenience?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by ranting-moth on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:51PM (#38539110)
Gosh, but you wouldn't download a car even if you could, would you?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Loughla on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:07PM (#38539252)
Once metal 3d printing is affordable in the home, I'm absolutely downloading a car.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by gosub100 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:32PM (#38539440)
Carbon fiber might even be possible before metal, for at least the structural frame. Probably wouldn't pass a single NHTSA test, but imagine how cool it would be if you could assemble your vehicle this way, with a CAD system doing the heavy math calculations, then go to a junk yard and get your suspension, axles, motors, etc. Plug the motor into an rPi that is your (whatever they call automotive computers, ECU?). Not sure how you'd do the interior or exterior, and the SRS would never work right. But you could theoretically get most of the way there, to a dune buggy.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:55PM (#38552268)
downloading a car is easy. Getting it registered at the DMV is the hard part. Very easy attack vector unless this is just going to be a street racing car.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by bigbillheck on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:25PM (#38539388)
I might.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:48PM (#38538577)
I've never experienced in the last 20 years of purchasing digital media. You can't claim it's common. I pirate when I literally can't give anyone my money, or after something like this happens. Before is just trying to justify not compensating the creators. I’ve seen so many studios go under, that I loved. I think supporting them is important, or we’ll end up with media made for the masses, that do pay.

edit: there be pirates in these waters!

edit: please include the third and fourth sentence in your comprehension of the above, before responding.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by f-securus on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:05PM (#38538732)
I bought one of the wwe wrestling games for my kid on my xbox account. Few years later there was a new version he wanted. After playing it he wanted to play the old version. The studio had removed it from the Microsoft store because they wanted to force people to new version. Even though I owned it I couldn’t install from Microsoft store. I contacted support and was told I had to copy it from the xbox it was installed on. I never bought anymore games from that studio. That was years ago and now there are more and more examples of not owning what you paid for.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by squeaky-clean on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:56PM (#38539602)
This is really common with any games that need to license a ton of things in order to exist. The contract for using a wrestler's wrestler's likeness usually has a time limit. As well as the songs they use for their intro/outro.

Racing games have this issue too if they use real car brands. You can't buy the previous Forza games or some old Codemasters racing games anymore because of expired licensing.

At least on Steam they're still available for download if you previously purchased them. No clue what the experience is in console or other PC stores.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by f-securus on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:24PM (#38539808)
From a user's perspective that is incredibly hostile. They push digital goods as more convenient than physical media but don't make it clear that you lose the right to download it after a certain time. That functionality is sold as a benefit but the limited time isn't made clear.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by tonyarkles on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:54PM (#38538640)
Ahhh while I've never had specifically purchased media disappear like this, movies that I want to rewatch do often migrate around from streaming service to streaming service, which is fine if you subscribe to all of them but is really a hassle when you start watching something on Netflix and then when you come back to it a month later discover it's not available anymore.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:23PM (#38538879)
Sure, but that's not related. There's no concept of ownership with the library of a streaming service. I think that's well understood by the general public.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by harry8 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:50PM (#38539099)
Sure it's well understood that it's a service fail and poor quality service leads to piracy.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:56PM (#38539155)
You are aware services like that rose to prominence precisely because people decided to sacrifice ownership for rentals, right?

You didn't pay $10 for perpetual ownership of IASIP. You paid $10 for a month of access to Netflix or whatever service hosted that show. I still buy physical media or digital downloads of any work I want to keep for more than a month because I value it for those cases.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by squeaky-clean on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:11PM (#38539723)
In the past people still would rent more than they owned. They just traded having to visit a store with a selection limited by physical space for an instantly available digital service.

But you'd never show up to a Hollywood Video looking to rent Terminator 2 and get told that it's a Blockbuster exclusive rental. There were Blockbuster exclusive movies, but they all sucked so it didn't matter.

Netflix Streaming gave bigger selection and instant access. You could get 15 minutes into a movie, realize it sucks, and you didn't have to drive back to the video store for a different one.

Nowadays the selection on any streaming service feels like 1/3 of what a VHS rental place would have. Sure there's more actual quantity, but it's like the $1 rental bin. Currently, if you pick X popular movie and Y streaming service, odds are you cannot watch it on that streaming service.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:04AM (#38540637)
>There were Blockbuster exclusive movies, but they all sucked so it didn't matter.

I mean, it sounds like they simply learned their lesson. Or got more budget to publish such stuff. Same tactics but now more effective after giving what the audience actually wants.

Its certainly an interesting phenomenon. Hosting brick and mortar is crazy expensive so it makes sense to delegate that. Hosting servers is cheaper and way more scalable (mostly dealing with country laws instead of every single nuldijg regulation code), so it's no surprise studios want to self-distribute now that the barrier lowered.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by meroes on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:23PM (#38539373)
Glad you asked. Steam stole my Dungeon Siege content. I doubt there is any language in their TOS that lets them do what they did to people who bought DS which came with the expansion Legends of Aranna, only to remove the expansion from libraries after some kind of licensing dispute. Zero refund.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by ChoGGi on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:43AM (#38544513)
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by starttoaster on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:23PM (#38539377)
I pirate loads. But if it's a small studio I always buy the BluRay in addition. If it's an excellent film or show but it's made by a large studio, I check to see if it's available on one of the streaming services I subscribe to, and if not, I buy the BluRay. Thought process being that it's the job of the streaming service to compensate the creators at that point (which a large point of the writer's strike was to ensure that they do.) If it's something I'm certain I'll only watch once, I just keep the pirated copy. It would be nice if there were some kind of, "I thought your movie was kind of trash but I got some amount of enjoyment out of it so here's a cup of coffee," Venmo-like service. Maybe every studio could just put up a Twitch stream that I could donate some bits to.

But this is all just to say that while I pirate loads, I do have a bit of a conscious about it. That said, stories like this are why I don't lose much sleep over it.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:16PM (#38539760)
> "I thought your movie was kind of trash but I got some amount of enjoyment out of it so here's a cup of coffee,"

For me, this is a rental.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by starttoaster on Thursday December 07, 2023 @12:18PM (#38559061)
That seems pretty reasonable. Is RedBox still a thing? Can I rent a DVD and give it right back the next minute? Are there better methods to rent movies these days? I guess Amazon Prime exists.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by anonymoushn on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:39PM (#38539009)
If you buy a defective game on PSN and then get a refund, your entire PSN account is nuked. If you buy a game on Steam and the devs push malware in an update and you get a refund, your entire Steam account is nuked. An example of a defective game you can currently buy on PSN is Kingdom: Two Crowns. An example of a game whose developer pushed malware in an update automatically downloaded by Steam is Street Fighter V.

In the case of PSN, official policy is that defective games are refundable. They just make it impossible to reach anyone about this during the refund window. In the case of Steam, official policy is that devs are free to push malware to your device.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:53PM (#38539130)
This sound more like an argument for companies needing to be punished for retaliating against refunds and chargebacks, more than an argument for piracy.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by squeaky-clean on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:16PM (#38539766)
How else do you punish them if not by affecting their revenue?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:00PM (#38540051)
You can't punish them for something they haven't done, by pirating before they do it. There will be no correlation, so no feedback mechanism, in that scenario. What do you see as the signal they should pick up on? How will they differentiate it from "they pirate no matter what we do"? These are genuine questions.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:45AM (#38540814)
Government regulation I guess.

But i feel "punish" is the wrong lens to look at this. It's hard for the individual to punish a corporation. Ultimately the goal is to maximize your own purchase so the best way to achieve that is to find a better product. Then that merchant grows based on their ability to serve the customer. In my experience, most companies tend to be punished not by people or competition, but by their own folly.

And if there really is no merchant serving your product for your price, that's a much larger discussion to have.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by squeaky-clean on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:15PM (#38539757)
I wouldn't say Street Fighter 5 put out an update with malware. It did put out an update that opened up a kernel level vulnerability to unprivileged programs which is extremely bad and worth requesting a refund for. But I wouldn't say Intel sold me malware because my CPU was susceptible to spectre and meltdown.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by tadfisher on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @11:44PM (#38540550)
Your account is nuked if you make your credit card issuer perform a chargeback, not if you request a refund and are granted one. I have refunded at least 10 titles on Steam, and my account is still there.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by JodieBenitez on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:57PM (#38538669)
> You can't claim it's common.

cough kindle... cough

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by delecti on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:14PM (#38538800)
Is it common? I only know of the ironic removal of 1984, and that was in 2009. I've got 500+ books in my kindle library and am not aware of it ever happening to me.

And to be clear, I wouldn't be surprised if it has happened again since, but I've never heard of any, so I agree with the GP comment's assertion that it isn't common.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by JodieBenitez on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:40PM (#38539022)
I don't know if it's common, but I've seen enough of it that I don't trust companies with their practice. Also it goes both ways: Remember when Apple forced a U2 album on iTunes users ?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by acheron on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:07PM (#38539248)
They didn’t “force” anything, they made it available to download if you wanted.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by jkestner on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:27PM (#38539400)
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by amatecha on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:07PM (#38539695)
If you haven't used Apple ecosystem stuff you may not realize, but there are many ways in which this album surfaces, such as simply pressing Play on your Apple Watch (without having specified any song)... I've accidentally played U2's music so many times since Apple "gifted" it to me, despite having zero interest in hearing that music at that time.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by JodieBenitez on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:52AM (#38541124)
Nope. It was right there in my music collection where it doesn't belong.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:01PM (#38538701)
Are you aware of any cases where they didn't refund [1]?

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18am...

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by mvdtnz on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:14PM (#38538802)
I don't think that's the point. If the industry is going to regularly make me go through incessant cycles of purchasing, getting refunded, rebuying (for the same price?) then I'm going to pirate the content. What an absolutely absurd expectation.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:02PM (#38539207)
I thought the point was ownership and how flimsy ownership lead to Piracy. Not a personal rant on how your bad customer service experience justifies your decision to pirate.

I don't care if people "steal" from billion dollar corporations. But let's not mince words and pretend it's some Robin Hood act of altruism. The companies already took that piracy into account on their budget book anyway; they won't change their ways over this.

That whole Gabe Newell quote about "piracy is a service issue" goes both ways. Piracy isn't always convinent and plenty of people don't wanna set up plex servers and search torrents and organize their library to get "the best experience". They just want to turn on device and play/watch/read seemlessly

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by mvdtnz on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @10:38PM (#38540230)
What? Unilaterally refunding a purchase I made years ago isn't "bad customer service". It's just a company being shitty and not caring. I am the party that acted in good faith and purchased the content! What are you even talking about?
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @12:42AM (#38540801)
Companies don't like refunding either in all fairness. And your phrasing makes it sound like this happens to you regularly.

I don't think "refund" is the best use of word here. That's usually a customer returning a product. And a company with bad refund policies tends to have bad customer service.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by rowanG077 on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:46AM (#38541084)
So from your perspective it would be oke if randomly thieves enter your home, "take" some stuff from you and leaving behind a calling card so you can arrange to get paid for it.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:16AM (#38541242)
This metaphor breaks down because you don't own the servers hosting the stuff in question. It's not your house to begin with.

And it's not my point at all in that comment. I'm just saying most 'thieves' aren't trying to prove they are good people by stealing like how piracy arguments oh so often go here. Nor trying to pretend they are archivist saving artifacts from disappearing off the face of the earth. They are either greedy, desperate to survive, and in a few rare cases a pathological disorder.

It's premium entertainment, and people either want to consume a product but dont/can't pay. It's that simple. and I'm not saying that from a judgmental POV either. I've done it quite a bit as a grade schooler.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by rowanG077 on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:45AM (#38541393)
The entire point is indeed that you can't own it. You saying it's not comparable because you don't own the servers is non-sensical. It's not like you can choose not use the servers. Well you can. You have to pirate it.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @02:59AM (#38541496)
There's plenty (most of the) comments talking about ownership, I have nothing more to add on that topic. It's only tangentially related to my main point in that it's an argument used to defend piracy. And it's IMO a futile argument because people can't agree what "ownership" is.

For me, I try to find drm free copies of games when possible, or physical media when that fails. That's enough for me to feel "ownership".

----

I simply wanted to talk about the internet attitude towards piracy in this thread. I've done it but I never boasted around about slaying some corrupt corporation by ripping an ISO off a disc, or simply finding a torrent.

No, I did it to either not pay for a game or to mod games with no native mod support. I'm not a good person to begin with and I don't pretend I'm a good person by pirating.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by blcknight on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:04PM (#38538729)
What good is that? If I buy a book or a movie I want to own it forever not until the company decides to take it back regardless of giving a refund…
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by tedsanders on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:35PM (#38538974)
Yes. When the old online Dominion lost the license to the Dominion card game, they didn't refund buyers with cash; they refunded the buyers with some kind of digital dollars to spend on their other unattractive products. So essentially every dollar spent on Dominion expansions was lost. Really soured me on the idea of purchasing online board games.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by lp0_on_fire on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:16PM (#38538825)
"We broke into your house last night and took that book off the shelf. But we left 20 bucks on the counter so it's ok!"
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:20PM (#38538852)
In the case in that link, the publisher was not legitimate. Amazon (literally) sold a pirated copy. They refunded, allowing you to buy a non-pirated copy. The alternative would be to swap it out for a copy from a legitimate publisher, but I assume there are laws around swapping goods out from under people.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Timshel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:08PM (#38539257)
It's not new that you do not own DRM uncumbered files. It's true that it was expected that you'll lose access due to drm server disappearing not pure deletion ...
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nullhole on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:25PM (#38538895)
> I’ve seen so many studios go under, that I loved.

I've never experienced that in the last 20 years of purchasing digital media. You can't claim it's common.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @01:48PM (#38547956)
I suspect you haven't checked. Or this means you only play big name (EA, Ubisoft, etc) games and only watch/read big studio content (Disney, etc). That's fine, but it's trivial to find lists of failed production houses, especially with games [1], with Embracer and Volition shutting down this year (as more examples significant to me). And, you might be surprised at the long list of movie studios [2].

[1] https://www.thegamer.com/failed-game-studios-best-games-meta...

[2] https://movieweb.com/famous-defunct-american-film-studios/#b...

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by HideousKojima on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:31PM (#38538946)
Almost all PC games that utilized Games For Windows Live stopped working (new installs and reinstalls could no longer be performed) when Microsoft shut down the service, and AFAIK there are still a couple games that never updated to remove the reliance on GFWL DRM and can only be played by pirating.

That's a lot of games, including several notable big name titles: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Games_for_Windows_%E...

That includes GTA IV, Street Fighter IV, and Resident Evil 5.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by alpaca128 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:52PM (#38539120)
Luckily Dark Souls got re-released on Steam without Windows Live. Until that point my purchased physical copy was unusable. Well, it's still unusable but at least the CD key got me a working version.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:41PM (#38539025)
As I said, pirating after is one thing. Justifying the pirating with a possible future event that may not happen is another.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by harry8 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:53PM (#38539127)
Justifying insurance with a possible future event that may not happen is another.

Sure but it's very much a minority point of view.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by HideousKojima on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:13PM (#38539305)
If the work to crack a game isn't done early on, it can become infinitely harder to do that work later, especially if there's a multiplayer component that needs to be reverse engineered. Being proactive about cracking, emulation, and piracy is the pro-social and pro-preservation of our culture/technology/heritage move here.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by nomel on Thursday December 07, 2023 @03:13PM (#38561223)
Cracking the game early is completely tangential to you supporting the developers of the thing you enjoy. I've bought games and then immediately downloaded the pirated version before. If you don't support the things you like, you're going to end up with the things that everyone else likes.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by ChoGGi on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @09:50AM (#38544619)
You can still download and use gfwl to play the games. At least I could play lost planet 2 the last time I checked.

Multiplayer on the other hand...

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by HideousKojima on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @04:27PM (#38549699)
>lost planet 2

Only because Capcom had to put in extra dev work to make it work again after the GFWL shutdown: https://www.reddit.com/r/pcgaming/comments/qq3sq9/capcom_has...

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:01PM (#38538698)
> I've never experienced in the last 20 years of purchasing digital media. You can't claim it's common

I've never experienced a car crash, so they can't be common, why should I wear a seatbelt?

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by tzs on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:52PM (#38539115)
What he should have written is "I've never experienced it in the last 20 years of purchasing digital media, am not acquainted with anyone who has even though most people I know purchase digital media, and it is only been reported a handful of times".

Unless it happens a lot but doesn't get any publicity, which seems pretty unlikely as there are too many widely read forums where people it happened to would report it, and too many publications like Ars, Tech Dirt, The Register, Torrent Freak, and many others that would jump on any such story, we must indeed conclude that it is not common.

The important question is not if it is common but rather will it become common?

Discovery is part of Warner, which is currently being run by someone who will kill content for the tax write offs. He killed "Final Space" for a tax write off, cancelling future season and pulling existing seasons from streaming and sale. And last year they killed a movie, "Acme vs. Coyote", that they had completed and scheduled for release because they decided they'd rather write it off.

Because of that right now I would not buy any streaming content from Warner. In the specific case of Discovery it looks like they are just pulling it from other platforms so that it can be exclusive to services they own, like Max and Discovery+.

That probably means it is safe for now to buy Warner owned content through Warner owned platforms, but I'd worry that in the future they will decide to write it off and it will leave their own platforms too.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:33PM (#38539443)
I can Google a car crash down to an exact street in my area with no problem. I'd need to Google pretty hard to fine another instance of a store delisting a video game and retroactively removing it from the buyer's library.

I can only recall it happening once before on steam, and it was due to malware on the now delisted game.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Aurornis on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:37PM (#38539472)
I suppose I’d have sympathy if someone previously purchased content, lost it due to this action, and then pirated a copy to continue being able to watch it.

I don’t have much sympathy for people who see these headlines and use it as a blanket justification to pirate anything and everything.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by Brian_K_White on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:08PM (#38539706)
I don't even pirate and I do sympathise and excuse completely.

It's perfectly rational to me to decide to avoid getting burned in the first place, and actually a bit less rational to knowingly allow it, then wait for it to happen, and only then do something about it.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 06, 2023 @10:00PM (#38552299)
I don't sympathize. But I don't damn them either.

I especially don't sympathize for those who feel they need to profess loud and proud and act like Robin Hood for pirating. No you're not. Limousine liberalism at its finest. Acting like their actions are going to topple the empire instead of being seen as an ant grabbing some tiny crumb off the kitchen floor.

You can't even claim some technical boasting. You downloaded a file off the internet based on the work someone else did to upload said file, on a website that did the work of hosting. La dee da. It's not the 90's anymore; I'm not going to praise someone for doing a basic internet function in 2023.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by dotancohen on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:41PM (#38539501)
I don't pirate, but I would understand the position of acquiring any object - physical or digital - preferably from the place that won't try to take it back later. Pirated files do not carry the risks that purchased files carry. Risks that range from the files being deleted later, to data breaches exposing PII.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by notatoad on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @08:47PM (#38539546)
that's okay, the pirates don't need your sympathy. Our TV library didn't just get deleted.

i really don't try to justify my piracy much anymore. i like free shit and it's easy. but things like this really make it hard to feel guilty.

Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by autoexec on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:06PM (#38539689)
You're much better off getting a copy of everything you buy digitally before some company remotes into your devices and steals your legally purchased media. You might find certain content much more difficult to find if you wait.
Re:Playstation is erasing 1,318 seasons of Discovery shows f... by pdimitar on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:10PM (#38539722)
So you expect people not to take lessons from such occurrences and not attempt to avoid getting burned in the first place?