News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jafitc on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:31AM (#38379682)
OpenAI's Future and Viability

- OpenAI has damaged their brand and lost trust, but may still become a hugely successful company if they build great products

- OpenAI looks stronger now with a more professional board, but has fundamentally transformed into a for-profit focused on commercializing LLMs

- OpenAI still retains impressive talent and technology assets and could pivot into a leading AI provider if managed well

---

Sam Altman's Leadership

- Sam emerged as an irreplaceable CEO with overwhelming employee loyalty, but may have to accept more oversight

- Sam has exceptional leadership abilities but can be manipulative; he will likely retain control but have to keep stakeholders aligned

---

Board Issues

- The board acted incompetently and destructively without clear reasons or communication

- The new board seems more reasonable but may struggle to govern given Sam's power

- There are still opposing factions on ideology and commercialization that will continue battling

---

Employee Motivations

- Employees followed the money trail and Sam to preserve their equity and careers

- Peer pressure and groupthink likely also swayed employees more than principles

- Mission-driven employees may still leave for opportunities at places like Anthropic

---

Safety vs Commercialization

- The safety faction lost this battle but still has influential leaders wanting to constrain the technology

- Rapid commercialization beat out calls for restraint but may hit snags with model issues

---

Microsoft Partnership

- Microsoft strengthened its power despite not appearing involved in the drama

- OpenAI is now clearly beholden to Microsoft's interests rather than an independent entity

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by amalcon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:06AM (#38380225)
>- Microsoft strengthened its power despite not appearing involved in the drama

Depending on what you mean by "the drama", Microsoft was very clearly involved. They don't appear to have been in the loop prior to Altman's firing, but they literally offered jobs to everyone who left in solidarity with same. Do we really think things like that were not intended to change people's minds?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by gcanyon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:27AM (#38380522)
I’d go further than just saying “they were involved” —- by offering jobs to everyone who wanted to come with Altman, they were effectively offering to acquire OpenAI, which is worth ~$100B, for (checks notes) zero dollars.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by gsuuon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:41AM (#38380703)
How has the valuation of OpenAI increased by $20B since this weekend? I feel like every time I see that number it goes up by $10B.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by sebzim4500 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:48AM (#38380803)
$110B? Where are you getting this valuation of $120B?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by tacoooooooo on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:47AM (#38380797)
you're off by a bit, the announcement of Sam returning as CEO actually increased OpenAI valuation to $110B last night
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by breadwinner on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:37AM (#38380651)
You mean zero additional dollars. They already gave (checks notes) $13 Billion dollars and own half of the company.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rvnx on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:38AM (#38380671)
+ according to the rumors on Bloomberg.com / CNBC:

The investment is refundable and has high priority: Microsoft has a priority to receive 75% of the profit generated until the 10B USD have been paid back

+ (checks notes) in addition (!) OpenAI has to spend back the money in Microsoft Cloud Services (where Microsoft takes a cut as well).

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by theptip on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:45AM (#38380760)
If the existing packages are worth more than MSFT pay AI researchers (they are, by a lot) then it’s not acquiring OAI for $0. Plausibly it could cost in the $B to buy put every single equity holder, at a $80B+ valuation.

Still a good deal, but your accounting is off.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by FirmwareBurner on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#38380287)
>but they literally offered jobs to everyone who left in solidarity with same

Offering people jobs is neither illegal nor immoral, no? And wasn't HN also firmly on the side of abolishing non-competes and non-soliciting from employment contracts to facilitate freedom of employment movement and increase industry wages in the process?

Well then, there's your freedom of employment in action. Why be unhappy about it? I don't get it.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by spankalee on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:13AM (#38380323)
> Offering people jobs is neither illegal nor immoral

The comment you responded to made neither of those claims, just that they were "involved".

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by notahacker on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:57AM (#38380927)
I'm pretty sure there's a middle ground between recruiters for Microsoft should be banned from approaching other companies' staff to fill roles and Microsoft should be able to dictate decisions made by other companies' boards by publicly announcing that unless they change track it will attempt to hire every single one of their employees to newly created roles.

Funnily enough a bit like there's a middle ground between Microsoft should not be allowed to create browsers or have license agreements and Microsoft should be allowed to dictate bundling decisions made by hardware vendors to control access to the Internet

It's not freedom of employment when funnily enough those jobs aren't actually available to any AI researchers not working for an organisation Microsoft is trying to control.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by malfist on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:22AM (#38380441)
The GP looks to me like an AI summary. Which would fit with the hallucination that microsoft wasn't involved.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by chankstein38 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:53AM (#38380863)
That's a good callout. I was reading over it and confused who this person was and why they were summarizing but yeah they might've just told ChatGPT to summarize the events of what happened.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by RationalDino on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:35AM (#38380620)
The one piece of this that I question is the employee motivations.

First, they had offers to walk to both Microsoft and Salesforce and be made good. They didn't have to stay and fight to have money and careers.

But more importantly, put yourself in the shoes of an employee and read https://web.archive.org/web/20231120233119/https://www.busin... for what they apparently heard.

I don't know about anyone else. But if I was being asked to choose sides in a he-said, she-said dispute, the board was publicly hinting at really bad stuff, and THAT was the explanation, I know what side I'd take.

Don't forget, when the news broke, people's assumption from the wording of the board statement was that Sam was doing shady stuff, and there was potential jail time involved. And they justify smearing Sam like that because two board members thought they heard different things from Sam, and he gave what looked like the same project to two people???

There were far better stories that they could have told. Heck, the Internet made up many far better narratives than the board did. But that was the board's ACTUAL story.

Put me on the side of, "I'd have signed that letter, and money would have had nothing to do with it."

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by blihp on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:57AM (#38380924)
The Board was screwed the second they were unable to provide specifics that people would get behind. Had they been able to present examples of 'the Board repeatedly raised concerns of X which were disregarded despite assurances they would be addressed...' or 'Sam said to the Board he would do X but then did Y...' (i.e. if they couldn't trust what Sam was telling them, why weren't they able to provide a single example of when he lied or misled them?) at least a good faith argument could be made that people could have an honest intellectual discussion about and even if they ended up disagreeing could say 'but I can see why the Board did what they did'.

As soon as the push-back on this started[1], they needed to demonstrate that they really couldn't trust what he was saying, since that was the reason they gave for the firing. Their inability to do so made their motivations look petty and/or suspect.

[1] Which was entirely predictable since they went around the Chairman of the Board to pull this off and seemed to think their demotion plan of a 'vital' employee was going to work.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by TheGRS on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:56AM (#38380913)
I was thinking the same. The letter symbolized a deep distrust with leadership over the mission and direction of the company. I’m sure financial motivations were involved, but the type of person working at this company can probably get a good paycheck at a lot of places. I think many work at OpenAI for some combination of opportunity, prestige, and altruism, and the weekend probably put all 3 into question.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by qualifiedai on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:39AM (#38379802)
No structure or organization is stronger when their leader emerged as "irreplaceable".
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rmbyrro on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:43AM (#38379860)
In this case, I don't see as a flaw, but really as Sam's abilities to lead a highly cohesive group and keep it highly motivated and aligned.

I don't personally like him, but I must admit he displayed a lot more leadership skills than I'd recognize before.

It's inherently hard to replace someone like that in any organization.

Take Apple, after losing Jobs. It's not that Apple was a "weak" organization, but really Jobs that was extraordinary and indeed irreplaceable.

No, I'm not comparing Jobs and Sam. Just illustrating my point.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by prh8 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:50AM (#38379956)
What's the difference between leadership skills and cult of following?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by spurgu on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:12AM (#38380308)
I think an awesome leader would naturally create some kind of cult following, while the opposite isn't true.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Popeyes on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:19AM (#38380398)
Just like former President Trump?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by marcosdumay on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:27AM (#38380515)
There are two possible ways to read "the opposite" from the GP.

"A cult follower does not make an exceptional leader" is the one you are looking for.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by 0perator on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:28AM (#38381352)
While cult followers do not make exceptional leaders, cult leaders are almost by definition exceptional leaders, given they're able to lead the un-indoctrinated into believing an ideology that may not be upheld against critical scrutiny.

There is no guarantee or natural law that an exceptional leader's ideology will be exceptional. Exceptionality is not transitive.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rmbyrro on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:27AM (#38381345)
Have you ever seen a useful product produced by a cult?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:37AM (#38380657)
Leadership Gets Shit Done. A cult following wastes everyone's time on ineffectual grandstanding and ego fluffing while everything around them dissolves into incompetence and hostility.

They're very orthogonal things.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rvnx on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:45AM (#38380762)
I also imagine the morale of the people who are currently implementing things, and getting tired of all these politics about who is going to claim success for their work.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by thedaly on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:18AM (#38380390)
Results
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by pk-protect-ai on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:18AM (#38380388)
Can't you imagine a group of people motivated to conduct AI research? I don't understand... All nerds are highly motivated in their areas of passion, and here we have AI research. Why do they need leadership instead of simply having an abundance of resources for the passionate work they do?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by DSingularity on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:33AM (#38380584)
As far as it goes for me the only endorsements that matter are those of the core engineering and research teaches of OpenAI.

All these opinions of outsiders don’t matter. It’s obvious that most people don’t know Sam personally or professionally and are going off of the combination of: 1. PR pieces being pushed by unknown entities 2. positive endorsements from well known people who are likely know him

Both those sources are suspect. We don’t know the motivation behind their endorsements and for the PR pieces we know the author but we don’t know commissioner.

Would we feel as positive about Altman if it turns out that half the people and PR pieces endorsing him are because government officials pushing for him? Or if the celebrities in tech are endorsing him because they are financially incentivized?

The only endorsements that matter are those of OpenAI employees (ideally those who are not just in his camp because he made them rich).

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jjk166 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:54AM (#38380874)
It's not hard to motivate them to do the fun parts of the job, the challenge is in convincing some of those highly motivated and passionate nerds to not work on the fun thing they are passionate about and instead do the boring and unsexy work that is nevertheless critical to overall success; to get people with strong personal opinions about how a solution should look to accept a different plan just so that everyone is on the same page, to ensure that people actually have access to the resources they need to succeed without going so overboard that the endeavor lacks the reserves to make it to the finish line, and to champion the work of these nerds to the non-nerds who are nevertheless important stakeholders.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by gcanyon on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:41AM (#38380714)
Someone has to set direction. The more people that are involved in that decision process, the slower it will go.

Having no leadership at all guarantees failure.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by scythe on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:14AM (#38381152)
Jobs was really unusual in that he was not only a good leader, but also an ideologue with the right obsession at the right time. (Some people like the word "visionary".) That obsession being "user experience". Today it's a buzzword, but in 2001 it was hardly even a term.

The leadership moment that first comes to mind when I think of Steve Jobs isn't some clever hire or business deal, it's "make it smaller".

There have been a very few people like that. Walt Disney comes to mind. Felix Klein. Yen Hongchang [1]. (Elon Musk is maybe the ideologue without the leadership.)

1: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2012/01/20/145360447/the-...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Aunche on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:31AM (#38380559)
I don't think Sam is necessarily irreplaceable. It's just that Helen Toner and co were so detached from the rest of the organization they might as well been on Mars, as demonstrated by their interim CEO pick instantly turning against them.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rvnx on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:22AM (#38380452)
And correlation does not imply causality.

Example: Put a loser as CEO of a rocket ship, and there is a huge chance that the company will still be successful.

Put a loser as CEO of a sinking ship, and there is a huge chance that the company will fail.

The exceptional CEOs are those who turn failures into successes.

The fact this drama has emerged is the symptom of a failure.

In a company with a great CEO this shouldn’t be happening.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by osigurdson on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:46AM (#38379890)
Seriously, even in a small group of a few hundred people?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by catapart on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:51AM (#38379971)
I dunno, seems like a pretty self-evident theory? If your leader is irreplaceable, regardless of group size, that's a single point of failure. I can't figure how a single point of failure could ever make something "stronger". I can see arguments for necessity, or efficiency, given contrivances and extreme contexts. But "stronger" doesn't seem like the assessment for whatever necessitating a single point of failure would be.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by vipshek on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:17AM (#38380373)
"Stronger" is ambiguous. If you interpret it as "resilience" then I agree having a single point of failure is usually more brittle. But if you interpret it as "focused", then having a single charismatic leader can be superior.

Concretely, it sounds like this incident brought a lot of internal conflicts to the surface, and they got more-or-less resolved in some way. I can imagine this allows OpenAI to execute with greater focus and velocity going forward, as the internal conflict that was previously causing drag has been resolved.

Whether or not that's "better" or "stronger" is up to individual interpretation.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hughw on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:49AM (#38380819)
I guess though, a lot of organizations never develop a cohesive leader at all, and the orgs fall apart. They never had an irreplaceable leader though!
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by osigurdson on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:39PM (#38389347)
A company is essentially an optimization problem, meant to minimize / maximize some set of metrics. Usually a companies goal is simply to maximize NPV but in OpenAI's case the goal is to maximize AI while minimizing harm.

"Failure" in this context essentially means arriving at a materially suboptimal outcome. Leaders in this situation, can easily be considered "irreplaceable" particularly in the early stages as decisions are incredibly impactful.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dimitrios1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:53AM (#38379994)
This is false, and I see the corollary as a project having a BDIF, especially if the leader is effective. Sam is unmistakably effective.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by acchow on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:00AM (#38380115)
Have you or anyone close to you ever had to take multiple years of leave from work from a car accident or health condition?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by slingnow on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#38380280)
Nope, I've never even __heard__ of someone having to take multiple years of leave from work for any reason. Seems like a fantastically rare event.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by thingification on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:31AM (#38380560)
Not sure if that's intended as irony, but of course, if somebody is taking multiple years off work, you would be less likely hear about it because by definition they're not going to join the company you work for.

I don't think long-term unemployment among people with a disability or other long-term condition is "fantasticaly rare", sadly. This is not the frequency by length of unemployment, but:

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1219257/us-employment-ra...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by yeck on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:48AM (#38380807)
In my immediate family I have 3 people that have taken multi-year periods away from work for health reasons. Two are mental health related and the other severe arthritis. 2 of those 3 will probably never work again for the rest of their lives.

I've worked with a contractor that went into a coma during covid. Nearly half a year in a coma, then rehab for many more months. Guy is working now, but not shape.

I don't know the stats, but I'd be surprised if long medical leaves are as rare as you think.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by filleduchaos on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:26PM (#38382134)
Yeah, there are thousands of hospitals across the US and they don't run 24/7 shifts just to treat the flu or sprained ankles. Disabling events happen a lot.

(A seriously underrated statistic IMO is how many women leave the workforce due to pregnancy-related disability. I know quite a few who haven't returned to full-time work for years after giving birth because they're still dealing with cardiovascular and/or neurological issues. If you aren't privy to their medical history it would be very easy to assume that they just decided to be stay-at-home mums.)

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dimitrios1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:43PM (#38388989)
Have you ever worked with someone who treats their work as their life? They are borderline psychopaths. As if a health condition or accident will stop them. They'll be taking work calls on the hospital bed.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jxi on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:06AM (#38380221)
Was this really motivated by AI safety or was it just Helen Toner’s personal vendetta against Sam?

It doesn’t feel like anything was accomplished besides wasting 700+ people’s time, and the only thing that has changed now is Helen Toner and Tasha McCauley are off the board.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:22AM (#38380438)
As someone who was very critical of how the board acted, I strongly disagree. I felt like this Washington Post article gave a very good, balanced overview. I think it sounds like there were substantive issues that were brewing for a long time, though no doubt personal clashes had a huge impact on how it all went down:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/11/22/sam-alt...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jkaplan on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:54AM (#38380880)
> was it just Helen Toner’s personal vendetta against Sam

I'm not defending the board's actions, but if anything, it sounds like it may have been the reverse? [1]

> In the email, Mr. Altman said that he had reprimanded Ms. Toner for the paper and that it was dangerous to the company... “I did not feel we’re on the same page on the damage of all this,” he wrote in the email. “Any amount of criticism from a board member carries a lot of weight." Senior OpenAI leaders, including Mr. Sutskever... later discussed whether Ms. Toner should be removed

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/21/technology/openai-altman-...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jxi on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @12:41PM (#38382356)
Right, so getting Sam fired was retaliation for that.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by cbeach on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:28AM (#38380529)
Curious how a relatively unknown academic with links to China [1] attained a board seat on America's hottest and most valuable AI company.

Particularly as she openly expressed that "destroying" that company might be the best outcome. [2]

> During the call, Jason Kwon, OpenAI’s chief strategy officer, said the board was endangering the future of the company by pushing out Mr. Altman. This, he said, violated the members’ responsibilities. Ms. Toner disagreed. The board’s mission was to ensure that the company creates artificial intelligence that “benefits all of humanity,” and if the company was destroyed, she said, that could be consistent with its mission.

[1] https://www.chinafile.com/contributors/helen-toner [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/21/technology/openai-altman-...

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:04AM (#38381019)
Oh lord, spare me with the "links to China" idiocy. I once ate a fortune cookie, does that mean I have "links to China" too?

Toner got her board seat because she was basically Holden Karnofsky's designated replacement:

> Holden Karnofsky resigns from the Board, citing a potential conflict because his wife, Daniela Amodei, is helping start Anthropic, a major OpenAI competitor, with her brother Dario Amodei. (They all live(d) together.) The exact date of Holden’s resignation is unknown; there was no contemporaneous press release.

> Between October and November 2021, Holden was quietly removed from the list of Board Directors on the OpenAI website, and Helen was added (Discussion Source). Given their connection via Open Philanthropy and the fact that Holden’s Board seat appeared to be permanent, it seems that Helen was picked by Holden to take his seat.

https://loeber.substack.com/p/a-timeline-of-the-openai-board

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by cbeach on Thursday November 23, 2023 @06:09AM (#38391559)
Perhaps you're not aware. Living in Beijing is not equivalent to "once eating a fortune cookie"

> it seems that Helen was picked by Holden to take his seat.

So you can only speculate as to how she got the seat. Which is exactly my point. We can only speculate. And it's a question worth asking, because governance of America's most important AI company is a very important topic right now.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Zpalmtree on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:33AM (#38380586)
Wow, very surprised this is the first I'm hearing of this, seems very suspect
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by neonbjb on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:36AM (#38380642)
As an employee of OpenAI: fuck you and your condescending conclusions about my peers and my motivations.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by jprete on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:46AM (#38380778)
I’m curious about your perceptions of the (median) motivations of OpenAI employees - although of course I understand if you don’t feel free to say anything.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by iamflimflam1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:05AM (#38381026)
"condescending conclusions" - ask anyone outside of tech how they feel when we talk to them...
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by alextheparrot on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:48AM (#38380799)
Users here often get the narrative and motivations deeply wrong, I wouldn’t take it too personally (Speaking as a peer)
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:01AM (#38380138)
> Peer pressure and groupthink likely also swayed employees more than principles

What makes this "likely"?

Or is this just pure conjecture?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mrfox321 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:06AM (#38380220)
What would you do if 999 employees openly signed a letter and you are the remaining holdout.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:10AM (#38380275)
Is your argument that the 1 employee operated on peer pressure, or the other 999?

Could it possibly be that the majority of OpenAI's workforce sincerely believed a midnight firing of the CEO were counterproductive to their organization's goals?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mrfox321 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:27AM (#38381350)
Doing the math, it is extremely unlikely for a lot of coin flips to skew from the weight of the coin.

To that end, observing unanimous behavior may imply some bias.

Here, it could be people fearing being a part of the minority. The minority are trivially identifiable, since the majority signed their names on a document.

I agree in your stance that a majority of the workforce disagreed with the way things were handled, but that proportion is likely a subset of the proportion who signed their names on the document, for the reasons stated above.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:34AM (#38381428)
> it is extremely unlikely for a lot of coin flips to skew from the weight of the coin

So clearly this wasn't a 50/50 coin flip.

The question at hand is whether the skew against the board was sincere or insincere.

Personally, I assume that people are acting in good faith, unless I have evidence to the contrary.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mrfox321 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:20PM (#38386642)
I'm not saying it's 50/50.

But future signees are influenced by previous signees.

Acting in good faith is different from bias.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by dymk on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:22AM (#38380442)
It's almost certain that all employees did not behave the same way for the exact same reasons. And I don't see anyone making an argument about what the exact numbers are, nor does it really matter. Just that some portion of employees were swayed by pressure once the letter reached some critical signing mass.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by paulddraper on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:28AM (#38381361)
> some portion

The logic being that if any opinion has above X% support, people are choosing it based on peer pressure.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by mrfox321 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:31AM (#38381377)
The key is that the support is not anonymous.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nurumaik on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:40AM (#38379804)
Gpt-generated summary?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Mistletoe on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:12AM (#38380303)
That was my first thought as well. And now it is the top comment on this post. Isn’t this brave new world OpenAI made wonderful?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nickpp on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:30AM (#38380553)
If it’s a good comment, does it really matter if a human or an AI wrote it?
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by makeworld on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:44AM (#38380747)
Yes.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nickpp on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:49AM (#38380814)
Please expand on that.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by iamflimflam1 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:06AM (#38381049)
This is the most cogent argument against AI I've seen so far.

https://youtu.be/iGJcF4bLKd4?si=Q_JGEZnV-tpFa1Tb

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nickpp on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:09PM (#38382778)
I am sorry, I greatly respect and admire Nick Cave, but that letter sounded to me like the lament of a scribe decrying the invention of the printing press.

He's not wrong, something is lost and it has to do with what we call our "humanity", but the benefits greatly outweigh that loss.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by makeworld on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:56PM (#38395456)
If you think humanity being lost is acceptable, then it's hard to discuss anything else on this topic.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nickpp on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:44PM (#38396031)
> you think humanity being lost is acceptable

I never said that.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by Mistletoe on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @01:21PM (#38382972)
I think this summarizes it pretty well. Even if you don't mind the garbage, the future AI will feed on this garbage, creating AI and human brain gray goo.

https://ploum.net/2022-12-05-drowning-in-ai-generated-garbag...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gray_goo

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by nickpp on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:09PM (#38383658)
Is this a real problem model trainers actually face or is it an imagined one? The Internet is already full of garbage - 90% of the unpleasantness of browsing these days is filtering through mounts and mounds of crap. Some is generated, some is written, but still crap full of wrong and lies.

I would've imagined training sets were heavily curated and annotated. We already know how to solve this problem for training humans (or our kids would never learn anything useful) so I imagine we could solve it similarly for AIs.

In the end, if it's quality content, learning it is beneficial - no matter who produced it. Garbage needs to be eliminated and the distinction is made either by human trainers or already trained AIs. I have no idea how to train the latter but I am no expert in this field - just like (I suspect) the author of that blog.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by makeworld on Thursday November 23, 2023 @12:54PM (#38395431)
The value of a creation cannot be solely judged by its output. It's hard to explain, it's better to intuit it.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by orsenthil on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:02AM (#38380157)
> - Mission-driven employees may still leave for opportunities at places like Anthropic

Which might have an oversight from AMZN instead of MSFT ?

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by sam0x17 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:05AM (#38380196)
> Peer pressure and groupthink likely also swayed employees more than principles

Chilling to hear the corporate oligarchs completely disregard the feelings of employees and deny most of the legitimacy behind these feelings in such a short and sweeping statement

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by DSingularity on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:38AM (#38380661)
Honestly he has a point — but the bigger point to be made is financial incentives. In this case it matters because of the expressed mission statement of OpenAI.

Let’s say there was some non-profit claiming to advance the interests of the world. Let’s say it paid very well to hire the most productive people but they were a bunch of psychopaths who by definition couldn’t care less about anybody but themselves. Should you care about their opinions? If it was a for profit company you could argue that their voice matter. For a non-profit, however, a persons opinion should only matter as far as it is aligned with the non-profit mission.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by windowshopping on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:47AM (#38380788)
This comment bugs me because it reads like a summary of an article, but it's just your opinions without any explanations to justify them.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by seydor on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:58AM (#38380086)
who would want to work for an irreplaceable CEO long term
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by rvnx on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:33AM (#38380589)
Desperate people who have no choice than to wait for someone to remove their golden handcuffs.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by ensocode on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @10:06AM (#38380213)
Good points. Anyway I guess nobody will remember the drama in some months so I think the damage done is very manageable for OAI.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by miohtama on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:41AM (#38379822)
> Employees followed the money trail and Sam to preserve their equity and careers

Would you not when the AI safety wokes decide the torch the rewards of your hard work of grinding for years? I feel there is less groupthink and everyone saw the board as it is and their inability lead, or even act rationally. OpenAI did not just become a sinking ship, but it was unnecessary sunk by someone not skin in the game and your personal wealth and success was tied to the ship.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by acjohnson55 on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @11:45AM (#38381583)
How do you know the "wokes" aren't the ones who were grinding for years?

I suspect OpenAI has an old guard that is disproportionately ideological about AI, and a much larger group of people who joined a rocket ship led by the guy who used to run YC.

Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by brookst on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @09:57AM (#38380071)
Yeah, this is like using “groupthink” to describe people fleeing a burning building. There’s maybe some measure of literal truth, but it’s an odd way to frame it.
Re:We have reached an agreement in principle for Sam to retu... by scooke on Thursday November 23, 2023 @03:58AM (#38390838)
Many are still going to use this; few will bother to ponder and break the event down like this.