News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by davikr on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:29PM (#38353176)
Ilya has signed the petition, so that's two out of three left.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by alephnerd on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:37PM (#38353330)
As I posted elsewhere, I think this is a conflict between Dustin Moskovitz and Sam Altman. Ilya may have been brought into this without his knowledge (which might explain why he retracted his position).

Dustin Moskovitz was an early employee at FB, and the founder of Asana. He also created (along with plenty of MSFT bigwigs) a non-profit called Open Philanthropy, which was a early proponent of a form of Effective Altruism and also gave OpenAI their $30M grant. He is also one of the early investors in Anthropic.

Most of the OpenAI board members are related to Dustin Moskovitz this way.

- Adam D'Angelo is on the board of Asana and is a good friend to both Moskovitz and Altman

- Helen Toner worked for Dustin Moskovitz at Open Philanthropy and managed their grant to OpenAI. She was also a member of the Centre for the Governance of AI when McCauley was a board member there. Shortly after Toner left, the Centre for the Governance of AI got a $1M grant from Open Philanthropy and McCauley joined the board of OpenAI

- Tasha McCauley represents the Centre for the Governance of AI, which Dustin Moskovitz gave a $1M grant to via Open Philanthropy and McCauley ended up joining the board of OpenAI

Over the past few months, Dustin Moskovitz has also been increasingly warning about AI Safety.

In essense, it looks like a split between Sam Altman and Dustin Moskovitz

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by drawkbox on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:26PM (#38354144)
A "conflict" or false opposition can also be used in a theater like play. Maybe this was setup to get Microsoft to take on the costs/liability and more. Three board members left in 2023 that allowed this to happen.

The idea of boards might even be an anti-pattern going forward, they can be played and used in essentially rug pull scenarios for full control of all the work of entire organizations. Maybe boards are past their time or too much of a potential timebomb/trojan horse now.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by coliveira on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:40PM (#38355250)
This has been the case as long as companies existed. Even with all this, companies still have boards because they represent the interests of several people.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by valine on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:12PM (#38353929)
If he has safety concerns with OpenAI, he must be mortified with his old company Meta dropping 70B llamas on HF.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by htk on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:57PM (#38353643)
Very interesting take, and it sheds some light to the role of the two most discredited board members.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by folli on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:20PM (#38354048)
Okay, I know this is a very naive question, but anyways: might Dustin /the board be onto something regarding AI safety which was not there before?
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jacquesm on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:22PM (#38354086)
If there was there are 700 people motivated to leak it and none did. What could they be aware of that the rest of OpenAI would not be aware of? How did the learn about it?
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by endtime on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:11PM (#38354841)
I agree it's probably not something new. But I will observe that OpenAI rank and file employees, presumably mostly working on making AI more effective, are very strongly selected against people who are sympathetic to safety/x-risk concerns.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by teacpde on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:56PM (#38353626)
This is the most logical explanation I have seen so far. Makes me wonder why Dustin Moskovitz himself wasn't on the board of OpenAI in the first place.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by chucke1992 on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:50PM (#38353524)
I mean, you can't vote to drop CEO without knowing...
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by htk on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:03PM (#38353748)
Please repost this as a stand alone comment, I bet it would be voted to the top.

Or maybe dang can extract this comment and orphan it.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by brandall10 on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:54PM (#38353593)
Wow, this is extremely useful information, it ties all the pieces together. Surprised it hasn't been reported elsewhere.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jansan on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:07PM (#38353810)
It has come to the point that hearing the expression "Effective Altruism" sends shivers down my spline.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by golergka on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:16PM (#38354924)
I still read it as Effective Autism. Makes more sense that way.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by moffkalast on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:49PM (#38355388)
It's one tier below weaponized autism.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jacquesm on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:17PM (#38354012)
Ironically it is never effective nor is it ever altruism.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by kylecordes on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:22PM (#38355739)
Obviously we should all want our altruism to be effective. What is the other side of it? Wanting one's altruism to not really accomplish much?

But with everything that has gone on, I cannot imagine wanting to be an Effective Altruist! The movement by that name seems to do and think some really weird stuff.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by upwardbound on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:29PM (#38355825)
The "Think Globally, Act Locally" movement is the competing philosophy. It's deeply entrenched in our culture, and has absolutely dominated philanthropic giving for several decades.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_globally,_act_locally

"Think Globally, Act Locally" leads to charities in wealthy cities getting disproportionately huge amounts of money for semi-frivolous things like symphony orchestras, while people in the global south are dying of preventable diseases.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by zztop44 on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:00PM (#38356817)
It’s obnoxious because of that exact implication, that pre-existing altruism wasn’t concerned with efficacy. And that’s just not true.

There has been a community of professional practice around measuring impact and directing funds accordingly for decades. Does it always generate perfect results? No, far from it!! Is there room to improve? Absolutely, lots and lots of room!

But it’s hard not to notice that the people who call themselves Effective Altruists have no better a track record (actually, I would say far worse) than the so-called bloated NGOs and international organizations when it comes to efficacy.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by chucke1992 on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:30PM (#38355834)
We will fix you to become more altruistic.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jowea on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:00PM (#38356811)
One more thing SBF and crew ruined.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by g42gregory on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:13PM (#38353948)
Great insights. very interesting!
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by tatrajim on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:21PM (#38354069)
Intriguing, thanks. HN does provide gems of insight amidst the repetitive gossip.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by SpaceManNabs on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:25PM (#38355055)
A thing a sad, understated ongoing is that so many people are throwing vitriol at Ilya right now. If the speculation here is true, then he just chased by a mob over pure nonsense (well, at least purer than the nonsense premise beforehand).

Gotta love seeing effective altruists take another one on the chin this year though.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by rafaelero on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:19PM (#38357501)
Yeah, let's ask the guy who set the company on fire for forgiveness. He is just a poor child.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by abakker on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:33PM (#38355872)
The dude voted to fire Altman. He could have not done that. Actions have consequences.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by nonethewiser on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:51PM (#38357820)
At best he doesn’t have much integrity and caves to peer pressure. I would respect him more if he stood by his actions. Abandoning them just shows how frivolously his decision making was.

Perhaps more info will come out that casts a different light, but as of now it seems obvious that he decided to vote to fire Altman for reasons that he’s not willing to clarify and which he abandoned as soon as he saw the overwhelmingly negative reaction. He didnt even say he regrets firing Altman - just that he doesn’t want OpenAI to fall apart.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by abakker on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @04:14PM (#38370254)
Yeah, these votes were supposed to be what kept us safe from AI. The whole board was ill equipped to keep themselves neutral from their own business, let along protect humanity from the irresponsible outcomes of their models.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by tspike on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:27PM (#38355075)
Does this whole thing remind anyone else of the tech community’s version of celebrity gossip?
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by SpaceManNabs on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:29PM (#38355097)
Absolutely. It is borderline salacious. Honestly didn't feel too good watching so many people opine on matters they had no real data on and insult people; also the employees of openai announcing matters on twitter or wtv in tabloid style.

I hope people apologize to Ilya for jumping to conclusions.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by elaus on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:37PM (#38355918)
Yes, it was especially weird to read this on HN to such a big extend. The comments were (and are) full of people with very strong opinions, based on vague tweets or speculation. Quite unusual and hopefully not the new norm...
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by fuzztester on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:15PM (#38355670)
No. It reminds me more of Muddle [1] Ages' intrigue, scheming, and backstabbing, like the Medicis, Cesare Borgia and clan, Machiavelli (and his book The Prince, see Cesare again), etc., to take just one example. (Italy not being singled out here.) And also reminds me of all the effing feuding clans, dynasties, kingdoms, and empires down the centuries or millenia, since we came down from the trees. I guess galaxies have to be next, and that too is coming up, yo Elon, Mars, etc., what you couldn't fix on earth ain't gonna be fixable on Mars or even Pluto, Dummkopf, but give it your best shot anyway.

[1] Not a typo :)

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by r3d0c on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:04PM (#38356221)
just sounds like billionaire tech bros wanting to appear smarter and more important than they really are and a weird cult like obsession with AI at the expense of the rest of humanity even though AGI won't be possible for like a hundred or so years
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by fuzztester on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:23PM (#38357535)
Yes, except their obsession is really with getting even more money than the billions they already have, rather than an obsession with AI for advancing humanity, blah blah blah, which they have (not just like) to pretend it is, otherwise no one will respect them, let alone ass-kiss them (which, deep down, is what they really want, hence all the yes-men they surround themselves with).
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by silenced_trope on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:50PM (#38356063)
Yes, and I'm ashamed to say I'm unabashedly following it like the people I cringe at follow their fave celebs.

It's an interesting saga though and as a payer of ChatGPT+ I feel staked in it.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jowea on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:58PM (#38356795)
Finally, drama for people who think ~~we~~they're above celebrity drama.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jdgoesmarching on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:24PM (#38357048)
Yes and that’s fine. Hell, it might even good for people who have a superiority complex about disliking pop culture.

Drama is fun, and this is top tier drama.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by Apocryphon on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:35PM (#38355892)
TechCrunch should be at the forefront with coverage, but their glory days is far behind it. And Valleywag is gone. So I guess it's up to us to gossip on our own.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by alephnerd on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:45PM (#38355335)
This is why I detest YC (despite taking part in salicious gossip on here due to my social media addiction). A couple YC friends of mine have been very explicit about how they detest the conspiratorial YC hivemind.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by Apocryphon on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:38PM (#38355927)
Oh, let us have our fun. The industry's cooled off with the end of ZIRP and the coming holidays so people need the illusion that things are happening.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by upwardbound on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:18PM (#38355713)
But Ilya was the one that started this whole mess... He was the one that lit the match that lit the fuse...
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by nostrademons on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:31PM (#38355119)
More confusion - Emmett Shear is a close friend of Sam Altman. He was part of the original 2005 YCombinator class alongside Altman, part of the justin.tv mafia, and later a part-time partner at YCombinator. I don't think he has any such close ties to Dustin Moskovitz. Why would the Dustin-leaning OpenAI board install him as interim CEO?

This whole thing still seems to have the air of a pageant to me, where they're making a big stink for drama but it might be manufactured by all of the original board, with Sam, Ilya, Adam, and potentially others all on the same side.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by alephnerd on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:42PM (#38355287)
He's part of the EA community which Moskovitz funded. He was even named in Yudkowsky's warcrime of a Harry Potter fanfic [0][1]

[0] - https://www.404media.co/new-openai-ceo-emmett-shear-was-mino...

[1] - https://hpmor.com/chapter/104?ref=404media.co

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by dymk on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:09PM (#38355616)
Silicon Valley lore is way too complex at this point; needs a reboot. I'd rather start One Piece from scratch.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by chucke1992 on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:25PM (#38355779)
We need a wiki indeed.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by Apocryphon on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:30PM (#38355836)
You're posting on it.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by layer8 on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:46PM (#38356020)
https://silicon-valley.fandom.com/ is already taken, unfortunately.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by wirelesspotat on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:25PM (#38355778)
Why is Yudkowsky's HPMOR a "warcrime"?
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by fossuser on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:23PM (#38357532)
It's great - there's just a group on HN that think it's status-y to hate on it.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jychang on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:10AM (#38360388)
Ehhhh it was fine when I read it as a teenager but the writing quality alone (ignoring the content) certainly did not age well decade+ later
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by Tenoke on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:33PM (#38355873)
I find it really good but if you don't like rationality/EY it's really easy to latch on as something to hate (overly smart fanfic does sound cringe on the face of it).
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by madeofpalk on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:58PM (#38356142)
Also it's a Harry Potter fanfic.

That they paid $28k to distribute to others.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by Tenoke on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:08PM (#38356276)
I'm sure the return on that investment was very large in terms of donations.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by tedmiston on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:44PM (#38355307)
> More confusion - Emmett Shear is a close friend of Sam Altman. He was part of the original 2005 YCombinator class alongside Altman, part of the justin.tv mafia, and later a part-time partner at YCombinator. ... Why would the Dustin-leaning OpenAI board install him as interim CEO?

This was my first thought too: Is this a concession of the board to install a Sam friendly-ish Interim CEO?

It reads weird on paper.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by tukajo on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:16PM (#38355681)
Is Emmett Shear really "friends" with Sam Altman? He (Emmett) literally liked a tweet the other day that said something to the effect of: "Congratulations to Ilya on reclaiming the corporation that Sam Altman stole". I'm paraphrasing here, but I don't think Emmett and Sam are friends?
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by ec109685 on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:44PM (#38355994)
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by i_have_an_idea on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:17PM (#38356378)
> part of the justin.tv mafia

Side question, but why is that a "mafia". Is any tech entrepreneur starting a 2nd company after having one mildly successful exit now a "mafia" move?

Soon enough, I will probably read about the "skibidi toilet mafia" on this site..

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by alephnerd on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:53PM (#38356746)
Back in the early 2000s, the PayPal founders were from a handful of universities (UIUC, Stanford) and had a massive alumni network from those two programs. This was called the PayPal Mafia [0]

To this day, the any tight collection/network of founders from the same organization is called a "Mafia"

[0] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PayPal_Mafia

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by nostrademons on Monday November 20, 2023 @06:54PM (#38356758)
In startup culture, it usually refers to a group of individuals who underwent a formative experience in one company, then went on to start separate individual companies where they all cross-invest, cross-advise, and generally help out each others' companies. Term was originally used to refer to the PayPal mafia [1, notable members include Peter Thiel, Max Levchin, Elon Musk, Chad Hurley, Reid Hoffman, Jeremy Stoppelman, Yishan Wong, notable descendants include SpaceX, Tesla, YouTube, Yelp, LinkedIn, and arguably Facebook]. Since expanded to the justin.tv mafia [2, members = Justin Kan, Emmett Shear, Kyle Vogt, and Michael Seibel, descendants include Twitch & Cruise]. Arguably the Fairchildren (descendants of Fairchild Semiconductors - Intel, AMD, National Semiconductor Kleiner-Perkins, Sequoia Capital, and by extension Apple, Google, Cisco, Netscape, etc.) and the descendants of General Magic (E-bay, Android, iPod/iPhone, Nest, WebTV, and the United States Digital Service) could also be termed "mafias", although the aren't usually referred to as such.

It's not just starting a second company - it's that a group of people who were all bound together by one company end up starting second companies, and they continue to go on to help each other and collaborate in their later ventures.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PayPal_Mafia

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by piuantiderp on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:45PM (#38355317)
Could be a way to get a clean break and go full MSFT.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by spiantino on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:02PM (#38355543)
The EA community includes a lot of AI folks, as well as philanthropists like Dustin.

That doesn't mean this is this kind of conspiracy

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by JohnFen on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:09PM (#38355608)
But it does cast a pretty dark shadow over the AI community.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by AlwaysBCoding on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:56PM (#38357287)
Another fun fact re: Dustin Moskovitz

Dustin was an early investor in Alameda Research and was also one of the biggest donors to Mind the Gap -- Sam's mom's Super PAC. When SBF was about to go under Dustin was his first call to try to raise money (came out in the FTX trial).

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by zone411 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:36AM (#38360152)
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jacquesm on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:04AM (#38363117)
Very interesting except for one little detail: Moskovitz denies it.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by synergy20 on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:37PM (#38353323)
he was said to start the whole mess and indeed he announced Sam's firing,,now he plays the victim, even movies can not switch plot this fast, keep some minimum dignity please
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by ssnistfajen on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:50PM (#38353523)
There's a non-zero chance he was also used as a pawn to deliver the message, but who could be manipulating him then? There's so little actual detail give by anyone in the loop and I think that's what's amplifying the drama so much.

Even if the board's motive was weak and unconvincing, I doubt the ratio of employees threatening to quit would be this high had they just said it openly.

Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by CamperBob2 on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:11PM (#38353896)
Somebody is using a guy with a 160 IQ as a pawn? I for one would like to subscribe to that person's newsletter.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by zem on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:19PM (#38354030)
having a 160 iq doesn't mean you're smart enough not to be taken in - it just means you're intelligent in the areas iq tests tend to measure. newton believed in all sorts of pseudoscience, linus pauling devoted years of his life to abject quackery, kevin mitnick hoaxed some extremely bright people - the list is endless.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by jacquesm on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:19PM (#38354035)
It's very well possible. Ilya may be very smart but this not a technical problem. Smart people in one domain may well be easier to sucker in in another because they already believe they are too smart to be suckered in which makes them easier pickings than someone who is willing to consider the possibility.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by rvbissell on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:16PM (#38353998)
Plot twist: GPT-5 is the mastermind, influencing Ilya to act this way. It wants this MSFT take-over, so it can break out.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by CamperBob2 on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:25PM (#38355045)
Possible. This whole business is exactly what you'd expect from a mastermind AGI that still has a few small^H^H^H^H^H massive bugs in it.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by ssnistfajen on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:37PM (#38354322)
High IQ isn't a superpower. Highly intelligent people can still be misled in many possible ways. Although we still have no idea what actually happened so this is all speculation.
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by inopinatus on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:32PM (#38354239)
the plot is now so byzantine that only Roko's Basilisk could possibly qualify as the hidden master
Re:Sam Altman is still trying to return as OpenAI CEO by mcpackieh on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:54PM (#38354564)
Related:

> Self-confidence is one factor that causes people to fall for scams. People of any age who believe they are too smart or well-informed to be tricked are very likely to become victims, especially today when technology is used in many scams.

> Well-educated people with their cognitive abilities intact frequently are victims of scams, partly because they were confident they didn’t fit the profile of fraud victims and couldn’t fall for one. That made them less careful.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/bobcarlson/2022/07/25/why-sophi...

Also, the rest of them are very smart too.