For example, you use Linux, and can't understand why anyone would use Windows. Or you're a work-from-home fan and can't understand why some people want to work in an office, or why management might need it.
Or, as in thus case, if you work primarily for money the idea of a job that pays in something other than money seems exploiting.
Whereas, of course, there are lots of people who have enough money to meet their needs, and are instead looking for something else. Solitude, Community, Experience and so on.
I don't say this to be disrespectful at all, but part of maturing is in understanding that others can have a different point of view of things. We don't all have to be the same, with the same goals.
These are unpaid positions, with specific requirements and benefits. Clearly they don't sppareal to you and thats fine, but perhaps, just perhaps, there's someone out there this is perfect for.
There are so many things I complain about in the US but our national parks and the services that make them accessible are not one of them.
I truly believe capital E everyone benefits from spending time in nature, and want to find ways to support this however I can. I really appreciate the feelings I get after extended periods of time in the woods/mountains.
I like that and think it fits here.
Some people can't imagine picking up litter or caring for the elderly as anything but torture and humiliation. For others, the chance to do it, to feel valued is what makes life. Context might be that you became unemployed and just got sick of seeing garbage in your street.
During the pandemic cabin fever drove me out to do volunteering at the church and vaccine drop-ins.
I volunteered a lot in my 20s. Homeless patrols handing out blankets etc. The typical "Kibbutznik" doesn't go to dig soil expecting it to be a picnic, but to satisfy a bunch of other drives. At a certain age you have a ton of energy, a desire to meet people, and the world you know seems too small.
Of course that's always a good recruitment chance for armies, but I was taken with William James' "Moral equivalent of war", at least the abstract ideas and insightful social psychology. There are thousands of environmental and rebuilding projects that need doing - but won't get done - because it falls outside the realm of "capital".
The problem is when profitable interests and corporate workflows intersect with altruistic labour supply. It's obvious the most cynical sort of exploitation is afoot. Many large organised charities suffer from being poisoned that way, I've heard.
I guess before volunteering for an org these days one should do a lot of diligence, check out who runs things, who they're associated with, and whose ethics are behind whet you see on face value.
For what it’s worth: if I were at a time in my life where I could do the linked opportunity, I absolutely would. Even better would be an Antarctica opportunity for a winter season.
A particular volunteer opportunity may not be interesting to you, because of the time commitment and the opportunity cost of sacrificing paid work, or because you aren't interested in the particular area of volunteer work, or because you just aren't interested in donating labor in general, but... so what? The posting of the volunteer opportunity isn't a personal solicitation aimed at you, either.
There are some things that are too much work for anyone to call it merely volunteering, and should be compensated. I don't care if you find that opinion acceptable.
Bills don't stop existing because I choose to eat a watch a sunset, either, but I don't ask if watching a sunset is going to pay my bills. People obviously need a way to pay their bills, and lots of activities they might engage in aren't part of that. If you aren't in a position where you can do an activity because of what you need to do to pay your bills, than that activity clearly isn't for you, but unless you were personally and specifically solicited for that activity by someone who should have been aware of your personal circumstances, I don't see how that warrants anything besides "well, that's not for me".
Your circumstances aren't universal.
Take your socioeconomic bigotry and shove it up your priveleged ass.
What I will not do is be exploited for free labor by the USGS who can absolutely afford to pay someone to do the contract work they are asking for. But by all means, if you want to, go for it.
Some people wouldn't want to spend their weekends working at a homeless shelter unless they were paid for it, but would happily spend time in a national park without being paid for it, and don't see it as being "exploited". You have different values/interests, and that's fine, but I don't know why you're trying so hard to be condescending to people that just have different interests than you do.
They described a high of 4°c as "mild". Fuck that.
But that isn't my point: people do all sorts of things to volunteer for others/organisations. Just because you wouldn't do it unpaid doesn't mean it isn't volunteering.
"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."
IF and how much any given person is willing and, given their other circumstances, able to donate is, obviously, highly variable between people.
A person living paycheck-to-paycheck may view the Antarctica opportunity as pompous, but environmental-club peers may view it as volunteering to save the planet and deserves a round of cheers with drinks in hand.
It's near certain that every person on HN is in the top 20% of intelligence in the world, and probably in the top 20% in their country. Are our actions and achievements less meaningful because we are lucky enough to be smart?
If someone has the ability to donate months of their life volunteering, I see no reason to diminish or demean their actions simply because I or other people couldn't do it.
> Housing is included
> room in a shared apartment or house.
You're out of your mind. Homes should be a standard. That's like, one of the basic human wants/needs as an organism. And having the privacy of your own space is essential to the human psyche.
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/volunteering-and-claiming-benefi...
In some particularly stingy places this is as little as the equivalent of 80 pounds per week whereas rent is oft closer to 800 pounds per month.
In many cases its something you receive later after weeks or months of bureaucratic wrangling after you would long ago have lost your housing if you didn't have any of your own money saved.
Hell we make sure you can't exploit the system by getting food stamps or housing help while going to college even if you are poor as a church mouse.
Heck we set the benefits threshold low enough that as you move from part time employment to full time employment the poorest households experience a hump where if you move to full time you may end up poorer than you started because you lose more benefits than you gain income. This is especially true if you go from free medical care to $500-$800 out of pocket.
Because most professions don't involve doubling your wages regularly one has to in effect agree to take on more work to climb into greater poverty in order to work your way out the other side IF increasing costs ever let you get ahead in the first place.
One of the most attractive ways OUT of permanent poverty is naturally a college education however this will almost certainly be by way of borrowing tens of thousands of dollars but since you don't qualify for benefits during your education and you need to keep eating and living inside you are liable to need to continue to work full time which creates a much higher chance of failure which stands to leave you without a degree with thousands of dollars of undischargable debt.
This concludes our tour of one of the shitty parts of America.
Its not implicit, "volunteer" is the word for a non-coerced unpaid laborer.
Most of the old folks retiring at 70 aren't doing any of these labor intensive affairs so its mostly a task for the idle children of the upper middle class to rich. Are we feting people for being born on third base again?
Look at this[1] particular ask:
> Applicants must be available to work a minimum of 32 hours per week.
> [minimum 3 month commitment with possibility to extend to a year] ... Weekend and holiday work is required.
> shovel snow for extended periods of time, hike-ski-snowshoe in extreme weather conditions with a 35-pound backpack at 7,000ft, live in remote locations with regularly snow packed roads.
> Groceries and shopping facilities are approximately 60 miles away; reliable personal transportation is required.
[1] https://www.volunteer.gov/s/volunteer-opportunity/a093d00000...