It took very minimal effort on our part, and was very rewarding for him; certainly a lot better than him crying with the hope that we could guess what he wanted. Definitely recommended for any new parents.
The best moment was when he was sitting on the floor, and looked up at his mom and made the "together" sign, it was heart melting.
I have friends who had much more success with it, but the value will largely depend on your child’s relative developmental strengths. A friend’s son with autism got literally years’ benefit out of the gestures before verbal speech caught up.
Please don't blame this on the signs! This doesn't mean that he would have learned to speak earlier if not for the signs. I'd be glad that he could communicate proficiently at all.
Could still useful: instead of shouting across the playground on whether they have to go potty you can simply make the gesture with minimal embarrassment. :)
were you always talking when you signed to them? maybe they thought it went together.
I can't remember exact ages and timeframes-- that time of my life is "blurry". I wish I could remember all the gestures we used. (The only ones I can remember now are "milk", "apple", and "thank you".) As she became verbal she quickly transitioned away from them.
I wish I'd learnt sign language before having kids so I just already knew how to do it, it's so cool. Props to the Ms. Rachel videos for including so many signs.
At about the same age, I bought my son a mango lassi. He looked suspiciously at it, but took a sip. With a look of shocked delight he tilted it back, back, back, and emptied the cup!
Then he put it down, looked at me, and said, "Want more!"
I'm looking forward to kids out of the house. But there are some moments that I treasure.
It probably doesn't matter either way for babies, but fyi ASL isn't a sign version of English; it is its own language. In fact American Sign Language is more closely related to French Sign Language than to British Sign Language. The Australian and New Zealand Sign Languages are largely derived from British Sign Language, so there isn't really a correlation between English speaking regions and ASL. Canadians mostly use American Sign Language and French Canadian Sign Language.
Almost 20 years later, I still know all the signs for baby food ;)
For example, voluntary supination/pronation of the forearm is generally not something a 9month old can do. If you try and teach them a common sign for "enough/finished" (fist closed, thumb pointed out, then rotation of the forearm back and forth), or "done" and "more" in the parent link, they probably won't be able to do it properly. They can copy something close to that (thumb out and wobbling their hand around? good enough!) so you have to go with the flow.
There are quite a few signs like that actually, so try and think about how many muscles move together, and how controlled or complex that is. Simple stuff is good -- and doable.
One of my favourite memories of that was when we went to see the Vivid light show in Sydney and there was a contortionist on the street so we stopped to watch. I looked into the stroller and said "What do you think?" and she made the sign for "finished". So we moved on.
This is interesting. My son also did "index finger up" in response to "thumbs up" for the longest time. Why is the thumb so hard to manipulate? Late addition to the evolutionary sequence?
You can teach chatgpt too as well. It's like a toddler. A very articulate toddler:
https://chat.openai.com/share/40c94561-2505-4938-8331-7d10ae...
It makes mistakes as any human baby would. And as a parent you can correct it.
All this means is that learning an arbitrary sign language isn't a differentiator.
My favourite moment was in March, my daughter was about to turn 2 and wasn't speaking yet.
I asked her if she would like to hear some music.
She made the sign for dog.
I searched youtube for some songs about dogs and she shook her head.
She made the sign for tree.
I was like "dog, tree", she nodded. Hmmm...
I was searching for "dog tree music" when one of the pictures that came up was a christmas tree.
She pointed to that excitedly!
I was like "dog christmas tree music" ... it took me a second to realise that she wanted to listen to the Charlie Brown Christmas soundtrack that I had had playing off YouTube at Christmas 3 months previously!
I put that on again and we danced around to it.
I thought that was totally wild! It was the first time I remember her communicating a really sophisticated preference other than just wanting to eat/drink/help etc.
Settlers interacting with natives knew full well how complex their desires were – they lived side-by-side, traded, socialised, and learned from each other.[1] Any suggestion of a primitive native is self-comforting propaganda from the industrial complex that comes after the settlers.
[1]: Indians, Settlers, and Slaves in a Frontier Exchange Economy; Usner; Omohundro Institute; 2014.
ML is pretty long way from being able to make generalizations like that from…20 samples?
But I can never seem to find more information about it, and can't recall the documentary name for the life of me. Since you seem to have at least some familiarity with this, do you happen to know what I'm talking about?
-She learned some gestures of mine instead, which I didn't realize I was doing.
-Defaulted to speech as soon as possible because it was just easier.
I think it makes a big difference, both for us (parents, to have a clue what they want) and the kid (being understood, when they can’t speak).
Perhaps worth noting that it is possible to teach infants (often starting at around 9 months) sign language so that they can more easily signal their desires.
Some priority recommended words would probably be:
* hungry/more
* enough/all done (for when they're full)
* drink (perhaps both milk/formula and water† gestures)
See:
* https://babysignlanguage.com/chart/
* https://www.thebump.com/a/how-to-teach-baby-sign-language
These are not (AFAICT) 'special' symbols for babies, but the regular ASL gestures for the work in question. If you're not native English-speaking you'd look up the gestures in your specific region/language's sign language:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sign_languages
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sign_language
† Another handy trick I've run across: have different coloured containers for milk and water, and consistently put the same contents in each one. That way the infant learns to grab a particular colour depending on what they're feeling like.