News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:59AM (#37688334)
I start to dislike Chomsky more and more. His work in linguistic is over my head, maybe it's true, I can't tell.

But whenever I hear him speak outside his niche his points are stupid (like this one) or harmful (like his Ukrainian takes).

Everybody sees faces in rocks because we have brains fine-tuned for seeing faces. Does it prove that there's something universal in looking like a face or even worse - being a face? Some objective "faceiness"?

Or just that we have overfitted neural networks in our heads?

You can get hit in a particular way and stop recognizing faces. Or morality.

What Chomsky is saying is that if you include only the people who are "healthy" according to some subjective criteria and take a crossection of their moralities - the result isn't an empty set. Well duh.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by irrational on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:16AM (#37688503)
I have a bachelors in Linguistics. We were taught what Chomsky believes, but our professor also made it clear that many linguists, including himself, didn’t believe it was right or true. Though, this was 30 years ago. I haven’t kept up with the field to know what professors of linguistics think today.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mcv on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:42AM (#37688806)
I think his importance to linguistics is not so much due to being he's correct, but due to moving forward the way the field thinks about language and grammar.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by olalonde on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:41AM (#37688791)
His editorial on ChatGPT definitely read like "sour grapes"[0].

[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/08/opinion/noam-chomsky-chat...

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mcv on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:44AM (#37688830)
ChatGPT does feel a bit like a refutation of his life's work.

Because whether or not ChatGPT can think, it certainly has a good command of language without starting out with an inborn sense of grammar. It learns grammar by copying. Just like kids do, I suspect.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by coldtea on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:01AM (#37689030)
>without starting out with an inborn sense of grammar

I'm not so sure though, because it starts by being fed sentences assembled by people.

Sort of how we wouldn't say that a book itself has a "good command of language", but that the writer has one, and put it in the book.

So you might need a seed with "an inborn sense of grammar" to create language first and a training corpus second, but once that's available in huge volumes you can mechanically train an LLM to appear to have a "good command of language" just by brute force.

Would an LLM gain a "good command of language" if it was just fed all the taling a human hears and the words it reads in its first 18 years of life?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:05AM (#37689068)
> Would an LLM gain a "good command of language" if it was just fed all the taling a human hears and the words it reads in its first 18 years of life?

Depends on what its starting weights are ;)

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by BobbyJo on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:07AM (#37689802)
Aaaaaaand we're back to inborn sense.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by theodorethomas on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:57AM (#37688997)
I suspect not. Children are exposed to far less text than LLMs. LLMs are parlour tricks that teach us nothing about how humans do it.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by benpacker on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:14AM (#37689894)
Kids learn grammar by copying, but a group of kids with no language will invent one (see Nicaraguan sign language), and empty transformer models will not do this.

Kids raised hearing a mix of French and African languages will also invent a new language (Haitian creole) and a LLM will not do this, it would alternate speaking one or the other.

ChatGPT proves that language is not so complex that it can’t be modeled, but the core Chomsky arguments are unaffected.

I haven’t looked into the alternative perspectives (emergent grammar, etc) in the discipline since undergrad so I’m not saying Chomsky is right, just saying LLMs don’t disprove it.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mcv on Friday September 29, 2023 @05:45AM (#37701349)
> empty transformer models will not do this.

Do we have evidence for that? Of course those kids did have a real world to communicate about, and that creates the need for a language. I think if you had AI models that had a world to interact with and other models to communicate with and learn from, they might be able to develop their own language too.

But this does get to another of Chomsky's points: the need to have a world model. To current LLMs, the only world model they have is text they read on the internet. And they only communicate with us, and I don't think they learn from their communication with us. So that's unavoidably limiting them. But I think it would be a very interesting experiment to give them a world to interact with and other similar models to communicate with, to see if they develop some sort of language (which would be completely incomprehensible to us of course; that's another hurdle).

I agree that LLMs don't disprove his inborn grammar argument, but they don't support it either. I think more research is needed.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dllthomas on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:06PM (#37694149)
I suppose I can grant "feels a bit like", but unless I'm missing something (and to be fair I have not rtfa...) it hasn't actually reached refutation. The observation that there is enough information to determine grammar rules in the training set for an LLM is only very weak evidence that there is also enough information in the much smaller training set for a typical human.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mcv on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:42AM (#37704113)
I think it's pretty obvious that there is more than enough information in the training set of a typical human to learn grammar. Because we do. And people in different countries learn different grammars.

Also keep in mind that people get more feedback over their control of language ad grammar while they're learning. We don't just listen, we communicate.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dllthomas on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:05PM (#37706237)
That's the point, though. As you say there is obviously enough information to learn grammar given our starting point, but Chomsky's point is that there's not enough information to distinguish between all possible languages, so (paraphrasing from a decades-old recollection and probably very much putting my spin on it) learning a (first?) language as a human is probably a matter of figuring out how to apply existing "machinery" that imposes some of its own structure rather than operating entirely from the information provided to the senses.

I'm not saying it's necessarily correct, but it does seem well formed, and LLMs only undermine it in a very weak sense (so far?). To defend the conclusion itself I would have to know a whole lot more about how he estimated information content (needed and available).

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by 4gotunameagain on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:37AM (#37688756)
The concept of an innate, universal language that Chomsky came up with is almost certainly true, now whether that universal language contains information regarding what we call ethics, that is an open question
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:53AM (#37688956)
> The concept of an innate, universal language that Chomsky came up with is almost certainly true

It's important to clarify that Chomsky's argument about universal grammar, in that there is an innate universal base human language, is not remotely certainly true. The existence of a human capacity or ability for language is true, but that's not a really amazing finding. People have been talking about that for hundreds of years. There's very little actual evidential basis in neuroscience or brain research for Chomsky's claim. It also frequently falls into private language fallacies, which is a logical blackhole he can't really climb out of.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by twoodfin on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:13AM (#37688466)
What Chomsky is arguing is that, yes, in an important objective sense there is such a thing as “faciness” that our brains recognize. In the same way, I hope we’d all agree there’s objectively a color red—even accepting that it’s the structure of our optical and neural systems that are the basis for this fact.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:20AM (#37688554)
The only definition is "most people recognize it" and there are people who disagree about it or don't recognize it at all.

How does it differ from something that exists subjectively then?

I'd say arguing that colors are like morality is pro-relativism stance.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by roenxi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:22AM (#37688576)
> I hope we’d all agree there’s objectively a color red

We don't. For starters there are colourblind people, for seconds there is no specific colour that can be called "red". There is a large and fuzzy category of red-ish colours like blood-red or rose-red.

Even if there is some academic "these light wavelengths are the ones" definition of red that is arbitrary. Aliens might have drawn the lines elsewhere.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by twoodfin on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:33AM (#37688704)
This is exactly Chomsky’s point. Try to get through life considering the color of the traffic light you’re approaching as a subjective rather than objective fact.

To pick an example closer to the morality case: Hunger could equally be called a subjective phenomenon. Aliens may not experience anything like hunger. A rare genetic condition might produce a human who experiences escalating hunger as an escalating degree of pleasure.

But as humans making our way through the real world, we are forced by physical and anatomical reality to see the causes and consequences of human hunger as objective truths.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by roenxi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:41AM (#37688798)
> ... Try to get through life considering the color of the traffic light you’re approaching as a subjective rather than objective fact. ...

You didn't consider what I wrote - colourblind people get through life without considering the colour of traffic lights at all. They have to. They are colour blind. The colour of a traffic light as a practical matter is a subjective fact. In fact, the practical colour of a traffic light is more subjective than the philosophical take because at least philosophers can be convinced with a wavelength argument.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:57AM (#37688994)
Hunger is subjective. Starvation isn't.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:36AM (#37689409)
Hunger is pretty objective if your body isn't malfunctioning (and it never is logically). If your body works correctly, you are not free to choose whether to consider yourself hungry, and this is what I understand as objectivity.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:07PM (#37693340)
What I consider hunger someone else can consider the norm or vice versa. If you define something that depends on the person as objective - then subjective loses meaning.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:15PM (#37695986)
I improved my definition of feelings so that they can easily be objective.

I define hunger as the ideal signal that corresponds exactly to the extent of starvation. 'Ideal signal' is almost like sensation or feeling, except it may not be always or in full precision accessible by consciousness. It is a physical signal, or a function from the physical state. Extent of starvation seems objective (after fixing its definition), and so hunger seems objective too (correspondence is exact). By this definition, if you are starved, but don't notice a feeling of hunger, it's that, you still are hungry, just don't notice it.

> What I consider hunger someone else can consider the norm or vice versa.

How can that be? Do you mean definition, or something else? What do you consider hunger?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:46PM (#37698732)
> I define hunger as the ideal signal that corresponds exactly to the extent of starvation.

If you redefine words how you please you can prove anything. What's the point tho?

> What do you consider hunger?

The feeling I sometimes get that I should eat something. It's VERY subjective (for example when I'm fasting I can go a few days without it, but when I'm not - I get it just cause I'm bored and haven't eaten a breakfast).

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by knewter on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:33AM (#37688708)
We universally agree that it is at least "the wavelength produced from a well-calibrated display when asked to render #ff0000'
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by roenxi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:42AM (#37688815)
I mean, ok. But that isn't objective. That is a subjective judgement of the display calibration standards body, with no reference to what most people think "red" means.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by knewter on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:06PM (#37710659)
At least they can reliably compare society's idea of red to their own but I'm pretty sure people's ability to think of red as things outside the rgb gamut is likely diminishing over time.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:28AM (#37689322)
If you insist on a definition in terms of physics, there may be a universal standard way of interpolating all distributed ideas of red into a main definition, even if extremely high-tech.

Otherwise, this question comes down to whether the meaning of the term 'red' is generated objectively or subjectively, which is related to philosophy of language and mind. See article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity_and_the_... .

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dsego on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:18AM (#37688531)
Does that relate to Plato's world of ideas?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by botanical57 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:45AM (#37688841)
To his doctrine of the Forms, yes I think it does. He seemed to think that when humans gain knowledge, they do not generate it, but rather discover it. For knowledge to be discovered, it must have already existed - in the abstract, non-material world of the Forms. Plato had an involved epistemological argument for why the human process of gaining incrementally less partial knowledge of a subject fundamentally must be a process of discovery - but I would fail to do it justice.

Chomsky seems to imply that in a moral context, similarly, as humans learn abstract concepts and boundaries from sparse data, we are also carrying out a process of discovery. He seems to skip over the epistemological reasoning.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ducharmdev on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:44AM (#37688832)
It's odd to me that you chose color as an example of something objective, since so much about perception is subjective.

Even if we think about it in more quantitative terms, with red being defined as having a dominant wavelength approximately 625–740 nanometres, it's a bit of an arbitrary definition isn't it? If we observe a wavelength of 624, objectively we might say it's not red, but someone may still observe it as red considering how close it is to red. Or someone with protanopia won't see anything in those bounds as red either.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:02AM (#37689042)
Color relies on ostensive definition. It's a public part of language whether someone is color-blind or not. When we say "that car is red" we are, in a sense, pointing to something and then using the concept and rules of color in our language. We might see something as a particular color through perception, but when we see "that --->" we are, in a sense, "seeing" in language (including body language, for instance. You could ask me which one is red and I could simply point).

We, of course, might disagree, but color-blind people learn which traffic lights are red, green, or yellow, regardless of their perceptual faculties. Because the color is not just what you see, but what you say.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:40AM (#37689458)
[delayed]
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by js8 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:32AM (#37688697)
The problem with ethics is that if you take almost any two different moral rules, there are always moral dilemmas where it is, for a large minority, unacceptable that we apply one rule over the other. So the moral rules of society as a whole form a logically inconsistent system, which appears to be only consistent within certain boundaries.

Since it is inconsistent system, every moral position can be logically invalidated. Therefore, the sensible positions, compromises, are also the least rationally defensible.

Now, Chomsky has a humanitarian angle, according to which no harm to other people is justifiable to make the world better. This means he rejects notion of justified war (which is anonymous killing of humans). And from this comes his position on Ukraine.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by elondaits on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:13AM (#37688471)
Chomsky is one of the most internationally-known intellectuals. Most people in my country (Argentina) know him for that, rather than his work in linguistics.

... So I think it's very unfair to say he's speaking "outside of his niche" here.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by actionfromafar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:17AM (#37688518)
I guess one could phrase it like this - his work in linguistics was important and somewhat falsifiable. The rest, not so much.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mcv on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:48AM (#37688893)
Is anything in philosophy or politics falsifiable? If politics is not his field, then whose field is it? Are only polsci majors allowed to discuss politics?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:58AM (#37690495)
"Peace for our time" by Chamberline and Germany's dependence on Russia are as falsified as you can be in politics. Chomsky would probably support both :)
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mcv on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:37AM (#37700912)
Fair point, and definitely a valid refutation of his position on Russia-Ukraine.

My point should have been that everybody is entitled to their opinion on politics and philosophy, but you do have to take facts into account when available. They're not always available, and it's not always obvious how relevant they are to a new situation, but you obvious shouldn't ignore facts completely, and that does happen way too often. In every corner of the political spectrum.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by psychoslave on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:50AM (#37688919)
Is Karl Popper's theory on falsifiability as a scientific criterion itself falsifiable?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cracrecry on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:42AM (#37688811)
I don't believe that. I have traveled the world and very few people I know know about Chomsky.

I know a lot about Chomsky as someone who has studied parsers and natural languages a lot and I usually ask people I talk with if they know Chomsky so I can explain something I do.

People in Argentina knows Chomsky because he has always been Communist and an apologist of marxist dictatorships and regimes while a harsh critic of the West values and institutions.

Argentina has been a Marxist loving country for a long time. I was born in Spain and lived in Mendoza for some time. Argentinians also love to feel victims about everything that happens to them so they don't have responsibility on it so Chomsky message is powerful there.

I am not criticising Argentina, but describing it.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by Gud on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:00PM (#37693249)
Chomsky is not a communist, he's a syndicalist. His views are more nuanced than you give him credit for.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by asah on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:36AM (#37688742)
+1 - I got off the Chomsky bandwagon decades ago.

Language is a loose encoding of thought, nothing more or less. Want proof? Spend some time with ChatGPT4.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by stavros on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:52AM (#37688939)
I don't entirely agreed, as there have been cases where my thought has changed because I learned a new word for something. I started to see that thing everywhere, where before I wouldn't notice it as much, just because I learned the word for it.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by asah on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:29PM (#37712570)
interesting point - but was it the word? or the concept?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by stavros on Saturday September 30, 2023 @03:53AM (#37713483)
Are the two different? What is a concept without a word?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by asah on Monday October 02, 2023 @02:59PM (#37742789)
multiple words! :-)

I'm arguing that it's an obvious optimization to assign short tokens to commonly used concepts.

I'm arguing that many people had the thought before society agreed on a given token for that thought.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:29AM (#37688663)
Well, at least it reduces the problem to the criterium of "health". At least you can individually decide it and use it to accept or reject relativism, treating it as a subjective belief itself :)

Hence, why debate relativism at all?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by maeln on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:16AM (#37688507)
> But whenever I hear him speak outside his niche his points are stupid (like this one) or harmful (like his Ukrainian takes).

Chomsky was always like this. He is an unapologetic hypocrite, constantly criticizing the U.S and "the west" while defending "socialist" country for the exact thing, and often even worse, than he was criticizing the U.S for. Even going as far as denying the existence of genocide during the Yugoslavia civil-war.

Manufacturing Consent was a very good book, but for me it won't change the fact that Chomsky is a genocide-denier tankie.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by Spooky23 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:40AM (#37688776)
[delayed]
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by maeln on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:53AM (#37688959)
> It’s good to critique the US or the west - you cannot improve without dissent. Fortunately, Chomsky is in the US and enjoys unimpeded speech and academic freedom.

That I can fully agree with. My issue is that he often criticizing the U.S while downplaying the other side violence.

Saying something like "France should not have had a military intervention in Lybia" is fine. But saying this and then adding "and Gaddafi repression of the Arab Spring was exaggerated by the media" is when I know what you really wanted to say.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by boppinz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:23AM (#37690027)
I think this is hardly the genocide-denial you think it is. In the Gaddafi case, I doubt he really sides with a military dictator.

His critique has always been how the West intervenes, but mainly for economic security and superiority. We don't give much of a rat's-ass about installing a fair democracy, if that's even what these countries want, so much as installing someone who agrees with us (see: Reagan in South America)

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by pauldenton on Friday September 29, 2023 @03:55AM (#37700596)
Yeah. Not like Snowden or all those other provocateurs forced into exile.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by imjonse on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:27AM (#37688636)
Can you cite him exactly on any of your points or are you paraphrasing what you have heard second hand?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by maeln on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:43AM (#37688821)
You could just go to his wikipedia article.

Anyway, he tried to downplay the genocide and the violence committed by the Khmer Rouge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Chom...

He, in the same fashion, downplayed the bosnian genocide: https://www.dw.com/en/dissident-intellectual-noam-chomsky-at... https://books.google.fr/books?id=7Bl9KT9NME0C&pg=PA142&redir...

And said that the Russian was acting "with restrain and moderation" in Ukraine: https://archive.is/EJp7e

That is how he operate. Whenever there is a conflict involving the U.S, even remotely, he is systematically downplaying the opponent violence and insisting that everyone focus on the U.S and ally violence. This way he can always look like the reasonable man, while basically defending massacre and dictator. How can he do this when criticizing (rightfully so), the U.S for the Vietnam War or the Contra, and not see the hypocrisy, is beside me.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by 6stringronin on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:31AM (#37689350)
He tried to make sense of numbers, as a point that it serves the US geopolitical goals at the time to have a distraction from their own atrocities.

"We do not pretend to know where the truth lies amidst these sharply conflicting assessments; rather, we again want to emphasize some crucial points. What filters through to the American public is a seriously distorted version of the evidence available, emphasizing alleged Khmer Rouge atrocities and downplaying or ignoring the crucial U.S. role, direct and indirect, in the torment that Cambodia has suffered."

Calling it downplaying genocide is a nice strawman. In any developing situation the media wants to jump yo a conclusion, that's his point overall.

He wasn't denying or downplaying just stating, if its happening how can we know to what degree when we have unreliable sources?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by LindeBuzoGray on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:58AM (#37689689)
> he tried to downplay the genocide and the violence committed by the Khmer Rouge

The US carpet bombed Cambodia just like it did Vietnam, and Chomsky condemned this.

This nebulous "Khmer Rouge" you refer to was armed by the US starting in 1979 and even more so in subsequent years. The US worked to put them back in power and put economic, military and diplomatic support behind it. As reported in the New York Times, ABC News at the time. Chomsky was against this.

The US establishment was anti-Khmer Touge until 1979, then began arming and supporting them in 1979. By the late 1990s they began going out of favor in the US establishment. Chomsky's opinion hasn't changed, he was against the US bombing Cambodia during the Vietnam War.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dgb23 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:21AM (#37688564)
You seem to mix things up?

He has been very critical of "socialist" countries, especially towards their underlying political ideology.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dhoe on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:33AM (#37688717)
Happy to learn otherwise, but everything I've seen follows the pattern of briefly paying lip service to the fact that some enemy of the US is not perfectly innocent, but well we're all human, and here's five pages on how the US is the worst.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by miracle2k on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:41AM (#37688793)
“My own concern is primarily the terror and violence carried out by my own state, for two reasons. For one thing, because it happens to be the larger component of international violence. But also for a much more important reason than that: namely, I can do something about it. So even if the US was responsible for 2% of the violence in the world instead of the majority of it, it would be that 2% I would be primarily responsible for. And that is a simple ethical judgment. That is, the ethical value of one’s actions depends on their anticipated and predictable consequences. It is very easy to denounce the atrocities of someone else. That has about as much ethical value as denouncing atrocities that took place in the 18th century.”

https://www.antiwar.com/blog/2014/04/01/why-criticize-your-o...

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by zdragnar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:01AM (#37689035)
Calling for introspection is all well and good, but there's nothing ethical about actively denying the reality of what is happening abroad.

In the end, it is just an attempt to shore up weak arguments with weaker falsehoods.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by calf on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:06AM (#37689081)
That's interesting, I'm a millenial aged leftist so I don't have the political baggage from the 70s-90s that older people have on Chomsky.

And so I find in a globalized, hegemonic world, Chomsky's first reason is just as important if not more so than the second: Seeing what the larger component is is crucial, as a prerequisite to doing something about it.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by maeln on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:45AM (#37688837)
Yes, fair enough, it is more that he systematically downplayed the violence of the "red" side whenever there was a conflict with the U.S. Like how he basically tried to deny the Cambodian and Bosnian genocide.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by anewhnaccount2 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:23AM (#37688586)
Since people keep saying he's a genocide denier, I'll drop this link here https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/gsp/vol14/iss1/8/ which explains that it's more a matter of semantics. He hasn't denied mass murders have taken place. He would probably also object to using either "terrorist" or "freedom fighter" since using these words emotively serves to obscure what's really going on.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:09PM (#37693366)
He argued against stopping it. I don't care how he calls it.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cscurmudgeon on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:23AM (#37688590)
Two for one here: calling him stupid and a straw man.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:14AM (#37688485)
Yeah I have to say he's always seemed like he made up his mind about the world by the 60s and hasn't really adjusted since. His Ukraine takes are right in line with his awful takes on the Cambodian genocide, which he still claims didn't happen.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by imjonse on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:30AM (#37688667)
which he *never* claimed didn't happen. You are another of those quickly educated on PragerU and similar Youtube channels but who never go to original sources?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:35AM (#37688731)
No he definitely made the claim.

He was quoted saying “tales of holocaust in Cambodia were so much propaganda.”

He went on to say that refugees were making up the stories to please the west. It’s in the 1977 article on his own website.

Chomsky apologists never seem to be able to admit that he carried water for the worst regimes of the 20th century.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by imjonse on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:12PM (#37693415)
Due to little info coming out of Cambodia at the time, from what I read, Chomsky said he underestimated the immensity of the genocide, not that he denied it. Later he acknowledged it, you make it sound he's some sort of Holocaust denier. Funnily Chomsky gets a lot more flack for incorrectly assessing the gravity of the Khmer Rouge killings in the late 70s while the US foreign policy which was intstumental in keeping Pol Pot in power at certain points where it was convenient geostrategically are considered par for the course.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:22PM (#37693546)
This is bullshit. He unequivocally said that the refugees were lying for the benefit of the US. Chomsky is always quick to shout that anything short of the literal Holocaust isn’t genocide and doubly so if a leftist regime is doing it. He was then and always has since minimized crimes against humanity in one direction.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by imjonse on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:10PM (#37694201)
"Always minimized crimes against humanity in one direction". You haven't read much Chomsky have you? The one key point that comes across from his thinking is how much we (westerners) minimize our crimes even when they are comparable or larger then the enemy. His whole manufacturing consent book is about such examples.

And that if you criticize someone it better be your own side, where you at least have a slight chance of changing something even if democracy is a thin veneer over something shady, rather than bravely criticising totalitary regimes where your chance of having an impact is really negligible. Just like if you have kids you'd better make sure you correct their faults instead of gossiping about the neighbours' kid's mischiefs.

Chomsky and his cohort was criticizing the Vietnam war at a time it was very unpopular to do so at home, today you get western people criticizing Putin and Xi as if this was some act of bravery and not the pointless navel grazing that it is in fact.

Until the West has a shitty foreign policy, and increasingly shitty domestic one as well (see surveillance, making terrorists of activists or journalists) totalitarian regimes can use this a valid excuse to shake off any criticism on their part.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:39PM (#37694673)
I've read quite a bit of Chmosky's commentary, that how I knew to reference the old article from his own site.

It's perfectly valid to criticize US foreign policy and double so as a citizen. But Chomsky is jut full of shit and a liar. In Invasion Newspeak[1] he claims there was never any American Danchev with respect to Vietnam. Early coverage was actually critical[2], and after the Tet offensive it really went south. Chomsky just totally ignores this, it's inconvenient to his narrative. Moreover, you don't need to call refugees liars to criticize the US. You don't need to "well actually" what happened in Bosnia. Chomsky is a liar and piece of shit.

[1]https://chomsky.info/198912__/

[2] https://web.archive.org/web/20091211102035/https://www.museu...

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:34AM (#37688725)
Chomsky is a mixed bag, on multiple fronts. He's very strident, and especially many his recent takes on geopolitical issues are unable to understand the new polarities at work in the world. He's been an important critic of American foreign policy, but it has blinded him (and his followers) to the absolutely more terrible nature of e.g. Russian hegemony. (I actually think this turn began for him around the conflict in Serbia.)

But I find him a useful and important antidote to the dominance of total relativism postmodernism/poststructuralism on the "left" and respect him for doubling down on the important of reason, rationality, and an empirical method.

These days, especially in American academia, most people preposterously labelled (by conservative opponents) as "cultural Marxists" or "Marxists" generally are anything but. Marx and many other people in that vein in the 20th century were committed materialists -- attempting to ground their analysis in rather cold hard economic analysis -- you can debate whether they were right or not or using the right tools, etc but this was their philosophical position, what they were trying to do.

The bulk of today's apparently-left wing intellectuals are effectively idealists (in the epistemological sense, not the moral sense). They fundamentally believe in the primacy of ideas over the material world, but they've done a slight of and instead of referring to it as Forms ala Plato, or Idea as in Hegel, etc. it's now the "Narrative" etc. I think it is having a destructive effect, and has in large part discredited this line of though about the people it's supposed to be liberating. It's a middle class movement for middle class academics, and has little to offer the working class.

Chomsky is a refreshing antidote to this. I can't speak to his linguistic analysis, though.

He's also very very old at this point.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by reducesuffering on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:29AM (#37699277)
> Marx

> cold hard economic analysis

Haven’t heard something like that in awhile. Maybe you missed how much of his writing was more about how a Hegelian spirit force overtaking the world was inevitable, disproved by the Soviet Union.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by eddythompson80 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:15AM (#37688488)
He’s also a genocide denier.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dgb23 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:18AM (#37688525)
That's not true.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by snowpid on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:24AM (#37688592)
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dgb23 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:54AM (#37688971)
That's not what "genocide denial" means. This was perhaps wrong judgement in hindsight.

Calling this or other things "genocide denial" and similarly extreme terms is a common tactic in order to craft an ad-hominem attack to divert from anti-imperialist criticism.

I'm in part Bosnian, so American intervention has had a very real impact on my family's well being and even survival. So I'm at least ambivalent if not opposed to some of Chomsky's views on anti-imperialism, even though I respect his principled stance.

But calling him a "genocide denier" is incredibly cheap. If you read the rationale behind his early assessments of the situation, it becomes clear that it was based on (well founded) mistrust of American reporting. As the author of "Manufacturing Consent" he has been very consistent in that view.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by hotdogscout on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:11AM (#37689139)
So, based on your views, socialists are incapable of genocide? Since it could be an imperialist smear campaign?

Every instance of genocide denial I know of also follows this line of reasoning.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dgb23 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:00AM (#37689723)
> So, based on your views, socialists are incapable of genocide? Since it could be an imperialist smear campaign?

That doesn't follow does it. Why would you try to assume that I don't understand basic logic?

Whether you live in this or that empire, it's people at the top telling you what to believe, what is right and wrong, while committing the most atrocious crimes.

Socialists are very much capable of genocide and other forms of mass killings. In fact, they seem to typically start with killing other socialists, especially the democratic, libertarian left. That's no coincidence.

> Every instance of genocide denial I know of also follows this line of reasoning.

Genocide denial doesn't _follow_ this line of reasoning. It presents itself as such in order to hide the true intent. It is ultimately a propaganda instrument.

From my understanding, this is not what he did. He openly and repeatedly denounced these regimes. Look at what he actually said and wrote (sensational YT videos don't count). I can't speak for him.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by snowpid on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:07AM (#37689798)
'I'm in part Bosnian, so American intervention has had a very real impact on my family's well being and even survival. So I'm at least ambivalent if not opposed to some of Chomsky's views on anti-imperialism, even though I respect his principled stance.' That does not matter. It doesnt make your opinion more valid.

'Calling this or other things "genocide denial" and similarly extreme terms is a common tactic in order to craft an ad-hominem attack to divert from anti-imperialist criticism.' It is very normal to judge based on other areas that someone said. He denied the Cambodian genocide and never changed his view since 50 years! What does it say about him? And why is it ad-hominem? Do you even know what does it mean?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by hotdogscout on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:24AM (#37688597)
You're lying. It is true and a repeated decades long offense. He denies, when asked, each and every genocide that harms the reputation of socialism.

[https://youtu.be/VCcX_xTLDIY?si=v99y8DiJidzYOJES]

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by eddythompson80 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:20AM (#37688553)
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:30AM (#37688665)
I don’t know why people still defend Chomsky’s horrible positions on this stuff. Moreover his claim that Leninism is distinct from Stalinism was absolutely disproven when the soviet archives were briefly opened and scholars could read Lenin’s letters and memos, but Chomsky holds to the claim.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by eddythompson80 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:06PM (#37698871)
My main problem with Chomsky is that he's intellectually dishonest. He picks his positions, then redefines words and picks facts or parts of facts that support his position and ignores others. He twists narratives dismisses anything that contradicts with his position as conspiracy. I used to like Chomsky when I was initially introduces to him because I agreed with a lot of his leftist ideologies. But being so intellectually dishonest in supporting them makes him no better than an Alex Jones of the intellectual left.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Monday October 02, 2023 @09:52PM (#37746986)
> My main problem with Chomsky is that he's intellectually dishonest

He also routinely cites "the archives," and every single time I've checked the source he's referencing his grossly misstating things (if I'm feeling generous).

> an Alex Jones of the intellectual left

This gave me a good chuckle.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by foobarqux on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:59PM (#37754544)
> He also routinely cites "the archives," and every single time I've checked the source he's referencing his grossly misstating things (if I'm feeling generous).

Can you give an example? I've never found a gross misstatement when checking his citations.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:57AM (#37802767)
As an example he claimed in 2022 that in 1970 Soviet Citizens could access the BBC, citing historical records of broadcasts in Russian. He neglected to mention that the Soviet government jammed the signal.

This is just one example.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by foobarqux on Saturday October 07, 2023 @06:24PM (#37806050)
"However, jamming was never totally effective, and listening to the [BBC‘s] Russian Service as well as other Western broadcasters had, by the 1970s, become a ubiquitous phenomenon among the Soviet urban intelligentsia."

“a Harvard University study in the mid-1970s estimated that 28 million people in the Soviet Union tuned in [to US-funded VoA] at least once a week.’”

Far from a "gross misstatement".

https://fair.org/home/factchecking-the-factchecker-on-chomsk...

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Thursday October 12, 2023 @09:56AM (#37857201)
He was technically correct that some could, but it was obvious that he meant the USSR allowed it, which was a lie. This is a dumb argument.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by foobarqux on Thursday October 12, 2023 @06:43PM (#37864100)
The point he was making was that 1970s Soviet Russians had more access to information in practice than Americans today, which has nothing to do with whether or not Russia allowed it. I don't think "both countries tried to censor but only the US was successful at it" is the gotcha you think it is.

On another note I don't know exactly what you are trying to say in your top-level comment but Chomsky has said "when [Lenin] became the leader he didn't waste much time and Trotsky helped him in instituting a uh a pretty repressive regime which wasn't Stalinism but all the basic elements of Stalinism". Is that what you are referring to?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0q_2A_RoonI&t=304s

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ch4s3 on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:40PM (#37876778)
He tried to make that incorrect point by lying, because Chomsky lies constantly. He only turned around on Lenin because the archives proved he was full of shit.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by hef19898 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:09AM (#37689126)
Chomsky is yet another person, who gained public "fame" for expertise in his initial field. And who then went on to believe that his newly gained recognition, and expertise in one field, qualifies him to reach out into other fields with public comments. And since the internet and society works the way they do, people assign him authority in those fields as well since he's famous. Hence, he became more popular science than hard science. At which point it is almost fair to just ignore him.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:38AM (#37689424)
This is absolutely not the case. His political writings and interventions got publicity the same reason as for many other people who were in academia in the 1960s: public opposition to the Vietnam war. This was a fulcrum in American (and western) culture and opposition germinated strongly on college campuses, so plenty of people in academia got a bit of "fame" as a result of this.

Most people I know who have read Chomsky have read his political writings only, and barely know him for his linguistics, and he almost never in any of his writings blurs the distinction between the two or mentions one in the context of the other.

I'd say rather his linguistics career has been mostly something that ran parallel to, not intersecting with, his interventions in debate about foreign policy etc.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by hef19898 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:41AM (#37689473)
And he if he wouldn't have been an linguist at university during Vietnam, just how many people would have read his thoughts on policy?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by boppinz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:26AM (#37689290)
I'm sorry but that discredits his wide history as a modern intellectual. He did philosophy and linguistics from the start.

Like it's fine to not agree with him, but he often offers a great introduction to topics like war and labor organizing for folks. His pop science is at least based on real science and his own reasoning.

And who would you suggest instead? If you say anyone before the 1960s but filtered through the likes of Jordan Peterson or Steven Pinker I'm going to have a hernia. THEY are pop science crap.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by hef19898 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:31AM (#37689353)
Personally, I have a peoblem with all those "intelectuals". Most of the time they were never top of the crop in their field to begin with, and then switched over to general intellectualism using top notch rethoric skills. Peterson is living, or already fell off, the extreme end of this spectrum. People like Chomsky occupy places on the same spectrum so.

And spare me philosophers.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by boppinz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:01AM (#37689739)
Laymen need people who can synthesize the works of academics/researchers.

If someone like Chomsky wasn't talking about "faciness" and the ethics of ChatGPT, would anyone really bring that up? In an academic setting or otherwise.

This again also discredits his work as an academic for coining and bringing to light topics like CFGs.

Or in another similar vein: Bill Nye helps to distill scientific concepts for children (and adults too). There is something to be said for him helping to engage some students more in science, AND for whatever interpretation and analysis of Creationism vs. Evolution he did at that debate with Ken Ham, for the lay people. To a degree, it doesn't matter if he got every one of his points 100% logically sound, it can be a springboard that hopefully gives theists some food for thought on why Evolution is the best we empirically have and that the Bible isn't a primary source for citing.

So I again ask who you would rather speak to me about these topics, or am I supposed to just dig through thousands of scholarly articles and hope the ones I discuss and cite have the "correct" opinion and rhetorical skils?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by hef19898 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:13AM (#37689876)
Bill Nye condenses scietific facts, true. And he does that very well. What he does not is selling his own ideas on everything.

ChatGPT, well, everybody brings those issues up. But who really cares about "faciness"?

Also, evolution is as much a fact as gravity. Pretending there needs to be a discussion being had, especially one not between biologists and other experts, just gives credit to opinions that don't deserve it. But since there are people denying gravity, well...

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chomskyole on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:15AM (#37689179)
> What Chomsky is saying is that if you include only the people who are "healthy" according to some subjective criteria and take a crossection of their moralities - the result isn't an empty set. Well duh.

Where do you get that statement from? I don't think he says that at all.

He says that the idea of morality is bound, i.e. it isn't infinite. I think that is easy to agree.

He also says that you can argue morals. So he doesn't argue for a cross section of morals at all, quite the opposite: he hints, in this short video, that you can analyse sets of morals for their consistency.

He uses the example of labour under slavery vs labour under a wage contract and how these different arrangements lead to different attitudes to labour. Implied is the idea that Chomsky is against slavery, but considers certain arguments slaveholders made valid.

Are you sure you aren't, accidentally, putting up a straw-man?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by boppinz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:34AM (#37689387)
1 - His Ukraine stance is simply that we have had a Cold War paradox in our American minds since the 50s, Russia is both too strong a foe to ignore and a paper tiger working off of shoddy USSR tanks and being beat by some farmers with lock-on missiles.

This article helps clarify his points, he absolutely calls Russia's invasion barbaric, but he has always vehemently stated the West's bloodlust and policing has never helped our case as peacemakers: https://jacobin.com/2022/06/noam-chomsky-interview-russia-uk...

2 - Sometimes philosophy is about stating the obvious "well duh". Because if you can't establish solid axioms, then how can you try to prove a higher-level thesis?

And if the linguistic stuff is over your head, I'm not sure the philosophy stuff will be easy for you to grasp either. Unless you have a major/minor in dialectics I don't know about.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:52AM (#37689614)
The problem with the Ukraine stuff is that it falls easily into the same crap position as Varoufakis and others on the left which is basically a) some kind of "realism" about what Ukraine should do [basically surrender] and b) gives credence to much of the crap that Lavrov has put out on the public stage about this war being somehow about American imperialism.

Well, duh, everything is about imperialism, but what's missing from Chomsky's analysis is that: Russian imperialism is far far far worse.

I am not so much distressed by Chomsky's position on this issue as that of many of his followers/fans who seem to lack nuance entirely

Lefteast had some good articles on this topic and the crappy role many western "left wing" intellectuals have been playing. I will try to dig them up.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by fishtacos on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:23AM (#37690024)
Chomsky has missed the mark more than once. His response to the NATO campaign against Serbia during the Kosovo war was what clinched it for me. He's come back to apologize about being misunderstood in that he was only opposing NATO intervention because it would lead to a response (no shit) against ethnic Albanians by Serbs...

Talk about missing the forest for the trees. The ethnic cleansing of Albanians in Kosovo had been going on for almost a century at that point - not all ethnic cleansing is militaristic. It can occur via political representation, whitewashing of one's history, meaning, presence, through educational systems, sidelined and ignored into oblivion, like so many cultures have been.

I think he's taking a similar tone-deaf view of the Ukrainian conflict.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:22AM (#37690910)
Agree 100%. FWIW I was in various left wing activist groups at the time and the Chomsky-type position was both mainstream, but one I disagreed with and one thing that pushed me further away from those kinds of groupings.

It's a blind tribal positioning -- NATO / US bad, therefore everything it does bad. But this is in no way a materialist or logical method of analysis. Either you support the oppressed and minorities (e.g. Kosovan Albanians or Ukrainians etc) or you don't, and making abstract statements about right and wrong without having an actual tactical answer is irresponsible when people's lives are on the line.

But, worse, we're finding there's people who not only have essentially abstentionist positions but also there's a large portion of "the left" that is explicitly pro-Russian through some sort of aesthetic and/or cultural attachment to some Russophile past related to the Soviet Union (e.g. "Tankies"), or just raging anti-American positions that push them in that direction (the George Galloway types) etc. etc. These people are... really messed up, but also way more prominent than I realized/feared. There is simply no excuse to support an authoritarian, homophobic, violent, quasi-theocratic, terrorizing gangsterist regime like Putin's... wow

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by fishtacos on Saturday September 30, 2023 @01:24PM (#37717628)
Like you, I've managed to navigate myself through the minefield of various activist groups I also subscribed to, at least in concept...

It appears, to me, that one's alliances are teaching moments (months, years) that lead to a rather enticing, surreptitious, inward analysis of of the logic and values one considers primary.

>>There is simply no excuse to support an authoritarian, homophobic, violent, quasi-theocratic, terrorizing gangsterist regime like Putin's...

Not to pat each other on the back, but we are in agreement. To bring it down to a more simplistic, humane POV, follow the Golden Rule: do unto others etc... Russia has failed at the first 3 words of that written/said idea of reciprocity and is unfortunately, damn proud of it.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by johndhi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:07AM (#37689801)
Why is Russia's imperialism far far far worse?

What about the us invasion of Iraq is "better" than the Russia invasion of Ukraine?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by torstenvl on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:38AM (#37690206)
The U.S. could do better about prosecuting troops who commit war crimes, but it does prosecute them.

By contrast, Russia openly condones war crimes. Not in the debatable "enhanced interrogation" borderline kind of way. In the kidnapping children to wipe out an entire cultural history and intentionally bombing civilian targets kind of way.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by za3faran on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:20AM (#37690872)
Why prosecute just the troops and not those in command who ordered the war crimes? Starting with Bush sr, Clinton, Bush, Obama, and the rest of the gang and all the way down the chain of command.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by snowpid on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:12AM (#37689863)
1.) Iraq was never annexed by USA. 2.) American govertment never claimed there is no Iraqi culture. 3.) There was no large kidnapping of Iraqi kids. 4.) There are no mass rapes made by the American military. 5.) Iraqis were never forced to forget Arab and learn only English. 6.) Hussein used poison gas on Kurdish people and used Zyklon B filled rockets (yes, same gas like in Ausschwitz) to attack Israel. Hussein occupied Kuwait and attacked Saudi - Arabia. There is no remotely similar thing the Ukraine goverment did in the past.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by za3faran on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:15AM (#37690787)
Lots of these are paper arguments. Yeah so Iraq was not "annexed", but the west installed a puppet government to do what they want, and they attempted to brainwash the population with western values. They did the same in Afghanistan, but fortunately they failed miserably and left in a humiliated manner. Maybe the kidnapping wasn't as bad as ukraine, but the hundreds of thousands killed and millions displaced and sick and poor and left without anything would like to have a word with you. I'm not defending Saddam's atrocities, but let's not pretend that the US didn't nuke Japan or use napalm in Vietnam. Fact of the matter is that the western hypocrisy is now more exposed than ever. You think they really care about Ukraine? All they see is more room to expand their influence and power in the globe.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by 0xDEF on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:27PM (#37695346)
>Iraq was not "annexed", but the west installed a puppet government to do what they want, and they attempted to brainwash the population with western values.

This is a lie. There was a legitimate democratic election in Iraq in January 2005 with 58% voter turnout. Because of the Shia majority of Iraq they voted into power a pro-Iranian Shia-dominated government which is the very opposite of a US "puppet government".

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by za3faran on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:37PM (#37696244)
If you believe that the west didn't have a hand in the outcome, I have a bridge to sell you. Plus, we don't believe in western style democracy in our tradition, so further proof of western destruction and meddling in other countries' affairs. Quite the hypocrisy when they do it themselves but then cry when another power like Russia does it (and I don't condone what is happening in Ukraine either, but the hypocrisy must be pointed out).
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by snowpid on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:04AM (#37705336)
Can you elaborate how a pro Iranian government is a Western puppet government? With credible sources etc.? Also I like to know who is "we".
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by za3faran on Saturday September 30, 2023 @10:39PM (#37722035)
Wikipedia states: "al-Maliki worked closely with the Multi-National Force (MNF–I), and continued to cooperate with the United States following the withdrawal from Iraq."

And "we" as in Muslims.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by snowpid on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @12:30PM (#37767597)
This is not a puppet goverment. And interestingly "we" excludes parts of Iraque society, namely Christians and Yazidis. Also ask your local Kurdish (mostly Muslims) people what they think about Hussein. You will be surprised ;)
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by LindeBuzoGray on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:14PM (#37694269)
The border of Iraq was created by Colonel Sykes and Monsieur Picot.

Iraqi culture of thousands of years disappeared from the Iraq Museum after the invasion, as Rumsfeld said about it "stuff happens".

When Americans "kidnapped" Vietnamese adoptees to the US during the Vietnam War, Americans hailed themselves for their big hearts.

Rapes, you mean like at Abu Ghraib and other places?

The US lifted arms embargoes to provide Iraq with the helicopters that attacked the Kurds.

The Ukraine after the coup began attacking Lunhansk and Donetsk.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:16AM (#37689923)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_genocide_of_Ukr...

Let's also remember a few millions of Ukrainians were starved to death not 100 years ago by Russians. Ukraine is and was the most fertile soil in Europe. Russians sent soldiers to steal food and to ban people from leaving.

This is what happens when Russia invades you. People in the west have no comparison.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by johndhi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:01AM (#37690570)
Some interesting responses here but imo these sound like "worse" but not "far far far worse" conditions to me. A war where lots of people are being killed exploded maimed raped generationally ruined or traumatized - is really horrible either way. It sounds like Russia has somewhat worse intentional practices than us but I don't see what the us did as okay in any sense.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:26AM (#37690984)
Russians on their TV openly argue for killing "every Ukrainian".

The fact we are even arguing about this is the best evidence that morality is relative...

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by mrguyorama on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:32PM (#37693698)
And that's just the start. They openly advocate for nuking western nations. Imagine if Anderson Cooper spent tens of minutes ranting about how we should just nuke Russia and China because fuck them
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:22PM (#37698195)
I'm no apologist for Russia, and you can see that from where I started this thread, but...

You act like there aren't actually dozens and dozens of Fox-news style commentators on US media and talk radio who haven't said similar things before, about various enemies of the USA?

The asshats on Russian media saying these things are basically the Russian equivalent of that crap. Demagogues etc

Some of the shit I heard coming from American right wing media after 9/11 was downright scary.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:41PM (#37698685)
[delayed]
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by cmrdporcupine on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:35AM (#37691144)
Ok, let's put it another way so we don't play whataboutisms, which this is what this is veering into:

Would you rather your country and governance be controlled and dominated by Russia or by the EU & the west?

I think most people here, if they're being honest, know that despite all its issues, political and economic life in the Baltic states, Poland, Czech Republic, etc. is better in most respects than life in Belarus or large parts of Russia, or the Russian dominated states that surround it. We can debate why that is the case, but I think that's basically fact. (Yes, I hear the streets of Minsk are very clean and it's a "well ordered" society, but this is the kind of thing we hear about all sorts of authoritarian countries and it doesn't make up for lack of basic democracy and individual freedoms, etc.)

In other words: We are not talking in this concrete instance about whether "the invasion of Iraq is better/worse than Russian invasion of Ukraine", but whether Russian dominance and control of Ukraine is better or worse for Ukrainians than western.

I think on the whole the Ukrainian people have voiced their position on this.

Now, whether life will be better for Ukrainians in a post-Russian-control world, I can't say, because it seems the Putin/Lavrov regime is doing its best to make that impossible by destroying as much of Ukraine's productive capacity and future success as it can. Russian strategy seems to have transitioned -- about last fall -- from "occupy as much as we can and destroy the Zelensky regime and take over" to "retreat to a defensive line and f*ck up as much of the rest of Ukraine as we can, salting the earth to make it clear what leaving Russian domination looks like"*

Clearly the US invasion of Iraq is a historic war crime. It should not have happened, and I agree with others that the perpetrators should be held to account. But this isn't a math equation where we balance the one action with the other. We are talking about the physical real lives of Ukrainians, and their ability to control their own country and trade with who they want, and manage their own affairs -- not Iraq.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by johndhi on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:43PM (#37711806)
Great post.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:08AM (#37689806)
Ad 1. There's no paradox. Russia is a paper tiger that barely works. But it has nukes and enough conventional army to fuck up small countries in Eastern Europe. Hence they seek NATO membership. The war isn't about USA, the war is about deciding whether Russia can again occupy about 100 000 000 people living there. Chomsky arguing against west involvement is enabling Russia. This isn't rocket science. If Baltic States didn't join NATO they would be gone by now. Poland would be likely fighting a war as we speak.

Ad 2. I have a lot of people I respect tell me his linguistic ideas make some sense, but for me it's just wrong (see LLMs). It's not my specialty and it's his specialty so I usually resist the urge to speak about it. He doesn't seem to have any problems speaking about Eastern European politicis tho, without knowing much about it. I'd cry "colonialism" but that's cheap.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by snowpid on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:11AM (#37689855)
According to wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_positions_of_Noam_Ch...) ' In October 2022, he called on the U.S. to stop "undermining negotiations" between Ukraine and Russia.[137]

In an interview with New Statesman published in April 2023, Chomsky is quoted in saying that Russia was fighting more "humanely" in Ukraine than the U.S. did in Iraq, and that Russia was "acting with restraint and moderation" as Ukraine had not suffered "large-scale destruction of infrastructure" compared to Iraq.[138] Chomsky also asserted that Ukraine was not a free actor, that it was the U.S. and then United Kingdom which refused peace negotiations to further their own national interests, and that U.S. military aid to Ukraine is aimed at degrading Russian military forces.[138] Chomsky also argued that the applications to join NATO by Sweden and Finland had "nothing to do with fear of a Russian attack, which has never been even conceived", but instead was to give both countries new markets for their military industries and access to advanced equipment.[138] ' and that is copying Russian propaganda. Not all he says about the war is Russian propaganda but more than you claim. Chomsky fan boys just start to read the wikipedia articles and stop defending him.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by diegoeche on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:12AM (#37689873)
The article is bullshit. He had interesting criticism for imperialist policy in the US, but after the 90s it becames a tiring "west is bad".

Not only he blames the victim with Ukraine, he did it with the Serbian ethnic cleansing and the Cambodian genocide.

Him: On the Cambodian genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambodian_genocide_denial#Chom...

Him: On the Srebrenica massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosnian_genocide_denial

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by tomjen3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:59AM (#37689705)
I agree with you. I wish he was a banned subject on hn.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by boppinz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:11AM (#37689857)
nah, I think a lot of armchair philosopher techies on here could use some alternate opinions and dialectics.

The primary reason for bringing him up (or any philosopher on this forum, really) is the nexus of ethics and AI. Although we haven't particularly let ethics stop us from a lot of high-tech atrocities throughout the past century, in the military field or otherwise (I'm thinking private equity and rampant credit use).

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by tomjen3 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:06AM (#37690636)
I don't disagree that we could use other useful perspectives.

I strongly emphatize he doesn't bring them.