News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by twoodfin on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:13AM (#37688466)
What Chomsky is arguing is that, yes, in an important objective sense there is such a thing as “faciness” that our brains recognize. In the same way, I hope we’d all agree there’s objectively a color red—even accepting that it’s the structure of our optical and neural systems that are the basis for this fact.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:20AM (#37688554)
The only definition is "most people recognize it" and there are people who disagree about it or don't recognize it at all.

How does it differ from something that exists subjectively then?

I'd say arguing that colors are like morality is pro-relativism stance.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by roenxi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:22AM (#37688576)
> I hope we’d all agree there’s objectively a color red

We don't. For starters there are colourblind people, for seconds there is no specific colour that can be called "red". There is a large and fuzzy category of red-ish colours like blood-red or rose-red.

Even if there is some academic "these light wavelengths are the ones" definition of red that is arbitrary. Aliens might have drawn the lines elsewhere.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by twoodfin on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:33AM (#37688704)
This is exactly Chomsky’s point. Try to get through life considering the color of the traffic light you’re approaching as a subjective rather than objective fact.

To pick an example closer to the morality case: Hunger could equally be called a subjective phenomenon. Aliens may not experience anything like hunger. A rare genetic condition might produce a human who experiences escalating hunger as an escalating degree of pleasure.

But as humans making our way through the real world, we are forced by physical and anatomical reality to see the causes and consequences of human hunger as objective truths.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by roenxi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:41AM (#37688798)
> ... Try to get through life considering the color of the traffic light you’re approaching as a subjective rather than objective fact. ...

You didn't consider what I wrote - colourblind people get through life without considering the colour of traffic lights at all. They have to. They are colour blind. The colour of a traffic light as a practical matter is a subjective fact. In fact, the practical colour of a traffic light is more subjective than the philosophical take because at least philosophers can be convinced with a wavelength argument.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:57AM (#37688994)
Hunger is subjective. Starvation isn't.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:36AM (#37689409)
Hunger is pretty objective if your body isn't malfunctioning (and it never is logically). If your body works correctly, you are not free to choose whether to consider yourself hungry, and this is what I understand as objectivity.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:07PM (#37693340)
What I consider hunger someone else can consider the norm or vice versa. If you define something that depends on the person as objective - then subjective loses meaning.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:15PM (#37695986)
I improved my definition of feelings so that they can easily be objective.

I define hunger as the ideal signal that corresponds exactly to the extent of starvation. 'Ideal signal' is almost like sensation or feeling, except it may not be always or in full precision accessible by consciousness. It is a physical signal, or a function from the physical state. Extent of starvation seems objective (after fixing its definition), and so hunger seems objective too (correspondence is exact). By this definition, if you are starved, but don't notice a feeling of hunger, it's that, you still are hungry, just don't notice it.

> What I consider hunger someone else can consider the norm or vice versa.

How can that be? Do you mean definition, or something else? What do you consider hunger?

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:46PM (#37698732)
> I define hunger as the ideal signal that corresponds exactly to the extent of starvation.

If you redefine words how you please you can prove anything. What's the point tho?

> What do you consider hunger?

The feeling I sometimes get that I should eat something. It's VERY subjective (for example when I'm fasting I can go a few days without it, but when I'm not - I get it just cause I'm bored and haven't eaten a breakfast).

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by knewter on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:33AM (#37688708)
We universally agree that it is at least "the wavelength produced from a well-calibrated display when asked to render #ff0000'
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by roenxi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:42AM (#37688815)
I mean, ok. But that isn't objective. That is a subjective judgement of the display calibration standards body, with no reference to what most people think "red" means.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by knewter on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:06PM (#37710659)
At least they can reliably compare society's idea of red to their own but I'm pretty sure people's ability to think of red as things outside the rgb gamut is likely diminishing over time.
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by chromoblob on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:28AM (#37689322)
If you insist on a definition in terms of physics, there may be a universal standard way of interpolating all distributed ideas of red into a main definition, even if extremely high-tech.

Otherwise, this question comes down to whether the meaning of the term 'red' is generated objectively or subjectively, which is related to philosophy of language and mind. See article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity_and_the_... .

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by dsego on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:18AM (#37688531)
Does that relate to Plato's world of ideas?
Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by botanical57 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:45AM (#37688841)
To his doctrine of the Forms, yes I think it does. He seemed to think that when humans gain knowledge, they do not generate it, but rather discover it. For knowledge to be discovered, it must have already existed - in the abstract, non-material world of the Forms. Plato had an involved epistemological argument for why the human process of gaining incrementally less partial knowledge of a subject fundamentally must be a process of discovery - but I would fail to do it justice.

Chomsky seems to imply that in a moral context, similarly, as humans learn abstract concepts and boundaries from sparse data, we are also carrying out a process of discovery. He seems to skip over the epistemological reasoning.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ducharmdev on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:44AM (#37688832)
It's odd to me that you chose color as an example of something objective, since so much about perception is subjective.

Even if we think about it in more quantitative terms, with red being defined as having a dominant wavelength approximately 625–740 nanometres, it's a bit of an arbitrary definition isn't it? If we observe a wavelength of 624, objectively we might say it's not red, but someone may still observe it as red considering how close it is to red. Or someone with protanopia won't see anything in those bounds as red either.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by beezlebroxxxxxx on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:02AM (#37689042)
Color relies on ostensive definition. It's a public part of language whether someone is color-blind or not. When we say "that car is red" we are, in a sense, pointing to something and then using the concept and rules of color in our language. We might see something as a particular color through perception, but when we see "that --->" we are, in a sense, "seeing" in language (including body language, for instance. You could ask me which one is red and I could simply point).

We, of course, might disagree, but color-blind people learn which traffic lights are red, green, or yellow, regardless of their perceptual faculties. Because the color is not just what you see, but what you say.

Re:Chomsky Explains Why Nobody Is a Moral Relativist, Even M... by ajuc on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:40AM (#37689458)
[delayed]