News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tylervigen on Saturday September 02, 2023 @08:58AM (#37361108)
Author here! Glad you all enjoyed the article. It was a fun journey into the history of my community.

For the record: I am an advocate of walkability and think there should be more bridges, not fewer. I just wondered how that one got there given the context of limited walkability in the area.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bufordtwain on Saturday September 02, 2023 @09:12AM (#37361200)
That was a great read, particularly the frequent hidden notes :) thanks for taking such an immense amount of time to research and write it all up.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by dang on Saturday September 02, 2023 @06:55PM (#37366190)
The notes are so good and so amusing that the article is worth reading just to enjoy the notes. Don't miss this rabbit-out-of-hat moment:

Believe it or not, I was specifically trained by the military as a geo-spatial analyst to identify bridges in black and white aerial photographs taken in the 1960s.

Also... @tylervigen, the note after "Peter Wilson of the Bridges Division got back to me very quickly" doesn't work for me in either of the browsers I tried. I want to know what about Peter Wilson of the Bridges Division getting back to you quickly merited a note!

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by woobar on Saturday September 02, 2023 @08:00PM (#37366527)
From the page source:

This is an understatement. I sent an email to the Department of Transportation at 11:00PM on Wednesday and Peter responded at 7:48AM on Thursday, which is ZERO BUSINESS HOURS later. This is the fastest response to a data request I have ever received.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by dang on Saturday September 02, 2023 @08:59PM (#37366805)
You are clever and that was worth it. Thanks!
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by joveian on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:36AM (#37369928)
Most of them, including that one, pop up the full note text if you mouse over (annoying UI but helped for that one note). I appreciate that the notes worked without javascript :).
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tylervigen on Sunday September 03, 2023 @12:01PM (#37371460)
Glad someone appreciated it, because it was a lot of additional work to do it that way!
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by gammarator on Saturday September 02, 2023 @11:25PM (#37367449)
As well as

> By the way, about these epic pics: you can't just fly a drone this close to the airport without getting in trouble with the Federal Aviation Administration. This is restricted airspace. That's why I went through the process of requesting and receiving drone flight clearance from the FAA, just so I could show you these photos. You're welcome.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tylervigen on Sunday September 03, 2023 @12:03PM (#37371469)
Fixed! Sorry about that. It's an artifact of my stubborn refusal to use any web editing tools other than Notepad++.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by iandanforth on Saturday September 02, 2023 @09:24AM (#37361305)
Really enjoyed the article! Your tenacity was impressive.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tiahura on Saturday September 02, 2023 @09:31AM (#37361369)
You see these "bridges to nowhere" in analogous places in a lot of the midwest. I think the city planner nailed it - it was built in anticipation of development. I.e., back in the 60's they made guesses about growth and some of those guesses were wrong. There are probably many others, but these catch our attention because they're 50 feet up in the air.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Two9A on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:29AM (#37361832)
Honestly, you see this all over the world where anticipated development either hasn't materialised or funds have dried up. The A57(M) freeway through Manchester, England was planned to continue from its current endpoint southwards, but the rest of it... never happened. And now there's a bridge over the A34 that doesn't connect to anywhere.

As I recall, the M1 emerging from London starts at "Junction 4" and there were three more junctions planned deeper into central London, but that part of the road never happened either.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by RetroTechie on Saturday September 02, 2023 @04:54PM (#37365441)
Great article!

Reminded me of the "Leave as you found" rule:

Say you're hiking through some fields, and come upon a fence. If it's open, don't close it. If it's closed, don't pass through leaving it open.

Why? Because building a fence takes effort. Maintaining it too. And if whoever built that fence left it open, probably had a good reason to do so.

Read: until you understand why it's there & in the state it's in, don't mess with that. If you do know who put the thing there & how it's used, then by all means have at it.

And the detective work here: hacker spirit in optima forma! Kudoz to the author.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by pimlottc on Saturday September 02, 2023 @07:11PM (#37366278)
This is more specifically known as Chesterton’s Fence:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chesterton%27s_fence

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by markphip on Saturday September 02, 2023 @09:53AM (#37361549)
I really enjoyed this. I did not really know where it was going at first but it got really interesting. My daughter is in school to become an Archivist so it really started to get my attention as I went further into it.

I do have to say in the beginning of the post, I was thinking it was going to end up being about pork and politics and in a sense that is how it ended.

I loved this so much ... "While I am dedicated to this search, I am not about to fly down to Kansas City to dig through federal archives, especially when those documents may or may not be there...

...just kidding. Of course I flew down to Kansas City to dig through the federal archives"

Thanks for creating this

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Macha on Saturday September 02, 2023 @07:50PM (#37366464)
If you enjoyed this, you might also enjoy two videos from CGP Grey:

- The Race to Win Staten Island (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ex74x_gqTU0)

- Someone dead ruined my life... again (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEV9qoup2mQ)

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by markphip on Sunday September 03, 2023 @09:44AM (#37370379)
I usually prefer reading to videos but those were excellent. Thanks for the share
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by mashygpig on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:06PM (#37373945)
I thought of these as well while reading the article as they convey the fun aspects of archival visits well (I’ve done a bit of my own and really enjoyed the random “side quest” things you discover along the way).

If anyone else has recommendations for things like these (text or video) then I would love to see more!

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by echelon on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:29AM (#37361833)
This was such a fun read and a fantastic little mystery.

Thank you so much for sharing your project with the world and for making it so entertaining. (Glad you found the smoking gun, too.)

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by asmithmd1 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:36AM (#37361897)
Thanks for the thorough research, not just on-line, but including calling people.

I occasionally go down rabbit holes like this and I have not gotten the helpful responses from officials I have contacted in the New England area. I don't know if I was telegraphing some agenda the officials did not want to further, or if it was because you were dealing with "Minnesota nice" people. I first heard of Minnesota nice when a curmudgeonly co-worker was grumbling about calling Anderson Window, "I hate calling them, they are so effing nice!"

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by qingcharles on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:52AM (#37362042)
This article is so wholesome, thank you. I was going to just scroll through it real quick, but I got so engrossed and read every word. I died laughing about the Kansas City bit!
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bandyaboot on Saturday September 02, 2023 @11:23AM (#37362332)
This is the third place I’ve encountered your work in as many days. I first read it from a social media post, then saw it had been covered in the Star Tribune, and now here. Good to see such hard work getting noticed and appreciated.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by flir on Saturday September 02, 2023 @12:35PM (#37363057)
This was great. I too go on these ridiculous local history research binges, but I've never had a good model of how to write one up. So thanks for the interesting story, and the template.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by DiabloD3 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @01:18PM (#37363461)
I enjoyed reading this. Write more, you're good at it.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tylervigen on Sunday September 03, 2023 @12:05PM (#37371494)
Thanks! Means a lot!
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by justincormack on Saturday September 02, 2023 @02:59PM (#37364429)
There were fascinating protests against footbridges when first created in London, as the people felt they were losing their priority against the car. I copied out these notes from the book Leadville about the history of the A40 and the building of the first footbridge here https://www.flickr.com/photos/justincormack/256217251

The Bridge of Fools, the first footbridge over a road in Britain

In 1938 the inhabitants started to protest about the rising death toll on Western Avenue, the "Avenue of Speed and Death". They petitioned the Ministry of Transport to impose a speed limit of twenty-five or thirty miles an hour. The ministry said that would be an "ingenious provision" to save lives, but it would be against "the whole object of constructing a road free from congested traffic".

On 21 July 1938 the protestors filed across Western Avenue from the Approach, and then back, causing a huge tailback. The next day the Ministry arranged to build two bridges, one here and one by Gipsy Corner, much to the disgust of the protestors, who thought it would encourage cars to drive faster and to force pedestrians off more roads onto bridges and subways. A week later a thousand people demonstrated again for "their right to cross on the level".

In September the hastily erected bridge was complete, and five hundred people demonstrated against it again. The bridge became a tourist attraction and it was "quite usual to see people from other districts coming to look at it".

In October torchlight processions were held on the road every evening for a week, with a dog with a red light attached to it and four bearers carrying a coffin, and placards saying "We want crossings not coffins".

The war brought and end to the protests, and for a few years the traffic.

from Leadville: A Biography of the A40 by Edward Platt

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @04:50PM (#37365413)
Sounds like the kind of hypocrisy you'd hear from "urbanists" today: Complain about pedestrian deaths, then complain about a thing that prevents them.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bombcar on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:27PM (#37367205)
It’s amusing how nobody complains about pedestrian infrastructure over and under trains.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by growse on Sunday September 03, 2023 @03:07AM (#37368334)
Isn't that because most people understand that trains don't drive on sight?

Railways are for trains, roads are for people.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:48AM (#37368816)
Except of course that roads are NOT for people. But you knew that.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by defrost on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:57AM (#37368858)
Who were they for then?

Recall the context, please:

    the first footbridge over a road in Britain
a country with a network of roads 2,000+ years old.

And who were those roads for? Armies to march on.

You know, armies of people.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bombcar on Sunday September 03, 2023 @07:58AM (#37369688)
Everyone forgets the horse and its carts and carriages.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:31PM (#37384720)
Great. Stick to the ancient roads while you're walking, and you should be fine.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by defrost on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @08:01AM (#37390552)
If you're not comfortable with an answer to a question that you posed then perhaps you need to be more careful with your ill thought rhetoricals.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:25AM (#37369853)
Roads existed long before the motor vehicle did, the Romans were famous for them. And last I checked most people use roads to transport themselves, their not domain of empty cars driving themselves around.

In the civilised world, which the UK is part of, pedestrian have unlimited right of way and priority on all roads, except highways. Motor vehicles are guests, it just seems that drivers believe wrapping themselves in tons of metal gives them the right to bully and brutalise other road users with impunity.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:29PM (#37384702)
"it just seems that drivers believe wrapping themselves in tons of metal gives them the right to bully and brutalise other road users with impunity."

It seems that way to people projecting their hysterical delusions on everyone else.

And, again, we all know that modern roads are for vehicles and not PEDESTRIANS, (since you pretend to need it spelled out). That's why we have sidewalks.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:29PM (#37394103)
> It seems that way to people projecting their hysterical delusions on everyone else.

Are you telling me I was having a hysterical delusion last week when a driver chased me down and deliberately used their car to smash me into the side of a lorry, hospitalising me for a week? If so, you should really tell my local police, because they need to release the guy that hit me.

> And, again, we all know that modern roads are for vehicles and not PEDESTRIANS, (since you pretend to need it spelled out). That's why we have sidewalks.

Again, in the civilised world pedestrians have universal rights to use the road, and can use pavements at their discretion. From your language it seems you’ve yet to visit.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by xorcist on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:43AM (#37369973)
Most of them are. Horses came much later.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by buran77 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @05:56AM (#37369094)
If you look at it superficially - everything is people transport - it can look hypocritical. But the issue is with the externalities each of those apparently equivalent decisions create. Cars and trains are certainly not that similar beyond "transporting people".

A drug den isn't a hospital just because drugs are administered there. A diesel and an EV are not the same just because they only differ in fuel source. You treat them differently, you try to encourage the positive externalities and discourage the negative ones.

Some people have seen it coming a long time ago that as a society we are encouraging cars and their infrastructure too much and among other things we're giving up some (maybe too much?) individual freedom in favor of them. And wouldn't you know it, a century later we're aiming at making cities walkable again, even banning cars entirely in some areas, as proof that society is realizing those concerns weren't at all hypocritical.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by masfuerte on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:23AM (#37369829)
Yes we do. There are pedestrian level crossings in the UK but because there is the very occasional fatality they are increasingly replaced by bridges. This is a huge inconvenience for the vast majority of us who are capable of looking both ways and we do complain about it.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by eCa on Sunday September 03, 2023 @07:06PM (#37375485)
Ever heard the saying ”wrong side of the tracks”?
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:16AM (#37369791)
Why should pedestrians be forced to clamber over bridges for the convenience of drivers?

Drivers are the one with huge mechanical advantage, make them go up and down, don’t force the local pedestrians who live in the to take huge detour, just so drivers from out of town can save 30 seconds.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ensignavenger on Sunday September 03, 2023 @09:30PM (#37376312)
Those are good points, but the simple argument to the contrary is a matter of cost. It costs a whole lot less to build afoot bridge over a road that to build a road bridge over a foot path.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:54AM (#37378183)
Yes cost is the obvious elephant in the room. But ultimately all these things come down to priorities. Do we prioritise building human scale environments that are welcoming and pleasant to people, or do bulldoze that for car scale places that are hostile and unpleasant for people, unless they’re wrapped in tons of metal?

Turning all of spaces in car centric spaces also has cost, it’s just less obvious. Many time building that car bridge is cheaper for a government, if it helps keep people out of cars, and removes the huge number of negative externalities that car ownership brings.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by account42 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @04:53AM (#37389382)
The cost of building the structure is hardly the only cost involved. Either solution means a cost or benefit to the two different groups that you can't just ignore away.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by JambalayaJim on Sunday September 03, 2023 @01:32PM (#37372246)
Bridges are still very real obstacles to people in wheelchairs, bikes, with strollers or shopping carts, or just mobility impaired in general.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by IIsi50MHz on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:18PM (#37400670)
True generally, although many Tokyo pedestrian bridges have narrow ramp space reserved adjacent to the steps so that people with bicycles can walk them up to or down from bridge level with considerably less difficulty than if only steps were provided. The remaining cases are not addressed in these designs, though.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Reason077 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @05:35PM (#37365730)
The speed limit was indeed reduced, in 2020, to 30 mph on the elevated eastern section of the A40 (Westway), but remains 40 mph on the Western Avenue part.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by userabchn on Saturday September 02, 2023 @03:13PM (#37364560)
As others have said, it was an enjoyable read, and I thank you (and everyone else involved) for caring. One small bit of feedback: I suggest being a bit more subtle about how much work you did. At times I wondered if you were telling us things just to try to impress us with your dedication rather than because they were an important part of the story.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by kasztelan_ on Saturday September 02, 2023 @06:47PM (#37366160)
Huh, it didn't struck me as such. But maybe because I read it partially over the course of the day.

In any case the author DID make a lot of effort researching this and I can imagine it was not always pleasant hitting dead ends.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by quinncom on Saturday September 02, 2023 @03:57PM (#37364961)
Have tor spoken with Roman Mars yet? I hope this will be a 99% Invisible episode soon.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by fortran77 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @04:40PM (#37365333)
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Reason077 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @05:05PM (#37365514)
The UK has many similar pedestrian bridges crossing motorways and other major roads. There must be thousands of them throughout the country! Wherever there is an existing right of way (ie: foot path or bridal path) you can't just block it by building a motorway or other obstruction. So usually that means building a bridge!
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by pm215 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @05:43PM (#37365792)
True for motorways, but even on busy dual carriageways sometimes the planners just say "the footpath crosses the dual carriageway on the flat", ignoring that this comes pretty near to being an effective closure of the right of way; there are some on the A14 near me like that.

This forum thread lists some other examples: https://www.sabre-roads.org.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=41259

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ralferoo on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:06AM (#37369723)
There are a couple of instances of this on the A45 just after you leave Coventry going towards Birmingham. Some of these were later closed off entirely (the A45 has been there a long time, but some roads I used to cycle on 15 years ago and now closed). There's one or two that I would take my chance on when cycling, but there's simply no way to cross safely as a pedestrian because of the curvature of the road restricting visibility and the speed limit. One nice change is that the new road junctions to Birmingham airport now mean that there are more cycleable bridges again.

As to the GP's comment, since I got a gravel bike, I've been exploring a lot of random routes that are basically underused footpaths (because they don't really go anywhere useful) that cross the motorway in delightfully over-engineered ways, for instance a narrow path through a field of crops, a stile then a nice tarmac'd two lane bridge and a stile to another field on the other side.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by adolph on Saturday September 02, 2023 @06:53PM (#37366179)
Y’all even have bridges for boats

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pontcysyllte_Aqueduct

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by dolmen on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @07:49AM (#37390459)
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Gibbon1 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @11:15PM (#37367406)
Nagging thought of mine that gets brought up by the comment that there are two overpasses on each side of it. Which is those carry car traffic which makes them dangerous for pedestrians and bicyclists. It would be a good idea to build more pedestrian/bicycle only overpasses one street over from the car overpasses.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by samstave on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:05PM (#37367097)
We need a bunch of pre-fab structural designs that municipalities can put in quickly and affordable for various span lengths.

The American river could benefit a ton from this, as can all sorts of waterways in urban environments. Every bridge doesn't need to be unique and if we had a design contest which balanced aesthetics with durability and quality we should have a library of several design styles and have them placed over thin waters everywhere

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bombcar on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:29PM (#37367216)
We need federal “no permit” guidelines for such - often the cost of the materials and labor is the lowest part.

You often end up having to determine if the waterway is considered “navigable” even if nobody could ever run a boat up it.

[dead]
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by dang on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:26PM (#37383999)
Ouch. You've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines a lot lately. If you keep doing that, we're going to have to ban you, and eventually your main account as well. I don't want to do that, so could you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to using HN in the intended spirit instead? (That means thoughtful, respectful conversation on topics you're genuinely curious about.) We'd be grateful.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by syndicatedjelly on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @01:46PM (#37395254)
I'm sorry, that was out of line. I'll do better.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by dang on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @03:42PM (#37396753)
Appreciated!
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Fatnino on Sunday September 03, 2023 @03:42AM (#37368495)
I suspect that some of the bridges that lead to "parks" may have been leading to schools that no longer exist where those parks are now.

Might be worth digging into the history of those few parks.

Many parks around me in the bay area started life as the field for a school. Then the school closed as the boomers cycled through and it became just a park.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tylervigen on Sunday September 03, 2023 @12:04PM (#37371489)
I did actually check for that! I didn't see schools nearby enough to make sense for the ones I labeled "park."
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by db48x on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:01AM (#37368585)
> … limited walkability in the area.

One thing that I really like about your article, aside from the many things that others have already mentioned, is that it shows how much perceptions have changed. 50 years ago, this area was so easily walked that schoolchildren walked to and from school every day. Families walked to church every week. They didn’t need a dozen shops on every block in order to make walking worth–while. They didn’t care about a few parking lots even completely empty lots. They didn’t need sidewalks to feel safe while walking, or bicycle lanes.

Today we say that it has “limited walkability”.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:30AM (#37369886)
Today over 7000 pedestrians are killed in the U.S. every year, and the number is going up, not down.

Today cars are heavier, faster, and more deadly to pedestrians than ever before.

Today isn’t a good time to be a pedestrian in the U.S.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by wilg on Sunday September 03, 2023 @12:27PM (#37371683)
Most interestingly, the number of pedestrian deaths has only been going up very recently, since 2010. Before that it was decreasing.

https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/pedes...

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by db48x on Sunday September 03, 2023 @02:19PM (#37372796)
Plus, pedestrian deaths are most likely at night, presumably due to the decreased visibility. The statistics also show the lowest death rate amongst children, and the highest amongst the elderly (with middle–aged adults barely overtaking the elderly in this race in the last couple of years). School children thus seem to be the least at risk, though I don’t know why; it could be because they no longer walk to and from school, or it could be because they are more likely to survive an accident than the elderly are, but neither of those explain the much larger drop in deaths amongst the elderly pedestrians. And of course national averages tell us nothing about the specific location in question.

Still, I agree that the pedestrian accident rate really ought to be lower. A lot lower! I also think that the pedestrian accident rate is just not high enough to declare that areas like this are unsafe to walk in. Especially with a dedicated pedestrian bridge that allows people to avoid the car traffic at the busy service interchanges to the east and west.

No, when people talk about the “walkability” of an area, they are almost always talking about the sheer density of businesses in the area not about safety. How they can walk to the grocery store, and their dentist, and their favorite bar, and also three different art galleries. How everything they need is never more than a 15–minute walk away. How each parking lot represents a wasted opportunity, because there are no services there, and nobody lives there either.

But when this bridge was built they clearly were willing to walk further to access vital services like the school, past any number of parking lots. People are just a lot pickier today than they were in the past.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:31PM (#37374219)
> No, when people talk about the “walkability” of an area, they are almost always talking about the sheer density of businesses in the area not about safety. How they can walk to the grocery store, and their dentist, and their favorite bar, and also three different art galleries. How everything they need is never more than a 15–minute walk away. How each parking lot represents a wasted opportunity, because there are no services there, and nobody lives there either.

I guess I’m confused why people wouldn’t want this. Walking through empty car parks is unpleasant, and discouraging people from doing it, and it’s obviously not benefiting drivers either. I’m lucky enough to live in place where I can walk to shops, parks, cafes, transport etc etc within 15-20mins, and do so under cover of trees, surrounded by green, and without crossing roads due to well designed pedestrian facilities. This is all in a medium built area, and leads to wonderful quality of life. Why wouldn’t people want to live like this?

Visiting the U.S. I’m honestly bamboozled that people seem to want live surrounded by car parks, having to drive from place to place, because walking is almost impossible. Not just due to car parks, but also because the boundaries between car parks and businesses seemed to be designed to prevent foot traffic. The U.S. strange belief that good walkability is something that can’t happen in the U.S. for reasons, is right up there with the U.S. belief that effective gun control can’t be implemented in U.S. for reasons, or trains and public transport can’t be implemented in the U.S. for reasons either.

All off strikes me as weird given how much evidence that these thing can work in a country like the U.S., with plenty of that evidence existing in the U.S. own past! There’s an old quote attributed to Churchill that I think summarises my views very succinctly “You can depend upon the Americans to do the right thing. But only after they have exhausted every other possibility.”. I look forward to the day the U.S. has exhausted every other possibility, no doubt they’ll learn plenty of valuable lessons for everyone else along the way.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by wilg on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:54PM (#37374464)
Nobody in this thread is disagreeing with you, and in fact, a vast majority of Americans do want walkable cities according to this survey I just googled: https://www.nar.realtor/newsroom/new-nar-survey-finds-americ...

GP is just pointing out its interesting our tolerance for long walks seems to have decreased, which is not a commonly discussed factor. Also that pedestrian safety is not necessarily why people do not want to walk. (I agree with this, I don't think average people think about it at all. Though I do think they think about it for bikes.) Perhaps lowering costs of car transport or increased comfort or something like that contributed.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by db48x on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:31PM (#37385755)
Correct.

However, I do partly disagree with avianlyric:

> I guess I’m confused why people wouldn’t want this. > Visiting the U.S. I’m honestly bamboozled that people seem to want…

It is very parochial to believe that everyone will want the same things as you.

Some people want open fields of wildflowers, farmland, pastures, creeks, shady forests, mountain paths, and perhaps a few neighbors. You can’t get any of that in an urban area. Yes, you might find parks and shaded avenues in a nice urban area, but those are a far cry from real nature.

Many others want to live in a suburban area. They want everything within 15 minutes walk of them to be a school, or a church, or a neighbor’s house. They want to sit in the back yard with a cold drink on a hot day and hear children playing near by, with the drone of a lawn mower in the distance. They want to build a deck there in the back yard, and invite their friends over for dinner on that deck. They want to plant an oak tree when they move in, and one day hang a rope swing from it for their grandchildren to swing on.

For these people, driving to a grocery store and parking in parking lots are just things they put up with in order to get what they really want.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:24PM (#37394011)
> It is very parochial to believe that everyone will want the same things as you.

I appreciate the point you make, and I certainly don’t believe that everyone wants the same things I do.

But I also think that it’s false dichotomy to say you can either have walkability or you can have cars and car parks. That’s simply not true.

The Netherlands has plenty of fantastic examples of cities, towns, villages, business parks and industrial areas that are all friendly to pedestrians and bikes, and not just endless slabs of asphalt. Plentiful public transport, that makes it easy to get anywhere without a car. I personally don’t accept the idea that cars are essential for people to have options in their living environments, to say they are just strikes me as an immense lack of imagination.

> For these people, driving to a grocery store and parking in parking lots are just things they put up with in order to get what they really want.

Your point here would carry more weight, if it was legal in the U.S. to build anything except huge empty suburbs, with soulless car park shops miles away. US planning law simply doesn’t allow any other form of building, so people can’t choose anything else. There are obviously small fragments of the U.S. that buck this trend, built before modern planning laws, but there’s so much demand for them, only the wealthiest can afford to live there.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by db48x on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:58PM (#37400861)
>> For these people, driving to a grocery store and parking in parking lots are just things they put up with in order to get what they really want.

> Your point here would carry more weight, if it was legal in the U.S. to build anything except huge empty suburbs, with soulless car park shops miles away.

This is completely and utterly false. Any laws governing what can and cannot be built are entirely _local_. There are no laws that govern construction on a national scale, or even a state–wide scale.

And you are the one that judges a suburb to be “empty”, and the parking lots to be “soulless”. That is just your opinion; not everyone shares it. The majority of people in America prefer suburbs precisely because it maximizes the type of neighborhood that they want and choose to live in.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @01:30PM (#37408233)
The US use a zoning systems almost to the exclusion of any form of planning system, and pretty simple zoning systems at that. As a general rule the zoning systems simply don't allow mix used zones, you simply can't build a shop or business in a residential area. As a consequence you force a design where shops and homes must be kept physically separated, and usually with a significant distance between them.

Are there exceptions to these patterns? Of course there are, but a general rule, zoning with no mixed used land areas is the only allowed development pattern.

> The majority of people in America prefer suburbs precisely because it maximizes the type of neighborhood that they want and choose to live in.

What are you basing this on? Just because it dominant doesn't mean people want. Stupidly expensive healthcare bills are dominant in the US, do you think people want that?

Where mixed used developments exist in the US, demand far outstrips supply, resulting in crazy high house prices. Given the huge premium these developments command, you have ask the question, why doesn't more of it exist? People are willing to pay, so aren't other people taking that cash? Mixed used, walkable developments demand much higher $/sqft than suburban development does, and is cheaper to construct due to the density. So all the right market signals for medium and high density development exist, what's preventing the market from responding?

> And you are the one that judges a suburb to be “empty”, and the parking lots to be “soulless”. That is just your opinion; not everyone shares it

True, it's an opinion. But are you honestly trying to argue that Americans find parking lots soulful? I'm not sure what you find so exciting about a featureless slab of asphalt with some painted lines on it, but I've yet to encounter a parking lot with architectural protection, or awards for beauty.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by db48x on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @11:55PM (#37414573)
> The US use a zoning systems almost to the exclusion of any form of planning system, and pretty simple zoning systems at that. As a general rule the zoning systems simply don't allow mix used zones, you simply can't build a shop or business in a residential area. As a consequence you force a design where shops and homes must be kept physically separated, and usually with a significant distance between them.

Yes, this is true. But remember that these rules are not the same everywhere, and they are not imposed nationally. Cities and towns are largely free to choose their own zoning laws. In the 50s and 60s they overwhelmingly voted to change them to allow suburban areas, and a huge percentage of the population moved to those areas. They did this because _they wanted to live in a suburban environment_. They weren’t forced into it.

>> The majority of people in America prefer suburbs precisely because it maximizes the type of neighborhood that they want and choose to live in.

> What are you basing this on? Just because it dominant doesn't mean people want. Stupidly expensive healthcare bills are dominant in the US, do you think people want that?

Don’t be ridiculous; of course nobody voted for higher medical bills. During the war, employers were largely prohibited from raising salaries to attract employees, so they had to resort to perks like medical insurance instead. After the war the practice became nearly universal. Higher prices for medical services was an _unintended consequence_ of that change.

Meanwhile people voted for suburban zoning _because they wanted it_. It wasn’t an unintended consequence, it was the _intended_ consequence.

> Where mixed used developments exist in the US, demand far outstrips supply, resulting in crazy high house prices.

This is true today, but remember that we are talking about nearly 80 years of change here since the war. In the 80s and 90s demand for mixed–use development was super low. People had moved out of urban areas by the tens of millions, and very few wanted to move back. _Today_ there is much more interest, as generational changes kick in.

My Grandfather on my father’s side came back from the Pacific theater, purchased a farm, and raised 9 children. This was not for lack of skill or education either; he wanted peace above all else. After a couple of decades or so he sold the farm and moved to a suburban area in a small town, where he took a job as an electrical engineer at a hydroelectric power plant.

To house all of the children he raised the new house by a whole story, dug out a basement below it (the house was on a hill, so that eliminated about half of the digging), then built a whole bunch of bedrooms down there plus a really nice workbench.

His children (my Aunts and Uncles), had a lot more interest in travel and adventure than he did (having gotten his fill during the war), but they all lived in quiet suburban areas, not urban ones. Among the many many grandchildren there are some who live in bustling cities with nightlife, but not all of them.

>> And you are the one that judges a suburb to be “empty”, and the parking lots to be “soulless”. That is just your opinion; not everyone shares it

> True, it's an opinion. But are you honestly trying to argue that Americans find parking lots soulful?

Seriously? Are you deliberately misreading what I wrote? I said that most people _don’t care_ about parking lots, and I meant it. A parking lot is neither a positive nor a negative aspect of life; it's just a place you spend a few minutes at before and after you do your weekly grocery shopping. The rest of the time it never enters people’s thoughts. Home is the important place that people think about; parking lots don’t matter.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Thursday September 07, 2023 @03:58AM (#37415982)
> Meanwhile people voted for suburban zoning because they wanted it. It wasn’t an unintended consequence, it was the intended consequence.

Ah I understand your point better now. But I would position that people at the time probably didn’t completely understand what they were giving up when they instituted those laws. I’m not trying to claim they were stupid or ignorant, suburban style land development simply wasn’t possible before then, and I can why that lifestyle would be seductive if the consequences of such development simply weren’t known.

> People had moved out of urban areas by the tens of millions, and very few wanted to move back. Today there is much more interest, as generational changes kick in.

I think to claim it’s just generational change (which suggest the change is a bit of a fad) is overly reductive. Instead I would argue the consequences, and costs, of suburban sprawl are now much better understood, and its long term unsustainability is becoming apparent. Ultimately a mono-culture, whether in biology or in land development tends to result in bad outcomes, and current U.S. planning doctrine enforces an unhealthy monoculture.

> His children (my Aunts and Uncles), had a lot more interest in travel and adventure than he did (having gotten his fill during the war), but they all lived in quiet suburban areas, not urban ones. Among the many many grandchildren there are some who live in bustling cities with nightlife, but not all of them.

Again there are more flavour of land development and residential design than suburbia, or city. They represent two extreme ends of scale, if you only give people a choice of two extremes, you shouldn’t be surprised when you end up with two large clusters of behaviour.

> Seriously? Are you deliberately misreading what I wrote?

Hey! You’re the one that wrote

> and the parking lots to be “soulless”. That is just your opinion; not everyone shares it

The opposite of soulless is soulful. You claim that not everyone shares my view, which by necessity means you make the argument that some people find parking lots soulful.

> it. A parking lot is neither a positive nor a negative aspect of life; it's just a place you spend a few minutes at before and after you do your weekly grocery shopping. The rest of the time it never enters people’s thoughts.

That’s kind of the point. Parking lots take huge slabs of potential useful land, and make it almost useless be design. Sure nobody thinks about a parking lot, to say that means their existence is inconsequential is foolish and completely the huge opportunity cost. That thoughtless nothingness could have been a field, an open park or some other productive public amenity. Hell just leave it as unmaintained grass, it massively improves water and runoff management. Instead it’s a slab of asphalt, with its huge negative externalities in the form of contributing to urban heat islanding, increased rain runoff in drains, and reduced water holding capacity on the ground below. Parking lots aren’t free and without consequence, they contribute plenty in turning a potential lush green area into a lifeless desert.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bandrami on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:57AM (#37370044)
Drivers back then sat at half the height above the road compared to now, and their forward viewspace was about half again as big as it is now.

Big cars kill pedestrians.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by xcskier56 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @09:32AM (#37370297)
You missed a bridge in your map! There’s another random pedestrian bridge over 394 near Louisiana. Connects some strip malls to a Burger King and car dealership. I finally used it when I went for a run to pick up my car from the dealer
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by tylervigen on Sunday September 03, 2023 @12:00PM (#37371449)
Actually skipping those two was intentional! They were built in the 1990s, but I was specifically looking for pedestrian bridges built in the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s. The reasons for building bridges seemed to shift over the decades, so I wanted to focus in on the ones built in the same era as the interstates were being built out.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by impetus21 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @03:33PM (#37373582)
I have a few ghost mine stories I would like to dig deeper on, but the people who worked on the tunnels, are dead. I would like to connect and see if I can't learn more. Anywho, this is inspirational and good shooting, tex.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by caf on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @05:37PM (#37398110)
The question I was left with at the end was: is the Catholic school still there at the church? If so, do the students still walk/ride to school using the bridge?