News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by justincormack on Saturday September 02, 2023 @02:59PM (#37364429)
There were fascinating protests against footbridges when first created in London, as the people felt they were losing their priority against the car. I copied out these notes from the book Leadville about the history of the A40 and the building of the first footbridge here https://www.flickr.com/photos/justincormack/256217251

The Bridge of Fools, the first footbridge over a road in Britain

In 1938 the inhabitants started to protest about the rising death toll on Western Avenue, the "Avenue of Speed and Death". They petitioned the Ministry of Transport to impose a speed limit of twenty-five or thirty miles an hour. The ministry said that would be an "ingenious provision" to save lives, but it would be against "the whole object of constructing a road free from congested traffic".

On 21 July 1938 the protestors filed across Western Avenue from the Approach, and then back, causing a huge tailback. The next day the Ministry arranged to build two bridges, one here and one by Gipsy Corner, much to the disgust of the protestors, who thought it would encourage cars to drive faster and to force pedestrians off more roads onto bridges and subways. A week later a thousand people demonstrated again for "their right to cross on the level".

In September the hastily erected bridge was complete, and five hundred people demonstrated against it again. The bridge became a tourist attraction and it was "quite usual to see people from other districts coming to look at it".

In October torchlight processions were held on the road every evening for a week, with a dog with a red light attached to it and four bearers carrying a coffin, and placards saying "We want crossings not coffins".

The war brought and end to the protests, and for a few years the traffic.

from Leadville: A Biography of the A40 by Edward Platt

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @04:50PM (#37365413)
Sounds like the kind of hypocrisy you'd hear from "urbanists" today: Complain about pedestrian deaths, then complain about a thing that prevents them.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bombcar on Saturday September 02, 2023 @10:27PM (#37367205)
It’s amusing how nobody complains about pedestrian infrastructure over and under trains.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by growse on Sunday September 03, 2023 @03:07AM (#37368334)
Isn't that because most people understand that trains don't drive on sight?

Railways are for trains, roads are for people.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:48AM (#37368816)
Except of course that roads are NOT for people. But you knew that.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by defrost on Sunday September 03, 2023 @04:57AM (#37368858)
Who were they for then?

Recall the context, please:

    the first footbridge over a road in Britain
a country with a network of roads 2,000+ years old.

And who were those roads for? Armies to march on.

You know, armies of people.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by bombcar on Sunday September 03, 2023 @07:58AM (#37369688)
Everyone forgets the horse and its carts and carriages.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:31PM (#37384720)
Great. Stick to the ancient roads while you're walking, and you should be fine.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by defrost on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @08:01AM (#37390552)
If you're not comfortable with an answer to a question that you posed then perhaps you need to be more careful with your ill thought rhetoricals.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:25AM (#37369853)
Roads existed long before the motor vehicle did, the Romans were famous for them. And last I checked most people use roads to transport themselves, their not domain of empty cars driving themselves around.

In the civilised world, which the UK is part of, pedestrian have unlimited right of way and priority on all roads, except highways. Motor vehicles are guests, it just seems that drivers believe wrapping themselves in tons of metal gives them the right to bully and brutalise other road users with impunity.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ShadowBanThis01 on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:29PM (#37384702)
"it just seems that drivers believe wrapping themselves in tons of metal gives them the right to bully and brutalise other road users with impunity."

It seems that way to people projecting their hysterical delusions on everyone else.

And, again, we all know that modern roads are for vehicles and not PEDESTRIANS, (since you pretend to need it spelled out). That's why we have sidewalks.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @12:29PM (#37394103)
> It seems that way to people projecting their hysterical delusions on everyone else.

Are you telling me I was having a hysterical delusion last week when a driver chased me down and deliberately used their car to smash me into the side of a lorry, hospitalising me for a week? If so, you should really tell my local police, because they need to release the guy that hit me.

> And, again, we all know that modern roads are for vehicles and not PEDESTRIANS, (since you pretend to need it spelled out). That's why we have sidewalks.

Again, in the civilised world pedestrians have universal rights to use the road, and can use pavements at their discretion. From your language it seems you’ve yet to visit.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by xorcist on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:43AM (#37369973)
Most of them are. Horses came much later.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by buran77 on Sunday September 03, 2023 @05:56AM (#37369094)
If you look at it superficially - everything is people transport - it can look hypocritical. But the issue is with the externalities each of those apparently equivalent decisions create. Cars and trains are certainly not that similar beyond "transporting people".

A drug den isn't a hospital just because drugs are administered there. A diesel and an EV are not the same just because they only differ in fuel source. You treat them differently, you try to encourage the positive externalities and discourage the negative ones.

Some people have seen it coming a long time ago that as a society we are encouraging cars and their infrastructure too much and among other things we're giving up some (maybe too much?) individual freedom in favor of them. And wouldn't you know it, a century later we're aiming at making cities walkable again, even banning cars entirely in some areas, as proof that society is realizing those concerns weren't at all hypocritical.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by masfuerte on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:23AM (#37369829)
Yes we do. There are pedestrian level crossings in the UK but because there is the very occasional fatality they are increasingly replaced by bridges. This is a huge inconvenience for the vast majority of us who are capable of looking both ways and we do complain about it.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by eCa on Sunday September 03, 2023 @07:06PM (#37375485)
Ever heard the saying ”wrong side of the tracks”?
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Sunday September 03, 2023 @08:16AM (#37369791)
Why should pedestrians be forced to clamber over bridges for the convenience of drivers?

Drivers are the one with huge mechanical advantage, make them go up and down, don’t force the local pedestrians who live in the to take huge detour, just so drivers from out of town can save 30 seconds.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by ensignavenger on Sunday September 03, 2023 @09:30PM (#37376312)
Those are good points, but the simple argument to the contrary is a matter of cost. It costs a whole lot less to build afoot bridge over a road that to build a road bridge over a foot path.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by avianlyric on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:54AM (#37378183)
Yes cost is the obvious elephant in the room. But ultimately all these things come down to priorities. Do we prioritise building human scale environments that are welcoming and pleasant to people, or do bulldoze that for car scale places that are hostile and unpleasant for people, unless they’re wrapped in tons of metal?

Turning all of spaces in car centric spaces also has cost, it’s just less obvious. Many time building that car bridge is cheaper for a government, if it helps keep people out of cars, and removes the huge number of negative externalities that car ownership brings.

Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by account42 on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @04:53AM (#37389382)
The cost of building the structure is hardly the only cost involved. Either solution means a cost or benefit to the two different groups that you can't just ignore away.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by JambalayaJim on Sunday September 03, 2023 @01:32PM (#37372246)
Bridges are still very real obstacles to people in wheelchairs, bikes, with strollers or shopping carts, or just mobility impaired in general.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by IIsi50MHz on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @10:18PM (#37400670)
True generally, although many Tokyo pedestrian bridges have narrow ramp space reserved adjacent to the steps so that people with bicycles can walk them up to or down from bridge level with considerably less difficulty than if only steps were provided. The remaining cases are not addressed in these designs, though.
Re:The Mystery of the Bloomfield Bridge by Reason077 on Saturday September 02, 2023 @05:35PM (#37365730)
The speed limit was indeed reduced, in 2020, to 30 mph on the elevated eastern section of the A40 (Westway), but remains 40 mph on the Western Avenue part.