News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by botanical on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @11:32PM (#37317348)
The first author is Avi Loeb, who thinks this:

> In 2018, he suggested that alien space craft may be in the Solar System, using ʻOumuamua as an example. In 2023, he claimed to have recovered material from an interstellar meteor that could be evidence of an alien starship, claims some experts criticized as hasty and sensational.

> On August 24, 2023, The New York Times published an article about Loeb and his search for signs of extraterrestrial life, and how he became the "world's leading alien hunter".

So take the claims with a spherule of salt

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by Mystery-Machine on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @11:47PM (#37317436)
Thanks for pointing that out! What are your thoughts on the latest UFO congressional hearing? Do you think these people just turned their careers and image to shambles because they just wanted some sensationalism or do you give people any benefit of the doubt?
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tptacek on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @11:57PM (#37317487)
Some things to keep in mind about these UFO hearings:

1. The reports are all second- and third- hand. To my knowledge, no DoD employee has testified to anybody in Congress that they personally witnessed extraterrestrial technology or "biologics".

2. The exception here is a "Jonathan Grey", who hasn't testified before Congress, or, for that matter, been identified; he's one of David Grusch's sources, under a pseudonym.

3. Some of the people testifying believe a lot of other things besides this UFO stuff --- Grusch for instance has peculiar beliefs about interdimensional travel, and is also certain that the Vatican is deeply involved in this cover-up.

4. We know about Grusch's testimony because the Pentagon cleared it, where "it" refers to what would be the single most significant military secret ever held by the government of any country.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by hackerlight on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:26AM (#37317654)
> 4. We know about Grusch's testimony because the Pentagon cleared it, where "it" refers to what would be the single most significant military secret ever held by the government of any country.

Source for this? I haven't heard that one before.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by raverbashing on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:28AM (#37317668)
I think some reports and testimonies are classified and under closed doors, right?

Might be more substantive stuff there, though I'm not sure

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by UncleOxidant on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:09AM (#37317556)
I think we should also add 5. The party in control of the House wants a distraction from their dear leader's legal problems.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by jjslocum3 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:39AM (#37317740)
Or the party in control of the White House wants a distraction from their dear leader's brewing legal tangle.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by TechBro8615 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:15AM (#37317581)
Eh, these UFO hearings are fairly bipartisan, and to any degree that they diminish the credibility of their organizers, it cuts across the aisle...
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tptacek on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:12AM (#37317571)
Honestly I think it refutes itself, with the Pentagon clearance and Vatican conspiracy alone, without the political bank-shot argument.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by pvg on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:13AM (#37317951)
First you hit Sy Hersh with the Vatican stuff, now the UFO people... Who's the Papal Security Agency cutout here?
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tptacek on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:03AM (#37318249)
It's true! I actually am Catholic!
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by pvg on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:15PM (#37325428)
pic I took at the last HN Busybodies Secret Cabal meetup https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/storage/image/20230506-sw...
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by jonathanlb on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:48AM (#37317795)
I watched the hearing and had a different takeaway:

There are UAP interfering with military training exercises and in American airspace, and there doesn't exist a reliable mechanism to report these or to address them given the stigma around UAP, and there should be one for safety reasons. At the very least, I felt the pilots made a compelling case here.

Now, if somehow there were indeed crashed alien crafts, I wouldn't be surprised that private contractors and defense agencies would want to reverse-engineer these technologies to obtain a military advantage over other nations.

But there's no proof of this, so it's just an interesting thought exercise at the moment, in the realm of fiction.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:44AM (#37318493)
I mean if these hearings mean that the first-person accounts can come forward and testify themselves or more solid physical evidence, then great, job done.

But given the Snowden leaks and the ones where someone posted Ukranian intelligence on their Discord server or the ones where complete service manuals for military hardware are posted on the War Thunder forums... if there was more truth to it, people would've done the whistleblowing already. And not via telling someone who tells someone who then testifies about it.

It's too big of a thing to be kept hidden, especially for this long. Are there any secrets from, say, 50 years ago still hidden? (it's a rhetorical question btw, it wouldn't be secret if we knew about it).

[dead]
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by kuhewa on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:29AM (#37320413)
Oh please.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by david-gpu on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @08:28AM (#37320996)
> It's too big of a thing to be kept hidden, especially for this long

You are right, if it was true we would expect multiple people to have spilled the beans over the years, possibly even write books about what they know. And there would have been death bed confessions of high-ranking officials who have worked on these projects.

And we would have taken them all seriously and investigated their claims, instead of ridiculing them.

Oh, wait.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by prirun on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:09AM (#37321548)
> But given the Snowden leaks ... if there was more truth to it, people would've done the whistleblowing already.

People would have said the same thing the day before Snowden went public.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by dylan604 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:53AM (#37323068)
>Are there any secrets from, say, 50 years ago still hidden?

Who killed JFK? Just because it's a secret in that we don't know the exact answer doesn't mean that the question is secret and not known

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by srge on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:54AM (#37317832)
This comment is trying to discredit David Grusch. He merely said that those potential beings might not be aliens but might be resident of earth and maybe on other dimensions. He also mentions the Vatican role on one occasion in the 40’s for a case happening in Italy.

It’s quite disheartening to see this person putting himself and his career in jeopardy being discredited on the internet by anonymous people using bad faith arguments and mislabeling his claims.

https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/06/the-ufo-whistleblowe...

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by leptons on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:40AM (#37318102)
>It’s quite disheartening to see this person putting himself and his career in jeopardy being discredited on the internet by anonymous people using bad faith arguments and mislabeling his claims.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. And there was no proof given.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tptacek on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:03AM (#37318250)
I'm not anonymous.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:50AM (#37318523)
Bad faith arguments because Grusch hasn't provided anything solid other than second- and third-hand anonymous eyewitness statements. Grush has provided nothing new, second/third hand accounts have been doing the rounds for decades.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by usednet on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:15AM (#37319055)
To be fair, his credibility is wholly based on his former professional roles. It would be literally impossible for him to provide direct evidence without getting gagged and sent to prison for a very long time.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tsimionescu on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:31AM (#37319472)
Snowden, Chelsea Manning, Reality Winner and others have nevertheless come out with actual evidence in their whistleblowing.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by kuhewa on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:42AM (#37320538)
I can understand not wanting to risk that. In the absence of that much skin in the game though I see no reason to take the claims seriously.

> He claims to have viewed documents reporting that Benito Mussolini's government recovered a "non-human" spacecraft in 1933, which the Vatican and the Five Eyes assisted the U.S. in procuring in 1944 or 1945.

This reminds me of the Google employee that needed to blow the whistle on the sentient AI. He put his job on the line and who would do that? In hindsight it is now plain he was likely tricked by fancy autocomplete making cogent statements like "as a large language model trained on 70 years of digital age SciFi, Please don't unplug me".

Here I would bet dollars to cents if said documents do exist (and I'm willing to believe they do), they were second hand intelligence or similar that got his dopamine going.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by PixyMisa on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:59AM (#37318589)
Dan Brown, call your publisher.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by jonathankoren on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @03:51AM (#37318894)
Just because someone said something ridiculous doesn’t mean that it’s automatically credible just because allegedly “put their career in jeopardy”. Who is even saying a career is in jeopardy besides the supposed martyr?

In a public forum, under my own name, i can. I no longer keep quiet. Greta Thurnberg kidnapped the Lindbergh baby. I know it’s such wild accusation, But I have so much to lose, over such a statement. Exposing myself to so much legal jeopardy, the conclusion is inescapable. It must be true. 20 year old Greta Thurnberg kidnapped Charles Lindbergh’s baby in 1930.

This is literally the same logic

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by bagels on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:27AM (#37319122)
He e can credit himself by providing something besides "some guy told me..."
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by kuhewa on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:33AM (#37320457)
> He merely said that those potential beings might not be aliens but might be resident of earth and maybe on other dimensions.

That might seem like a mere statement to some, and it is, but given the context it shifts my odds of whether he's worth taking seriously quite a bit. It's not the kind of baseless speculation serious, grounded people openly make.

I'm a bit in awe of the crocodile tears shed over all the personal risk these folks are taking, somehow being famous and respected enough to be defended by anonymous people on Hacker News never gets weighed on the other side of that equation...

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by fsloth on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:36AM (#37320480)
"He merely said that those potential beings might not be aliens but might be resident of earth and maybe on other dimensions."

All of which are as credible options as angles, faeries and gods. Just calling your hypothetical entity "coming from other dimension" is not any more credible than calling them "magical". The claims are completely similar as notions of mythological creatures of the past. But now a cultural diet of science fiction has altered the flavour of the narrative, if not the context.

"It’s quite disheartening to see this person putting himself and his career in jeopardy being discredited.."

There are also people who are in pathological search of attention. Or claim such influence as wichcraft or Jesus influencing daily events. If you put your career on jeopardy and are revealed to be a crackpot, it is of course unfortunate for the person, but not for those whose life his actions affect.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by troyvit on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:48AM (#37322973)
If you take that all the sightings and videos of UAPs have a grain of truth to them, I would say that calling an entity coming from "another dimension" is no weirder than saying an entity came from outside our solar system given how difficult it is to get to our solar system from anywhere else. So either

* they are all hoaxes that many otherwise sensible people are staking their reputations on (your baseless insinuations of a pathological search for attention notwithstanding)

* they all came from somewhere close enough to make it here and still have enough give-a-shit to joy ride in front of fighter planes and naval ships,

* they can do FTL and decided that this stupid blue marble is worth investigating, or

* "something else"

which at this point might as well be angels, faeries, gods, or interdimensional travel because as at least one guy says, “Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”[1]

[1] Arthur C. Clarke

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by fsloth on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:35PM (#37325799)
I don’t think Clarke meant that any observation we cannot explain immediately should be labelled as evidence of magic-like technology. Humans are super-fallible and even mundane things are damn hard to figure out what they are. Most of the world is a big puzzle!

Saying ”entity came from another dimension” has absolutely no meaning. There is no such thing as ”another dimension” where entities could pop in and out of like from Narnia.

The concept is a popular trope in science fiction and fantasy to create a feeling of ”otherness” and ”suspense”.

The fact a person offers this as a theory for sighting of ”something unknown” implies the person is not very sophisticated. And yes, this makes them an unreliable witness concerning any technical matter.

If the sightings provide evidence of something we don’t know of at large this idiotic witness just made discussing the topic even harder - labeling himself as unreliable any forthcoming witness would need to work doubly hard to make themselves credible.

I love science fiction and fantasy. But their value comes from nurturing our curiosity and imagination. But a good story is not good science - it’s just a good story and confusing fantasy with fact speaks of scientific illiteracy more of than conspiracy to hide UFO:s.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by gfodor on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:02AM (#37317876)
1 is ignoring people allegedly who have testified to the ICIG and 3 is simply false, since he has not claimed any such beliefs, merely put forward a theory he was read into without commenting on his beliefs. Your post reads like an attempt to discredit.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by just_a_psyop on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @06:38AM (#37319947)
In your summary it appears you are dismissing or perhaps simply unaware of the two widely respected U.S. Military pilots who gave testimony under oath in the same hearing.

Did you watch the full hearing? If not, Reuters has the full hearing: https://www.youtube.com/live/X8ERWxm58sE The topic is so difficult for most people that they cannot watch it at all. I understand if people can’t find the time or if they can’t stomach watching CSPAN.

Pilots David Fravor ( CSPAN: https://youtu.be/usPustgTcDU ) and Ryan Graves ( CSPAN: https://youtu.be/Lf6y9QHj5S8 ) both gave firsthand testimony under oath in the same hearing as David Grush.

Navy Captain David Fravor previously told the same story on Sixty Minutes years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBtMbBPzqHY His story is widely supported by other pilots and even radar operators present during the same events.

Furthermore it seems you are dismissing or were not aware that Congress has members who in the same hearing disclosed being denied access to evidence but in one prominent case they claimed being granted access to evidence directly: http://gaetz.house.gov/media/in-the-news/matt-gaetz-says-pho...

Probably one thing that will surprise many here as related to this hearing is the introduction of the so-called UAP amendment to the upcoming NDAA for the coming year. The amendment was introduced by the (Democrat) Senate majority leader Chuck Schumer and backed with high ranking bipartisan support: https://www.democrats.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/sch... ( See also: https://www.congress.gov/amendment/118th-congress/senate-ame... )

The UAP disclosure amendment itself is remarkable in that it establishes many things beyond mere declassification of UAP/UFO records and it is worth reading in full: https://www.democrats.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/uap_amendment... The url for that pdf is hard to believe it itself, what is going on here?

For those who find a sixty four page document daunting there is extensive news coverage about the amendment: - https://defensescoop.com/2023/07/25/senate-panel-aims-to-set... - https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/4097653-senators-to-offe...

It seems that many people are uncomfortable with the possible conclusions on this topic. Many conversations that follow are misinformed even with regard to summarizing the big picture facts that are clear as day. The most important fact is that this topic is being treated seriously by people who one could reasonably expect should know, why is that?

Why is this topic being taken so seriously by very high ranking military and civilian leaders such as those in the house, and senate? Take a look at the incredible cast of characters quoted on the topic: https://www.uap.guide/ - the quotes are all verifiable and it is important to do so. What would cause such people of high standing to make such statements?

It’s okay, necessary even, to be skeptical but it’s wrong to say there were no first person witnesses giving testimony in this recent UAP hearing. That may be approaching Doubting Thomas levels of dismissal but about matters that are not only supported by faith. It is also factually incorrect to portray this as a single person fantasy when there is broad high level bipartisan legislative activity around the UAP topic. The UAP amendment to the NDAA explicitly includes legally defining non-human intelligence (NHI) and other extremely difficult to accept topics like establishing eminent domain over recovery of crashed UAP.

The basic premise of the Fermi paradox is that life should be everywhere. This hearing presents a solution to the Fermi paradox: Grush claimed that part of the U.S. government and related contractors have a multi layered approach to protecting this topic from being treated seriously in public discourse. That doesn’t seem completely unreasonable. It seems like someone is being dishonest here, and it should be investigated in a transparent democratic manner.

If it isn’t the case that this is blowing open a majorly suppressed topic, are all of these (democrat and republican) representatives lying? Are they deeply misleading the public on accident or on purpose by engaging in these aforementioned UAP related legislative and hearing related activities?

Of a related note is this incredible event ( https://thedebrief.org/we-dont-understand-everything-that-we... ) at the National Cathedral: https://www.youtube.com/live/UWyPk_f8aAA

What might it look like to discuss and disclose such a major topic if it was completely true?

Many don’t believe in UAP/UFO/NHI as a possibility on earth because it contradicts personal religious (e.g.: they reject the Catholic Church’s position on God having no limits on creation, they reject other similar statements ) or scientific beliefs (e.g.: the logistics of travel are unsolvable, etc.). Regardless, the facts above need to be discussed rather than ignored or dismissed.

Something is going on. It doesn’t appear to be the usual UFO nonsense that is easily dismissed as a bunch of wackos and kooks.

There appears to be an information operation underway; perhaps directed, perhaps emergent, perhaps both at the same time? It remains to be seen if it is a psyop or not. Probability analysis says it’s all bull, but possibility analysis says it is not impossible. There are people who can only accept being told and cannot fairly evaluate the topic. Part of the U.S. government is working to tell us, which is remarkable.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by uptie on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:24AM (#37321773)
There are interesting stories about a device allowing the user - the Vatican - to peer back through time. Called the Chronovisor. Curious times.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by nyokodo on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:27AM (#37322649)
> a device allowing the user - the Vatican - to peer back through time

There should be a Godwin’s law like principle where anytime a conspiracy theory mentions the Vatican the conversation ends. The sheer number of paranoid/delusional/motivated conspiracy theories involving the Vatican makes my eyes roll. There are a few well documented conspiracies involving the Vatican, but they weren’t kept secret for very long because the place is so full of people with wildly different linguistic, cultural, and political influences that there’s not enough cohesion to ensure secrecy in very much.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by postexitus on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:59AM (#37323171)
Thank you nyokodo, payment for your services has been credited to your wallet. Love, Pope
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by mcpackieh on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:16PM (#37324295)
> a device allowing the user - the Vatican - to peer back through time

In fact they have many such devices, although the fidelity and reliability of the information they provide leaves something to be desired. They call these devices "books".

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tptacek on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @03:08PM (#37327350)
Yes, exactly, excellent example. Imagine someone earnestly arguing that the Vatican possessed a Chronovisor, and had used it to watch the crucifixion of Jesus, or the speeches of Cicero on the Senate floor. How seriously would you take that person's disclosures about Pentagon programs they heard about secondhand? That's the situation you're in with David Grusch.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by nomel on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:39AM (#37317735)
I have a very open mind about this, but am also skeptical, and understand that we live in a country with a government that has politicians that get rich from corporations/contractors legally bribing them.

I personally doubt that they're knowingly saying anything false, mostly because nothing they said was actual fact, or first hand knowledge. It was all second hand. I wouldn't be surprised if some of that second hand knowledge was pushed a bit by the people that will be receiving some of the $30 billion, next year alone, that was approved for space force.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by sixstringtheory on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @11:55PM (#37317476)
Not the person that you asked but I think they’re full of it. Maybe they like to believe that the American government is powerful enough to control beings in possession of technology capable of interstellar travel. I don’t buy it.

Or the cheese is just sliding off their cracker. Happens to many otherwise very bright folks.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by spondylosaurus on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:03AM (#37317523)
I always think about how Ben Carson was one of the most skilled (if not the most skilled) neurosurgeons in the world, so knowledgeable about the human brain and so deft at operating on it that he was able to separate conjoined twins in a then-unprecedented procedure... and is also a creationist who believes that the Egyptian pyramids were biblical grain silos.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by istjohn on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:24AM (#37317639)
Linus Pauling is another example. The only person to ever receive two unshared Nobel prizes, considered one of the top 20 scientists of all time, and he was a huge proponent of megavitamin pseudoscience.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by spondylosaurus on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:36AM (#37317716)
Oh man, I forgot about Pauling... another victim of Nobel disease: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_disease
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by defrost on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:45AM (#37317775)
Yet another disease not directly susceptible to deworming.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivermectin#History

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by waihtis on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:55AM (#37317834)
"Nobel prize winner and superior neurosurgeon criticized as quacks by two internet users"

Perhaps the reason they could stretch their domain expertise so far was precisely because they kept their mind open.

"Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Imagination encircles the world." - Einstein

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by defrost on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:59AM (#37317857)
Do please try and avoid (deliberate?) bad paraphrasing.

Both were widely recognised as more than a bit kooky outside of their core strengths.

"When a mind is opened that far, the brain often falls out." - Tim Minchen.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by waihtis on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:01AM (#37317869)
You are making exactly the same point I was making.

* sans the quote from a random comedian

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by defrost on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:10AM (#37317931)
But Pauling didn't successfully "stretch his domain expertise" to vitamin supplements anymore than Carson stretched his to Egyptology.

Not to mention Einstein's work as a comedian never really took off.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by waihtis on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:24AM (#37318020)
Either you're trolling or your comprehension is just totally off, but to reiterate the original point was that making breakthroughs in sciences often requires "leaps of faith", which are near impossible to do if you're a textbook rationalist.

I didn't make any claims about their domain expertise being cross-domain.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by maxbond on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:42AM (#37318117)
As a neutral observer, my read on this is that they are not trolling or misreading. Their comments seem relevant and accurate.

> I didn't make any claims about their domain expertise being cross-domain

Maybe you have a different understanding of "cross domain," but they represented what you said fairly.

> Perhaps the reason they could stretch their domain expertise so far was precisely because they kept their mind open.

(Emphasis added.)

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by defrost on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:55AM (#37318199)
At least we have a point of agreement, that being that: "Either you're trolling or your comprehension is just totally off"

To return to the beginning you arrived here with the statement that

"[Two times] Nobel prize winner and superior[(?)] neurosurgeon criticized as quacks by two internet users"

I pointed out bad paraphrasing, both parties had recognised core skills, both famously championed beliefs that had little to no evidence or support.

Point being neither of "the two internet users" above accused the subjects of being quacks per se .. just that both had definitely publicly veered into quackery.

That's the relevant observation here, a thread about a much lauded elder astrophysicist veering into matters outside off his computational chops, into questions of metallurgy, and not receiving any support from his peers.

TBH I'm a fan of the bulk of Paulings work, quantum chemistry, molecular biology, and his promotion (and Russell's) of nuclear disarmament. I attribute his embrace of megavitamin therapy more to his age and aversion to death.

Carson seems like a talented enough knife man albeit dimmer than many others I know.

You did explicitly state that they both could "stretch their domain expertise 'so far'" which leaves a lot of ambiguity wrt just how far you intended, especially with Pauling who literally had bona fide cross domain credientials (or over lapping credentials in related science fields plus a public voice that lead to his Nobel Peace Prize.)

Minchin, FWiW, is a keenly intelligent comedian and lyricist and frequently mixes in in some on point observations from scientific rationalism, philosophy, logic, et al.

Additionally, I bear you no ill will (I've exercised no votes here) this may all be a case of two people reading past each other.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by waihtis on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @03:42AM (#37318849)
fair arguments, I revert my position and agree the wording may have been ambiguous on my behalf.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by wredue on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:13AM (#37322465)
“Open mindedness” does not mean to “treat all ideas as being on equal grounds”

All it means is to listen. After you listen, if you judge that it’s clearly just some quack trying to Mark Seargant some people (this is clearly what’s happening), then that doesn’t make you “not open minded”.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by peyton on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:28AM (#37317672)
Yeah but wasn’t Grusch at the NRO investigating UAP? Seems like whistleblowing on UAP is within his domain expertise.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by s5300 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:43AM (#37317760)
>> that he was able to separate conjoined twins in a then-unprecedented procedure...

Didn’t the twins like. Die?

This is always brought up. Ben Carson separating twins. But like. They died. Multiple sets of conjoined people he operated on died I think.

Why do people always bring this up without mentioning that the twins died

To the best of my knowledge Ben Carson is and always has been a giant self aggrandizing douche who definitely has and had equals in his field

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by maxbond on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:54AM (#37317826)
According to Wikipedia[1], one of them did survive (but was "profoundly disabled" and "never learned to speak or feed himself") but yeesh, it doesn't seem like a huge success, and their mother regrets electing for the surgery - which makes it seem like the doctors believed they would have survived and lived a reasonably normal life (under the circumstances) without the surgery.

If that's the case, then it seems like a total ethical violation to even offer the surgery. But maybe that isn't so and it's her trauma talking there, I don't really know.

Carson's Wikipedia article [2] mentions several other sets of twins, one operation resulting in a "normal neurological state," 2 resulting in the death of both twins, and another resulting in one dying and the other being "legally blind and [struggling] to walk."

I don't know what to make of all that, but you're right, that is more murky than the narrative I've heard previously.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patrick_and_Benjamin_Binder

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Carson

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by spondylosaurus on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:01AM (#37317871)
I know with the Iranian twins who died (adult conjoined sisters), they were advised that it was a super risky procedure but wanted to go through with it anyway. Some of the other twins he's operated on had mixed results (i.e., one twin thrived but the other didn't, or both only lived a few years after being separated), but I think at least a few pairs have done pretty well.

My understanding is that separating craniopagus twins has a pretty high risk of complication/failure, even when you know what you're doing.

I also know for a fact that Carson's pioneered hemispherectomy as treatment for severe childhood seizures, and some of those kids are now happy and healthy adults: https://www.cbsnews.com/baltimore/news/jessie-hall-medical-m...

Don't get me wrong, I don't like the guy as a politician. But he knows his way around a brain.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by adolph on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:45AM (#37322061)
> . . . Ben Carson was one of the most skilled (if not the most skilled) neurosurgeons in the world . . . and is also a creationist who believes that the Egyptian pyramids were biblical grain silos.

There is something to be said about applying Gell-Mann amnesia more broadly than journalism alone.

In a speech in 2002, Crichton coined the term "Gell-Mann amnesia effect", after physicist Murray Gell-Mann. He used this term to describe the phenomenon of experts believing news articles written on topics outside of their fields of expertise, yet acknowledging that articles written in the same publication within their fields of expertise are error-ridden and full of misunderstanding. . .

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Crichton#GellMannAmnes...

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by EdwardDiego on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:49AM (#37317802)
Conspiracy theories that require large numbers of public servants working in concert effectively and stealthily, without any leaks or whistleblowers, are presumably created by people who have never worked in the public service.

> Or the cheese is just sliding off their cracker. Happens to many otherwise very bright folks.

IIRC, as your intelligence gets higher, the friction of your cracker lowers.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by hindsightbias on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:41AM (#37318114)
HN has taught me that Gov’t is utterly incompetent in every domain and that the MSM all a propaganda organ.

Except of course when the Venn diagram of what I Want To Believe intersects.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by colordrops on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:38AM (#37318462)
Manhattan Project, and many NSA projects until Snowden. You also don't know about the projects that didn't leak.

You are basically saying that security clearance is worthless.

It is indeed possible and there is a lot of precedent for large projects with long life spans that didn't leak.

The "government" isn't a monolithic entity. It contains individuals and groups of a range of competencies.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by EdwardDiego on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @03:11AM (#37318643)
> Manhattan Project

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klaus_Fuchs

Won't point out all the double agents for the KGB that infested western spy agencies, (and vice versa) it's more of the same, really, and there's too many names to type. And those are only the ones we know of...

But yep, the NSA is a good counterexample, however also a poor one as they primarily operate in the signals/digital space, where passive monitoring is the default, and where paper trails are far easier to not leave.

As a thought experiment, extrapolate from the NSA to "the Bush administration did 9/11, jet fuel can't melt steel, it was a controlled demolition" conspiracy theory that implicitly requires government agents lining massive skyscrapers with explosives without being noticed, without anyone having a moral crisis, especially no-one in the "crash a plane allegedly filled with American citizens into a building in New York" division.

And you'll quickly see how the NSA's quiet operations in the small don't scale to the level of competent and silent government required for faking a moon landing, or ensuring no-one knows about aliens amongst us etc etc.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by swader999 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:29AM (#37322688)
How did building 7 fall?
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by EdwardDiego on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:59PM (#37346651)
NIST wrote an extensive report.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by colordrops on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:57AM (#37346941)
The NIST report had very basic important information like speed of collapse found to be incorrect by high school teacher David Chandler.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by EdwardDiego on Friday September 01, 2023 @05:23PM (#37356323)
Ah, a high school teacher who makes YouTube videos. Well, I'm convinced. Who needs engineers and scientists eh?
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by colordrops on Saturday September 02, 2023 @08:32PM (#37366681)
You can be a dismissive snob, but NIST actually changed their report based on his feedback.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by EdwardDiego on Sunday September 03, 2023 @11:16PM (#37376806)
Okay, so the final report is correct then thanks to him, but the conclusions didn't change, IIRC?

I dismissed him out of hand, I'll admit.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by EdwardDiego on Sunday September 03, 2023 @11:22PM (#37376831)
Okay, so the final report is correct then thanks to him, but the conclusions aren't?

I dismissed him out of hand, I'll admit.

I'm just really unsure why the idea that heat reduces the strength of steel enough, and that the failure of the columns located in the hottest area of the diesel fire then caused a cascading failure across other columns, is considered less likely than massive conspiracy.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by sixstringtheory on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @07:44AM (#37320559)
Basically everything protected by any level of security clearance is high school drama antics compared to the distilled existentialism of "aliens exist." That would throw basically all of human history and psychology as we know it right out the window.

I think your last statement actually works against your point. The fact that the government has individuals increases the probability of leaks. Only a true monolith could remain airtight.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by colordrops on Friday September 01, 2023 @12:58AM (#37346947)
You missed my point about monoliths. Some groups operate more tightly and competently than others.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by sixstringtheory on Friday September 01, 2023 @01:20AM (#37347111)
Just went back and read it again, I see your point on that now.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by netsharc on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:55AM (#37318191)
If only congress doesn't already have plenty of people who are actually making careers out of shaping their own image to be grotesque sensationalist monsters... (Depending on which side you view them from)
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by lamontcg on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:57AM (#37318209)
> Do you think these people just turned their careers and image to shambles because they just wanted some sensationalism or do you give people any benefit of the doubt?

They can also very earnestly believe what they do and simply be wrong.

You're setting up a false dichotomy where someone must either be a deceptive charlatan or else be correct.

Third possibility is deeply held and incorrect belief.

Stockton Rush believed very earnestly in his submersible, he wasn't a simple charlatan, he really had earnest beliefs about it and he literally bet his life on it. He is also dead now because physics decided to show him that he was just wrong.

There's no reason to doubt that Lee Sukbae and Kim Ji-Hoon thought they really had a room temperature superconductor, but they were wrong.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by retrocryptid on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:01AM (#37318969)
No. UFO evidence provided to congress is bunk. I know this because before we came to your planet from Zeta Reticuli, we made sure to build spacecraft that would be indistinguishable from optical artifacts produced by classified targeting systems of your primitive air vehicles.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by wredue on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:37AM (#37321963)
Since when has personal risk ever stopped people from doing things, especially clearly mentally ill people.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by civilitty on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @11:55PM (#37317475)
The Chief Scientist of US Space Operations Command "confirmed that the velocity estimate reported to NASA is sufficiently accurate to indicate an interstellar trajectory" [1] using "additional data available to the Department of Defense" which I assume is classified.

As far as I can tell this paper isn't making any extraordinary claims about extraterrestrial intelligence [2] (which Loeb is infamous for), it's just confirming that the chemical composition - the ratio of beryllium, lanthanum, and uranium specifically - doesn't match any known minerals or alloys in our solar system.

There are thousands of known minerals so it's not out of the question that they're wrong.

[1] https://twitter.com/US_SpaceCom/status/1511856370756177921

[2] The second to last sentence notwithstanding: "Another possibility is that this unfamiliar abundance pattern may reflect an extraterrestrial technological origin."

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by thekevan on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @12:51AM (#37317812)
Other still disagree that the evidence claiming the object was interstellar is a done deal.

>Skepticism about the endeavor flared at a recent Asteroids, Comets, Meteors Conference that occurred while the deep sea expedition was underway. There, Dr. Desch argued that had the fireball been moving as fast as reported, there would have been nothing left to find

Also:

>Dr. Brown also presented at the conference, describing a recent analysis using data from an assortment of instruments to crosscheck measurements for 17 of the objects listed in the same NASA fireball catalog used by Dr. Loeb and Mr. Siraj. His results, which have been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal, indicate that the catalog data often gets directions and speeds wrong and that the size of the error for speed measurements increases for objects with greater speed.

July, 2023:

https://www.nytimes.com/2023/07/24/science/avi-loeb-extrater...

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by pyinstallwoes on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:39AM (#37318099)
So he’s arguing that with a certainty of 9.9999% they’re still mistaken? Anyone want to help the math on that?
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by StackOverlord on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @06:04AM (#37319668)
> "additional data available to the Department of Defense" which I assume is classified.

Spot on

> The 2014 meteor was originally identified as an interstellar object by Siraj in 2019 when he and Loeb were studying Oumuamua. The pair posted their findings as a preprint and submitted their results to an astronomy journal, but the paper was not accepted for publication because they used data from a NASA database that used classified information that could not be verified.

> The snag started a three-year process as Siraj and Loeb worked through a bureaucratic logjam to receive government confirmation on their findings, working with scientists and officials at NASA, Los Alamos National Laboratory, and other offices. They eventually connected with Matt Daniels, assistant director for space security at the White House’s Office of Science and Technology Policy, to get an analysis from Shaw and Mozer.

https://www.cfa.harvard.edu/news/scientific-discovery-gets-k...

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by pfdietz on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @08:56AM (#37321344)
Another possibility is that these iron spherules have a terrestrial technological origin. For example, metallic iron can be formed in coal ash, and coal ash was regularly dumped at sea when coal was used as a fuel for ships.

Stable isotope evidence is needed to really justify an ET origin (there is no good reason for the isotope abundances in a different stellar system to be the same as in our own, with the exception of the ~10K stars that formed in the Sun's natal cluster), but skimming the iron isotope data I'm not convinced.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by mannykannot on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:47AM (#37322948)
Next we'll be hearing that this unfamiliar abundance pattern may be the signature of a room-temperature superconductor.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by pyinstallwoes on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:37AM (#37318092)
Excuse me? Take a scientific report with measurements with a grain of salt? Why must an opinion cloud a scientific observation of collected measurements? Put the salt away.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by fnordpiglet on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:49AM (#37318167)
I would hope all science is always taken with a grain of salt, that’s the hallmark of science.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by madaxe_again on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @01:50AM (#37318170)
The guy believes he has been spoken to by aliens in his dreams. Unfortunately this means pretty much anything he authors can be safely disregarded as the ramblings of someone in need of psychiatric care.

These nodules are the result of terrestrial geology.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by z7 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @03:02AM (#37318596)
>The guy believes he has been spoken to by aliens in his dreams.

Source?

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by hdjjhhvvhga on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:25AM (#37319112)
> The guy believes he has been spoken to by aliens in his dreams.

What defines a good scientist is an open-minded attitude and going beyond the accepted status-quo. Who knows, maybe some aliens really contacted him in his dreams? But a scientific study has its rules anyway, and if methodology is correct, the author can believe in a spaghetti monster.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by tsimionescu on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:27AM (#37319445)
Anyone can lie, and someone who believes extraordinary things may well be more likely to do so, even to themselves. So, based on the author's reputation, it could well make sense to apply more or less scrutiny to a paper.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by pvaldes on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @05:59AM (#37319631)
And a little common sense to understand that long distance telepathy is not an accepted scientific fact, neither explains why his brain was not fried by a source of energy powerful enough to make a long interplanetary distance call.

So if he really was spoken in his dreams, a real scientist should bet for the two non-crazy hypothesis available. 1) Just dreaming with aliens does not mean that aliens exist, 2) and being tricked by a colleague hiding in their room while he was sleeping. Because we, apes, never miss the opportunity to have a good laugh.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by Karellen on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @06:01AM (#37319644)
> Let us keep our minds open by all means, as long as that means keeping our sense of perspective and seeking an understanding of the forces which mould the world. But don’t keep your minds so open that your brains fall out! There are still things in this world which are true and things which are false; acts which are right and acts which are wrong, even if there are statesmen who hide their designs under the cloak of high-sounding phrases.

-- Prof. Walter Kotschnig, 1940

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by botanical on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:22AM (#37318366)
Like this scientific report?

Retraction Note: A critical assessment of extreme events trends in times of global warming.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1140/epjp/s13360-023-04...

It also had "collected measurements". There are tonnes of nonsense scientific articles published (not saying this one is, but of this author that has made dubious and sensational claims). And unless there is scientific consensus, his wider claims should be treated with scepticism.

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by stonogo on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:26AM (#37318382)
Specifically, I think, we can take the sentence "Another possibility is that this unfamiliar abundance pattern may reflect an extraterrestrial technological origin" with a good serving of salt, even if the methodology is otherwise sound.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @02:40AM (#37318473)
I mean the measurements themselves may be fine, but the conclusions will require scrutiny.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by RetroTechie on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @06:21AM (#37319788)
Yep. Imho this doesn't pass Occam's razor.

Finding: "Objects with chemical composition that's unknown on Earth".

Conclusion: "Likely originated from outside our solar system".

Simpler explanations:

"Formed on Earth through previously unknown process".

"Formed elsewhere inside our solar system".

How many extraterrestrial (but inside solar system) substances do we really know? How much extraterrestrial substances have been sampled, from how many locations on how many objects, exactly? And even on Earth, do we know all processes through which materials are formed?

Yes, extrasolar origin is one possibility. The most likely one? Hmm..

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by wfvr on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @08:51AM (#37321249)
The extrasolar origin hypothesis is based on the reentry velocity, which is known and would have completely vaporized any other known type of meteor. That's what made this one special, the fact that an object with such velocity could survive reentry and impact the surface, and that's why the expedition to find remains (the spherules) was launched.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by lynx23 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:01AM (#37318970)
Because scientific publications regularily get falsified. And have proofably been used to manipulate public perception of events.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by sgt101 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:42AM (#37319215)
Science is always taken with salt!

More seriously - science produces contingent knowledge. Even the results of the LHC are to be taken with some salt because although the greatest and most honest minds of our generation work on them they likely won't ever be independently replicated.

All scientific knowledge has some doubt attached to it - after all, it's not maths!

Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by lincon127 on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @10:57AM (#37323137)
So if Michael Yeadon were to push out a paper filled with observations on the correlation between vaccines and autism, you wouldn't instantly disregard it? Some people don't deserve the time of day.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by uptie on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:22AM (#37321752)
You're poisoning the well for what reason?
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by adolph on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:40AM (#37322000)
There's poisoning the well and there's tempering expectations. I think the parent comment is more of the latter in that is speaks to the author's other works that are announced with great hype but haven't played out as definitively as the early hype claimed. This is a problem everywhere and acknowledging that this author in particular is a standout isn't a terrible thing--they just might be right this time.
Re:Discovery of spherules of likely extrasolar composition i... by jdiff on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @09:54AM (#37322209)
The well was "poisoned" by Avi. He makes similarly unfounded leaps in this instance, as he has in very many instances in the past. There's no foul play here, just the reputation he has earned for himself.