News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by oflannabhra on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:29PM (#37267270)
I know Apple has a strong resistance to the two-in-one form factor, but an M-series MacBook Air with detachable screen that seamlessly transitions between macOS and iPadOS is basically my dream device.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by blackaspen on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:39PM (#37267354)
This. Or a Yoga style fold-over in an 11" formfactor.

I picked up an X13s (the ARM one) for travel. It's not perfect -- one thing I like about iOS is that the airline apps are kind of required for IFE, but, my X13s weighs the same as my iPad Pro with a keyboard and can do much more. Trying to use Google Slides or Docs on the iPad is a poor experience.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by timestretch on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:30PM (#37267284)
They want to sell you two devices, and a monthly subscription to iCloud to interoperate between them.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by dmonitor on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:50PM (#37267455)
I really don’t buy these kinds of explanations when it comes to Apple products. They would love to sell you a 2-in-1 device for twice as much.

I just don’t think the UX is good enough for their standards. MacOS is poorly suited for touch interactions, and iPadOS is poorly suited for mouse cursor oriented interactions. 2-in-1s are just terrible UX experiences that Apple doesn’t want to be associated with.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by gtvwill on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:11PM (#37267633)
Lol no they wouldn't or they'd have done it ten years ago. Apple is after your dollars they care nothing for what's better for you for productivity or any ethics outside of profit really. Their actions over the last 20 years set that in stone.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by nomel on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:21PM (#37267731)
> they care nothing for what's better for you for productivity

What is your perspective based on? I'm not sure it's accurate, especially for productivity/professionals [1]. This matches my personal experience.

[1] https://www.jamf.com/blog/total-cost-of-ownership-mac-versus...

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by gtvwill on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:44PM (#37267961)
Well if they were really for productivity they would have made all their software offerings over the last 20 years cross platform in order to allow users of other systems to feel such amazing productivity boosts. But they didnt, they walled it off and made mac's about as incompatible and hard to work with for any other device (android,windows,linux) as they possibly could.

Proof in case, I can plug an android phone into a windows or linux os device and have zero problems yeeting files around and doing stuff off the block with zero input from me for drivers or some fancy app to let me get to the data. I cant do this with an iphone. The most simple act of using a phone as a physical storage device to get something from point a to b....near impossible on apple hardware. Meanwhile its been stock standard functionality for about 15+ years on other devices.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by nomel on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:28PM (#37268318)
As a person that always had, and still has, PCs, and also now has MacBooks, I'm suspecting that I use my devices in a significantly different way than you do.

> made all their software offerings over the last 20

What Apple software would people want outside of the Apple ecosystem? Do you have an example? Most of the "niceness" is system wide/cross device integration related, many of which don't have an equivalent in the other OSs to share. For example, try to wirelessly transfer a file, quickly, between any combination of linux and Windows without an active WiFi connection.

The only "substantial" software I can think of, from Apple, is iMovie. My only frequent use is Preview and Keynote. Everything else is either Microsoft (including Office), or third party.

> they walled it off and made mac's about as incompatible and hard to work with for any other device (android,windows,linux) as they possibly could.

Is this also about wired connections? Do you have an example? For me, NFS, VNC, and lots of third party stuff to take care of the rest, the same that I use for PC to PC/linux. I'm not aware of walls for macOS. There's no restrictions for software. I even have third party kernel extensions installed right now.

> plug an android phone into a windows or linux os device

That is obviously intentional, and probably annoying. Although, I can't say I've used wired transfer with a phone in over a decade, including on my Android phone. I have a far less $/Gb USB3 drive to go from computer to computer (or phone if wireless wasn't sufficient).

I might be breaking HN guidelines with this comment.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by gtvwill on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:06PM (#37268572)
I mean, what kind of OS company would want to build software for another companies competing os???

...

https://apps.apple.com/us/developer/microsoft-corporation/id...

:)

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by nomel on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:08PM (#37268588)
I had some specific questions so I could have a meaningful conversation. It doesn't look like you're interested. Cheers!
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by paulmd on Friday August 25, 2023 @10:42PM (#37269483)
> For example, try to wirelessly transfer a file, quickly, between any combination of linux and Windows without an active WiFi connection.

bah gawd that’s IrDA’s music!

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by trelane on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:09AM (#37269867)
> What Apple software would people want outside of the Apple ecosystem? Do you have an example?

How about starting with iMessage?

Keynote etc. for Linux would be rather nice.

At one point, I joined a local MUG (Mac Users Group), hoping we could find common cause and support each other in a Windows world. Sadly, that was naive of me.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by TexanFeller on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:46PM (#37268451)
> The most simple act of using a phone as a physical storage device to get something from point a to b....near impossible on apple hardware. Meanwhile its been stock standard functionality for about 15+ years on other devices.

It's been a long time since I stopped trying to like Android devices, but quite a few years ago I remember Android phones no longer working as a mass storage device you could drag files onto. That was a widely discussed intentional decision by Google and was one of several things that made me decide that Android's talk about freedom, openness and all that was just marketing. You can plug an Android in and drop stuff on it like a thumb drive again now?

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by trelane on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:17AM (#37269901)
> You can plug an Android in and drop stuff on it like a thumb drive again now?

I don't think that ever changed, though the vendor can probably turn it off, since they have the source.

On Linux, it can (depends on what you told the phone to present) photos or storage or such. It appears in Nautilus like any other external drive. I usually use it it move the photos off my phone onto my computer.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by katbyte on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:17PM (#37267703)
You are just speculating - having a 2 in 1 device is not as easy as “osx on an iPad” or “iOS on a Mac”

Until the m1 is was 100% not possible, now that they are both arm it’s possible but still would require an entirely new device class to do it justice

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by hu3 on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:23PM (#37267764)
> Until the m1 is was 100% not possible.

Microsoft made that possible at least 6 years ago with Surface Book. Why couldn't Apple? (spoiler they could)

https://youtu.be/SdQQ8uvylJ0?si=as1k5R5BhFTZiys_&t=106

And there are other brands too: https://www.ign.com/articles/best-detachable-laptops

Took me 10 seconds to Google. Why do people go to these great lengths to defend giant soulless corporations is beyond me.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by Spooky23 on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:27PM (#37268298)
Sure, and they don’t sell particularly well. That whole segment of the Microsoft ecosystem is a dusty corner that doesn’t get a lot of respect.

Hell, Microsoft has had a tablet offering since 2003 or earlier. It’s hard to do touch and traditional and do justice to both.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by katbyte on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:42PM (#37278293)
different cpu architects - surface book is still just x86 under the hood.

ios is arm, macbooks were x86, now is arm. thats why. it is impressive what rosetta 2 does, but it still impacts a significant performance and battery hiut

Now why they didn't make a touch macbook/detachable screen with osx is another question, and likely because there isnt the demand. i was just addressing why you couldn't just smush ios and osx together/run both on the same device

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by afavour on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:34PM (#37267856)
Anyone that used an iOS simulator back in the x64 days would tell you that it’s entirely possible to run iOS on x64, just Apple chooses not to do it.

(before anyone jumps in to tell me the simulator is not a full OS: I know. But there was a full toolchain to build for x64, if they’d chosen to Apple could have leveraged it)

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by katbyte on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:46PM (#37278316)
the os isn't the hard part, its the app ecosystem and navigating how do you ensure they all run properly on x86, and not with a huge performance or battery hit. i would be rosetta2 in reverse, and as great as rosetta2 is it has limitations & does come at a cost.

sharing the cpu arch makes things easy, case in point at launch m1 ran ios apps.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by afavour on Saturday August 26, 2023 @10:35PM (#37278958)
> how do you ensure they all run properly on x86

Again, simulator builds in Xcode are exactly that on x64 devices.

> it would be rosetta2 in reverse

It wouldn’t. Rosetta takes programs compiled for one CPU and runs them on another. But in this scenario apps would be built specifically for x64. Xcode previously had the ability to build multiple architectures in one package (32bit and 64bit), they could totally package ARM and x64 together if they wished to.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by katbyte on Saturday August 26, 2023 @10:39PM (#37278980)
You seem to be forgetting that every app in the App Store would need to be rebuilt.. and developers would need to buy in and do so
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by afavour on Saturday August 26, 2023 @11:21PM (#37279148)
Make it a requirement in order to ship a new version, developers would do it in an instant. Just like they did with 64bit builds.

Sure, a small number of apps would fall to the wayside. But it’s not like Apple has hesitated to do that before.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by katbyte on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:47AM (#37283781)
I think you are grossly underestimating the number of apps that no longer see regular updates/have active developers
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by afavour on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:40PM (#37284297)
I think you’re grossly overestimating how many of those apps are actually used regularly. Even if Apple only got 15% of the entire App Store available on x64 it would fulfill the needs of almost all users.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by hotnfresh on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:42PM (#37267936)
> Apple is after your dollars they care nothing for what's better for you for productivity or any ethics outside of profit really.

A damning indictment of the personal computing industry is that Apple nonetheless deliver the best of anyone this front, by a mile, for most users. The whole product category of personal computing devices and operating systems is a real shit-show.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by zakki on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:59PM (#37268080)
The problem is most other devices are cheaper so no complaint for the shit-show. With Apple’s prices, I want more.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by housemusicfan on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:53PM (#37268037)
> I just don’t think the UX is good enough for their standards. MacOS is poorly suited for touch interactions, and iPadOS is poorly suited for mouse cursor oriented interactions.

"They've developed utter shite over two decades but only did so because of their impossibly high standards and they care about you, the customer."

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by paulcole on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:10PM (#37267613)
Yeah, this is why they’ve pushed so hard for people to carry both iPhones and iPods.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by nomel on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:13PM (#37267651)
What is this in reference to? I have an iPad and a MacBook. I don't pay a subscription. I usually use Microsoft OneDrive, so I can sync between/to my non apple devices, though I usually just use airdrop.

Are you referring to extra cloud storage?

edit: A response would be appreciated, so I can understand what's going on with this comment. This is a genuine question. What subscription am I missing out on here?

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by zeven7 on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:48PM (#37268471)
I haven't owned an Apple device in 10 years, but I think they're talking about iCloud.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by nomel on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:53PM (#37268500)
I don't understand. There's no iCloud subscription to enable all the cross-device interoperability.

The cloud subscription just gets you more than the 5Gb of free storage. I use Microsoft OneDrive for extra cloud storage. Handoff, shared clipboard, airdrop, sidecar, and all the other nice stuff works without extra cloud storage. You do need to have an iCloud account.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by giobox on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:20PM (#37267720)
And in the case of the iPad, try to sell you them individually for each family member...

It's 2023, and you still can't have multiple user accounts on any model of iPad, "Pro" or otherwise. This is a feature you can just take for-granted on virtually any other "computer" too.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by wlesieutre on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:24PM (#37267765)
You can if you're a school!

https://support.apple.com/en-hk/guide/deployment-education/e...

The feature has existed for years, Apple just won't let you use it because they'd rather sell separate devices to every family member.

For all the talk about environmentalism and their elaborate phone recycling robots, they're not too concerned about the "reduce" part of "reduce, reuse, recycle." Never mind that it's the most important one that you're supposed to do before the others.

EDIT - I'm aware a local users system without a network login system would require a slightly different implementation from schools, but a small 2.8 trillion dollar company like Apple could figure it out if they wanted to

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by Gigachad on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:57PM (#37268070)
I've heard that the multi user feature for schools is pretty skin deep and that it basically just acts as an auth for apps which store all data remotely. Not at all something you could just drop on regular consumers.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by behnamoh on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:51PM (#37268013)
The thing is: I can't even do media consumptions and web browsing on iPad. Browsing the web without uBlock and a few other extensions is a battle I'm not willing to fight. And so many video codecs not supported on iPad makes it unusable for media consumption. And have you tried opening your videos in other apps? Guess what? The file gets copied to the other app, meaning that now you have two versions of the same movie/whatever.

The iPadOS is so broken in basic ways that I can't even.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by doublepg23 on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:20PM (#37268245)
For web browsing I recommend installing Firefox Focus and then using that as a content blocker.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by mattl on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:54PM (#37268044)
There are decent Adblock apps for iPad.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by mmh0000 on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:58PM (#37274566)
You can even! Just gotta put a little leg work in.

AdGuard and Hush for ad blocking, both free.

VLC for video, has built in ftp server which makes loading your pirated videos on super easy.

foobar2000 for music. Hands down the best music player, also has ftp support for easily loading all your favorite pirated music.

Bitwarden for password/totp management.

Joplin for notes (free). GoodNotes for pdf/sketchnotes (not free but worth it imho)

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by TillE on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:38PM (#37267341)
The problem with a convertible MacBook is that you'd have to move the battery to behind the display, at which point you're really just making an iPad that can be attached to a keyboard dock and run macOS.

I think the latter is a plausible evolution of the iPad Pro.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by novok on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:23PM (#37268277)
Or they can leave it in the body and give it a 360 hinge
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by oflannabhra on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:54PM (#37268884)
Apple’s big philosophy is that the interaction paradigm should be distinct, from the hardware to the software, and that mixing the two is confusing and a bad experience.

I happen to agree with them, but I would love to be able to switch between the two. macOS is powerful, but adding touch to it would actually be terrible.

Switching between those modes and input paradigms, while maintaining some level of context would be a really great experience.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by makeitdouble on Friday August 25, 2023 @09:11PM (#37268977)
> Apple’s big philosophy is that the interaction paradigm should be distinct

They're allowing iPad and iOS apps on the macs, so it doesn't seem so clear cut. Feels more like they don't have a clear incentive to push further when people keep buying both products.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by oflannabhra on Saturday August 26, 2023 @06:17AM (#37271383)
Yes, but not touch.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by isametry on Saturday August 26, 2023 @05:21AM (#37271028)
That might have been their philosophy once, but important people who believed that seem to be gone now, because basically every piece of software that gets touched on the Mac now resembles an unloved offspring of their touch platforms.

See examples: Control Center, Share Sheet, Notifications, the entirety of the new System Settings app…

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by hhh on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:33PM (#37267307)
The iPad pro is basically this, but just needs to be able to swap when you hook up the Magic Keyboard.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by oflannabhra on Friday August 25, 2023 @10:14PM (#37269328)
It doesn’t offer macOS. My whole point is that when I have a keyboard I don’t want to be touching a screen, and I want the power and freedom macOS offers to be able to do productive work. I also want iPadOS for other types of interaction, like reading or watching, or drawing.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by hhh on Saturday August 26, 2023 @03:42PM (#37276144)
By 'It just needs to swap' I mean to be able to swap into MacOS (when you hook up the magic keyboard)
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by oflannabhra on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:11AM (#37283436)
Oh, then yeah! This is exactly what I would like.

I don’t care about the particulars of the hardware that enables such an experience.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by forrestthewoods on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:11PM (#37267632)
I would also accept an iPad that can dual-boot into macOS when using a Magic Keyboard.

The fact that they don’t allow this is absurd. They basically charge $1500 for macOS. I’d probably pay that to let my iPad dual boot if they’d let me!

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by hinkley on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:16PM (#37267681)
iPad with a power connector on the side where the cover attaches, and a macbook the exact size of an iPad with no screen, just a remote desktop on the iPad.

Either data over the charging port, or low throughput over Bluetooth 5 (when is 6 due?)

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by bgoldste on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:17PM (#37267697)
And now it’s mine too…
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by willio58 on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:32PM (#37267840)
As long as it didn't sacrifice the user experience both devices currently have I'd be on board!
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by gizajob on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:37PM (#37267884)
I'm amazed the two haven't converged yet. I've no doubt apple have lurking in their labs a "double iPad" with a "screen" and a second screen where the keyboard now lives, running a version of iOS-like MacOS. Would love that device and think it'll emerge eventually.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by satvikpendem on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:12PM (#37268188)
I don't think they'll converge, I see Apple eventually using its Vision product line to supplant traditional rectangular slab based devices.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by gizajob on Saturday August 26, 2023 @10:45AM (#37273374)
Yeah does seem like it’ll go that way. Not sure I want to spend the day “goggled in” (as Neal Stephenson would say) - I may already be an old timer and want to use external devices (my first computer had 48kb of memory). But no doubt I’ll be engoggled at some point in the not too distant future. Plus for the time being, there doesn’t seem to be a way of plugging in external peripherals to the Vision, so we’re stuck with the same problem of not being able to reasonably use pro audio interfaces and suchlike, same as the iPad.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by bdcravens on Friday August 25, 2023 @09:19PM (#37269036)
Why would they willingly create a device where people can buy one instead of two?
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by gizajob on Saturday August 26, 2023 @01:41AM (#37270211)
I think there’s probably benefits to be had in terms of interface without having a fixed typing keyboard. Logic and Final Cut for example, could be hugely improved by this.
Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by walthamstow on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:14AM (#37280853)
That device exists, I saw it being reviewed on The Verge recently

https://www.theverge.com/23794761/lenovo-yoga-book-9i-review

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by toasted-subs on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:53PM (#37268030)
The iPad I have has effectively become a second screen for my MacBook as a with a walcom tablet.

It's too heavy to read from.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by crimsontech on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:21PM (#37268251)
I mostly use the iPad for reading, ebooks, pdfs, saved web articles, HN, etc.

I initially got the biggest iPad but it was certainly too heavy to hold like a book and read comfortably. I switched to an iPad mini which was perfect for reading everything but PDFs, the problem is I read a lot of PDFs. I currently use an 11” and take the cover off to read with it, I find it to be the right trade off between size and weight for me.

Re:Giving up the iPad-only travel dream by LTL_FTC on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:52PM (#37268868)
I just traded in my 12in pro for this reason. However, I think a MacBook Air may be a better reading device because it will prop up the display at whatever angle you need it to be for comfortable reading, while remaining ultra portable or easily resting it on your lap or chest (if you like reading lying down).