News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by gottorf on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:27AM (#37134413)
I use Firefox everywhere I can, warts and all, just to avoid the Chromium monopoly. It was actually a huge bummer for me when Edge gave in and switched to Chromium; having a giant like Microsoft support a third browser engine would really have been a boon to the health of the ecosystem.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yummypaint on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:29AM (#37134439)
I do the same thing but it isn't much of a sacrifice. It feels icky to use google's software knowing it's actively working against my interests.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ReptileMan on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:33AM (#37134486)
Kinda like Brave.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Calamitous on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:42AM (#37134582)
How is Brave working against the user’s interests? Not being snarky, I’ve been using it for a while and it seems fine.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by some_random on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:16AM (#37135009)
Yet another Chromium browser contributing to Google's massive market share which enables them to push all the anti-consumer shit Brave is supposed to fix.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by iLoveOncall on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:37AM (#37135271)
It's heavily tied in with crypto, but even if you don't care about that they have done extremely shady shit like inserting their own referral code in registration forms.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by sdfghswe on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:51AM (#37134703)
Crypto.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by baal80spam on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:48AM (#37134649)
It isn't, but on HN the agenda is "Brave bad".
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by input_sh on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:09AM (#37134925)
Anything Chromium-based bad, Brave is no different in that front than Opera, Vivaldi etc.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by KingOfCoders on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:29AM (#37134433)
Me too. I wonder though what would have happend if we had given $7B to Andreas Kling.

I guess with WebDRM this point is moot though.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Tade0 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:34AM (#37134497)
You would need to spend at least a billion to clone him first - this whole project is moving forward because the man is an exceptional programmer.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by stephen_g on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:21AM (#37135098)
I think now with the sponsorships he’s hired one of the contributors full time, and I think Linus Groh was also going full time so that makes three people dedicated to working on it as well as the other contributors.

Better than nothing, and just incredible what they’ve achieved so far!

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by tudorw on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:37AM (#37134532)
can they afford to turn on a dime at some point?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by echelon on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:36AM (#37134521)
Write your legislators and tell them it's unfair for Google to control the web's leading browser.

Google dominates web search, controls mobile as part of a duopoly, pays the other mobile provider to feature their search, dominates mobile advertising, ranks websites based on ads and chrome performance, increasingly takes over functionality from the websites they index, etc.

They use their money and power to transform the web into a platform they own and control with AMP, Manifest v2, WEI, WHATWG, and repeated attempts to kill the URL bar.

Chrome is a key instrument of their monopolization. Their business units need to be carved up, and Chrome needs to go its separate way, kept apart from search and ads.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by tudorw on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:38AM (#37134540)
so Microsoft adopting chromium as it's engine, would, erm, make this more likely or less?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by echelon on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:40AM (#37134559)
Microsoft, in third place, barely has a 5% market share. I don't think they contribute to the present situation.

I hope they gain in browser market share alongside Firefox and all the other non-Chrome, non-Safari browsers.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pwython on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#37135068)
Probably a very unpopular opinion, but it seems any time a business/product reaches the point where they have majority of market share, people say it's a monopoly. At what point are businesses forced to scale down because their products are TOO successful? I still don't understand what the big deal was with Microsoft having IE bundled with Windows. If a competitor has a superior product, then why not just leave it up to the consumers to decide if it lives or dies. Imagine an amateur boxer fighting a pro twice their size and saying "it's no fair, they're stronger and have more experience." Well, the pro put in all the work to get to where they're at.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by coldpie on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:37AM (#37135283)
Good question! Speaking in legal terms, not popular usage, generally the problem being addressed is not "you have too much market share," but rather, "you used your dominant position in one market to then dominate a different market." To stretch your analogy, it'd be like your pro boxer entering an amateur tournament and taking all the prize money. In the case of Microsoft's IE bundling, they were using their dominant position in the Operating System market to become dominant in the Web Browser market, by bundling IE with the OS and providing specific OS integration hooks which were unavailable to other browsers.

> If a competitor has a superior product, then why not just leave it up to the consumers to decide if it lives or dies.

The trouble comes when the entity in the dominant position squashes competition unfairly. In the IE case, Microsoft included a browser with every copy of the OS, so consumers had to overcome hurdles to even try a competitor's browser. Additionally, as I mentioned above, Microsoft provided secret hooks into the OS that were unavailable to other browsers, so it was impossible for a competitor to create a superior product. Those actions limited fair competition in the browser space, which usually results in worse outcomes for consumers or the market as a whole, hence the laws forbidding monopoly abuse.

Hope that helps give some idea of what happened there. Of course, you can read much more detail about the case & anti-trust law in general elsewhere.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Kab1r on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:45AM (#37135357)
I don't really like this boxing analogy (because browsers don't directly interact with each other and browsers aren't a sport, etc), but I'll go with it anyway. When there are only two boxers and nobody apparently cares about the amateur, gloves that fit the amateur stop being made. All boxing gloves produced only fit the pro. But I guess "the pro put in all the work to get to where they're at." Again this analogy doesn't make much sense to begin with, but I think I've made my point about websites being designed exclusively for chrome. I have had websites tell me that my browser is unsupported and promptly refuse to let me use the site until I fake my user agent and then it works perfectly fine.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by alluro2 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#37135402)
People start complaining something is a monopoly when the business starts squashing potential competition from the position of power, using bully or shady tactics, or screwing their customers by being more and more greedy.

In case of Microsoft and IE, even if you don't read up on the history and details of it, it's obvious that they were just trying to do what Google is doing now - gatekeep the web and get some of that toll money. I don't think many would have issues with Microsoft just including a simple web browsing tool and leaving it at that. Instead, they were actively working to kill the competition, took over the majority of market share and then just killed off innovation basically completely, and held back the web for years and years afterwards.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by _coveredInBees on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:43AM (#37134594)
Same here. Then again, I'll never leave Firefox as long as Tree Style Tabs[1] continues to be supported as an extension. It's been a life-changer since I discovered it well over a decade ago and makes every other browser pretty much unusable for me as a daily driver.

[1] - https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tree-style-ta...

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by knd775 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:07AM (#37134896)
There are multiple chromium alternatives for this extension.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by gowld on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#37135057)
And they are all terrible.

One of them is called TabFern, get it? It's like TabTree but it doesn't have branches.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by CharlesW on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:58AM (#37135545)
> And they are all terrible.

For other Chromium-based browser users, Tabs Outliner is great, more powerful (but with a steeper learning curve) solution.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by twobitshifter on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:53AM (#37135483)
It’s not a one for one replacement but edge has vertical tabs and tab groups built in. I have to use edge for work and it’s a decent compromise.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by sdnas211 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:20PM (#37135835)
Have you given Sidebery a try? Also for firefox.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yomlica8 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:43AM (#37134601)
Edge seems like a blunder in general. Prior to the initial Edge introduction IE seemed to have 20-25% of the desktop browser marketshare. Nothing like the crazy 90+% it had at its height but certainly not a browser you can ignore. Now they're at about 10% and it seems like they have to use every manipulation tactic in the book to get it.

But I agree, that third browser engine kept things interesting even if I didn't use it. Selfishly I hope Apple continues using its iron grip on iOS to prevent anything other than Safari's engine there. I don't use Apple products personally but benefit from the diversity of ecosystem it provides.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:22AM (#37135107)
> Prior to the initial Edge introduction IE seemed to have 20-25% of the desktop browser marketshare.

It had been on the decline for years. Statscounter shows 26% in January 2013, 17% January 2014, 13% in January 2015, then Edge was introduced in July of that year.

If anything Edge was a recognition of that reality: the investment in maintaining their own browser engine wasn't worth it when compared to the resulting market share. IMO the failure of Windows Phone was the death knell of Trident (the IE engine): desktop share overall is smaller and they have no footprint in the mobile OS space.

https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/all/worldwid...

https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/all/worldwid...

https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/all/worldwid...

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by temac on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#37135380)
You are confusing the old Edge that had an engine forked from IE and that MS exclusively maintained, with the new Edge that is a fork of Chromium. Maybe that the old Edge was not of stellar quality was simply because the age of the codebase of its engine.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:16PM (#37135778)
I'm simply replying to the OP's assertion that "Edge seems like a blunder in general".

IE market share was declining before Edge was introduced, and it continued to decline after Edge was introduced. Since the browser engine switch their market share has actually increased a small amount! So all in all I don't think there's any evidence that Edge was a blunder.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yomlica8 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#37135849)
Yeah, this does seem to line up more with the Windows8/Windows phone failure more than anything.

Despite people having a better opinion about Edge Chromium it didn't seem to stem the decline.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:25PM (#37136720)
> death knell of Trident (the IE engine)

Nitpick, but the Edge name signaled the switch to the ground up rewrite Spartan engine. Trident is still sort of alive in its zombie corporate state in the Windows backwards compatibility swamp. Trident was still maintained for backward compatibility (and still exists in IE Mode in Chromium Edge), but Edge was always Spartan and it is Spartan that is dead (RIP).

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by n0tinventedhere on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:15AM (#37135001)
I can tell you from doing testing on Edge back when it represented a potential third engine to support: that browser crashed a lot. It was very unreliable prior to switching to becoming another chromium fork. It is clear the dev team was either underfunded or plain incompetent and Microsoft was in dire need of a default browser that didn't make people wince, ASAP, they could not afford to wait [insert X years to get a mature engine] so they went the obvious route and chose to make a chromium fork.

Making a reliable engine that supports all of the modern web is a monstrous undertaking. Not just "support", it needs to be reliable. Microsoft missed the boat when they allowed IE to rot and it was too late to catch up now. Every year spent without a reliable browser preinstalled on your OS is detrimental.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mywittyname on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:06AM (#37134886)
I think the problem with Edge was two-fold:

- People were trained to automatically install a new browser on their computers when they got it.

- Edge is a never ending nagfest and that became another prompt to go and download Chrome.

Less is more was probably the better strategy to take with Edge.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by softfalcon on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:42AM (#37135327)
> Less is more...

You hit the nail right on the money. Every time I accidentally open Edge through the Windows search, it never ceases to shut up about itself. There is fanfare, there are notifications for details I don't care about, popups showing me all the features that are standard in any web browser.

You know what would make me use your browser Microsoft? Getting the hell out of my way. I do not care that it's Edge, I don't care that it's new, I don't care that it has 7 ways to input and take pictures and who knows what else. Just show me the search result.

Contrast this to how Safari behaves when it pops up to show you something. It just gives you the web page. That's it.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cptskippy on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:53AM (#37134730)
> Edge seems like a blunder in general. Prior to the initial Edge introduction IE seemed to have 20-25% of the desktop browser marketshare.

The only reason IE retained any marketshare was because it was required for legacy enterprise and government applications. For security this was bad all around and Microsoft was right to kill it off even to their own detriment.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:43AM (#37135345)
> Selfishly I hope Apple continues using its iron grip on iOS to prevent anything other than Safari's engine there.

It's so weird these days seeing people literally cheering for the success of a proprietary product on a completely closed platform over an open source engine. Firefox, sure. I can get behind that even if my professional life technically argues against it. I see the draw there and won't argue about benefits.

But Safari? Seriously? Even discounting the existence of Firefox, the "monoculture" argument falls down in the face of products like Edge and Opera (and countless others -- Linux distros ship Chromium, Teslas all have a build installed, etc...), which are *successful forks* of Chromium. If Google goes evil and turns into a bad steward, we know already that Microsoft et. al. won't be impacted and can continue to ship their unadulterated products. Because that's what they're doing today.

Really? Safari?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#37135860)
> If Google goes evil and turns into a bad steward, we know already that Microsoft et. al. won't be impacted

I suspect that's not OP's fear. Google is powerful enough that they can do whatever they want with Chrome. They could even close source the thing and implement a load of proprietary APIs if they wanted and the bulk of users would continue to use it.

One of the things holding them back from doing so is the fact that Chromium can't run on the most popular mobile platform in the US. I'm no defender of Safari but I can see the logic at work.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:40PM (#37136097)
> They could even close source the thing and implement a load of proprietary APIs

Right, but that capability is exactly what the upthread comment is cheering for Apple having. Apple goes even farther and straight up denies competitors access to its platform entirely.

It's the asymmetry I don't understand: why is proprietary control good for one side but not for the other? Is the goal here preserving open systems and interoperability or is it just to Beat Google?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:50PM (#37136208)
> why is proprietary control good for one side and not the other?

It isn’t for either, this is a “least worst” scenario. Both sides have the capability to push proprietary APIs but largely fail at doing so because they don’t have a monopoly over the market. They are forced to compromise on a middle ground (supporting the open web), which is better than one side being able to entirely dominate the market and do whatever they want.

> Is the goal here preserving open systems and interoperability or is it just to Beat Google?

In this specific scenario they are one and the same but the aim is the former. Google controls the desktop browser market already, one of the only reasons they haven’t done the same on mobile is because Apple won’t allow it. The argument is not that Apple should control everything, it’s that stalemate is the best we’ve got.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:56PM (#37136266)
> Google controls the desktop browser market already, one of the only reasons they haven’t done the same on mobile is because Apple won’t allow it.

Yeah, I think this is wrong, but I'm going to bail on this discussion since it's too close to my employment.

But my opinions haven't really changed anyway: from my perspective both sides have "control" over a market, but one side has been a good steward, allowing forks and experimentation and open implementation, and the other side has been an inarguably bad steward by disallowing competition entirely. And it's shocking (and frankly a little Orwellian) to see people trying to argue the opposite.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:12PM (#37136534)
One side having been a "good steward" is your opinion, describing counter opinions as "a little Orwellian" strikes me as hyperbole.

From my perspective I agree that Google has been a better steward of the web than many others would be or have been. But I have spent too much of my professional life dealing with things like AMP pages and shitty, browser-crashing ads provided via Google ad networks to say they are a total objective good (to say nothing of the Web Environment Integrity proposal and other stuff that never succeeded, remember when they wanted to put Dart in Chrome?).

Even if you think they are objectively good, remember that they've been a good steward within the current context where they don't hold overall power. Microsoft is a good steward of the web these days but I've been around long enough to remember the IE6 days. If given total control over the future of the web I have every expectation that Google would behave like MS did back then. It's nothing personal against any company, I think it's inherent in the nature of any private company in total control of a market to bend it to their will. Expecting them to do anything else is foolish.

I fear the native future Apple wants but can't achieve because of the open web. I fear the dominated web future Google wants but can't achieve because of Apple. I'm equal opportunity scared of all these bastards.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:56AM (#37147064)
> I fear the native future Apple wants

It seems like you agree with me then. I remind you that you stepped in to a subthread arguing in favor ("seeing the logic" in your words) of Safari as an alternative to Chrome as a way to preserve open access to web content. And as you yourself point out, that's ridiculous: iOS/Safari is much more locked down than any WEI-compliant browser ever could be.

I repeat again that I'm happy if you want to boost Firefox or Chromium or (if you must) Opera or Edge instead, as those platforms represent open choices in a reasonably free market. But telling people to use Safari on iOS in this particular argument is a very weird up-is-down/gaslighting/Orwellian take. It's just wrong. Your stated goals upthread don't match your recommendations, at all.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yomlica8 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:19PM (#37136645)
I haven't commented really since afavour has mostly articulated my position for me. I don't use Apple products as I am philosophically opposed to the control of the hardware. And my life goes on fine.

WEI alone is enough for me to disagree with you on who is the bad steward.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @02:11PM (#37137307)
> WEI alone is enough for me to disagree with you on who is the bad steward.

But... again, WEI is just duplicating features that have been there from day zero on iOS (and mobile apps more generally).

I understand that you dislike WEI. I understand why you might argue against its implementors and push platforms like Firefox that don't do that. I get that part.

What I don't get is your celebration of a platform that is even more locked down, in every reasonable interpretation. Your ability as an arbitrary client to connect to the service of your choosing using the software of your choosing (which is all WEI is about) is objectively much weaker with iOS than any other significant client platform. So maybe you should revisit your thinking here?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by tapoxi on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:44AM (#37134607)
Firefox has lost about 20 million users since the announcement of Chrome moving to Manifest v3. It can't avoid the monopoly even with the press in their favor.

https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity

Call me a pessimist but I don't think Mozilla is managed well enough to actually compete against Chrome. We'd need the Linux Foundation or some other large neutral standards body to fork Chromium at this point and create a vendor-neutral platform that everyone can rally behind.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:22AM (#37135105)
Ah yes, so Firefox is faster than chrome, allows you more latitude for adblockers, and isn't pushing garbage hostile web standards, but clearly, mozilla just isn't doing enough

Can we stop pretending that this is mozilla's fault that the GIANT corp sitting in front of the internet, being the homepage of 90% of computers, that nags users to install chrome "for a better experience" on every single web site it can, is able to get onto more systems than firefox?

How many average users even KNOW about firefox anymore?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by n0tinventedhere on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:31AM (#37135203)
> so Firefox is faster than chrome

Faster on sunspider. In practice, on real web pages, as someone who occasionally browses the web using a low end tablet PC (Surface Go 2 with linux. The CPU is downright anemic but good enough for treating it like a reading device/video stream platform), I experienced many more stutters on Firefox that I did not on Chrome and it has become one of the reasons I stopped using it (the syncing is also way worse and often breaks. "Read latest tab from other device" is almost useless if you don't manually trigger a sync because it sure won't do it by itself in any reasonable time frame).

The performance difference is much less visible on my main computer though. But yall really need to try firefox on low end devices before you make generic statements about its performance. Or the android version.. lord, firefox on android is just unpleasant.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by seanw444 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:43AM (#37135347)
Funny, I use Mull on my Android, which is basically Firefox on Android but even more heavily restricted. Have for at least a year. Didn't know people considered it unpleasant.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by onli on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#37135456)
I don't think they really do. Firefox, at least after the rewrite, is what made browsing on low-powered android machines bearable, in my experience.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by seanw444 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:55PM (#37137129)
Especially since it supports uBlock Origin and Dark Reader.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by caskstrength on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:04PM (#37135625)
I have very similar experience - subjectively I experience more stuttering in FF than Chrome both on Android and Linux laptop.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Dah00n on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:10PM (#37136515)
I have the exact opposite experience. Streaming video is stuttering and buffering so bad that I can't use Chrome at all on those sites (Brave isn't any better). It was the reason I switched to Firefox and the performance was so much better.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by caskstrength on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:40PM (#37136941)
Your experience is not "exact opposite" since for me video in FF with VAAPI-based hardware decoding also works better than in Chrome. However, FF can stutter while scrolling animation-heavy sites or when open/closing tabs.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by garciansmith on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:27PM (#37135926)
Firefox still runs great on my ThinkPad T420s running Linux, which is 12 years old at this point.

And while I never use Firefox on Android without uBlock Origin, I don't get how it can be described as unpleasant after the rewrite a few years ago. The combo makes browsing bearable compared to Chrome.

The sync tabs thing used to be flaky, I agree, but now sending tabs to and from Linux and Android always works for me.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by sundarurfriend on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:55PM (#37136259)
By stuttering, if you mean video stuttering, I used to experience those a lot; I installed Brave for that very reason, because Netflix, Twitch, etc. were performing pretty poorly on Firefox (on a 4GB RAM low end laptop). But I very rarely experience that these days, to the point I've switched back to Firefox for those sites too.

But general performance-wise, Firefox is so easily better than Chromium in my experience, it's not even a competition. Firefox with hundreds of tabs open performs better than Chromium with 10-20 tabs. It's more responsive to interactions, uses less memory, and is much less likely to freeze up. With Chromium, I have to constantly keep a watch over open tabs, and close them mercilessly, or suffer from overall system slowdown and a browser that's almost a slideshow.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by drawfloat on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:20PM (#37136653)
It's about 12 months ago now, but I worked on a GL project where Firefox was significantly slower than Chrome – and, agreed, it was often on lower end devices. This was to the point it was easier to just drop features wholesale from Firefox, in order to ensure a steady 30 FPS (with Chrome solidly performing 60). I believe a large amount of it related to WebAudio APIs.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Kuinox on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:41AM (#37135321)
Not shipping WebReplay in firefox (instead it's a startup called replay.io),

Killing the servo project.

Running metaverse projects instead.

Yes, mozilla could do better.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:57AM (#37135539)
These are all things that the average user doesn't even know exist

"Power users" aren't most of anyone's user base. The vast majority of people use chrome because google told them to, because google IS the internet

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Kuinox on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:23PM (#37135872)
Websites arent made with firefox, so they are not optimized for firefox. They also can be buggy, firefox is my daily browser, yet, multiple times per year, a website is simply bugged on firefox.

Google Chrome was recommended by power user, and that how they took the market lead, not because they are the internet, but because power users told regular users to use chrome.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:31PM (#37135985)
I have never found a website that is broken on firefox that isn't also non-functional on chrome. What does firefox break?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Reubachi on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:59PM (#37136309)
Folks mistakenly associate "breaking" with "not being completely compatible with an illegal streaming website with improper TLS/cyphers." That's just an example but you know what I mean.

Those are the types of websites that have issues with firefox, because mozilla maintains it's own root trust store held to various standards/compliances, and many..less savory web addresses use not HTTPS content on their HTTPS pages.

This is a feature/value added bonus, but because it "breaks" sites for people....back to chrome.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Kuinox on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:26PM (#37138204)
Most are due to the firefox tracking protection. Others (with everything disabled) were for an airline company, some french governements website, and recently an SVG editor that just call to use chrome and doesn't works on firefox.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by 878654Tom on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:21PM (#37136671)
Google massively advertised Chrome at the start with banners on Gmail, Search,... telling you you should download it.

Powerusers don't shift the market.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ndiddy on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:30PM (#37136812)
Google also paid freeware application developers to bundle Chrome in their installers.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:36PM (#37136876)
Somehow they managed to have a huge market share when Microsoft was fighting tooth and nail in courts and out to tell people to use IE, and Microsoft WAS home computers.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by tapoxi on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:42AM (#37135330)
Faster on one benchmark, but they don't have a consistent history of performance wins. The bigger issue is that nobody is embedding Gecko. Every Electron app is another developer targeting Chrome. Applications that embed a webview? Chrome. Any new web browser that wants to deliver a new experience (like Arc, or even Brave) is built atop Chromium.

The problem is that "not pushing hostile web standards" and "more flexible ad blocking" clearly isn't stopping the insane bleeding of the userbase. These are people actively migrating away from Firefox in droves.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ComputerGuru on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:01PM (#37135579)
I would argue that Electron webapps shouldn’t really count towards the browser marketshare. If would be nice to have a Firefox version, but it doesn’t matter precisely because the end user is not choosing the browser - the company pushing the product is. And let’s be honest: nerdy HN users aside, Joe Schmoe has no clue Teams is a web app running in an emasculated browser at all.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by dataangel on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:56PM (#37136277)
every time someone uses electron they buy into the chrome ecosystem -- when they run into problems they write mailing list posts or stack overflow questions that other people can read to help them when they have the same problem, and if they actually want to contribute bugfixes or features upstream they go into chrome not firefox. also if they have a webapp version the webapp version that's running in chrome works exactly the same as the same code running in electron without really having to do any separate testing so which browser are they going to push to be used internally?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by lkbm on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:58PM (#37136303)
> I would argue that Electron webapps shouldn’t really count towards the browser marketshare.

Perhaps not, but if you're writing your desktop app in Electron, you'll be benchmarking your performance optimizations against the Chrome engine. If that same code is used for your web app, you're optimizing your website for Chrome.

Mozilla can pour resources into making Firefox more performance, but the real-world ecosystem will change behavior to improve Chrome's performance on their webapp with little concern as to whether it hurts Firefox's performance.

(I assume people use largely the same code between Electron and their webapps, and that optimizations for Electron translate reasonably well to optimizations for Chrome.)

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ohgodplsno on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:11PM (#37135719)
Keep moving the goalposts, Firefox is going to go real far this way.

Google is _forcing_ Chrome, onto everyone. Gecko is fully embeddable on Android, through GeckoView. Nobody uses it, because the default WebView is chrome. androidx.browser is Chrome. And if you want to delegate to the browser while still staying in an app context, the feature is called Chrome Custom Tabs. Everything is made to make people forget about Firefox's existence. Google actively harms Firefox performance on their websites, while happily displaying a "it's better on Chrome" everywhere you browser. They force the WHATWG's hand on 90% of features. There's articles every month on new-obscure-feature-that-is-only-implemented-by-chrome-and-requires-an-army-to-implement, pushed and paid for by Google, which dumbass webshits are going to go and implement because obviously their VC backed startup _really_ needs WebUSB and WebMIDI, as well as Google's shitty, unfinished implementation of WebGPU.

Google is a cancer that grows everywhere, killing everything it touches. Firefox smoking a cigarette from time to time is not responsible for that.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cxr on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:31PM (#37135992)
Google sucks. Your position seems to be, though, that because Google sucks, we can't talk about the self-inflicted wounding of Firefox and other buffoonery that happens under the Mozilla Corp umbrella—since Google sucks so much more. There's a word for that: whataboutism.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by lostmsu on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:58PM (#37136297)
> self-inflicted wounding of Firefox

This makes no sense. The parent argument is that Chrome wins due to aggressive bundling and free ads on Google. Neither of those are self-inflicted wounds. The claim is that Mozilla doesn't actually have self-inflicted wounds.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:30PM (#37136808)
The claim is that we have to blame Firefox's failure on bundling and google.com banners, and can't discuss how hostile and bizarre they've been. We also can't discuss that 80% of their revenue comes from Google, for nothing, and that the other 20% of their revenue is the entire return on 100% of their investment in the browser.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cxr on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:47PM (#37138452)
> The claim is that Mozilla doesn't actually have self-inflicted wounds.

Not in the comment I was responding to; you would have to be arguing that "Firefox smoking a cigarette from time to time" doesn't describe a type of self-inflicted wound—and for you to be right—for that to be true. (Whether you genuinely think that or not is one thing, but you definitely wouldn't be right about it, in any case.)

The entire comment I responded to belongs to the flavor of apologia that takes the form, "it doesn't matter if X is bad, because Y is worse".

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ohgodplsno on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:29PM (#37138948)
>it doesn't matter if X is bad, because Y is worse

In the case of Mozilla and Google, yes. Mozilla's leadership fucking sucks, and I've written at length about how the entire Foundation board is a bunch of useless MBA clowns that are here to suck from the golden teat.

But it doesn't matter, when the alternative is Google having absolute and total control of the web. Mozilla, for what they're still worth today, still have a weight. Write an article titled "Mozilla opposes API proposal X from Google for privacy reasons" and people will at the very least give it a listen. RFCs from them are listened to. The WHATWG has to at least pretend to hear them out.

Go on. Let Mozilla die. See what the web looks like when Google can push every API they want, unopposed. WEI would look like a walk in the park. Apple could say nuh uh we don't want to, and Google would do the exact same thing they did with Firefox: snuff it out. Microsoft wouldn't even need to be pressured to work with them, pissing off Apple sounds like a lovely distraction for them. Little by little, websites would stop working on Safari (not that they work quite well currently, most Safari users are doing it because of a complete lack of technical knowledge and it's the default browser, with three nerds on HN saying it's because it's better for their battery life), APIs unsupported because Apple isn't interested in the open web.

At best, you end up with an Apple Web, and a Google Web, both of them sucking ass in their own right. At worst, Apple becomes irrelevant because of their focus on native apps. Most of which are already Chromium wrappers anyways.

So yes. Pinch your nose and go in. Mozilla is worth the support, no matter what. Their leadership already sucks, what's the worst that could happen ? They keep sucking, but take back marketshare ? Good. For once, give them support instead of being the worst user in the world, the one the just shits on them for not being good enough, while flocking to Google anyways.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cxr on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:52PM (#37139156)
You seem to be replying to an argument no one is making (e.g. "Don't use Firefox"). Not sure why.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by dataangel on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:58PM (#37136301)
maybe don't forget that firefox probably would have died a much sooner death if mozilla hadn't been google's pet charity project though. mozilla has yet to demonstrate really being a self sustaining organization
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by iscream26 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @02:05PM (#37137250)
Corporations (and the wealthy in general) don't do charity. The tacit objetive of every corporation is and will always be profits über alles. Every time you see a corporation donating money to some cause there's an ulterior motive that ultimately grows their bottom line. The most common motives are: pay less taxes (or none at all), PR move to improve their public image, and, finally, publicity (sometimes because of controversy).

Now, of course, Google's financial relationship with Mozilla is no exception. The stated reason is that they give money to Mozilla in exchange for having Google as the default search engine, but its actual purpose is to mitigate claims about Google having a monopoly on the browser market and thereby avoid anti-trust laws.

If Firefox were to gain the majority of the marketshare Google would no longer have an incentive to give them money. Mozilla wouldn't be happy about that because they'd lose their biggest source of income. And Google wouldn't be happy either because they make money through web ads and harvesting data to sell it to ad companies, and there's no better way to go about doing that than creating their own web browser and a whole ecosystem surrounding it, and then making sure it's the most popular one.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by SubiculumCode on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:11PM (#37135709)
1. I use firefox in Windows, Linux, and Android. I am NOT suffering.

2. Most people aren't actively choosing their web browser. For example, my wife uses the Samsung web browser on her phone because that is the default.

3. Most people think Google is the internet, can't distinguish between the browser and the google webpage, etc.

4. A dwindling marketshare percentage does not directly imply old userspe are moving from Firefox to another browser, it could imply that new users don't know/use firefox

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:58PM (#37136305)
>4. A dwindling marketshare percentage does not directly imply old userspe are moving from Firefox to another browser, it could imply that new users don't know/use firefox

You're right that it could theoretically mean that, but unfortunately monthly active users have actually fallen by ~20% since 2019 according to Mozilla:

https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/user-activity

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:15PM (#37136592)
It may also just mean more users are opting out of telemetry. Given Mozilla's privacy focus in their marketing and their UX, it may not be a shock that a large number of users are also opting out of even Mozilla's telemetry.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by SubiculumCode on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:38PM (#37136910)
I do.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by wslh on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:17PM (#37135796)
> Can we stop pretending that this is mozilla's fault

Clearly it is Mozilla fault: the world is not fair, if they are where they are they should crunch their resources and win. Google haven't started being the home of most computers. It is the nature of competition. Is it hard? Sure.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:33PM (#37136016)
"The world is not fair" in part because we refuse to punish Google for their blatantly anti-consumer practice of purposely making their websites work worse on non-chrome browsers and advertising chrome on every google property.

How the fuck is mozilla supposed to compete with a GIANT that is nearly everyone's homepage? Even if they had comparable budgets (Which they don't) mozilla still wouldn't get the free advertising that google gives chrome

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by wslh on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:56PM (#37136279)
I think the Mozilla foundation has enough money to lobby about monopolistic practices. Did they?

If your argument would be 100% true there will be no innovation or market dynamics. Business history has proven that one day you are at the top and another you aren't anymore.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:51PM (#37137068)
If firefox sued google over monopolistic practices, that lawsuit would have to be funded completely by google. Google is 80% of firefox's revenue and 0% of its expenditure.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:48PM (#37137032)
> purposely making their websites work worse on non-chrome browsers

This is wild exaggeration that I never hear about except from people defending the mismanagement of Firefox. I've used Firefox since forever, and I don't have much trouble anywhere that I can remember. The browser works. This is an article showing that it's outperforming Chrome on some metrics. It's Firefox's business and design decisions that wreck their browser. It went from being awesome to being janky Chrome that calls you abusive when you complain that they put an ad for a tv show in your browser.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by tristan957 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:33PM (#37136012)
If you use anti-trust practices to get your foothold, it isn't fair.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by n0tinventedhere on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#37136192)
I find it amazing how people forget that being a monopolistic power doesn't help if your product sucks: Google has, time and time again, failed to gain traction in the messaging app market on Android, the market being entirely occupied by competitors like WhatsApp.

Chrome won partly because of the marketing and being preinstalled, sure, but also by being a good product. If nagging people to install Chrome was all it took to win, then why is Edge in such a precarious position on Windows with all the nagging Windows 10 and 11 brought? Microsoft failed to succeed time and time again.

People on HN have weird preconceptions about how suggestion and marketing works.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Dah00n on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:22PM (#37136688)
I don't know where you are from but you seem very biased to your own friend or country bubble. For reference I don't know anyone at all who use WhatsApp. I use Google Chat and Facebook Messenger with a few but SMS with Google's RCS with everyone else, including my younger and much older family members.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by wslh on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:30PM (#37136817)
WhatsApp is used all over Europe and Latin America. Very easy to check. For example [1].

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1311229/whatsapp-usage-m...

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Dah00n on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:42PM (#37136959)
According to statista.com 12% use WhatsApp in Denmark. As I said, living in a bubble if one believes everyone uses it.

Edit: A quick search said this from the same source:

>Using WhatsApp less often than once a month was the most common usage frequency among Danes in 2019, according to 23 percent of the service users. 15 percent used the app weekly and 13 percent used it several times a day.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by wslh on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @06:53PM (#37154942)
Please don't joke about Denmark, it has a population of 6m. Anyway, it is easy to check what I said, I am from Latam and anyone uses WP.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by n0tinventedhere on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:58PM (#37137159)
I live in France, and WhatsApp has a pretty big presence. Not a monopoly style one though, there's plenty of other apps used: Facebook Messenger, Skype, Snapchat, Discord.. I have friends who have family in other countries and some different apps will be dominant, like Viber, but the common theme is that the only time I've seen people use SMS is when they're unsure as to whether the other person has any other means of communication. Most importantly, I've never seen someone use Google's own non-RCS chat apps, like Google Chat, Google Hangout, Google Allo, Google Talk.. Google has had many chat apps, sometimes just different names for the same thing, but in the end, they have no users here. Google continuously tried to make a dent in that market and failed.

RCS is a non-starter if you need to do group chats with iPhone users or send them pictures without a massive loss in quality, as iPhones do not support RCS. As long as Apple refuses to support it, it will continue being a terrible choice in any country with significant Apple user base. An Android user with WhatsApp shares an identical experience with an iPhone user with WhatsApp. RCS on the other hand will drop you back to what cell phone messaging was many decades ago.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:46PM (#37138435)
>I find it amazing how people forget that being a monopolistic power doesn't help if your product sucks:

Which is why none of our companies use microsoft teams, right? Or wait, maybe when it comes to products that aren't that different, what comes with the package matters.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:20PM (#37135831)
That never stopped Phoenix in the early days, or Chrome itself in its early days. Firefox just offers nothing substantial over Chrome and breaks a lot of sites. And over the last decade it kept pushing crapware and spam on you, right in the browser.

Mozilla mismanaged it to hell. They don't even really care about the browser anymore.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by radicaldreamer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:23PM (#37135882)
Which sites don’t work with Firefox?

Safari is a huge simply due to iOS but it’s a shame that Apple stopped maintaining the windows port.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:43PM (#37136130)
Sadly I don't remember anymore. I ran into plenty of them 3 or 4 years ago (every week or so), then I stopped using Firefox altogether because of that. At work, some coworkers were using Firefox last year and it broke various third party libraries (especially graphics heavy ones). Rather than trying to fix the bugs, we just decided to deprecate Firefox support altogether because its usage was down to like 2 or 3 percent. Those resources were better spent on, say, improving mobile usability and performance for everyone.

Edit: I wish Mozilla would just fork Chromium and add/delete whatever privacy things they want, like Brave. There's no reason to maintain Gecko anymore.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by n0tinventedhere on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:56PM (#37136273)
I didn't have websites outright breaking on FF like solardev, but I had other issues with it, like cloudflare getting me into an infinite loop of asking me if I'm human and not letting me browse the website. This happened even if I deleted my firefox profile and started fresh with no extension. Note that this behavior of Cloudflare is highly dependent on the settings of their anti-ddos stuff, some websites have it set on a higher level of defensive behavior than others, I didn't have this issue everywhere.

This wasn't due to my computer's IP, the problem went away the moment I browsed the same website with Chrome, and this time I wasn't even asked to click the checkbox to prove that I'm human.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by wintermutestwin on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:45PM (#37136164)
>Firefox just offers nothing substantial over Chrome

Hah! Let's see you try to use vertical tabs in Chrome. If you ever have more than 8 tabs open at once, Horizontal tabs are clearly inferior.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:42PM (#37136956)
Firefox is still hostile to vertical tabs, adding a useless sidebar header that can be hidden with css, but you have to know that and spend the possible hours it could take to figure out how. Then, since that's unsupported, you have to prepare for it to possibly be broken after every update.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:01PM (#37136360)
Anecdote: I tried that back in the Netcaptor days but it didn't really stick (or something like it, anyway). Having to read a long list isn't particularly fast for me, personally, so I just use a combination of multiple windows (one per context, and easy to switch between on Mac) and the search engines feature (where you can make custom keyword lookups for Wikipedia, Stackoverflow, etc.) to quickly look things up. Chrome also has collapsible tab groups and pinnable tabs now, but it's not particularly great.

I never have more than 4 or 5 tabs open at a time, closing them as I'm done with them. If I need to recover them later they're always in the history.

I'm sure Firefox and other browsers offer some power user features that's good for some folks. I just don't care enough.

As a user I just want to see the information I need without tinkering with settings, and Chrome does that well. As a web dev I'd much rather focus on UX than cross browser compatibility, and the Blink/Webkit duopoly makes that possible in a way that standards never did (and still don't). So there's just no need for Firefox in my personal or work life. YMMV of course.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by wintermutestwin on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#37136201)
>Firefox just offers nothing substantial over Chrome

Hah! Let's see you try to use vertical tabs in Chrome. If you ever have more than 8 tabs open at once, Horizontal tabs are clearly inferior.

Brave and Edge can do vertical tabs natively, but chrome doesn't. The extensions I have tried in Chrome are as unusable as Safari's native vertical tabs implementation.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:38PM (#37136900)
> Hah! Let's see you try to use vertical tabs in Chrome. If you ever have more than 8 tabs open at once, Horizontal tabs are clearly inferior.

That's it, though. If Firefox breaks that again, like they intentionally broke it before, that 3% usage will drop down to 2%.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by madars on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:59PM (#37136322)
What Firefox definitely offers is uBlock Origin on Android. Augment it with anti-paywall blocklists and the experience is basically a killer feature for Android over iOS. I use Chrome on desktop (mostly for better sandboxing) but on mobile there is no real competition between Firefox and Chrome: Firefox just wins.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by kilolima on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:26PM (#37136739)
Except there's no way to export your bookmarks on android out of Firefox without using their sync service. I think this omission (a simple export!) speaks volumes about Mozilla's true goal of browser lock-in and another example of their chronic mismanagement.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:40PM (#37138354)
Ah yes browser lock in, from the company that makes zero dollars selling their browser, compared to the company that wants to actively harm the open internet.

What's wrong with you guys? Could google stab you in the face and you still swear up and down that firefox is negligibly slower than chrome? What will it take? Google is pushing a "feature" to completely lock down the internet, take away all meaning from "user-agent", and make blocking ads functionally impossible! When will you stop aiding and abetting this behavior because you feel mozilla is "not perfect"

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:05PM (#37138671)
In truth I just don't really care? We've gone through this cycle so many times with various kinds of DRM, from DVD CSS to Denovo to WideVine to Adobe Cloud to various other schemes that at the end of the day just aren't big deals.

A lot of the tech echo chamber bandwagons and freaks out about things like this, but I bet in a few years it'll turn out either a non issue or else alternate browsers will naturally rise to popularity. No point fussing about it beforehand. In the meantime Chrome just works, Google is whatever, Firefox is annoying, and Mozilla just feels irrelevant.

Shrug. I feel way more annoyed by Firefox than anything Google's ever done. Whatever their ideology, their product just isn't great.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:04PM (#37136414)
You can get the same experience (but across all apps) using Adguard, which acts as a fake VPN and MITM certificate. No more ads in any app, while still keeping your Chrome synced tabs and logins and such between devices.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by madars on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:41PM (#37136951)
Is the experience really equal? E.g. uBlock Origin operates at the DOM layer so it can and does block dynamically generated content using CSS selectors. Does Adguard simply inject the same DOM-aware JS in every page?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:00PM (#37138611)
I dunno, but it's good enough. And way more useful to block in app ads than to be limited to the browser only. Of course you can use both if you want, but then you'd have to use Firefox or another browser.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Dah00n on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:13PM (#37136555)
VPN and MITM?! What a horrible horrible security nightmare!
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by solardev on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:59PM (#37138599)
It sure is. But what a great user experience afterward! Security and convenience are usually tradeoffs, and in this case it's totally worth it.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by lost_tourist on Thursday August 17, 2023 @02:28AM (#37157952)
better extension environment

much better privacy

practically the same experience while surfing

keeps competition going

ublock origin actually works as it was meant to

mozilla didn't forget what "do no evil" and "open internet" means

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mda on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:21PM (#37135840)
Note that in the Phoronix post it also mentions in the modern and demanding Jetstream benchmark, Firefox is still way behind. While seeing improvements is good, Sunspider is a very old microbenchmark not sure how relevant it is.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by TX81Z on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:31PM (#37135980)
Uh, clearly you don’t know anybody who actually worked there? Management is very very very unpopular and they’ve been facing a massive brain drain for years.

Because they do have a great browser, but have a horrible strategy and have wasted money in any number of ways, and made themselves wholly dependent on Google for handouts.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by leviathant on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:33PM (#37136009)
>Ah yes, so Firefox is faster than chrome, allows you more latitude for adblockers, and isn't pushing garbage hostile web standards, but clearly, mozilla just isn't doing enough

>How many average users even KNOW about firefox anymore?

A hard lesson I learned at my last company was that it's not enough to have the better product. Better marketing and better relationships will, more often than not, trump a better fitting solution to a problem. It sucks, but it's real.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:43PM (#37138400)
Yeah! In fact, I would say a large portion of this is every android phone coming with Chrome pre-installed, and you know, that entire decade google spent with literal super bowl advertisements and THE GOOGLE DOT COM WEBSITE URGING YOU TO INSTALL CHROME with a mountain of dark patterns that plenty of smarter people than I have written about.

Can you imagine the fucking fit HN would throw if mozilla dared to buy a super bowl ad?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ido on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:14PM (#37136569)
It’s not about speed, compatibility with Firefox is actually getting worse. I switched (back) to FF and DDG a few months ago and FF is having trouble with multiple websites I use on occasion (for an example off the top of my head, if I want to log-in to Haaretz.co.il to get past pay walls I have to use safari as FF doesn’t manage to log in).

This is still the small minority of sites but I keep safari and chrome around as it still happens often enough.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by darklycan51 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:21PM (#37136665)
I am a tab hoarder, and on multiple different operating systems, with different installs, etc.

Firefox ALWAYS seems to have random leaks after weeks that other browsers don't have, once I saw Firefox taking 24GBs of RAM, while Edge and Brave on the same or more tabs and time were taking only ~2-3gb of RAM.

This has been going on since at least 2019-2020 or so, when I started dropping Firefox because of this behavior. It is just random websites that seem to cause leaks but this has never happened with Edge or Brave and no website should really be breaking a browser like this, the system becomes unusable after a while.

They are seemingly unable to fix the issue or pretend it doesn't exist even when its reported so I basically had to stop using FF as my main browser.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by burkaman on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:54AM (#37134741)
I wouldn't expect Manifest V3 to have any effect until Manifest V2 is actually disabled and ad blockers stop working. Approximately 0% of Chrome users are following technical browser announcements, they won't care until their stuff actually breaks.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by tapoxi on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#37135059)
The Manifest v3 version of uBlock Origin (uBlock Lite) has been out for a long time now, and it still works its just less effective.

For people using Opera, Brave, Vivaldi, Arc, etc it won't impact them. Their adblockers are all native and not using the extension API.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by comte7092 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:07AM (#37134889)
Have to agree here. Most people have no idea what manifest v whatever is and have no reason to switch.

Not to mention, google pulls its own underhanded tactics.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yorwba on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:14AM (#37134997)
Even among Firefox users, only about 41% have add-ons installed in the first place: https://data.firefox.com/dashboard/usage-behavior So 59% of current Firefox users could switch to Chrome without being affected by the Manifest V3 change at all.

I don't know how many Chrome users use add-ons that would become less useful after the change, so it'll definitely be interesting to see whether Firefox's numbers will show a sudden uptick at some point.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by arp242 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:21AM (#37135102)
I expect that number to be biased since more tech-savvy users tend to disable/block telemetry, and they're also the sort of people who install add-ons. I have no idea if it's biased by 1%, 10%, or 50% though.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toastal on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#37135611)
Even still, add-ons have always been a Fx selling point so I’m still quite shocked.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ComputerGuru on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#37135612)
Not really. Firefox blocks more things out of the box for a better browsing experience than Chrome does. But I admit that there’s a good chance that at least some not-insignificant percentage of those 41% wouldn’t notice and realize that they would need to install uBlock to use Chrome comparably.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by caskstrength on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:07PM (#37135668)
> Even among Firefox users, only about 41% have add-ons installed in the first place

This seems like surprisingly low percentage. I wonder whether these stats count people who disable telemetry or install add-ons from their distro's repository.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by bee_rider on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:12PM (#37135727)
Firefox should really (somehow or another) come with ublock origin installed and on by default.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by infamia on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @03:40PM (#37138349)
This isn't accurate since Firefox comes with a built-in ad blocker, which Chrome lacks.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by LordDragonfang on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:26AM (#37135153)
There was a huge wave of anti-chrome propaganda about how manifest v3 would prevent all ad-blocking* on Reddit and Tumblr (and probably tiktok) and such. even if none of them read the actual announcements, the low-info folks still learn about it from the outrage machine.

*Which isn't actually true; "cosmetic" blocking (altering the DOM), the original type and the one most users actually care about, will still work just fine. It's only privacy tracking which is going to be totally broken, and frankly, outside of the unreality bubble of HN, most users care much less about "privacy" than you'd think.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by vxNsr on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:07PM (#37135665)
Not sure why you’re being downvoted. I agree, I myself was waiting for ublock to stop working before I migrated to Firefox but now that I’m hearing it will still mostly work… I just don’t care that much. So they collect all this info on me… as long as I don’t see ads I just don’t care
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by croes on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:12PM (#37135723)
Just because people don't care doesn't mean it's unimportant.

So these limitations of manifest V3 don't exist?:

>One of the main issues with Manifest V3 is its limitation to filter lists: an extension can only include up to 50 static lists, and only 10 of them can be active at the same time.

>There are also limitations to the number of filter rules inside these lists: installed extensions cannot collectively exceed 300,000 static filters and it is no longer possible to update

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by LordDragonfang on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:52PM (#37136223)
I never said it wasn't important, but it is misinformation. Case and point: to answer your question, no, those aren't limitations on DOM-manipulation ad removal; those are limitations on the new declarativeNetRequest API, and they ONLY apply to blocked web requests.

Also, even that part isn't as catastrophic as you'd think; ad blocking, like most things on the internet, roughly follows the 90-10 rule: 90% of the ads are blocked by 10% of the rules. So even with a tenfold reduction, you should still see the vast majority of the ads blocked by even the intentionally-gimped declarativeNetRequest API.

Yes, it's going to make ad blockers slightly less effective and make your page loads slightly slower. But that doesn't get as many clicks as "Chrome is banning adblockers!!1". And it's important to note the difference because when v3 rolls around, all those users that were lied to are going to see that their ad blockers still mostly work, and lose even more trust in whistle blowing.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by croes on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @02:19AM (#37143446)
>Chrome is banning adblockers

You forgot the part where Google postponed the original timetable for the deprecation of manifest v2. Without that postponement, developers would not have had enough time to change the extension so that there would have been a time when adblockers were banned. The outcry prevented that.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by dataangel on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:01PM (#37136352)
> It's only privacy tracking which is going to be totally broken, and frankly, outside of the unreality bubble of HN, most users care much less about "privacy" than you'd think.

explaining this distinction is actually enough to drive me to switch thanks

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by hooverd on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:22PM (#37138878)
If that's their takeaway about Chrome, good.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:25AM (#37135142)
Manifest v3 announcement feels like a pretty arbitrary line to draw in the sand.

> I don't think Mozilla is managed well enough to actually compete against Chrome. We'd need the Linux Foundation or some other large neutral standards body to fork Chromium

Ah, yes, Linux, the OS used on something like 3% of desktop machines! I'm sorry but I don't see the logic at work here at all. Chrome dominates because Google pushes it and they have the means to reach basically every internet user out there. Switching out Mozilla for the Linux Foundation would do absolutely zero to counter that. Case in point: by most measures ChromeOS has a higher desktop market share than vanilla Linux already.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by sam0x17 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:58AM (#37135548)
Linux accounts for:

82% of the smartphone market

90% of public cloud workloads

62% of the embedded market

99% of the super-computer market

The first figure alone makes it more relevant to the general population than windows or any other OS.

Let's see, 55% of all web traffic is mobile devices so that means roughly 45% of all web traffic comes from linux-based smartphones.

And that isn't counting things like Chrome OS, or linux desktop browsing, which account for another 2-4%

So roughly 49% of all web traffic is literal user-facing linux devices, and 90% of the websites they are browsing are served by linux servers...

So yeah, if anything linux is probably the most important OS in existence right now. Definitely not obscure..

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#37135609)
And how much of that 82% is attributable to the Linux Foundation as opposed to Google?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Krutonium on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:44PM (#37136139)
100%, because Google is using Linux?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:55PM (#37136258)
That makes no sense. 82% of the market is using Linux not because of the inherent goodness of the OS, it’s because Google chose to use it. If they change their mind tomorrow (see Project Fuschia and all that) there isn’t anything the Linux Foundation would be able to do about that.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by sam0x17 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @08:24PM (#37141166)
This isn't true at all. Most people are using containers anyway, and guess what they're running in those containers...

ASP.net had it's day, and everyone wanted to instead run their .NET apps on linux rather than deal with windows licensing and security issues, which is why mono was so popular

Other things had their chance too, like MacOS-based hosting, and it never really took off, again because people don't want to manage closed-source production systems that they can't simply patch themselves.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by sam0x17 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @12:03PM (#37149147)
Public clouds don't dictate what people use. You can freely run windows or any other OS on an AWS or Google VPS, it's just people very seldom choose to do so, because (this is the punchline), linux is just that much more popular and developer-friendly.

The domination of linux in the hosting / server world predates the existence of public clouds. I was there, I remember.

At the turn of the millennium for a very very brief time there were a lot of windows servers running ASP.NET. That was it. Nothing has come close to linux since then, and it has absolutely nothing to do with what AWS/GCP offers. What they offer is entirely beholding to what developers like.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by postalrat on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:14AM (#37134987)
Why does the announcement of manifest v3 mean anything? They keep pushing the date v2 will no longer work back. Why?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by pessimizer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:59PM (#37137176)
Because they've already taken the media heat for the switch a half dozen times, each time less intensely. Eventually, when they finally switch it off, there will be one article about it on the Register, and it will be mostly jokes.

It's a tactic.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by gowld on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:18AM (#37135043)
Extensions including ad blockers don't work at all on Android Chrome.

I use Chrome on desktop because websites work properly in Chrome, and Firefox on Android for the adblocker, except when a site is unusable.

What is FF marketshare on Android?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by jeffreygoesto on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:22AM (#37135106)
Us two probably?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toastal on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:07PM (#37135654)
Make it trouble.

I really wish the timing of FxOS was better as well as the marketing. I’d certainly choose it over Android, but we’re now sort of locked into the duopoly with terrible decisions from apps like Signal requiring you have a Android or iOS primary device or no service for you.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by josteink on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:50AM (#37135429)
> Call me a pessimist but I don't think Mozilla is managed well enough

No disagreement there.

> We'd need the Linux Foundation

Who spends a whooping’ 3% of their total spending on actual Linux? [1]

Call me a pessimist, but I might look for a better candidate.

[1] https://lunduke.substack.com/p/linux-foundation-spends-just-...

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:51AM (#37135442)
I’m confused why people would move away from Firefox to Chrome because of Manifest v3. If anything, it should convince one to move even harder in the other direction.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by gattilorenz on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:29PM (#37135957)
Indeed, the point OP is trying to make is that despite Manifest v3, Firefox is nevertheless still losing users (to highlight how dire the situation for Firefox is).
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by rgrieselhuber on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:36PM (#37136049)
Got it, thanks for clarifying. Definitely points to a management problem IMO.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by remram on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:44PM (#37136138)
Where does this data come from?

I use Firefox because I am privacy-conscious, as a result I have telemetry turned off. Do people like me show up in those stats?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by lamontcg on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:45PM (#37136155)
> We'd need the Linux Foundation or some other large neutral standards body to fork Chromium

Why is the answer always more chromium?

And for a userbase nominally so positively biased towards open source it is weird to see how google gets a pass on pretty much everything, while mozilla/firefox has this incredibly carefully curated list of offenses that is maintained and spread by the community, doing most of the work at ensuring that firefox never goes anywhere. There's a lot of Linux proponents here who are doing all the heavy work of carrying water for Google when it comes to chrome dominance.

Yeah, so every time you actually restart firefox after it updates you probably get an ad for mozilla VPN. Okay compare that to Google literally being the central advertising and spyware hub of the entire internet. "I'll just have to use the worst option possible, because the alternative isn't 100% ideologically pure".

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by hooverd on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @04:24PM (#37138893)
Nobody hates FOSS more than FOSS users.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by m_a_g on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:45AM (#37134620)
I tried migrating from Chrome to Firefox with the recent developments. The user experience of Mozilla could be better, imo.

After not liking Firefox, I tried four more browsers: Orion, Arch, Brave, and Vivaldi. I finally landed on using Brave.

After you turn off everything related to crypto, it becomes a great and user-friendly browser with adversarial interoperability with Chrome. It's the only browser with an actual chance of beating Chrome by convincing its users to migrate.

I'm hoping they can continue maintaining the Chromium fork (it's an actual fork, by the way), as it'll get harder and harder as it diverges more and more.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by matsemann on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:28AM (#37135173)
What's wrong with the user experience? To me they're all the same there: you have tabs and a toolbar and the rest is the webpage. Little else I actually interface with in a normal day.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Novosell on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:55AM (#37134754)
It's not an actual fork, by the way. Them saying so doesn't make it so. It uses chromium as a base and applies quite a lot of patches. Otherwise every chromium based browser is a fork, despite all pulling in more or less all upstream patches?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:26AM (#37135144)
More importantly: being a fork or not doesn't matter! As long as the Brave team is not able to write their own browser engine that could compete with chromium, they are stuck with whatever development goes into chromium. "Oh it's just patches and things", but it won't be forever, and we WILL see work go into chromium that is deep enough to be difficult to untangle and subtly designed to to force you into whatever path google wants. There will be a day where Brave is unable to degoogle chromium to a useful point. Participating in a chromium browser is only helping google, and there's no way around that.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Karunamon on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:32AM (#37135219)
… Taking an upstream project, and then applying your own patches to it, along with a commitment to not ship anti-user changes (like manifest V3) is a fork by any objective definition.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Novosell on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @10:53AM (#37148012)
I find nothing saying they didn't implement manifest V3. The only info I can find from them is that their own adblocker, which isn't an extension, will continue to work[0] and that, for example, ublock will continue to work as long as google doesn't remove manifest v2 support.[0] Seems odd to me that what Google does to manifest V2 matters at all to Brave, if Brave is indeed a fork and not just chromium with a skin.

0: https://twitter.com/brave/status/1574822799700541446

1: https://twitter.com/BrendanEich/status/1534893414579249152

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by gowld on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:23AM (#37135119)
OK it's a branch.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by r053bud on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:02PM (#37135593)
Maybe I'm naive, but Brave doing anything with crypto doesn't inspire confidence in their long-term product vision. Why does a browser need a business model?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Bloating on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#37136202)
Why do developers need to be paid?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by freediver on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:51PM (#37136214)
What was your experience with Orion and why do you think it does not have a chance of convincing Chrome users to migrate?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by matheusmoreira on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:54AM (#37134743)
The real shame is Mozilla cutting back on Firefox development despite being a billion dollar corporation. Google would have had no leverage to push stuff like WEI if Firefox was the dominant browser.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toyg on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:05AM (#37134873)
Tbf, they cut back because they thought that, strategically, they needed a competitive mobile OS. Unfortunately, regardless of whether it was the right decision, they then mismanaged development of such OS (particularly on the commercial side).
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by fabrice_d on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#37135055)
Not sure in which reality you're living, but FirefoxOS was developed at Mozilla from 2011 to 2016, before any cut back. Mozilla Corp actually grew a lot during that time.

About FxOS being mismanaged, well... you have to understand that if you follow a model where you rely on others for distribution (carriers and open market OEMs), you are bound to their constraints. In that case, it was a chicken and egg situation where selling devices without a WhatsApp app was very difficult, but WA didn't want to develop an app for a new OS until it grew to tens of millions of users.

Then Moz top management lost some key proponents of the project, and the FirefoxOS haters got their wish. I still don't understand why Mitchel Baker didn't agree to support a community based project (like Thunderbird) or try a strong privacy based spin.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toast0 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:53AM (#37135478)
> In that case, it was a chicken and egg situation where selling devices without a WhatsApp app was very difficult, but WA didn't want to develop an app for a new OS until it grew to tens of millions of users.

Disclosure: I worked at WA during the FirefoxOS time period as well as when the KaiOS client was developed and launched.

I honestly don't remember the internal sentiment on FirefoxOS, and I don't know if Mozilla ever approached WA to ask for a client. But the public interfaces for apps were insufficient for a WhatsApp client, so that's a bigger issue. The KaiOS client (which afaik, Jio approached FB/WA to ask for) was difficult to build in part because the OS was missing important features for apps, and that takes time and collaboration to get added to the OS and then pushed out to users.

From memory, the major missing interfaces were around access to TCP sockets and ability to run code that accesses the network in response to a (silent) push message that optionally submits a notification for the user. If FirefoxOS didn't have push messaging (I can't remember), then ability to keep a socket open always and post notifications at will would suffice. Arbitrary tcp sockets are needed because the chat protocol is not http based; running code on pushes is required for e2e, so sender names can be populated from the device's address book, and to avoid notification horrors. Horrors include getting a notification about a message you can't read because the client hasn't fetched it yet and getting a notification about messages you've already read; WhatsApps model is the client is the source of truth, and so there's no reason to accept notification horrors that are common with server source of truth systems. e2e was under development for quite some time, so even if the public timelines don't match up, it would be a requirement for supporting new OSes.

For calling, access to UDP sockets would also be needed as well as ability to run native code as the voice codec and data marshalling is in C; although Firefox OS came out before WhatsApp calling. Calling didn't make it to all platforms, and would have been an acceptable thing to defer, IMHO.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by fabrice_d on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:29PM (#37135958)
Hi! Yes Mozilla approached WA (talks were held with Brian Acton if I remember correctly). We tried various workarounds:

- 3rd party clients. That worked initially, but WA was quite aggressive in breaking them, and once e2ee was added they stopped working.

- we wrote a j2me VM in Javascript (https://github.com/mozilla/pluotsorbet) to run the S40 version :) Perf was not good enough when dealing with java threads.

- we collaborated with a company (OpenMobile) to run the Android app in a container, rendering in a DOM element. That was a pain in term of OS integration, and OpenMobile finally didn't get the distribution agreement from WA.

I implemented the KaiOS additional APIs, basically exposing a subset of libsignal. You're right that there are missing pieces in the web stack for these apps - it's very frustrating that you can't rely on WebCrypto for all the e2ee. Let's hope WebAssembly will fix that!

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toast0 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:13PM (#37136550)
> - 3rd party clients. That worked initially, but WA was quite aggressive in breaking them, and once e2ee was added they stopped working.

Yeah, that happened. :/ I was mostly in favor of a light touch, but e2ee would have been a hard cutoff anyway, and we didn't have the desire to make a compliance program for 3rd party clients, so they just got the boot whenever they caused inconvenience. There would usually be a flurry of activity around individual changes, but afaik, third parties saw the writing on the wall when e2ee started showing up.

> - we wrote a j2me VM in Javascript (https://github.com/mozilla/pluotsorbet) to run the S40 version :) Perf was not good enough when dealing with java threads.

Wow, that's impressive! (and kind of terrible!) Were you able to leverage this for other things, I hope?

> - we collaborated with a company (OpenMobile) to run the Android app in a container, rendering in a DOM element. That was a pain in term of OS integration, and OpenMobile finally didn't get the distribution agreement from WA.

I was unaware of this. That's interesting to hear about. I think you're right from your earlier post, that user count would have pushed WA the other way, and that lack of WA support made it harder to get user count. Samsung (Tizen) and Jio (KaiOS) got WA to make clients by subsidizing handsets and leveraging user counts / other business relations; s40 got a client because Nokia was clearly going to sell at least a few million of them (s40 predates WA, of course, but the earlier ones never ran WA); same with WP7, although no client until 7.5, because the platform was missing pieces.

WebOS didn't get a client because the platform was missing pieces and didn't survive long enough to add them (lack of WA support wasn't really an issue, given the timing). MeeGo didn't get a client because Nokia cancelled the N9 before they launched it, and limited the release.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toyg on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:55AM (#37135520)
> FirefoxOS was developed at Mozilla from 2011 to 2016, before any cut back

It absorbed resources and focus, which resulted in the browser stalling development, which resulted in shrinking marketshare, which resulted in less money from the search deals, which resulted in the ongoing job losses.

> you have to understand that [hard realities of the mobile market that everyone knows already]

I don't disagree, but: none of that was new or unexpected when going in. That's why a lot of people thought FFOS was hopeless: because breaking the mobile duopoly is so hard, by then it had already claimed a giant (Nokia) and seriously humbled another (Microsoft). The play for the "developing market" and low-end devices was hopeless and misguided. We had just seen Nokia dying while trying to hang on that same market... There was a lot of wishful thinking in all the strategic moves, and unsurprisingly they didn't pan out.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by fabrice_d on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:41PM (#37136106)
> It absorbed resources and focus, which resulted in the browser stalling development, which resulted in shrinking marketshare, which resulted in less money from the search deals, which resulted in the ongoing job losses.

That's history revision. The browser development didn't stall because of FirefoxOS, it was slow for other reasons (look at the leadership team changes when the Quantum started).

Please remember that FxOS started in 2011. At the time WindowsPhone was quite new (first release in 2010), Samsung was pushing Tizen and Android was not nearly as dominant. Context matter. Mozilla already knew that Firefox would not be the default browser on Android (Google waited for Chrome to be ready to replace the crappy default one that was subpar compared to Firefox) so owning a platform was a logical step. It would still be better these days.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toast0 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:29PM (#37136791)
> The play for the "developing market" and low-end devices was hopeless and misguided.

I don't think that's right. The developing and low-end devices are probably the only plausible route into the phone market. Especially during the time period that FirefoxOS was active, there was a tremendous opportunity for a phone that cost very little and was widely available. I don't know that FirefoxOS could have really addressed that market, given their software stack, but the market was there. Wikipedia claims 23 million KaiOS devices were produced in Q1 2018; given that KaiOS is a fork of FirefoxOS, I think that's a demonstration that the targeting was fine. 23 million devices is a small chunk of the mobile market, but it's still a lot of devices.

Microsoft was making significant gains in market share with WP7 and WP8 by having devices that were low cost and worked much better than similar cost Androids. In the US, you could go out and get a $60 wp7 device or a $100 wp8 device when they were new and have a much more usable phone than a $150 Android. and an iPhone was like $400-$500 at the time. Microsoft had some high end wp7 and wp8 devices too, but not many people bought them, because high end iPhones and Androids worked well, and at that price point you're looking for different things. WM10 had promise and interesting features (Continuum might have been pretty cool, especially if Intel hadn't dropped development of x86 phones days before the Continuum public demo), but WM10 didn't run well on low end phones, so there were no low end WM10 phones, and user growth evaporated. (It doesn't help that WM10 included at least the 3rd new framework for windows phones in 3 generations, and called this one 'universal', which meant it only ran on the OS which had the least number of phones for its whole lifetime....)

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toyg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @11:52AM (#37148975)
> Microsoft was making significant gains in market share [...] Microsoft had some high end wp7 and wp8 devices too, but not many people bought them

And that's the problem: the phone market is fundamentally aspirational, phones are status-symbols, it's the high-end that directs the market. Yes, you can have a number of bottom-feeders at the cheap end, but they are fundamentally irrelevant: (almost) nobody buys a KaiOS device because of KaiOS, they buy a cheap phone that will run whatever OS ships with it. And the same was happening for Microsoft: people bought MS phones because they were cheap, and then chucked them away as soon as they could afford a flagship Android or iPhone.

If you cannot produce a flagship phone that people actually want to buy for the OS, for the experience, rather than for the price, you're having no impact whatsoever on the direction of the market, regardless of numbers. Nokia was still shipping hundreds of millions on cheap featurephones when it died on its ass.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toast0 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @02:15PM (#37151286)
I mean, maybe you both high end and low end, so there's something to aspire to, but on a global market, the majority of phones sold aren't flagships. And a new entrant isn't going to be able to sell a flagship phone with no apps; and you're not going to get apps without at least expected sales. Addressing the bottom of the market allows you to get sales to justify app development, and that allows you to make sales for high end phones plausible.

I don't use iOS devices, but I understand the experience is generally considered to be pleasant. The Android is really not that great; there's definitely room for someone to build something with UI that's not made of molasses; but it's going to be a real uphill slog to get it into the marketplace, and it's going to have to be driven by market share on the low end that goes upmarket over time.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toyg on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @02:38PM (#37151660)
> a new entrant isn't going to be able to sell a flagship phone with no apps; and you're not going to get apps without at least expected sales.

That's where you need the commercial talent to go out and make deals, build relationships, get mindshare before you even go to market. To do that, you need sexy software, a sexy experience that makes a difference, and a lot of money. A clunky OS targeting the low end will never be sexy, and you'll never convince developers to work on it "for the good of the web" or some other non-financial reason.

> The Android is really not that great; there's definitely room for someone to build something with UI that's not made of molasses

But the thing is, there really isn't. Android is actually pretty good, on flagship phones it works as well as iOS. There just isn't a massive quality gap to exploit. One needs a value proposition that changes the game, because you're not going anywhere with progressive enhancements.

> it's going to have to be driven by market share on the low end that goes upmarket over time.

Nobody has ever done that in post-2007 mobile. Nobody. Every player that saw the low-end as strategic, went there to die. As Microsoft demonstrated, it's a road to nowhere. You need to make a splash at the top end, make headlines, make people want it, or you'll never move the needle.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toast0 on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @03:01PM (#37151978)
> That's where you need the commercial talent to go out and make deals, build relationships, get mindshare before you even go to market. To do that, you need sexy software, a sexy experience that makes a difference, and a lot of money. A clunky OS targeting the low end will never be sexy, and you'll never convince developers to work on it "for the good of the web" or some other non-financial reason.

I think I agree with most of this. But on the other hand, Jio was able to make KaiOS "sexy-ish" by promising to gather millions of new to smartphone users, only possible because of the low cost. And they delivered, and apps showed up, at least a little. That's not because the phones were sexy, or people were excited to buy them, or because they're not clunky, or because of some open web BS; it's because the phones were cheap and capable enough and the numbers were there. Mozilla clearly wasn't able to build the relationships to get there as we know from history, but it was able to be done with Firefox OS because Jio did it with the fork.

> Nobody has ever done that in post-2007 mobile. Nobody. Every player that saw the low-end as strategic, went there to die. As Microsoft demonstrated, it's a road to nowhere. You need to make a splash at the top end, make headlines, make people want it, or you'll never move the needle.

If anything, Microsoft's WM10 flop proved it. WP7 and WP8 were doing ok, WM10 didn't address the low end and the sales disappeared[1]. Is 2.5 - 3% market share great? No, but they had a reasonable bump after WP8 (q4 2012) and WP8.1 (q2 2014), and a proper release of WM10 (q4 2015) likely would have been another bump instead of a rather quick demise. It didn't help that there were signs that the WM10 release was not a quality release and that Microsoft had plans to abandon the platform; I was interested in a phone at the time, and could see that a) there was nothing worth buying for WP8.1, b) nothing worth waiting for on WM10, c) Microsoft didn't care, so I should start making my way towards the door.

Like I said, it's an uphill slog. You've got to make consistent releases that don't suck, which isn't easy.

[1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/236034/global-smartphone...

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by toastal on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:10PM (#37135695)
Capyloon is an alternative trying to carry the FxOS torch, but its focus on IPFS & things other than telephony make it hard to recommend if you can’t use a phone as a phone.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by fabrice_d on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:36PM (#37136045)
Thanks for the mention! Capyloon (https://capyloon.org) had a grant from Protocol Labs (the IPFS stewards) in 2022 so we focused quite a bit on that indeed. We learned a lot - especially about the maturity and usability of the IPFS stack.

I'm still very bullish on the dWeb pieces: content based addressing, UCANs (https://ucan.xyz/) for distributed auth, new web app models (https://hackmd.io/@robin-berjon/tiles) to create an ecosystem that is not locked by centralized app stores.

There's a lot to do, all contributions are welcome (frontend, device ports, platform apis...). We have a Matrix channel (https://matrix.to/#/#capyloon:matrix.org) and you can try desktop builds easily following the steps at https://github.com/capyloon/nutria#quick-start

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cxr on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @05:17PM (#37139389)
> Moz top management lost some key proponents of the project, and the FirefoxOS haters got their wish

That's an interesting way to say that the people who foresaw its imminent failure were correct—but (conveniently) does so in a way that not only downplays[1] the correctness of their prediction, but also maligns them by ever-so-subtly suggesting the reader consider whether blame for the resulting failure shouldn't perhaps be shifted onto those who made the prediction [1 again, unfortunately]...

1. <https://web.archive.org/web/20201022224913/https://www.colby...>

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by gowld on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:25AM (#37135134)
Giving up on a failing browser, and trying to make a whole OS instead, is insane. The OS is much harder.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:29AM (#37135186)
IMO it's not insane (and they didn't give up on their browser in order to do it).

It was a Hail Mary for sure but really their only way to be competitive on mobile. iOS and Android are both owned by direct competitors in the browser space, Mozilla is never going to be given a fair shot there. FirefoxOS would have their way to rectify that and I think we would have all benefitted from greater competition in the mobile market. But alas, it was never to be.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by twobitshifter on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:01PM (#37135586)
Meanwhile firefoxOS as kaios has been successful in their goals. There are likely more kaiOS users than firefox users at this point. That points to there being a commercial solution that Mozilla missed, as you say.

In terms of being the right idea, the idea of firefox OS was great and really needed in the face of chromebooks popping up and iOS dominance. I can’t imagine building a browser and not also planning a response to mobile lock-in and cloud based devices.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by Justsignedup on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:07AM (#37134890)
Personally I think ms did the right thing. Edge compatibility is no longer an issue and their maintenance cost plumetted.

I still love Firefox. Not seeing ads anywhere is worth whatever warts I hit

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by nomilk on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:09AM (#37134923)
What are firefox's warts ooc?
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mrguyorama on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:32AM (#37135213)
Usually it's some nitpick about the time they advertised Mr. Robot "breaking our trust", or buying pocket, a bookmarking utility that lots of people liked and used and integrating it into the web browser, which is clearly a user-hostile move, to buy and integrate functionality that might be useful. With such horrible missteps, you should obviously instead use the browser that has pushed MULTIPLE APIs with negligible real world use and significant fingerprinting capacity, lead the change to limit add-on functionality, makes it harder to block ads (BECAUSE THEY ARE AN ADVERTISING COMPANY), sends most of what you do to their advertising engine, and FUCKING WEI.

Or, oh no, the CEO of the foundation makes more than they do as an engineer at google, that must be corruption! Meanwhile Firefox is faster, less buggy, has never stopped being a very good browser and the only one made by a group that can't subsidize it, and doesn't get to shove it's advertising down your throat on every single website that Google owns.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by px43 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:34AM (#37135233)
> It was actually a huge bummer for me when Edge gave in and switched to Chromium

I don't get it.. that was the day that open source won the web. There are now no major closed source browser engines remaining. It was a massive indication that in the end, open source software will always win in any market. We just needed Google to dump in billions of dollars to help accelerate the process, but they did that, and now we're all better off for it.

Now we just need Windows, OSX, and iOS to die out, and the whole world will be running on open source software.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by xibo9 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:41AM (#37135319)
Hard pass. Monocultures are bad.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by px43 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:59PM (#37136319)
What monoculture? There is an incredibly rich ecosystem of Chromium forks, all playing with different ideas for how the web should work. There's a nice, clean, stable base for people to work with, and extend upon. This seems like the ideal scenario.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by theallan on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#37135394)
I think the GP is more disappointed that Microsoft choose to use Blink rather than Gecko as their rendering engine. Not that they abandoned the closed source EdgeHTML.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ragnese on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:34PM (#37136020)
Free software and open source software are great. But, web pages are "you get what we serve". So, if there's a hostile standard that web pages all start using, having an open source implementation of the thing working against you is a very small consolation...
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cxr on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:55PM (#37136260)
> I don't get it.. that was the day that open source won the web. There are now no major closed source browser engines remaining.

Microsoft announcing an open source "Edge Core" (cf .NET Core, ChakraCore) would have satisfied the same criterion.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by behringer on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:19PM (#37136643)
Me too. I find the vast majority supports it fine. I find those that do not are happy to fix the problem, often within a few days or maybe a month.