News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yomlica8 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:43AM (#37134601)
Edge seems like a blunder in general. Prior to the initial Edge introduction IE seemed to have 20-25% of the desktop browser marketshare. Nothing like the crazy 90+% it had at its height but certainly not a browser you can ignore. Now they're at about 10% and it seems like they have to use every manipulation tactic in the book to get it.

But I agree, that third browser engine kept things interesting even if I didn't use it. Selfishly I hope Apple continues using its iron grip on iOS to prevent anything other than Safari's engine there. I don't use Apple products personally but benefit from the diversity of ecosystem it provides.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:22AM (#37135107)
> Prior to the initial Edge introduction IE seemed to have 20-25% of the desktop browser marketshare.

It had been on the decline for years. Statscounter shows 26% in January 2013, 17% January 2014, 13% in January 2015, then Edge was introduced in July of that year.

If anything Edge was a recognition of that reality: the investment in maintaining their own browser engine wasn't worth it when compared to the resulting market share. IMO the failure of Windows Phone was the death knell of Trident (the IE engine): desktop share overall is smaller and they have no footprint in the mobile OS space.

https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/all/worldwid...

https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/all/worldwid...

https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/all/worldwid...

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by temac on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#37135380)
You are confusing the old Edge that had an engine forked from IE and that MS exclusively maintained, with the new Edge that is a fork of Chromium. Maybe that the old Edge was not of stellar quality was simply because the age of the codebase of its engine.
Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:16PM (#37135778)
I'm simply replying to the OP's assertion that "Edge seems like a blunder in general".

IE market share was declining before Edge was introduced, and it continued to decline after Edge was introduced. Since the browser engine switch their market share has actually increased a small amount! So all in all I don't think there's any evidence that Edge was a blunder.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yomlica8 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#37135849)
Yeah, this does seem to line up more with the Windows8/Windows phone failure more than anything.

Despite people having a better opinion about Edge Chromium it didn't seem to stem the decline.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by WorldMaker on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:25PM (#37136720)
> death knell of Trident (the IE engine)

Nitpick, but the Edge name signaled the switch to the ground up rewrite Spartan engine. Trident is still sort of alive in its zombie corporate state in the Windows backwards compatibility swamp. Trident was still maintained for backward compatibility (and still exists in IE Mode in Chromium Edge), but Edge was always Spartan and it is Spartan that is dead (RIP).

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by n0tinventedhere on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:15AM (#37135001)
I can tell you from doing testing on Edge back when it represented a potential third engine to support: that browser crashed a lot. It was very unreliable prior to switching to becoming another chromium fork. It is clear the dev team was either underfunded or plain incompetent and Microsoft was in dire need of a default browser that didn't make people wince, ASAP, they could not afford to wait [insert X years to get a mature engine] so they went the obvious route and chose to make a chromium fork.

Making a reliable engine that supports all of the modern web is a monstrous undertaking. Not just "support", it needs to be reliable. Microsoft missed the boat when they allowed IE to rot and it was too late to catch up now. Every year spent without a reliable browser preinstalled on your OS is detrimental.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by mywittyname on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:06AM (#37134886)
I think the problem with Edge was two-fold:

- People were trained to automatically install a new browser on their computers when they got it.

- Edge is a never ending nagfest and that became another prompt to go and download Chrome.

Less is more was probably the better strategy to take with Edge.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by softfalcon on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:42AM (#37135327)
> Less is more...

You hit the nail right on the money. Every time I accidentally open Edge through the Windows search, it never ceases to shut up about itself. There is fanfare, there are notifications for details I don't care about, popups showing me all the features that are standard in any web browser.

You know what would make me use your browser Microsoft? Getting the hell out of my way. I do not care that it's Edge, I don't care that it's new, I don't care that it has 7 ways to input and take pictures and who knows what else. Just show me the search result.

Contrast this to how Safari behaves when it pops up to show you something. It just gives you the web page. That's it.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by cptskippy on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @10:53AM (#37134730)
> Edge seems like a blunder in general. Prior to the initial Edge introduction IE seemed to have 20-25% of the desktop browser marketshare.

The only reason IE retained any marketshare was because it was required for legacy enterprise and government applications. For security this was bad all around and Microsoft was right to kill it off even to their own detriment.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @11:43AM (#37135345)
> Selfishly I hope Apple continues using its iron grip on iOS to prevent anything other than Safari's engine there.

It's so weird these days seeing people literally cheering for the success of a proprietary product on a completely closed platform over an open source engine. Firefox, sure. I can get behind that even if my professional life technically argues against it. I see the draw there and won't argue about benefits.

But Safari? Seriously? Even discounting the existence of Firefox, the "monoculture" argument falls down in the face of products like Edge and Opera (and countless others -- Linux distros ship Chromium, Teslas all have a build installed, etc...), which are *successful forks* of Chromium. If Google goes evil and turns into a bad steward, we know already that Microsoft et. al. won't be impacted and can continue to ship their unadulterated products. Because that's what they're doing today.

Really? Safari?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#37135860)
> If Google goes evil and turns into a bad steward, we know already that Microsoft et. al. won't be impacted

I suspect that's not OP's fear. Google is powerful enough that they can do whatever they want with Chrome. They could even close source the thing and implement a load of proprietary APIs if they wanted and the bulk of users would continue to use it.

One of the things holding them back from doing so is the fact that Chromium can't run on the most popular mobile platform in the US. I'm no defender of Safari but I can see the logic at work.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:40PM (#37136097)
> They could even close source the thing and implement a load of proprietary APIs

Right, but that capability is exactly what the upthread comment is cheering for Apple having. Apple goes even farther and straight up denies competitors access to its platform entirely.

It's the asymmetry I don't understand: why is proprietary control good for one side but not for the other? Is the goal here preserving open systems and interoperability or is it just to Beat Google?

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:50PM (#37136208)
> why is proprietary control good for one side and not the other?

It isn’t for either, this is a “least worst” scenario. Both sides have the capability to push proprietary APIs but largely fail at doing so because they don’t have a monopoly over the market. They are forced to compromise on a middle ground (supporting the open web), which is better than one side being able to entirely dominate the market and do whatever they want.

> Is the goal here preserving open systems and interoperability or is it just to Beat Google?

In this specific scenario they are one and the same but the aim is the former. Google controls the desktop browser market already, one of the only reasons they haven’t done the same on mobile is because Apple won’t allow it. The argument is not that Apple should control everything, it’s that stalemate is the best we’ve got.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @12:56PM (#37136266)
> Google controls the desktop browser market already, one of the only reasons they haven’t done the same on mobile is because Apple won’t allow it.

Yeah, I think this is wrong, but I'm going to bail on this discussion since it's too close to my employment.

But my opinions haven't really changed anyway: from my perspective both sides have "control" over a market, but one side has been a good steward, allowing forks and experimentation and open implementation, and the other side has been an inarguably bad steward by disallowing competition entirely. And it's shocking (and frankly a little Orwellian) to see people trying to argue the opposite.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by afavour on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:12PM (#37136534)
One side having been a "good steward" is your opinion, describing counter opinions as "a little Orwellian" strikes me as hyperbole.

From my perspective I agree that Google has been a better steward of the web than many others would be or have been. But I have spent too much of my professional life dealing with things like AMP pages and shitty, browser-crashing ads provided via Google ad networks to say they are a total objective good (to say nothing of the Web Environment Integrity proposal and other stuff that never succeeded, remember when they wanted to put Dart in Chrome?).

Even if you think they are objectively good, remember that they've been a good steward within the current context where they don't hold overall power. Microsoft is a good steward of the web these days but I've been around long enough to remember the IE6 days. If given total control over the future of the web I have every expectation that Google would behave like MS did back then. It's nothing personal against any company, I think it's inherent in the nature of any private company in total control of a market to bend it to their will. Expecting them to do anything else is foolish.

I fear the native future Apple wants but can't achieve because of the open web. I fear the dominated web future Google wants but can't achieve because of Apple. I'm equal opportunity scared of all these bastards.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Wednesday August 16, 2023 @09:56AM (#37147064)
> I fear the native future Apple wants

It seems like you agree with me then. I remind you that you stepped in to a subthread arguing in favor ("seeing the logic" in your words) of Safari as an alternative to Chrome as a way to preserve open access to web content. And as you yourself point out, that's ridiculous: iOS/Safari is much more locked down than any WEI-compliant browser ever could be.

I repeat again that I'm happy if you want to boost Firefox or Chromium or (if you must) Opera or Edge instead, as those platforms represent open choices in a reasonably free market. But telling people to use Safari on iOS in this particular argument is a very weird up-is-down/gaslighting/Orwellian take. It's just wrong. Your stated goals upthread don't match your recommendations, at all.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by yomlica8 on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @01:19PM (#37136645)
I haven't commented really since afavour has mostly articulated my position for me. I don't use Apple products as I am philosophically opposed to the control of the hardware. And my life goes on fine.

WEI alone is enough for me to disagree with you on who is the bad steward.

Re:Firefox finally outperforming Google Chrome in SunSpider by ajross on Tuesday August 15, 2023 @02:11PM (#37137307)
> WEI alone is enough for me to disagree with you on who is the bad steward.

But... again, WEI is just duplicating features that have been there from day zero on iOS (and mobile apps more generally).

I understand that you dislike WEI. I understand why you might argue against its implementors and push platforms like Firefox that don't do that. I get that part.

What I don't get is your celebration of a platform that is even more locked down, in every reasonable interpretation. Your ability as an arbitrary client to connect to the service of your choosing using the software of your choosing (which is all WEI is about) is objectively much weaker with iOS than any other significant client platform. So maybe you should revisit your thinking here?