News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by lucubratory on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @12:58AM (#36952499)
Everyone in this thread needs to understand that particularly for materials science, and particularly when there is bad methodology documentation, it is really, really normal for early replication attempts to fail. What works in one lab will often need to be adjusted to work in another, with different equipment, altitude, humidity, all sorts of stuff. Making it even worse, apparently the original team can't even get production correct in more than 10% of runs! Combined with the slipshod methodology, doesn't this make you feel like it was silly to release the arXiv paper when they did? Well, the LK-99 team agree, according to them it was a rogue industrial scientist that they'd apparently fired four months ago who published it to arXiv with himself listed as third author. They wanted more time to nail down sample production and otherwise make a paper to their standards before release, but it effectively leaked and to avoid having credit taken from them for potentially months (or like, forever - science can be brutal) some of them decided to publish what they had on hand within a few hours. This sucks for them, a lot. I don't believe that their intention was to put out work with errors in it or incomplete methodology.

Secondly, this all happened two days ago! If the methodology was perfect, I still wouldn't expect good replication results back within two (part non-business!) days.

I don't know if this material is legit. I really hope it is. But the process of figuring that out could potentially take months (or more), and a two-day-later failed to replicate is not a death sentence.

As much as it sucks, this is really just going to take time to prove it's not a superconductor. If it is a superconductor, we may not know for a while either, unless one of the influencers/"makers" attempting to reproduce the material succeeds and posts some good convincing video of flux pinning or other Meissner effect stuff (that person is going to go insanely viral, if it happens).

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by dmvdoug on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:35AM (#36952711)
Not just materials science though. I’m a longtime reader of Derek Lowe’s In the Pipeline blog, and he often emphasizes the trickiness of lab work and lab techniques. But the model we have of science from elementary and high school doesn’t give us room for the random, ephemeral things that come into play in actual experimental work. Our model is methods equal result, every time, even though jiggling your foot a little bit to get the feeling back may have somehow made your small molecule production have less binding affinity or something. And yes, eventually you figure that out and stop jiggling your foot but two years have passed.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by lucubratory on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:37AM (#36952725)
Absolutely, ultimate failures to replicate are generally multiple labs across dozens and dozens of attempts and continuous communication with the authors. And yeah, it's a thing in science in general, materials science is just particularly susceptible because of the nature of the work.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by tetha on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:10AM (#36952878)
NileRed and other Maker Channels are great to demonstrate that. In every video, there's 1 - 2 of these situations - Nile has been following some documented, established procedure which should result in a specific reaction and it looks decent to the layman - and then it just doesn't work at all. And then he re-does pretty much the same thing and it works.

I can't imagine how frustrating that can be. And then you have to do it with something you don't even know works. Kind of like dealing with obscure retro computers. Does it still work? No one knows. What does it do if it works? No one knows. Can it even function or are parts missing? That's right - no one knows.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by teaearlgraycold on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:24AM (#36952958)
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by MichaelZuo on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @09:03AM (#36955419)
Well to be fair it's very difficult to nail down every possible parameter to 99.99% accuracy and precision from the original successful experiment. There's a lot of randomness even in a highly controlled, well funded, modern laboratory setting, let alone less well equipped facilities.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by whimsicalism on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:21AM (#36956266)
It is incredibly frustrating, my experience in an experimental physics lab involved in creation of certain types of wafers for SEM characterization, there are so many things that can go wrong for certain materials. just a certain speck of dust being in the wrong place at the wrong time

It is why I quit experimental physics.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by oceanplexian on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:08PM (#36963855)
Anyone who has dived into FDM 3D printing knows this pain well.

Filament is too wet, the air is too cold, a batch of filament might behave wrong. Or everything goes 99% right and the axis of the moon and the constellations are off and it ruins your entire print after 57 hours. Then you start again and it breaks at 59.5 hours. I’m sure it’s not as hardcore as synthesizing superconductors but the real world is incredibly messy and imprecise.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by stevage on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:39PM (#36964240)
But Jesus in this case the payoff is immense.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by Loic on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:41AM (#36953067)
For computer science people, I always use the yield on wafers as analogy to explain how hard it can be to nail an experiment right.

Usually they understand directly because this is something they can easily relate to.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by eric-hu on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:43AM (#36953453)
For those of us unfamiliar with the numbers, what do typical yields look like on silicon wafers?
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by peyton on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:56AM (#36953532)
50–97% with 90% considered “good.”
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by XorNot on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:32AM (#36954416)
It's also worth contextualizing percentages. 90% still means 1 in every 10 parts fails.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by OJFord on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:15AM (#36957053)
It's not always outright failure, but rather different performance binning.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by Chabsff on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:38AM (#36957435)
But the performance binning is a direct result of careful design that goes out of its way to ensure that a subset of failures can still lead to a workable/binnable products.

It's still a failure to produce a part that matches the full design.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by crote on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:58AM (#36954227)
It really varies.

Samsung 3nm had a yield rate well below 20% back in early 2022, and that's not unheard of while still in the development phase. To be economically viable the yield rates have to be around 80%, so mature nodes can be expected to be in that ballpark.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by djtango on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:57AM (#36953170)
We also don't have a culture of replication. Basically all of the post docs I worked with in the lab lamented how hard it can be to replicate reported syntheses in chemistry wet labs.

Everything from humidity and altitude to undocumented "magic tricks" (eg baking something in an oven under vaccuum for a week to get.rid.of.all.the.water.)

I heard anecdotes that experiments were sometimes literally only reproducible in one exact lab because reasons.

Turns out there's just as much art as there is science in experimentation...

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by mschuster91 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:31AM (#36953372)
The problem IMHO is funding related. Often enough the original lab's grant is barely enough to account for the research and a shoddily put together paper, the rest is filled with a crapload of un(der)paid/"voluntold" labour.

It's rare for researchers to get the budget to replicate someone else's work - this case might be one of the few exceptions given that everyone and their dog want to be the first one to show the world a successful replication. Hell, there are Youtube and Tiktok streamers on the task as well, that way you know just how nuts everyone is going.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by michaelt on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:24AM (#36954371)
Even in well funded fields, nobody wants to give away easy follow-on publications to other labs.

Oh, you want to document things well enough that people can build on your work and give you citations eventually. But if you've just demonstrated a groundbreaking technique for Foo and the obvious next step is to test it on Bar, you've got an opportunity to get your lab two papers instead of one, and all you have to do is less documentation?

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by techdragon on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:52AM (#36953512)
The simple truth is we don’t have a culture of replication because no one is paying and no one is paying because no one is demanding it as part of the incentive system that the money is part of…

If a prerequisite of publication in a top tier journal was someone having replicated the work… anyone at all… then the quality of write up would improve dramatically because all the stuff that never gets written up would be written up so that the second lab costs them less money to do the replication work, so the second lab doesn’t spent a month failing because they didn’t bake the powder in a vacuum for a week before performing the entire synthesis under dry nitrogen purge when the methodology just said the powder had been dried and the synthesis was performed at ambient pressure in a zero humidity atmosphere…

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by grall on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @09:58AM (#36956028)
> If a prerequisite of publication in a top tier journal was someone having replicated the work… anyone at all

For a SciFi take on this see the section "A Note on Governance" at https://eldraeverse.com/2018/05/25/approach-vector-2-2/. Specifically, the "Dean of Evidence".

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by Someone on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:21AM (#36956272)
> If a prerequisite of publication in a top tier journal was someone having replicated the work… anyone at all… then the quality of write up would improve dramatically

I would expect pairs of labs to gang up, with one of them giving the other the details so that they can reproduce the result, and the contents of the publication staying more or less the same.

Reason is that everybody wants to prevent others from being able to build on one’s work faster than one can do themselves.

Even if the lab you give more information isn’t run by a buddy of you, having a single competitor is better than having the whole world compete with you.

For example, in this case, people will start cooking all kinds of variations on this stuff to find one that’s easier to produce, allows for higher currents before losing superconductivity, doesn’t have lead in it, etc.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by techdragon on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:15AM (#36957062)
Oh absolutely, there’s a lot of potential issues with the simple suggestion of requiring replication. I was tempted to write a bunch more to outline strategies and counter strategies from a game theory perspective but realised it was basically unnecessary since it will never happen.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by pjc50 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @12:23PM (#36958185)
> The simple truth is we don’t have a culture of replication because no one is paying and no one is paying because no one is demanding it as part of the incentive system that the money is part of…

A darker comment: the non-replication of results implies that nobody's actually making use of the science output, and an alarmingly large fraction of unreplicated positive results are simply a waste of time.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by Vespasian on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:58AM (#36953538)
In that light, industrial processes seem even more impressive.

The super power of modern technology is the ability to perform follow precise steps on a massive scale and basically forever.

Obviously it takes a lot of effort to keep the machinery running but still, the mere fact that it's running in the first place blows your mind if you think about it.

Modern Machinery multiplies the impact on the world of any human who operates it.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by djtango on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:13AM (#36953619)
Research experimentation is like doing a gymnastics performance, you're trying to prove the limits of what can be done.

Industry is all about doing it cheap, consistently and at scale. So by comparison you don't want any flourish or special conditions that take lots of practice and super skilled operators.

The magic of industrial engineering is figuring out how to go from research to scale. But the flipside is all the crazy stuff that is achievable at the frontier that never gets productionised

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by ilc on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @09:02AM (#36955405)
Look up FOGBANK (nuclear material), if you want to see what happens when people get REALLY motivated to replicate the impossible to replicate.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by kitd on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @09:58AM (#36956021)
A chemical well-it-works-on-my-computer experiment. Nice!
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by whimsicalism on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:23AM (#36956301)
This was my experience as well, my job was basically to specialize in reverse engineering those exact “baking” techniques in the tube furnace and it is so challenging and subject to variability.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by paulmd on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @12:24PM (#36958205)
> baking something in an oven under vaccuum for a week to get.rid.of.all.the.water.

vacuum oven also works great for drying 3d printer filament!

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by OJFord on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:07AM (#36956932)
> But the model we have of science from elementary and high school doesn’t give us room for the random, ephemeral things that come into play in actual experimental work. Our model is methods equal result, every time, even though jiggling your foot a little bit to get the feeling back may have somehow made your small molecule production have less binding affinity or something.

That wasn't my experience, in either high school physics or undergrad electronics. I hated keeping a lab book (just wanted to 'do' & see results I suppose) but the emphasis was always on recording as much as possible to understand what's important and what happened etc. when you review later.

I suppose looking through another lens you can call that an expectation of repeatability, but it's just a matter of emphasis isn't it? You know it might be hard to repeat, so you record as much as possible about the setup & process to remove variables and control what needs to be controlled (especially if you don't yet understand what that is, or the full scope).

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by sterlind on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:07AM (#36956936)
FOGBANK, the classified styrofoam-like material used as a filler in US thermonuclear warheads, had a similar issue. They needed to restart production, but the new samples didn't work! It turns out an impurity present in the original batch was critical. Once they reproduced that impurity, the material acted correctly.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by AaronM on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:39AM (#36957459)
I am not involved in lab work at all, but his "Things I won't work with" posts are wonderful
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by vasco on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:28AM (#36952993)
If research moves more to arxiv + discussion forums rather than paid journals, sharing research results earlier seems like a good thing, not bad. If they didn't publish early, when they published maybe things would be clearer for other researchers. But by publishing earlier other people have the choice to engage with it or wait for later. Seems like many people decided to not wait, so it seems like it was a good choice?
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by was_a_dev on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:41AM (#36953070)
I think this would vary greatly on the field. This example of results is one of the better examples imo
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by brutusborn on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:37AM (#36954133)
I think this is the best direction for science generally: publish everything open and early.

It might be naive, but I would love an environment where everyone self published or arxiv papers/reviews/datasets/models. Then journals could publish the best papers/review preprints.

I imagine a world where journals beg researchers for the rights to publish their paper after seeing an excellent preprint. Or a journal finds an interesting comment on PubPeer and pays for the author to expand it into a more detailed review.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by WanderPanda on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:43AM (#36955250)
Nice counterfactual! Do you think it is just a path dependency that we didn‘t end up in the (local) minimum that you mention?
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by brutusborn on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @09:26AM (#36955657)
Yes I think we will end there someday but are still overcoming a publishing model historically based on physical journals. Open science becoming more common shows that progress is occurring.

It will take a while before academics and systems upgrade skills and infrastructure. When they do, I am excited for enhanced capabilities like continuous science. Imagine a website with a study result with P values which continuously update as data is published and integrated into the existing analysis!

https://towardsdatascience.com/continuous-science-6b5ed833ab...

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by bckr on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:40AM (#36956519)
You’ve heard of CI/CD, now we bring you Continuous Experimentation and Publishing
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by ryukoposting on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:46AM (#36954173)
This is a great philosophy in software, where meaningful contributions can be made by any given person with a laptop. It's not as compelling when the only people who can meaningfully advance the research need to spend millions in grant money and/or allocate time to use expensive equipment that's shared across other research groups.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by ryukoposting on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @07:56AM (#36954883)
Just want to add to this thought: this isn't to say I believe the status quo in academia isn't antiquated. It is. My point is that we can't just "take open source and move it over there," so to speak.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by brutusborn on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @09:34AM (#36955757)
What is the difference? I would argue it is more important to publish early when using shared expensive equipment, since there is a huge opportunity cost to wasting resources when better information exists.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by bckr on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:43AM (#36956574)
But in what case is this the reality?

Science is generally dealing with more data than any one person can look at. Anyone with a laptop can provide unique analyses of the data which can fuel new hypotheses, which can be explored with simulations and further analysis.

the big machines represent a bottleneck only in the physical experiments that they enable, but a lot of science can be done around that.

Tighten the feedback loops by all means I say

Especially for public science, but that’s another story

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by matthewdgreen on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:03AM (#36954943)
This is an incredibly high-profile type of result, so in this case people are willing to spend a lot of resources replicating this result, even if the paper appears half-baked and unfinished. Most scientific results aren’t like that: people will be enthusiastic about polished work but won’t waste any time on something half-baked. Think about how many “Show HN” posts don’t get voted up to the front page. Now imagine there is no HN and no voting system to rank posts, and also you didn’t have anyone test your code so your cool project immediately crashes on 50% of browsers.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by joefigura on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:39AM (#36953050)
This comment intrigued me, so I pulled together some information.

The first paper submitted is titled "The First Room-Temperature Ambient-Pressure Superconductor." It lists three authors: Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim, and Young-Wan Kwon. Its timestamp is Saturday, July 22, 2023 at 07:51:19 UTC. [1]

The second paper submitted is titled "Superconductor Pb10−xCux(PO4)6O showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and mechanism." This paper lists six authors: Sukbae Lee, Jihoon Kim, Hyun-Tak Kim, Sungyeon Im, SooMin An, Keun Ho Auh [2]. Its timestamp is Saturday, July 22nd, 2023 at 10:11:28 UTC, or two hours and twenty minutes after the first paper.

In both papers the first author is Sukbae Lee and the second author is Jihoon Kim, and in both their affiliation is given as "Quantum Energy Research center, Inc." in Seoul. The first paper posted has Young-Wan Kwon as third author. The second paper does not have Young-Wan Kwon as an author, and has four additional authors with various affiliations.

The second paper appears to have been was prepared in LaTeX, and the first paper appears to have been prepared in Word. The title and abstract of the first paper explicitly claim the creation of the world's first room temperature and pressure superconductor. The title and abstract of the second paper don't explicitly claim demonstration of the first superconductor, though they use some terminology that sounds like superconducting properties.

The accusation is that Young-Wan Kwon published the first paper without the consent of the rest of the LK-99 team, listed himself as third author, and left off the other four. Two hours later, the rest of the LK-99 team stuffed as much as they had into the second paper, and released it as soon as possible.

To me that totally seems like what happened. It explains why there are two different papers from the same group submitted on the same subject on the same day, and it explains why the author lists are different between the two. I haven't yet looked in detail, but I'm betting it also explains a lot of the oddities that people have noted in the first two papers.

This also makes me way more excited about the possibility these claims are legit. The information so far is consistent with a research group that was forced to publish early, and who produced a superconductor through a fabrication process that is a bit tricky. There's nowhere near enough evidence to conclude LK-99 is a room temperature superconductor. But one failed replication doesn't prove LK-99 isn't a superconductor - if the fabrication process is finicky we'd expect to see a few dozen failed reproductions and a few successful reproductions

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12008

[2] https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12037

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by chrisjj on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:00AM (#36953556)
The second paper's "semiconductor" claim is no less than the first.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by joefigura on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:19AM (#36954039)
In general I'd agree with you, but in this case I think the second group very likely didn't reproduce the first group's material. The measured electrical properties of the two groups aren't even close to each other. I think that strongly suggests the two groups were measuring different materials, and that the structure of the second group's material differed in some way. A more convincing failed replication would find mostly similar electrical properties and reproduce the levitation that the first group found, but explain it with a phenomenon other than superconductors
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by mellosouls on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:09AM (#36953604)
Yeah, this in-fighting thing has been proposed before as credibility-supporting. Here's an earlier tweet with some background on the palaver, account worth following on it all:

https://twitter.com/8teAPi/status/1684385895565365248

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by rozab on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:22AM (#36954355)
This is going to make such a great movie
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by mellosouls on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @07:05AM (#36954599)
Yeah, especially if it pans out as real.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by _0ffh on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:59AM (#36953910)
Rushing out the second paper was a mistake and not a good look for the group. It would have been enough to force the retraction of Kwon's paper, and even without a retraction it's very unlikely it would have counted for anything with such weak data.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by joefigura on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:10AM (#36953986)
idk if it turns out this material is a room temperature superconductor, the rushed second paper will have been the right thing to do. Science happening in real time is gonna be messy
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by _0ffh on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:52AM (#36954198)
If it's about the Nobel, no it doesn't make sense. There's been more than one Nobel where the author(s) of an earlier paper were passed over in favour of a later paper because it was insufficient to conclusively prove the claim. One example would be Randy Hulet.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by Qem on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:22PM (#36961198)
Was the removed researcher junior to those latter added on?
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by lucubratory on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:29PM (#36965279)
Thank you, I made the original comment on a whim after coming to the thread and being disappointed at how everyone was talking about this result as though it immediately exposed Lee, Jihoon Kim, Hyun-Tak Kim etc as frauds. It was also late at night and I was tired ¯ \ _ ( ツ ) _ / ¯ I really appreciate you putting together some more sourcing and explanatory material for it.

Side note, the upvotes on the original comment have pushed me well past the 500 upvotes mark, so now I have a downvoted button on most comments. Which is actually kind of annoying on mobile because God, they are right beside each other and absolutely tiny, with no remaining visual indicator afterwards as to whether you upvoted or downvoted a comment.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by welder on Friday August 04, 2023 @04:29AM (#36997106)
> with no remaining visual indicator afterwards as to whether you upvoted or downvoted a comment.

A new link appears on that comment with text `undown` or `unvote` depending on which one you clicked.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by bruce511 on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:03AM (#36953572)
It's not dissimilar to the way food recipe books work.

Creating a dish, replicating the dish, writing a recipe, getting competent cooks to follow the recipe, getting non-competant cooks to follow it, and so on. [1]

It all leads to multiple revisions and takes a lot of time.

And this is for -food-. Imagine doing it for something a lot less tolerant of variation.

[1] old recipes start with "pluck 2 chickens" because, you know, someone followed the recipe and didn't pluck the chickens...

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by comboy on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:56AM (#36953884)
This is a good summary: https://youtu.be/RjzL9cS3VW8?t=32

TLDW it seems very unlikely that they have what they claim

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by lucubratory on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:46PM (#36965435)
In Sabine's opinion. I've seen Sabine's video when it was posted and intend no disrespect to her. The predominant theoretical explanation for the alleged new superconductor is that it may be a new type of superconductor, not type I or type II, or it may be presenting in unusual ways. There have been a bunch of confusing theoretical prodictions, like anisotropic conduction (how would that affect the way levitation looks)?, chance-based copper substitution in the lattice that could lead to superconducting clusters in what is otherwise just normal lead apatite (how would that affect the way levitation looks in a bulk chunk like that?), etc.

Plenty of people who know the theory of superconductors are sceptical. They're not wrong about the theory. It's also worth pointing out that every previous time a new superconductor critical temp limit was broken in a major way, superconductor theory saying it shouldn't be possible was a cause for early scepticism amongst those who knew the theory. Sabine's gut reactions in a YouTube video doesn't make the result very unlikely. It doesn't make her wrong either, she's right that all existing superconductors, if pure and homogeneous, would not behave like that on a magnet. It is also the case that all existing superconductors do not superconduct at room temperature and ambient pressure. It is also the case that (absent fraud, which is on everyone's mind after Ranga Dias) we don't know of any material that could plausible behave the way that video shows something behaving. The only thing I can think of that could behave that way would be impure/heterogeneous diamagnetic material, but like 15x as diamagnetic as the next highest non-superconductor, which means if that material exists we don't know about it. If it was fraud, it would be with a magnetised sample on a magnet like that. The reason I think fraud is the only option if it was a magnetised sample is because that's a really, really obvious explanation for the effect and they have to have measured the sample for magnetism before putting it on a magnet. They would also literally feel it/see it/hear it while placing the sample on the magnet. Also it would almost certainly have to be composed of different elements than they describe, because lead apatite with copper definitely should not be ferromagnetic at all.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by michaelt on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:09AM (#36954286)
> Combined with the slipshod methodology, doesn't this make you feel like it was silly to release the arXiv paper when they did? Well, the LK-99 team agree

As I understand it, the 99 in the name is because they first discovered it in 1999.

Seems to me that if you didn't manage to nail down the process in 24 years, it's probably time to publish and let someone else have a go.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by londons_explore on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:17AM (#36954337)
And if this technology is on the critical path to solving world hunger/curing cancer or ending wars, then those things have been delayed 24 years, and millions of people are dead, all so these guys could have a shot at a paper in Nature.

Humans really are selfish sometimes.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by simmerup on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:20AM (#36957143)
Assuming the worst of people is bad for your mental health
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by guerrilla on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:18AM (#36954340)
It sounds like you don't know the history. They were doing other unrelated things in the meantime, not working in this.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by michaelt on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @06:43AM (#36954476)
I'm aware of that.

But if I was an early-career researcher looking to establish myself, secure funding and maybe a tenure-track position, and I had a nobel-prize-winning discovery up my sleeve, I can't imagine many things that would take precedence.

I mean, obviously whatever happened happened. It just seems strange to simultaneously claim to have discovered something 24 years ago, and to have been rushed into publishing prematurely.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by guerrilla on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:33AM (#36955165)
> It just seems strange to simultaneously claim to have discovered something 24 years ago, and to have been rushed into publishing prematurely.

They had to get other jobs to survive. Somone else forced their hand with the publication. There's nothing incosistent about that.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by lolinder on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:55AM (#36956754)
There was no one who would be willing to fund their research into a room temperature semiconductor? Even though they had a sample that passed the basic tests?
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by guerrilla on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @11:21AM (#36957156)
You make it sound like that is easy while not knowing much about them or their circumstances. There still isn't. Look at their shitty rented lab. Obviously there are aspects to their situation that not everyone here is aware of.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by paulmd on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @12:29PM (#36958280)
the world is filled with quacks looking for funding for superconductor research, I can definitely imagine that 20 years ago it would have been difficult to find funding for blue-sky research in superconductivity even with a modest amount of evidence in-hand
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by Qem on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:03PM (#36960887)
> mean, obviously whatever happened happened. It just seems strange to simultaneously claim to have discovered something 24 years ago, and to have been rushed into publishing prematurely.

Probably there was a big team. Somebody with a low rank worked his/her ass off on the breakdown, but then noticed their names would be filled off or put only in acknowledgements section, to be replaced with some senior lab manager that did just administrative paperwork and barely knew the work. So they said screw it and just published whatever they could before the laurels were stolen.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by DannyBee on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:26AM (#36955111)
The thing is - there is a totally easy and simple mechanism to create early-stage believability.

Take a video of you producing and testing it, with a mobile phone.

It only works 10% of the time? Not an issue, post 10 videos. Whatever.

Would it be perfect? No, of course it could be faked.

But i guaranteed people would be a ton less skeptical and willing to push hard on this if the original authors had done this sort of thing.

It's honestly not that hard to set up a tripod and a mobile phone, and even in the circumstances here, where they apparently got pushed to publish quickly, it could still show that it works.

It also would help those trying to reproduce see exactly what you did, in detail.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by bluGill on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:38AM (#36955205)
Production takes more than a day - I don't know of any phone that can take videos lasting that long (if people are even willing to watch it). You can of course take several videos and splice them together.

Worse yet, I can with a bit of trick photography and standard liquid nitrogen cooled super conductors make a video that looks like success even though I'm working with colored wax for materials in the production process. (liquid nitrogen is hard to disguise, but with some trick photography and multiple takes I can do it). Or I can skip all that and spend some time in blender to do the above via CGI. (well I don't know blender that well, and most blender animations are obvious, but someone with a few months could pull this off)

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by DannyBee on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:09PM (#36958946)
Ignore mobile phones, put in a nest, whatever.

It is not that hard or expensive to record footage for a few days at a time having a continuous overwrite.

You likely don't even need to go that far -Most universities have cameras everywhere, anyway, including plenty of universities that have cameras in every lab of this kind.

It is also done by millions of home users all the time.

As I said, yes, things can be faked, but who cares that’s not the point

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by mhb on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:49AM (#36955300)
Are you suggesting that they take phone video of all their experiments over the course of multiple years? Or just the one they know will succeed?
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by lambdasquirrel on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @08:58AM (#36955372)
A lot of science takes a mind-numbing amount of time at the lab desk. Something like 40 hours a week just dedicated to picking apart fruit flies with tweezers under a microscope is pretty common. I think I read somewhere that with MatSci, mortars and pestles and blisters are involved. It would be a lot of recording that would have to happen, and then you have to record every setting on every instrument you touch. How do we know that that's actually that reagent in that bottle? Yeah this just doesn't hold up for actual science. It's not something you can just take a Zoom recording of.
Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by fullspectrumdev on Wednesday August 02, 2023 @03:11AM (#36967930)
> mortars and pestles and blisters are involved

Can confirm from my life prior to working with computers.

“Is this mortar and pestle actually clean?”

“How much grinding is the right amount?”

“Is the window open or closed?”

“Did someone fuck with the settings on this machine since I last used it?”

And so on…

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by DannyBee on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:07PM (#36958910)
I'm sorry, you really think it's that hard to have a camera running in a lab that records footage continuously, and you save the clips where you succeed?

What percent of the cost of running these experiments do you think that is to buy a nest or a unifi camera? Heck, Do you believe the university doesn’t already have a surveillance system almost certainly in the hallway to the lab. Plenty of them even have cameras in every lab already. In the past two weeks, I was in three material science labs in Georgia, and South Carolina and all of them had cameras in every lab.

This is not that hard. If you wanna argue that it’s not helpful, that’s one thing. But arguing that it is difficult seems very silly.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by mhb on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @02:22PM (#36960158)
Ah, another example of how something is so easy when I just imagine other people doing it.

Your aspiration, I suppose, is that this (e.g., surveillance?) video will document the experimental activities in enough detail so that they can be replicated and/or convincingly proven. As a practical matter, it's ludicrous to think that any of the examples that you suggest as obvious and trivial would do either of these things much less survive a cursory consideration of their cost/benefit.

Further, this is a classic example of premature optimization. Should only labs that are confident that they will be contesting for a Nobel prize be monitoring all their experiments or do you also envision this as an activity for labs with lower aspirations or self-esteem?

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by DannyBee on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @03:47PM (#36961632)
What makes you believe I haven't done this before?

If you want to know, maybe, you know, ask ("Have you ever tried to do this before in a lab?" - this is also not hard, and even the people not contending for the Nobel prize can do it), rather than just assert that this is just something i only want to see others do in my imagination, which is not just rude, but actually, it turns out, wrong.

But hey, don't let that stop you. Please, continue to assert things about me rather than actually ask or otherwise use means that might gain knowledge of me and what i have or haven't done.

To answer the rest, so, actually, no, that's not my aspiration. My aspiration was "producing and testing", specifically targeted at "early stage believability". Which is what I said. You seem to have decided that means "be able to show all pieces in a convincing way" or "make a how to video". That would be silly, which is why i didn't say that.

This is is mostly about showing a video of the end result in a meaningful way, as the literal top thread on this on HN now does, posting multiple reproduction and testing videos. If you can show production in some way at all, awesome. I'm not interested in the residents cynics shitting on every single way that it could be faked, nor are most other people.

To most people, those videos are much more convincing than all the papers and anything else you produce.

As for who monitors, as I mentioned elsewhere, lots of labs already have cameras, because universities now put them in almost every room. As I mentioned, I was even in multiple material science labs in the past week, and all had cameras. But please, feel free to continue to pretend that this is some super complicated thing to do when it's already being done and being used to good effect, convincingly, on HN, right now.

I guess they all just contending for a nobel prize, because otherwise, this is clearly impossible, despite it literally having been done.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by mhb on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @04:34PM (#36962374)
I don't know what problem you think you're solving with the idea of using webcams in a lab. The inventors of LK-99 have a video of their sample on a magnet. So it's not addressing that problem. Some replication attempts are livestreaming on Twitch, so it's not solving that problem.

Do you think that it would be easier to replicate the LK-99 process if video from a corner of their lab existed?

OK. I want to know - have you produced compelling video of a controversial experiment in a lab using the pre-existing security cameras? And did that video quiet any critics?

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by bckr on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @10:46AM (#36956621)
People are plenty motivated, it only came out a few days ago and there’s a replication attempt.

As others have pointed out the idea of using video as strong evidence is underbaked.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by DannyBee on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @01:19PM (#36959112)
Which is why the top thread is now replication videos?

I didn’t say strong evidence, I said evidence.I was, in fact, quite clear that it is not strong evidence. you seem to have added that so that you could be more dismissive.

Re:Semiconducting Transport in LK99 by throwawaymaths on Tuesday August 01, 2023 @05:03PM (#36962859)
we used to joke in the chemistry lab that someone once tried to reproduce a reaction that was done in india. Procedure called for boiling ether, room temperature, WTF. Of course, room temperature in india can get up to 40C.